K M Byrappa vs Venkateshwara Prasad on 9 November, 2010

Karnataka High Court

Author: Subhash B.Adi

ﬁi Tm E-a:§§sH Cii:}E_E’§”§’ SE? E§&§§f€’};”‘&§€Zﬁ £2″

§2%;E7E§ ms ‘§’E$ aw’; may §%’»A«%j%’g?:}’%’;§a§.”*§E£i’%’§V:i’3″é;§§i.§C:?. V %

E§:_:£=:”,:E§<__ A % _ é .

Baﬁmg :s@.J:::%§’2*:§g g*;:_:§r::a«$§§
%E2@::mE g.@§g.:jj:§a:,:: «§§ §::ié*_2§<3§

3§;LK.§.E'&'§ﬁx?F*.§;.

3;ﬁ§£E§%§I$H&§£;&§%.?:§;.
.&GE: 3% yg:A¢:%;%Vm§Aavﬁ§-zq _ % _
KA$A% Ham: J
€’eE-§§{§%§:.§g§..r?’;E*E;¥%f:”ff§}é;;”{,I;%’_E*;.§é?.r’Z¢:% ~:%;s;; AwELm.r~s:s*

gm a1§::,g,g:§;23?29r%:agé;,% ‘$3255 yam ﬁgs, E,
$RE§EF*19s4E3._§%s.’%-;$£}??;§é§?§’1’€;?$;;..§gs’3§’%i§g_¥;g s2.;§;%”
ﬁ€§1§§%’$E£;’ ‘ _ * _ 4

ﬁﬁﬁ:

……………..—.-….u ~

A j8’§’%3V§é:$%:{:?~I$;¥i’E{am&
X a:3E;J’-ﬁgéjmsmsi
R.g§%.%§;g$.§§i;}*sz% GEif.’:LE

$E;§§£&i?i*;’;%§’_fJ –

.V — 3 am

I ._ I-ISEEJE

4-mm

‘ 3, ..f§i%°:a.e<'..% i3?s1_it is <;::;.§ fa?

' 'tile éaéazziéisgzitﬁ is gxwuia

ewm? 35 33.2%: gchﬁuéa '2

Em}

— 1 :53 513$ midgr ﬁg’

ma: aggimz {Em éfﬁﬁf §3;’?.2{@§ pxa:%$éé;~.’i:g:€..T’
1*§€:.3.§§§;§%§§ ms; ‘aha $33 6? file Sivﬂ ‘

Jkﬁﬂ ~$»§z31sl»:ba%y:;:*§ éigzafzsaérg

a§g:sa1E&z:i Ezgraézz far gpaciﬁc §}¢rf$:%§ﬁIm:§.?r;;1¢._§::£T_§.§g§3.2§:g.:;§.§vvV ”

Caugidﬁiivaxﬁ the . _

‘, :’

éiemree détgzzi am Juciga :33:

mg; ﬁg ;.z?m§%

mfi}. ‘m wfermszii as pea’

2,” §’¥;:>?’ $13
ﬁwéz’ ra:{2;§aaZ:1Lg§§-4%;z:’v§%§-f§”zF;::§’£i?§::s:;.:*:§

‘ §:}a=:r£2%3§%2’m£: £237

3% gmg 3a.::2g§;@4 €53’ ggmnégm m

Earﬁ gala ﬁsaﬁii iii famizf sf

%;;g§;g;;g;g§.

§, ‘§% aﬁﬁ $3′ gig piaixiégﬁﬁ’ 3.3% :%mt, ziﬁfﬁzﬁaﬁt Eiiﬁmig

ﬁIZ§EI”‘&’§ Eﬁm an

agwméiiiz sf gala mi: 3§l2,E.§§éw fag’ a irmgﬁidagatiam :3?

& § ¢::e.§m*

r%~ﬂ«

qr-o

%Z:,2§§§%3;’- and éfmézéwd §,E§€3§§;1€}§g’w $3

rgﬁmtraiiézzg $22 ihﬁ ﬁam $27

— %§ §»i§:,§$§ §~ wag $3 $3 ﬁéé

9373.}. éaiismmé wesmgimza Ea: i°r:rifm:;s..2:4=”¢;§.’ ‘é§§se *’

tbs plaixazéiﬁ’ a§p§:*§:;s::3%3m* s;i$f& }::§;§n”::€;_ §*§<'.,éi;§;V. {Ema

I@%'r:ez*ai miss = »- masam
égafenégarzé ﬁg: Qaie éas-2%. ﬁr:

