.¥;N ‘.E7§”‘£Ef§- §”§I_:1’§§§’.3 T} s: :55; ‘:’m%: (32% IEAY {E}? E?§§;:3’3§e:;A§%’y1:.~«:2,I{§ ” ” V
PEQESS E’
‘H–§§~iZ E’§(‘}E’~»;?’¥3L,§*-3 MEEJ L3’ST§.£’:E£ .:%s54.:»::1;”ix§%:}i;:J5€’*T >4 A
AN D
*1*’z’»-“$7: E—-;ei?>a:’131,.:’«: MRS” JU;E§’§’1’C§*i £3 .”Vf.fiAGA§%;5i?§§~*§;N;’§
R.E7′.2%..E\EG.?’31*-«§E¥’. .::@0′?*– V’
B£{l’I”‘WEEi’N
E,
AN?)
{}}E,}R’ij?”J:’%.’i’f–I §?.E%)§3E)’;’ _ Y
s;:’> ‘~+.z£:,.:-: }<;.?:':'A :+<§:«:::3:3'~r
A :.3: wfgézmés, _
€.’)€f.:{‘.i. ;.sx A1,) :’«_:.1 {H
:’3:s:=;:*:
{By E%§:”3′, §€. A.. ;;;f2_;<x{;t,' g5%.E}'a.5_{,}{fi?f%,&ELEi}
:~§£~§.%"%_»';~:a.%,é_N’x1_ V’ ‘
513%) E13;-fiat}–{A RE:§1?si:2§»’f ‘ ‘
;~’x([}i?:f,¥f> ‘:’E%ZAI~’i:?.~}, ‘
:.:<;,, Xi}Rii.fUEfZ'§f5E*3.E§;
.. «:3; <3!' :3 'E?~£<J<}I;'–7'€£§,E.A{§EZ
V-v..'(£'.l!&§E»'-:fi{',;iE£4 A.
H , §;3§,~;-‘:<;;:1;z.;;';m§:2<';_ga 22:2:
– ‘;.:ra:I.;:*.;§«<:. $3..
}AM- .. ….. ..
},=é.:’is,s:=
” *§i’7;§§~:~’:’;<: ;?§…?Z,E:.:,§;'«'*1.§'€€;.i}..»*'-"a 22;.'
:4: :i':'x:2::.¥; .:..:::%:§. 2.; 1, :='2’z :32:
E2 :%;§e::a2;:a:::,2;
., ,f’2.P§”E~Z LE ,z”‘aNT
, . L1 §i;§?3§fii§3{f} ?’~§§}E§?’aET’§’??§
was g;~;’1:’1’1.:–>:.§ in >f’°z=,w<3z.:2' <13?" i:E'2e-.% pI2:2i:'1.ii;';f?f E3}; the Laiiii
E%ef1::”;:,:.E by <_:»r'._r <i2m:€i 29.2 3,1€~3'?E.-%. Ti1.¢:35"~:s;1id
§”<£e:" E"22%..';-.: .2-u'.i2;-z.im%(i E"i.:'121I££;:»;. in \=".i€'.'€.£–' of '£:%1r;jV….23..;7".:s:i':5§;;2it} 3
gram? GE{.}i'{.T11§}£i'£'}C:€ E"igh'€.fi-S, ;:)E2.:%m'i.f'f Clzlixxise; tififafg; h :%'»i:'= 3 i:E*:€ _& b
eX{:h.1si'v<:i= <::w:':::&2" in p<):~3sex<:;si:’: eff t:.hé’ smit. -1 ‘£z;:::j.<E., .__ {)'V§:1:e.
Ye1.:11ei;1e:zy;«*;»:., :'<';»ss§f Ac§}s::’_ ziilscé’–j;’1§;pIi€£iT.:§?.;r °gi°2m5t. ‘Of
0(:{31.Ep:i¥.I’}i.?}” I”i§3jhIZS:% t,::T:.dé=:1″ t.E3§: L’*;;g§”{3av§:sEGi:::5_ §§§§{%21b21&
Abaliigicjsx f §n.::1m xx:*2z:%v”Ag§i;%1nt€d in
hiffi f}a;«;::2:i E?’7§;:=1.i;V1 i.1E:”£” :'”;_ af ihe samse
prefwrcrci ‘ ?\i;z1:*§12:t,221{e1 App€Ei_;::’E:e:*.
