High Court Karnataka High Court

Gopalakrishna Murthy G vs The State Of Karnataka on 17 April, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Gopalakrishna Murthy G vs The State Of Karnataka on 17 April, 2008
Author: H N Das
IN THE EEGH CCBURT C3? Ka%%PLTflKA AT' BANGMJEDRE
mama THIS 'TI-E E?" EBAY $1? APRI3', 201}-B

BEFORE

"rm Hmwam. MR, mamas 2-mfiaaamamgfi L]:  

 

 

1; ampawmzsmxa wmifim
3;' an amwwya  A 
A'CrEIZ3 -'}{}YE£'sRS,, __   
IfiST'%C-TQR, mm" ""~ «_ 
mm' rmam, smxaramia   *   
gas ammawmm, mmmaima.    

2 &mav1aas;R.*=~,;c§; M51 .  
aw &..dIJi*Ii:%.~'i?J.&2u:-*3; Rag)  _  L 
mxm §?«._'§"§§;-fis}%'»,   '-  
  rC4fi.%;%¥§2'3;§s};'*E;§IfiG.,
my aim 1C§,it}*;§f.x5 1$%'«$*'wm,

:?"1'H Ra M&1I€.REé'£§C§E_R£-§.§Pfi,RAGfiR,
EfisfiG£%.LC.*RE;"   '

3 sgggiia. 3% $s.%::asHwARAm:,v. <3:

 iaigggz, .:§»1.A'x'EAFé+E':;*'i}£~¥ST1¥'€.mT¢i)R,
% * .m.z«:c,<:;2:c«aL mm mmmwmmxczs mac-.,
    Ei'£1.,§&€?¥?',».E.*E}'"i§fiAIYA. Gmmn,
% . EEEEEE. _:~£;.§.;i_"LWAY mafisfl,
Vmmmam 'aamsrzamma

 

, 'A =.:5s_;'G EEHNANAEWA. H

" _ v _25f'JI3rEaB :31 YEARS, E3ST@i2T€3R,
 m.E£.mIcAL & E.L.mTH:3mc3 EEGG,

 RgA*mw.15&3._. A§¥}.£fis..fl'EYA Tmmfi STREET,
  mm, QEHANMPATNA
Emmawfis REJRAL mm'.

€j\w\/\.

%  rmamzgs.-r«z.'a:s;L%i[%&kAK    k



3 KR smmwasa MIJRTW
3; £13 §*;.R&M£xS»'WAIW'
fimEI;3 Qfi WARE,
3';fiS"I"RE.;¥<f.:»"I'€.}E¥
mymzmfim ENGG
R; A'? I'ECn'.'2*'?3, ii C;Rfl8~$,.
mwmufi TDW
mama mamzm:   

 
  

    

Q  $151.19.?!
33% v'.mRrvAW&
mm: 29 vmas,  
msmmmfi,  
iE'§"S'I'%Is.iIEI3'".{'R'I'IflI§' A1513 CI=DN"I7Ef'§£L.~_ ~».,

m§3~+:;.§ RXAT EEG-.1519,  MARI',  . . 

"NH E'.;R®Ss'$ 
E.§2.fiG»fiL»G3EE ,,

 

'2 mvzfimap   A      
mm B.C,mm*A$§?m.£ay'G@WD&'_  '
amgm Q6 ¥E£eR;Ss,.%IA$g§&3'$*r2'i:C.';'1*1:iR,j%A 
my  %  
§:$t::Im€C~EiZ}: R§m'';:"2€¥mwg:m';a ;
s:$§iMrm«'afi;TNA' TfiL.¥J7£i;   ,, ¢ " 
miiwaimmmmaa fiéi. 'R_I{;'I".

 

8 I§h=mE~E*IBRfi...S;.'V
  :£It'§sJ§'?€,'r;»_:?:'%i.¢Sv;.'s.v'E»1\IE'€.g5*~;*'i'F;é.;SI~i mwm

% 'fix-L2-'EvK3A?ȣ3A"zTE:AR$

 _   ma.   mam

% . '1*§g?«1%;*§T"«§L_é%§}*€~g'}§EB %";1'flLCfiNY,

A  $H%§?2%fimAGAR,
BéEE.:%fi"§"x'1'3I.:;

 

  

.. 'Z 'V

 

 . aim; zaavmfisg, Imwmamfi
 mrmemmamt Exam.
Rm NA 1&0», BEL QU.m*'mR$
FEEAE ::.&M1E SH 
amfimmxg Bfi.N€."?cALflRE

fimb.



1%

11

1?

E3

 fifilfi. Eflffi Sfifflfiii. G

.&GE: 3? YEARS

LW$"I"I-"E"K;§C';Tfi3E£ E$f;.E£'.';"I%.3§€IC fla
flfikfififlfiiflfifififi flEP'I',.

