High Court Karnataka High Court

Gurukripa Beedi Industry Pvt Ltd vs The Asst Provident Fund … on 23 June, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Gurukripa Beedi Industry Pvt Ltd vs The Asst Provident Fund … on 23 June, 2009
Author: Huluvadi G.Ramesh


w

” ,;3?;’::§:i.§§:–Ig is igazfisig $33: <'2r:;§:.::~ zézéiéii 3{E.i.2iTi%§}{.'% .':%§'&1*Z§§;i§§'€: 5% fag' gas E

:22; '§'§-£5 2-;:;:<;+:~»: <::J;:..:';:.s:"z* a;_:~»' §;é-a.2:__:*a;;a'::.»a:«;;: 9;; §T~:A;xf:';A:%Lé:}:éf§;-,T: -.

'§}2aia*§ {am iiw :3" {$3}-' s.;sx§:;m 2£:::';§.–f*

B–';:§%:a:"s –

§:?<s§5 §g£}_;¥'§g,§5 ;%.5;% g':;;§:5{f;? §§:§s:i;'§i–:Ts%;§: E:;.

§%?~i£ Pgiigifin 255%» 2&3 {:3 ma;

fietweeris: V’ ‘ V’

{.§%,;§’:3ie;:*i§3 Bsaéi Z:a{i’::s’i:”§;* E3″*sf§ “§:.:_§

Regé, {;>;§’i”: 33 2~:?w.. ”

iE:»£:;i««::2r:§ Bang’ Eaiizzizz Raga

Eiiarziwgé ;2?s; 21; §:3E{ . jj _ ‘V .

333′ $3 §}iz=a3ra;:i9s’ R E?}amé:_{£Zi:.,3;:’ E;3%%mr:»:§29£z%*§:ij_’~. _ ?s:.i§{z::’z$§

{éfifix K E~;;a:§i.§’3a;:*;’;/b _’;1’§j3*.%Tf€;fi;*:se§-.:f%;:’.:fL E’-;s:£§é.$f:;r.§..;’%:§g£’s.g A{¥;”s.»:}

fiztafiz “”” H’ M

m

E. :%;§s£{‘ P:’s>1f%¢§{:;;€’ ‘i?;;:”:»:§ V %:.,’i§§_¥i’§§?§;?$?5ii>§’§€?E’
E£§’§§;?;§§jsr’2:e3 E*:j:3%-daéiii ‘E’?-s_2§§?»:§« ‘€f}:*g;zz§2.§3a§%m3
E?_eg§i:21_;:iA{}§§§¢<i; ? .33 §4§ég§2E;zz1s;i§;

‘ . ffsiixsa Eég; E&::§;a::gs§{:»a=:2 3’33 8%}:

V’ Ra:-;:mz2.e:j}» {f;%§E§<:»:i:€* ""

.3 C3133 Elmjgsfijyees Pr—::+vi<ie§:§ §5:1¥§<i§ Sfgafiisaiian
T _ R§::*g?_.;i§);"%éi'§ .,§,1?§§%:::'g E' B 5?; Eiégizéggzaifi;

. Si§’§?3~R{§e.{§,vééziagzgfiiafe §”,?§ {§£;’£,?; E%e%§3~§3::5§z:=§:§5

:j;8js;*’$ri ‘s§_§§3’yfa4–§-Eanagsafiéfigadfi Agéaszé

A “§§’:%§ €¥§§%; .?aE§?é:”;s*2 is féiafi i§Z’§i§i§.’i” ._-fi.:133{é»:’ZZ? é.§”:.& §:{§§§S§i§i3§i{}§§

f”if3§.-ziziiii 3342 $2.3 €:”§’é3§$”i” éaéaé {é.§«2€}{}’3 ~ ;m”;2.:.::::;::m “E3 E3; fizz: 253$

f§§S_§’I*3§§{§£§§§’

Eétiéa ‘&}~:”:*é.’i ?:;$i%:i§>§3 hgaviizg §7§%.i%if-§’: §@s;&§2=’€é ii}? {}§’é§$i’§ :3: 2?.=§QZ€}{E§§$
iiifi {:C%?;3i’§ §:2;2.:i3 52$ .§€}§{}i’£§E?gZ ,.

