Hmt Limited vs M C Ponnappa on 11 August, 2008

Karnataka High Court

Author: N.K.Patil

TEE’. HIGH CQLFR? OF KAREGATAKA AT B;§3€€}Ai.£’_’}RE W,}3.NO. 9889 GP ;’.-‘.{n3S &
Gﬂﬁ CGENECTEE MATTERS

IN THE HIGH COUR? OF K;!:2’NA TAKA A 3’ BANGALORE

DATEB 11-11% THE 11th DAY 09 AUGUST, 2098

BEFORE

ms HOAFBLE am. 3:237:95 A£.K.PA r*:;.:

W.P.N0. gesg 012* 2(3*{}8′{{‘:.K:§_-;i2E.f.V-*:3u§ V:v

cm. ‘7
W.?.NO.9085/2008 [GM—.RESi_;j;; % =
W29.r~za.9e8′?;;?.{;{>8{G2sM+z£s;;
WP.NO.9082/2008′{GM–i3PC’:};’ :
W.P.F~fO.9O84/2VG–Q8;§_G’M-CF’C?};-..
w.m~zo.g39e/:zoe3%icgmsgpc}; %
W.P.NO§909$;’2-(H38 {GM-.Ci’P.C};
ELEJQO-§3088’£’2Q0″‘.i_'{3M%RES}

% %
BE:wEEzx; g_ * ”

2 _1-<L!\éT LIMHTEC . V
; A'CQMPA£\:"!'.AREG§STERE& :.2:~:£3ER
frag' §NBiA!\£ szawamges ACT} 3913:
aswaue {rs REGHSTERED GFFHJE AT
» , moﬁae, –8EiJ.ARY ROAD;

‘- _B;a.h;;e:~=.LraRE«56Q $323 32’ ms waoux
§.3’s:*;i£$<s'F;Q EQBSEQEARY NAMELY,

Hm :.am<::–<Es am,
A CQ&éF"#§.éi1Y %NCQRPORA'i'E§ uweaa

T3»:-5 CQ?%2§PA?~£§E$ Act 1955:.

riévéﬂﬁ ETS» REGJSTERED GFFKEE AT
m… 59, BELLARY mm,

" . sasszaamaa 32

x _ 'fREP'RESEN'%'E9 HEREIN 33' $39
" SENERAE. MANAGER.

% W ma axecursva maecrea

‘e”e’f&’§CH GROUP
HM? LTD:

§E’~E ‘£’}3.El H§G.H COURT 0? KAR3~§ATAK.é\. AT BANGALCERE \1}P,N=i), OF ;2€}{?8 “f.’EE§§R C{}2\ZN’ECTEl} §¢siA”fTER$

EN TEE HIGEE COURT OF KARNATAK.;%, AT B,si;..?€GALOR§£. WPYNO. 9389 OF 2&8 &

C’3’£’I~E€.R CQNNECTEE1 zvi_z*;I”1′-Bis

-3.

N0 SQ, BELLA??? RQAD

BANGALORE 32

THE GENERAL TECHMCAL MANAGER

HEAT LTD,

WATCH FACKERY i 8: H

H;?a:%T P.Q.¢

B§§NGALORE 560 33′!

(av SRNQSHUA H,$.AM£.!E¥_ ASK Appaamfe 9%.-39.. 3
M38′ CARWDPA 3. co. A9vo<:;A1'E:s;

ANS:

‘E

M c PONNAPPA . _
ago mRMpc;–:::~.zAPPA«. .
PRQPR%Ei’§’QR ca? ¥’e§A?~§JL.%H.A?§-TA _ V ..
E£x§'{ERPR§SE$R1ATNO’4U€,. -. 1 V

saga S3-E%VAJ\”CéTH£, «
MU’£”HYALANA{3ARA ‘
Msaaom _ –

eazwzeaaoaz

RESPQNC}E§éT

{BY sRt.é:%_.NA..s:;w.ér%ig ‘j8a}é;r.,T»}§:£%§§L”;a.§vF*t§AR::~:r3« QNBEHALF o:=
%¢%!$ susea RAG Aw: cagz9Amy;::m~<ocArEs;

was wk». ._'§s'::2.LE:%"-LQKESER AR":':cLEs 225 A340 22:! 0? THE

CCéN$7§?iTU"Fi€3N OF' i%'¥3§A, PEAYENG TO QUASH THE £MPl.¥€3¥\£ED GRQER

«–,DT. .PAss5m'v~—-:–:e" A'S.64!2GQ2 9Ei*~éD4N<3 BEFCDRE THE W
':.7a.a;2";ms;=\:, :;:m<_<:2veL mass BANGALQRE cm' (scam; ma SXNNEXW

v*4.%;:,%§;0.T'%'9[%a3isCF 2008

3EI*;i;f§E:~:v~..': '