Rgfifi.' Nflfifif 1, $§flV:°a.K'§{.IRPA

IEED 3% . Bfi13A\?£ S-§'§WARPa. LJFLYQUT
'wwfiyfifififiafi, Efi.«.§GvA§'(3RE«.

mAmm.M,.K. am mama. 3;:
AGE», 33 YEARS, Ew1'RUcTGEt 
1am::HAr~z1=c.A.L   .. 
Riga ~zmW,. gcsmm. E=A£'3;§{EmE__ 
M   1  
Bmma%.mRE.,

mvm.:a:.$ am Kfi:ME.SE+IW'AR'.Sj,R 
ME: wmma      . 
IR'§'3"'1"R'E§i1'+TQR, AE}'TGM4«'i3IéEE1;.E  
REA W9; "mam. Afi"'1%§4§E§"f§iA'§"E'. a 

   '   
ammm3é2:E%  % *

x+~1;a;.E:m.m;:. m[%:: 1¢2E:ZiI.D3%
astaagz: 2a'a'§::mar«.% - _ . V
LfiS"1"RU€;T?3Rg'«B§STEE§fe£;EfiTATIGN &
uwwam: m»::m%.k    %

':§

Lflfi RESIWMWJ MEC§'§&NI€
Efifi-fiH&fiIfifiL Eflfifi. 33%,,

Ol\W%.

 vIsvm§E E;Dm«;     %



16

E?

1%

 .

Himfififi, TREES $80538
€”:vr%C}Vfi¥%RAJABfifiAR
E}-{B %3’*fL*§.£3E%’Y, BfiaIiC}&.LflI33E–5f:3fl fl’?9.

V.”§’§RISfiI’I1%a!IL?R’fiiY

;.’§.s’»§'{} VENKAT ‘MfiH

fi;.fivE~: :25 YEARS? MB £kS3}IS’1’A,E’T
E§EQ.I-IAEEC-AL I3vEPT.,

{if 0 V5-NKATASWAMY

PIiZ’}.E’4~*fl§,, 4TH W3′? 1
Eififi £3-Rfkfiafiy K.I~E.fl CQMDNY
Efififim.-%$¥RE-ESQ G”3″§. ‘

FE £21 ms-ARMA
3; U m~mamm.mm9m

mam; LAB .a.m:$rmaVT;E§sE¢;$2a2n¢%

m_:mMmmLE DEF§3,i*§:3;.6Iéf38
ma mm.mm.s1 mmfiv; KEfi’J..’i§i1R1
Efi:§%’.}fi;E¢C1RfF:a.S;f6G mau.k%k;: % t

G}, mag k

am §.«.S7;. _VG~!%g&?;USm3I37′
mE%m.%kmkygm:%s% % k

W: msIm*m*?mm€xs§w:c
MB1fiiHfl.NE€’iA;L W. 1.
Han fEf.?g;23,, m 1\.a.fam”
:eM;:.¢ mywwg ?~w.a2rMm..m
E’1..$~;.i’§¥’..f’m°’,;E&«’:ZJ’:EE»’-‘;’%iiL’% am.

K

.’2’-EMRS

_ lemma mimmw.

if§.’§§’£}HB£.={§”I”IQfl EvCIE!%IC:E }3EP'{‘»,
fixi-%E.1–LI ‘*w”I§..«L.é’s.*C.’3~E ANE PQST
HQBLE, I’§’lU§’%E{‘=’rAL TALUK

swzwta

mm bi % ASSIETART

d\’/\/\_d,.

E1

22

24

E«LE€»TRQNEflS $5.573 €,’;C!hm’IUNICA’YiON EEPT,
flfi} fig Smmwa, K523 NCEEQI 22

IS”? Ex-*ifiLIfi’ Rfifiili; VRU’ VATHI I-1’AGfis.R
I§§fie.B»§,&KE&WfiLYfi, EfisH{‘.?rfi.£CI?RE~56i} CW9.

VENU EAKEU
fiffl §{.tM. NfiR.é5L”E”.i%.flA SWAEW
M2?” ‘L2? Yfifififia Lfisfl A$SISIAN’I”

Emwxmmawatwr AND Ct:Z3E€’1i’:R£”JL’EH(§G’; A
Rwmmmmnx mm VEMAGALT7I€3Em– % 5

zérramm “§”fi:L{§K mI3’2*mc.is;=, T

S. mawmmm
agmfifimmm %
@333 43. YEARS,HE}i.\PE1;.;;_____
mE:mR:cA1.. mm C.*m»:;:1§ia_:”.a _Ls:?:.P’r

PIC} 3:858, $29135 $@?i¥..§3EOS3_ .

vmmmsmafl ‘,
Efi§«Efi.F%;E,£I*RjE«% 4£,

mm §.3f”iE$’:’3f.§.’fI.E3:vz”‘; _3§.§’-. ‘«-._V k L
samyaafismzir-g_ k .%
.m3E.%m%31T%§i:3ARz;kk% % _ %
fi«.T”£TE:’;W3BE«Eé &EZ%¥…#3%FFi€3?E- :
ma @m1%LamI€mgmL%mGE mm m
wm vammm; E.I%&PEGr;:%LQREA.

