IN THE HIGH coum' OF KARNATAKA AT A'
I)A'E'I£i) TI 118 TE 11%: 5*" I")/W or H_«:1»3RuAI---2_jx° =
PRE:sE:N'_Ef..... ._ V fl ' . V 1'
THE HON'BLE MR.JUs;i?;c:§"'1\f.§K;P.$'r'Ii; fr "
2 %% A
THE HOIVFBLE MR.._ms'rIC_E:"B».,sRgE1\é:vA$E c;¥:)w1)A
M.I*'.A.N(). 32%; $9 :)F"2()O: 6 {1'\_/IV)
E315-'W\/f:IfCN:
%sm¢. Aslm Si'1ct'.1y.
I . .}z1y2f='z.1sj11.a"i' 'SV§v1t..'1;-1'}/, " x .
S/Q. E131 C"S}'%i.11k}fi'\"'\'i"i SI';@"1.1_y__.
r*\},{c.' £3'{T)fL[<'::1::a.;§ ' * "
2. S'm'es'~s§'1 S}'1vc.='1"@f;._Tb"
S/(5: }..2-111:: S;111_}L=A('\»*e,; "S.11c1'1'_v'.
_ ;-'\;;;e 3%»? '{trz11fs{;. '
V ('Z.\.:)§'§("v11'6(1 c:1"é":3*;'2'.'1VZ()I(;) in View (';E'11i.~1+ de2,111'1 on
E "E33"? ,_2U.Q 7)
A S;-.1:'{'i1V1:sI1."8i'i<*1.1y.
' S/0)' £;_;,11'E:* Sa11'T:'_j<?c:=\*2.1. S§'1t.*1I_\_I.
i\_1;i(? 3 Ym11".~';.
W'/0. Vastl Sl'1e':1}~u
Age 33 Yc'r21:'s5_
Miss ,(,.1cla*1y21ks11i {QT E,Jcia_v;.mE'11"i She-'Hy.
A;;'(* 3] Yc'a-1115+.
. * N<.i'1'i(.'e i-.as.ssc~.(i in MVC
_ R31' "c:V I'll0wi11g:
All 2111* ro:si(:1i1'1g £11
:\/§c)<')ciL.t]<<é1"c" (T}1.11.h11 II<)1.:s;c=.
K1-':11(ld\-'z--l1';:': \"i11z-Lga' z-111d PIl2i't'1{.$'--- 5'
{I3}-' Sri. I3 13112.11. /\(1\-*(')(:211'.c)
AND :
I. M/H I)11I';;'a1111l')21 M()%c)1's. K
1%:-.-*13r-c.sse.>111 ed by its
I--3:--m1?1o1'. N.I'I.l7.
KL.1t"1cIapL1r2'1. .
L}dL.1pi 1.)i51ri<rI..
pix
The BI'£1I'}{Th' IX/1a1I'1g1§{§,'t-*'1'.'
E\Iew I1--'1di'2..\ r'é1t'--1(5€-- .(Z<)'iLi d..'j.
I..»L1A.¢;'n pg.-x'fL%1 lifdiixg "'I\11g11'-i n R0":-1'ci~. 'V
ffiund_z11)'::.;r;;1_._ ' V '
L'J'.c.'§11'}')i 1.1)i:.sLf1'.i.r;'%... *
... Rc:~a}.)(') t1('1m'1 Le.-s
(}..T3j;"'~3;$i'i. }':. SL1 t'}l'zIr I\3;.1..I_'_"¢.1";y"¢1I"t R210. Ac1vc*.z.11.<? For R2:
V' . ''§}Ei?;K_:..is filvd U/S 173(1) 0:" Mv AC1 2.1g2:1'u'1s1 rm
No..._14a5.,r.2_0p'1 cm me rm» or m» § Add}. Civil JU(I§__{(.* (S31'.D11J
IV§;'\(.?'I'--\L::"a IVLF./\. e21l is a'1:'i;~siI1_g;' out of lhc' 1;::=1»;-;j::s.gm:(-1
_§11(1g1'nm11. zmd a-;1w2-1111 (..12;1t(=?(;1 09.09.2005 1.')2.z_s's':é-ccfi ~
N(.).148F3/i20()1 on the file of I130_,[.....A_(1di1i_t)¥'iéiV}"..}1.:Vdg§_§
{S1".I')\*1'1] ftiz M0101' 1\("{'i{t!(?t1I (iT.l21i11'2';"'s. '1"i."'i;'§')Li:i'1'(.l"§*.\7'§'_NI;-I1iV"z§;.f£'.?.\lA(;i;:§i{
I").K.. {hL'l"('i1'1£--[ffC1" :'(-.*1"e1'1"e(41 1.0_2{-11':'a._' Trib-1..iI'1zi1i' R31'
The "1"1'ib1.:11a-:10!"by. i":§ f'j1,i {1g§I1jC1'iI'». mad aw2211'c.1 hails
deI:e1'1'1'1i1'"aecl 21 s;';_;[1'11f_1 i':R':§.V'I ;£}0'.L«{);0./+ V-aij2.r;Vi' awarded e1 Sum
0? Rs.75.0(}'()'j' §é.,.\,.v.fl._fi1'1"1'1'.:1_ :.g;-M351" '..'211¢..'vat':/VQ . per 21 rmum from t'he
1.