‘E’1~-§bz.:.r1::%5§§’.”VV by E53 z}rde.;« daizieczi
29.3, E§}v§%é§ig-:.§_1{‘3xafl:V§§’.V fiictd. by 2319 ;:;i:5:i:1€:1?f£Z ‘LF’E1=:%
331:5 _Y2z.:’11azé”;:;§g§;::;w. T’r{§s:r :33′ E’hr:’;’i
i_3f£’E:’3::_.:’:V§2.’§”*~§;:’ §?%?$_P,N{;bEé%E%€}2f .1996 E3{:i°:::’@: i’:h;§<%:~».E~§é;,{}§2._ éTT:u;*%:’. Q? E~i;1;’*:1a»fi.a%.E»«;:;:* Thfi :e;a;§d avrii p«:’%'{%t.im1
§::;=;–:r::3:£=%.+”£<3V{:2}?'a:'E§%a:'*:'1ésss;%:::i mi; 4'E%' E§}§§€~§. 'E'he.:se, E:h<=': {3§E;'z.§i'E3 {sf
_ €:h€:: :.<}§a1Z::ie:::iaz:2zyj§,r22 <'%am<:2 in 221;"; e.:'?:r:.£5
""§'E/':9 t:%zr:§'%=;3r:{.E2m§. ?*§ £1}? §;:%{}§;<;z:_ {>5 3%}?
§24;§.§’1<i§ it §é_'%':'1&:'iE"§'E.?:§f{fi§ §;.2::§':<'§ I::"i.}_"1{.'§ a';{i:<'::4zg221:3{:}«'
b€~:-rhafi" :3? 1.11:' i";m2i_i}.;' 2.-1n{§ 2%); '{':}':€ <z%1':i_4i.r:e' f€EiE11§}}7 0%" pi.21i:2t.;'.ff
and <:;i<~%fm'1€é;»2_;":":. ?'€{'}. 1. "i.'"E'2:='3 E'’£’ E::E’2<:=. pi;ii;":i:i.i7§' E11132" i.%:{: <:?.1':f;i:':;2 f'21m§.I:»–" %;7:a§?.£}_)j:*{:
' Effie" ~ .
iszxixai ‘E”riE:}’1::-12;} ;_:.:;:s:Ti (Eu: §,,a3’1.{i ‘I’:’i%}1.::’3z1§. Se:i21::é:~» .if1.é.-:.g.§:’ 136611 ”
pi&%21:ssc;l”.i,15′:s i»If; ‘£j;’.’a”L€:–_ :<:'me«£i%_ ‘£:1§_; :’cie1’ <ia£'<§e:f§ .29. §Cal9"}" f. ,~"'*27§?:.§–:r<:21:f:.<=:.1f°M,
pa:m'::£t:i<.m izmiwa pE:e:z:%.€ in 31¢? .fa:"1i'iiyg21.f:<i §¥.].'€','SI.','£.i'{I Iésfid has-3»
i'.:e1i.Eas;%:'2 :29 §§'1{=;é s~,:ha1":: 52$"-.._<_§'::i:f's%z:{c§ai:';i; ' 1;', 'i."heref<}re, in
View (.3? i"E'2e:='* E';.::–?.:<:«,r.<;;.V._ ii: ":a"3i§Iii<:é<i that the
"i'\1
'&,:i'L.z:¥é'iw?rV €A3i'_'c"".?..1{".'l' i§.£'"3V§p€)E:§$€}E%S§{}I'} <35 the 53:213.