1% «m.;:£.L:..’2?”:fEAR3§ LAB ASSISTAET

% A%L3mM@Em Erma, ngvn

. :%:a.*:: xzga, flaws, 22% mm

‘.T§3EEFfis.fi1;€fiLiNAGAR, MYSORE Rfififi

R é”%fi*%’i~’%f$§1;f33RE .

, * a;m.:.mK.A& cs»

– aagfat} mmcximca K
.m:;–r:r% :23 YE-ARE: r2z3′:*Rm:*’rm2 mcmmzcm

% H,g,.a. EC}. 93 :3? mafia. mam

E~”»£.fi.Bn QGLGNY; E».W.S
Efififiw $fi’WfiRm£aGfi.R

amm.a:.mm .

©L”””

zae§..%.. mmvma MI.I’RTm
smfl 42 YEARS, ‘E’Y9IS”§’
Egg. $9.391, arm mm
mammmm awe
éifiimmhfi 5:2: FT.

Efi.Ev§’fl’zfiLaC3RE.’

:,.M.smmAmyma, ya
£3 ELIME
zeimmm, Ewmm ms’?

KflEK$GEEE}KfiflJ
wum-{$.15 m Ea mm:

$wMfl
mmmmwawa
I’§I’;Z:6.§.flM§ 4*1*HMAm5~.

M.m&MYmIT    *
wA&5YMI%&€;a3&R    .k 

m§%::m.mRE:_+5wma, ” % %
* ‘=.’.;.-.PE’I’1’1″IflI*IE~RS

my $19,: : ‘V;

ARE

1 .

“mm afirzifi ‘€;};F ”

§’E”S”»P§R§§NCI§72%L E’:EC’.;RE”I’AR’f
1′:”§I3U€?fl?Iwfi fiE%R1’IsIENT

“‘%%’lI$>fi’ mzmmmm

A ;fa}ma*§=::;g;;§.:i::¥R;Ew¢5m:a

%%

c4§»m1c:;§-.L Emu mflfimzq
mR~:¢s.mE~1:>Kxm vmmm

= mNmmRE~mm3z.

MANfiG:E»1!wN”§”

vmmmaama vmw. P*E=E-“‘§’E§fi1

‘ wmpam TR2m’:* gammy

Efz”-fl’ ‘ifiv-B1..£fif;’;;Pi’Z EA’-§J.%’aHNAGAR

Bfifififibflfifiu

‘% ‘VH3 PRRI*C§PfiL
RV. F1. PQLYFECEMKQ
fu§.fi1£=L.L3s:’.i?%LLE
Efifififiiflfifi W

RESPQNDENTS

{BY ma: mmmmfim axaaxumma ECG?)

“§.’%fl$ ‘am? FE’I’I’§’Tm’E§ m FELED:

ma mm 31:3’? Q? mm EGfiS’i’E”.fi.FTI_Q3€€, ‘mi mm9.?%’

mama m 1″31ZRE£:’1″ fim msmramxm «%*:.”fGfILT~§
DESWSE :3? ‘ma A?*PEAL 1E5EAm»*%G’k%H0.T~13;’200t}

mxm:m%;~3 Emma EV “$3-iE””~vHOH*ELEV .Pi;?:_I]’E£:1’PAL

sacammv T-D r::mvERH1mm._”IfmPAm§~m»m%§ QF

mcmxm mammxau, B;fi{£1iCi$hL{3;HE ‘mg

mmamrm Q? ‘I’EC’:I-mE€§.E;,. EI;’.!U§1a§LI’I§£}1\i”‘*,.BANGAI4QRE
mam

ma WRIT” mwnmi %z;:jo2»m{§ nu ma
Pammyam’ H;’:1fl;f§IE§G:TI~fi$’~’fl&»¥’; TI~IE..;*i’.’.m}RT MADE
Wm §?~2:%LE…-mw_}”fi£;’%;§ ‘V .

3:51. %%%s.kmrma3, Eearmenci HCGP is

rmyondenm land 2.

_ ax” ma pammmm ia that may

mgmg %u.,3:8f2Ufl4 mad hm:-e the 1:

mmfiger tkm Biarmtaka Eo:i”u.e&?.:;im1 Act Tm mt”

»;mm mui mt fiiapumd. Heme um writ petition

‘ dfirzmfimm Ea tim rmpaxxfimw E and 2 to dispose eff

‘am eappmmfi. fflmfi by ‘thfl pafixixznam, Ha preju.d¥1c=e wiii he

<71\_V\/\-

cmmwfi ma T.}:’1€% wmmxadmm if may am cfwmwd ta talca my
t1’1ea 1 Pimnuiefifflfiaxid ts paw a m ardm

in acmmmwa Wm Law and £3 expeclitfioualjx as pasaibh?,w _j
aw 133:1 -am}? tmm mt lama” fiwa £92113′ mtnnths ~

cw uf1wmpt.::afr::mp3: rzzf thifl wciar. é

fivfi. ii-:=’.:;’=’: ff
mmiitfied an file mmm mi”

fi.

,,.,Ww;,…

«ME      §    Judge

 8aK%di,  "  '

mu m. nun. _n

.—.4-. n u._nn. an- -_–nu