(>\.:\.»’a=11″(.1v’;¢-. (ton1.1?i1’ju1’m;y’«.._i0’x:-2g.i~igen(‘c: cm the part of Hit”
(01ccca.asv(‘1.”:15 -a§._3;21-i:1$,_tv”i_«1:1~~L> claim 01′ the a}’)pc11an1′:s for a
$91111′; (‘V)f*.,Rs.5.VU'{);0()()/–. on :.wu1’11 of the death of ‘£116
:.1;'(‘%’t.*e1s§”§;(ii $271′, E.)i1’3cs1’1 Sl'”1eI’t”y. in the I'()&1C1 t:1’21ffict z;1<:.rCid.eI'11'.
E:3c%i:":g§_; lay the sziiicl _ju(.1gmc111. 2:1.1"1('l 2';1\»v2.1I'd. Hm
a1p.;__)c1121V1::IS0'hzixrc p:'cst%1"m:(i this appeal. for {:'.I"1h&i1'}.(?€i]1€1'3iI
01' (:':c:21fi;;)e;:1'1s2-11ion, on {Em _22;1'(')w1(:i that Hm axnoum
an-Vi':-;'&(.1cci by 11"1(_"I'rib mil is iI':E1dt.'C'iil£,11(_'..
:'y'_y_M_____'_m"__,,,,,.,,'..-w
'l'ril"nn'1e-:1. \\'}1ii'””’19_.I,.O().Qf’){J’/; “eiI’Icf1’1
em’aI”(!c(‘! a. Still} of RS.75.U00/V _£ifiI’§§l’ (‘iL'( i1′.}'(“.l”i’l”2’f_?’,”Z259/i) ‘
izm-’21|*c.is <'01|trib1:to1'y \\;it'T'.EW.._V_ 6%
13.91. from thv (:lz:1£_c (:«1§¥'po$iV1_. i:%ic=iu'1;._{
a;.§;.§|'ic\«'<*('1 by tho a'1\var(,.i. {P10
21 1,) pol Ea. 11 its h zfzx/é '};jj):Vi'E~ se:i:_1&1 i'sV if) 0 A
4. (101.1 |’1s<)V1 1('i.t,.:_.1'&:V fix' c()11':pa1'}y.
5 _AE'1v.Vr »<1;.1':'«;:.-'i'1.|l pL'|"tIse1} oi" ihc im;:')11;,.§|'1c('I _j i..|dg2;1'ncr11t
";1.1j:cf1" 2-i\:?\?§'1:'(:A1' *,_Dasse(1 by me: 'E'1*i}3L.:1'|aE. we are of the
*~.r:j(m_.~';ifiic:=a"i:i'–c1 \'.i.bw' 1.}"ui11.. thc c'c).ntribL|1my 11¢-r;;_{Iig;§('1'1c*c: fixed
by Mac .T_i"|*i%:31’_ a.1″IV(:’:’ p|’p<31'. Fur1I'1c1' it E'.l'1"1(T1'g't',S E"haE._ the 'I'rib1.mai
1"':_z'1L9"(%|'1'(..i in not en\?z’iI’c.fi1’1§__:” |'(:r2.1snr121blc;*. <"r(')|n])c|ase'i1ion
""1'c')we1.|"d\.:s: 10:-:5 of vs142.1Ec._ 1':re:1|'1sp<.)I'f:aIio|1 z.:r1c'% l'"1.:11(?m}
crx] )c1':.s* (‘()I’1’1I)CI’lSE-l1.i(“)l’1 nf Rs. 1 .00 . 000/ ~
w’flpM’_’_u’W_,_W….=.x
.(},
(“WIC1″i’:”1ii’l(_.’d 1);’ tin’ ‘§’1’il:)L11’m} is; iI’l2E1dC(]1.l£E1It’ zmd iE ‘1’1ccds
to be ,’C1′–(‘1zm–Sa1p;L?1*\2i’:i§(;:i_ SJ”) -Ca._”E3;.uf “zi1’1cVi7
R<.'st211.11'2_11'}1' aaui ('I:'2u-=v:'1'w' tl'1:L'~ Se-1lé.:.1'\f'–._<.)1' I{s,.4§,C)'(}()/ ')'cI' =.