_pE2zi1mIf{ :55 $112.63 5%
Eéifld. M; £53 f:%’;.1 §:}£féT3Efliifiii’§I§’?.§.£*€’-_fI §’i€3 j:=::;uii’ iamfii. ‘xwzs-:e joiafi. fiszmiiy
;3rc}pe:~r’:”,y ski: ;3E:j.2§:’: iiiff “.:;:j::<j£ " &:3;.§ffé;%.r1<i:4::1tT N0. E ,
3%; '§'fE.':<'== p:f":{2g%£;%z5:i:§i:::;,{$ §X'},iiZ§::l':'iZi"I{i E3}.-I YaIz:a1z19nrva whiziiz
3.:§};§£’,33.:§’1;:i’&:i’§II€if;’:§}:” :t:i:Emé:’3amid; in f§E§.:’2_g; :3? the xvriit ptiifiizm. by
19i_E;1¢:- .__ E.}:3é’,§2é%=::i ‘§:.,?i:’:5 Efifiggh <i:<:mm. is 2:.d§1"1.i§:i::=::i) 3:: Es; f:.1fi."§2<:~s*
_ 4:02':€:.%§:'m:ia:V{'i. 'gfifz-:i2'::.':'_§E.7£" .::::':::§ e::§€f<::2:':e§;2:.:r'zE'. E\§'.,?; 1%?£?§’€? $ziw;::”.Eé.ng;* in
V%’VE”;ts;?::’%.%;I:.:’z’1v=i’¥ E:}c.::2.:’z:_ in ‘the .s:s;.2z.éd ;3r, pig.-wzigéyéf
<g::{'%se;2:..i::=::<rj€:<%i.~:%{'§ :°<:gg2.1r{E:£:':;§ &;21:Es: aieéézédg
" V<}%f$:é:<..%':2E"'é-;%{:'§ E2}; <,'§<-:%§%;%:?;s:.'§;«.u1'i ?'é§<}. '3. E"; §';»:2.r:";'%L.:.:' 5:? {§{?§{*?'r'E{f§2':}"3§. .i\é"<i:f£
?%§.E§§ E2,:§::,E:<a "§'§'1<i% §3'§2;:;'%::"s€:'_:.E'f Eéma
gm
3-M»
D-vu-1'
me
A
g-/'WV
Au-n~""'Y
3-M
("'1
/«A
wort
..~\
M.'
mm
2.:
/’
‘V ” «.'{j.he
fl. LI}-
5.3 §_E}€3?Z ‘E’§1i> §:::<§s._;.:<:;<-4=,f.”{§’1<;% smiz" Ia_nr:i he;:1:+,: 23159,»-<3 been
de:?13Z*e,;*s%:"<?::'i in §a=1.v<;z.1r° of a_ié;?iE?z1<:;Eg.1m N<'.:s.2 zmd c:ie;fe;'i.€1;1.ni.
.E\Tr;3.2 5;-;:im*.{: :_}'1{:-K gjime. 2..1.:”<'fE12ase isg in ;3<)s;sti:€ae:~'.§'::::'_' ;g3«f1':;:§
{::1jym.a:::’:”£ mi” %’E”1.€-é :i-;L:i§. Ezzrid am abse::sIz,:’t:¢’_?<i::«: 21.1%.: £c:s§-gag} azrzii ::'rr€~C.t,.;; !}L_if1’t:’~V ci»¢fé?4z:_’:’s?§_;1’§1f{_’Tij j
has no Ec:;§;2:’:_I rig;{1′:i: or pc3sse.s;.s;::7n is CEa€;jn’i–e3d.. i?E§§¥}’fi?f’f)’F€::; 1.1′-‘*
=:£@fe1’2§E2;2_;:’i’. :~;L1g%’1″f’ EE::«:”‘ d§s:1’1%$$2i}L’_E”$16: .s;*a}1i~t; ‘ ”
E7. ‘.i’iTw 2% a.Er;:E%:r’:ci_g_1§*;.€, flied,Ef:is..°w1;jité:{;r:*; s;iaJ;.emer2f: 3;”€~
£te.r21t:§r:;g; zzii i.fr;;¥e?:’ ;.rTfEE,é:§£i£»:3:V&:§§g*”>:i}f1&t iieférldzani; in
the ‘W1″_i fit’ an 1′ .31′ 23;,_
‘_1m:€:’1cie{L he is the
E:s::3g1{§{%.z: ;,>’e.,2é§<".Ef1;:;1scelf1:% <:<::*:5;§c§c%mt:i{m and he
is; 1316* ai5i'_:=:=s§.1:é@>.z;\;v’tf};::%?Vi.:j”‘;3g>:3is<%$sin Q? the pr’::>pe§”{.y on
“EEK <;3;21i:v 2:}f”;s=*a..;:£Iz *5.1i”£{§ §.§1{?’I§”€?§Ef>F1″€:?, S{}’:3§_{§1E. far d§$mi$a:ai of
.;_<..,'k§' {'}.i'E€" E)E:ii.:":'*§;i*%3f'E";
,§%.«.§ff§;:”‘a_E”§”zf:.__2′:.i%’>rz;:s;e;1i:i ;;3Ea%:3{.§irT:;g;s%.; %;i§1.€: iréezi <:im_§"§. Ems;
f:'z2:'::':.::i {"1 £i":::.§s.V;,',"'§?..§%f':"V2'?4'§VV2'i3"§§% §’.”§.¥;’? 2′:-:<i:’:2’1E i.:%s:;:,:e:ss 22:9; :.m{E€»::”:
5’2? _ E/’?:.:=;2E’f’:a»?:” p’z’:tz§;2:.§[}”‘ g3r«:2::es :”f1<;;: he? is: fifty GE,£fi?'"Z;€3"'
s::.:z:ze:£ 5;": §<2:.:,§i%.:E ;3<35;s;e%s§;i<;:": :'gij";<;u§: §2r:'};3a%z"E:§;?
