IN 'l'I'"¥E I"II(]}I"I C_',()UR'I" OF K;'\I{;\2'A'I'AKA. BANCEALCDRE
I")A'l'EI.) THIS 'I'I*iE iO"" DAY OF I')BCE1\/EBER 2009
B 13 FC) RE
THE HO_N'BLE MR.JUS'l'£(3E 5.N.SA"1'YANA;2;;§;'§%A?»:2x-T
RFA. No.8 1 8 OF 000 M
E3I3"E'\'VE§.':NI I K
1<.1T>A1...
as/0 LATE KEMPANNA.
AC} 13:1) ABOUT 55 YIC/\RS.
No.8. c;AIatK1;MAN';':--LANA A
I:>A_1:m <:.v.m\MAN :\.=;<x_<';';»x1<.'. _
E3x'\.N(.}z\E.()I21Cf36()('I)¥'):3. ...APPI~3Li,AN'I'.
{By 51-; G. 1,.\r'1s}*1x?v'A 1\IA'V'J"t-1:'. ' r{.:I;\f. ~ . V_ 7 ~
TI 11;: ';\/1z\NA( -,1.N<.j; . {j;zR1s«<..:"1':.,=sr1 IAN ';A.1.;Rr.);~:.;\'{*:'.;*1t:r:5
Li M m_«:1.:) .1-3AvN(_.m._I,<)£f<
1 m. Pcma. uB1'\N(..3z\I..(")RIC. . . .R.ESP()NI)I'CN'I'
. - A V"i~z"3:v s';*v,sIJ1/\$9 i*1'-ii.' ADV.)
" ;5if;.iS"T:= P§FA fi}c=::<.1 {.1/$.96 of' CPC. ag2';e1i1'T1&st ("I16
j"'--.1(.1;:.£"1"ic:"1'i' élllld C1(:.'.('.'.£"(_'€:" {:11} I.O--8--2000._ p2'1ssc?(i in
T(i.).Sv..N:n.1584/I991 on 1110 fiiv of 1"hc:* VII Addf. City
V' , (Ex.-'i! Juciger. }'3an§_;e1}1"c-'. ('iismizs-$i1'1g the Suit for
p1'm;21.:1cm i;.1j1.111('EE01"}.
"W
"1'I'1is RFA (*0n1i11g_{ cm for 1'1.n'1hcr z.1;'§_§L.111'1c'==11t's {his
<':i2;1_v. the Court <_.'1cIivc*1'('c.i Elm 11)i1(_)wi1'1g':w
JUDGMENT
This is pI21i1″1i.i1’1’5 e=:ppC2:1i C112i1it%’i’1gi1f1g_{_: ”
_j1.1(1g;11’1c111 a1″1c’i c’ici'(‘r:”(?<i2 (.1ai'c<;i 10.8.200v{):'~..pé1ssed __i4n=
C).S.N.1584/1991 01’}. an» ri7zg~ (:17 \/:iE :’~.\ E1ci’l)” ‘(E”iVfy.’_&C3if»_~Aii
JL1dg<:. Ba11gai()1'e vvhe1'<Vir1«…_1'}1e Sim 31' 11~,|jé:.pl.e1i;1f,ifi;f0:f
pcé1*1'r12me1'1t i1'1_}"u1':ct:i<)1"1 I1s:1s___b'w:_1'1~..giism.is5s<;é{.i. V
2. ‘1’hc (%e’1é3(=~..«_(‘)E’ U10 p-1’_i1′.1i’i..tf£’ than he is the
s;()iL% zilqd’ ~aj”o_:s(>l{:.V1’t’L’ .( )’\?a.\1’1c:’ in pc’)Ss(:s-;si01’1 and c%1″1j(>y111ent
of :;.1xf:’-1. Cx’£1e111 ””~ K£:l1’V1′:E&lN'(:.).287 1. G2,1ri.ken1a1’3t.hna aiva.
V-‘:C3’:;V;:-¥’§ama11 Ba11’1gz,1lu1*c– ~ 93. ‘1’1’1<;* ;'_)Ia_i1'1i.i1"I' is the
'"g1*;1:'1V§i*S0.1'i'elf ()1':c? Ve1'1}<atasl"1e11nappa who t':1'_1e head
W 01 :"]i$'jG'il'.}::1 family (f(.)11Sisii1T1g of I'1im.s11″ a1’1(i his; two
$”(‘>1’1SA viii, om: Kc-.mpe11’11121 z=u’1d M1.111iIwm~(.i 1;-md be->z:11*i1’1;,,{ Sy.N(.>.2l/1.