z-» _ A. _ Av éi
morxth. E-Ian.-'i:":;_3; 1'crga1'd to andVUfiytfi;;5e.1t i{'%1';"bf the
c*1cra.~sc(ii emcl r9ii1(..’C” Mj? ()(.'(‘Tv1v..IHl”l'”(x'(“.i in the
_\_/can’ 200}. if t.l:1c l’l’1(“(‘)f1V’W.v'(‘é is taken at
Rs.13.000/~ p_&>1*”‘i§:1 ::)V11f1:’7–_«itiu and r<:2.1sc)nabl€
and 21<:*.<*1’c€”‘.:iV.i1%.§%}¥’;-§_x’V. V o’i’ wl’1iL.:}’1, if 530% is
{fled 1 ‘;3¢1V’V:;()n'(-1} &’.Xpt?flS(;’.’..~3 of £Tl”:e
(fI{i?(‘(?E1St: C1 15¢-1<*1'1c'I<):' at the tirrlc of his
(i('..'&I1H.~'1'.-» 1'11-Laii"1<"'t:')I1'1£* ('.(_.)1'I1t-'S to Rs.1.500/– pL==-:1" mrmth.
"I'.}ju3"" c_1é1:E%cr;-iVIsA<§_d_ was a;_{ec;i 21}3oL11'. 29 yes: and Iht"
'a}_)Vp1'"QTp-iii§.1–i;V¢% I'§./'E-z.!–vE'1i}3Iit?:' 2-1pp1i.('ta-ibio 1.0 i'l'1<-'3 ins1.a.nt. vase
'17";*«._i11,jeéé'c.:~_x:–"of Il"1ration and another 1’cp(_)r1.e(‘l in 2009 ACJ 1298.
“‘I’?1c-~.1’c’~§’. Fu1’tl’1c:’._ we 21wd.rCE a .
>sL:n’1 of Rs. i(),()()(T)/– ‘:.()\=m1’cis Irane+p?lié11’1i$.i’$..ai1Ig’>\».§9_i::iHiii
part and I”h(‘~ i:’1T11)1.1g1’1ed’j11tT1g§fi’n31’11’ ai’;c,i 2’»1\Vé1v:f(i’:g§£’e’sw::;e”d by”
the ‘£’1’il’)u11-(11 in MVC,.Nu. 148-55/:iZvOU’1._is 1’1i%’:fie}3’\rVAV¢1§”11odifieci.
g_§r£111E.i1’1g the <'.()n'1pe1'1séiticm / — i1'1st.ezc.i of
Rs. E .0 O, 000 Va rd b_ E! 2′: 1
Om dcdaxmcd 1:owe1:’*c1s:’s
c.’m’1€1*é.1:)uE();*y’724.4ggli§g:t1′;–{j€~Q1″: {“119 part. of the (ieceaseci, {.119
1’lE:’T (‘()i:a1p(’11s2’1€Vi_€i1€. ‘–<'€_£"3;:2_;ii*:s".':0 Rs.2.37,()O()/ Om. of
\»\-'}m;~Er. L i1' em-'211'cic*ci by the "E'1'iIm11'1z.:I is
cie'(Il.:i'('?ficr.i."– f:.1'1e VG':'i}'1a1:1('rc%ci (i<)n1pe1"1sa1i'i(_):1 C'.()£"I1("?S to
A R5. ;
“‘I’i’r6_”_v»I1T1s;),.V:’i”a’11″1c*(? Company is cii1″ec.t’ec1 to (:!ep0si1′ the
tr11}”2.2.1:11’1 of Rs.146.’240OO/V i'()§__§€.t’i”iE?1′ V»-“i'{I1’1
iAA:1i(“1*c-.:sv1._.i1t 6% p.z’:.._ {mm 1119 date of petiitiolu 1.111 the (131,:-.1
_c;3′ ‘I'(i.2;1Iisa»1′{:i(“m. wiihin 21. }’3€~rn'{‘>ci of four weeks from iiht”
<:i;;21£t <.)fa;1 c"ég_\r of {his _jl.:C1gl1’1C?l”1Y. z.m(.I a:\w1:’c,i.
w__W___WW_m.,MJ
E
Tile-* c-=’1’11′”12111(‘cd (‘nanpc*115z:1t’i{)1″1 $1211} be 1′(-‘§(“‘a15t-‘(IE in
{ax–”i*’I~»i<)1[1.
in'1111cdia1.c1y. 011 ('1Cp().':5i1 by me I1'}su1'anCe (-:()1'I',".l}}.'<'1'i"1_\."."'V:
(.)'£'i"i('c is (ii1'<?L'E.c=-.*('€ Eu ('1 rm-v the ;1\_-ya-11:fcT1";_Tz1ii'9C<'a1_'c*i§;zgiy V'
% «%§@5"[
35;/a