Dr Dhananjaya T N vs State Of Karnataka on 3 June, 2011

Karnataka High Court

Author: J.S.Khehar(Cj) And H.G.Ramesh

 

IN THE PKGH CCJURT EFF KARNKFAKA AT BANGA_I_g{}RE

ggms 3"'E~§iS "ma 33% B533' 0;? 3:39.35 29: in 
?RESE§T " "'

mg %{{.'}1'$'BLE MR.J.S.i~';HE:£{§aRg c§--§§F.g;'Us'§f:}c3::':   A A'

A3232} _  _ A
'm:: E~£Q§\?'BLE MR.Ji;s<:':c:§ '§'«:'.:3;*:=;;»;:2z:r::$:  2  " '

WRIT PETITION Nos.1s9o2;»=.1i*--i

Between; :

Em)

Q»)

Dr Dhananjaya T N __

SIOT Nanjundaizih V J  «

Aged About 36 Yea::s. r  _ 7
Medicaf Officer? 

PRC, Kacialuﬁ   .  '- A 
Maddox" Talazig, Mandgfa Disiﬁcé  
Drshg-«ak§;:masV.v;s;;;ms«h¢:;yv.  
zigéd      
I\r4f3<;ii,C§1IxQff1Céﬁ:;::_    
?HC. DuIea:sd;s,v':Human::ad Tam

B_id3r_ Disiriéi.  "  .. ' '

Dr éxszd 'K2».zini3Ii  
S;/O Mti -.Fa:21ra}i' -_

j ' Aggd Aboatﬁei' Ysarsi,
' Médical Qffiééiz, .fT_H€.L' Rajeshwas,

B:i2§§e;u'i<é3.yan Tahzk,

" ~ _ V mags ;3.i%g:'::::

" =  B? '\;"»?£:V:Lk2':VtjaV*é;VI%

szc Mama;

4' Ageé }$§::<::;:z 3:3 Yaaifsg

::«1eé:.;ca: Qffécszg ma hfiasgizscéh

V A.  Bidar Disirici

WE: Paﬁmaj S '~§;:::§::1:2d:"5

Sit} Siiatinaiéz Ra§§§:¥§ 4%? ¥z:;::':e,
fﬁiggiiazzzi §:}§§§£;"if:'.,



 

E Z . {
~' ' '$330. *5} :«;ngappa"K:2::1a.rja§

m

PRC, ﬁaddﬁegiagi,
Dadéabaiiapum Taiiiiég
Barzgakmz Rurai Qisiréci

Dr Sahém Kama? Sizeiigs
S30. LV.S§*;€{i}~' .
Aged Abmzt 43 'x"<°:az*.«;
Meﬁiaai Gfficegg

Genera: iéospiiai, I L .... ., _

Sakaieshgmraé Basgsaa flisirécg

I}: Shzmiakka N Biradar

D33. Laie 1\$ir:gap§z: Eiradar  ~-
ﬁgad ixbaut 3?: Ysarg,

:*v1edi<;a§ Qfficsr.

GH éewargia Eizzibargzg §is:ri:; ..... 

E3: Sacizin S Pujari

SE0. Sriéhar ?uja1'i _ V
Aged about 27 Years,-A"'  . 
Medical Gffzccxg'-__ 11 , 

PHC, L{3ii.;::pui§T"" _, _    
Muaazg-'ra§:§;:.V £~:Vag:s.;:::a:--.::i_s:'::s:: _  '

  i5MaIgh:éin'--..V' "

1 3/3. Laxfxrmvs Maig;h.ari'«..¢_' --

:%,ged~_Abnuf'#?4i"'féa3'5,   ' "
Mzéagiicai Ot"iE»;ef,V '§*a}_ui<: Hdspiiai
Mudhgi, Bagaif<.{:£€.Di::t;i's::

ifﬁr Basavar;.1j_S Viiamaéai

V"  , skgéd Aime: 38 Years,

' " -»  :9i.fedie::a§.{§i"f1_cer* PHIL', Managuii,
'Easa.3{é2i:€1 Bagewadi Taiak
' --.__.'§ijé:;:%r;'_§a.__ iiistrici

 §rr.S2éti;:%§Bha§awa2:

ESJ5,' ﬁhagawan Tiwafi

V, _ Agﬁé Aheui 36 'faars, Mz:c:i--iaa¥ Ciffica;
" " Iigmnugg Medaiibehai Taiuia,
H r8i3;».1p:zz'a §is:::'i:::

3:' S353}: Kama: {E S
356* Q S 

Rgﬁ éﬁsat 39  Mséiaaé Gffiizm

€%§{lZ '?23§§§i:;§i%% §ar"'§:§{;§:?a"@i§1§% "i';§§is§3,HG_  .
3};/Iudkal;' CTi:i§:kb:i11a;;t1ré' «'}f'_q & Dis:

ﬁt. Agmma; V  ~ 
Age{i.Abm1t 46 Yé3:s,.. _
PHC, }¥«i€:<ii'{:aIV Qfficér,  "

1' 'F'H_C, Rippaxgpétg Hoséﬁurga Tag.
' ' Cﬁﬁtxznziurga £5ist:'.i_::_£_. v

,1"): I\vi§a:1j ﬁi:.3{h S

'  «Sf€:.Sh2;rér:a;5;;3,Aged About $6} Yearg,

 ;M'ezii"c_:;2i_ Gfficer, FHC,

' ' g::§:e§s;._;x§:e::a:'1*aiu;g
 -. Ba_:1ga§m"€ Urban Dist.

Q: Rbopa Jayaprakash

j " 4, &D,!o,{} layaprakash
_A.--§&gs& Abel}: 35 'fears?

Esiedicai Qfficsr, Fﬁil',
Aaajé, Qavanagers 31;; 8: 3:55:

§: '%'€§2*3;§§*:a§:*es%;

S§§,§233§%nga§§3,éga§ 55:31:: 2'? "{§§:5g

§5f:€§?:C3§ Qfféggzx
Smsgrgmanz §-§:3;<:§§i§§, Ear2ga:"ps£s:§
Eisaéar Dégiréaz



3G.

1.4»)
W404:

353.

U'!

Br M Vs' Rzzvikumaz"
S'f{3.M K? Venkategiz

ﬁsgad Aimu: 39 Yea:'s:_
Madiczsi C}%'ficer, PRC;
€Ihaz'2é;:g22iu§ Baﬁéa Eiabié,
Mazzciyzz Tq $2 Bis:

Dr Bhagavaiz 5?;

336. C} Subbaéah

Aged Aﬁoui 3? 'réagia

?»=§edi::a§ C}ffi<:s:r, Pﬁifl
Sonenahaiiy, Bangaiori: §*v'<::rz§j;; .'
Barggaimfe -- '

D: Raviraj Kariyappa She:
SKO Kzariyapgiza Shat . J ' _ «
Medical Officer, PH__r «ﬁﬁzshiimnih 3 i;_   ..
?s»1edicé.I{)fi'i£i€?r, CHE.   =

  .

