High Court Karnataka High Court

Deputy Commissioner For … vs G.Motilal Kothari on 2 November, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Deputy Commissioner For … vs G.Motilal Kothari on 2 November, 2009
Author: D.V.Shylendra Kumar Swamy
._ .,......'.. nuufl yuan'? or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA men COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA men c

.1.

rs rm man cam: or trauma; arr 

DATED THIS THE 0239 DAY 01%' NOVE£vE jE§ I§'

Pfiif

rmxorma: _ "     '

'rm norm  1,. x§m4§rnA% swwv

WRFI'    rr-Mvry

 

  A. Z  ..... 

   £31: Tframparm
 I..'"r-iv'i_af:_'m::',,' Mysore.

_ H -'  Mysomficgozz, Mysom.

 (Bf = gésmha yawn? AGA}

...Am1zanzs

' } % A1 V{}.Metih1 Km:har:i

Agaé 58,, F 
No.13, Emlapm Stwet
Sowmrmt, Chmrmi-'?$



. ...:..:..'. IRI m-mnnsnnn ruun \..U'U!'(l Ur HAKNAIAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH 4

2. L.Krishrm Gcwda
S] 0 Linge Gowda

 , 'I'.Haz-asipura. Tq
Mysare.

Tm Wm Apm1 in  mm     

Karnataka High com Aafi:-.§rayfi:g3:o s::t"w.a§i:i§t1_1e wage
passed in the Writ Eéatitian k%2a:k;%2:.2/@004 dawd
1s.1o.2ma.    

m hflSC.W.N0.67§? ?3F  %   

2. The 
  

{By'1$mt;{3aetE=j;a'AAGA)

11%;'


-  "38' §s3'nafimfi..'

'A   ?I::_:;3.V3,VF£vru3apm Street
  Chmxnaiflfl

 Lzkrxim Guwda

3/at:§L7%(3a*ae'da

"  ..   ma.T.Hmmipma Tq

. , Easwzxéegfzm
Ttfim Mficfil. is filaci undar Swtion 5 af' rm

Lmtauien Act prayim tn eemiene tiw ciealay of 125 days

i11fiJim%..iw'§e?rit&%l.

    



.3.

E MIS(3.W,N0.;§'@ OF' 2069

1.

DeputyC»c:mmisai¢3nm* firfiflwrm H’ ‘V V’
Mysore Eiviaiozx, Mysore. -‘ ”

(By smmwam Mama, AGA}-J . &

1. G.Mot:iLai Katha:-i
Aged 58, F’ina1fi1ue:t’
No.13, Eruhppa” ” :4 V”

Sowmrpet, C1u:<t'm.%:'ai-+":'*'8 1

V . .Rwpemci¢::nt

This Smtisn 151 of CPC
praying ta}: 'gxqgizt (sf shay, staying the
operatimz 'sf 31¢ aim erder dafiafi 13.10am
%ed3vby,- in Writ Petitison

1:3': ,

and M$c.W.Haa.5?97/09 and
679§} O9%a0mmgV. ab::1_f'e:*" Prelmmery Hwrirg this day,
JI, delifi tbs felhwimz –

“»-:§§a”‘a95″.:§i’¢:1ay at’ 125 fiays in pa-em-rm’ this

,’ £3: mrficnafimn cf éelay in find.

‘ ” feum werthy 9:!’ examzm’ Elan, pumps,

V ‘ tlw naeé $3′ fiazmzg’ xmtias to

…,.. ….._…,_.:. ur mmnmxa HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA men COURT or KARNATAKA men COURT or KARNATAKA men c

‘mfiomanm an the apphm” fiat: swbhag mmanamn

“‘d;8§E3r, but we haw found the apfil in wt em:

-_ ..-up ..

érarthy sf admzhsfian fat than rmmm mdiwtadg bclaw.

., jg .’ ” V’ “V

.4.

fimraforc We da not prepoae tn issue any 6:: than
appliaatian fiar eazzndanation of delay wifiiciié’ a

mere fm-mafity amen aflzmwine.

2. 11:9 appeal

Qamequently, I
delay as wen as Mi5<§'V3I.1$e;é§?ff£39i–.2jG09"fr;:r.atéiy am bath
dismissed. A "

3- Kaxnataim smm

V’ t is dingcted agaizfit

passed by the mm
smgxe .;uage;n;«=m-it -$%¢;22;2em§ whmmaer a
Court Em gm}-m a
amrmrity ma am mm-

T was Amnate Autimrity, mm tbs:

um nmna1MIMI\H nrun MVURI LII” l\l-“HY!-\!i’\I\I-\ T’IHJI”I L-IJIJKI Ur 1\F\KN5\1Al\A HIKSY1 L.LJUK3 Lil” RHKIVRIHRH P1!’-3P1 \-

verncm” Taxa’5mn Am 1957, in

%e£%«a:m~m~ vemye bmzmg rmawazmn He.’E?IG

fihd finm QL&5.};.’%1 ugm 31$-§u2mI.§

il\Ii I ‘5-\(§lI\I

‘ gmiod tax Imd hm: am ‘W the auflmrity far

zmsan that the mahkk which Iémd $92′; Bafizghi: in

nu’:-I» It-:t\avwuwn\» was I\a–1I\n’I1’|Ir1nIa*\ 1

City at’ Bfiyséffi in the State cf Kamtaka wwfi it: mm’:

3;: /« ‘

…-….. suurrt .gu..:,_m ur MRNATAKA Hm-H count or KARNATAKA men COURT or KARNATAKA men COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH c

.5.

of which, the aubsequmt cwm4*-smrnd had.

the first rwpazment-finarm-M51, ”
tranafierred in the ow%hip:=_g:f 4-:


by filing a oommemzzraté_a9pIi¢ét;§:i11    *

4. It   mcnfhly
'zmmzmm am to     pug-chaser, the
finamciar    had mm the
vehicha    in the sum of
 hem mm me am!
an  efict had Ewen  on

3§}*.95..1 §91:§,§*§:t .1′.H§;é::s mt ammnm w the arigfinal

. q *'{g::_ rwa’ itration ‘ fie, hmumm

” .. prwamt rcund sf limatiezz fix. which me

mm an be paswd arxzi whisk in in challerga in
‘ this apml imgif was mm” the mfim had gang timmxgh

czwaar1£m*murzdnfwriftpefiianwdwritappmla11dazs
tlzis (Smart had fauna trma wm samc: amps for faotzml

mifiticnk fiat ma afbw an appartumity an km

VJ! I\r’\i\i’Ir’\I.I”1.I\r\ I

“V” \-v\-_.’\-fn- vi nnminrnnn rllurl uvuul Ur nnnwnlnnfl HEUIT L-UUKI Ur IUKKNAIAIKA ruurs LUUKI Ur lu-\1(l\£n:nl\H nlun x.

.6.

tax pays: to present his vmfian and in

ind beimgon the firmxduerxg

tathefixaandmebc.

6. Iris agaimt such ‘ ~

7′. for ..V/isfiizbéfiabn cf

Smt.(}¢etha the present
1-fir! af aazziiar
Court, in ma
the max: arder mm
anew the §a;;ge¢i’ % L5iL’L’%%%§fin Wm the Dwfirnl
tax liability as: :23 pa-gea.

fié “fife fimi the atzhmisaitsn has be apt, $3

V it1 th.. ¢ “‘%m”8t iarmtam, in tha 1-mad m-dam? the:
ofthia Ciourt had set aside the Apmmm
ma mm was mm as the First
Authnrity withmxi: the 3mm fisr

mafifian sf the tax Eabflity far 3:. mm pmied, film