High Court Karnataka High Court

G C Indraraj Urs vs Esi Corporation on 13 March, 2008

Karnataka High Court
G C Indraraj Urs vs Esi Corporation on 13 March, 2008
Author: N.Ananda
IN THE; 1~mH I2I?.li"JI_I13i:'T cw IF MARCH 53008 
BEMRE    %

~TmH«3N*H:L1": MR.JEJS'I'IflE N.AIifi.!.'-ffi.t;€&VV   If 

f'.3I"itLnI"*.,.I4fIf.?J§_;',_2*°§;7;" 3on4 :3; w..  '  7 

E51"1.1P. .. 4'?' WM:
£i§._'T¥i'iflE..I'_I.;.

1.. Sri *£;Tr.f1..Im;1.d1ra.r'aj Tflrs,  V

3,!' =12: P'.L'1I1.an.aa.ra3jv.m. {Iraq " - « if

Agvexi aH:u::nu;!:.« 3!'=s:=:a-ma, 3; ..

  ..  

Mgas. K.1i…1:.13’»; Cmrpurafigi1,..__– %
fmmrmupafint’ :::i.'{7 ;fE§.a,rx_1;s¢t_ai}:£i. .. V .
Ba:s:¢ga1mrTeQ»_v

2.. Sri 3-~£.§F.a§%ag11fim;nn. %
Sf !E5.’H?WI}*1D.11.?z:£it;’&¢:?c1alt1 Raddy,
Vfifgemgil, iflmut 439?. 3r_;as:1:’a,

_ _ “’33-‘<rc::£"A';;§1'r::nii:1ft1_Illirwtor, 242.3933,
' 'C~mm1*m:;z»t=;)3t<. of Earnataka,
. "-BfiTJ?iiE:33§"1**?"'vV*"'

V 3.. m,:%j$%.i+;a:-mmm Lnaathm" Inc1ua'£;rie.a

jflewsflupnument Elargmmtiun Limimd,

kfizimsmw, r~m.1:r,rs-, -C}-hlang Block,

V "i'{'3'1nr;-::ux",, Building, JJL'. Road,

B¥§l1!T3e"§5";4'El1El|I'"f5?-"5'f3'(:3 CHI)-2. .Pe1:itinner-a

(B3! Sm? H,fl».=L'11*1£:ax1drss1:not1Ei, Adwmte fr:.ar'
firi K..e%.a'§l:1amdr'a.shekar, Adwcat-5:}

§~}

_I_q__I£_11"1.1"'r".;N~a:»–..;3»'f.:'E"rfi.:*' grm:

EE-TWE-EN:

1.. Sri }i”i.WRmghL1ram.

3! ea»: fififlvenlcatachala Raddy,

mfigmi. aha 1.11; 4′?’ years ,.

‘C3fl%::: Jflilfllt UiI’ectur, KBPHE,
Gr:uwrtmmn!t.nfI{arr1ataka, ‘
Ban1ga.].r;:re:,

2.5 Mj’w..E{arT1atE1ka Ismathar In:i11é»’tries
£3r&:%aw.=:lop111¢11t Elanfipn rattimn Li_rifit_aed.,
“I.»id.}i-mar” ,. PM . 1’7! .¢3’b_1ong;VB1dsg’k_ V ‘V ~ . ..
II flmzl 1*, ‘fT.F1r.iit};’T’I3ui1dii’15_gA’, J .I’£;i:n3.&’–,– ; AA
Bmflfifilusul-e~5»fiO £1432.

[By firii Im..c’na§1;1r~ameuu.ni, gamma %
Sri K”.fih\’.£3hu§4.nr3;r;a@11-a§&:flr_¢ .

E-SI {‘.”::;i3:’5:acm:*41.Iét1:isJi1;,’:’:’-~ *
Nu. IE1, £E:i:nI1_}»f 13’5i:a2.»I_dx;,’ v “‘ -. ‘ ”
E5i11I1jF’}3M§t., ‘ifi.g17x;1g;a1-am-T £’:\C:v£I3é..i’.)23-.
E|E2]_JI”§f.fivif’!1Tl1t@!E’§V1§;!~ju’A’fl”1e ‘

. ¢_ I1w.*!.Vft1i:3»:~a.1;1:f;t:~ ]V[2l=’1E’.l-_'[.’.it.’}!’~”.’.”‘.’3.’I’»’.’.r_.a.’ .
” V ‘ExSI”1’.’T:::ai*f}+«::-*a<'42~u?*,;ia.::11,

–|II3’P3«’. ..Ruwp-student
(Gammon in both Gas]