QM? :L§M§TE{'J

' ' A CQMPAM REGESTEREQ BNQER
'rag 522332594 compmzas Act 29:;
'A HAWNG as REGETERED emga AT

NCXSQ, QELLARY RQAQ
8§N{3AL{}RE-5Sﬁ Q32, BY €13 WHQLLY
OWNEG SUBSiE}%AFZY NAMELY,

TEE HEGH C{':{§R'F Q1? KARNATAKA 55!? BA?'€G§¥.§,C3RE W.P.E\§€3. 9089 O? 38:38 8?:

{}?.EE{ €'O?*4".?.'~IECTEX}

TEE HECEI-E CQLERT OF KEKREQATAKA AT EA,?\E€E;3.LOB.E-Z, '3§,P.3\'§Q\ 9089 OF '?£?£!8 «£2
£}T}% COEKEEEECTED E'e'§s¥§"'E'E1+?.S

,3.

HM’? WA”{CHES L’€D.,

A CQMPAQW 1NCGRF’*C3RATEB UMBER
THE CGMPAMES N31″, 1956} ”

%~§ﬁ.V§-MG ¥TS REG£S”§’ERED OFF§£E AT
NGK 59, SELLRRY RGAB,
ESANGALQRE 32

RE?RE8ENTE§ HEREtN 8′? ES
€3ENER?aL MANAGER.

2 ‘§’HE EXECLETEVE EHREQKDR

WATQH GRQUP

E-MT {$9,

NC?’ SQ, BELLARY RQAD

EANGALQRE 32

3 ma GE§’~iER:?ai. TECHNECAL M&N§1;§E§?__
Hm? Lm _ ‘V
WATQH FACTORYE :2…

aa? P,Q.= _
BANGALQRE 532: 931 ._ ” .

V H V _ V’ V ..a=-*»ETm.r::2:~.2EP.s

{BY SRLJQSHUA H.£:A,M_LIEL ;;L:sv,., .awE..;AR’;:::j::*3.§o£::j’

mas. s’.:AR¢AP,r2A_, a:’Vc<.2:T,'L;ﬁ';m:;:a::;é;"§Es) _

ANS:

2 (3MA_RAYA£x§;% –»:sc:v~;0;~._ — .
Pﬁ;GPR£E”§'{}R; ~9″a:As:e¢A:¢m’ :§L:TC}£v2AS
NC)’ 33:31′: 47:-4..:;’,§<:2;~:ss, :35: eemcsa
P§E§'?'§?5s 4¢~1Du2frRs.AL;AR;EA
_e§§N$Awa'£,.5a,— "

RESPQNQENT

; » {3’*{.$?{:.£s5,E~éAR§4Y’ANA BHAT, ADV. APPEARWQ QNBEHALF 05
_ 1_ 229235 saggag; szaamso CQMPANY ABVGCATES)

. ?Evii§% V~V’it’!.§:?5iVV%S’ FEED UMBER ARTXELES 225 AME} 22?’ G? THE
F$D€5%-_3T§TL§?iC3¥§§.’ C}? §§~iB!Ag PRAYQNG TG QUASH THE MPUGNED QRDER
$3 {}9.£§4.2{}§~3 PASSED N A.S.?’§f2%2 PENDibéG BEFQRE THE ‘J!

_ ,. 2 _’ ‘ ,é£1i’3iT20N!5§i. QTY CEW. JiJ§GsE BANGALQRE CITY {SCH-H} VEDE 54″-d’-i}=Z~Q,
8 ~ w,R. NQ9087 OF 2008

ggE”:§%;E§sx:

‘ ” 1 RM? LWHTEB

R CGMPANY EZEGKSTERED UMBER

THEE. EEGH CGCRT QF KARE’\EATi3.KA AT B.–5;}ZCtAL{)RI§, ‘s3i,?.}\3O. 9&8? G1’? 2{Z*f3S £3
E3 €L’£)E’\§E\é”£~;'(‘.’E’f£i{} ?v§A.’E”I’ﬂS;

