High Court Karnataka High Court

Gowramma,W/O Late Swamy, vs B Manjunath on 10 November, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Gowramma,W/O Late Swamy, vs B Manjunath on 10 November, 2010
Author: B.Sreenivase Gowda
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNz'iTAKA KI' BAI*?GALGRE_  2

BATEE Tms THE 19%: my 0?' HQVEMBER, 291:!  Q 

BEFORE

TI-E Henma xsmausmcz    

M.F'.&. NQ§_446I 2009 ' 

BETWEEK:

1.

5*

 

2;
  " 119$ H01' mraw, Na. 1253,
  I<:,p.1='.es,LYa.§

GO  WI (3
LATE SWAHY,
AGEB ABCFGT 28 YEARS.

. seuxmaxwg n;om'm_svz;é1$;?g~V:I: 

AGEDABOU'I'6'£;E'_£5$;~'_   

AISEWARYA, cg     
AGED ._ABC3L"'I'----3\    .  
mm  sm'é0va*r;A,
mm) mow   '.  
$I}}}3Alߣ!%,., Wm  aowba,

awn AE£§Z)U'1' 61  _

.}LLL .g'm_  Rgfiir  . V ;§nAfiAI..LI mmam,

B;::+_.1=iJ1e;tw.J.HAa::E.:J; ._§&}1LLAVfiLLI "1'A.}..I3K.
 APP}3LI.A1?I'S

   x.ma}2e:mAsHEKAR & LAWYER8 rm', A};}'i1'S.)

"fr.-.me§§;:UHaTH, 313

B.QGA,F'.'FA.5



2

KEAR €'.tAf!Ei3AP.£'§.RAfl$HWARI TEBHLE,
BEGUR, BANGALQRE $GU'1"'H.

%. mg Jsrvmmzqm, MAHAISER.
THE oamrritaz msfimncm :39. 1:92.,
nIvmmzm.. oypzcm Ema,
fla.22, v,c.P&, D.v.s~. Ram,
maavamaunx,   
EAKGALQRE - O4,

(mam. a.§A5vJATHA1§ARAYAKA,ALw;.3oR"£@§ .   
H{}TICE m R1 9139324339 WITH w.,3;>1*.2s. 1£.'z.;_2_(3"1t_}';-e; L

mm ma mm) U13 ;'z3;1; :3?  Ac: Amman" THE
Jursemm Am AWARD DA'£'?1}:. 9*1;2wa%[?%PAa$ED EH mic
2«:o.3a27;2os5 ax THE FILE as THE xfnjABm.1'gr:I3aE, mew,
Baxmwas, PARTLY gaimwfis *1f:m'  EFETITIGN $93
GO1fl'ENSATI93N'  sfifima  _EI4Fi~I.A,2%'G£h£E2€T GF
mwfimanea. "    "   "   A

mm   Dfl"§fiR Ammsmfi THIS my, TI-IE
aoum nsnrvmamg. mEVvm;mv§mc:~:-

"Ja9§&nnr

 %%%a§m»[%&:  j?§._ by  claimam for mhamement of

 stuzza-n:a;paA1*51is.':»..V_a%:':_:_._::§ 'E57 rm Tribuxxal.

  2, %:::.amj%§%%ji2;.a apgmx 7m aamlma ané mm 113$

  aftim  caunsel a  fer the particsa, it im

% y  w      aispmaz,

6%

 xEs?0H%fi%::ez4g   7] f  %



 

3. Fear the sake of mzxwnkxme, the fltiw a.t*¢

réarred to as they are $1-ad to in the ciaim V

the '£'rib1maL

4. Twbriafiiacwafthscase:

013 29.3.2038, Wham the    VA

ethera Weave pedastrians and  

--- Machxmptlra village inwards     H

to sum: 3: fimcsm,  Ho.KA 51-
5553 came hf:   and dashed
diwd on tha sygézt.  twa mizrmr c}n'1drer1 and
mm mg a  rfbefare me man', mgalom

 r.¥é§§nw.§z1e:aA.1:t"nxA:§.""6£«"Ra¢2{)390§fiI}9I-. The Tribunal

% awafciefis'13:f;;:.§§fv¥€z;§..'3572,00O{~ with interwt at 5% pa.

V 5.  is £16 dispute Wding death at" the

':i..;'.1na ®d mafi accident, nagfience and liability sf

 the afimtdmg vvemcke, ths my point that arisw

H '   --f::x"1.:§%V'§i=:3::wa?r1.era'£31€sn in the apfil is:

%



 

the income of the deceased has in be deducted tnwmth 

personal exponents. 'Ihn multiplier applicablau to his age 

'16'. Thnreforc. the 'ban of dcpencicncl"   

Ra.5,'T6,000f- mooouga/4:12:16) and it   0

H5, 12,000f- awarded by the Tkibunal.

a. As RI.60,,0OO/- m.a;dm1_.»0::3§0"0i:ha0.0_1&ujsum1Mvimder
different heads like 'loss of  of low and
aztfection',  of .§.':at;at¢',    and
'transportation of dagi  amfi  there in no

scope for mhafiéémczifiz   

9. mm,   entitled for the fiallowing
 X  ..... 

 - Rs.5,'T6,(}O0
b] Lo1a~o'ofco'm"s:-.rli11f1?i ~ Ra.15,000

 Loan' rgfjhflection - Rs.15,000

d) . Lona tifeastalia' - R:.15,000

~ :5}.  vauflbaequiea -- Rn . 10,000

4:   of dead body - Re.5.000

. C n C - I I u I u - u u u u D u .-

TOTAL Rs 15,36,000

. - - . . _ . -- - -- . -- 4 _ -- . . --



 

6

10. Awordingly, the appeal 3 allaww in part. 

§udmerfi and award passed by the Tribune} is 

the extent stated hwtfixx above. The: claimant» are   

a total oayzsafinn of R'3.6,36,C¥J£3§_-_j   

Ra.5,7'2,000/- awardfi by cm mama: Wm. 

pa. an the enbanwd eompexmatiuri  %

date :31' claim petitian till the clatgz of ::»,a}$t£§~.tic.:;. '

11. The Immwmeef  '  ?"_._  dapeait the:

enhanced comperx5is4'§n!§eL31:{""a"":nn--__ :  t within' have

months mm    {if this judit.

 12. gaf  czcmpenaatinn, Ra.25,{}flf3f-

ea.éh, fijitu if:tm-m'A t is amazed ta be mm' ted in

   cf claimnt Ras.2 and 3 wim are

 1- ehildrmi'  the dacaaseuzi in any zxatienans ad

"  Ba11k[F-'oat Gfiime till they a1:I:a1n' 

  with propcsrticrsatc intarmt is -mrdezmd ts

 'f5e9':re3:=-g ' 1. éea sun fawn: sf c1m'mm 1333.} and 5 wlw are wife

 .

amci mzather of the: d%eci in equal garoporfion

after the depusfi.

13. No arder as to costs.

Vak! –