_ (E£g;””‘;.’v”3;17ii T_=.&”\.’I=-*;’%§’i*’§=1a¢J?31:t1laasa:. Hcrlla, .P:.dwcat»e]

nrmimirml pa/titixanla are filad uncieer Section

” _’ ‘iI3-x’.I3′..K’.§. pr:-aj,r:E11g tan aetmaaide the order dated
_ ;;’3~.*lF;a’:’$;’E*5ITtif:I*fi- pr-.139-mi hey f£’»_§v1.C¢:aurt far Ecozcmmic Ofiencea
” fir; K-.’fl4a:11g£aa]{r>1′<es in C2.4Z'l.N<:a.133I'S and 1235f2003

' "'rt3apes:1t.i1.mJ&5,r..

aurimirtmzl peatiiimm :2:-«:r111ir1g an for hearing

this :E.;u:z.j,r, Em (1-s:m1’t mating the following;

DRDE

pa.=.:titénI1em in criminal petition Nn.3246f
a11’a3r~r:m:i ma. 4sr:.c:~z:~»L1:m-fl in £3.C.N«::.1:..”!35! $003
fart’ an cffieannzze urxdbar SF,-‘E;1nacia1 Bntlrt for
E-cammm: tflffmficgaa gt’ fil-rad thew

thereizl.

_ for

and §.ue:.9o;a?2r:q:_.-n;i flrutltxmésfl’–;fi:5’1*-..;L}Le:aprandssnt.

fillrcauxlsessl far’ petitinrmra has nmde

V” ‘i?-.*1-.fl’n”:uwii1z;*.~.g ‘eammfiixiarainns;

U Subsequent in filirg af cnmplaint,
mm Es: subscription iI1::]:ud1’;ng
ir1’l:ema’t was paid by amused No.3-

M;’E.Ka=.u’11am1:a Imzaflzer Indurstriaa
Denmlopmant (It«::-rpomtion Litllitfifill and

c::m.1su:’: wax: also ahown four be.-latecl
.

11. Ma per clefinitiam m1de:r of Sanction 21?’
caf E’«.S,I.4 Amt, employer ia the Cofifpany
Pffititinnears aarumt he’. ]51!l€’¢I¢=f¢i’}E=:z:1y_1′:I;§V=;f(:i'”

vi::fla.titn1 of _–‘bf” ” V’ V

Rafianw 513 fjvai:a:. “I
rapmrtead in_~2ooas.t.::1..L.J. 3e§%£::%t1w W. %
of H.SnBam_._@-V..V_and”‘ 1«’:;k.s.1. k
fi3a::x”p«_:-1:r4=1tie::rA1V..__ fj~._ h’ 7

4%,. Thm leam-ad relying on
the d:E.~.4::i5icI11:_”‘ I4C15nR.2’i-’93 has
c:r::nt::+.:r1«:fl::eci; by employer
wsnruld M auazmnsed. Therefore,

pmwml iilgfi i%:*a.1*3′..*.”.1~fi’&.:.’1A::-¢’.=.:_

_ I1*;:.v%vi¢vuVi::fv–.t&1a ju«dgmm.’11: Inf flzia iiizzrurt reporwd

” auhseqmant payment, interest

géfgamn. by 1;>etit1’mmx’ N’a:«.3-M,la.’Karr1ataka

_ ¥f1’fi:!.11a1t3£’ie:=z Dermlopxnent Curpuzaratioxl Limited

‘ 5.’ ha a gmund to quaah theta 1:~1’s::s::n;-:ac5tir1ga.. However,

V’ mum a. grmmd bra {Mum penalty flm

» i11t1pom2:i¥1:g.srtrial«co’urt. 1*’

£75.. T.}&fiI1it:fL¢.m. «ca-f amplograr Lmdar Sanction 2(1′}’) of
E-.S.I., M21: Mada: I’1’111E§-5 ‘

“tE_1.’7:I “‘prfi1rmipa1 n3mp1c:o3,m1″‘ mamm-

al}; ha: a fmtnry, the: Warner of ”

famtnry and

agent of 511.511 bur c’:i::-::,i.:tpie.r,”

legal re1J1″i.~§5_§§u1t&1tivie’=; inf _ A L’

om-‘1’1:=:r azn.” occu.ip;§@r,. iii} person

ham ‘$;_:=..V,.v1v.v*i”..:I;-:M 0f the

fa-»a:=tc.:s:3.r< #L1'm;l'i.'=.§:"u:'t§:3us=__.Fé=A¥;§ts:§i:t%j:':.i3 1':-ct, 1943
4 . j }(ifi7a;:§f- ' , §;~_a1v's.cx:;1".%.'mr named;

unnzi-er thfl cxzrntrol

—- ‘i:$j’:E; emf any Gnwmmcnt
I ‘V ..tJr.1é auflmzarity appcrintmi by
‘ ‘£11-‘::};11 in thia bchalf cur
‘wiafife aut.}1r::rity is; ac: appcnitlte-cl, tlxc
AA V”Vl1::i+a;1-£’§’s:af flw departzne nt;

T’ in. amy mthcar eata!al;i.a.]nme=nt., any pnrscn

mapurmihla fur the aupezrvisinn and
cuntrul nf the establia-hmentg”.