.S’himog’2: .Er5§sIric:1″i ‘

S/::s.Babm7a0
Aged AZr70ut28 ‘$63255, ‘

. ‘megiical Ufﬁcez’; mt;
» ‘ﬂﬁhifisrgig Bidar .::_;;;;;<;:

:3: Lshgvaziumay

" T,:~:z:':«…I;:' Lisgaragu

%~Meas¢a;_ Gffiéer, PHQ.

V V "~, W;"s:::. '1" N Nagenérg
aged Aebut 45$ "¥"sars;,
Ivieciicai Gff%::s:',G<2°v£r;:r:ze::: Eégsggpﬁal

_ V SaiIj*z¢g'a§:;,AK0§isg3§Tq.
Ch_a:n:';{§énaga: Qistrésé

§:*v-S:z{§2.ii)2: A s

i<e?a%2:g&:*$, Ehrizizazi' Eiiigirisi

3:' iélirzgsfé Ramaiaziz"

S;'€}.§ S R:~3:::'z:;§;:: 2% “”1’$a;*:x;,)
§%;§:.§’,:0u;t_3;7I Yeérs,._ ‘_
N.7€diCaIV.0ffiCé§;;._P.HC,_V ‘
Kamagér »K011égai Taiuié
Cizamaia_jaIia;;2ir.}3i3{riC:__ .. ‘

Br Mﬁlesh L
S10. Liirgamnxalégmasda’ ‘ ”

;’ ‘éiggd A§:’3{)£”s’§__27 “‘i”ears}
PHC, Shivalii’ ….. .. N

:v:an:1y”a.’:fq 5: Distriei

_. ‘
= ,’ Sis}; Rangamiiz

Agarﬁ A698: 48 Years;

M«:d:c:;:”‘0ff;cez, 93:1:

5%?

Gajisiagers, Madiiur ‘fa1:1};.,
Pviandya Diszrici

3: L \?€;’::3i;:iaE.’f E1 Laksséz

éxgaé 53301;! 4% Yéars’

fwieiiigzii Sffiész, Pﬁfj’,

Bihészgré i:§’§ié:k§>i%§§§{§§’ “Fig S5 §§%;{{%C€

E}? K S Szsziééggééa §fC% img Sigﬁﬁgir/5%:
Ag:&::%£f§

Agégé ?§.%3@:s: zféi} “r’$:.::’>;§

Fﬁ$:§§::2.:i {}f€§;:§i:: ?§€{f,I

ilifa

48.

49.

Mandya.VDistrict ‘ ._

Kappa, Madam Tz:§::%=;,
ﬁéaaiiya {}i;~s{rici

E): M Suresh

S59 Labs E} M Munékrishzm
ékgeé $505.1: 3&3 ‘Y’ear:«;§

Eviﬁiﬁicai Qffifléi”, 98$?’
Narasapura, K013: Taiu§<; 6;: 3&8:

Dr Rzsvikuznar B 1%

S50. Laue L Hanmmaiah
Medécai Ofﬁcer, PRC,
Jadegenahaiia

Hosapura T:;:1ui;. _
Bangaiore Rum} Disiriéa

Dr N C Narayan Swamy
S/<:3.Late N Chinnaiaijw _
Ageii Ab0.:1£'-#5 "r'.eareg
Mad:ca1c)ffic;5:;' _ '
UPHC;-, "1<c;;:s..:f « ~ *
Dr P,\%' Y/'e_erab}:;;;i:ap–;u_zé '
fﬁia. P F"ut.€z.i_ah . _
;+1_ged_ Abcut 46'-Yéa;f$,' _ " _
Medical OffiCe7r,. CBC; _.
Mzﬁodcii, IVE'-m:i£i'a:.:* *:".q;';*–« '

' DrLAIV§ahesh'C"" A _____ H x

3}'%é;A€huiim§irashekarappa 'F M
Agecé Abauf 30 Yearg,

JM_ed;Aca3 Lzjffigsr, ma:
' u Beiag'2w_aéi,,'Mai3vaIiu Taiuk,

an
§\.Ii

;'\xi2;nd.ya–.V_I3istric:

£71". §g.*'ini\;2:s S R
Age:35£

A ; ' ' S!0.K.Ramaiah
Aged About 34? 'fea:i<;§

Medicai Officer;

PRC? Kyathanahaiié,
Patzégvapura “faizgig
f§*’§2iIE§}’é1 Bisiréai

$3″ ;'{‘§§§§Z§§}’iE Kumar 3 C

M f{} §…2::2 {ffzikézzgiézigaéaig
gifgiaié ézﬁﬁiii féé ‘¥'{:;i:’:e;.
§*s:§séis::.:2E {}i’§’§£:::

{5§:”%e:’2§ Eieszpiéggé,

‘w!¥
ZN

‘wt
:5”

U5
U1

‘=3’? ”

Naganéaiszgaizz
Efizanéyzz Qistrici

Dz’ Shaséikumar S E?

S§€}.L2z£€: Qarjéapaiiaizzéz
Agszé Abeui 33 ‘:”e;;r;s:%
Merziicai Gfficeg

PRC I1K.i-Ea§i%,
Eviaiaxsaiéi Taiuéz
Mazzﬁya District

Br Sraeraxnaiah
A§:s.~:35

S50 Raniaiah.

Aged About 353 ‘x”e3r%;’
Medicai Office:

Genera} Hospiiai
Turuvakere Tahiii
Tumkur Districz

DrArvim:i .

Age:3<§ H 1: *_ .

SIC) Thamma1ms.v’

Aged AbQuif__3~§?+_ i’1″‘e2£ra; K

?»{¥e:’~.-ica} Ofﬁcéf :;:_
CBC, J. §Vi:*ji§_2;puré.’

R.aich.u: Tamig. &.,f.:31s:r:c:_ .. ‘

Dr Kiran ~Sha1i}:ar”3
S/’0.Dr.’G.. Shivan;;_nd::.V

; Aged Aboui A35″?’;’ea;s;
‘ 4 Nledical (}ffic5c%,. .. _____ H x

PEAJHQ Y athamabad:

” ~ _ V §vi;3iaxzai.3_i ‘*i*a_:u;;.
1″.?i_:i3;:;iy”a }I)Ti3:zfv;c%

my ;~:¢g;«?;L;:»a;§ H C

Sig}. Ruzéjappa $33.

Agegi sfxbczist 35 Y€3I”S.
;’&s’i’e<:iic21§ Qfficsr,

x I ' ~.. « PRC. Szziagamé.
Pizzgsaiz 'F3§::§< £5 §}§s::'i§:

Er Sridhgy E23
Sf:::.Niag§ge<s:e:%::

Agﬁéi ﬁbaai 3*} Y€:ss';»s;,,
Essiséiczsi {}ff%{:ea

Ciééf' iigéuggggéaaaéizgfééﬁ
§i;»;:r:g2:i<:2z'£ E.,§¥'E3£§§§)

6i.

. 53..

” T.w;v;>A, K;m.%hd:;yan MB.

Dr R£i’v’i:<;f1:121k3§" if
Sin. Chikkaiingaiah
Agecj §&§{}U{ 3? 'z"e.:ms,
Medicai Céfiiaexz
PRC, Bésagamhzziii.
Maiidzir "I'aiui<.%
Exlianéya District

Dr Nirzmgzgrz B S
Sia.B.P.ShankI".

