- E _ IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, BAN DATED Tms THE 18'?" BAY OF ¥*EBRUAI2¥x,jf BEFORE THE HON'BLE MRJUSTICE I.
MISC.W.,3.68 /2010
WRIT PETITION NO.37?:”32i _/2009 [LB-BM?)
WRIT PETITION Is?o.;3*?.§~*sv2x~,(2¢Io’oT9 (LB-BM?)
I.E3l.£’.§”WI*3I*§,N ‘
{J12 R,”PeIIII1I’I1.2}§L;;’i, ’72 V ~.
Agml :’;V13<)I_Ii. 74 _'x:,V-'.{V"~';~1_E"'.'V:§;, " I
R<?s~:.s'dis:i:;____§ aI5._'s\31vr.r? Smsetg V’ ”
ZN’ I*3I0v.R. I V
§{Ls.s1j1é.-1’1″;.-1. Pa1’k W
w §?:?3E’l’:§’:i:}§§EiI:(]i'(f ;_; 560″02.().__. « ..I–}§£’I’i’I’I()NER
‘ g:a;.- ‘§«:»..1};;czI1a;-. Adv.)
{Xi-,f.V.I’.) ‘A
L I-‘§;11’:g;éi§<)1'cr Mé:11"1&1l1é1g&i1'£1
" P21'1%}~«;e.
._ I-?;%3};_)1’e.s~;<;*1'1tIc;rd by its
C()1":11I1:'s;sei<)1Te1'.
A H1,1dsm1 Ci;’:?1cm
{‘3211’>.§,___{2-1§<.)I'c.* »~ 560 002.
The F\:;e.sisLa-t1’11. I?I:~;I=’»:<"'I.:1'.i\,»*<;?
I:I1"1;_gi II If E' 2" .
C} 2.1 III”? 11 2′ 1’121g2’II” 81: b– I..)ivisi0:’1 .
53%
‘§’:’\/EC I{<)_v2.=.11 Ra(.§.
F32111g211()1’€ M2-1112’11’121gI2j21:’21 Pz’1EiRc.
I3zT111;§e:11()1″<r.
3. IT32’11’1gT__€z’11(‘)1’c Dt”‘\-‘t.’I()]i)l1)(“.’,1’11.
A1 1E.1’1o1″i1..y .
IQe.1′)1’e-?.ssc~11It*(1 by its
(5011’11″1″1issi011c1′.
i{a1111z’1r£’1 Pa1’l{.
1T32.111g;fz’1E()1’e W 20. L’ b _ I;T§ES13C)I’§I’)EN’I’S
[I’-3}; Sri. SN. 1″‘ra1shz’11’1i’1*1._C’imr’1:5§1′;:1?_ V
Adv. for R.1 {<2 2 and J ' " _
Sn'. l.(.'.}. GE}(..'}'1('l'1ilvlé-1111211111,"Adxf: §7r.)_1"
'I'he I\/Ii.ertt'7.\r'§7[*1"iV-;" N0".-36%'53/'20§'O_V is–'1'i1ed«* 1)1"2,L\:"i1'1é§ to i1T1l)lt'.dd
the ;)1'()})<.)s__é:d '1*:’,iI.i()1’1 for the
11′;-1s<)1'1ss 51.;–1t._e(i.::(l'1,t*1't;'ii'1.~ ' "
_hi,~';+_ W1fiI' 3.'€%.I__ii'ir'm'~.i;5'~i'i_1cd- 11I"[ClC',1' Articles 226 and 227
of lhc (7-'j)1'1.s;.Iit1.:€i<mA:121' J'1f1gITi';3"p'1"2:1yiI1g to qu21s1T1 the impugned
1″(“ic1′ f\1’11’1~!_’X.U’I’£”-F, ti;-{1.c:ci””-.EV().12.2009. whi<":1'1 wz1:~; iSS{.,1(*.d by
Hit" §:"{L""FE])()I'Ia£'1ITS,V A
'I"1'ii:;= Miscré:11;-1,1_1_§7Qxis Writ gmd W1-"i1. Pe1'iI'i0n <ro1}'11'1'1g on
' *fk)1' 1′(i(:i’§ tV}’;.i’.~:. dzny. the cm,11″t 1″11z;uie the i'(_)§.Ici’::r(iiy the pcE.ii,i(.>1′:e.1~ has ;:)1.:£ 110 1..1:i4s(: at
I'(‘.’€f.-.’siui”.]€:’.§’1″”?..Aié1.}Vx1)I’€E’%jiS(¥-:-3 to comme.rc”tia.I. £1(.’1iiX«-‘if y in a
;_;)1fa?d():’i’:V*éf1a»11’1My re.s’ai<1e:*z'1'§iz»31 i(::<"'21Iit'y. céc)m'.1*2:1'y to the
"~'.1_'1V'1':;-;;¢,"t':e=»1* 1.312211' :.111cier Em? Ka1"1'121i,al~;a 'E'c.)w;'1 and C()L,11'I1.3'}-'
VA V. ..,P321:'111i1'1;§ Act, £96}, for s;}"1.():'t. {"110 'P1a1'11'1iz.1g AC1' 2111c} £1116?
g a
I-31.1i11′(? M.a_1j’;’;1.Jiiz–;.gj;;=11*;1.
