High Court Karnataka High Court

H S Shivashankar S/O Shivappa vs N M Chandrashekaraiah S/O … on 10 February, 2009

Karnataka High Court
H S Shivashankar S/O Shivappa vs N M Chandrashekaraiah S/O … on 10 February, 2009
Author: Jawad Rahim

Sfifféfi THI§ mg 197″ mm {L}? z:~”§3Rzz_.&.;%;%::f:,’*wV2;?c::ai*sf:§ ._

mg HSEBLE ma, 3&2 _’aTE£E §§§:*§é§ g,&gé.–:::§§ ”

re {E rt: 35.. *’§.PrV.4″‘x:.fif
a,§;.,az-2.2»: 949, ;;r….;., U?’ gauw.

man was? 3% iv;’r~'<;'=51- ' % ' V "

R
T §’ags*a:’;f.,;s*&g”:3″§”<;»é§*\:;*; ?:'§T§SE§E: *3"
Q? §§*:i55'a§',1%%g%;'l_;£i;€;3{}§'4E??;§'i;…. E aagiaaa ;FA.{Z."'§'§R':'
§..,T{.'5, g.:.:.;a§;,-*3 ' '

3; 3 $;e:<.aa,$a-s;::~:;s:a
fig: mgr: A
3'§z é ff:

§Au§§a§&%;.

g«~:; :«:;~: :;

A*&§*”wx

é
:v:;:?;:aa
T,?~§fi.R,EHA:R,fia

3
M. $
ms. V,”

w,..’……, Q
5% …..w
mm 3

; as

2%

‘Q. E 35%,

2% L}
a av’ 2*-

E’? ,3:

MW, Wm. M” ,n….g
.. z .1: .. ;.

. aH….§ S. E .

,€i_

1:>”=< Kr-

: Q, _.m
§;§*;i2’§§eT%~:z%g 3% §§’°§%..§’?§”‘%E

E
M5
…u
an
5
Mm
mm 2.»
% mm mm

3., Wm Hm
% Mzm vs; “.3
_a S, R
.3 $2. «mu. ya
mgmw
mm ES mm
A 3 QM é. um Q
1 .3 T

ES”‘{E§ $§s§3§’3″1f’\§

35$} Ef*§’§§ %’*?E§*~§§§§E 33%
Efiiiffiffiifiéfii §§’%’§,5;?*§ ?~*?if,”‘i*§-“§=&’§.,..i.,_é
%is§x.:’§E§”§ ; §S3§:;’A§§§ERE

$12.;

03

M”!

‘£33

‘ ‘ gig

Eu?

3;» 3
$32?

$'”‘1
3:; “‘0
ill
‘E33
$3
3;?

W
5
Vi
:33
N3

gas A
H ,mv:§.;:*r.VV

aim
. ‘ 3″ s E
RE ‘;%?;A, §A’:§fig?é.§ER

K

Iv

1–1
M33

am ‘
{“2

:36 aw
*2}

U3

%€§:R§%’§é;~_”?§A;;5;’f:z§x’s;’e§E’§§ZfiE§'<i::

I’; V

E’:’E§ K’ 1-=”-‘s’:_EEL

3,52′? §’fE§ §”v:”_§”§~§§§£Z’*i’–“‘éS§3 .A 2 ”
*”‘i§’3;T»fi1?’~§fis~§;§-t~f–,fi==§-E MILL ;é§’§§§*§'{:§f;~i;’3} §;€IZi§-IQ

*is;a§«*%:aa%
ax!

CE” W Va 1.”

W:

U:

A as
(“.13
5;

3;»
C}

%v§§éa§s’3:f%g%%§2’%i..L§ 2-:;a:..;a??,:=;

ggwm _
czxyg

$5??? ?*?é%$A?§§aH&§,LZ §§2;E’aE€3§’=’x??fi:
§!§é*%C§-§j5fi:”fi«T .F’4iEf*’§BE;9; .i{5J§*=’§BA§.i};§}

‘:~E2%R§%w§s’%RA,§?a%:’§’a?€§E:’iE

:’9j’:”:”” ”

fink.

Er §3g§2_.i’z3a?\§?%$E§§3:§:??§é

SEQE: §§i§,fi:??.%

f’-‘¥i.i€’**v.i;§€E.’?;55a.§J[*§E?»’¥;B*i:.’fQ, §{L§§..L¥8fi;§,.fi=. EEEBBLE
§”§§%§E§*’E§%§%§i, §?a’z:*’;’%§’~§§E%’%E

W/

«L».

ism {:§§?¥§7Zi$§3.§;$ ‘Es? iézsa eff:-i~r”:i:f:;n;_’%:;:.§r2§§%i’a§;§féTéiséagr fiassfzééa

-:-39$, §§§F 3&2, 3&2, :2§:*=;&,, ?;2§_~,§;s: -=*?e;_:*3,df’~–§. §§ ‘?’f’sz’ee fiea. 3:’: E?£
sgaiisgi 25:3 <r'é$g§§:éef:2i$V_ z%s%::3*~..ja§'§*;:~;V_':i:: r?:;m§%*s%; Efiié away

ii": {fie §a2'<:'2;§%a§_%'2'E aa*.::é–_:s£=.si§f' "?4%é§$; is

2}.' ::<4é'§gr€;éfs*«.._ Vé";é ',.E-Egiaé $3: §:§§§"§'E§§$§§,??, é+Ia3?§§

gégémiiéeég 353?? :;s;2$'Va:'2A:–._e:'-§'~~–'?L£::€;2*::§": siiiag ii is Eaiagré 13$ fag' fifiéi

" " _A§§*~f.2;?.§§:-sag»_§..L§;':.__;*i:":§§§'£§,v ~ —– ~ *

-“:”§r*:;e”_j..f’~:ai%.3§% msirix “£”§2§i””:§§’§i fmm vi-E-ye mm

;:&?;.3§’r§ §fs.>::;é;:;§’:T

%
£32..

€§;.

W’
E;

53??

£’~£:_
ma
rr”€1′
3;.

gm.

:3;

m
«at:

Q}?!
wt
fig!
1:3;

as;

“”‘t
M
g:

aF”‘
3
M
£31.

£11

%.;§§&:;i sf

‘(-2

._§§:§;Ve!s3:;&§% wag: :5 miéfiafi 5?: §$§¥é§§§:$’:i 5:23 $i;”;s:..%§§*’2i

s

gs? &§)§§’5?§1f”‘»5;T§ game anawfiai ha sufiméfis ifiai iééa case Er:
aguegiiw fie fésfiéfiééfiié were igafiicégaiirzg iii: the rfééeetiég

Eféfi i?:&;r’e?’::§e, i§””‘£&’§.f 32% ééaizaie fiéréézéss :3: aiéeasi.:i4§g:a’f;L-sisgaiséyf

far? $::::§*: gganéaéaus §:§i&z’fier:t$ am gimagééigi-.,::E1:é}§ e L’

,:,,£

Sf?-iafsaaiz a§aE’:*:3i&

m. $3? Cfiftifé, fire §é&’§’E”‘:E§ ‘:é::?–?”:$ei f§’:”‘;_ jr*A’éi§?;3«3’r’:=;§é::i1s:–..L

gzsfifiarié fa iffifimfififié @r§fer””«3;’§raz*% $&a§¢;:?a__§”&:i.&::r;i’i§a3§§ 67′ i?:é$

as

.§£§$:jm§é*E:;;2; éfsé ‘?r}§’::f~sa* :a&%’z*ai«vE’fs urgaé ‘mg’ béiéa sides far

fsii aéaéiisi V§%_’:7»s’~.X “%§:V’2;2vi,,$%?§;rf_z’7e5’§ éréef raferanaa ii? fiéfiéifi

flfi

aES§$£%$, *w§*’:%€§”2 §§’&.fr*2£s;v”:_ §ir’+:.§’§s?;3s::a is necassary. “ffze §’§”§EEi§é”‘¥§

Er; 3:1-=i;;s.e$:f§a;:i:*: %”:é5i’::?E«…@%:”:.v Z5-Q?-ZQGE Er”: 1%-y’§§’:ya i-ieiéé is

s.3:5::?’::e;;i2–€,_e’:;§§3,r..%_af”*mafia mewtifig. ii §$ :’:e::si E2′: fiifimiié iiéa %;f:ure$$

reiefasé is E3,é.§§f::2:fi ziizfier’ sE§§3aiu:’& éf aéiused i=£§.§., 2 asrsé 13

L §§*séy’.” “1T§’§é*é megs reééasé iéfiiééfié Eifiiéméfii, ‘¥’x?i”§§£_§”‘§

“..jL’V..:2?::s*s:§§::é is: the tf§F’E’:§§a§?”é”?¥i éiratiiy aficig his fépfiifiiiéfi

* égigfi éaffiigfiag fiig imafia E? E5 E6? in fiififiiiié €313′: aarass rsaia

…:_ ‘

%§ mix? fiigfzee $3: ra§§§r:§$:r’:ts 3 ‘iii; 35 §”%§¥’E§¥’E. E’: is mi; §§’3

/§*'”

E4

:3, “fééa éaax flaw; is: f:*&%2._,a*E*E§g:«:rty.f;.:s?’E:§%§’,§-:2§§@;f’rsa§:§

5§’&?é*!’§’E§ ii} afieva, wfiéiééa’-23$ “‘:§1g’e:asc::*””jrj;~’:§;:,f:

“Lé?f’2a§””‘:Ei?’i”3§;§S ¥’§S?§§;§'”‘”*$’€”: §a§$§§ .u’§:2′:’:§a:’§f;’2’§J§”f;fi%-ggsgratéssn,

W :2;,,:-: Ea ‘:%s€:~i$ ?;§§§iI:§§ zmfias’ :§§.i$§{:E§'”§$§§W_§. E: was aiiéfieaé i%’§$*i

.z~ , , ..

“‘?:%j:a Efisiifiiiiéifii §}§f§ifE_§?’§8 Am: Cass: wag 322$ af iéza ir:*:e?z’~r=:i:e:”

u_.._$.ia%;aime::?: against ihe saéé §’*§’¢i§’§’§E’i”2. fiféxesé €;§’£”¥’E§§&i?2§

ma.

éafare iha éear;-*2′

j?;§§*§§§%::’§{:::é:é vagigiiaie $32 “:§*’:”am §e&§<;%§':§ pzaéacagiéézsé

?:':$ $i§s':§?§r:§ «::<;2r":'-:';'r:§~i;ias:2 wag $3??? is the ragséiaiiérz Se

aagseaifi ans: i§§§TE"é§"§"&, tfiéy ¥*éé'f'é iéabié Ea iise §m;'ie$"'e§

"fie mesa féiéafia :3 Sésgimeé gatiéy bg tiraziea éf the aéausééi am:
me'; 33 3 {E$€;*§¢.,Ei§§E"% ifi i§"'~::*é7§":%":.a5e':%':%%:;gvv s'1t;:. jhe§:fi "§"%:e iegi iii: fégzé
"' 'fag béiuiiéé éE:£a§T§§?Lri3§y

Csifii fiéfiié fig =sz~:%fas §§;""'sv&§§{g::§r;3§;:_ie

'grass raéeasa is a?;:?§i3:3%:e:i iii? i%=:&%~r"zf §?Eé§*' ::a*s"':<:'s§%; $38

5.23:.

$3»

Q.

“”4
(2%;

L)”:

m’

::g:’*
Q
0′?

‘£3
ILTF
W”

HE’
‘J

az:§:””s€:+$£;:&%i£:¥; by’
Enizendasi 11:45:: r
E

?£’E§;}E’ES&%’¥i’ Ema, :”::a§ifjEsi*;s;esi . *ar:3;’

3&3 §5?*;W§§§£;m$ Q?” $&”‘”;i::: I-ES? i?£ ééfanas ygimi
&’f’%”:’2£§*:§£”3:’:, %.”}”f”‘5’1*s§fi:i§§: umiifir i%:%s; *p§”$=.r2S;é:: i3; gs firrés
hiss .. –

§¥”§’:g’:ii.§’i;3i§?.:=;¥’§ €€}¥’EC%i’.*¥’°!”%§!”§§ gay pegrmra §r:ie,s:1::*£§;r”g=r._},’§::= ” ‘

§”§3§’§T}, 52:’ §<;2ma:E2"2§ fif §3a5's.:'§:*§§ Feaséfi iehflaiézezfe _
tfia: 3:;r.:é"2 irrzgmtatéetz vgE§–§._%:5grm, ¥:i':a:»';= 'r§;..ss;:_:af'§§'éé's2~~w "
:2? gaah Eéffififi, is $ai§, "&;:{t:;s1*_§€ in'-.i§é$':3s:es
hereénafter axcagsteié, t;:V_e:§§f3;§::<;v§-~.:§mi gse-trs:.4;'-G3."

L

i

‘O
W?”

3″‘
$3 I’
m rm. ‘:3 W1.

3% :;’2W””” gm
“‘1: 0 W “-2:

*2? *T&E§'”s

avg ameafii
§;¥’;E?§E?§§_é§5§§§§’? «E: €253 §i:”:’:;;:’:…:iai%@:”: is gaéii ii; §”33’£’ffi 3
_ §€::*;.,r.:~*”s remztaéiseai zmiesg that Emmtatéaa
§.:§Er’::;:ii:y £73?’ §§”§d§I?&€?3’y’, ii’: 32% a$iir:*:a”i§:s’: éf
€:vi:%s$$t=$, iwwerg tha mesai aw iriiaiéacizzgai

§~’:ara::?§§r G? 2513′: 9és’.3€2::, <2? iwvers {fie

§"E§E"§€'§§?§'° sf mat ggfssf: in magaci: ef hég C§$'E§%

:3: 5% Eaés aiegiéérzg, élf" éimfaffi iém iféfiii :22' ibai
5 it i::& be tsesiéeased that the

;r:s$?$@_r2, 5:23' 5% :23
fiaazfsg éf £333': §3Ei"S§i"E £5 iii': 3 éaaiéésséiirse siaée, :2:
a state generaééy eszmggifiaareaf as :£§…gmce:fL;§,"'

1/,

:3"

mn