EM)

{}:’€L£3};?R

§3::€i§§£2n¢s’ has saugki fag.” qziashing iézs :::§”§r::r -;§éss;:%V ‘ SEQ

égsisianf P3″{}’§J§{§%§1f Fzmé €e;m:’z*:%ssi@::e:’ i}::~’§%*:’};5»?,§%.}i,} – ’95;§i§1::7~;:i§$__

1

aim ihe fsrfim’ iisisfi 6£9v3£’2é;3§ syznssfizuzf-E} éééatgefi T133?’ E

Pr=.:avi{%e£:£ E51::”;é :§p§€:3E.3i:€~ “i”:*i}>z1£za§”;é;1¢3€1~.§¥*:¢:= miss? gxf. ~{,,T>:’«:§a:” *

ézzzezi 1<§.i€i2{}{§§ annexure E: ;33§seti_§s:§7iE:¢ 2*€:g;$<§m!'a::i. 5

Paiéiééfissr is a E66-éé ..gfré.':z-6213?:-%;cE1.i§*i:':g " %%_3{E;z§"irig-" §.'Z3'§2'i'E}g 12%} fifiiifi 3%

Efiiai and E.3¢%*:é§§;s féiéééig 2*.;.§t§fg.%_§;_ %Ez§ '}:'s.§fij'TV§_S:"i.V§'ié3f§~€}»E';.' 1:;:,i;i§i=';;*:;":p§ix*:s§§-36:3 ?r:'3v§<%::::§

fizzsé §.:égisnz§§,:'=Sz;:§c';?-. J-i'§3§°1a§.3.§}§"fé:'§{;3;f%"4§%'1§~§&§'gé3§i??$.~: Z'}':€r«.i= §'%;/'33 33%} ii} ire

2, wage 1V§::v%3i:}§:'{;i;';:i;§§§"?é:f :1-s:);iE':~._%"_z$zae.:% afiiaxz. 323$ 531% 32%: Efiflii-S fig: };é%.9.19F}:'§
as $532' Ei%z§"5a$%:£§z%:3*:é;'3.§ §f:?::§V%ée;"-zfétav.z7;§§m,§g§é:§{i€’3 izazzéuééixg @353: pa}: Efigéa E*£RA.; !é:%::a§

a§E&§2s7;«fi%,mis anéi Efirafa §§}p}§€I33¥f§§£ ta 3% giaéf, fiépaeziai &§fl§’%;’3!§§33:’§

‘afi%:§é:é::s;§:%&:%a§;*as gjxfsfi. W3 caiiaiiz €§¥§§I§i§}}?%$E§ Whéé §’>;2’€i§’§ an %;%:a miig 2:5 9::

=$.§’2€,-[{§2ai5Ae ~:*§f’~:a.5e5i<:§a.%§[;:§fa*:§ mu Ei3.;'%,§§§3§ as §£¥' §§'§4£ saiiéemesri Ezsmasgz £21:

ygagiggamgfii é;:g::*;'i:§":z3 Eanézm 'z,:::§er fiifiii} 52? im iitaézégiréai l{.'§§s;§3u§:s; Ski,

V.,,»%§§;a:}§*{§%':*gg i3 £332 §w€i¥.iG§3::.r, Eisss: bsmtiiig Q? iiksz ssaié f§£.3§§§$§'§%i'E'€ 3%: ms:

*3"%sa:i§'a-%:3§<: "ii: £€:§:s'g:a:;:mr§»* saéaff as wag as fiiiiuéifi $§'§'i§"&E'}§:"§ izxziw §£a§3'i:. sen-Yigs

gags; :39. 29%.