‘*E53l-‘_N(‘).E39 e.1:1<"l Sy..='\'0.b'8/4 1c':;,_{e!'§1c1' 1"11e2is111'i1'1g..§ in 21$} 7
W':
.JJ
z21(‘1’cs 20 g1.n’1t2.1s situz»-11.i1’1;–_=; at C.’r.11’ikmm,11″1thema Palya.
K.R.l—Iubii. 1’32.z1’1f_{e;1!<)1'c Sm11'l'} '1';-;11:.1k. In the yc:/a1" 1943
an c-'xivni ‘!.”5 z=-1c’1″cs-; 2 f_{1..11′]ia:1s~s 0111’ 01″ 7 2-u*1’cs 2().g_{_n1’1t.a1s
xvas 2’1(‘qui1’cd by the C}o\-»'<r1'1nm*111 1'01" the 'E;1L=1?11–£=%§i'i'i1'<.0f
(Eefm'1<"ie1.11i C()I'1'1}Jé1l}_V.
3. I1. is the case ()I:’* th'(}fT *}jj1’a2i’nt iI’£
(}(‘)ve1’11n1<m1. 21('('1I.iil'C'.(_1 21 .1_'V)4("3~:.Tv1'i()l1 '{3ff §'2[11f1"Vz';-V_léifid' €131' €'lT1€"
13c11Cf'if" ()f1;.hc* d&?ffi'?l'].d21I']I' in–~-cl'-.1:1"+:Xts_j111' <)f1'i2~–';1(:.1=L5es and 18
;_{un1:a.s was é'1»rE-Iii;-"l'l.)V'!.£i' 't'o_ 3*f':£'1<.Véimily in Sy.No.69.
S1}bSL'('1U"€?lf§?_vl\,' §v}"1't' :f;Vw';s.~; 2:. (am! p2.11'1iIion in the? f2;1miEy
of S;-«1id= Vca1'1}{2.1._1a_s!'1~:;=;ii'1«;rpp;,.1. w1'1cr1"oi11. Sy.N0.69 was
("i:iwid<'(1 '{?'c;1.te1'i1y"13{?i.\xf§i.e-'1[1 his two .=-sons; Kempalula and
' "i'AiT11*1'i§<231'riy21})p£1"éi'i'}(i ezlcrh one mok 1 zzcrc 9 gu1'11.21s to
V,111611.1"?'1ig:s}'JC(:Vtfi\rc' .<s!'1a1'<-;: in S}/.Nn.69. Aft er oral pa1"ITi1:io1'1.
"'r,rj'_'c=*111m£.£1$1":a1'n2.1;.J1._3z':'s 5-son Kcr1'1pe11ma (ficci. In the ye-21:"
A j 1983,":-1 suit' for pe.u'titio1'1 \.va._~; fiicrd by (')m:'. of the sons
V' 'H(.A\£'!,!.J".:-11C.' K('1'1}p&l'1l'11'}2} in ().S3.I\f(').522/ I983 011 {he fiie 0fV
Adcll. City Civil Ja1;1’1I. of 2:xi’c’m==*s;.ai(i rival (‘n1″11’c~nti(.)ns. the trial Comm
f1″;–u’11cc’l the ih}10\\ri1’1;_{ iS$Lit’.’b’.
1. \?\f’hcI1’1té1′ the plai1’11.ifi’ }.)1’0vcs-; than he was
in ]3()$S(‘SSi()I’] of Ihc suit scr11r:jd’a.1l<:%
E)m13c_~1"t_v 21$ on lhv (law of suit'? V V V
2. W’1’1c’i’11r 1111c-= pl;-xmtifi’ p1′<.)\-fess
obst moi icms (1:23 1.:.sc$"l3_\r ¢1.11%; d¢f'é%nd;'1i1tf.?',
Wl3e{.11c%:" T,l"l§§ _piaii1–.1_Aif'Vi7.. ?(:3.ri:.*..ViAVtfie:V'& V*fcV)V'r< V
P3
pt'.}'I1'1'di]E:'.1"}{ i1'1']".,1_1'VV1"£-'.U()I] ass ;V)1<a.y_edV":f1)Vi"'?
