High Court Karnataka High Court

Gopala Sherigara S/O Shesha … vs The State Of Karnataka By Its Secy on 23 June, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Gopala Sherigara S/O Shesha … vs The State Of Karnataka By Its Secy on 23 June, 2008
Author: N.K.Patil


}?i{?:E~§ fI,’.{‘}*?.}E’1.LO§€E W..§’,’?\EC}.~’%’2;%??e (f}§’ 3€3{‘é3

J2’.

“§’§-%§$ %§*«:’.9 58 FELEEI i.,§?’~EEf3E§§ fie??? §.,.Ef”? 22$ $5539 3:2? GI: ‘THE.
i3Q;¥’a§S?”§TL§TiQE”~é €39: §%’é§§§.§ ?é’€,3′??-.\:”E€’~.%¢°3 W3′: QLEASH VEQLE !3%.§\§}f.» C3 3′? 1;’§’3\;2€;¥€£’l%_

$5!’ T95. §.fi§”‘x§§£’3 “?Q§8¥_§§’~§Pe§.:. i§Q9..§P;%. §}EC:35§iE§§~§€3 T§~é7§L §F3’§7’T5§’%”%i’Z}§’°~§E§’~i$ 53$

f)£§35..%§3§z;l’£? {SF THE 33.3%? L:i«’a§*~£§3 S3§?a,§fi.?EB 35%;? KEEDEKAQ ‘s;’§LL§%{§E3 i,3§H.,§F>i..4_

“i7″é:4iJ§v<{

@423 $59' :,::;-wage ms msa §~g*E,££::a::i,; ":'"§~:iS &w_, ?H_§*:$@é,§§:~??Lj"* "

f*£fié3E THQ F%3L§.C3¢£%§'é§::

Tifie fietéiésrgrzga agsaiiing {She a?:?3:”;”%z+%:§::f”i~z’§e3I’3. ‘::*_4″‘ ‘

impugned carfier éawfi “‘i’%§3 ?K11ar c§*:.v_vL’2€};§3 ;::a~s:.$3::§: ‘c3’3%V’i’%’:e

Efifififéé re3;3anée:*§§:-=E_3nd T–:é§una;§;””§§: §§;i;ré§’;_ in gafsueefiéng

Ne. a_§v:?22 és:33e;TR:?&?§ k :fi:j§’:f’_:%:%$:’;;:%éa_§f3,, SQ £3:

as it reégies 29 Eag:z.’;%”«%.;:’§j’«Sy}§.E:;.?i’s;!?’;.«$§éi:;a:f§f’3% E~{sde%a;’;.:

aséiéagé, §}é::§v;:,*§’§’Ta§V§;,§’§;; wréi §$”£§?§S§’§.

2. éegpaadegéi a§aér::%r%§ $9
éée the ré%;?§.. i:en§§:?$VAha¥=s f§§é§’:V¥a:’r2% 94%.? ‘Ea: rggéatrgtéafi
?sf’f:V.ééa:€3;;§§;%’f%2£ir§::A “§;%*:v””%é$p&:.:*; 3% the égézd qaeséésn

§e%§g:§” jé?””§?’;._’V_ré$§i:r*:éent–§.ar::u’ ?r§ba.;naa iffiupé. ?E*3e

f;– :S$&$€}§%fi “‘:–“–a$§;’s7r:-§’*é§’21:»§_§:%d “§”:”§b:,m3i, iééupé has pagsefi

::~s:*:.”‘%§.’V”?.’§$?8n “‘;”%:e said ewe? éaga been aagaééed :3;

;–‘g§’5£§%§arae¥ Eefsgrg éhé

A ;~? AL{Z’%<'.';é {I}? :3;-'£53

§}'€ HEQEEE (IT{IEi?R'§' C}? §{;i{§€E'~€;'1.'iX?«'x§-£3 :33" §:§?&.§\§{}?a§,{}§2.'§'Z_ '%.§5.§'}_?\E€I},£2f§'"="§'% 3633

'Z

esnsééergééerz befgza iéza Sévégésrg Sencié éé' iézés, flew:

8%' March '§§§&§ 3&5 ibis Com'? has afiimwd fhe *' V

p§t%%:§as*2 and the srder pawm by €§::e»_§_gr%::é

Udupé, has men 3%? egéfie, in 3% far éa ;–:i_f_ §'é§$'€€$ '$€}:

swig 3? Sand £5': Sy.;f\;a.?2§'? em €%§%e.§¥2§i:f§§e-5 tiiféiééa

Lam "§'r%ba;::a§ is Ehai %§i'£€?;§'%'§ 53;}?–§€%¥' "'§§°§S§'% €§§:i.,"?'»;."'2:§S$§

accaréérzg 'Ea iézsg. 3:2 £33393: $5 s:.éit%2§é;: ?$;§s:":{%Ca3v= .A'::';§;'§'s:_%.*.2e%"§, 2&3

rséer §gss%§ E3? '_'-E-_a:':§ "§':*§'%.,§%L:r':§iE;'.j_'~i}§?__;;{ja':é remgéng

unéégtagsfiefi 35$ :3 .;%§i?e_§3%, :'s*:£af£§§§fj» §£33é,:.§°.%:§ fig; fig mgsée flag;