TEE HZGH C013??? 0? KAREQATAKA 1-1%.?’ BANG;Xl.GRE. \3oi,P,:”§{:t, 95389 OF 2003 £5

QTTIER CONNECT@* MAT?RS
.4″

we EMSIAM CQMPANEES Am, 19:33
aavswa {TS szeeisreaaa QWECE AT
NQ59, BELLARY ROAE3,

8ANGA£_GRE~5$Q 932, By as waoux
QWNEQ sL:ssu:::ARv NAMELY,

Hm’ WATCHES am,

A cowamv WCQRPORATED ucxzaaaz
“:2-:5 czemmuzes Act, 1955,

%-§A’JiNG rrs REGISTERED <3?-"FiC3EE A37 ..
M3. 59} BELLARY game, :

BANGALQRE 32
R§PRESEN?EQ HERESN 9: as
aamema. MANAGER’ _

THE EIKECLETNE §iREC?QR
WATCH GRQUP

%-EMT LT8; .

NS 59, BELLARY ROé’~.;¥.”$1 ._ f

SRNGALQRE 32 ”

“ma GENERA;TECHNEC£e.L_f&1A£%i.¢eGE.R’ .%
Hwms, _
‘&e’A?CHF£1C1″f}RY! sgau ::
HMTP.£1._.’–.. fj ~ « _
Bé§’=§*3f§LQRE. ‘:23:

PHEHQNERS

gas’ sR:.ss;’se5:L;:A.%%:-:.sA§géLs~éé§.; a;%::*.z. ;”:z;3’t3s.,AR::~.:Q FOR
M13; caaéapm & co. Am%’f}CA’§”£S}

AN§”: { ”

C Ei&;:r¢:i;;A..

ii-{Q “£H§KKN\§NA

3 ‘” ¢s*:w:3§1*.s=z:&i’;f;{.3§<:..sR;z RAMA AUTQ ssaaapezazaaars

NC} 3'i;.,GEE%.;'?ARA BALAGA LAYGLET

. :s':A<3§;, aéaaaaxsamz LAYOUT
5t§héCu.%L.QRE~8§

RESPQMDENT

4 ~:év'Ts:::;.a;4.mAaAw~:A saga Arzwz APPEARN23 (mag;-:A:_:= as:
= _ ' ..m;s_ swam RAG AND cempamv Asvecswes;

Ti-{ES WP. IS FRED EANDER ARTtC;¥..ES 225 AND 22? GE: YHE

-~C»;ﬁNS?tTi.FFl€}N OF §¥’~§D¥A$ PRAYEMG TC) QUASH THE NPUGNED CREEER
$3″, 9.42938 PASSES EN A(S.§5I2G«C%2 PENDENG BEFORE THE V5

Tﬁ EHGEE {70¥.§RT§’ OF E;’X;R2K§.=’-‘&T?aK.~i AT BAEGALCERE W.P.?~§O. $389 C3?” 2{}i38 5%:

<Z}'?HER CO?~EZ€F;CTE§I3 3\:i,-%T"i"@,S

TEE HIGH C{§i§RE' OF KARNATAKA AT B.?al'éG:–'%.LOREn '<§£'.P_.'§E{}_ 93853 {BF 2&8 &:

OTHEIR COBQEECTEIE §¢£A'}""E'ES

.5-

ABCHTQCENAL SET’! €.Iii’e’§L JUDSE Bé¥£’${3Ai.ORE QTY {SCH-1%} WDE
Ai’~i£\£E}{i..ERE £3,

W.F3′.NC3.9O82 OF 2968
QEEWEEN

‘ ” ” .. ,;mgG.aiL;:2R’;E..5ee Q31

HM? mzarsa
A coagzpmv REGiS’€ERED amen

“sag swam: compmzas ACT, @913, –
HAWNG as agessreaea asmca AT
£40.59, EELLARY Ram,
8AN<3A§.QRE-56$ 932, By :13 waom
awmga SUSSLDEARY NAMELVC

z-am WATQHES rm, "

A CQMPANY ENCQRPQRATEE) u:<:.%aE't%=2
THE cemmxmgss As: 1953, _ " – . _ —
HAVENG His RE{§tS?'EFiE§Z) oF§.:<:E :3':
Na. 59, BELLARY RG35}, " «– — . .
BANGALGRE 32 — * T- . '– .