§§.4~.;§%, §4.4.:9%,
wfmraflﬁ fﬁirmzg he Emﬁ $ﬁﬂEE
£216 3..§;.§V4″1§§3 ma. gs: vém $2′ am

aaizi p:;§s:g%;g.;:§ a 5%: géay by éafendarzt

V £133: zﬁﬁfaziziant §§$.:2 Emd ﬁlaé &

§3,§;§%:?;;ﬁE§§§% mg gm &a§’sz:z§mt’5

& % .%a::’.fr3″s}’% :i5«;=’# ﬁefﬁifzégna

. * m§°§:%%§§ 3:13 sgéé; 32.21% a’%s&§’§$’§2S§’f£’

rg:.m:%§za;i’k*%%:a.%;:%k§:aa amiééaa’ mg: éﬁ GzSgf€::.38§§1§8%

$3 msther

=, éﬁfaridant 3%. 3.

zém gfmzéézzta ammr 3%’ ﬁgs §r$§&:*:lw in

3§.§§$E1:”.;z§f§,§ §,5i§g’:13; gm E551 ﬁﬁaf thg dézaih $2′

V Vv .é&§ez§5:§ats1:: Ema rm: exmzzzéziﬁé $313 .:;–:5.

*’ — éafaﬁéaﬁi 2%.; msaaétﬁi a apﬁﬁiai

a:5!:m§*r%* fgvmzr 3? ﬁx

af agwﬁzézzt ef gals in favmzg ::;f”»%:E’:sa; 331$?’

afémttiﬁ aim’: Em wmzld mamata é
in $3,a§sm;5§ ami Sy,}f$sg§§§;3:§_§. 5% k%::§§;§,

aﬁmahaméaﬁ 3&1: s:%””§;%:aV.:§§m§t}1m G?
defenﬁaaea ﬂag}. :_:ﬁ3§;:zéi;r§xg’% ;’:{€s}§, imam Em
ﬁbé mi: :;g,g*g4%?; mm mm;

‘mﬁz ﬂﬂiiﬁ 3;1ae:» fﬂaﬁ &;3§3§c:.atim’:
in ;a,s§:%.;’ ﬁ52}$§;%§§;§ *§;.%§$;§#§3a§g };§§§ fa’: impiamirg

hm’ 333%’ 33$ aaaigi Saiﬁgﬁﬁ, Eifﬁwﬁﬁﬁfg °§}%

withﬁmw thus $’:.2.§m an rim

ﬂag mm? hag haam aaéﬁagi mg? $§ iﬁaurtg

V’ éﬁﬁitﬁ $1? 23% regwﬁwci ﬁammzdg

Vvéima %3ﬁ$ & ‘Ea ﬁig éézé 3:332? far agaczéﬁs

w*;:3ﬁ%ﬁ§:e. ﬁiﬁiﬂmﬁﬁt ?:ﬁ§:ﬁ’~aE§a =s§E§§”f_g’;’;§’% the

-9%>”€f?:

agrgamszzit aéaam 3z::,:§,:@»% am: fmizeg ¢img§::g§k¥§§gé
2-mg agzégma gmmgim ﬁg” the gmg.

Haa§’i&sz&*£§ Em a&@1’t:&& tizai. ha §}§;;aii»AA»Vé§52éEs?s%;:;¢;af:*e<€;i_ a:'3#::§%:;is:~,¢aV:L

24,4, 221% {E3 ﬁn saga pawﬁft .§¢i' ?a.:<a;~;éa.é§§+L ~ _
ﬁxmﬁtﬁﬁ am 12,2g3.a%@2 Egg &:1ﬁ~.'ifi§2aw i2'::¢«:';2':m: Ha

was allgaai {Eat mimumé

a wig: an zixzmém "mggga A i;e;;,§;2%:*%g§§?2ag:- sfmm gr rm

gm M' £1": famur
af' defméaaéi E13 harzi axamztsegi an
sf ﬁafsnéazzﬁ Eagﬁ
13%;' a mtzé mg: 9? which,

§,%,Q§Z';s€f:*»;"§ *§e*a.§g an?' ﬁdvwm szxﬁ

*3; 55 """ H iwé mzﬁ he aémita zhai dafamﬁamt

gassﬁséagz ﬁﬁé ﬁ§3j?.'3:§:Eﬁ§fE€» af ﬁx

Fgﬁgié filﬁé aaﬁraiﬁ wrésaizan

H H " éﬁmyizg rim": mam is 3.23? agfaaemsnt in fa%m22:' syf

mwﬁzztﬁ gay §e§ar:2dm'€ $9": amﬁ ﬁigzi

~. %;£f'1i¢%r& ﬁg am

ﬁg E313 famzﬁ' and ; J'

xthaéi: the pégémﬁg 'mama £3 g:*a§ 'éém gmwriy paynﬁ'

4(;7'3<''";'"''
\ K '