Ehgé 3%: gaérgéé»; 3:75 §:£e3;v3<*-§':;f2§5e%:::4'%'r:TA_"é%'~:§a-iésn is 15% afggesgié Z?
aawia :3'? éagéd §%2.._{§;;..§'%§::.,?';';§?' ,+;."}§.§%'Si.§§§"éS% Q? fie §:'§e;'*
Qgafzzaafi <;é§}e ;5%v%é%§n…__§%a?:2a%é 3;? ms amt, ihe Land

'§'r§§b–:;?2::3%A,:' §;.§§;;:v:;rj;¥i'%=??1?$'a§f:'&;':;i<e§2 {:3 $23 mafia: far sanfiédgatéfin

"=.::%»?:'a €€t§' §§ér::%;. and rejeecwé 'iiw appiéczatéczn fiiéfi iay

"~ ..}§3f'€E7§:§_'§";§{7§?'§®§'? %a*é§7§§'§;§ié€ asnéucténg wage? erzguérgg 3:25 wéthaat

I4_'"–»::s;:f§§2§Af;;éi:*ssg .=:%';e diyaatéefis §§S£i$§ by 53% Séaxésésn germ: Q?

"£°?§%au iléuri: as zeferseé gm? .

Being aggréeaseé by the

$53 T?7§€ E-§’§€}E~i {‘.’€f 1% RT {FF A7?” §5§.3aZN§€}.5kEh,(‘.1i«’;E€ 7.3J}.-%?..§’?i% {..i=§’5 Eéfllsfifi

TQEZ €T£’§TjEi'”§” E}? 5%’? $5 ?.’f*E{},a3’l3’…%’?3= ‘Z{‘v€}f€

émgzzgnaé aréer gaasefi 5;: the Lam “%”§’§§:..:;°’:a§, ééfiaspé,

reférrafi amyé $28’£§’3£§%§’%8§’ ms grégenteé gm ‘mi: §a%;};§’ér:( .._ : :_. A

3. i have haafé iearmé eaagnsgé §:§§:2&a’;¢%:?::§.»’§’§:”

peiziéimei iearzéaé ffiazsemmeni: P§ea%:§er;”‘:s;.;:§§e?a_;°%:2:a§’

gaagsnéégétami am 2 3225 §earne7§£._ {;:§.s?:$é§ :a;:%:§;ef2§;{§z~e«ég;s’«-€53?’

3?” rmgfinfienfi §

4. %§%$2″ {3§;?E’§£§§ gariéégé’ §af-?;:%;e __”§§%?s3;:>.-;§%§2′?;efi awe?

paaseé by ‘fhé ‘%1g” %’v’§art:§”2

QQQB, £4; £5 §*:’aa:”;%’f§$=£_:-“:3’§§s”%i%§’é:s ,5c??%§jr§;eV”{;§’dei;* 2532, ‘:he Lam
‘§’:’%§z,;g’:a% has __ .i;’fi§’%;¥’%vEf’¥E§%§§é3§’2._ “‘¥7;Tf§§3.:’~:~”€’;l§%’%”§3§& gé’ gasséiae in
§5’§%E&§§¥§§ ‘£:a=g:;$$:~$ €:?”?& éééésééméi carsdzggtéag ;§§’£3;%§%”‘

g.;r.2qss§:y $€:?’~§r.:€ 3§%*r;§3ié a:’mé2 Q? §’8§%’%§§§’%’§ §C1%§”§%a’%S§§{%$ Q?

€:?V”:z%_V §_;§;j%”‘%dvvR$’§*%;1*ff?”;’T§f;i’~é”v%$? afié Qzsieg zagéé %;g%%%*:€;:_§%: agmgéyéfig

aé§ms:§:g:~;s $3; ‘%:;*”2& Qiagsgm Eanth 3% §%’°;§$ Qeufi

_ ‘_-«.$fS, %f§§C%¥’§’8¥.:§ :a=%2;32:e. 5%: am Emazzé “?;”é@;.s;’zaE figg %S3§§¥’%%é

4’-_ ‘;§:”%§ $;’§§§§”‘*;*aaaa%’:$ sag §”%C€s§”€2§4é’;E§ 3 ‘fémdégrgg has rejesééag %:%2a=

§§§}:;§} §Si.E%’%§€2€?¥ fiiaé fig §$’§fi§?§£%§§$-§”. La végzsv sf :23? atsrafiuctérsg

*–. ‘§:’~::é§e:’ emqzsigy agar; ms nan agfiééance :3? %ha éézectéans

……._—-..-u—._….-mu-a—-

fifxé ‘E’%5f3Z ‘Er§Ei}}§ {T-‘.’}¥.”§{“.§’ {I}? 51,?-Z;»’§ Ki’ .’E§5’g2*-é{‘zsE’i.(I3’§?;?E£ %’,}’.?»2i’}.-«%i33’§3 €f;?§9 2{%éIT;3 _

ER? ‘§’§’£E€. E'{.”£f_’§’§.-E {“f(f§i {“3279 Ei;3;%{FE };’§2″.3’?f% 53%” 2&3}

900$!”