REPRESENTED HEREW :32′ :73 J ‘
€3E£\éERAi. Mazesaem . ‘-

ma-:%:::mc£;:TavE-»;::s’:2Ec2fz:R
waxcu eacmt — V _
I~§%e1′{L7f£3,. ” .

.:~1c:>’59§ E%E§mLARYRi2¥:§.{3′..__ *-
egmeaaoaa 32

.T§«:E eE5§E:=eg4L TECS-{§@_Cﬁ;L MANAGER
,, 4_s.A;«:£s:z”:*~s$.zra, – « V

– ”«xr:%;r:r.::–:.£Ac?c:RY*–;-3.; :;

HM?’ ¥3′.G{;« ‘a
PEETEQNERS

{é’%eé;:.so3Hu}\;i. ;-zfsaagagez. Ami, A.F*f3’EAR%NG z-‘tea

% _ MiS;'{‘;AR.{AF’?A”& ca;

– ‘-ma; ” ”

£4 RAJAGQPAL

PRQPREETQR

MES SAi3’THAG%R2 AUTO F’REC£S§QN
Ef’%Gi¥’éEERENC§

NC? 891%, KALA THEATRE ROAQ
KAMPséﬂGOND.éHA§_LL

EN TEE; HIGH €ff{?’L?R’§” OF Ké3aR§’*§¥§?§.i'{;”§. A?’ B:~’§.?€{§}’aL{3E<"'Cd "JJ.l'3.E\2€f,:r. §*€}S£% C}? 3538 5:':

C€f31N'E~:'?;7LCT7E.§ MATTERS

Z53 HIGH CQURT C317 KARNATAKA A'? BANGALQRE. \V.P.?-3Q. 9689 OF 2098 8:

CC}?-ENECTE MATT@.S
mg.

8ﬁxNGAi.ORE-éﬁ

RESPQ.b£_E}’5§§T ~ V.

(BY SRi.¥ﬁ.NARA”{A%~iA 39:35:: ADV, APPEARENG oM3E+»:ALF +35 V ‘ ” ”
ms SUBEA RAG ANS compmv AD%:’GcA’€E-5} _ ﬁv _

ms wp. gs FELEQ masses: AFzT:;’:L.E:é-..:é2s “;’2.,Mé3A..’2’2?”<.'i¥._Is=e:£7
CQNSTETUTEON 05 £NDiA, P§2A\'£NG TO cm-'4\s:++__T:+:E §M§=t_,M3h;EQ C:RL'2~ER*.

QT, QAZGQ8 PASSES {N A.S,{\£O'81.12f302 FEDIDING BQEGRE 'THE Vi

Ai30iTlQNAL CETY CEVEL $UDQE 'BAf*-1§'sALQR:? QTY T' 'WEE V L'

ANNEXLERE D,
wm4o_%a4 0:: mos

BETWEEM

2 amrmvzsrea _
A CQMPANY 3'~T{E¢3.£S1FERED i..:§x2;..::–.-.'§z
ma eMa:A::'cc:wAN:£s sgcr; 1913.;

HAv:Ne_ ms. RE?3£S.TE'REQ e:ss;=;c.s ;::..fs*
N059, c3£:_:..A–:*~.*:1'~r"Rcw;;«,'–_jj– _ '~ V M.
aA:~s<3AL<;}R::-.:%;:~;se 932: 93:' rag: WHOLL
oa;:r.z~¢.E£:_Asa:es:£:az:g_;9;¥ ma.-:£s_x1 «
HM? WA'§"{3.HES L"?.Q_, _ .

A ‘€;QPv§P:K5§Y’%M$QRPQRAT’E9 mega
T9-§1:E_CC>£fv1PANHE3.13ef3″{;.’J’Q5ﬁ.,’
Haws HTS RE€3£3TERE{1_OF{-‘%CE A?
M). 59; SEL£..vARY.Ri’.:§D, A H
BANGALGRE 2:2, ‘

4;’R§s»*saEsEr4″:’;1: %~£ERE§£’~£ 32′ H3
~s;E::s;LEEz4;:, MAN3sGE.¥?1p

.2′ *:”;~r_;é €:.<:E2¢:;£?§vE DERECTQR

f » .53'? SRLJOSHUA HSAMUEL ADv.., APi9£AR£N<3 FQR

" T "–&.!A"§"«CH»?3FéQLi{?
am? :;*~:t2:;,
' . 'M3 §9;8,Ei..:LAR¥' Ream
ﬁA§x§:3£iLQRE 32 –