11″”

” ‘~ .1. $3

Ls}

;»%§§::;* ‘i;:.:rii?ie;:ai’i:3z§ £§§ :32: ii’-{:si}.'{‘§§§ «:3? 222$ §:3§i§’is:§:e§’ 2t§}:’::-§_%§§2’2:*§’;’.V

.§.”§$§i}§E3{§€$§”zE Eésfi Eairmz §°Et’: asiatw $33; ggaizazéaaé aiisywszma gyaéé éézim §.A,’§3;?:f’?}§%i€a””

Ems 5:2 32:: f§;3;§ii}'{E€3§§ ii:-zr tin: puigmgz as? §:m§?i.:§%:z;§’ fgméh Li;a5’f§:;:%T§:~:.§§{§&’? £§§}{,§

;”s§’m!§§a:-:2′: Eéaizazi s;:§:§:*é7%:=z:$§3;:a:’s 33 iiaéiggxéfzéé £22.’: 23$}-.§;=:§a:§”:2;:§”‘:§;i%’»%a§é% ;§’éEé3*é%*:%§:r~.a:’f*:1j_’

f1{2*L–*.’}*§”§§§’ig it.) $326 §a:$§§§:’>2z:”:r_., mcreE’j;’ sgz;-i£§:’z§..a§7§;@*a;£;s”:<;:a ';:§§:";§«;'V§3§3is;iv:{}_H<.:<::%§:2%32

$§"'E"i$§§jgr'§$5§ aiaéag §'§{}'E §€?§'E'§7§ 332% {E§§'?§§S§%;2 ;:ssa}§';*.§"§:;s§.;¢':;a::"§:1.i'h§.s I's:;'_J.§§;£E'i§, afésr
isiuasmis :2? nikiizs, énquéziv ézzgéf fiai-{E §%':3.,_?;§.€%i'E? 5}' E33: fisséfiaazzt

?z'{:*v'ifi5m Fii§'§=t3 £T<::«;r:g'ar§i;~33i€;a:fa:@ far $%*§zéV<:E'i~~:§§§%a'::;%§§r2;; '$¥a"a3i'€$ féiaaéfi

_, , ;:a':§§$§§3:é'§:€}f1."§ a:.:'€§29ri§§*' as fiat:

§i’}§3’E§ :>i’ §):#%:ri :’:.:E?3′:3sa H? csé’ {iris 3§’i§é3.i’§’3.t?§?’§§’
a’Ea£e§ 35; par ::.§3:25§s E. Egg’; zfii.’
€332 .}f§’§§* ::é?,’§'{§*E.;€~§i£3§’z fiégzai 33}; iiw §_’}é§?§”E§£}§2%3%’, 35%

%::;~§§§;:g«;, gags §:’zs:}i.:%:s”_>; ;:e;a.::ss::sé._a317.§”:§?e.3~::’ as gar 3-3’51’ 2;} itéi’ iirge;-: Efi::§:§s§2″§;2§ Efiigpiiiséé

_ f£§§,f%_i?:€}%}j{} am? iiééemaéaeé ‘i§’sr:: §EIi€iiS §33§’::§}E$ by éitai’ §¥3€§§§<§§'§E$I" 3'; £32;

.,:%:2;*«:.z:'s§'2%i 5:3,? "§~s?;?1:,'?:€3{'}'i.§§:§5= '£{}'%'e'"§§'§rS <';csn%;'§.%:::iéi_::2 agaénsi whézzh agpézaé '@533

fiégéfi blziiéfiraV%'§1é é?:»§5§§E§aE€ ;'%.u'§z§§x<2r%.%fv'. fifififiiéaia :%1;§§':s.'se*§?f5 Mia? .%::.::a:i::g 'iha

§f§3i"5{§$*3=§§," a.f§..2E§:f*§;':§a;%§§s:§; $2: gggrsafii 'iéjg mafia? {§§§§€-§ =:§..Z.£}.?;%;'%»i§E; ifiasafi $2': aaaiaé

<2§*§:::'_,L–.'_@:': é'¥a:a:e§a-éiag ma §'§z”::. $333 {?~:)i.::’%:

V’ iifgifig; zrarézmsa g:°§::::z:§:’~;.