Aged Abom 38 ‘:”sa.*”zs;
Medicai Dfficesz
PHC. Haiagazr,
Evialzzvaili Taiuk,
Mandya Déstrisi

Dr Nagendra .

S/0. Late Kjirishna Z\:»Eu§:’iz}s§

Aged About 45 Years,
Médiczzl Officsa
PRC? H.H.K_Opp__a1::,
Maiava}5i;*ra:;:T;;,V-‘
Mandya-‘F)»i3triCi§V_ ”

Aged’ .4;bc;m_ 40 ‘Wars, .
Medipai Officer, ‘
PHC, i{.._Hemge1’s’_t

, ‘Maddur Taluii; ”

» Maizciya Exiséréct V H _____ H ,

E)? 3;’€:€dé”‘€i K S

; ?{gcsi:Abo~=,i€’37 Yearsea

‘ Me_dié;.:g:i.:3fficea

– C31′-EEC, -I<Z'éciug%0n&aVnaha§Ei,,

~Banga§c:n'€ iérbagz

" {Dr Sewmya 281%
WIS §{:és;hna.i'..

éﬁﬁieéicaé ﬁfficez”

Agsﬁ 53:59:33 28 ‘2″ea:sz
CF%{L’,, §’1:éi{§i3§5Q§§§;}§’§§§’}Zi§§:;é
Eaizgaéczie Urizag:

E}? Panéihg R

E}??? E§.iZ;:j:2«

Agsé Abw: 2%?» §’€::2′:’»;.
E’v§€::i§::.;:§ {3§§E::§§

69.

If}
CBC. Kadug0ndana§1;>:§%:
Bzmgzzkyre Urbm’:

{Dr Kraps

W50 ¥{.S.Chandra§izai<.a::
Aged sxbom $1 ':'sa:*;~;§
Maééczzi Office?

PRC, Kaitathi,

Mzznii}! Tziiuk & Disiricz

Dr Archam:

WKCJ \5ai§;:scEev BK.
Ageai About :32 Ye:::r:s.
Mézdicai Cifficer

PHC, Shivaﬁi

Mandy Taluk & Disiric:

Dr Harish G R 4_ é
Sic). L.G0wadh3r3i3h, ‘ V
Medias} Officer, H
Ageci Ab0u1_29 Years:,
PRC, H&s3r3g§wa:£aV
Baz1ga_}cme’ a 2 ~

Dr Ram€,s;h”,-‘ 51.; ,
.’*3fOMmV/it:gIiRao. ’73
Medical <::im;.~ea.:_:_, " « , V
Aged' Ab<is:;t_ 3r3,Y:*,afs,4 °
PHC,_D'omma:;andr:i; S "'

Bangakm: . ._

. DrL's:righn;§ppa 133; _

'S263. 8;'i~{.Kaxse:rapp3,

Med iizai (Li-fficezz,

V _ T. rA;B{}ﬂ{'.'iffQ Yearsg
" ._ V« I?'£"*I{7';_~RF_a;'t1{1:i:", Eangaiars: Urbzm

— §::; ‘€ ‘ﬂzésanna Kumzar

~Ag:;«:j
SP5?) P Venuggtspai

AA ‘ Medical Qfficer,
Agezﬁ Absszt 42 Yc32:§:>;,

PRC, Eéarﬁagzzéé
§~:i0§«:i»:<.3ie Taizxka Bzmgaéiarzé Rzzfgi Bisi,

'$3 K ¥is:we:awg:a§aﬁ
$15,) E*£.?s:'Eﬁ5r3:3:;:§::;*2

Maééczgé Q§§Eger,x3:geé z%%:€s::: éi '%"@2zaia

{:§4§if; *"I23r;::°:gaEE:;§
§§::r:<§:,::* Ezizzég' ;S§:§i;::}: §§§:-;§:%s;:%

E3.

’26’

If
{Dr Shaiini H3

W/E} §r.Ragh:2n2e:;{iz:: Swamjg, {}.E;.

sfxgaéi Abezii 35 ‘fasars,
Ekﬁiszziicai {}{f§::a::

{Erhan Farzmfg Weifare Csrszra
kppu, Mangaiara. §,I{.{}§st:’i:*:

E}: B Pzmda Vijyaﬁ
SEC) Basewzziah,

Agsd About 52 Years
Meéicai Ofﬁcer,
PHCI, §33H€§i3{‘£§3§
Gunélupei Ta§u§»;,
Chamrajangar Disgrici

Dr Karihik R

350 Late Kc.Ramas:;6baA_Rea;1g§”‘ ” V’

Aged About 25 Years–;g’– » _ —

Meciicai Officer,

PHQ, Dibbu: _
Chickba1iapesATa¥uk S; Di;:tr§é;«:

Dr B R. P;*é*:t;ariIa_:_3_d_I
Age: 1 _ ‘ ‘ r
S!Qé_L.a{é” B.H.E€.nmeg<:g\2§:'da " "
Aged K}'\'}3Q§'1:§ 40 Yaéra, ' ' ~ . «V
Bxieéicai ofigsm. '

PHC, ﬁavgal, "V

Argikgre 7F3Iu§;_

Hassan'-District ~_

. Dr .l?as'unkum3z*.T G
. 'Sfo";v.Triv§kram Guéiigar,

Medi§:cz§ Officer,

3 " ' Aged l215{;:;I-iii Kyeara,

:22. 1'

.PE¥~£'{::"§s;iz2:i;§§I;2':i:€:ie,
V C.R.Pa:n;: .Ta1u}:,Hassan ﬁistrici

:3{B._ S Saiish Chandra:
Ssh… Srinivasa Gewda,

x I Aged About: 43 "¥'ea§§;*

H .–ES2ieé'::;% 563 ‘¥’$2::*:a;

?s%§é%::;:§ Gférsﬁgz

?§%€T,§3.r§€.=~;\é:ar%, “%”;§’€,?’:z:1: “fésizsfis.
E*sii2::2§j,:;: i}%5»;%:’§Qé

Si}

Siﬁ

S3.

84, 5

Dr Shaiiaga Ta:n;n.a:n;m::;:

{Eff} Leas ‘Y’P,’¥’2:r:;::1;:nszv::{;:.
Agérci Abmzi 49 Years.

