High Court Karnataka High Court

G Somashekara S/O C Gundu Rao vs The State Of Karnataka on 10 June, 2008

Karnataka High Court
G Somashekara S/O C Gundu Rao vs The State Of Karnataka on 10 June, 2008
Author: Ajit J Gunjal


, % $3»

HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HiG|-I OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH 1

-wummm W

5%? A ~37?

wvW””‘

EX WE 2%%3H $%R”Z’Q§’ 3?fiK& A’? BAI*§Gfi.I..2GRE

Zfiéiififi Tffifififie léfflfi §§§§” fifi’ 33% 2%8

EE1F*fi%

“I”I~§; fiflf-aT’BEE¥v£t: gamas gJITO%.;@§§§xLHOO1H%%H 7: f

EE»’§”@E~EE*I :

fixfiamasliaimm,

figa Sffiuzafiu Rae,

figafl afiauéz. 5″? yam;

immw in Enigma, . V
3§¢”§~%»%? E?-_I?fl;’E’i1f.1″‘-L%’~””1§¥’:i’lfV_V_ ‘V ‘

_”‘!=

“%

~ . :~
A agm

affimmm
” ” “‘§’i:£a;m:a;%i.er:g %3.a£:e Raafi,

-._4}}f;:i’%:;.-‘:.:&%’§§er1 §

1

1′? Ea;§;a.;§maW’,
B&’§&Z@z°’&- ii}

f 34″

q 1,
g ..,»

{<3

32,, 'éiw ;?r:§mi§§§
Cszrilgfig
E? Eaéafiifiagser,
Eamgabm :9,

{J3

, C%::a?i.mm$z1§
€";7§~:;::a*@r2~z':;*%§,.-*e§':*:g ifmmzcélg
l%§§I E-zsarzim ?u§§:€m§13ic§

Eaigaiarawfiafifi mm. R:';:3z:*§1%::r:2E'1§%!%*:':s3;'[V'%%%%%.¢

{§%;&$g:zs:s=:%'3::§$z§?%:= fiafi ia bwught fig;

?m~.11.;:::::3?;§ A V

{fir}: ‘E’;3ai:3a.*mcmra}*an, 551* R3 Sri —
$.z.gFm:mm:g, am fcrzf E1 a_i&1d_R2§_ ,

*:.:m is raga m;@£,a.ek%aL~ n?;eT®L*<242€5k%aa:;a mi czfiha
§::Qf";§'§f;f;?iL?:§"3£I1 sf ~§:::*r 'aim imarég
%5:s*: tégig i.;m.§V3'%.-z;g'::'mé.*1"£s:.**fiiiti'-;.'zf_ §§.§..2§% vfiaz
fi…m£14;z"$~–%f§;-*§:2é::.$éfi:-7I33? '-$3-~;§ yamsa arici quwh tim

'§f'§?_{?'%;%:s31i;_,i:2g s:%:§"f§§§.'. ;3z2&.~1%mi1:ax}r heafing in 'E'
{}s:w§.2:;;:: th;:'.a~ aigagg gm fn :

§,.;3fa';~¢:'..i£v%*.;Z'-mgfiz is qufitierfizag azmmzure-Q3
'him:-4 mwema yanaky fif

'z"é§'.3a'ammé: Q hanéaéz m {Em

~V ; §a%.it:'mm*:i§.az"im film maizw af % s%@

3 afi 4 ww aaddled with tam

nun ………u ur l\nxwM£A!\A mu:-1 punk! or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA man COURT or KARNATAKA HtGH COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH <

I

X

gmmitazi 5%; the m§d.Em$§ar1 (sf the fl

"Iuar: uuunl ur mmmnm I-lib'!-I <.juuxr as KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH <

wag' %u._€:. "

:*:%i::§.~%2.-e*:*§2.%.%:i 2*;-:3 amfi :m% 3?’ Efiiifil” arid nméfi ané fiat

he Eflasse aeftaifi

& ¢ ¢ mama: wag §msu&j%%;,_ nf&§:i§?..T’ ifiéfi

3$%.:g%*1″i.;, gm-26:2, $.33 ezguérfif 9§”a§_;$§§u£:’_:’.%’ »

