High Court Karnataka High Court

Dundappa Shivaputra Khot vs Damodar Earthmovers By Its … on 3 April, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Dundappa Shivaputra Khot vs Damodar Earthmovers By Its … on 3 April, 2009
Author: Ajit J Rahim


1:: THE meg cam? er KAR§¥&’§A;i{A.;« —.: _

sxncmr BEECH Ail’ ymxwm. ” ‘

BATEE THIS mm 3% nAY”‘m*« .A;*%+.,m,;L

PREs;EHf:9?*, ‘

rag. E~§0R”BLE msficg A:IT[%%J@:~§:§ g;AL
$53 §i§3%§’B3;E am; g*£;:.;s:§:1<{:§E:– gyggavan RAEIEX

3§1$$£L fiS_ 3135'?' z%::~;§._«®95;20et4gr§§,'v1

3E'IW'£43E!€:: _

Shri Qzindagpg»shizéap-;ma_Kha:

Ageaii a§§s:>11§. :32. ‘é;Z?céV:-T._Bi=*§_x?€;i”
V Banaga Tait1i{‘§%Lfi:1{i f3*:.i;St;8&igazim
* V ” ~ _ a.??E:.,L.A§*’rs
{By Ashdiz: §{;2%i§*a:3.a§’§’:ziit§’, fidvocaié}

V’ 3. 3 “j;’ 3;.” E-i)§37;i::éi:«:l a;2*. Earéhmavérg

ma”

. E33? ii*s<«'€:i'::t,E1r::.%;f£3é<i raprfisentaiivef Manager
' .(}§;:§}@si:&' Efifate Bank sf india
i?'@;s§sg__;'£i3.~~3ama.§ G03

Tbs ééiafiagar
'E"E:§ Griextgtai Ensumncr: {Tic}? Ltciw

" "§'~%:'eim Chamhezfi, .15'? £~:*

“$32 &csse, V32 Reazi, Pvfifiex $30. 3951
__;'<fasca-{)a~Gama, G03 ihrazzgii its Bivisiaxiai Fviarzagesrr

'§'E:a iéfiérzmi Exzszirance €3mpa::jg Ltd’,

Kirlaskar Raaéig Beigaum

R$$?0?é’BE§5T$
{E35 81$. S, S ejeghi, fi;givs<."t3i.5: fm' R2}

MFA is fiéd uzédmr" Saction £'.?'f,%{ 1} of
the j12{igm€:;':t and award éatfféi ;{4§.e3f§.2i}Q4
z~se.sir,r29e;:: or: the ffic: 93* me iaaizxsgi I §;{i:%i;' %:a:;~;%§;; ;iéi£§g"a gar; "
D11, 3 & Membsr, Acidi. NEAUE', p5_;~r1:g~g§:é2aré.;;{g' §h§:

p

ciaim pstifian for {':€3};I1p€I1Sa?Z§£)fl a11§tE s6–:.2_ki:1g éixhancgnfiéix-iévfi

compensatien'

Thia appfia-I comgfig «:;1::VAV.1":}g{ a§i;n§$*§jen. if.§1rAiAs"{%a}_;, AJIT
GUHJAL J, ciélivered théf(;_310Xis-§fif1g;" ' A V'

'. «-¢»§.:;4i.?'T;.;..;;I3.."§€.–+?: 15.: m:+i~
2?m:s__ a:.;i§p5§:;a;1«..i_}s~b;g;'__c:a:;ma1:~:. The eiaém getiiion is
flied seekmg cifipéi:.Sa§’é;t§1:a,,V” $3′ perseyngsé ifljéifi’. We arsf: 121%?

r€:qu§_:a’::;{E jto axmfifiié’ thé q__u€%si:iQz1 of a=::ti0*;ia’bEe Qegiéganca in

‘:-23 fi”i”x3.<:}E';"L*c2$"i*.:.i1as reached finaiéty ami it is 110?. qaestimzsii bf;

_'3'€Sj3(§iE.§{1'3fi§;',. V V

4' ii: tbs accident, Tim {Z'§3.EfBE2"iiEi'{;';2-'i§§}€f§§aI§§, hag

.,§u12fe.;'eaj':~§1:e felicxwéixg izzjmriesz.

i} 6 X 3 cm abrasion esvsr zriarsum {hf 3:55;. €:2bQv;?,

ii} 3 X 2 cms abrasiim 0:25;? {;§0:*§;":3;m 0%" xvégm §1an§:§ 3:.
bass {sf middia finger.