Ti-‘€E GENERAL TEGHWCAL MA?*iAGER
_ HM’¥”LT§,
“–WA’?G§’E fr”-“AC?OF’;Y E & H
* ._ _§%§!%*§T R0,,
E:53\§GALORE 560 C31

‘ ‘gm

PET!T§G{\§ERS
” V _ W8′ CﬁsRiAPPA 8; C0 ASVGCATES)

THE HIGH Cf€3{§R’E’ Of? KAR?i»’£TAKA. A3? i?!.’;t89 GE’ 3663 35
OTEER ‘CO?€3’€E»CTP3f} E\:iAT'”£’H?S

IEKE TEE HIGH COURT :3? KARNATAKA AT BAN’€’.’:ALOR£_ ‘$:IPNO. 9989 Q? 2£¢£)8 ﬁr.
{FIBER C{)Z\?§\ECi’?$ MA’f”}.”%S

.7.

AMD :

1 S§DDARAJA£AH
SON OF CHEKKANNA
AGEQ ABOUT 59 YEARS
PROPEEEETOR

Aaum F’RE<"3lS§O'N ENGINEERNG
No 241, EWS 1: STAGE, me. caaow
BASAVESHWARANAGAR,

8.A£~iGALORE. ~

{av SRWENARAYANA 3HI”5:{, ADV’. Awagairsa ‘c:.zs4$EHA4_f-fr ;cF,;
M18 SUBBA RAG ANS cewazw AQVQQAEES) ‘ V _

was wp. ES HLEG r:.4:s1:;>~ER,i;i;F5zr::.Es:-.226 :x:~.aa’~2*2? QF we
CONSTITUTEQN as i?~£i1I§fi,, PRAY¥–NG .TQ:QuAs:-H525 éhgﬁ.-PLEGNEQ <::R2::sEa
mi 94.2035 PASSED gm AT$,a9:2s_2_c@ ;PE!\'iE}£é~%G .e.EFz:3,r~2E THE vs
Aa§3mc::NAL CITY (2% 31.2335 agsgeazme g§3r:_;-«M1; was ANNEX-

D,      V 

W.P.NO.9G§3ﬂ§"{>F1'::.fZ$'Q_$§   1;      "
3EmEE%;_

2 §~§MT:,EM:TED   =  * '

A CCsA:i??;%NYv REa.Is”:r§§2£§£3;’L’IJ:»:aER
mg !Nf:ii+W cewvamsas ‘;v-xm, ms,
4 ;H.m:«4a £TS”;”ZEG£STE§<".:ED ‘%«2,._js$3, §ELi.AR’¥’
§A?~£t;”3A£.;QRE~5§S Q32, 9:: as WHQLLY
= 1. _ 0’*.!?a’£\i£Ei}«S£;%~;?%_S!i3§A.RY NAMELY,
“3-i?~ﬁ’.3;¥;ATC§%ES m::.,
I A <:;::s;:;?Aw::qce§2Pa£2AIE2s uregaa
' . '~*;':~4§ Q€3?«ﬁE3P{NEE-S ACT, 2956,

HAv;s«:e3 .§.f:-is RECSESTERED omca A1'
" NQ159, BELLARY RGAQ

a~AV§\2GAL0RE 32

_ REfr–'='RESEN"%;"EQ HERBN av ITS
'- «,GE§'a1ERA£. MANAGER.

“THE EI3{EC3U’§”§’\fE {3EREC?QR
WATCH GRCKEP
Hfaﬂ LTD:

N6 59, BELLARY ROAD
BANGALORE 32

TEE EEGH C€”_E?.ER’F Q’? 3? B.»”~.NG A§.<'}RE 9089 Q17 2-.€!Q8 !€Z\é}:IC'i'E{} 3-Vi z'%.3"TERE§

T REsI3r:3r}3':3E;§@E'L?1.J.'

EN 'i'Ei£ HIGH {TCEIURT Cs? KARNATAK51. AT B44.E~E{§.!1.E,C}RE. 'Js:'.?.1'\§C).9{§89 {I}? EQG8 &

5)’?!-{ER COENECTED MékTT’£.R5§

_g..

