IN “mi:-; H163 C(.}LiR’i’ er’ 1~;A.R:~:A;:’A2; A AC1′ 1:’:AE\éGM§:*(T}1’1,}:’: A’
DATED THIS THE 5*” DAY 01%’ 5XUGU$T”2if{)9_:V’. ” f kw
5x~;r’uR1~; _
THE H{}N’BLE MR..IUSTICE S’.=;{£BDUL ;’vZ{1ZEERVV”
MISC C1»*:;;;w. 9s36;z2.£é:;;a VA ‘ * ~ . %
IN REGULAR FIRST API~’E ‘..+L&. %v§g;gg§g;999»(RE;§L
.-
4′
—–……
Between:
l*€9.44..-55, Si:1gasatic’:;’.E;,, ‘ 4
Bangaiozfe S0utE1’Ta11:1:;._’:”‘-»,A ” ..
By its ?ewcri:~f £–‘;ttori:s:}9’I:jit;idé:rg ‘
Laiazhaad Bha1iSa_ii§ . ‘ . ” Appeiiam.
‘ afiumya Adv”)
A. Sré Szirésh,
_ “?r$sidem:§ ‘}f’h€ Aircrrafif Iimpioytes
fiooperaiixfe Smziety fifiiieg
Naé§
Daubie Rgaé, Ba:1gaBere=«27.
2 Viswanaih Raddy,
Ioixzi Diraston
The Aircrafi Emyloyees
Cooperative Saciety Lt-:1,
1\73.1:’>, 15$ Crass, C,K.C. Garden,
Opp:B.O. Husgiiai, Rwad,
Double Road, Bangaiare-27.
3 The Aircrafi Empioyees
Cooperative Society Ltd, T.
N015? 15′ Cross; CKC Garden? ” ‘
€)pp:B.O, Hzaspilai, K.H.Road, . « -‘
Boubie Road, BangaIo:’e»2’7. Respondéntsf
(B§;M;”S Shettyfic Hagde;£1fS,Aé*§%:).A $ ; ”
§i3m€)_PMQM%j~1PPL1f;L%§:’Xmfé %
Sr: Laichaud B’h_an;s:a1i; _
S50 Kesrimal Bhazmalii
Aged about 65 years;-. . _
§?*éo.8i4, 12?”r1~:*%..!s4ain, %.
A ….. .. V
B5:’:mgaiu:::_a 569
Ti1i§=Pviis:aé..Ci%e*I’:’iS fikté. under Qrder 22 Ruie :9 read with
L1 and Sec. 11.51 efihe CFC; praying to permit the appiisani ta
é gxama .s;)1′:~r§:;§rd as appsfiant ?€::>.2, am.
Ifiiisafivi, ctoming an fer Gréers this day, {ha Court
V ‘ v’}§i&.gé}5}’f§I€_§fG§i0W§figI
property. Thai the piaintiffs filfihfid 10 the jurisdictienai
paiice and with their imervezitisil the ” =
acitivities sf the $313:-nzianis was stoppéggi. “ftjatj. figs: { 4. ”
éefenfiants may gaurilace again with m0re7he:’;9hn1en»g1; ” ”
am 1;}; to dispossess the §la;&ntifi’. ‘iv’h¢:’:;1′)*i.r:_1%i::3’£ii:i:’T’;<; has 11:?
Gthar alternative but ta agprfgach thj$__VHQn'!:}e G}:3u:1_
and hence suit" .
3. The defiendanis {fled ax} applicatiénv°1;;3;,.§€it3 fbé£fi?;>re the
E343} C0121″: fer 1″6_§${:’£i{‘)I1:.»i.’;’l:”‘ .;§§§;2. phfijni 1: ti1«¢ gi”j<_?mVrv1_};i fliihfii notice
Efifliifii' Section 32:5 of Societies Act has
mt been mzgeé. éi*?;e"s;ai<i' i1:;=,:«§ been contested 'by the
giaifitiiil The Cffiifi 5eEu€§W Q'§';vvéppffifliéiiflfl 01:' the rivai cententions
of "*p:3:fi:i§é':: Ch3i$TL'Aa§iL\.3s:ed i}:1:éWfi3ppiica{ian and has reje-cteaé the
. plain; sa§Vd3T'9r_ Qa:.:r isVV§fiV<§§.=:r chaiimge in this appeai.