Medics} €3i’§£e.r~

UFWC Canzanmszm,

Sangaiare

Qt Szzresh B§’£iZ’¥}8.p§)£: Hitiaiamani
S;’CI.Bhim2:;3pa Bﬁﬁiziaiamszni’
Aged Abmsi ‘Y§€;.ifS%

Medical Officer,

Tzﬁuia Genera} Hoapiiai.
Souciaiii. Beigaum Dixtrici

Dr Raveendrakumar Jakaxnur
Ags:

SIC) Nagappa iakanur; ‘_ _
Aged Aboui 29 Yearsy ~ _ —
Medical Officer, V ‘
PRC, Hosur, Soudati Ta}:;§:.
Beigaum {)if§$IfiC3:. I

Dr Shséfal? Ku2::;;_-mg V ~
D!O Pra.ka::}_1 k1;:.Ku:;<am:;TA~.V'L_- «_ *
Ag3d.ABc»:_Ji 3"?' :Years;._ V
:V§€CiiC2i}VAtr}VINflC€I', 4 ' '
I-;'.H€–A:nma:::4g'i, " _
Hukke1'.iTai::k V '
BeIgm;mM~Distfir::

. ' Br _S0nn;yz1» V;S'ajj'an V"
' Agé:36 years 'D:'or_S.3.jjan

M'éd§,c2{iA.Officer3
Gencra!.VHé;spi£a3, Hukkeré

" ' –F§Ve':'igz_1:,:'v:*x2VD_is_£:;?ic:t

' ' Ab¢:;;:sgi:i::§ 5 zvijuavas
Sfi} Szmisbiai Mu_}3x:g::*

Agegi Abam 35 Years,
Medicai C¥fficer,PHC, Bidaaﬁ,

AA ' 'Chikacii Tzziuk,
Beigaam Bisarécsf

§*2f§£i§"1';}§§'€ Sangaggzs Eltetaaé

SEQ Gazijagga €I%.{Iraas;:;;

ﬁgsé é£*3::»:12: if 'r"ea;:;

iieéécaé {}§§§'.2f::1G*3§'2€'i"2§§ Eéagggiiait
S:::§2:i;zii§§ ﬁeiggmszz 3%.t~;:§'§;;§

if%:22::g':'2:z~;%:§%<.:§":;:r §{;;::':;::
85% Ezssggga.

8%.

9%.

‘~53
Kw-mt

1.3
ﬁagéé éimaz ES Yaam
Eviaciicazé Qi’fE€ez*
Taiuiua Geasrai i~§:.i>s§i:::§,
ﬁsﬁzzzni, Eeigazsm ﬁigzrisz

$2″ ﬁfijagzx Ciasgii

ES §§r.?~Eez::an:z::.,
éageé éabazzi 3? Years;
Meéiaai Cifféiter,
Gemrai ﬂsézyiiaég

Aiizaai, Beigaam {}i:’«:{:*i{:£

{Er Saiisiz {T ?s::3:a§:zr

SK} Chaaséraiaanih Fsiaéaz
égﬁd ﬁsécszzi 39 Years?
Mﬁdicai {3fﬁ::e§,

CEC, Hsasakaia, «_ ;

Baagaiara: Rafa} §i;;:ri::=% » _ —

Br Ishwar Siéiiagpa H;:*:%;i::s.§.}§’= V

3,123 Late S;r.4:’§,f3;’§f1e¥:£:}ai1§: ..

Aged Abétzi &
Medic§;i’¥3i”f.i§é;:,–:2
CHC, Exaﬁéha; ” » _ ‘

{:%z.é¥;k.Qu2: 33 Yé3:s,–
f’»iicdicei%£3ffE:te;;’._ A V ”

; ‘cjécrgerai }~Z<::::§§téiiV
' G;:gka%_"I'aiuk, Be§g:a3.i;:: Bistrici:

» £3 Rasizafééz Shaiiy
"«,'55i'£3!_«B:'.{}e_€;::ak X58355

=.,;%gV::;é.;é'a;'t2<2li;;:Vl:=¥»§ '§'ai:22ra

§ﬁ§.

§%a?sezi§saZ’*§.}ffEc:;;

‘ {$253323 Famiigg *’:€§§§£”$

%?«.%’ei3;§a£§: §'”:(}S§3!§£§,i§
Eziangaiers

«A “ﬁr iizzsri Biraém

$58 §§%§§’§£2;3.’i1§€§ Bizzzééziii,

Agsﬁ géhgzzi 3? ‘{ea::»;.§

észieééaai §§§’§::’:£a:.

?§°~£§, {3§§:}§:2% {E}

éafzgiaf f§”::§:z§<;% iéaiiiézsfgzs '§ié;£r'§£§

53;' gjéﬁié §'%a;i%:a§§;: Qaiéié
ﬁagg:

§§{Z§ :E§jg::§ 2g:§1:>,r’:§§§:3 Qzzﬁsi,

I062

um.

Medicai {}f’fEc:=::*
PRC. Kasnzgizzpum Guihzzrgzs

{D21 \v”ivr::$<:2m22:1€i:: K S

S50 Lair: A Siééaigiz

Agsci Abel}: 39 'fears

PRC, Singaszzndrza. Bangaiorré Urhzm

Dr. Gangzziizmzz

Aged Aham 311 Years;

Meziical Officer? C H S Simgappa
8e§i;iz”_\,2 Dis?’ _

9;’. P Baaijssa Naié;

3/0 P Shankar Nazi};

Aged Aboui 3-/ii Yeaiia”
Medicai Officer? ”

PHC Huvina Hadagaii Bé}.Eé::y

Dr. Promadez. S’ B

W30 Dr. Manjynath L
Aged z__iT’.§:sx:,~’1’1*.:._3®._’.3:’.é_i:3;5s1: ”
Eviectiicizl Officézr, ”

P1v:V::VT;2;i:1a;:;5u1>:: 5:_::;a;:::a;naga’m .. V V

Dr. Sharéﬁégigga’ ‘ ‘ M

T 1:} L322 curappayiaii. 1:i:;:§¢§;…
Aged._Ab:3u€3§ YE:as*.s,_ “‘ 4
Medical .Of’fiz::€r,’_ 3. * ~’

1′ ‘CBC, Kan;-:a{ahag’ara,V’Bi:ia:

a:>::;’*.~: PV”GQ;3a1R3V{:§ “””

:§!(}’Lz::*: .I”P__M0han Rae

_ , ‘ Ahoy: 4.2 YE£i§’;§
. ‘ Mé&ir;::3__ i:’€:§”,

ii}?

“é:é:;¢

‘ A Te;_i<:i<aEi<:@i€, Baﬁary

fir; 'fzzszznihzs Naéia;
SJG Lats M Rama Naii

A I Aged Abaut $4 'fears
.. '§a?ft€E§iCé£§ Offices,

?i-£%; E~§22::a%1ar§u§;:, Chizziazézagaﬁgz"

3:: Sziiziggéz Kama?
S53, §§§}:l}':'3i§i§§ Pizza Ezziis
Ageé £33323: 3% 'tfaazrs:

fviééiaaé 8ff'i£€§:,2'3 H éazifaﬁ {E} Eééag:

$35 {E §'2i';2§a:z2j:;
358 {E 'izﬁsraiezziﬁséésigiéz:
s%§2s:::2€ 3?? ':/'cz,::<a;

H3;

H5.

125.5} V .

” ‘\A;%z@ M N shivare’d55z

Bidar D.i_Vs£. .

if;

Evieciical €}ff”i€=:*z’
PRC. Kamgie. H0596: Tiziuii.
Eeiiary Diisi.

13:: Naganzzii} Fiuisoiarc
SS8 Eviaiiiiaisjzm Hoigszaarﬁ
Agaé Absjui 38 Yezxrs
Msdicai Gfficsr

CBC. Haliikheii {B}. Bhnmzzbad Taéuig

Bidar ‘Gigi.