Q/"§:s;?E§:.::?:" gi}£.m'§': §1'§_f}"" ;.?F{3E,fi£,%3% z':'E':.0;i, $5/55$ €§€'€€i
f'»£z,:s. E f £3 ?~3:'?=5 :3? Z? {E.?E.€§ 5%}. ,3 52392 ,5' £3 ?»§%é§
2
Mrermw
7. am
{:E¥.:Ti§}I?’,? gm,-.> mzff o:n_c.’i i.J()i{}§ {moi z’z’z:::j}{“f’2:=,>(ii’..37zI:»s3 an
zlfw z’ig;f’z§, Q[I}’z.e? ;3§.(1frzi.§;f:f”?’
{iii} E’i”‘§’::%z,f’ze:>r” fin’: pZ.(z:’;1£’§gf’)” p:°:3z:§a; to 5;zg§§_’..fr:g”§j;_;g%;’:,;j ._a;[:;'{
;_?{‘zz:s;(;>c:! Z32f.€.?¥:]€’I”z”fz<:z" ofcgg/éz'z.eticz.*:I.:~'; p#*QL:é.«. i.i'z(1£.' cf:§:i3;:z*2'..j'E;?e" ;37c:.:–fd '
is; z'rz;s°’ e:ia§1£::>z’:{/i(}i’z»f;’;:::;f €111?” .. :{:,>’r:z{iZ.Z é?d Ufbf’
<'c.'2s7'z;;2e2;'2s<2 t <;f_=,*:z;'<§' ' jg" – ii? , w k fmm
;.7Ze:f2z'r2z'.'gi;f}f'.~' " VA — 'V ' A
51:5} 'Zb m*:_a._z'- e:;r'c.f;é%'éiyr.§§§.«2cE;2§%6? '-
Adai'§'§.. V"
5;’; $115′;-;gg}=;_,gr 535:5’/;{?’?:’i§’§ggég–{‘5,.;/ E ;§f’0E..?c:”f:§ €::’z::;:£. ifze 3:555’
“”” ‘ §€f}”i’T.{._’A?j.z;i’:I_’1{‘.’&'”.€’.’_Z_’} :’I;VEf2.§”jEé§E6?f’E _€'{§”?’zis s§’:a;re in :?2€_;’?czzniZy
*;2’a.;i.i:2;.23″ é’§’:x%:’–:}.’::’::E-ii:E3; :vE::E.{.fE”: 2;,m::é m;.a.:”§«:é-mi 2,15%; §é*xh§’§:2i1?.s; PE 31:} E342′
i{}:7;’ *%:>_<'~E";;-:5? iii' f:.E":::? <:'E<=;'=.f"<:*:':{:i:a=2§':E,..s§;.; 29"" »:§{é€'m’fi _;%2′::-mé;:i§xj;;;z zmfsa s.>.>;2;22″;’:;’::«:>%::E
“~.€§’§§2J’ E 2-maiii %.%:{:?}7 p:*{:’}:§:2::.”e;;>.::’i E21 :i:_;<*:,::m%:'2_§::5;s 2&4-%:§<':E'%
:'§12.%.:*E«~;.§:%«:;'E ;I':s~: s;-;::»:_E'::'§_:s.:'é'..'=~; E}? E'..:;; 1'32: '§_'i§'":_s'é <§<'}<'::.::":'2:;:?:"2*
:-"s2;1mrm}1"1r;::e::E {mm ting: EVEamiz-ziity w<:–2'c=; :11.a.:°k<?:z:i 22$
€%Xi1ibiE"5-%; {if 2 to (I.f:':i.
iii)’ ‘Wig’ E’.z°i;;1§ :’§ of ‘{.§’1′?§i””ai§§f3VVI?t§§_S§§£2.