ﬁﬁﬁﬁﬁﬁf =~ ami f f

, =
23?}

pasaeaémm mzé sar;§a§=*m;e::t mi" the 3:35;: am.'t'1e§.gié- _

ﬁx £3 yagmzlaxme es? 231% f:%§§;_. ;"§"z;.,Ii.s:;};


frmmé 3% fﬁlkwigzg igaum: V

E,

 ._ 

"whﬁﬁmr E313     A'    Elm

scigafaziéaﬁi 3g3’§{i’1’%.’§ T $3 ségfﬁiiv maﬁa is
him M rmivari
R5: 3 éxazuiﬁ Elm
J , 3%-.?§*’-9r and 3&5
aa5f”a%3V;§mpm=ty”?

” gmsgm ﬁmt E15: hag

éézzzaﬁm :23 parfzzrm Eﬁg

. _§%mt é:’.§;E;z.%.:;mi’€ra§%t?
‘ g is zmtitiw m a aiwrm

as grajgai Fm”?

am the pa:-ﬁm miﬁitieﬁ?

Esazmas
§rﬁ a w% W313 iy amuirm ﬁy him made?

ﬂaws? i?$5.é@§5

an T;

§ E3’% ﬁg .- — .-;

mémuzaﬁ §§§1:”;ﬁ&i:=- 3,?

: H’ 3.”

§ timé
wag Ewviﬁ ifazasfamkéa iitéa in

éﬁfagzdggai

” mg mg’ 5.3

fziemw, ﬁe §3}a.%2?1’§i§ ﬁg ﬁzz Eafﬁrﬁ T =

aim wit gawrty mam
agrmmmiwssg wiamztﬁd?”

w§%$m m the €¢§ gs–‘§3s;.*:ri%ae 3?

$3} ‘

ﬁlm ﬁgfﬁﬁﬁﬁi. . bf §éff$:%3;§e::’.$s.ﬂ%*3§ dgfmdmt

Sal gm’. hizméif dgfgzzéam Re’?

get and amazed me
$9 F’–%? were mmisaﬁ
ané $33; §3§f£:;:_’$Ean§%%?:f” :3 343 wars; mmkai £11

thﬁwéﬁﬁszmza ” _ A

failﬁ is grew ma he was rmdfg mﬁ

parfgrm his gag”: ﬁg mmﬁaai amﬁ $smc:ﬁ§§g}§s’

*s§;’w méﬁ jzzﬁgmgtfzi: mﬁ

fa,

V ma? :-.-

gg ﬁxéikéiggam gmzg iegzﬁaﬁ

méﬁrﬁ iﬁiﬁ ma ‘V

— ‘ fag» the phinfﬁ” mamgma

aamzgaeé whirgth 53 cigar mm §;g%m%:§«»w,

agammt £21 famézr mi” ééy; b:; ‘$9,: ﬁg
aka: 51% ﬁcsm ﬁy
aefmém: rm, 2. it:V_fav0u§*..9.f_ 3&5? sghmsn
éaﬁenﬁargi mi agﬁ-amen:

in {mm af A’ arzimiﬁ am, in 3.9%

his mgiémr, §;1e::;::::g;n;mi iéazi aim awacraztaé arz

may E? 1:5 Ema aim asﬁznim

thaﬁz vizatgamuia tém 333$ émai £3: fawn? mf

af E2235 mniﬁéﬁr arzﬁ aka an him

._ 3:313

é WE-»-5 twai: witrmsﬁ 3% E315 E§.ﬁ§Et¢ W3»-435 in
_ ««1L3i§§’§§§en3e hm gdﬁtﬁﬁ tém exmuﬁam $5 ‘$23

‘iilza fmizaa Q? Fﬁhé &fi& 3% as aigmé the agmmntﬁ

P@-5 ﬁg amﬁwr wiﬁwa tn ﬁrm Ea Ema aisa

aﬁmtigzi ﬁgs ﬁxiﬁﬁéifiﬁfi ﬁf tbs agfﬁgmaﬁi if: 231% Excuse sgf

(s§:%\:’/*1»

. aééiﬁmmt hag

W3’-4, E: 3% 313:: guggmatazi by em} mzisssgm mf ‘gs:

a aesribeﬁ, whm hag siateé ﬁmt he

mﬁ. :: :3 slzmaé; by W3»-«2 mid 55 :33

km §;a”§a=:z1dan§ 2%.}. Wm yggsﬁwr izsis {E15 ‘E:§i%*

félﬁihﬁf mzismitigé iféwt ‘aha wag
ﬂmaaqmzﬁ $5.1
mﬁ 5:: 31% exagimg i2m%L aaés gm
examzztad in Eaia 3&3? aim
ﬁeafih sf ¢ éiﬁférzﬁmzi 3%: mm {Em
Eek %ine:*mn’m $5.5 afmeiutg

swam :53. m. aha: ztgm rgmiamm

“the a:1aag§en&.mg §§m§ ﬁgﬂﬁ mg mam

iﬁﬁ’ as ‘éim §x3aEI3;b:.§ wag 3. pvswgr af atf§rz@”