D2′. Ramanjaneyzs

3%} ‘V’ S Vsnkaiasiszzéaz
Ageai Abou: 34 Years;
Medical Officer

PBS Sidiginamea}, Beiiary

Dr. Yuvaraj M Birada:r.__ _
Sic. Manikappz: Biradar _T ”
Aged Aboui 37 Years _
Medical OffiC<é;".__ ' ' '

PHC, Ghatbefg.§,;Hs;r:i:1nb::<:I""£;ai{ii:f.%_1?rath;p”: 33.;ada;_, V ‘

S/O Jaiiaygifan R553 E3 iréidrﬁ

.%fxged_ 3:3 beam} Yesars ‘ ” – .
Medical Offficeﬁ V.

PI-£C._M2.:1taI, ‘Bas’:*z§k:1%}}’3na’ Taluk,

Dzi”N iayanihiv .

zﬁgeﬁ Abbatt 45 Yearx

” ‘ Ms _<j03c;:»_ Gcjneraé Haspizai

SE'?

V« C3hénVf;1.::}a;a§,’ ‘ChiCK§}3.H3pLiI’23 {Bias

D*:_;’Ba::;,é1 E P

S!{I!«:_L3E€ Dr, EVE C Paruraé
€;3′:”£–hQ,

x I ~. Gen$r::i iigsgﬁiai,
Sewrébédansr, Chiaiihaiiapzzrei i}i;§E.

E132, jiéamaiﬁg E3’
63$;

ﬁeiizczzsé i-£::«s;p§£2;a§$
Eézzvagsszgsavc

E32′. %;”€€::2: 3%
%?*é5€} S2:§§.~eE”: {E éé
3&5}

EEG,

124.

1′?

Generaf Hosgiiai
Keppai Bisi.

E311 \«’;a:§i§2:_§ B Pokkars
S59 Saba; Rae Pekkaa
Agsé Abaué 43 ‘faafs
Bistrici Hespiial, Fiaiarzi

{)1 G A Seshagiri R30

SEQ S if Asxvaihnarayasz R229 .

fxgeé Abmzt 593 Years;
Genera} Hosgitaé
G:>\?sribi&z:nus., Chicki:sa¥§ap:2r22T.£3%2:,

Br. Nagabhuﬁhana M L

SIC} Lingappa M S

Aged Ab:.:{31 Years’ &
Karatagera Tumkur -_

Dr. Davaraju 155 S

SIC) D Sidcis._i§2is:>1_\«’ai2:§§
Aged Abcgaisi .’-:”ear3″._
Gener3£–H’aspi{§§__’.’_ 4 _
Gubbii Tun-1R:;r.Dis;.$… , *

I3:’.”V’may”i;: V.

;;/0 C :2 Vas;-m¢~.:::.%
A’ged’.Ab0u: ° V __
Tufuj§e%v:re,’1″‘:1_mks.,1f’ N ‘ J

‘Dr. B €’~§R:«1 iani~
WK} Dr. H V’-.R:jgimQhan
‘ éigeﬁ Lékbaui 43 ‘féérs

L£:p%rQ&;}f ft%i)spitai,Banga10rs:

M. C
V SIC? A iéffhannabasappa

. §g;éf;§é

Agefi Aboigz 36 Yﬁafs
P52:-“iiatris::s§ CBC; B N Du:’*g2:§

AA ‘ Haiaiizsze Yaiuk, Chiiraéurgzz 5:9,;

, A $2: Saasiiha K E WK} E2: Vévcxazzanﬁzz

,%g€:3z$

ﬁxgéé §%.b:::::: 3% ‘%’s:::§.%;
{“I:jm::{:§*:é:.<:i
Ekziagzséi. Eamanagaga £13593,

13:. 3:5? Sésagmngzms
35$ §'2:~;

E3}.

” – 135:.

18
Grim. S R Dissé. H{§fsfg3iE23§¢
Kiéiam

Dr. C J Sushaaeiadavi

Agaé Absut 55? Y€:;i§’s;
Gynacha. 86:16:31 §*is§:2ii;:i
Paaéavapura Maﬁéya f}%s«;:.

13?. L Rajz;

SEC) 8 Lingaiah

Agad Abaui 57 Years
Leprexy Hospiiai,
Bangaisrs

Dr. Vanishyse N J

DJO R Narayanappa ‘ __
Aged About 35 Years; *
General Hospizai, V
Bangarpai, Krﬂar Di:s{,”* .

Dr. C L Piiahaliiéxéa. _ . ._
Sfti) La-re ;1’_L.,eni;-appa
cam, ‘ ‘ .

G.c–:}s1’al H’QspitéiE;A_ _
‘?V-“iptuxg Tﬁiflvkﬁf IZ)I.iss. .’

Df.uB V Cha’nné1i3zis:3V»?ai:.a__£iA”

Ageéi About 48 Yéafs »

Dkg§*.e.’ij«;.’1:”‘;’§§/§U”T£;iVii’I” « ‘
S30′? Thi;pp€g{}WC§’ci

V’ ” F&gé:’iAb_0{1’E._i_;’«5 Yr:ar.~:

:3..~3 _
” ,A.g:s.:i éihoué 4? Yaara

{:3
W,

‘§EN’§7.’A:La$%£:§re, Hasszm Digs

Br, Bash:-varzijga

GV¢:1’é,ra2 Hosgiiai, Sira, “§zm1i<2s§ QESE,

Ck'. Ravikumar B N
MS OBS. Aged Abau: iii Years;

Eisi. Ir§0.<;§i%§£? Ciziirgsiiigrga

{E31 iziyarzzm E' E

359 3 Pézziéuzgsgiisiiiagkgzzz
Agﬁﬁ Abezsi 3'? Y€§§";*£
£33353. %~§::zs;pii2:%, {;'f%a§i§'z1;:
S58 $o::2ai;:%’2
fagaé §:.§’§{E%.§ «:33 “:’«3;:§.a;

_Genera1” Hospitgd.-_ Ti{:.;u£;umi<:ur Bisz.

E48.

14}.

£433

39
ﬁnaesi, Dist, i~i0;:>i£21§ Cititraéuigzs

R1. Siwamaia ‘V’

{}.z'{} R Vimkaiafz
Aged Abouf Bf’) Years;
Em. {3€f!€iI’é3.§ }-iaagaiiaé

CT’nannapatr:a5 Ramangaramm Dix:

Br. S Chaniirzikaizg

Wii} M Srinivasan

Aged Abmst 44 Yieass
Generai Haspitai
Srinivasapura, Kcsiar E}i5;i.

Dr: Suresh P A
SEQ Ajappa P N . .