/

J

iii} 4 X €%'{};i’E~ X {XS {rm iactziaéémi an :»:;.;i§é.r;:§.;*.:2i;;§}§:§§*;:_{§§

rigid: Egg Zfficrm Es:-~§.e:,:w ggaisiéag

iv} 3 X fifi 2; {§eE§»:7m §acus=:_’%£:Z:7§’§;. ;a;::t§::*i<§;_§" 'a;:~:§;aéif'§. :3?'

Efifig :3 (rm bfiiow ;_}22f£$§ié::.

V} 12 X” 2 X 1 {THE }é:€11a’§E;§:c§i:.<3:1 m£:¢§i{:ai %'+i_':§§§"LV§{"f€§_f'{H ii??? Eiiég V'

18cm %}§E@§%;' kmzs

izi) 2 X E X 1 cm }a{:z1é§¥j£%jie:;' 0z1'::%;:€:giiC.a} '&S}°§€{??. $3" 8.26%

26 em heimiz' 'i£:::{e€ ;;?i;::z§:::_. '

vii} _. ~L'??'~v;. g:;;Z1::'ve:g?;'§*a:s%.§.::;:{z._"£;i§ vm:":;(§i<:.n::.a} a§~;p€<:*'§ Qf L féfnigh

–. E592; akgtére §{:fs’££% :i5§31t’§,

V’:;%;§.3T.}._ — i§ :s;*’.{3,5 ;:a: ‘::a:a;– iaauafiens svsr meziica} 8§§§}€€3§

” ” ,
‘ 25%;} .S’::ia3Ca pi*£a’§2 fiégsiiim neck ieft faxxmr.
$5 eff:-amzrs of right tibia sméi fabzlffia.

1 §;§;ax;¥§§;1g ragaré £0 {E15 aibsvs injfuries, isarneé

mé’;:-§Rs;2.,5«:;s,Gea:/«« wfih %re:-tak up af Rs.E§;$@§;’~ Emfisaréis ‘Fain

” = émmic”S11fferi11g’, R$.£§8,Gf}Qj» tamsgazfis ‘iviaifiicai E%X§}€flS€$ mic.’

_..§€s.},E>2,C3G€3f~ Eawarés ‘L033 :3? faiiilm aaziniazg {ra§a:::éé:y”,

/’

J

R3¢}(},{§{}Qj~ imxzaxxfls ‘mag fif §E§C'{}.3’i’3§€ éurizag §}€§”§G{§ {W

2%

§§’e2«.:iA’::1i:::%,’ zmzi :9; éaézfiz <33" £33 E€}§{§€f}{}§« 'i(3w53;§'%§S~;_4'"ié§%ég$£~ (:1§'

2'§.i'I1£?i{};§'£,§;€<S'a §i§§a»'iF{3.§ §_§f.i§'iES€f€§ 'rim §"w;".1g13:.:::':"i'. sazzé _.§»";:ii"k;*22..:*{.1§,;- 7§_'=fii'.§ .

Q15 iliafi afwvsr '£313: £313 §:i'§3J8E"{§ §§E%SS€f{§. §}f=g,=:'m§§:'iff. "§'§§§37':.::':z.?:§'_::%€:§::i:'»:§; 21%;; " "

he maiiéfiazi @1313; in :"€:$§e<::'{. 95 fizsréfxzfi i<:§:'£aiai¥…;¥:é iizx, §.':§'§'f;%.§§'j;3-.._'§§%é§;1

am}. :2;'a;:fi%;§°i§2gZ '?%v§a:}:%.€::33 :::é_g7;aé;§:~;§§;'
'E"i".;% :::a'§'ui':f es}? é:';§'a2§'7E€$ VViiV"r2u?:a'L.i.%.:a::;:fi:_ .%?::mz:'§",
%:E"z'a:::tm'$ 0%' rigifi. iihéa égzjégz :%..sx:*: ':"m%;'
g.1é<e::v01:s; %;r:zs§am'zz.:*:.h as 2;.é§;»;:§ §:;.:§_:*i;$ 0%?

{ha i12{§fsr1 é

=%,._ — §Vfi’;iV”€.§:é’.}€?§_»{::§’,j. gig’:-;:*:{§;g§ 1-*§3é:: {3?{}?;£fS{? of ii: fig §31′{‘;¥..§.g%:§
{mt :%3.3;&§:’%”::*: (E§LE’-%.§’.§iE§§iiu §f!}.§}4Ei§i§f:”§f. fmsszz 2% §{Z3.’2€}€{§§ is

:3} E’;’2§ }{}§; “§£§€féafi€r Essa was aa’§:;.”:2.i2:i:’:{,%. :6 this Emiagiézéé at.