:2? gm *~;§&:sa imam; Tim a{‘:ztE1r§:*if;;%{‘}:.;ae:%iitjg

mgmd s*;:afi.1.:.a”4: a§§;..}’i£s_. pe’§tir::Vn:.3:_’§ T’ L’

wfimh ‘wag aft bsferee
212:2 T3:*é%::,§%L E’: :3 ‘figs ‘ta: gas mm tim
1′”&a€§’§:’:;:§ Em zfirctiezr,
ifzaazzr: acacaptzacl by tk

éz:§:§i?7;:*;?,;?;:;-r.:~;’,”‘j5 ‘ a§$a1’%*:%.3° a%wed by am

:r’ i,=-

$-

fiismfiafi fimm smfuw with

$3: aaidss mad fix gstitismr

wifi rm: ?% mtisbfi far 3.11;;

:*é%i2é’;~ ifi mcfi 332*:

?§§%3,

§;=7ga§a_ §:~§« 51.;::a%~ E wnéitmmfi – far the wtciafi

an $3 fiuiyz I-L: Was: am

‘ fif fihfififi

gig $ta% Em SE».-Iifmfi :3 § in tha

i.E’2a%O 232?: rm: Emm am; $§a%m Whaétsafimr an tkw

%isesf1s§”§%§ at aawésm £fi§§§§€:%1’i5 €33′ the

iZfs§,{§;%\.1 522.513 gémfém €13 fiiity. E913;

.§:’:::= fififi ” ‘

21:1 fi$”§’°%:’§aw*;?£3z ragimtar péimamzi ::ra*:ie.é;:-._;3aé;a¢%1:”O*§§;’:’T1*:i:a

‘ . L4

“§’§f§§1:.:.*w§E¢ Fazafiiezr I If H 2

1?


Em aim 

  

312:': gim    mllawful
g€.'3'%r:?'%:éa=:a     _gc:a§fius::t md t&
    as}; acfian in
     viaalaiitmm :3? tin
O A Wafi O by W

§:?@fi§;az.met:”* :§%;._2f%*= mick an

:,:.3fi:*:2:’:*:~ = O V: 3 m::i3fir.’ :9

. T fiém A’~.§}§:27;ii:i:2z1ar has awe again

which saw nut

:25 izmgmugh 493, mm was faiawd;

afianm gszszfmkble mfiarr Sacttinn

–. :~;rs;§” tifaa it is mt arm ‘fiat as mariy aa M amaw

azaafiéfi by

:§:.;rE% ffxaafi mimm, mm: sffime 1’3

ejpaet Feilm betwmn

«~.§%1;:.gm”% Eggs ‘cm :% fisa3§u.st 1993. fima, he hm

O ‘:%m.11::5é $.§:%m.r§§. ::i23r’:m film’; wfié. f ward ta fl

FIIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA H56!-i OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA I-KG!-I COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH :a 2:133 af aim Eiaammm Prmte Eeizmatiari

EBia:m§§§§;11e mfi fianfiai}? Rufim 19′?8 {Fer

$®§§§ ‘%?.§:::3 Exam»). Encidgflmlg, it is aka ta he mviiaseé

azfiar at firm¢xmQ wzsufi aha

mfg} cazzgidarahiem tim yam a;_f::_3;l§V_O

ammrice ymwéa esf ‘aha ggiéitéaam: $3 .

imgii; §f’:%&’t wag a Eha egg gs§f»5:up&f.:é;x51r;iif&’fi£j?nv’§n

?7’3.,.eisa%*§'”,:.*:?::;-522*’ Eififjfé 33$ salsa} 53?: fix $3-$:’g¢,:j_£’O V 7-]

Em”é%:::;?s.ti£2:§’.%.