{}I”2iI ;;21″}.<'i ('1<}€.'L'§I'T1€"?E"ET2§.I'_'y' €*V§{T§ &::'1<'*.e an .:.'r:i.k§’1»:*::%;’«:§v i:’i’-:§1i:..i;i3é[‘
p1a3′.r2i:if§ has”; ;’.};'<na":'=S$€.ssi;’1. of 1′ F2:-> ::~’.;ui’:: ;>:”p{‘:r’i§;., §§”:::;1;1fi1′,:.i.f”f:” ?-.’:’é?:’::: .é;’;jv1i£<::;j§; {it}
p.r<:x»-Ye? 1'E':2:1'é. ?E'1a'r sszzicé iitéééci {i2}N;:e:i '5=.,E3. ZV9§}"?'i::s,_¢£::'1iE afind x.n:)id
and Em-:f'L€'<?:'¥,.i:?at {H} £,§'1<;'-3 :3? (if Eiififh 'p.E_é5:vi,1;:'£;fffI TFIE'. plezintfif
has p;'*V'<:<.% that. A.{f{€E?fE?:§'}Ci§1:'.1?;&3:uh}2i"g't:% <iéz1i:*:7:'§[. "1§'{‘};>:%:”i..__g;5.3;-1<.i;" *'2.3.:.::%é':.-zii in E16rjfe1gf<1::':<:<%','"%{%1{;": zrourt" fee paid
is izT1.s+:2,.:_£:'i'".1E("fish-':§.é,. éji.cV':§%:%'rj:{f:«:1z'1%T;é:: _' Eli"? 1101;. <':%_m..ii,§<3d tie
{?iC3H'i};':€.':I'"2:'§§i£§V_.s;e;i.”:;-::7~ 2gz:r1«{i”%herei’2:>;’é3; it ;:>rc<3€€k3d {G
dc%{.'r:_"<-::*r;:;.– –§.?;{* @}§"é:§"2§' ;::;2'1:Z:'1"'éT.ii'i*' gjr;:::ij.E:":g_§ d:=:<:E2?;.:"aii:i<f:n as;
;i»:§7C73EE.x'§.}§tE :"i::}VA:€"'i' g::<.:*.:"<%{= fin' _ps;%:":'m:::'1@:";E. iI'iji.1I"i(':?;é€}§'T§ and 2133:)
E1-eiiiig 1:.}'E."€? i*='.;'§§.$;'.T{T§:i§i?€§f%?s 212%': '1m§i amid v§<i zzrgéi §:':€:§'§E%<:é'.iv€:
E's.§§§§f§z:1%v:-*é__§ am: §;;:-22$ _§ L:c:;i;gn'":a~.'t§1f. 23 31:73 C§€:?{TE"{"ff;,'. :3)? E1312? iflrizié
. s;§{;:::"j£; {.i€'.%§"E:r:::z §_€;;:«:.};. Es;*a::°;’2a=-:6; {$1.2 E’1:’:=§€’.E_ fa}? %’;%’_3_~a:>
–, “;t:§>g1><%EE2'z': 15%' a2s;ss::2EE.§:.2;§ %E'1g:~. ;'1..:<T§§.§;:'zz{=%:";E 2-ma'? £:§é:*;.».::-:'<:i::% 9? 1218 "mai
<j%<:3:..::*E E§":{..t– a:':t:;.§<§<,%:¥"'z<'-:2: szm 2'{:§:<:?{:}:*§E {"§:'.:;{“:_?::”T;§::§-2: §§’3.2:~2’§’:
:
fig»/””_4 .. ‘
“.4; ‘
.P<}:';r2_,i. §F~1{__§j§.\; —
piz;1§1′:ti£T. ‘1’.¥”:C:'<'f<::'e, iv:-* 5's:.1E}mit:5-5:. Iihfi? j:.:dg'n1e.mi. ariii
C1E?{'§'E"{.'€' 0:? :.§E;<:-* §.:'§;,1§ g..%<"m:r§'_ :"a%<:y:,:ére;:.<3~s S0 be 59%; a:=.;:1i<i{-_1
E3. §'3:'*:' <'::T1I.?2L ie2u’:1<,?:d (,';€}U.I1E:§{'?E
r<?é;p:1.a:i:-;>.2us an ;)p:>I’1:'{‘%{‘i Eixéf i:}1_p14:g13e’-3d j:1_gi§;’m.a%:iE1* a1’iE%.:§”
cie:i:w:::?.