_ ; \7\/'V¥'V:f1r;=¢"'.~. <i:~'r».fVE?-2"'? V"
‘}V1″iV”{V}’V:1′..’f Vs…ea_iVf1».};”:*cccdi11gs. p1e’1im:ifi’ exan1ine<:i
1'1i_111se}i'VV£1S_VPWJ eV*:.11ci" 2 other wime:ss<:s as PW.2 and 3
"M1cE–.'"mé'u:}V(‘VVu1m=?111s EXP}. to 8. T116 c1ef<=:11d21nt
VV__-eX'a3».zj'rj_;"1'c<iI*~1:513;es of its (_)i'iVi(.'e1"s an f£1'1gi1'";(:c'1' 21$ DW. I zuld
*~I.'1']e.t1f1x(?(i
d()('LiI1'1t31"1F. Ex.E")I to D5. Bélfitid on the
j pl<.%a.c"E'i1"'1gs, om] zmd c:i0(:u1'1T1u'1'1Eary (.r\~*id<==;é1"1('(;-, the C<:)u1'1
"Wt
bcloxv ('1isn1i.ssc"<T.i t_l':e2~1l the’ trial Court._..:f.¢’L:r.):1’d”;u921.s
b’€’.(‘1.11′(?d. 01′) ;3;<_)i1"z5_{ t"hmt1g___{l'1 lzhc cmi_;'ér,r€if()1'd the': '
IbIl(_)w'é1'1gg points zzwiscs for c'(')1='gsidcé1*a:..Vi(.)1"1 ()f'~C(5LE_l_"[{.'
.1. \rV"I'1e1:'hc:*1' I11¢;p4ie':i1"1fiflfE213 _I}1°'f.i1'.1.';: i f"s1L'fii(.€
cs{2[:i')lisl'1c(i l.lI'21«.l_:F2ji'11 vx.1'(.:-*–:.1_lV.'c'1;[f'_ 2 18
gunias in Sy.{\1c.3«. 21\raiilz:–b.E{3 t0 his
Iiunily _I':I'1«;n fa ailcmied to
hAiV:11 in 1_.h..{}) 5:iVE31lA"(V.i_V $_L_11"'.\'Ir<T:_'y"':i1L:'i111)&t1' to his
""" . _
V W I'z£{_!~i:1{:':'.._ i"ia.p.~ pla1é1'11iET 11213 p1'ovt:(:1 theexi.
»tE'1(11.1lL2 pmp(=’=.1’1″y is p()1*{.i(.m 01’
‘Vs:-a..iA<T! Syv N<).€59 of Ga1*ike-%n'11harm Paiya'?
A “‘Wl’1r:tI’1er the _j1..1(‘lgn1e1’11 of t”1’iz~1i Court.
r -:7
w
:=i*vqu.i1′<'r(.§ Eu be <:(')11E'i1'1n<':<:i or z'c11'12,:11c:1(:d
for I'1'cr:s"I'1 corxsidera1.i<'m'P
1'-\i"t<*:* hez11'i1'1§_§ %)oth <_*<:)1.11'}sels this C01.:1'f'
"a:'1:sxvc:1' 1'11:-'? p<n'1""21 f\Ec).! ancf 2 in m;*;__§at:ive. E:1l'1Ci a1'1s»v.:’
“*1
Poim No.13 h(>lding,’ E”§'”1&H t.i’1(‘r suit 1′(;’C11_ii]’t.’C1 ___10 be
re1n2,1:1dccl ibr fo}1owi11g i'(‘£.1:-5(.)1″1S.