=::m:.t§::u..%§riI3-* his
Fmrflmg an him salary’
fi_’§§ a}fzr::”i”%=*&3:”1%ui’§*:%§:* July is
gawk” wag
E3%&.id sis; bcfrsrzs tilfm Court

O

mzfinsaé a flax tha

£53? tha

Wfifi

-KGB COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH (

‘3a”a_:’i}:1§if3 that %he gmzsvmkian whisk was mwkw

t§? af Immpukarjgr

:€a”§§rl’:’rt%;,im§ éima, Rm 1% Expfirzaéuian Qévéj sf this gem

§,a§§.}i§ma%1e ‘E9 the rmpagzdarzg irmgmugh mg t&

Heme ffipefidfiit did mt

Eriarae am}? $f.%W’$E’ ta mmpakariiy mfim the He

g::.%m§_’m fiahaat under 3:-emifin $2 sf tim Eéuwatésan

‘/

z<§y::*-*5; {far awya, 'firm am {fig mazn.-mum parinfi ef

a?s.:;a§Ee;maarZ§i§% fa mglg; 53$ mnntw azfl

$"$.'§§§%'3?'E$§9i:%*§Ea raguifim a.%;§tE1§1*%miuicsn.

22%: éimzaai. flflfi suapamésn wag @1332" _ " ~ :75 .

§%eiz;Satgrax1wa3ran,f

aha §'fi$f%:'.li1%§'§;'§23 3 5 tn
the zz;:';5a:rs@ua'£: '£131 'ewe dfietmxt
mx:m::»:is%:::2$ 3 maxmagfimant
éfi him
mm is takan E3; the
finch mgrwszilaery re'E3m&1' tg
21:3 % Egg hm: giwn Eh: «mtira
afimanrsm withmut any dfimfism

i'£.:a§?V§eL_'_;_;a.;§r%';1$2:§ :fs%::.:;f:;L~{.:¥fi;;§;$n"€@ ia&., mm tha éais, the East sf

enéfi in an amfaittaiz til? flzzmber

~ ..T'.;:;;fvf:%:{:31é:$

E§§¢% as am apggmafigzy af gm 1:}, 2»

that mgmhs

35% fiasaettg Kafifmafiaag

Em ism? g as mzitampéatsd ikwaitz, are :"

–u\3r1 yuan: Ur nnxwnlaun mar: Ljuuxr or KARNATAKA HIGH coum or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA men COURT or KARNATAKA HiG-H 1

cz3’zaz1s€2§.a’?§V for?’
._ _ ._ i,

O. arzflgg at

___§§::2;.§m%.é:a.m. 32% 3; fiwsirig

HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH CIOHRT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA PHGH I

iz’za§::r1:;€:h am 1§’?8 Rum $t.:’l§ mfitinum tar hnfifi tm fiaki

Mfi afwmiifi ‘E33 {E13 may ruleeis are fixaactfiz.

s§z,h§::’::%;3¥5 am: umiar swwn 1% fig 23% a¢::#O

fiwi téze

$.13:-§ §$fIz!;’%’%§1’1d&’ €33 $1233: if

$94 E @3195: my ts; tim
auhméaaémzw mafia: fi§ hr
the ;::»2§i.:i§,a§:3::a:.r..j” H O V 2 O
maém m23t¢n$n cs? thc

“fur fisim mm’ ‘ 11$

¢:~§m:mz gum Rule 13 :g rzssqizirfisi

éiapmad $5. Efiefi 3 $15431 af

-Q weuld ciaarly

‘aim pacswma mam fink §.§ Expkrnaifmn
Exam izmaskfi far awmdig aha mafir mrmlty

j%;,:s”:t:2§3.§3′:;:§$a2y it éa rm ésufivt mm thafiz

ffifigtz fiaigd 25% Qeirebea’

gflfiéig fifi 1§?S Eflgfi am: –ff’

and .