45 "it2 "§Ehis« 3:: Laichané Bhansafii E133 fzieé
_§;g£.§;z§§.€?*s{1.N6.§E£3éf3Q§3§ Lififier tjmez» 22 was 16 axzfi :2 read wi£%;
§§;ea'i§_as:€ E :é=§th€ Cede 9:' Civzii Frecedure '£0 came an rscaré as
'A .§;"~3<}.2 is mfgiinzse the agpeaé. In 'aha affidavit filed :2:
2%
H
W
8. Having regard to the arguments advanced an behaif 91′ the
parties, the question to be C011SifjB§’§§(i is whether the applieani:
sheuld be permitted :3 come on recerd as as: assiglee to enable him
to coriiinue the pmceefiings’?
9, The suit filed by the plaintéfi’ ismfer e,n.’inju§{s’;f§i:(i1:::
restraining {he defendants from interfi-3-ring-._ wjéise .. AA
possession and enjoyment ofihe suit seheduie e1=e§e;1:§z. 7.ijhe..’jeeseVH
of the i;e1§:.;has”‘*’;§;;;1;eh§§SeziV~£i*:e prepefiy item the
pIaintiii’unde_§**.3 saie The piaint was rejected
by the eeurtjbeie;i%”3;ndve:qQ:eee_’7*;{isie 1i(d) efthe Code 0% Cfivé}
v*E§3e:”ei5ere, the aeplieant has filed the
abmre .3pj31§ea:£e11;eeei:iag pennissiosz ef this Ceuyt to came an
vgfecerd es gp’p:e;;;’a;;3iei.:;:¢1:2 if} career is centirme the appeal.
ye, Reie fie effiréer 22 prevédes fer ihe precedure in case
._ efe;esi;§1::e.e’i’3.”i befbre £33231 erder in the suit, which is as under:
5′
, é3’*’%
he camiei raise any defiance which assigmr £01315 not have put
ferward, An assigzeae pezzdenie iite is beund E}-* the decree’ Whefner
he is jeined as 3 party or not.
12. In aHa?1%’wHAR PRASAB sIM;H ‘;;1A:f %
PRAKASH zzswvpffisirr’ – (2901; 5 Jr 5?3;%:he “€;§i;.:: 523% A. ‘V J. J 1}
heifi that ikder 22 Ruie :0 pr0Vide3.’i°er__. ea.§éTs;A.V_¢’ji’
creatésn and desvakuiioiz of interest éuring th€:3}é13(§encj;’ cf :aé’;’uit,VfE’£
has been ‘$;z.°ia”i– siaéi be brought :9 3;}
and ifiéffiilfii beVs;:l’a;:sIc%<'_the: in the mbgect maths: 03*"
311i': is éeveijred $13 pendency, it is held ihai
g:§C§:,aE s::é;£:§';31ai§%AV: in s{::£'ziir:aaé__.wifi1 {he have at' the {Iieuri E33: 0:'
aga:i:1$t.%t?i?e-V_§3_e1*$§§f:~ §1;1§$r;–.:¥hQz33 sud: émerast has devoivefi, But. if
' VV '-..,f3;;Q suizzii is iai{:éQ…Ti}1e guit may be c:§f_s§1’1 upon whem the izzteresi has devoiv-ed? wéfi he
‘i ‘i:t9u::%<i bjé {E39, decree,
5
3%
EXE
Q’
(.
‘£8
13′ Yhe aibregaid principle has been reiieraied by
Ccmrt in JASKIRAT mrwpégwv 1/3. .P51l3DI€»=i§*i2i’3iT.::’_;f:§$TD _’ H k
OTHERS — AIR 2052 .-5′ 2186.