THE fL’sE¥’£ER.!1.§. TE{3§-%E’&é§{3iiL MRNAGER
HEAT LYD,

WATCH FACKDRY i & H

HM? F’.C}.;

BRRGALQRE 55%.} O3′?

A ‘

{EY SR?-JQSHUA HSAMUEL A3V,, AF’PEAR!!$£{,3MFQR
HHS’ CARiﬁ.PPﬁ-. 8: CG ADVQCSATES} ” « .

AND :

‘1

saw :3 RAJMAIIMA
WIQF are ax: MARAYANA RE:z:2;~r~~
pRo:>;:=z:amR, * ‘

ASHWEME ALJTQ CQMPQNQNT-$_…. _
we 3’§3fA, GQK_L§LMS’s’AG5, é:£=:~eA$E_ V
§;:%AC;?H%KERE, 1 ‘
BANGALQRESA

‘ 1;” éespemaem”

(av sag.M;r.zgs:é*;%é£:~4;5:«12HA1;._é;a>g?.’ ;«§’£’»s:–>:.’.–r.A_R_+:§G QMBEHALF <3;
MES swag :%;e:=.Tm}~2r;a ::Q:~:.:-é;-;:~;j{ ADVQCATE3}

THIS WE _i$xFi§,ED_ Li§'%i5B%.-'I,F=Z ARBCLEE 22$ ANS 22'? OF THE
C0!\iSTiTUT.}QNQF %§$;£Qi'–.¢.'s,'–3f-"i:"Q£'E'§'<i§3 "IQ Qi..}AS§~i THE WEPUQNEQ QRQER
OT. 9.4.2888 F'§}SS£D LEN" .Ag$§?@!2Cé3$ PE£\iDl§'1G EEFQRE YHE '£3
A§3D€'Ti<2}NAL GET? €.3i3{§L~ £8993' BANGRLGRE €3£T"s' {<3C§~i~'H§ \{!E1'E ANNEX»

1'.

% % % *w;Pj%Nc>%:9Qa3 sémoa

éz;f;*s.5$Eéi%;»–.._ ” A’

é-:£§ST’tL %§isEi’§iEQ
F~’«…__C<Z;a§'.ﬁPANY REG§8'{EREG umsg

1' ma i£\éD§AExi £{3£iéPﬁxNiES Am 1923,

I-=%§?¥.'i'iE\iG FPS RE{:'a£$TEREQ QFHCE AT
NQSQ, BELLARY Rﬂﬁﬁ,

V 1' Bé!-£GALORE-E5-G Q32: B"s'§TSW§-§<i}LLY

" GWNEB SU8S§£3iARY NAMELY,

HM"? WATCHES LTD',

A CGM?A%\£Y iN{3€}RPC¥R§'xTED UNDER
T"?-iE CGMPAME8 ACT} '@531

1+-§.R'*J¥NG ETS RECERSTEREQ OF¥§C.3E A?

E?'-E THE Pilfﬁﬁ €.','f3U§iT ~if;sI5' A? B§£.?-3€3r£L€%REi 'S'i'}S9 {SF ZQEFS £3

CBETE CTOI'\£":\§£»C'i'}§3ZI Z'»£;'5.'§'§'ERS

(.0

{BY SR§.»Jf3SH.LiA H.SAMl..§Ei. §;4::»i.a; Awygiaélem
MS' CARWPA & co AavacArE~:s}V 5 *

ANS ;

n-A.

‘E

CETEEZ CfOEx?2\£’EC’F”§33 MATTHKS

mg.

Ni}. 59;. BELLEERY RQAC3,
BANGALORE 32
REPRESENTED HEREW EY HS
GENERAL MANAGER’

THE EXECUTEVE macroa

wmca aacsup

HM? ma

NQ $9, BELLARY RQAD

BANGALORE 32 –

THE GENERAL ‘%”ECHN§CAL MANASER .,
Hm LTD, V –

WATCH FACTGRYE & u T A
HM? Pg,

amaaaoaa see Q31

t.;€1 s’§§iAm~§§;aaA §i:i’o§49.fs

IN EEEGH CQURT OF KARNA§’ﬁ=,KA. AT BANGALQE. W,P.,?~é(}, 9138!? OF 3908 6%

PET§?iQ<."~§ ERS

F'iEPR.E3EN?.iED. B"? THE §si%Nﬁ.G%NG DHEECTOR

ska bi !~;Acs.am..s}a;L.§2EQ_c:'x#._' ' __
SR3? sgaagsa £?;EL'—.835 N£3__ sragaenma
v1NA2';aK;:a TEMQLE. .e.a;:;Q;{saaALA