§$$%§&§ by 325% Qéisiséarz Beam sf 23% 333:: 33 §’§fe-{ms

§ tfie éénpaggnad swag’ pegss-ré by ‘$8 Lmé “§”§”§%%.é_%*%V§_}’;-.._’T~.

§_§%§§.:§§ caramt %e $§§$§8§§’E&§ and éhe Same is §éa§§§;~;:–.é:§ %;a~§=_éLj”* ”

aaé: agéfie. am this gmund aiarsa, 2:gi%hs:§$»*A§9%4ng

we maréis aaé demerézs sf iézéa aafiéfaéidA”the”§;§§’::::_:::fi$ :”«.

Lsrgeé by haih 53% parééeg.

5. §”§§¥§§”§§ regami ta.*’;§*°2$_§3;ié; é%é§’ §§’§§’s:;;;s”:”2§sé:%i2;é% 3?
2225 cage as aéateé V 3be*.:e:,:_ fééeé by
peéitianeg <_'-tanés: V

5:; ggégby gatasssnaa is
a%§axa.se§'§?}: grzért.' " '
w ':.aej; -2-he V&%§jp§'gr{a§'%$:¢er éaééd 2 :* march
sacesnd ?§3§£xfi§E¥'%€~§.,3¥'%§
1" __ W pi in fimceedéng ékie.

§_§Q§;*i’:?z’:2M’*V’§’V9%§%3335:’E’§t34Q§:?S=-“?§ aside §s.%’§-{“§é§~iLi§’8~=
set aséciéa, 3% ‘E2: 3% §€: reiaigg ‘Ea Q?

Ea §,Zrg.£\£aT?2§? -‘ Er: reams? :32′ {:”2’§%”a&r

_________,…._…….._’.’a-

3?’; ‘§§’§£€ %ii(,§}’§ (“f€_..3E.3’§§.’?”*s§§_2i;'”£’.,«’%K;.% :-‘if? i’§§a§\§{‘§-_é’s§._.ii}%?i’§{ {,§=? Ziiéiéfi

EEGH C.{‘}°§.T~’.”§’ £327 2″‘~I§’ ‘»¥’.§3,§\;’§’.I>,»$23″3’3 {EE5 2%}

survey rmmbezrs $29 953%: gagged by 2&9 Lagzd

“?s*§§e..ma§ Léfiupé is kept énéasi

{ééé} faéafiéf géaafis ramifigd back

samnd rasganéantméang °§’;’%%a2ééa%,.’§§5;’r- ‘

gecsnsééeyaééas: 3% $25..» mafia?’ a§§e§%:§.%:’~;’£ ifi

aggrsgréaice decégém €53 3gc$;iVég:f§{;,423′?3 E}? E{.%i%3

E33 ‘.§”E§E}l §’§}i€}i~§ (I{.}i,?}~’C? X}? ,.59aE<ZA 5%'? R?1?_'~§{.%.s'§–E,€ 322$. ,§3,f'~§{"£$fE3'?3 if)?' Z{%{';3

§ é§m§:.,;§%:'2g '5£§§é 35%? mama éy the §§¥'§$§$f'§

bench at' $33 Saw': 3% iefefgeé shave, wé'£;*':%:3… ~

Eight waaéstg '§§"$§'¥§ the fiete 9;? gaeeépé: sf 3 ca§3;§V.:§f".i"':: '

éghéa away. ._

{a} "$129 sergand E'$S§–%£ii"£{§3%§"é§I*'{L§:%.':'_2:4i'¥..:";§"%"§§%é§'%éE.§.,V _

iédsmé fig dirgsted Es :'eeé%–*§fé"~.,_%th§'"garzzei

grassed ':5 pass $23 ap§:*'-{;';.'3%"§_fa:€¥e¥"-»__a:*§é?;s§;~

sa;'§2§£éer:::g 3% 3I§"%§ e§$é;&§ §§§*é%:£ié$§2}§'~vA%3L$'as$d $3:

thés Gang.

‘”§§>?:}’. HEGH {‘{}%3’R”§” €21?” §i,+%§{?’s’§’a’E”*;’%.§i.:1 .:}’..”E-K §%s3..?'<{% 2=§<':i9f '$2373 5}?' 2é'%3.s,1.