:4″ This Court 1;; .§fR%2*L%%»’%;%:.s*.Lc>;’;:§2:»1%I :23′;
MB’.;S’I§II-/;<iRAK4 & 01353.3? — iLg2é3':?7 am: 391:; v.1:3as..v§£1eid
that 3 iraxzsiéeree pendente Em-:' ' _i,mmev'abie
prepreziy which is £113 suhject ma%:te;'_ ::i'a–.,<j;1%; i;:~: 2s. yépgcéentative in
ixziersztsi and he5;i1:%fi ?;:f:'p$i§:1Vi1:te£?:1es.¢:.3§1ié":;vi;ecorc§ under Order 22
Rule H} ei”:,hE::. _Cé;>{ie af;:C£:€;f§§_ :*;~n¢eai:;;~.~:;_; %
:5. In z1′;l’%i1′””e’§;’:l:J}_’ii?i;;i?§”:’i§i?;i;4i@£”‘Ag?!) Azssorggg 1/3.
V%%;;4;R19;¢:%%k1g:g§2**aQ;v9& ‘;§.;%?'{}THER »– AIR 2995 SC’ 2209, the
€:i}£m’._ a transiéree pendants his $0 the extent he
aé{q2:»£féc;i Efum the defendant is Vitaily izzieresied-in the
iitiggtim ‘whiéfilef ‘the irafisihr is cf {he satire izzterast csf the
dfifiariahig’-..:he iattar having :29 more inierast in $112 propefly may
_:;’5§’ pfégperiy éefené the suits He may cofiuée: with the piaimifil
-‘E
=.\
‘if
Heme, though the plaintiff is under no ebiigatiefz to ma}-;_e-jj
pendens transferee a party; under Order 22 _R”s.1i§:’ H3 ai.1i§¢:1éé~:: = _
pendants hie may be joined as I}EiI’i’§f. the Ceuri’:1}as;’fcii3;.*§ét;{;fi’Aifitfxé V f ~ A’
matter which must be jxzdiciaiiy exe1*€{§s_e:d_.and’3.n xa1ien_ pr<3ftect.E1ia.i§;f§ereS§i.
BASS — AIR_!–9?5 held that Order 22
Rule ii} is trial cf a suit azzazrmat be
bmughi in an éixsi m.er§é.£§,_: {has interest of a party in Eh':
..s::§;3jss1:<)f' hag cievoixred upon amther durmg the
Vgzcfiniielncsg 7i°Ai§A:x;:–.;f§i3–it but that suit may be centinued against the
perékkaf ‘é§qui1’ifig,fi1é{ in£erest with the leave ei’fi1e Seuri,
K ‘V V ‘ s iéafiefi Qounsei far the responéezzig has giacesé reiiance
]:;::r: “éeeisgan at’ {big Cam in 2:M0§AMEb {;iS£.?’F Vs.
T §S’MT.R:i:N?G.$§£%L£ W WZP.N{}.21 53:22:23? dispoged of an 4.9.3307
§’
E32
$2
‘:9 c§:>n€:3.:3.d thai ax: &§§:”::’1s::e §%€§Eé§i’i??é.s:3 iéfae is :29: 3. ns:e:cs3:’a%:f§;
the precsadiazggx E2″: {E36 :~sa%=:.i EEK: gtziaiggiéff §:as.’§”§'{§:+.:s:3: 2-132:5: ‘§g:;;*
ggecific ;*>§:ri§33′.:21a::;:e {:5 an &g§”éi%3§E’:€§1i-,<}§ '§;&?-6: {§»s.z_£eai "§,'£".:§%;..}.'¥*1.T_'
aizgifiiifii i%1s3 éeééiifiazai. fize
cezzfse ma :*ea':a3srai as aéééiiaézgai i%1%.'g2*§é;:.z}éVA§v§§aE 'i§3:3};
Eéave 3&2 ufiéiviséeé saixarfc pr:3pa:§*:§;. Tizisz
C£:;:.::'£ iiéid iiaai 31:: _;3!2;.i11§i§'f-;gg;::.r1{f::i {}a'.'E'SC%fi agaémi
2:-=E;<:z:: Em §<3<:;-:.2:sI.'4c§i::;_;;::; asaféf' t_f:*:%i_§§. .5': ';§:&§'E}' ,s;:a::m§’ Saw. “,{“§”;ar piaégiiéfi’
is; ‘£26: §s:”3’§’:}§E”i.?:iS §§%a;§;”a2′;{§’ f§iz;:_ mafia? :2
a:{:s::”:§;:§§§é3:iL..::} figizii x2VégVi*1§;£”zSi 3 §’3;3%’S€}E”§ ‘»’€§’i€{3Z”§} 13:3 {Eats 32;}: aaé§:2§’§ iii?