V .8ANGA§;QRiEv _

.; ﬁazwssn

HEW? LiE\I3§'¥"EQ
9% CGMPANY REEESTEREB L§ND€R

{3"§'E{'E'§: CONEGZCTEI} MATTERS

RESPQNDENT

. "(;B'§';':'E§¥.?<§%ffxfAR'%YAf%éA saga, gem: AP?EARé.?xI<3- QNBEHALF 09
» eggs: 1$u$a:s».. §<E.£§;.3~–A§§éD COMPANY ASVGCATES)

I 'E!-é£S'–'¥¥ P}: is F§L;'-LE umsaa ARTlC§..E$ 225 AND 22? GP THE
CQ§'-i,S?i"{§§?§Q§§.: Q? WDEA, PRAYENG To QUASH 'me EMPUGNED QRQER
« $3'. ':{3L4;'2i}Zl8' PASSEE 1:»: A.S.$2f2€3£}2 PENBQNG BEE"-'ORE we vi
Anmrmsxz. cm' CML JUDGE, 8AMGALORE cm' {SCH-H} was

:m:s1Exu:35 :1

'*..V%§»..F5f{Na 9088 0? 2098

EN T}§ EEIGH {?£)§R? (E? §§éi.R?€..5%.T§:K,5. A?' Eé'5.}€€}.§%L'C2RE 7%5'P.'}éf_"}. 988'? £259 Zﬁﬁﬁ &

KN HE HEGH COURT 0? K.iXRNﬁ.TAKA X!' EANGALCERE. W.P.N?O. €308? (fl-F 21388 4%
€)'§'HER CO2'-?i'««E{fTEE ?sf1ATTER.$

-93-

THE NDSAN CG£%:IF’ANi§ES A91: 1913,
HAWNCS as REG§STERE{3 ems; AT
$6.59, aaamav ROAB,

BANGALORE-560 Q32, B’? {TS WHQLLY
owwgzza sueszamm NAMELY2

HM?’ WATCHES Lm,

252 cawamv INCORPSRATED umoarr »-
THE cezvmmgas Am 19%;

é-§2%ViNG {rs REGESTEREB <;2z:=;r§er:-: A? :
MG. 593 BELLARY RQAQ V 2
BANGALQRE 32 _
R5932-sEm°E9 HEREM ax' ;"rs.–:.__ _
GENERAL MANAGER' '

3*»)

we axacunva maczgsz
warca emu? 1. –

HM? ms,

N0 59$ BELLARY RGAD _
EAMGALQRE 32 . –

3 THEGENERAL;11TE{3H}u”2CA2,MAP~£AG.ER
HMTL’__1.”f3; .

WATCH FA$’i'{}R.Y 2- 3.. sz=–.;- ‘ . 7’

HP9£TP.€:>.~_,. 52;. ”

Bi<N€5ALQE.E saws: * « _

PETETEGMERS

{BY sRa.JosHLm- §»~:'s;e;e«:L;s:'. ,¢§¥:jv. § }4PP§ARme FOR
M13' €A£~'&,§APF'–A s.»:::Q, gmmcmrgs)

A%'~«£€.3..:f-A: é
S§:§}3..,3§13Ei_ESH KUMAR
. " -V . 33;; -39:1) £-1–._QES!GAN
Taeaa A3GEJ§7~~4& YEARS
A PRC3F??i£.E?€}R

;m\_i&:<1s%::TENTERpRasE$
M: 1:5; worm: ti~£¥.'.iUSTR;AL campaax
Bm_<3ALeRE

RESPC:£'~3§EM'§'

' {B3:"£§:§.M.NARAY£N& EHAT, Agar. AFQEARWG <3:»:8E§-éA;_:= SF

f¥'§fS SUSEA RAQ AND SQMPANY ﬁDVQCA?ES)
T TM8 W.P. £8 F§LEC1 UNDER &R?iCi.ES 226 3WD 22? OF T%%£

CQ?~£ST§TL.iT£O¥\é GP ¥3'i§i.ﬁ, ?RA'Y"!!'4{3 K} QUASH THE tMPU{3NE3 QRQER

QT' 9;-4=2Q€38 PIXSSED EN A'S..63!2QO2 ?EE's1€}§§'éG SEE-'ORE THE Vi

93% THE} RISE C'OI.?RT €333 KARTf'«§ATﬁLKA 61.? BANGALORE WV?,}€O. 9133? 2938 £2
€3?."1ﬁ<II~1 CQEVY'-ECTB3} §L='i;3.T'§'E"§{S

TEE, HIGH CCXERT OF KARIMATAKA AT BABEGALORE, W.P.}$C*. 9085') {FF ZOIIIS £2:
O?!-E CQNNECT33 MATTERS

-11.

