G L Manjunath vs The State Of Karnataka on 9 September, 2009

 

IN 'IKE ffflfiifi CQERT (BF Kfis.RNATAKA AT 

EATEB THIS mg mg my :35'  

mg HGBFBLE MR. msncsg  %

M21': P3111101»; ztzQ.663é.:g¢93<%swxE_§gMk 

BETWEEN;

1 Gzmmjunmh   
SEQ. S 3 Laksmngnaraymaagspa   % 
Ag242%'i'¢«'!%'S    % 
      
  
Schafl-B:ra1m maliafli }'i11§s.g£,

 3}zia1a§;zms:%k'rs1u12;;  
'r _K$3.m %  '  '  .. '

2  3:: saw»  %%
..  S;':::., R 
;§;;,g¢&.3? Yam

, , - ., __  _'Fnac}mr

  ~€7§{;m;f¢r3:2:s.:§::£ Lawn' Prirzw Sakaaasl,
  ' Hfiifisfifiiisunféfi Vi?-mg
 gfiihiaflgixws, ram
~~ Kcfia Efisiaricg

%   :54 Vkiawfiamma

3:'a'Vm1k%haia§§.I*:.i Shmfri
Agmfi 3? Yam

fiwmtmi Tmhx

Gav -.    
fifiiflfimfinm '%'§B%s.,.

 {I  3? gm taiuk,

5

 
 

 

 

X"? W'? "59- EM 4%: ii  ?sw#'w mm' as am: .1» ~ «



MGM fififiifim" {W %M%M&W%%& MGR mm": QF 

 

ii-;;.RM$%'f&%% %°§Em*

§
3
§
X
3%-*
§
33"
%
:3
§

an -wur-n uuwwwltfi  Wuflflv"   

 

Ksfia Qisaégi

E R. Naaymxaswzmy

Sis Rmxalz

A.gaM.Iym*§  
Asm-rim: Teacher 

Gammm Laws}: Pxinemy ..;":'s_ 

Raywpmahalli Viflagég 
Shié.1ag:w.aTatm  
Karim Eistlict 

Namimha Rsfidjg    
35afl§%ns§:§:a  V' '     ' 
 K    7'   .
 H;€gheir§"fl*::}m*y,.3¢ha¢i

  
 .. ' -

 K€z§af {Jis:fit$r:'%j%~ '.  % 

 E Hawaywtmaé
*Sfc,'E.§3£mu1a
' _   »Ag§Li%.£2..Ye3:S

 Higher Prinw Schmi
Elyaségaze Village;

  ~ sfiamma mink, Kala' aim:

5 3 V 32-zivsgpa

35%. K  .;.z-_: ;-..s-'.  ' .
Agsa 4s Yam
   . :1-: 1 T636313?'

 

  
 

 
 

{Zia} $12" aink, Kala mm '

8



 

8

 

K 'SE' N  Raddy
S!aVe21kmmeddy
Agcd 3§ yam
Asfimt Tcacimcr

Govcrmnmt Higher Prinzm'y $;;hm1,'; "  *  V

Kagfllté Villgc .

Chintarttmzi Taiuk, mm» mm»; 2 ? %'

 

Grzrvmzznam   * 

    
 Tainlg Is:§sImj4_E:§.s§'m::""'

aged 43  ' 
 Tammi». 

. _ GaVé1"mnn:2£E.a£*wm? Prism Sehwl,

 'ViI_};@s;:3

J  2€:?;'z:'2:"";m;2é_. mu' Taiuk, gem Eimic:

Sgfmififi A L Sizhfia Rae

'~ Aged 3'? gem

-L752

 
   
 

 

'  Tfififlhfi
 --  - ---- fiigzer Prinm Sehevai
€  kink, I-{aim Qimai

 

E? Vmxkmh
S;"§.Ve:1kfiway®p&
Age& 3% Yam

.    _  E ffififihfif

cf

   

§"§§"'3;_'"'§g mwrwm wmwewmmmm H.»



