High Court Karnataka High Court

H V Rajendra S/O Veerappa Shetty vs T V Puttachennamma on 27 August, 2009

Karnataka High Court
H V Rajendra S/O Veerappa Shetty vs T V Puttachennamma on 27 August, 2009
Author: V.Jagannathan

my TH? HECH CGLFRT £3″? ‘§<AP,E\EA'E";f:.KA AT BArq{:AI.:i:¥{'1if"%;'-,T: -_

Qatfirdz Tfxis theft <33}; ::sf.z5;:2g1:=:,~:i: ;3.?¥i;'i:'t_5-55? , "

;3E.?§g ,

“‘¥”E-l’F,’; :»1{:>:~:-‘a:,,§:: :s,«m=..;:J:s~’:*z’-1:115: ‘<;..Vra{:§A§J:§§:§*§+§A«3~:' V A – f

;aFwa$:~:m3:::!2Qs:§a;n "

BETWEEFQ

H V ¥9EA.._IF1¥\EE3’RA $23.9 wzt=:V§a:’1i2s:P.;:~”.A”s::.§-§;=fr?w””
R/AT E§.«_¥E”f’E’r=E€3L;%’;. _’i€f’;&§,zE;”‘&’;?;§€?, ” ~-. j ‘ ‘v _
MYSORE *rAr.1;;«;, ”

MYSSRE. V
smcr.-3 DVE,.figL:,,3Y;_’L,p;.

‘PR3′:.P_;–!§~IAV:?_;T__.¥i*:E._ :’>’§%’:;vL’
ms; 0 ‘:,mf:a ‘ §2,v; §2$;2:»:’%gx:;r_:»’;:2¢;a 1
5?. ‘<3:<;t:;t; :2{:3.:__;':=3§;;:–iziziéy
1;: ,I :;;..-rt;-. }{EWIS3I}E4I§9;’Ey§;3LLES§i
:;:;:}.s«:3;. S1″? -Mair:

Ii S§T1%«GE-, -IN’ s3′;t:%:Asq.ggG;k1;e3
;RAr~2’a:”;;=w.(:;::.%’:–is :*~:’s¢f: 9:253:

* _ APPELLANT
{Ry 4?;-::~:~§’ 5:. 5; Razzp, Am: 3

‘9: T v.’%;f”¢::f:’5*§’%§T=;:g%%::I~;§::-§r~:;:\:«;::~«s;=x

‘-»w;€::-%.;*;:§é:Rap9a SE&’§7,:T”¥”:’

2 F~.g§.éxs;{é§;L ngn R V ?R_fi¥7E{fiS§{
Ae;:;_%;§:r£; ABe’§}”£..}’E”‘ :33 wagg,

“_=JE9:maHanm Sm R V PRm»s:As=,;H

}\.€f}Ei§} .5-‘aB€f}UT 128 ‘z’EAR$,

” ” r~.m:»mm:s;’ sgr; R V PRAKASEH

:’31{}§;*3i.} A§:$€fiUT 2i} ‘2f’1′:.’-.e*§§€-S,

_ALL,- ama $?,!A’§” I’mé'{1:”§28, Rsiwrwris ..i;§¥’éA;T,A
Qi;;%R*?ER3, ‘FELAWAL,

2
“¥'(3¥ ANS §3¥S’i”. MYS{)Ri3l,

RFZS-§§3’Z’J%”sEf)I?;F~éTS
{Ry Sr; K V NARASEMHAN, ADV’ §?(“‘}R R3.

FEFA tsm«:.r:~ U]$~’s 95 (W {:90 AGAENST

MHGEMENI’ Mxifi UFZCREFL n1:25.rs,2€:0ss §>.A$$;-‘;i%”§’
{},$=NO,fi/§;’¥r;§«”_; gsagmii: ANY} <:m., M*x«'snRE:, n:srgus:s;i%$:.{:é"-fiiifét
Sm"? ma: P,M%'¥"IT¥{)N AND PF,RMAFg'Fi;§T'iE\§;§i;«§_?~J<T7TFAE}{i§ErP§ t_??e:::é”1._HEAR’§.%:tj;- 1’*~§~{:’:é.”*~ V’

nay’; THE if1€)iEF?’¥’ E’)¥31I1§’\fF3§”£?§4’_.FV1~–T:E3«§sF?§ ?{i:§’;:;{)xs.!.ij;.~;;«:f;; ”

J1? 34:; M

_ r:é::::3:1s3e§’f’:3;**’–?;§fie §}¥;’%f§i€§5 E1; grasspnstct

ef the afgypfial ‘Em piaintiff q1_:z::=:§@:3:::;9;

“3-

944-:

£116 Wizzgjgnéizt Ci? §:<'.i:£eil~~–»:fl¥<;2LLt E332 wffizich {Em 'suit: fie.