{E33 %:=$éf’:;2if 52%’ E33-§§§§fE{§fi*§E?§’, széigegiéam Eagreza E”::”:z:é§§§§{?§’!@f fig éigbés is gay ggrawéiiazgsi fismi s:s:m%r§Es1s_:§é3§§

gm;-‘;%;;%g

maéis is em§;§£>§.-*::<¢.:-3 §€3§~%"£3;:'{,§5§ sgficiai aE§i:2§::§.:.'gg§}zm:Ls:£.’ ”

…%

§s:::* ¥”§@I¥%=~§%:§§é§%:§§fi?f”é :;;§§%*::: §)§°{:*»;ié$§’:€ faasaai s.:i:.;;r:§:%_7:.% rim, ‘;:%,0§’ég:é”:°s:a§§ § :’«s:~–=:;3e%2;?T;’:>

ééag pe$:i”iii’;n:::’_ Sims §}§:§§?§§§3’£a’;?§” :i§§;;:._:_:3:§ fiéééi».E:i§:-:’§*=:§éf’jv; §§é::§fa;vi3″f§’ :>;;é:’s

§3§’i€§i’Z§’ S,?;%., 331% 33%;?” fimféng i%’:s2 ;mr€%é:’:é«.§;%zi=;:: aigziéé’ 3g€?.§.2i§%§}ig} am§’;s;>>:2.’§m

,-5%. £33323 E9 1% _§”%§§$§€:f£§ §§SZ’i’§§v§si§.§_§I:§V’§_3’_ 3 ;§§§}::2;§ aiggi gészgiéiiyzafig £32: Qraiéfir £35 izizs

E3 §¢;<;§3z*é%?:.§;« 3;: E-33%: §'{::3:§:}:§;%:§_}?.§§E%§-¢._§§§é;;}é_;§E ‘:3%’Ez:sw22::<:-43* ;2s:§§';£}c.,"%::x:»g:F:-2:23

a§";:::§2,;z::§ §2.3{i %':;; §:;*2§£'§§1*'2a::§":§'?;§5'1'.?f:a: :2?" §.3:i:3Wée:§£ féifié a:;a§;;..:;§;a€%i§=;:
§?.ff"E{§ »::§:*£§3_*§Ei::§'§§3:": §'§§:§'3~:§£}_.'§f§a'f».§'§'iV§*z7a;§§:3 {:3 ii}: gaéé mwzsgzi gfigséii 3:23? 2):: ?:§*;:= Eészgis
fix Eizifi a;s::?:<§i'i§§:'::§.~7<§§ §é:§§3$i§Ei?:§'§§' amsfl ihfi E';%é3§'I':€2fé§£:€§"s:.§'E'i 23%'

::n.:i;§:9§%z:::;i.é1:g, {$29. _Z:"§' :»es;_mam=; 332% {he fiqargaciiats '?:°iE::ma§ §z;%'%.;<: aég§":§.§§:

A &:;:_%:'*;:s: i£% %'§::a% V€::.2:zc2:§3§szi"§§§a§ §§€:::§&3 aiiawama is bassé 13:2 *:£:§':¢ Emgiéi ef

s§;:a:°§c:,:'Vi§§;3i%a*%§%.;_fgezgtr 132%' Qgig, ea; "£"Ef:a 5%" §'$ii§fiE"i1§iE'§i§ :§"s3§<;£_:;t2§ iv;

s:”:.:’:§§£E::;i :£:: it E: aézéag rag}? §’:;§% aaséfééég $25 §X£§1.逧fiéi§ &§€}’5za’E§¥E£€« Ei§’I{§§i’ $.2’_’%a}

Aé:2;§*§%€,:3€. 9%’ §}3}f§¥1£?§’§”€’ if aiggzsciai %§§£}W3§’§C€ is

T.§§§§é:销:§2i T§’s’-ms”; .3323; a:;£§§£i* zlézmamxat as 5:22? §~i*Er{%:rj: am} ii §i}?I§ES fig: gar? £3?’