;i:§5Tz;é¥_:é §i£:}%:§:€«.f§E:a:§ is-2 tzsé 332% §%;}§;§§§§{}fi £3: 3% §.’éE’é3?§s3§1§
L?i§%;2″-é[;j3§;§§’L3;駢i.,_<:¢§5;éta':i2é:e ihaii ha has §}iJi§"i;:§'}&.$€§ zfisés g,:r<};3s3fi§=' £3-meg
121$ :2e3::*::j& agségzae ufidez” {ézrfiesr 2’2 Ruie ii} afiiae {I’§*C1 Eéais E5;
. éésixié. ‘éagae ‘%’§}é3i’i’: 2: ‘ééxigsé §”}:»’;i§’€.}=’ fig gnaiiégig 3:”: agpéécaiiam ii} ::=»::s§§’:@ {:31
V’ “:*:;%€:e:f§ afi&ii%€>’na§ 駣'{é3§1ii?:E§1§. ofiififfiffiffiy Qéas: Sééirfi é-a::cisé@i3 $5; 229%
2-:§g:s§%§::a§§§a3 ‘£9 fizz’: facis a}:?’§§”;;aZ5; gasaz,
Ea}
13
18, It is weii settied that no detailed er1;.~:{1ii:”j!’at’_tl:§.;:
gaming Eeave under Clrder 22 Ruie 10 is contcéfnpizaigéki. ”
has only to be prima iaeie satisiisd £0: exefcising d£::e3fé§jdfi– §1i’ S
ganting leave far continuing ‘£h§e:~’s:;};i’£ bjgwji’ ‘the t’§’ei1′:;;e~n.vv:£>n
Wham the interest has cievsived .§1′;V:.§i’i#’£’.%’v”(‘)§§.i1i()1’l and
the question am}: ihe é¢:v<:i§t¢tf1se GI'
devohriion can be is 11% expacted thai
the existence iI;g:xi' {fit} vaizttacks er flefences.
W'f'}1€1§"£ may bevvéipeiz 'is mafia s.i';e:;ui:;i be gene into at
E%71e:sf£a.<2:e* of m'ant§i:g.V1eax%%; fiheiher the cause of asziion
giséfiefi :;£ainiii§§"'a:£§:§;f§;§ s:{0 'ihe benefit <;::.f the appiéaam £3!"
nsisi is r€§cfi.1i;'a:1_§’3f§Si6€i’€’§ at a Eaier stage.
i9:”{n :;3§-*.vié€w:. the appiicant shesuld be permitteé 19 came
aii”$,dfiétianai appeiiazzi mad he: Shguié bx: pemzifieé ‘:9
;e§fiE_i:§£;$”‘i;§3é appeal as he is an assignaa 0%’ the Stifi saitxefiuie
T ;:§§s§3ez”t§?.
$3 2
RX:
34
29. In the resuh. MiscKCvE_.No.9836/21909..is’ a;;¢w¢a;i%t::;e
appeiiant is adirected to implead the applicant a§§¥_§ei?iTva11t:T 7]’
he is pemfitted ta pmsecute the appéiafiiyfifipng Awifi:
appeliant subject 10 the obseniatigns nude iii’-pérggaph’ ‘i$..0f§?{i1is
order. Qrdered accerdéngly. ‘ ‘ : _