“Mg. in the: §_i;,;*hi 0:’ ijhfifi £1f%}I’f:?:~§é.ii{}%”‘fiiitf .ffi§§{;é1I
c0m.::’:1”:i’i<}i.;'1é.s§ i':I':2?s.i. :i"§3:* élla?"E3{#i"1S.%§§£%E'EI.i.§OI1
are §?<.:»EE<:ws;: ' V V
{E} 22: {mi %_;'a;:i{s :':'Ijte ._::*z§;sn.zfiigéaijbr c£_<?crs§:2r{:2.z'€;:-;€'Qf'éiiiiéi«as; s;G:,:,g?1Ej?0?'iJ
(£0. ——– .~:E'E'z€ 5(::Es;;§ €;:ecui:e03 by €316 E8?
gt!" 2% deg erz,d0:m1' are smii.
‘ gziézgi’. :.2<2_z' (i §£e?.§{§?:x};ae€£ by {fie zriaé .:?ow"z'.?
g";';z'§_,2 :.¢f:f'E':e:r?'- i1'§'z<§: 5a.:z'z' of Sim p§ai:'::§,{7' £105
F}zziiif?Z.i£f'I'7Z¥:3E5C35E?? E/Vim: {3:"<:€ez*'?
" ""'§"u'_E"_:<': f:':éa£'<%:°§z1§. am r'<%:{:_:’s:§ <£§s»;é;es_e; ‘§’}”.1f: ssutit.
s;<i:he:<:§;,s§.<:?".;.:}:ié;'3<f:*:'}: ismm Ezgmzéa ?i2m'1i;if§°"s f21f,he:* W;-1&2;
<":.:;§é Ef1§."%'.§:i 1.322;: '£§:':{.:% iii Egmégi 22: 's';::e.-t%:'2z-m.':. E§f%;,{::tr 'E_'}':s3 de::*.21=sE.h {sf
ii)?’ E22:_’;i§_°%”:< 5':-3%: :.==-'fin éiéak :«:sa:§§"' E:m<.§ %='£"f.E%§1%;.'.%f§ w§§':.E".; iize
'4"'.V§§{_§'*€€?'??"§"§§":E€'.?'§E3 §';}a'.:a=z;s,':T.:s~;zT= :'..3§ ah:–i E&,:=:':;2:':::'*}; Ezsmx" §.E':m,§§;:E'2 §:.§'2.€:
3.{…mw~
deferidant under registered sale deed for a xraeivptiable
Corisiderz-uioi1_ therefore. IS” defendant says :_is~~.
the absolute owner by virtue of the partit_io4_riu, pa’rtit1cin”
deed produced exhibit .
document shows. the partiti,oJiis
doeumc-:.-.m-, it is not a therefore,
the said document 35 t1″F’3TU’t1’0n
and on that basis it t.hat under
that partition. to the share of
the ls: absolute owner.
The and Is: defendant being
brothersll’tliey this property from their
father;;’t’l1_oiigli “teiiaiie3} right staricls in the name of the
plairitliff, No.1 also has equal share with that
pl;-:i’ii.t_iiiiiii. the said property. If that is so. no
_deere”e- (let:l21:’ii’1g the plaintiff as the absolute owner of
n eritire'”p1″ope1’ty could be granted.
In the light of the aforesaid facts, it is Mi-
~._neeessar_v for us to go into the question ‘whether
plaintiff is in. possession as on the date of suit or