High Court Karnataka High Court

Divisional Manager United India … vs Divisional Controller Ksrtc … on 22 July, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Divisional Manager United India … vs Divisional Controller Ksrtc … on 22 July, 2008
Author: Anand Byrareddy

‘E
A

}§’=~$ T}*i}i. E-£_E{_-EH {j{}U,E<Z'i" (Ii? KARE=£?a_'§"AK.?a zfii' i§A.E~*s§

Ej};"3{§Eiif) 'E'i-{ES '"§'}i§-i 22'?~§Ef) i}.r%'.r' O?' 'E

B E3123} E%'.E¥L:

TE’:£}}L }*iC}}’sE’}3′;?A, 1%?-1 EVER. f{}E§’E’E{.3}_i A}:%§;’;:.

3:333&*%:a;aR;ei;;}%:L%jA

€.,:;-.%£;’§:»:s.»é’

{.3;«:::;

2: ,. _ .

I&»iEf:1{.’,’}:l§. ‘:’,.;*§N3§.l{}US ;«’;:zs’;’ ;§>:32s;;a:,v. :§g;%3 23% an: :;;;:::f2kk;:’-js’«.x:;

?.?iévi.~.;£s:ma.§ 1’vi:;tt1-czgczr

3 ited Endiafifiszggazzce
Cs..:~n’1pan.y Lin: i Ecai ‘
Divisianal Ofiicfi V . -A
T K M Ca.}mpi§:>'{}, If ~.’§fé:’;t:§*’__ V ‘
3339, 46:51, ‘ ‘
Ruaci, Vizihre 5315 {3G¥€!1i.;

No’. I rsprégentsdn é1:$ ‘ . %
Rt7g§i}{It1§ Mariggcéi” _ “V
U:1£’£adInd§9;{:f;s;’e.:; gm ” V’
Cemgpanjg .’Ei:11ii’:;=::i ‘ . _

V Regiegzgil Gffiaa H V
. §§–h;::n}c:1r;2.r:;;zfa}!:53j:a EuiE£’i’i’t’:’g
‘~.’N'{‘:. 35.. $133., if}, Read

1§§:g’n’Vg,§2E{V[:V:’:é§_§+:§_{} ‘,

7″}

{fly §if£x§§’:§aswa;}1y, E%,a§%s’£.§a;2sit:}

._ rDi%.%i+;i:,>z”:aE C:2:zir:_§E}:,:3″

fj §§§SRT€, Baizgaiasre

A.PP¥?.E

‘I

J;

ANT

mJ’ “I

E»)

2. Ev? §~§.a:i%rw§::

SEC: Lam fvI:misa>.;a.my
R$.:nga§v;3r’::: VEE?’S}5i{‘}?%§.E}F=N”{S –. L

(Sim, :”«l’agar::z}, A£ix2m;e:E.c £23: §.€:s;g.§:_33§::3::¥1*£._VE”\E::3. ‘E’-333$ R*EiSf}§}§§e’.§§33}§
Pia}. 2 W ;;’§e.3:”‘a-‘::3d:§ V_ ‘ _’ ”

.=§%.§s=si:§¥;f.%_V’£ L _
:;iwar”d dame: g}:5,:s.{;se:,__§§=i:1 §’%}E\;3§:g _E_”~§::. 7€}§§§§ §’§3 my fix: §¥§c*.
sf Fast “£’r:3,<:§;_V C:{;L§;"{ –" L é;{:iue::ts Ciaigzas 'frifi-Lanai,
T:1n:_}1’«g::e”£i£;§i>;;_,

‘$;1’:~cEe;a ‘;5:c€’ ,&5§§’i§§§1$’§”§§}3 guégament 332:?

This A;}pa:aE a:{–>z3§’§;ig..e§i2._§i;:’ Eacin:é.~x;sé.e::~:: Eizés day? EEK: Cimri.

c%eEi*2:*e:’ed the f”*1.¥*;:iV:;g–:~
E} i; M ii 52 *3′
TA:’i3fé13;,E%::’ ‘V£.}’é§’¥’i:fi.ii§?.g an {Err a;imi:;s~;é<.m, by e¢..:t'1xz:r:E.. {ref Ce°:am,~;::i

ii): pA:~:r:.;€_:’e:-5,, £_.é£,j§%;:s;.%;1 up £13?’ §§:’:::s.i z.i’E:=«;p<_:.aaE_

*~*«~; " H 33 'xi *= * .._'.§.=.z…£
;~ 'age: .':if.'§{.'3i:.§Ei3!IE fiififlifl :13 kw; 'i?ZE'si§§'ii§" Wm: 1-was imp Edéiigé; £3?» at