ADDiTiONAi. cm W2; aumea BANGALORE QTY gc:z{‘

THE {ZQUFQT MASS THE FOLLOWNNG: _ ._
.~oRoER; %

in 313 thesa petitions, pet%tii:’i’;sé*:_é’:.*A,?s.1A”are”‘s¥§s3.ai£ir*£§”§%ié~.VV

correctswess of the order détedV””93’ in

A.S.Ncs.64l2m2; 7112392; &%a5:éz>o_§2%;F%%31;2de2;”e9x2ee2;
7012902; a2;2m2 and e3;2Qa%2k%k j pa.«e.sg<a;3y \!§ Additionai
City Civil Judge"5§.éing;§!prsef Vida Annexure-

Sgi J:31e;§1.;J_:é: §-¥;~._S3mu-$1, caunsei appearing for

We Cari’alp;:_$a% afid far petitieners, at the outset

submffded thai; instant writ peiitians filed by

p§17:i’£i_Qr:e_:s ‘méy.__ be dismissed as withdrawn, reservéng

§’§b.é’:9t*;’t:43 i?’:.é§*;_;§éfi’tioners to tile necessary fresh appéication

}baf9r;e ..i§ie Tréai Ceurt, as envisaged under Sectéon 34 cf

VA “~:§f%:xe;: A_r’bitrat§on and Conciiéatgan Act, 19% read with

V. ﬁééﬁen –4(b) of tha High Cam of Karnataka Arbﬁaratien

» 7(Prmeed§ng3 before the Co rzss) Rafe:-1: 2001 and 3%! the

THE §~EE<3'§§ <Z'tf}E.§RT {E}? KA§E\EAT}3&iA AT BANGALQRE W.F','Z*${), .9389 Q? 3553 3%
€I)"I"£ﬁ{ C(.)l'\§E\?ElCT}E£D ?«;§riT'E'ERS

EN" TIE HEGH CC-iER'E' OF KAR}"~§A'fAKA AT BAQEGALCERE. W89 OF 3368 £:
{)'I'% C{3E\s3'4'E1ﬁC?'§'E1§ MA'E"1"'RS

.;g-

cententiong urged in thase writ petitions may be___kept

open.

3. The abeve submission made $5; ie3:fﬁ:ed ({o’x§%is§=:_i_4′

appearing far petitioners, is piaced ;1rz”‘lr’w:sr_::i§._ ‘« V

4. The instant writ pet§tiens fi_ie:7d.V_

dismissed as withdrawn, reserv’i’rs’.g:”V!%§.bert§f 2-<3_Vt¥*:ej"ga:éf'i'.t é'§L$tie%3 to V

redress their grievance tieigre §':¥ié I3.§jur¥"'a=g%9v§ 'bywaiﬁr af filing

fresh appiication as pravided u'I1:.~£E"e:'V t!':é :'.*é'§§e?§'a.nt prcvisicns cf

the Act and R;u£ér$V,:Vj'su%3§Ai_ec%.» ti":é€'»vL';:i,b§.e;¥;f§o:;rs is be filed by

respendentsi. " V V. '

the by the petiticners in these writ

peiitécns afe%4.1%e€t,of5§e;;£V.' ._ " .

éheéeﬁbsgﬁgatéons, the instant writ petitions ﬂied

*b§?'petii%v§;4r;a{é: S£and disposed cf.

W'L§a§;ﬁ'gfdA'I= }?§9unse§ appearing far respondenis is

' _ ;aerr.z§§'£'£e$A féie vakaéath within two weeks from teday.

ts":

Sd/-

Judge

EN THE EHGH CCEURT 5.}? AT BA}
OTEEER CONNECTE Be

Like this:

Related

Leave a Comment Cancel

Hmt Limited vs M C Ponnappa on 11 August, 2008

Share this:

Like this:

Related

Leave a Comment Cancel