 

 £ Lawn Pziznwy Schcxsfi
Yesagalaixaili Villas,
C  mink, kaim Eistrict

V Srzermna Gawéa
SȎ::s.A Vmzkmashwpa
Aged 46 yam _
Asaistmt teaacha " % 

"§?'a%aya§:afi.i mime

C  '1'ai'av.:¢_5_k?:§.  

K1'  
  
_§§;ssist;fl;i1'7?-Feachez" _  *

   mm:
 K$i?imifi§'5éLk%;lIl$fl§I8§}i '¥"iHage

€33  

  ..... 

E? ._V N
V. ” ‘=A;g:év&g3S~Y¢m3
. ‘ 1

§§? Lawn’ Prinw Sghwl
Bhalfabhwmakflfi Vilisge

” 3%.?-u£’bagal Tahk, Kala Eifiici

Agéd 3? Yam
Asmimi Tfififikfi

8

mmm

13

?,%%29

3.? T R P’:rabhava11%
Sfcxfiadhan Rana Reédy
Agcd 3}. Yam
Asmtmt Tsacher

Gevenmmn: Eighcr ,S¢If_Laza-I ” ‘ V

Kcndigmiaifl Villagg

Clzintmnmi Taluk, Kola ~ iv A

K. S Nmayazmwarzy

Sfbji C S9’§1r2sgm¥*&a .

Ageé 41yem’$
Amlsmt. Tamas: ‘ V f’ ‘

Gavmnznmai Lgwa

Ggkalslmlh?

jTI’a11.;1.;i;._.is?.4::};a.=a;’i.Z1§5m:i_si if; . V

B Af§§$13YE3?”«55df»?.’ % %
Sic:,$.ya3:£I;a~ ” -» ‘-

Agfia 39: 334%’
fixmizwzzi-‘;a_;&;1:1fl -_
$*Q’s” Ragga: P2-him Schml
”

% % % A«Tfa1uk, Kezwmgzzisa

3 M
35¢. 32$-a§4di”E.edciy

Agéa 4: gm L
Elaask rwaama yawn

6

_:””‘a:¢”w°'”a mm” W mmm. .&’s{E«>~ M W

?:%1%”Am mm

W WW..mmm mm Wmm W mmmzxm MW!-é mm? M agmwmmm mm»-a cow”? W flééé

muss And Disnéat cmbanagzu

5 Tim Ziiia Pmzshayat
Knim Dzlmici, Kala’
Rzpregmzicd by
Its Clzief S:-emu}:

{By s1ui.ms:;:msa, Aaai§¢;;g1

$G Advacm fer: }’;—r-V’:

Resp

‘ ‘ – kg;-.5};

This W£iiaPi:f&2:i£;fl 226 M11 22? Crf
the Cmmumsgrm ta dime: the rcspondmzzs
:2: ma time S£:;”sfi£ii;§S3I311§1:i;t§;”¢ i’i 7¥:§;= £33,; wfifii mm the dais ef
ma regulm appaézztrnengt as valid

mid git.

– es}: fa: welixnixw hewim ‘B’

grew $152: €Z.’*:;§1::i:,:*:1afie the fellerwmz-V
‘ ” %%%%% 03933.

» _ ‘é.c:zr7m 633. fax: pzeiinzinmy hmm CB’ grwjp) is

fizfl dispesai, hsvfilg mgmd as the fats mid

‘V ” ., Vsrérmzzéimzcea.

2%? gg izernmm zeachm in

31: 323%: 1988-3? émaé 321 E22: rgssiaztfmn gaissafi by the Ziiia

Fazzghzyam 5; :9 azzaificfiian . é by the §arsrw:zmen£

3

Apex Cam’: by $2 ardex aimed i£}.?.I§9£ diwesed sf.
with 3 dircgtian that each cwf an zeaahcrs,
yam’ of smviee um’: ezanitlcd far
wouid have it: be made, anly :32: mag
rendmd by each sf the pmiriéé
ter the swlé mi? Pa£i’a?§;z,R a direcfian
E113: smtéceg rmderad ‘maid 123% is be
reskanefi an yearly basis mm
mm ” amended the
danfé 94.32.1993, The
Recm£nnen§v’AR§$€$V and it ‘W35 pmviéed thm? 2%
‘far go-zsrgise as mad whmz the
weuié he acccarficfi. Tlnis was

isérsxeé hy tha Szzpreme: Cam.

