High Court Karnataka High Court

Imamsab S/O Fakrusab Nadaf vs Smt Noorjan W/O Imamasab Nadaf on 13 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Imamsab S/O Fakrusab Nadaf vs Smt Noorjan W/O Imamasab Nadaf on 13 July, 2009
Author: Jawad Rahim


A.r:§.£z.:;},

I
I§’€ THE HIGH CQEERT Q? §i\E’BLE MR.&US’r:QE:’*”a’asvg:;§
cR;M1z»mi, PETITEQN
BE’§WE§EN: V I A. 1 A’

Emamsab,

g/9 Fakrusab P€.é4:;€izaif,’–V.. » _ V.

Agra 6 § §:ears,=..QT;:1c;=;*.g «. V

Rio Maizakumbi,

Tq: Savvadamg’*–V 4. . _’

Dim: Bfiigaum.’ ” _ P’E'”f’i’i’I{}}’~§EiR

(By S;:i.M. ;%s§..é*acatc}

L _ ‘££~’;mi,. fiigjézjaen,

£23iam§3b Nadaf,
‘ ‘Age Yfifiars,
Sec: H:-gusahoié work,
R59 iiiabar Karmic: Shaw},
is? Véfrass, Shivaji Nagar,

V n Beigaum.

2»–‘.;A

Q ‘ –5SI’:.Da{ial{ala:1da:s:;

S/:3 Emamsab Nadaf,

saga 313 }’68;'{“$,

(Lice: Cacmmt b1.1Sifii3SS,
IR’/0 Babar Karade Chawi,
H Crcésg, Shivafi Nagm;

Bslgamn.

CO

Ciousbi E/:3 Emamszab Natiaf,
Aga 2′?’ years,

Gee: Banml Mexrthant,

R/’9 Babar Karadtt Chawi,

ii Cross, Sh.iva§i Nagar, 1 ‘_ .g «_ V
Beigaum. }”€ESPQfi’?}E;?{E.’_$ : A

(By S:i.Sanie::3h 3, Rakut, Adveérzzégt}
This erimifiai §=f’:€i?iOfi is §i$&.js;1f.3. 482′ p1’ay§:::zg ‘ie
set aside? {E16 szyréc-:1′ 0f v}tI”L8.ViIZt€1fiéi’}C*3 ‘i”I2’ ‘–i:»i’§. §v’IiSC’;N€.i}3?3/ 2685
pagsed by 321:: Eémiiy _Be§ga§;2r.n;~–s:§.ate£¥. _i3,,2e2GG9§ amt fttflk
This petitio:z;r_::c3:x:i1:gg 0i1:’§”<::t'–.:«::;¥,:n}.'.:s'Zs3;ir§i;s;lfi£i$ zlay, 111:: Cifiilfi

made the foflswingz 1

1fjQRn§§'
E' fiefifiefi _:€i';'».$..–~»"!+8;-.?*; 75:3,-=' 'Em: E?;.zmE'):.a:':

baa 3::_fi”s3:€§i ‘a.n; V{.i?f’€§éX° {§;f3;téa:I:’:$.i2§2{}(}€~}, §::}. €§z*1,Ps’£i:s;ca373;’2{}i§;’5 aé

* .,’§he a:3f;.§11d§gé;vvE?’–s:;;:z:i1}* Cam”? 3?. §$€}g:«:m::.,1, dirficfisag him ta}

irafe;-=” “E0 _t.hi: :’:i§1?}§§::=;i£:1:t aimaizgi

A 2, :Tf§.1é matéer is fisiaad fer a§m§ssig;>:’a afimf I}€}§§Cf3 E35;

– ‘-like 1’s3§;<';jfié3:i§nts, 'E'§1e§«* are dziigs rapresfizztsgi.

At the Gut Set, $313 Earned 6922:1362 for gtzetizicner

_2?§«*:§:1£d suhmit that fine ieazmzd Jucigei §¥'a::1i1§-? Comm has :20?

V consiéfizfed the issua regaxding actuai inccme srgf ma §€fififiB{EE'.