..’:5a3§§ s2:3.ga. and Em’; :3 :.:§2::§=s§r.: :’$§g$§Ta§2::’.:§’:§.§ ‘i”£%€:§§ émriaz éifififi $.25; 221$ gm: 331% is:

fgaié £2″; 5i$§”§”§§§; gé’ zzgmimaé <§f¥sm§2§e§'m$::°:€,

W

Ca/I

Siméiaséiyt, ;z£§%1S$ 2’*s$:~;as; %2c’i.2a;+::¢:a gr’;-<«:.s*:*§%::::§:::a:'za::": ei:-E s;§:;%j;~'._ §:i:,:;'§

§?3§'"§Y§=§§§§x figs ;%§;§$§§a§@ 'Z{§"é':sx;:§2g§ §':;2g :'i$i§j»;* ~::–:§S§3f'.fi;i-{§ ?:E*:c::2g%,é:";:§§::é§;*;;;:§:§I?z;._ A'

waé; ??za?IE'§i:§€§ 3%: a§§;s::c=§2»g§*;2€%a §'}.«1'§:'§Z'§£:§'§§'. if was; g§'%J€§'z »:ieg}e:_§:§.§z2.g, '?.;~§i§§'§ gm'

E:-£.':g§%é i}§f1:éi=f"'%.s'is':£f ami is géaééi :13 a;=¢::§a§%m:V far ayraaé-s1§:~i'” ‘is:3.}:e;f}=’-am? éiiez

a:m§:;%€>§g’s:2§ vmazki haw’: {Em hez2=::§%% if {Ex 3 52″ iééxaééézgzé ‘z:«¢$::”_ y:¥éri§€~’é ‘§?€§§fi”:.’

efflaci {mm 372% éafza emf iiés iééggmtc :43 §:::’5%*,:1§3i”~§:.33 mat: ri3.2_j%%€§j’§j= éfiizfiiiééii far
{he §il?§€}S8 Q? éééniféfifiiififi. V ‘”§§”:.e saiziéééafzrzii’ fi};’i$*’3-§’€£§ i§:§é§”‘{2a:§%Vs:*»w fizz:
zzzanggzmxzmi 323$ ‘éfzziztm aarmfii ::»v:;f’:*§:§?i3. éizecé p§f§*$%$iQr3’s–.§f $255: égcé, 73:3

§§ea::lséc2n as $9 $’£§’i@5€§fié§fi’.’é:€;3§§§’if¥}i{;I§§¥3I§5&3 §:3″E?s;”:’-,_:”¢:::i;m.;z;;»€x%{% as: a::f»_i p;3’j:m:::§”:§

mask: :9 iféze :m;:%3:e}5t:z%’.§?:%._é:”i:3r §*§:;.._%§ai§r§£§; under 222% ,»%;:;E, mi
pm’ 553:: aiaszszifi Mia ma: g§:i:VE£:tj:”i3é22i”§§§r:%§§2 mm; =£3G§§§’£’&§”_’€ is 22:5 §:;:”::s\é§:;.§@:;$

52%” {ha :;;:%.¢4€.-‘4» _ Km}:-. g:E9.’z;:£~:§$ ii”; {ha Sefiiiemmi wiziszfi :3 e.:s:>::§’;*3r”3: in $6

:\Z§’;”i’§’x{‘”:Eg§Vi”{f:z;:§: Eéi’ the A.»i%.€;§ is amfi hirzéirig 3:: {he .s’£:§€§’a£:§é?:%€$ 1§fi€§§}’ fizis

.,_.’és.~;3 §£1§V;§;§:;rV ‘ffzifiuna-E hag gaass-=3:-d E313 arésr giier §é:.=f:§i§aring 353

fzzspéafs 3:°:§%;;:§§e3″z:§’:é iefmg s”;§’§:i:i£Er::~:;’:’5¢:r’:€ 322$ raiaged éfiiiii-;.%£)§’§E; :33: ihfi §€}§Z’§.§.

gawk, Eaaziaaé czzzzszsei ssaghi €313: §§§:*;.’a§ss;-2:; a:§’§é:a: gyaééiégm.

