ifii TEE Rifiii fifiifiifi” fiF §(fiR?ii§T”fii(A §T’ 3AN$§§..ORE
DATEQ THIS THE 253′ BAY OF JUNE 200§
P§E§EiViT
Tfifi i*’i§?ii’3L§ fifi. 9&3.’ fiififiiififififi, €HIEF
fiffiifi
“YHE i~mfi*3:.E ¥¥§R.§Ei§”fit’:E vs. $n3sé§fi;H:*fA’%L’% ‘
Eetween:
K. Bast: Raga,
Sife. Ramakréshraan R.aj’z2.,
Ages? aibmst -63 years, ”
9′:f\£B% C.%.ass_I”a.’;s:’£§;?:f?g:.fita:r; ‘
¥\i0.6§,, E” =s*v::Voc:<, _
CQALi,ayei:t, ' –
Near Gama-sh “?’em;’:.E;:-zg ”
Sa¥*2a!<ara"m.ag;'5_:*, V' _ . _
Bang.aViore-S'6Q GEE. .. PE'?IT'I<1)NER
{Bi}.§rE.–,"~i2ia"g.araj$&§\i';"'?€Iva§du – fisdv. for ?et:",)
1; »._44"'§;§'ié2 VSt af'i§&;:rf Karnataxa,
Rasresefitad by its Sac:"a€2:–::*y,
£)e';};at*1-imam: of Cemmerce aria inziastrieg,
'A =%?e§.S."E:£%EdE::g;,
V. __E§:nga§ere~S6G GG1.
We Sugerérztenéing Engineer,
Karnataka %~iaa%%:%: Syswm Sevaéspment 3:16
Refcrms Pragectg
ff” Fmor, WE 8:,:%édéagf
Shashadri R036,
Bangakerefifii.
3. The Executive fingsszeer,
?:2:>%%<: Warks. Depaztment,
Hassan ifiivision,
Hassan.
4. The Ccmmissioner,
Bruhat Bangatare Mahanagara Pafike,
f’sE.R. $<:;uare, *
Bangaloreél.
S. The Executive Director, , V’
Ka;-*nata%<a Backward I§SS&?$"€€a§3ai"ti'?T_3E'%'a–t,
Buiidi-ng Construction Sccietm. .
Sevarahj Urs Bhavan, ‘ —
Vasanthnagar, ‘
Banga!s;»re~S50 052. H
6.”1″§’1ei\’ianag§ng:’i3ire<ftor,"".: 4
Gs3vernme;':t'§;1%':»4s§ Rserfi 7a5nd_"
'Training; Cez"':"tré}"*=. . ' A
(An §:_:_;£e=~2{%."a:i«%_s_h F'r¢je!ct}*–, '
Ra3ajina'gaV:?, Znd"i;fis€r§'aEAV'Estatef'
8a.9':_ga%._a:'%e'5-;':T%V5'.–..S'?*$;'«._ "~–.__ * – .. RE§P8§'%S§NT$
{By Sm.' §z:§sav'ara;ié'..VKaé}"ré3§'é§'y —- WE. Qovt. Adv.)
"§fh.es~e Wfiii 'F*e%éi;'io_ns are flied under Articies 225 and
2.2'? sfft21_e"v.Canst§tutEen of India praying to diract the
res;;:_}:1d_e?nt43 .Vnic$: to éeduct any royalty from the petitionar
(6.2-r1__i':En"g .§a:.e;;ri-<.T'VVbi'£'Es.
'~T:i'I§-Q59 writ Petitions are coming up far preéiminary
%:e%§?§n§-'er: this day, tha Ccurt éaliverad the fotfewingr-
ifieiiverad by P.fl._ fiinakaran, C3.)