Aged Aboui 3? Ysaré’.
Gcwemment Hospital ” ”
Turnkur Dist»

. Dr. Lokesh Fediifg B 2};

SID Hanufnangiia _E?:::dc§j;; BUB
Aged .;Xb0;Va_&..38″~’r'<?:;_1rs ._
Genera},Hc:3p2}i_ai ' _ ._
Paxut 38 Yé9.fs.– ‘ ,
DoMs”-Genera: :1os;~1ta;”

;’ Kzsiiﬁgai, ‘1 umlciif Disi

. ” «EV-44;

V. ‘M<§h:~1.n L

sic' 'Lag: Lakshmaiah

'V V E}, "

‘ A Genc:’:_:I._fi<';§pi::;§

V Mgdé'

i<.u:.:i.;g2:I;_.""E'u mkus iﬁissi.

3;: 'rmith H :2:

Agsiﬁ Abceut 42 Ysafse. OBS

. ,__I}SiL Bexpitaé
.. ‘€:E;ici<;r:agaEe;:"

$5" Rzsasé ﬁx

£3 Qfiiééi}

Samrzzi Baggiiaé

Pvizsﬁégr T2i§i§§<.?%'§&%'%§}%3i Eiﬁéiféifi

Ti}; §§i§<;f%§T§2£§:'2§%E§ if} E:
C)§3iE'a:t:

“sE\f§C§.§§ P E§2:%«’;;:§”z3:

34%.

ESQ.

_5S3?49 ‘ V .– V.

4 SfQ.Bh€€Iﬁ’aAﬁI_’£¢i Chandra
Eienezai Hospiiak ———- ~ ”

Chigzzieri Digirici Hespiigzi
Davanagere

1):” P S jagaéeashag:
EN?

Si{}.P N Nangundaiah
Qﬁstrici Hsspiizzi
Chickbaiizzpusz:

Dr \?’iru;32:ks¥3a_g0z;d2:
}3’hysic§
S!0,’1″ir::kar3agi::ve<§:2
Qisirici Hagpitzzé

Tumiazﬁ

Dr Ksdarnazh .

SfO.Ganad2:ppa Té1I’I£§£%.§’ ..
CHC Kaiagi ” ‘
Chiitapur Taluk

Guibarga Di:i::t%<:i

. Dr KaI1e§§i2.wa:;1:: <i: ~ "

Oahu M.

SIO.Par:;h3»§:é:harachary.K”f§ ~

Distfict. _Mgbi1e”¢;:pha:m1c=Un1: ‘ ” V

].f)isirict_ Hospitgi ” , 2
Ttxnliizxg ‘ ~

Dr Iridtajeast Ci;a.ﬁdfa~– ‘

Hgmnabazé

» . Taigjm Distiic-i

DE .M;mj’u math

Gpiha ” A

‘ Sz°’Q.L:3ié K C Ramaisés

{E
w

‘E’§ist:’i€t Hospitaé
“Fufnkuz

~…5§;€ 2-‘: Eﬁmesh

S.f{}.§~§ Kriahnappzz
Thaiizi: ‘3€i’§{fI”£i,§ Eiéspiiai
Sim

Tasmigur i3és:%sé:::

, {Er S:§’s:§f:i*;i H 3″}

{§jg:”:2;:’§3:’2
§”}s’i’}}{ i’}€::2:g3§:::,
Q£§E{“:§’£%§ §§:;2~;§3§aE

Efﬁé.

§5§.

Muiabagai
Kaiar Biszrici

Q: K, Srinivaxan M E}
Age:5€%

Physgicé

Sf{},M Krishnappzz
Genera} }ies:;3i:;:£
Maia:

Kaiar Déstrécz

Dr Gisish B L
Ag€:3é%

Gynaaha
S/O.La}<}wda
General I-I0spita§
Maiavailai
Mandya District

Dr N Basavaraju .

Agéﬂii «
SlO.Ning2£.§ah . ‘ _
Genefiﬁi ‘H.:i’s;3it’a~2~~ V
Malavaﬁiai f__ ” ‘
Me–ndTya Di$£ric:”:* :;:_

3:; R Sri::iV\s;is’. _» ”
Agczﬁi}. W ~V
SiO.Late~Ramé;iah'”.’ . “‘
Gene:’aH:{0Spi:a%’._ A

j ‘Gundlupet _
‘ 4 ‘7:.Ch;:rr;a1ja_inaga:’ D.i__s:_r§s:é

–» _ :3; iéavithév __

” ,%’wz<3.{;r._<3:;~;ahay A

Bhadra<;zj.z§éé

shgmoga' Disiric:

1:;;’~1<f N B Raga

" ~.S!{}.L2z:e K ﬁarashimhaiah
Samara} Hiaspiai

Kesiietgai
Shamrajgzgigai Qégz

E}: Eééazz Raﬁsiirs
A§5:<§3 }5t3I;:§'Eé
Ef§§,§f¥§.,.§€3E'{}E"£E€ R§%E:{a
Ciszésrzii §%as;:%:::E
K:;:1é;:§:::'z:.§§i:§:1pi §§§~:i3"éai'E,

263.

266.

16?.

E}: Sidwakumzzr C}
Agatéii

D Cribs;

Sfﬁffi Rama:

Gﬁnerai Hespiiaé
Ki}I’i{i2i§E§§’2}
iéiiupi E}is£r:i€:

Hiremazh B2}S£iV£iE’;I:1f§¥’s?Z1f’f§§
Age:43
Sf{}’Siéciave€myy::

Dist Hespiiai

Qulbafgsg

Dr Rzmganaih

Age:5O years __ 2. _
SfC).Naras;imhas:harya ‘Kati? ‘
Dig: Hespitai ”

Guibargg ”

Dr Sati 4S2;hiv2;s’h3_;1drayy::’
Age:5?? ‘

s;0.sid<iay:sa;"§3wa$&:§% ., ' '

I3isV£"}v§0$j:$§:aI " A
fjuibazfgzi <
Di' I'{s=:nui<:'e:«:iVé3;% 2 » "
Age:§"Ié§yea::; '

V . Aged Abagtt .'i4 '{e:af;;
Dist Hospita-§.._V V
. . . . . .. '

D1jP:3K21s:§1'_é
}A,s;§€:.S4 §;*é2.:j§:<_.~~

£6?

Dig: .:~_r’e4;s,p;;:a:,:xaiaa:iike::

E3: Fiadaghévappa EVE
Agézaii years

V ” SfO,La:e M Maagmazg

‘ :::{:.

