High Court Karnataka High Court

Francis Rodrigus S/O Lawrence … vs Urban Rodrigus S/O Lawrence … on 20 September, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Francis Rodrigus S/O Lawrence … vs Urban Rodrigus S/O Lawrence … on 20 September, 2010
Author: A.S.Pachhapure
fié 'mg %§§§%%? gang? §$ §£5§R§*~§xfiJ?,&£§€,zfi:; garésgagas
§§T§§3 "?§-fifi "i"?-%§ 2%?' ms? 3F §E?'2'§;a%a§?e Efiifi 
§§i*Q£E H "   V%
THE ;~§msa*g2.§ §s%R,3:.é§§'§{:E g5s,,?&:réa§_?ég::%#§V 1.]: 
'war; égmms §'é$.3S132;Z€fi':§3i%b;{ V:$;4~--~f--v$';"*:f'€'1%;S:%}*':;:zVV 
3g*§*2s*»:5§§:: :   Ah %% . " ' VA  VA

?§.§a§§$E$ §.§§§,E§§.§§

gggggzwgggggag mzsmgsgg

AQES ASQRT E5 ygagg '
§i§§._,iI?fli§;fi¥L§ §"§§§§$E

:.;;2§§3 ygaagsé & mg?    
§§L'§2~§;;%逧$:§%§T4a:§i§   V

     V   ?E*:'§'§°"i§?%E§
£5? SKI §'?a§J£§_...'Jé3i!"&_ $33¥;E'f.;¥§£'a_;C?§§--E? %'§;V.$,V,; fiifiiffifi}

.&§§§§;

3. a.,§a§;2§é;';%g§aa::§a§§'-«.'~ _ 
§§@,:§%g%::§rwE §t.{3Ef~§§.E§§;§€S
fi§§§§fis§$§.f?7,4§'Y§§§;§
::;;%.§£§?-MA %§§"i;§a§E _

 « :::.a§&;a:2§.,%%2z::;ga!s§ """ "

A -:=.>:¢$1;% §=5§:;§§;w

   {'n€3;§7§'?"'f§fi:i.i§ii
   K 

T35 §*:;*2§%%%§??a;2§-*»ma éfié-*§§'~%§.E
 $f§é~;§E%f£$§*§ écaggz
' .A g$§5:.;i3@u"! 5? '*r'E;%R.'§
* '§i;§..§*§'?Pfi'x§E *%§E§..i..$a$§
 " Efifi"? FE§%3§=%.;§%é
 §§:_*:'§~:ga§%a§**€ ragga
 flag.

 3: 'mg §.A§*éE"'§"§."§§§JP§.%i

§§§§?§°§fi%§§fi§'*{
§E§J?':§~§§§%é§é§§'%" "§:§;§.L§§{
3%;

£2? E'? W5 C§'*§fisI§.%§1'§§é
 R§§~?Q§'€Q§§'€"§§



,.a:*§ a§;4§:5,s;="s§%'::*:'

{fig §FL?I fiyfififiéfifij 5,?' Ffifi E3 5 
SR1 T,fi;si{i'x§§§%%§A§$.%§ %. $3.? ?*§fiJE§*i§TH$:; .4§..§§§§, Fifi §;1 .   
as: ~ $§;§§£§§j'.f:    

°r»-«:33 %:T§;3'§T%§£%séséfigaiésggéi, ';"§';':::,;  mm gummy ii":
zzasa §§@,é"€~3f?§~?? :.a;:§§..;5;;§::&;azzra §.

29 "%"%*2$*§§35:% §*§%av;_a*§:»t._"..fs§" fies §iEE'°"§§§$§ *9? '{§"§§E yasiéikm
.' §:飧fi5:§%::=s*;;§;es* §§ iizg awgzar in §§§§$5§%m $5 fig éagzég

§é:;::§f:§%i.§' §:§;9§jag'%fé§s.§§§é {?»2§ §?'§&§$%.§i!"$§'3§ 3; mm :5; max

--;a:':§ §§;'$ méasaaférzg fifi? fiflfitfi am in tatai mg exam:

 5; ~1§.;;*a 2§ mafia sf Kanyaéi 's;"i§§a§$% Tim §E:r$t §"¥'$§Q§'3§8¥'§§

'fa::9%§'fi £33? ufidar Sseaiiatfé égafigiié $§ §{§§'§'3§'?I$§e§a:§ :3: 2§?é yégiseséaé is gran?

 wégggasgarzcy régist 15:? fie Easzé is: sarggy ?'«§e,§§;'§; 3?' Ka:'K§§(§\\



"E
'aféééaga. '€°§'s§:.,;§?; the §§:*§€ msgmzéagzt §'T:§§ mt fééafi awg firm
§"'&§i.§§5Ei¥"E§ §§r fiia grmfi $1' $§€';§§§$§"'§§'f§ 2'%§?:*1: :3? §a;__:f*s§e3;

%»£¢§§§-»% {$23 ag-sé gfimfi {R-2}? tkga §~.$¥"§§ ?z*%%:si§a§_ '-«.%§;3s;

gsanézeé aampggscy rigéwt area therefareg 

gggrievéé §%; iha game flag fififi ifiég _§_§2§%;ga;;:: afiéééii' ';;%§f:;§t§:§§x'_'   é 