-Vifiifga dismissed 8135; :39 5321323 ma

_§§:€suT;*:t:53:*’-v€;{£e;i:;2:,T:made £3}; the dsfendamig 2 is 5:1

f3GL’£S{1S€’f} fer ijfrza a”§3§;:+s:*.£§a::fi.: Sllbfiiiiifid

E1331: th.:3::..:éi;§j;z xkeasgzz that. Essa’; 1:21:53 ‘ssriai <_: ciaitns

iaif 1.-:”:i%.;%*53fge::–V.%35;V ;l_<é:=:._1Vi'7€"'4'_,r;s'zf<';*_r.)_r:z':?;r, is; net
::::;,£;;Vt1e::i.V ':"'§:::5«:.;:,_<:;g::: _i'£ in t;§t:=:.sK,:* sf
:;a1T:""'-,V;ie.£::$§da:1t N=::s.1 as
p::;;::y§:'f z~zgAA*;é%;jkA%jTT3g§mg:: 2:115 plaintfif mg

E133 "513-..'i'-'i' 5 7i::3 :ic:%:::'e3«:~:-. 211:3 gait of

-} §3u§&13Z!1f;iff E.’€r;,1 jifjy wiring half share ‘§a::::u

if 2113 partvitiozz cjacrrire 9331120:

p§ai:1tfi’fs interzsa. _é_i’:<e:r

'§;i1'8_¥'§5:'§}§§€§:¢'i%E;§'§.Ti',{)ZE cf jmiaslgztiff 11:31.2, he has mat

céésjggiéd zamrgtiiérzg agaginfit the-:: §:::*e:2;r:n'*:".

A. riéféniiants and the giajnfiif "§\Ee:L T: has £1138

. :{:.{3t <:*la;.i.;::€:cE rsjiéaf against <:§ef::n.da:1?:s

2 :0 53 whsreas drifezndzmis 2 to 5 have
::l.3i.mfi(§ their 1;' 32*' share. in suit. girmgafitrfzf;-i
B1311; the: defefidamg i2 is 5 hays 3150 11:3:
fakfin siygin to bzing 311 this

, 2

'-J»

garepertifis of j:;x:5;_r:'*£. faxnilg: an mcgrd and 2:23
bring aiii the mambers ¢:af_§4:1i11t faglziigi r.::13– "'~
I'£3?€2=f3I"€§_; 'Th€Z'<':fC%I"'=53f, {ha defendants 112 ' "
are 9350: mat entitled {(3 claim fer pa,rf:i§=..i};;'

ef £13531; Share in thtz gait
p1'r:.-sszzrzi: suit. in £13.25: a§7,1s:::3::.§"::V _

pariias; "

4; In vifisn; ef the afr;z:’i’:;:{3§{::1tii:3):1:*:e;i. :*§I:.1:,r.r_:::’1:3, the
ma: cmzrt was_§11s§ifieciV i:?: ::%,és.i§;’i:3;3i:1g»..:’;:: Sui’: «sf {ha
piazintiff as :ga::::3;1._ as #:;f;& :.:::§*;.1:1.i:é:v* VHERCEE ‘:35: $316

I’-

dt3f€3!1€13_1}§’E§4 :2 ‘*-1:6’ -siiw: nos _§a53s3:1 i:<:::

disagzgéa wifiifihfi é;a_1<;::r; E3}; ti1::%'t:*Lj; cgurt am: 213

suck}, t.h;i;$ 911:1 it is ééamiaseszi At:

the .:«:«:a31:€:t i:i_1.:£3€ ' -1i'.:3t:i'i:'~; . is viartifl :9 the as 1."::€§L€;_°:1i; :0
I _ '.3 .. F3' E3:

‘ “z:3V,2i;§<:e '":<::-4a:+s*s3.:jgr parties and bring in 333 izigzf:

"'%:31*!.);:sz:%;*';é§§:::§'V sf-_¥:E€1<-3 jzaint fazziil, in thee ezzfii. {sf aha

.;;3g';:5£i£::::i §'€$h raiéefi

" "§' ':é§ stains -iiigmigsed m *£;Eé.::*. atwgva

§'::1'z;i 22;:

SdI_§__
Ixidqe