Sig: Heapiiai

Madiisré

Err ifésizavgiiazh Shizrzgé
ﬁgeﬂﬁ
Si§.?:.:::§2§%}:3,§3;:;:

5%: H{>s§%§a§
§’ar~%g€.i%%.&::

U3,

E74,

E75.

ta)
W

Dr Ranch: E’/’§:1h:1{iev:: Baiaars
Agzcﬁi yeara

‘Dist Hospitai

kiadikaré

£3? Rasizmi £3

Age:33

W§G.Dr B K Saznashekszz
Dist H»:}é~;pii::E

§\r1adike:*i

Dr K S Ravindrz:

;i’~.ge::i’E yearx

Md Peii

SXCLK P Sidéaramaiah
General Hospitai
Chaxnrajnagar

13:” H Yerjappa

Ageiﬁé yearsw
SfO.HuIugap;3g:

Gener3i_H-Qspégtéf , . ”
Béliéifff’ ” ‘

Dr Srstgtraviasa 7A:;{_”§._

,l\g£::48 jyezﬁirs 4

Ms {(.)p11£hc§}’.””-. ‘ _
SfQ.Ganapa:ha§jp§_:~ ._ ‘ ‘2. __
Saga}: M .–

_Shim0g;: Dist V

D}’._fI.”)2r1_akar ~ ….. .. V

Agfé.$3′ g::_arS

S!Q;L:31’L8. Ragga Naik
‘Dis:«._H’o:;p”;ta£_..~

. ‘– Mét;§”;i¥or%:%;; V

s*:’:f:

€90 ‘

92-‘-V:S. ?%’I”I.§2:ma;:;:a%<a5;%3
;-'xVg€138 years
SfC).S M3.h:aée¥ai&§':

; ,, .. gjaneml Hespiial
:%:':::?<a%

Br Vinay C Sajjzizé
;%,g::s:32

SEQ?' {:%'2;:13§:'::z«:%":5%;2zr.::é;2§§
Sa*::2::::'a% §"§{é§;§3§§,;§
f:%%§§§'&ifI§E%§§;i

1?").

ESQ.

ESE,

182.

$83.

F): L:3eya§~:nth Fmazia
Ageziﬁ

W:’G.Syed Nasiy
Genera? Heapiiaé
BE:iiaz’y

S: C irzgaiﬁz

Agstﬁfi

S.s’€).L:2ta Chikfezabomiaiz
Genera} Haspiizsi
Nagamangaizs

Mandya District

Dr K Y Vijaya
Age:§2
W500: K Gangadhar .

General Hospiiai ”

Magacli
Ranianagara Dis:

Dr Santosh. Shetty.

£\ge:37 H _. _ .

SfO.S1iiriiasVI?fad”S’h;tIy”-.f-._ _
PHC, Hgnniatagi ‘ ‘ _ ._
B,ijapm_a “£’:%1ukﬁ::3ci Dist

I3: Santosh Patti”? VA ‘V
Age: ‘V ”

Aged”‘Maj0r§

PHC Gdébﬁr BVV

_ Afzalpui’ TéiE:1§_<_:V
__ ' '~G1;ibarga District ~ ———- -« "

': » . D:*._A1"'uﬁE<.uir1::r A ':7'

;ag¢:*3g"

‘$50.93. 13; iégzuzanazia
PRC; Sajfagama

” iji2{§;§an°i”a§u£<; Exné Big:

@:'3£1wema M

" 5-%.ge:2?

.. AWfG.Santh:3sh §§f’§1§I32%§i§i’}3§§3

PRC’. K G Piaiéé
Ba:2gaE:3:’::. ijrbazé

Q3″ Ramesié E R

:§g»&::3″f

Sf{}.§:;mg3£h:g~:é § 3?

§3§~§{Z Esiégarcg “§”i§%:%;::’ ?as%2;§«:
‘§”::r:;§<::;* Ekéxiréai

in -'

38?,

18?.

AND;

:–>

N
U’:

Dr Ehmdur S S
Age::5{}

Sfi).Shév;:ppa Banana’
PRC Qeddanakuncié
Banga¥ez*<it lérbzm

B: Archzzna K£i¥}"ii}§3§)i1f}{£%§'

Aga:3?

{)x’€).Chanérasheiia:* –
PRC Feihsirars I
Chittapura T3321};

Gulharga Diﬁifici

Dr Nandish M I
Ag€:4’2
S/C}.}ay:::iingapp::
PHC Harzasegs:

K R Nagar T3112}:

Mysore Digtrigzi.

H V ‘ V ‘:….;. .. Petitioners
‘S:i.jXdv0c:at€
1,_frJ;.%’ Sri_:.}f_.F*:jas3ﬁ1a.r}£E1, Adv.)

SL§té”of ,
Rep By It$’Sccr¢tém; >

fiapafimené Q’;.§ie;;tm&-z::;;:::;_:y’
Weifgsre Servi::§:3,–.V ‘- ” ”
M S BLsiIdings§B.ang,aIér;_S60 00%

Thé~Direct<§r" ' V
'D;<§parIm€nt Of Héziiiii & Famiiy

Weifazgt Sczrvicsgg

" ' Auryiagiti R2323 C'–%rc§c:

.B':1«13§i:;.i,{3r:: V V

Srviiiﬁzasz-i'n€i2s

Agﬁ; 33,SfG.i~h:Vi<}<a:2§._§a Kegpzz
Gag: 'S0::ia¥ V\;'Gr§.Basar2:E<c::é
N .–Muddr:§ihai 'fa¥ui,§2:i».:.
8§§;:;%:,::” §}§:;:§*i=;:%

:39 Sri Fundaiiiszzz

Age: 48

SiO,’t’am;»ma;:;:2: Eviuraé

Gcc S£}::ia¥ ¥’s:’x::r§<s:'
R£i}.}{ire:m:rai2;;.

Muddebihai '?22Eu%;

Bijapm" Qistricsf

Hussainbiiaﬁha

Age: 48

S!O.Bandhagisab2: Sathihaizz
Dec Business; –

R/’0.Meh3b0r;bz1ag2:§
Muddebiha} Taiuiz

Bijapur District

Sjjx

“ME

Danayya r ~ _

Age: 33 *
S/O.\1%rupaks?2ayy3 Hir:::r:3£§:’V V

Occ Reporter, _, ~
RfO.D€Sh%I}uk§?'{)_I}L.NE1}af'{v’&d _ ”
zv:u&dc:’n”ih;5;«.3fa’iu::;V ‘
B ijagmr _I3is’i:ri:f,=_i ”

Tfue IK3vi’$if1″‘§1=’:T:iv.HE§§h’P.¥)dE%§f11i1y _
\:szje1fa~e Qfficeg’-..,, ” ” ‘ ‘
Bijapur *

Q: _ The “ream Heazth ¢Z)ffic}:%: ”
Muddebihai .__ ‘
V Mudcbbiha} T2iiu%:….. *
B’ijapur”Distric: .. Respondents

. A Basavaraj Kareddys Princigaé
f_GJ:>vemmen: Advocate for RL2 8 and 9}

‘Z’f§<:sé'i$fr':t Petitiana are 5232:: under Attieies 226 and 22'? 9%' 3:5
Censtitutiarz :35 India prayizxg ii} issue an appreprriaie writ. oréey er

«'i?.r§Ct.ie::ﬁ. reviewirlg ihe czrcier siatﬁci 183.1 E maiiéé if} '.15? 953.255/2021
{PIL"–~GM~R.ES§ Vidﬁ Annexureﬁ and 1.33116: 3.51 apgragriate direction {:2
* S£*2*:§:s:*&~§’

‘F%1s3g%: Kéérizi E~%3:i%%.é€}:3s €:?€i}§’§’§§§i§,§i Em fan: {::’:i€%::-9; iiféia éagf, ﬁzigf

Jtzsiice maﬁa zips §a:’;%Ess.ar§:3;1i:
Qitﬁﬁﬁ

:3:

I’

9»

0-manna:

jﬁladwga

onfﬁkﬁi ._
J.S.KI*mHAR; 0…}. (Oral) : V

Statement sf objectiazgs fiiad ‘behalf ,»:;;*. g¢s{;::Gf;j:¥;én’§%sVV L»

is taken on recsré subject j11§;._éX;:ép{iQn$. CGp§;
“shares? has been fur:1’iis-hed_«’i§:§”_{h~é§..}:%é-rned ééiufigei fa: tbs:

peiitionera -.