The patitiener in these petéticns is a registered Civii
Qantracter carrying on cm? works ef the Gevernment
5:" 3
3
Bepartmerzt and was? 893395. ‘It is contencied that for the
gargmse af axacutien of cévii works, tfie petétianer is
requireai 2:6 gurchase msiiaing materiais fmm thé §f§\{éte
saurcesg it is further centended that the p€ei§i:i:§c;r2§eVV’rL:”‘c§%;2:é’s ”
mt awn any quarry and that ha -IE5″ mi: i%_;ab§_é ;:{7ay jjari’;«; V’
royaity is the responfienis. i-iowé”v.er;;._th:e :’Té$p on§er:?jéa”s«.a’fa._
cieéucting reyaity from ti1eV»i::.§V:§ii;=~’,V_%of pefgit-§§;fiéf’wéiihout”‘V
auiherity af Eaw. Hmzzg, :h’e:sa+xXf.?.rEt«»Eetihfifins.préying net
to fiefiuct the royaity ff§}m”‘§:_h§§é:iv§’i’§’i’;£§V ,/zine petétioner in
respect cf §i’§:&4 ;!:”f3__a:t:&If:I}AE§!Hi§’#i:§§§u.f§:f§’ from private
ssurces fa: :jé;o’rf§f£’V:?éV§cV§t works.
2. i%s:. ssmi:a–rj::1$a;V’c:+;:érg;*-ti¥s..2s Cam in 33:. Karma fiafiifi
Wiifiivzs £5; $”§’7}!%iL”..E’E ‘vifi%””‘ Kfi;Rf\ifl’i”§§(fi fififi fi”?’H€R§ in
ifisgéfitgzafzs §’;i §;””‘3i265′-*31255 of W94 dispased sf’ or:
has iaéd Qawr: the princépies reiaténg tn
%:’r:§”‘%§&%;_;”:;*§é%;_$:A3;s€r rsyaéiy by the canfractsrg. The same are
exiractayzi heraunaar: __
(3) Whare pravifiing the maferiai fsubjested
fo rcyaifyj is the responsibiiity of tire Q
contraxrrtar and ffze fiepartment pmvides the
coxfractar wish specified borrow areas, for
exizractisr; of the required constrésction
materséi, sire ccantractor wiii be ifabie is pay
A,
reyaify charges for ffze materiai (minor
mmerai) extracted from sucfr areas,
irrespective of’ whezfzer the contract is a item-‘–.__p
rare Cmtract 0:’ a lump sum csntract. 2-£e:T;£.*e{‘j<«.._
dedizctgcsn af reyaity charges in such Ca'S(?:§"V1ir;!VV{;ifi"~~:: r.-
be iegai. Far this purpase ;30n»ex¢;;;2ti:3;?' [hf
mining Jesse LS' mt refevanflés'«£7t2e"..Afiaf3iiié';%_
gay royaffy argseg an accoL.é';.: ofrfié éfa:1r:'£?r,z$¥<:£fég<'§~.'.,, '1TA
extracting materiaf i":fv.;i::r:___ a émrérnmerif j_fa;;2_d,
fer use in five work.
(.5) Where :« v.»§:z:%;2tra<:tAA H the
re-sponsibiiify to sugpiyv':f;'ée__._(%?é%'§3}'i;af (minor
minerafsj. tirafféf ' {fie Q:V§é;:a:fm,eéétjempi0yer
and ;if_2é_ cc:éir:§z§f5'c£";::f1i:<,fV reg uj§rédV:f5"proviaFe oniy
Z;-?_i:e._ f,*5s£;ic:'i'.u*~..;é%;*:eq' for execution of any
wcrfk' .inv:2i}ki:*: g– 919::-: "cf' such materiai, and the
_ mif Lfafe ciaeas A:3_oéf*~'i}7cIua?e the cast sf materiai,
zffzére is' he ,v{£a§£z:ifty an siie contractor to pay
afirrfy .%i3}{aity. 7?'2fs wiii be the pasitfan even if
'V ' rf§e._ '¢%:;2;"}%aCfor is requires' to trarrspart the
mgéeimi' fram ourszfie fiza wcrk site, 50 Iong as
" z£%';§ ijfiié rate SS 053?}; for iabour or gervice and
ciaés fiat ff°f{f§£iCi€' the cast cf materiai.
: '{5} Where tfze CGf?i'f"3Ci'Of' uses material
purchases? 1:: apes": marked, that is materiai
purchased from private saurces iike quarry
iease fzraiders Gr grivafe quarry cwrrers, there £3
4. Fciiwsirzg the ggamgment of this Csuri: rendered _in__ Writ
fixggeai ¥\ée.83€3 Q? 2096 cfisggsed of on 25″‘ $e«;jts$r?s=z.§;)”e:;f,
2666 these Writ fietitions are aiso diaposed sf;
83 CG Ci3$iS.
irmexz ?”es j~f\§§:>’–
\fiiej!:§§¥i:>st: Ye5s~.Z f*§é
.,