Accaxfiizag {:3 him, the {Earned «Judge, Fanaiig Cm1rf,'é§;-i:11z}1::?.

insisting 021 daruméntary proef about {ha mcamgfié' pé'i.if;l:;<is;I1t;« é:1:1 §s';–'?'O£,:)gf– b

pm. in respmzdents 2 and 3. T}1is,V'«Vac'ee:;19{ii:1g"ii:o'him,'§;é,*s;é::35

harsh and sagidking €113 pefifiajfiar 2ari§f}1._ ii-'Q

i1I1pre::p€:r.

4. Tbs :r€spoz1ds’i1i:s;’ hé:a%:§Vi'<:§3p{é$3§3{i .fi:§s <:0n£entio11¥

E':§ """ '7:'§§}§,;=_"c;§ursc_vVé§f arguments, figs learned
C0u11s61VV"–fo$:'«. I£}f:§iti{);E£?L¥?V1'L 'jSflii?;}:{I::£tt€«€i that the? petitions: wag

wérking as {§':;.:*iv€r. §{;3RT*C whTo had; a rvsguéar incoms. 811?

'~ ._v:10xx:; }';:e gs, x*e:_ti;raed service arid is getting may pfi31Si8£i. in

Sixfifig :éc~:ivtg;1fitia:1 is the inmme: which the peiiticaner had at

tbs. htims: V 1 ifizvlpugnaé Qrder was pawefi has S1}§3$€€f{i€§'}.fl§'

hvfhemfgre {ham is changa 01° ciztmmsiafices.

' €}. First fif 31}, the: issue 33 zraiseti in éhia psfiiion

_.__j""'ca;§§:n0t ha gens mic 3/3 482 C::P,C; 'E'h::~ order passed; by {him

.F'ami1j«;* Ccseurt is revisabie by thf: High Court u/S };@{4} 9f {Em

Famiiy Ceurt gficts That benefit has 219%: bean avaiied Gf by 32531

W

3.3.

petitianaz’ and; on that. grcamxd iiseif the pfititian ghoulxd faj},

Hgweva, i have hearé it to asseirtain Whethfrr t’i1m*e _ is am}?

ifiegaiity in the proccedings befozt F’amj1y CO11’_~v’;._4{;;;”§MV}13i1T’£;{;::V§i”€}r

inierfcrencr: 12/ S 482 Cr.P.{Z. I am satisfiad r;9__;9;’:§g;1:fx::.VstLéfa3;gie%– i.s: b

bmught out Hfince thai request is #”éj€t’L3f€E1..f

Seconé asgsccé: ‘(:0 ba fiO’C}:(3{Etf1 is that 31$ *;%;€£’:§j”!:i.:>.23::;I’..3is 139.’: L’

dispufizxg ihat he was in sé1Vi<:¢__L:Tas:_:iriVer when {ha
petition was mevcd xthc ézivers cf KSR'§'C
were béing paid was z1€2At…£éS.'<3V. -»–. 'Fha'ugh the

salary éétrtiiicafe' .-:.3.*a$';r1CéE. _f}'rsf_;_d–z1C€d by the msyondenta it was
incomb€§i%.<.._si1.':h6=p:i'fifi:f::i&:f 'L0 §}I'0€11}£i3€ his salary ceaiificsate 3:3

prove; that hié mgénis véi-3.3 Tisss thafl R's.1{}0QG/-, if he cantsnszés

Ea:*-3? V" Hfifiefivfirfi he §:$ 'H§€iir€{§ subsequent iii} passing sf thfit

~§sn§;g¢:_~11':giz;.s;**;:V:E–.._,:4f}iw::4;,¥V €'T;*)?.V }Th6ref0re, his; remedy 13263 11,15 12'? flrfifi. is

apgfig to €335 court far maaiifisztatifirx $5? the $:c{§;e:;s:. Thia. is ma?

– Va prayér féfltim.

‘ . _ H }”§€11{f€, the pfiiiiian faiis ané is mjficifizi.

Sd/–~
JUDGE

S11b*