:25, 23s §&5§§§§§§ wezg $3?-%;’?£Eé ;ss$ zagalar

_ we aw –

ha iimaaé 3% _. ampiagzseg m aniiz’: sggvisé mm the

dm §f fzziiiai wgssizzanmg zzgéa Efw ém §§ W§a?:;h they Wflfi

6

%m\w5e. mxmzaw a. W ..

Qéw mam’ W mmamm =Eé~v£m.H=:

M w(I.’VOM”” ..m..m ymggn: «um mmmwwfimmfl Wfiwfi fiwafifl? flfi WRNAYAW E’-KEQW mam Q?

ii}

screemd far regula reczuiament bweé an p%cez:tgg’a :’_§yf_ mmks

abtafizzgé £22 me quaiifymg ex m mwg%am m;ma

fa: {ha pzwegss of :11: smut we’3:3l d A»V2;jscz3s_:a*:i§f« ih§f.x? e”;t:;§ fie

irate acwmzt far the puxwes af 5

made 3 represeniafien éagseg’ ta
smzsidezed far izzciumiay saf’V!h£§i”L_:*.§aé;n-gee.’ ma their
garvimc xmzicrm ha takm far 31:
purpesaa Siam: this: was mi
gamma; «me pezatm before this

éizacécms. The was was

V’ baggé gr; {gm ; 51″ ihg fiigyggm {‘:g3m§_ 221$ ‘

diwaseé ééf s5:::1<€_1:i¥ex"?j.f6;2s:i:;5-$.:':LV};';§'5;§32%'? reserving am 1% the

was ma :?.5.2§a2 mfi 3ma.2ae';. mg

§e€iiié:§§:%sV"%%%f:§§;_ as agmkzst €112 saneiianeé pasts bssaé

gessfi by the Ziila Pmshwatisa an
sf 2323 3312553 ?§2ci1g§m§:g Sifififi them were 219
M 'Ewes? ai Eim reigvmzi 93192:: 9:' fizzzeg the yaiiasnm"

Wazaid hag £3 E: mafia w rfigzzlm’ @pa>i::t:r:.m:g

fiflfifif

entry izxifi S§I’*i?i€§ Wauié have ia be ggrzgziéfisé fa: fixafisri Gfpay

5

M§%i§-Wé fiiflififif Q? fi€&fi%\é&”§%%& Mfifififl W? mmmmmm Mmrw mamwm ‘MW’ Mmmmflmmmm rmww wwvmwm Wu »w»..mumwww

mid increments sné ail £31122: benafits. This not Exavizig %§_:.=.f: taken

me sanszsammn by fmrzfh raspmzsfimt, it an

endezsemnz éatcd 18.1.2898 rejssting t._f1;*;r ¥:cé:s5g:V.:
pefiiisners, witheut affsrdixlg 3 zizg > 7. AV

is in this backgrmmé mm the p££i§ioné:£ wage k %

3. Th: Cmmsvsl fer ihe abwva
wmfld ” Qwfixa writ gfifiiifirg
yzitnmily cught ms have been
heazc} I: was pessible fer the
peu5ti§3:i5 ‘ that the fibfivfi facts md

s§rQu1:z3:mi£;a$V’i¢:aifi;§’~vfi1ii%inéat4e am my wars net an canfiaai

my ‘as fwaatnd w : empiaycsg md

Eefme ahaaxpalmz wmflé. rsgcessmly have

%.a~§a iakaxfiéiia eersgiéezaéian, by mime af the } afthe

AA Sggmiié Qmat arsé tfiarafare, Wsulfi ask ihfi fix mdexsmmt

éirgfiémzg ‘baa isgaeé :3 Q1: