IN THE mam COURT OF KARNATAKA AT
DATED THIS THE <::9'm my GP' 2,<:.:j7 E. A'
PRESENfi'""' M A _
THE HONBLE MR. JUs'riCE 'E}.NA*i'-13$
THE HONBLE Ix/IR.JUS:'I'I_C:jL?.VH.S;KE:MPANNA
M.E.A;Ef0,5'iE8Eflé'GEoE (My1
BETWEEN .
H.sHIvAEL:MAR:’EE’E’E .
S/O HUCIi{IRA’PP}'{“~.._b V.
AGED ABOUT~?.<3.YEA}£:S,"Y ~ '
R/A NO;"I4»1A."j2ND ":*\§2.1z:11\':–,.E
3RD CROSS, KzEM.ALANAGAEz\,.'
BANGALORE E' " " APPELLANT
(BY sRI.éH.E:EA1j -V s:HA.é*rR1 8: KS. BHAT –~ ADVS.)
' NBZXZX/V'EN:'DELii.ASSURANCE3 CO. LTD,
R;'O..»V2'5,»' UNITY BUILDING ANNEX,
' '– A 'MISSIGN EOAD,
»..EAN.GALjQRE » 560 0227.
Ex; ITS MANAG ER
., 2; «MAQKHADEE,
– __S{–,’«’O M.A.MAJEE3D,
R/A NOB/101, MUSAPET,
MAHABUBNAGARA,
ANDHRAPRADESH. RESPONDEN”§’:E3
{BY SRI.D’S.SRIDHAR – ADV. FOR R~L
NOTICE TO R-2 DISPENSED ‘WITH VXO D,é’:TED:26g 1 E E09 )
E’v’EF}% FELEJD U55 173(1) OF MY ACT AGAENST T§~lE
QUE/}GMEl\§T AEXTB AEREARD D; TEZD:€%5/*3}/288$ PASSES EN
M’3f€ ?§O,1Z§54}g’2O0:’§ SN THE FILE 8? ZFEEEE E47″ ABEL.
g \
X C
JUDGE, MEMBER, MACT, CQURT OF SMALL
‘Bx/EETROPOLIT./3d\E AREA, BANGALORE {SCCH~£O.};. PARTLY
ALLOWING THE {ZLAEM PETETEON FOR COMPE}N§3A7§ICN
AND SEEKING ENHANCEMENT or C:QMPEN.$fz;T1Q’N;vrj”‘ 1 ~
THIS APPEAL COMING ON E*Q.R_F:Ngxi;”Hriz§RiI~s::-Tr::S”»
DAY, MANJUNATH J., DELIvE:R:§:D r<'QL;Q.wt.NQ:;;' ;
Heard the counsel for '
2. The aphgtieialthvvheing not
satisfied with the by the MACT,
Bangalore 5: in MVC
No.1354/.2VOQ:4f;_’V.v.ht” r
5.30 a.m. the claimant
was sleeping in thevfiutoriekshaw near Shivananda
‘_ Cij: __?I?5:ir1ga»1t)’I’e.t.._.._.At that point of time, a lorry bearing
‘ dashed against the autorickshaw in
izzhieh ‘j_eté.1mant was sleeping. As a result Qt which,
he etxettzgihed the following injuries :~
i} Left eye lid abrasierr
ii} Fracture anterior rnaciiai & leteral Wail of
magzifiary sinus
iii) Fracture inferior, medial and left etzperier wail of
Qrbit
iv) Fraeture {)f8.f1’I.E:Y§0I’ cranial {C882},
5%»
V) Fracture of nasal ‘Genes and frental process if
maxilla H
vi) Fracture of left zygomatie arch”
4. To Show that he sustained ” ihjurie_é’–jt1eV”relied
upan the evidence of
Considering the nature Of”i’gi.1’1_§tiri€SV”~S1iS’iaiIlt:d by the
claimant the suhilefdv%90,000/–
under the head 368,000/–
towards * v….:?;5,O0O/~ towards
eonveyangee, it attendant eharges,
%’9,0C.l(5 Df_’Hdir1Vc0me during treatment
of amenities in life. Thus,
in all it a\xxrard_edl’ at gm of 32,03,000/~ with interest at
«E555/”5 the date of the petition till realisation.
s:!9_”tl”s;fied with the Compensation awarded by
the trihtiizal, the present appeal is filed.
.3′ We have heard the learned Ceunsel for the
gjarties. T he main eontehtioris Of the appellants are :–
The Tribunal did net eensider the income of the
Claimant whe was a paitnter £’)rOf€SS§Qf1i The Tribunal
did not awarci compensation under the head future less
of income. Therefore, he requests this “euu:r–:Kte
recurrsider the entire evidence and ‘h the
<:0rnper1satiorL
6. Per contra, the 1e.arned_z eourrsei
Insurance Company eonterzds.thatfherCorripensation
awarded by the Tri’r§u.r1a1 .”it’se}.f;is–».’s’en thehigher side.
Therefore, he requests this 1302 the appeal.
entitleei’ to g1a::fi’~é:gr§”p.;§r;«s;1tion under the head future
loss; 0}’ _ir1Ce1r:e,”‘since the injuries caused to his nasal
proeess of maxilla and left zygornatie arch
:3″
~;
due tu~W>h§eh’vthere is disfigurement Qéihis face and an
aeé’eur3,_t hofthe disfigurement, there Carma: be any loss
, efar__ihe{i«me or reduction in his earning capacity.
“?herefor*e, the first point has to be negatived.
8. However, having regard to the Compensation
awarded by the Trihunah it is rzotieed that it did net
/,
consider the deformi’r.y caused to the ctiaimaet on
account of the injuries who was aged 26 yeerre :1 :réivr.t};at
he was unmarried. On account of the __’me’;v~.§ve “J.I:’€
inclined to award €25,000/~ asferiehaneed e<errip.e3:s'ai:i0i':r..
Accordingly, this appeal, is ié::11:<')'w.ed
appellant is entitled re 'er1ihaneed"._eGn§per;;serrion of'
€25,000/– with intevrieesg at_«'AV.6'%VA trie eiate of the
petition till realisatiore L 9
On ef itiie increase in the
e0n1pensé;tVi0–r_1';;.V_we" 'd._ire(;r ih'e 1"r'£buna1 to release the
_____ ,,
5f'.§
23:5,; "
3
m