Palikc {iti3E:§MP) u1’1cie1′ t’hc=’ K2-in1z’>.1.2?11;;-Vi.”2, i\2’f1:j.1′:”1}ir;,11ion ACE E9″/”E3. This 2-::1.(::’EiQ1’1′ ;.(.iI’J.t:r1’n if:v(}:111(.§wc;.c.i ‘r;:y»i§;’s:.1.1(> of 21 r’1ot..ie d1.
10. $2.200?) An3:1c:xL:1*e§:.E?@>i:7.{mi B§{§;: }311gi1’1eer
st”e1i:i1’ag.__§ H12-iwt 1:I1fi;’:’V’ ‘1l’)t’.’IiI’i(‘:’;IJV(?1′ 4]’i2′:1ci ‘ i’1t;;’i:” sh0w1″1 (‘a-11.13:: or
sub1’a1it:t:c=>L’i =31’ “1-‘r[:’;l§iy 1.0 =t;h”(.:’ e*2;ii’*licr1′:§ 1″10{.i(*.e 5;-{lid having not:
111;:1(ih’,§.1’1:: 1’téq1.’ii.1″‘:?_d”21i'{‘.’cr_19é”ti’_i(;I}-S to {lie builclimg io put The
$321i’1’1L’ 1 ‘0_ :’:=–:5i'(‘iVa.%:n’.i;;E ‘z.:__§é'(‘as (‘.>;_:J1:)saL)(i 1.0 (‘o:1’um.*1′(~.ia1
;.2(‘ri’iv_i1::y i11″~Vtc;9V1’1:1Vg–.(>i7_I”i”1b S2,l1’1(.’I.E()11(‘:’.(‘1 ;:>i2u”1 21nd Z:’1i11g
I–fin.-‘;r_’__ff~1i2;I.j0::}_. §_{1’é§ir1:;–r:–d* I.h1’ee dzilyés time for (#0111p1i2:1.1’1Cc:.
»i}V2i»}j1’1g ‘wi¢1.jf*}:’1__ the ;..>rcn1isc:=.s would 11):? }(>(‘~.}:g…,1_’w:%{‘:.§>1?Léred {r(..>11′: the pc=:t’i1.ic>1’:c1r.
ii:-a1′”:1.(.:i (.*c>1..111s:’i for 11’1c-;*. ;.)c==’t..it:i(m 11’1a;1(ii(? an ap1)1i(‘ra.1’ion to the
‘VI–%I’:%%’\§’Ei”._ I:’1″1<' 13"' 1"(*sp()11(,ic-4'11. for (..'1'1;111g('.= oi" }2u":<:'1 119st: in
\
.4.
IL’}’}11.’.~§ of the P1z’21m1.i1″1g-.1″ Aci, E961 zemd E.lmt’. I’:}.”1<-' §.:1.}'_3_"}')]Vi1{:f:.i§':–§(5h
is pv:'1<ii11;;3 <"r(")_:1$i<'1e1'2»nion. In 2.1(.i(;1ii.i(..)11. leari-1._§*c'iv:{~<)i'.1:'1s-3} '
subn1it.~5 E..1"1;»:I the pc1.it'im.~r be }:i§(.%1′:11iii;%(.1:_m’L’=r(j{1’1–i’j1.’;Lit’ (1)7
LESL” 1.110 r<*sidc11I.i2;-ii builc.ii.:'1g;fQ1' ('01':-u1ié*I'<ti2'.1lb.;§§,(':1"i'\ri«{:y ":.ni'{;iI'=.
E-'»H('}'1 1.i.:'r1£~ 1-2-EDA takers a f'<'.:iSi0i'1;–
I3. I_,ea1*1"1:1 of the 13c%1′:iV_1’V_i<")I1Vc:'vV_}1;}\«'<-W.-t'mE}g:._$.15 21 .~_5urprise
si:T1 no s%t41(~.’;_’1 214;’ >’.:*1z1vz~’m_11;.*ittia1 l1f§(?.gj.§)..]’17;’1’E1I’:§7 to the master plan 21114:} the
‘@0111;1;;._i’c§g1v.gI’i1Li_<')I1$. 21:5 W(.'H ates Iht'-' BE.1i1(1il.lg_{ l)_\;'I” 1)’L–5;’ij_ tit: saritii ?;.i’1a: the 1’1m,i<'.:<-:~. A:'1.1"1(3:su1n~- F' is well
_ 1'11c*1*ii_.4:E¥'«§11"1(.i i}1l}v j 1.151 ified.
F3. “1′”‘lw1’t*.. is no .:’11e*1’it in this gm-?t”it’i(‘)1’1 ;;1.n(‘¥
a?m:c’>1′(1i1″1gly 1’c:.je’*c.;uc>.s1. of the I(1’ar11L”3ci
<'():.111:sc¥I F01' 1§'1<'~ §)CE.ii.i(')1"1c–'1' I:'i.:n:_* is r;=x1.c?L""1€..I(-'(.1 {mm t.l'1mc:
'*2
de1y..~; as wt out in the 1'1.0t'icrv to 11'1rvc 1:1(§;'1":'1.1"_;'§:;.___i"19i233i~.
t'u<.'l:zy. for 1’1’1})1i2m<'c.
In viw of the 2:1}::0\«-1-?. A:’MibE;s;~:\f’.I3E}§3/~2(i}«.1C3, “~i§51*._
i11’1;:)iv;»–:(:1i1T1gg 1’c:;}’ci>(:i.c=:c1 2.15 L:1’113«!;§€%e::5fsa1’V