2. HaVi11gA._hearci_…:?1{:-V.iq::ressed by the rival parties in

the p1eg;:.:;n;gs_ %

8. It rlaow er:f1e1Fgé:<.3«,._ -that the Karnaiaka Civil Services

'_ {R¢g§;1§ﬁiop oi:'I"1*a,:1$fr3r of Medical Officers and other Staff)

V2<'3,_I'i;M received the assent cf the Governar @£c%e

'cf"E{a1iiaiaka'5;.";§he aforestated legislation has been given

efféﬁz? sffect fmrﬁ 12,95,238'

V' * Our atiemiisn hag 3,150 Vbsexx irzviteé :3 the eréez

ﬁ;?,Si"£é§§ by this Csuzﬁ: in Wréi Feiiiian %sE.15§f2$I§ dazieé

£8.:f}§§SZ%E {$:*;1;%:a’vi:”;§a 3.23:1? eihsris Eats 3? Eiamaiaka

arzé $’:§”1$r:»:s}E Tim £;:a:*:$f2%? Q§’§{i?¥”§ gasgssé 33:?” ifiie S£3J:€
aria
:’}:>:!8::;:”:’::%:é: <;¥%2i{:§'1 5;; :~3::z§3;§:%£:fi, §i£'§§3E'€i':i" ea? §f:§:a§§a:':g.;fa% ihzsagéz

313.

CT M341»/’x

28
the instant writ petiziiczrg {basmé on the earlier oréer-‘-passeé

by this Calm; on 3.8.GE.2{3I E) was therefore

We state 30. :31: aciftaumi (sf {he fact. ihai
Qepartment sf Heaith and Fa1ni:%y*”AWeIfaz’§, pféséni ‘
in Cam”: in persan, has been at is inéiz;:a”::r% «the b:§Si~sV

of passing the impugned OVI’C’§’f’;%:i’;V;’..’Y§33.3t?: ‘;9V(}1.11d, id

clarify, that we ﬁnd :”I}p fagaii transfer
Grders, as it has met the same are in
violation of tildes:- oV1fr_ier 0:1 18.01.2011
in Sri at that juncture, we
were ‘me présess of iegisiation which
has e%’:?_niv§ai1§% passing of the Kamaiaka

Civil Seréiceé “{R€§{ﬁ.1a;£iGfi of Transfer of Medical Ofﬁcers

$taff)’ A::v’?;,–.–.’2;'{} 11 which, as already noticed above?

effect to from 12.05.2011. Having gone

ihréitigh _p§*ovisions 0f the aforestated enactment, we are

sati$iie€ii;’;\tE§at mgr eariier Qréer dated 18.C2i,2QE} sheuld $393

A ‘~?f”rrAV;é:;:2:%a*ﬁi;sa; ii) ggiise effzasé is éhss:

Kazfgaiaiia Qiszﬁ $€f’§.?§{f’£fS E¥E§g;:.g§2:ti§:’: i:f’§:§;;::~:;§%:” sf Eségziiégtaé

:;”§§E$<%:*s; 332$ aziéégr Séggféé fiaita 23:3. Whiég §§i::g:

..~…—…

29
proprieiy demanés, the}: {he interesei 3? the Depart-merit :3?

Heaith and Fa:113’3y Weifare, as 3.183. the medicéLi”.§L:>1_’v:C€s

under its Cemral am given pritarity. :’%ccGrd£’:_i.g1§2.TVii’§:”§é1*:’:*§}1 1554

granted is the respondents ta r;:’»’~;”>a{ria*£fc t_ii§é’V:vgo&?er::rrienz¢’

doctors Whﬁ am on de:-putatieng i::s;::: (:0 ‘€>ff'{S1;§{f€..£1′{i€:€}b£i'<?f§€

owe; m2\D\,£s£.€JV,a'9'.,,f'\}og,7\£.gsf\§};{i7.{,
medicaé facilities; in the Efgémaitais;'7gf:e:1:resj"c1i£:icS eta;
undsr the control sf 31$ If)€parfi1:éf:t._0f H'ealth..vv.éir1d Faxniljg

Welfare.

6. W5. th:;;{:..’§Eie”f’1}npugned transfer

orders haféfé “f::}.}y<i:f:pfcér11.e:ni:ecE. That being so, i:

would' ;;f3 'F\€:fest""'af justice to require the
respoﬁzjeiitg' "the instant; order by effecting
transfers:VV'L«–s:§n V. of bef61<c::-~'L' 15.075201}. Whiie issuing the

p<§si.g:ng_f,/'::rghnsfé"r' «.£f317'.f1=;31'{S] we direct the respandents ta

' §:5§?iract_V"t':z§:,ii1stant order therein, SO that the transfarreci

H .u':;.é€:rsta.nd, that their posting and transfer has

beéié esfféciééd in compiianca with {€213 prsvisions of the

n iiamafaka Civii Services {Reguiaiisn ofT1"a;t1$fer of Medica}

7i'§ff§%z::€rs arzﬁ other staff} ,:§=::E:, 2&1}, ané the éireciieﬁg

" ~~-'iégusé by ihig Cgzsri' in case; 5,2337 $5' ihe iransfeyreé

£i'f1"i§§£.1%}'€€$ 1% digsaiigfiaé? éhaé Eéigfhézr irazzgféirfgiéétsiifngg is;
in :::?01a?:i{%;:: §§ ﬁgs §E'ES€§}:}'%'§{ G1"{§€'.¥;; as? far 32:3! ::1s1:E*::s§:* :*&a;$@2::

%gv§*:g§;*a<:;€:2fa:: i; 33:23:} £533 Qgagz iii} gudi ézziizgfﬁrmé iEi'§"§"E§§G}5'ﬁ€f

3%
to approach ibis Clouri directiy by invoking the: kgurisdiatiarz

of this Cent: under Ariicie 228 of tins CQI1S{ii{i§if3f}'%'£*f"§ﬁ'f§'i3'

'5. We weuld Eikéi is remggi {}z1;'."2*;;'5;§i"::€:i£zti0::

gratitude H3 Sri Rarnan RedC1y;=.A14Ss€:;:r¢3ia.fjg, {i')£épé;:"i}:3i;;:-':;f:*'of

Healih ami Famiiy Weifarai wfiiz; *x'QiuT3*§§%i:i:iE;:_HVaxiipeareﬁi»
before this Cauré, SC} as Coiirt on the
technicalities of the: issi';-E'it-i;v0};*3é&;._

sax-E
j ' Chief Justice

Sd/-s
fudge

. 'l:1d§:X;§f';'i?'€~

Like this:

Related

Leave a Comment Cancel

Dr Dhananjaya T N vs State Of Karnataka on 3 June, 2011

Share this:

Like this:

Related

Leave a Comment Cancel