._ “f>iezs§’§’é§§’s”€ gjiméga fie ‘fins %é2’§’§§}§§§jsg*?e§xiE§ {aims gag? Q? 332%; wzggasfi

fits: {i’:3§:imE§§r;g_§ é5;£3″§;§’§sf.*§”§€§’ ag i»*¢::;§§ as éiza .,%.§)§§t:§»i;’%.%=S» 1-%1§§.§’3;€:¢§”3:i”3:’ %’:52=*i§;g

Ww

gsayrzzzegzi ii}? 132$ §;'<::~:r am 533:: 535:3 :35 ?£"§'2:"::§"- §u;1§é§}°Z1:+%g.!; $::.:§'%:é:*2. .;=~§3ié§ ggtzgzfiii a”a;v*;.}’§%.9:£::’§Vi;:._§~;3:*I %§;%$é; wagaaz.
Saws: spagégi §§:.e,;-étfzéisga paéé’ ‘fig %;s§'”_§:::2;3i4§::é’g3;j§§’§§§§z3ié«i’ :i:'{§”2%3§ ¢:3:§}a§w2:3§;. A
gaiirgs 3233:: <:si' s;g_x;€s.:§3% '§5é::fma¢z:s gzgmzm fszsrm gag'.

zzéf 2.3:: apaaéai aiéaiasvafzasa 322$
fséhaff ?:r:;i¢5;§–§w*€Ais is iéaacz éezzggéé itef fiérwias afifi ii s§<:s:f:$

mi flzgmfg pm $3'? Eiéigég "wags: 3:3 §§; make ii éizaéyies is gases}: <;@;rs%:2*§21::§s::::

' V' _§:m*-:%:"i£§'s §:-'<§V§:~§€:;§ fimé; aziega-*., ii éasg iii)-§ 3:33:23? éiaims is: $3 aéiampé

7£:a:*i:§g:r:j";;3e;§.$ §@ 5s:;=%;;;§§:=i: Eéaiziéééjsg ':a§i;;§:'€§$ pa}Im2§2i' (3% ;:is§;§ré?£a:u$.§::§1.

.;%$x. pm' §§':€: ififfiééi $3" S4'$"§§.§§TE"§t?3'%'i,3 §a§§€%<}i*;£§*"'s :;wa§:c;: wag 523%: z::§e:@ssazé%§,=

ii: figs zzérmafi w1:rss:= E9 $€ {Ef ¥i%fae'”§f¥’i$§’§§ £3? a:z§,%§ z:m9a2§*:%’f:é§::as{ g::;12¥§’v.::§’–%:za§é;:

wag-2′: as nasnagsmafié £3 §§3§.?§éi $1: $33′ ‘£;i§f’£”1§§”‘§£z?%3i§.’§A:’§Q?:”§”‘r§§§*€;1f£1§§ ;r}s;E’%3-‘;_i:§§;»§:EA

faizéz ma fim zzaié fiiiiérefise cf ar:3::v332*:T’§.-¢_f§”‘i*;e- C¥$:z§§é:’§3%ng ;5£13ff:f::§’i£faf aség Wézi _

33 ;~§§;3e§;ai2:: A13’§E’3a>:”i%§-* ham: cemrfiiéfigdd at: ¢:’i:*9t- ..§:;’:::s§:r;§::g ii} Séiiiffi 2
ceasiusisga :32: ihe E23523 i%2;g:’?;_:§§::}::.raf_i~«g§’§:’i:§ a;:2*:¢3é:::§ £3336 fzrmas gm’: <3?' sfie

iazzsic ivaga-.

i::”%3<§2:,€., f«s:':x:::trs::§i§:g

;5*g§i§§i€3f’§’ii§~’, 3,.:”:L§§f is sci asééia 332% ii 25: éwié
p V’C”””‘ , _ . .. ‘ 9° g€’*”_.”‘{ €””§””£\’T§M/Wm T _
T Oibc fa 5_¢__.£ a:{}§:Z?§§}’aEE§:3%’%$ {tar §i’,&”§-‘ =33 :2:;3%..*>r;::;:.§ :§.E.E::va;a:;c:s §T3Z},.§{% <'§e.:§ mi” §§>§”:*;: gum gé E2333:

2 ‘ _ wags? :35: is i”i’%§§sZ§. at éaaéi-is Ear §${}E§§r§§:%ifi’§é}§E %{}%%”§r{%$ §3r::_fi«’.:é::=n§ fésflait
F$&7gUw2;$ _ . I _ A. .. ….. ..

‘ . /§§{;»£¥,ii§§T{§§§?f§;¥}’_,§%§5, §§:’.3’€ié§€::§ ég §§§$W2{§,

Sd/-=
Iudge