” ._:g;:gaa§q%.;::~ag;§i.’_. mi {}%.€§;’%,;2§{}:Z:% am; wag {ii$::i§:;a;:°g€{§ am

:{2*–‘%_.€§&%%;vi-§i§§§V25 VAV§.;1é1sm:1ch aé 2:6 33:33 iflpafienz fa? 23~’2¥§» {Ea}-F3,

civsgimv fiéaf 83$ daémaggt :13 Elm? ha haé ;*«g§€’:1§: {:%;z::r-

nRs,£§§,v{E-f.;}{} ,1 ~ far §’:i$ meziicai as-:xg:€’:§s€;3.

55%. WE hava fixamizifid ihéz :'{~:s::€>3″{§s;; 311:5; §{}::Ta”2§,’§ Eézzai;

‘”§;§1{§e€:d {Em aiaimani haéi §;*g;€£:s’: §€$,:%§,§€§’2j ~ igr-‘§¥§a:'{§$ §ms§2.§*§;>”s;E

s:§3.a1’g§, a gum 3%” R$,13,{}€Z3{}j ~ §§.3W’aE'{§S znaéiainss sic: “§’3i1′:§$ lfi

Z

§€S.§i3£,15i?’;,? – ES Spazfi, iii} 3%.;-‘hé<:.E.';. we: §;.z'::}g';s::s$€ iii;»,g§i.%.§§ ~._z;:§:3

afiiéiiiigiiafi gum $5 §€$;L2f,é;.{}{}{},! – 50:' §2'}{?§££:':a":%,é-*:'é__ :1:'::::.§f .

rzxggszmes.

6. _ §E1S€}f8;§’ as ms: ‘gmigz A’
amsaitiag’ 3.35 {§0fi{“6;§’§}i3{§, ‘5:.:;Vié;§§¢{§.5 MT::1r.
reggae: :3? ‘giaé.-:1 223335. s;;_ii%;2″i:zg’V_:g’3;.%§:£§:_§§g 93.23.1293.
he {;:.i3;1*§€§.§€€i 3133. ‘§€?:I’1?fi$ ?” $22 $336 {.’E£§§E’. gm
hané, vase ‘s::::§.’:£’€:’€:%§ fmchim 6?? Efifé
§em:1r:’.§s:§;:$. »§%3i,és and fiéaézia, §«%a%z”::i:g zagaéfi
ts ihagé ..§.§§me ‘:%:?:_..*«»:::;1::%:,€’* war: am Csf $2.6 ziiaw *;.%;;;a.?: ma

<:e::£*’:2Z?§{:a”¥..¢3

” %:i;eg5§.. am arisimarzz 333$ S1}.§’§%i*§:a<i fz:.a1{ri%:;z;§:i

3% muah as mg énabfiéég? '=39 $*:az2z:§;'sa-'aiE:: zxziihmfi

:=;1§§;pé:f'i_. 3 C3336? Si&I§§ 32:: $§§::g§;§; ésg, §"€s'i:I'13ct*i{}1r.: Qf }'3<::%.%3

.§s::gé?sj;.s':1ip,Ia;.1::;=s: mgvgmerms. :iifiic::.%iy :1; ciimbmgf siaziaiizxg

sizzgie keg ami dischargizxg fixings ?I'€SS€1f3;'§{ ova}: leg.

./

?. Having mgard to the nature of iajujiigsfl
the disability factor, we pmpese to award an
of §'~2s.25,QGG/- towaxds 'Pain V
sum of Rs.25,0001 ~ towaxfis

total enhanced c91x1p€z1sati0:1§fi{'5'&3l(i Ws:$irk__ou.{_ is i?'::é;'?'G';Ut}O/ — 'V

8. Thus, we ‘:;:’mditj;> :1{:e paggeé by the
Tzzibzlnai im the fczzllowing te:1i_1s.s: ‘_ x b ‘

R3.

i} -‘if; 45,0{}G’0Q
_ ; ‘E’8,@GQ.Ci@
iii} {.?<:»§é gr Capaciiy ,§,62,GG{}'{3fi
52}. Less u«:5f..§V:1€<3inr: ;:3.u1:"i1:g Ereatmcmt P€I'i€}{§. 19,006 . G6
Amefiifiéfi 35,896.09

., A' '"—"She H'e:1I:1anced cempcnsation shafi 03:13: mieresi {sf S022;

R bffizsm tha date of patitimz till the data of éfiposit.

The apfil is parfiy aiiewezi with the ~

indicated above. The insurance Cnmpagfigy

rmhaizced; comjpensafisn Witt' ta i11te1*es£'a3; $36 if

'E"ribunaZ within six Weeks fmm: the ééta '<55 re£~:$::ijL§'i.¢:cf

°'d"'
A [ {% é ''

gab'?