___"'f"%:s}f:a;}n:§::::§ ir: a e;§2:§.:ri §:t:i.ii.i:3rz E}:~;"' rezspmtsziefii za:.}.E in ré.::~;pz::.:i szai' 2:

T\'i':%1¥.i;E§LE££-£..'i' ziamagc. '§"'r:t;: §.}§CiS 1}? ifzt: £3«':1.}£6 wmfiii 2'e:v:;.:aE éhai iim

%:<:.3._'1.§L:§:: bc:E<.._::';g§__s_a.g Eu résssgymzaiaatrf 520.? had me: wiih 3;} accidemi

Z'

3
itwzzriving, ::irmihé.:.r imrry mi’ I’c$p<;~nai(::11§. §':<..).2. Tht: c.:3z:1iz'a'2 §}_:ciéiée;n

isavizzg Emma Emigcd am ihs i.L?(§§§i§g $23.: i?%"::tz: appciéani. E';{:§*ei§i".V3,¥g::§'ss

fiat: irisumr in raspt-mi ii}? :.%1:; crikééniiéng m:§:§g:';:: %. EiicE:2:3.g,V§:é;s;;.:§:% "

rcspameieni 31.3.2, flit: Triimnagi has §.Lg£é§§}i:ét::§ «_§§';–€ §.%z;§3Vi§§:«'_}-fur"; *'i§1£:A

21,pp£:ii2:n': in rmgpcci :1? iizc &.'o:I:3agc:g i.'m1;__:;z:*'z;5 aw2sr:i'cfi§ " 5% is 'i1§*2i:§'–

svhésh unéiar €..:haH£:¥I'£g€:.

3. Thg Cm;rs:«;eZ £271″ i31::3 é3;{)p€:§_?é1:11_:1?%€.3.;1§;§’::§.3E1E£:¥”Ei§ %.h:».zi iéierz: E3

‘ A
{QC

my §Z’¥Si1¥”Eii3£3E2 pi_;3i:.:y iss;us:;§V_V_}%}:._V iiaéc §a,p§é§§}3.r§.£j .i*.’1 E}§v<}ur mi

u£"EE::z'::;iir3g vsiaieiait '?§?1'::VrE'ri'§";u§¥:;£VfV. vv§i.VE":AeV_;1§i é3:;§:;§%es~;t;%I:g é.E1§:~; ésspazcé. <32'

ihi: maimz" and –.w§':§.§:a;§:;3. i§:i:i;%.1.'; g.'a:«: ifiai {hrs agzpeiéaglé. haai in
E}g:.<.:i issuérii ihg" §§:§T§i§:§; 33:?: fe:$ p:::g:i– séi' E%3a~; §2§E7:m§it:g 2z::?:%'L:i:;:§ Ems

prexazesdeaf E11§E::sei::n°:E:¢"§ia3:}i'i%ijg an ihzt agépzfiazzi imgurszr am} has

i'u:'§1i:r_§.gié.mT2:i::L1I §i"i}:»§§..i;§36 £¥.f§7£¥fifiH!?i 3%};-z§§ I'{§3.§<'z: §§f§f.i'; pajgmeni it': flims-

'.fi1"ifé:§.V'§'37E_V:~5ni.':iIIvi.:£vé.2'2i§E}£§J'v!f€&§i.'I*s?€I" {mm Efw 5;m:e:2":{§ rm;;§:.n":<ic3§£. E1 is §'n'é:~;

wE":i£.:'r1"iS a£r.1_éi::§ij ~_s.:h'::.E}cngem

(J!

5. In ihixt; 2,-=i:*;’w’ €}§&E.i’§t: maiitrtg ihc: appaai is a§§<.}wm§,H__7§7§§¢' zéwfafii
é.n:.~:::EEi.r as ii ¢i25;'<;:a;is iézc §:1{'s}'}£;5§§:i¥'ii ii? ma-xééc: payaizgr'-§2E_ :"m:.<.:?xsn.:i ;”«::.~«:;§s:mi::zzé. is seei a.:z:é:7§s. “‘§’?1′:.::«.v §’:”:_ai§§tj.:r* vi???’1’7{:t3jfE£;ifE,§§€§’i’§

£0 ihs T:”iE3:a=n2;} E5? 21 §%e§:~;h a:-z:rI§«;%<§?e¥2:v3¢ii?::::_ in i.:;”i§;:,z;§3E is.

z;ié_::?s.:i.:::i ii} e_xpc<iii::ViE1:: g§is;g1::s«;¢;§'–::E' i–.§?:.é,}"'§:t£:§'ii{rifl." "

 """      .,