3, E haw bgaré the ifiamsaé £é;_;:{:5:@§ §%:s%' §a ?;§:%i§§:A§~é;va%.s§T f

afié 592% karma i-éiiii? agar ézé éfreis-§3;a§2§é5§%_; $;   
fin S3 far as time éeiay $5 4:::sV;§4:i'::ar§"§a:5§; .;§fi:"'§§:,.'.;?'&§£;'3..§?35§':'E §@

mate §§%ai":§i;e"§§i§i§%$$§?;é: %re«a§$- §"i{3§:l §"'§§%"i7y' ifi 33$ gmsrzeaéégsgs
fifiérfiffi §§"'§§¥ -§§if"E_§ 7:;;".Eb%:.;s«§*:'z:%; 7av§%§Vé?A~.;f§;f. i§"§% féwé: téms %%r§z$§z fig §§3'"'§'£$

ix §€§"§$§'_¥ aa:§% :.;:*: §§:§;V&jV»1§?*§*asi.:;"*::*=a2»L'%':s§3 ha mafia & ?§§iE$8§ Kfi the

"'~?a§:5:%§§§;._._i;é:%'s.¢ éssaééfitifizal §§§%'%'%E'%'ti£§"§§'£:aE5'E§%3t'§ ag gag' figmaxzgre Q

 ';s°:L§:;t%¥f1§§'§'2§"*:$§as§:"%§§§--§r:§e§* gasswé éy flag ?:_a;"2§ '§":*':§a.:r%a§ fiaafiaé

§ek:a 'é*:§:a§§e§5ff'j_.VEEV S; émmaééateiy Eéxaréafiarg 'fise gaéétigfia?

 'vifgaa aggzééfciégé $255 fiazxt $3? way' gt? ihis §fi'?§§i§§"§, Er; aaiawg

   12%'-..§&i§tirs¥3:ar Ezaaé fifi wiéca Q? '§§'E§ gmaggéénggg it mzsécé

 "'~-____" :§é ;;3§é$;2§::$§ that ha hag rm %:s*:$%*§%e23§§ a? me aaéd

 *.§'§§aea§éngs§ %§§§ fie gzgbméziieé a; mgrggggstatéaaz ta tifie

T&§"%§E§§§%'2 



si
3 Rzzrgaxgra $2 is tha arésr" $5 firm §?§§§;$%"%$§ Er: saw

§sé:.ta§8;"}?% --«E? dwkefi S«é§1§'5E§??. X2": 15% gaéé s::rs§&?; fie.-firs?

E'a$§'I':r§i"§§5E§TE Emg éesaa 5§"i$§i'~f§'5 £5 Em a§p1%%ca:%% gm %% $3

Er: the aréar tézat fisé agggizgarzi fiag féiaé gr: a§§%%a§%'§@;*z:§3é%'5'az§'_"'1' "

$&:i§a;'% 48 A {1} cf me Karaaiaka §5;a§r2é»--«§§a$§z%z;rHr'%"§v;s,'" fé:~;1#'k'k3é§:F%ké"

as amefifisfi in £§?4; ia; ragistgr hég éiéaéiiézfiég 5?:-§§::*;;§§;&z2%.§'«¥_3§A?'T-i

31% survey smmfier :6 as; $J€§T§F'é%y§i_§§&*§$§f'EA{€§%§§§'.$$§¥fif§§%"'*§v3{§;:}
3? fie mid hat. Sq, same?' :zu:*§';§:;e:;°..'$%+a5ciw_:f: tfi AS312';-ma:?:és';%: :3?' E.
mm 2:: guwey §%%$.§$g'§ '{§§' '  have %s 5%

gmzgiéareé wfiiig 4;;}f§é*§.:fs%ir:§;€VV':$E{r:%:'é:.:é;1*§§'r:i§;.f%§%*:§:.x %:§':a fribsgaafig

'fize %E§'s§'VV?ré?s'§:a§§i§§§s:*§%?-3'ézaéwiéct fEEé%af"'a:sy aggéécazim Fag" ma
gzwarst Q? };=£éL:§a3§:éf%;':'.%§:. §'%§'§%%§;-,. §§ aha Smé égafmg mwaig

5zas,§§«%§?~é%}xgn¢ §s~é*;:g?~é; af mag we gaiétézrgzsezr' Ea §%'é§

    ..... 

§r: i:§f=§ aéraamataficasg fig aréa? §§’%?§t§?’§§ €%§%

‘3:::§.:§§r:r:v§§”;.r§§?§m ta Ems 55$: aasgagzéagzi 5:: :’§§§3€§ $§ the

“§§a3a*2.é$k*z_$: siaémsé 3:5 ifiggai argfi wéfig

E. Ea iifig eérsumstmmsg writ gefifiésm $3 aiémzsaéfi ‘fha
sréar a? $35 éaizé “‘§”:*’§§§.3r§a§ at’ Eeitézaagaéi fiatgé ssmi; 23??

in age fig .”§.8§?§w?? gmséaggaé ai fimisexazra fig is Siéfifiéfiéfi.

The r:”%&i:%er is rsméitaé éasx m 33$ §..§€§§ “§’s'”;”§§::§*:$§ ta £fi§’E}$-§–§$§’

Em gswagti af asaaggaricy %’§§§”zE$ is $3 fig: §*’es§§s’:.:€§_§:’:%::%f~%f:~,

ragga: 3? EM mg giaimaé 53: %’:§:’m

11%”;

9. i