8. It is .<;cc}'1 t"I'"1et'£. in the <._)1'igi';-.1_é11
pl;-1.i1'1t.iif \VE'iS 1'equi1'ed to ("és»tA»é111)1i.sj_11'..« 1'h21 t 'V _i l'1Vcj'- s1,'1.'i1.
sc11cd1..11:’ti4<'m"'.g')f Sy'.VNA(')'.'69 x.1*:§._ oi? ‘vi-‘Iikgit.zisVl’n_;1;§a’1z1ppa. ihmily. ‘I’Ir1e
suit .”,-3(,”].’}L”.tfi:_1′.l 3.’_(:T 1’5n’>p”(:if’i-,y: “*i..~r;’ e.i’»1i(5tt’eci to the slndre of
pl.’-.1V’i._;”1ti.1’1″‘ in’V(}A1fip1″(mi”isC ‘<:ic(*.rc:*.e said 1.0 have been
].)E:1SSC.'uCH1u._'i"l}_ 19%-%3. '1'i'1()1.z':_3;l[: the (:c1't"ifie(.1
v~~c§';)pyA'(')i' _jL.1cig:'11g§_1}I. in the 5-saiti suit: is p1'<)du(".<-'id it is
1'1t3i'T,_h t31"«1fié'1._ifk(¥Ci 1101' lxélieci upon by {.116} piairariff and
'E';iic% 'siiiiiis (_fc;":<':iclc.(1 in the abscncfcr of rclevam'
(iu('i.:=;1'1(=2:'1i.s to })l'iH1d 't'a(;fic cs1.abiish the t'it'.1e anci
;)(:)&5s;.Jc1’ty by 1′.1’1.cr p1aim.ifE’.
11:. is the case of the p1aim”if”f that on 11.3.1991 he
“”7
1)1″o(im.~v(‘i <ficrE'ific{:'1 <.'<'.)1.)y of 1.110 j1.1dgn1c11I passc.c:1 in
(").S.I\?o.58i3/1981.13 2l1'1(i1 £L1."S(') t.1’u’:1* !’t”‘1L’\-‘&ll11 (1″(){V’¥’i-1’1″I’C}”1E”S
10 dfi-‘l11(I)1’1SIl’El1.t* that the suit s _–p11′()}’3″‘L=–;*-:’2;;'(.i. fI”.!i1«r1Ai’1g{1i’–»..§:.11e: Séxici. (..!{‘>(r:.111’1e1’1t.s
xvmc-.’. p1″0du(‘,ec1 by ‘$11111 E~}9″i,11e has 11ei£’,her
n’12u’kcc’1 1″hi:af ‘cio_<'r1.1z_fic1'1't*1'1a_)1"'«l.{%'«:1 211135 c';§.vi(1e.1'1(%e thereon.
IE is 11.1;"t'"1'1?§y1fV$<?§§;_3 Ei'iV;~1.1:."E~.}1<$§_1g3ji 21$': }')E'1é'1E"€-'(i st':-igc-' in the
p1'(:Vs't're=e(.i'iT1'3gjs ioé'1.ff<$1':;fi f1'.1_£* _4EucigT_,{111c11t. coL.11d be p2.1s.<.5ed. an
211ic9113}§€:_ Visa V'i;!.:I'é;1('f(?.H131}; {he pI2:1i11i_iff by filing an
a1.}.)pli('rVE31%:.j;Aj11. ()1'1._1(}.,8.~2uO()O u11(.1er”‘b::i11g 11>. _ the ri()i’i(.>e oi’ t’.I’u;’ Cm.1rI.. 1*egarc1ing 1:119
_ I€xiS’1″{‘:2’1i’eof su(“1’1 (:.l<')('L.1m€1'at.=s and its l"t'}(:'\«'2:1l'1(_',C in t.'he
V'__–.S{Ii¥f. b_Cff{)Vl'éTVj.1,1d§:{I}1CI1I. is f.)!'()l1()1.1l'l(iTCC1. the {Na} C,'(.)u1't'
'A liens n<_')':'i'j_<"'.. In fl-1m the c.i<:ume1:1is
1Ii1<)1=z.V_,§_{l"a'vé§21ic'1 ("'0 bi" 1'c1(-=-rv21:'1E for i'§'10$c:' p1*(‘:cc=cii11g$ were
A Te;w21:’vl;«fi:>Ie on 1’c<.:<.)1'(:1. 1.)1'(')p('.!' 2i11CI'1'1pE'I is made by
{'.1'1c pie-m1:.il'i' 10 got 1' hc sa.1111c==;' 1na1"kL==td 2-11"1c'i 10 rely upml
the 5.5211116. The (.T<:n11't. has also p1'<)<_'ceciE:<'i to c.1_isn1iss
me z:11.)p1ica£.i011. whiE’; xvas {“1196 by .«_”‘h_i_’I’:’.1 ‘*._a1′
pemxltimelle siztgt’ of 1,111.9 1,)1″<'.)ce('*(..1ings.