§£”jf:f ‘fiwaaff »:::«§’ €¥fi§fi1§ZJ’i3};%fi§ mfikament pamixazzt $5 an

a:miu%:;.’2§j§g pm*aia§m%z:¥ tha rcz3m2:ar§ retiirgfifi

am: :2: 12a :2: puhlk gamma <,*»:;"s§.1ci__.«3'%§é"§s;:.¢;1.i§~;}i:

figfig figmn mafia? the lcif »

mfiammé ami when mick;

fiamfiéeyszazigrziaa, 3′.he mam ‘:”aaté:’*§efl¥z’1’#L’
agate ihag 2′: f§”s;:’:::s£;ic eases mt
mfigzz fiffi gram? ‘it; éa mt Mate

tizaé: 33% z*=&%:§a’i&§;;~:=mt public: irzfizsrmi.

E2: is ‘ mfiw 9%’ mmpulani-3:

‘ ta that chwaciw ax
1,.z.£*&: fijsj the gvvisinns cf

?~.;:’fi::%§e;: ;3r::é;:2}%%:+;:”gm; gfigmgamzm But urilsss :1: 313

Emm. imaif that a (may 23:”

i£’:g;%é§té_§:i:3z§’«v:§§” fifigfifihavimuf G1′ §acit§r fit’ mat sf thfi

%&§&fim already’ rim crder

ixfiimat %g ‘£5 R arm sf swam} «err in the namrc ef

§ 3E is mt cyan for the Court tar get

. flag firdm” and hsfi Elhat iii. attaehfis 9. mg an

hsaasia 21%” 3% pxwgzavcxsai gr rmmmfinéafien wrist:-3 by

…… \.u\JIJi\l HIT’ l\.uIuVu-\IH!\.M .-mm puuxl or KARNATAKA Hist: COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or= KARNATAKA HIGH!

afiazfir 3u%@2*s:1?2Im%¢ fig the an

1%

gm m*£:&::* mi? mwukafir §fi fi§ fa rm: :3 punighmexxi.

Eé: m azjgm mar any 3%’

zgiéfihaéizmérfiir. Er: fast ptézieiplam -:32′

“mam rm ylaame 2’31 -::’:a”….-“iV’.’£;’3iIf’:{3..fiI’–v{3:’£

aamgzaémgja gafirmnt. f;hi3* £32?

1%’?

a§%fl§@?.E1:s:::*. gym zifgim &ara;;;1a%% am
mafia? as am hawarsmr it may
izszaxéim 5: is pwsed with
%1:’§e:’z.::e 1331′ that it is
viimssazmblez gram); Waufi
an 1&3 ma mmaaz in
§T%g>:”%:.: 312; a gamma aradar, in tha cam

gs znamg it *3 aa fie mama mt

fag: aim; the wiziawr ma

— ymmafiiws, reapczaéerzts 3

.1 ~=”%;:maa mag may m mm

Erzéwfi, mgmtgzm 3 ta 5 have: tam: a

“f:..’%%:ir 2°:’:§:’az:%i;§:fie

nun LUUKI ur nAuNmAKA u-sum count or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA HEGH COURT or KARNATAKA HfGH COURT or KARNATAKA men c

zgziaaw mini have mid the $ ‘ and allewaram fiar

thg manta fmm July ta Ga::tobaa:rfl

‘§§

Eéfilfiézy have 94%,: zifiéamiw. that *z$y haw net

aziy aiatuwyy é§L1z’b§.am:, 3:.8.§ a.

Egfizfi fafiiif – whisk is m§l&i:es:{ mg. rm mfimmfiéif .

Iszfiaazi, aw fzzrflr H O” 2

imp§.§§2t’:2.§€i iiftiéf’ wcufi ha 991}? &¢é;.d&;_}1:3ie’; if:.’=:.a-%1*3::fi;::§i””aa;’T1vO.j

1!»

tin gaiéiifiner .53 %.Q’ V:’VI§;””-.;fi.t?£K§.&”iI].E~ “iaf

$”i$i.fRf’§.-‘%.E”=«’.$”§{%;i$;%:’1§4:§fi in ‘E:.’3.!E gm}? 32?: art?’ tirzia gm?

