High Court Karnataka High Court

Dr A Jagannath S/O Y Arasappa vs S Nagabhushan S/O S … on 18 June, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Dr A Jagannath S/O Y Arasappa vs S Nagabhushan S/O S … on 18 June, 2009
Author: K.L.Manjunath And C.R.Kumaraswamy


“”v gaagzagfiwgg

“a ,§¢§=§E$§9§§gm?;

.x *E§EV§¥§§%ER am @3332 fiéffifi Qégfiafii §%$§E§ IE

ER 2&2 EEGE C§§R@ my fix;;aTAKA Ar E%E$ALQR§

msrgm mm ‘SEE :3?” Q? may

§RE$E§T

%§E gsgégaa an g§3$:cg K{;$g§xg§§§$g.”»a ”
$33 * ‘:” “_* 1 ,u

wag fi@§’ELE aa,Ja$€:cg_¢.§sK§§&2%5%A§¥w_ ;

R.?.&4§G¢%§3 aéuéasz ‘
gzfiwgggz A

3 $3 A a&sa§§&?§ s!$,¥méR&&é9?§*.’=*”

REEEREQ ME3I$§L FR$G$:$iQ§ER,V
afia ES? Fzaégffiyvaxgi§§Eg:s§§’§@’3:2g§a
:3 fiéfifi, $”BL§c§Q’:;a$?a@§'{.g
§AgAJ:&A§gR< }_ "'..V7.""V E
2§§a§¢&3e:@_ "

z T”?. §§§ELE&§?

§Ey $3: : §;g;$g§§sg:¥§$é§;”Am¥a;
éfifi ‘ .

:é “a §§§§§§a§g§§ $£$Ws afiégfifiésagaaggygé

_x§§@g Bffi fi@°2§?5
‘§g§:aa&§&,:3§£*fia:§§ E ELGCK; :3 gyggg

RA$A§$§AQ§§’2

2% S §’Q%%’§§%€’§

& §%§E§§a §$;:§%2§’?;§§: $553.,

;§§§ 3:2”; s 3 ggzggvng

* f-E§i$ Eflk Fxngfi $;g’§§ E§§§Q £2 gg syc A:a:§£?

“*.”$gg;§a.g2e§§§§ 9% %EE gxgg s? $32 2: éfiafi. §:%§

fi:?:L gvgsgf Eafira;

Q3′??? E”..?§§’%E;ZE*¥G ‘SEE EEEZE’
Ffifi §§E$EE’E$ §E%G éTE é §$R*%£€§§*§’E f,’€§¥a.;”¥i§C”§E€3%§*

Em)

E313 é§§EL fiemzas mg gag av2$§§@ %§;§f§gg,
Hflfifififiéfi 3; §EL:?ERg§ ffifi ?®§§QWZ§§: ‘ **~”

3::§.HR.§,§a$as§:iva§pa E333 §3f.,Tj3;&¢:i ;§pai}°.§saa-2:*’*.g§;m;%:
appellant. §”§*;a swim .§;s:i:3.g§::”~:>§:°é;’–ra$&;%::€, 1

2. éfiiter haaxigzg %: é’u._::%3.ft%;%;.a%;*g,.. V”%t:Z§*éa =:.j:<:s2;rt 323$;

fiuggfistefi ta bath fthaf agfififiés. t$ "éé::1e fifia
fiigpixte amiaabiyb x n b

3, af the
Smszrt, 'éfafiiled tézezlxr zfiigyute
3',. vfiQ§E§3<fi2%:'§§.1§g$$ gatitiazzfi Eh
ig =._ §§:'.$jeb:_ ';:;§'$§ea€;:*Je yzzrtias amé i;:;~a:Z.:'
gi&§£;§%r§S'–. . .

%.f’ ‘§’:’§§;.’_§az’?,i&§ &,3::a §:>§3e:3§;; bfiffliffi tha fimzxftw

ffhagf ‘A Qxfififiiiififi Qf the fiagygrazaige

§%tf%…é:;:;.zr;2§’ *§”‘:3.e partzas Eiaava imam ifiaazézifiigé; big

_ i::*:&3;r Eéfiyectiva Afigaaaézasd

§’E’:§ $;,§§%33,3.Z’§§ hag zggrégé Ea f§3.”j§’ 3; gum Qf

‘~E$?3§§$§,§§Q§m ta ihe ragpanént an ax bgfare

3’:,.E.2;2§%§ in fail 332$ £33333. gattfifim At af ‘igfifze

$1323.} 3%’ izéfza a§fi$aE.§,a::t¢ Tha xefigagnafiiazzét hag
$§3;”%€$: :3 rsazaivsa am afazfeaazfii agzzmzsaé; sf

‘(iii

§
R$.3§§§§,$$§f~ anfi ha E33 furiher agraéfi ta

‘vgaaia and. haaé fiver j§GS$@$$iGn Qf tke1 §:$am§

fiecr ané. sacanfi £399: ef the sui£~ $¢§éfi§1&

§rQ§&rty ta the afipélianfi at _t§§ igfi%z’§f”,

xeaeiving the éntire amgufit »Qfj.§$§3§¢$§,§§§f#.’

._,_

fhe yartiea %3v fiurfifigg figfieefi V§§%§ .ik.4i§§
amaunt of R$.3§gGG,®SGf~ ig mat §a§§f¢§ §%Hbefsré
3Z.i2.2@%§, tfie $a§§aa§§§§ §§$11 a%§r§ imtasggt
sf 18% yer anfium w5§j$%fi;§:éGi§;Q3¥$1m£Ea:l§, if

the r&sp¢nd$fi%5_fail$i=%a”A%$¢a$é« &nék hanéb fiver

ysssgssiamg. §&fi :5 x§§ea’ Em: t§& aggallant ta

Qfitain pég$égs£Q§ $y1@X&sa§in§ tfia fifififfifi afié he

‘_.i§ afifififiiefi fig figmageg 3: tfia raia af §5g2§,§§$§m

AV fifiiw mfiihu Exam tha fiata $5 makamg the antire

§§§%an§ %$_§éj3§;8$,Q§$fw by tha aggallant ta the

re§@fifi§fit;

“‘g§9 in View $5 tfie aampxgmige azgivfi at

-}bé§%één téa §art3&$ at tha i§§ar¥e§§is3 af ika

V $§uxt§ the §§§%ll&fi$ is ntitlw fa: ggfuné 9%

fihe full caurt fiaeg.

W

«g
‘-§

?. :§\ tha ragult tha Jmfigmama afid. éearaa
pagséfi im $»S,%a.22§§£§2 an tha file sf; City
czassig. gmgaf Eangalaze, a1é:..24.s.2sm_ 3:»

set agifia and mdified.

8. §ursuani ta tha fiecrgé Q§;ihe tr:a;_é§§$t,fi

the rfiayomdent has ;_§p§3§fi%& :Jaf% sfi$ ” fig
Rs”2;§$,fi8%fm bafora the $§firt bé1§§§5 it ia apfi
fsr “he rfispanfiafifi. is %t§ér3w Htfie afiumt

fortfiwith.

R@gi§t:§=i§ §i£aétéfi t§ éxaw the mmifiiéfi dficraa
ix ta:m$*a£%ihé_é§m$@miSe.

/3
Ridge

Sd/-3
Jud’-3