9. At this _EllI’1(‘I_l_lI'(.’, vT:;}’T(7′ ‘cr)L.11i_se3_,.flit’ ;J.;jp-E%’1lai’11t”.
s1.:bmi1’s that t.hc1’té. is 1223399 (‘)1 ifli.h<=: pa1't o..t' {.'}»1L":}5i~
1';.1»f_if{_:
maiflng r1eccssa1*y e1pg)I’i:.:;i1;.i;):1 fm-. V ;1.p})()i1:1thicaxltt of
Court C()n1rnissi(:m’c;f f<.J1',Aitf1'e:'1_:ii:"i("i'ajion O1""i'1'I"e property
and also Iaring it 10 I1}1c~'-a'£Ui.i<§(§1"<:'i'f~.t.h;g:: (%01.m who
a:1('i 1'0=r'I.I.': e i:'fp$é*::s, iii/Tir}iVi_T*}'1' ai1*c c<)mn'1ii.t.e(1 in <;r(;)1"1c11.1ct'i11g
the (%2.1§$’}.1()l’1EC’1 A1’1_()i» _1:”c,.s;11l1′ in 111is(“z:1:”1″ie-1g._{c of’_}u..s3tic*.<:% to
_~L'{':1e:Vpa1f'{.ies." ""?fEj1Ht&:1.x2 is 1110111 in {"1163 submission of the
"'<-:()1iv11}3st?I%"v~. ' i"£i'1_1' plaillfiff~E1}D})C"H2i1l1E. which requires
(*0usi('i'é:'j_aI5iei:T1;___§ not 1’nz,11*kc.es.<:;2:11*y to :'(:1"112u'1d the suit for fn-;*sI'1 cé()1'1side:*21'1'i()r1
"*1
' _}2!.s()-Vta011 that’. 111231}! be filed by
3!)
in :’!’1c> I1′;;l’1t (.)’E’1.h<fuzn111:-‘;. wI’1i(‘i1 arc’ p1’ch:(.:c=:ci by
the pIain1i£”f 011 11.3. 19$-)1. 1’m.:c’l1 1)(>fr(? the (“(5180 was;
E:al~:m’1 up for cvic’k>1’1cc 01’1’_hc–.* p:;.1l’E.i€”S and aim) E0 ggx»-*6?
f’u1″Il’1cr opp<)r1'.1,.111i1y to thy pIai111.ifI' 1.1’_'”s.€:e1<
app0in!'.n1cnt, of (vrnmissior1cr {or proper icE;er1'1t.ifig:_ai1fifm.
CJE" t.i'1(;? pr0pert.y.
10. Hcncre, for the ;.1_ik.>1*3:>s;-1fii(i1*151§;-.____ I’*h{f
_jud;§n’1er11. and d(“.'(‘l’G(;’ })£1’S§bi.I:7(ib_\F :Hi_1(“,’:’ 1..ri2rl”C.(;u.1ft. djateci, 0
10.8.2000 is sci arsicle anci’-f_i’1c__n1.2’1ti’e.r_is If-?n1a11ded
b2–i._Vb0o{“h_ lie” pa-u’11’es 10 lead furt”her
c’)\ridc*1’1t*’cr.._4Vw§1″l1′.11*Ff(:”1*r:j;::i'<?c' to d(x't,.1n1(-;:11ts. whi(tI1 are
aEi–:¢ad'},' on 1'E:__1j_gjI.v but 1101 i}1E1I’kCCl in t’3Vi€}€I’1C(*? and
“.1.!”a’*c4111 i0–§fj_ e::f.)p()i1″1tinlm1:. (‘.>f Co1nn’1issi11er Lo e.1s\«-‘e1’ ‘{.h.c:~ suit”
0 5$b.’i~I1cr(.l:.:Ic? p1′()pft}’1c maiim’ on 1’11c31’1’I;s
“W:
wit’I’1i1″1 9 mm1t1″1.r<:i€*r.
Ea-{€11 of the ;:)2’1r’t’.ies 10 b@21r (.’s;Es ITfl’:iS .&1’1′;v;§5<i~21:1';*' : '
VN