2%&

£16?! COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HEGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HEGH <

;%1j1::;a1'?O…H,.\4i_,~;=*5A::V. barfi coumel

&§~rgfia*§'§*3;';.%i".E;' %§"§,*~z*_it;?:1}& i..§"'3:1<1a'ii the m:1t%1t1::xaaE@z3 ef

Rule E3 sfthefiulaw

.

mag: 31.1%-Rzxlc iih} af Rm 1::

_ 3:1 ampéaym is aazspendafi at is éeamaé
. fiem S»§§$§@:t’1dfi§; iwéwtfimr in mnfiwfien
déwiylkg §m E!’ -? .s«.- an&
O. sfiaaw fiéwcipfimxy’ §1’m«mé:Izg’ £15 mmmncfi
agaimi him éurzém 2&3 wfifinumm af that

asazg-gemiaaig ifia §,u§haz’k§ mmpemm 3:: phw him
:fl;;2§:.§23¥ amfisfin. may far xsmaazns m be reaisrdfi
E-zg him in fifiwi ma: ‘E3515 amplmyec siml

£4

ncm COURT o:= KARNATAKA HIGH cougar or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or XARNATAKA HIGH COURT 0*’ KARNATAKA HIGH COURT 01′ KARNAVAKA “*9″ ‘

°:§:am:?@m, rzfinrzm: Ema — mégh $13 Eiahifity ta
%.i$ gain}-* mid a§%*wa far
w§§} baa againsi the pzfimipée sf

g?;3::..;%::a gwéwdg tha ._3–:_iEn§iat,e1¢;s:%4s:

fim yriwttf in is? V
uimwaéigbk.” ‘ 3

Eg imam? :3: .1i$:e:i£:3,jz’-gf ‘-Eléuri in the cam

af

j%A4é.%§$Rg;a4%nnma1-3? BEAT
Ema 3&9 rulfl thm;

:15 aim: Wham iim cmgLam* 2;

jé”§:2:?. at af 2% marmgementfi the
ma$aa;;£3n:aé:1t Em Iflifi 3:3 piay $3; ‘(Em crimfimal

;_;:j§*:;;%§;w::;,’®2’;~–:EaTi;m}1@ t mm}: emplayaaa.”

ta 3:213 wialiisgg af $1;-2 aficummmw,

I 97% that the qagmfiaa of inmerferi with

A 5 ” : §:s-amsiigg {sf éamgzfiilmrfg §$ %.§ in tbs gage an

‘ – %fi am: at all wasrantefi.

ggiajfi gmfi @a?fi,iw§y §.z@*§.zita?ek ta ‘_
€33: azfljrk mg mm mm%* }3$;f§L,. §'<i'§;¥s's;

fi."§¢$%' by %;r3*me:_.a;§ "

am-I noun!’ or KARNATAKA men cquxr or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA 1-new COURT or KARNATAKA men COURT on KARNATAKA HEGH c

ifi

fiyfiiafiiézg saihmita aihast afi; imsfi; a dfmmtian

Cmzigé. iaaaxaafix ta tém rmpgrsnci ta 333% the. a§

tiam §>::a::%?:.:§:: mat and gay $& mmaqfiafiéml

an: sf ‘$122 5En.

amsléi gyaxgmti 511:1

3.Z§,%§§§ ,§T §fiTf” herieifiém

fiizfifiisfifififii ”§}*’ 23% Essaflfig can
mar’cafm;%§ éazzige a m}&% !;:;a’r:; 31:3. tfig aaifi ciaim

mg Ea 3 is E: mevirzg

$53″ fi”.;@ mfifimsmfl and tkw
%’J.!E%fif3″%’+=7’ié?’§’§;».;;*f}Vfi;”7’§l~ Cilafirfi tlze mama 3!’

1″.E’z’1a$1x’%io:§;a$;.–*’f’:.’_-= A

Efg ¥:’.:–*::ii3a.’xm 5:1:a.§§a mémtedw

“‘ Sd/-

Iudqe
§§;~

  3    .