In 1Il’c1:=: wanna: M1 hand, liability tn pay penalty if

‘ ” £95 ea:u:n.:.gi’1t 13:: ha iT£mt.ene::L§ an M,P.iPé€L1arr1£1taka Leaflxer

hmfluawtmima Dmnaiopment. h1’3r:ry*.»crr.eu.T.i~::I;x Limimd array-ad aa
av»

amusmzi N::::.2 in C3:.£L’-.Nm.1235f20″(}3 and accused 110.3

in »:.:t.,:3.1ne¢’u.1;I:.9.a,.*2::»w3. fiumused

c:.:::.1sI.;:.12:3:a,r:2scn:»..’a ia ahczuwn. as -ma IuIan:agi;’1g.A..’I§ii?.é:§:tk:j1*–.– _

and bur} its .s3aI”ra.§,nm’:1 em amczusseifi ta: rv:3;:11?em;s§ant”.’H K ‘

MM. I-*im*1mua.1ka’ Lt-atlzer Ixlfiiuatifiafi

CI::rpv.:n’mtim:%1 L.1″£mitze’.::i. % ” L’

}mti’t.i»s:r=1’1e::’:ra9 1 a:=.u1d 5.2 are; ;~¢:;:fit$z«2x1t..v:;1c»cusecl
Nu .3–MI ss..PIm*m.ata;k:a Developrnant
t’.T:m’}:w.1»1z:’.ne;1tir;:1*1 I_…i*m.;i:fi;:;f:r_:14. ‘;:£”A:’Vf’1~.V£*§1@}T::»»::r:;¢’,««.V:’v1t_,1fl¢:1§vv’a§%}§§f¢11e1mion that
Lmafller
Iflfi1,1ii1t§f”ii?.’=é%?’ AV’.’t.:'”;’.’::fi1i:-;t:i§:si*ea¢’r’;:11~:a1r1 Lhrfltmd would be
}:neer:seon’a.V|:=i&’!_.lA.;..”” : of parmlty, he no ‘baaim.

Tm i’£+§mI1″afiéia;n}.;”‘ :e1.:l.;i;1r1;§é’–._;a§f=r.*.;’§.11L€!. he liaiznfle tn pay penalty

m’bowE~=, I uric: mt. flu-cl any graunds to

q::JLa§11 131%: §:.’:.:1ré§+’:»«’.;-s:+.«:=:r:11′;t1gam Haw:-:wx’. it ia made: claar, if

‘~w__ ‘-}:tI’n:1aeera:I’L.:V1{§EL”u1*1 wax’-3 m aatabliah alleged offences

T:.”Vfs;’a;3:13af§s:r;J=jL1«»5:111r psaymmnt -mi’ ESE mmtn’.b*uti.«m alcmg with

V% _,V1’_;I_’_’.i%’tf..’5f.l’.’af.’-.”;’.I»’i. fltld manage a.1’1u:m;r11 by patitinnaerrs he=.=.1*e1’n may be

‘V taker: i11trc:+ r.m:ua.=Lfi.de::ra’Lit;nxm “by tzriai mutt W’hflI.’% knpnaing

periafitjm. Tv

$3.. Thvfi lcsarnmi Caumal far pefitiomm would

auhrua-“11, attnandxmca Bf petitinneras befizrre the

an ue:1.ma.1.*g.«*’e:31ats.11tn:=: mk”l1ea.rix1g-wmfld cauaa undue ~

DE’ pmtfitflanars flncl hardshiplhi filiattvend-I

tlmy m.aarj,r nm.=11-:33: £1}:J]fh1″I.13£1’i1:¢3nIi§~>,”l{;’EflIhI”t”E;’– ‘V >’

::x:»’tL1x*’i:3m51y,a” -n:.=m1a1’iu.’im’ thfi mama ii1v.;§1:::r;:r:i£inc:é,-i’ ‘w7?it.IiJaW.

*1,'.fi.1'iti1 flmae    the cr1n11I1a' ' 1
patifimia was  H ' 2 '

Sd/-3

Tudqé
313* I