}.A’:1£i~:E:§;é::;’§&fV:’*’ :$§=£%vf;%§;1.;:£é5é::: ﬁeg}. mm hﬁ gmtiimz ‘§'”‘%1£s asyamst $3″

& % t;h.e 37.3%. agagma aid agfmamz gm, im 2:35

ézﬁwitiai ihai Egg}: Eﬁ

ﬁﬁ wglé Q8 Ezémgﬁif émﬁ mgsﬁwtaﬁ iha gwwmr sf

21:: faamgar af’ §La?mﬁ§. ﬁﬁﬁ “ms démiix ﬂf ik

§ a gﬁné wwag af a*.:§§r§%* wag wmumé 35 mt

Ex.?-33} ﬁg giw raﬁﬁ 3:”: tiw wéﬁmzm $5 WE-:1

gaxhﬁtmé 313% tifmﬁ is 3 wriifim agr®a::1@:”::.A..§%?i§:§%:¥§§:”‘?&ii$
aégpgavtaié hy’ ‘$13 srafi evééenm as wﬁﬁ ﬁﬁ ‘him
miﬁagxzm “§@.i Qssmrt ﬁm:1&a~us§y 3:335 ‘ V éé: K V’
tbs pmmzg has mt ﬁia

am. swag: ia mi ‘Erma. Ta %z§m%k ;§’:*§za1

Can??? ﬁik }1é$ ixwxz; -:§_%;@,2–:- —

an EKs?§Bl mza ‘7:%§;§é%.::*V>§é;z1;§–:::£.i:’:é5;%’;:§ﬁr

51:hm5′:ta§ zmggg ax :”%&2’dﬁ
the :aigr1a%,”:2s}é;;, aiiaiiid rag: haw ‘s:.ri£. ta

” – QWEE mlé it s§w§:§3& imm

refmxaci €E;s:§- far gaﬁtiirzg ﬁg Gﬁrﬁﬁﬂg

1:; gm mg mm by $3

?§ﬁ2{55§-3 §”3?.3§3–§é:m& Qmmﬁ $3; the saga sf $3.3

& gagsrm 1:; m gm sg

ﬁg’: ﬁw ﬁgpmz Cauriig whiisa

Eaa §haa:*~m ﬁat

” éésixgiafm sf a sﬁﬁllﬁ’ (3 agﬁ éﬁﬁzzaé gmmﬁm Wéfseﬁrg aéaérvims

= af anti ﬁm aaié.

213% Egg ﬁmzsﬁ éiaesﬁl TE: in ag tgzmh 3. aﬁﬁﬁiiﬁ mafzéaf 62%’

as am aaztziazgg magia mg: Esp- gnggaﬁaim

311$ in 323%: the

ham Ewﬁﬁ fﬁfﬁffﬁé :5 {Jim ccs12apé%;}§§:i%;:_’3E;s;§ <*art?

rewrcuﬁsisg azrigirig mi? ﬁg' furﬁm
mamgtm 'amt; im mg 311

sf €333

— 3&5? &€§m§;§?.&ﬁ
33%’ ‘ mm gaé ﬁg apéﬁiaﬁ. 3%
aka __…i’~.§%,«’.’ ﬁnk E; ?@ timi ﬁw

‘frigi ﬁazgfé. §E3::z1’1.%§;V tize ésamﬁ iﬁﬁﬁgliﬂﬁéﬁﬁiltifgl

Trﬁ Qatar’: has m~Z*:.:t%§ﬁ $3.} the

%§%’§.§2$;.’?*§ am mt mmmam mid ﬁiey wem

gmzﬁi §rz&®§a::d$:3%i§r mm? ihﬁfaﬁy has

V wiéiggrzt Wm Qﬁﬁﬁixiﬁfiiﬁ anﬁ agggarméﬁxg

V’ ;t’;”..1&5 ’12*:%%%.%:a::§ wiﬁﬁzm smakﬁ is Em ffﬁﬁﬁiéﬁfﬁﬁ. far

__ ésszmﬁ maé g1,:§ﬂﬁ?tt% ﬁrm: if 3% appkimiian far

233$ ﬁmttﬁ ia ﬁx Ezmiiiggzﬁﬁm wzﬁri §n% aﬁawai,

the maéfmr is rmﬁﬁ ta Em

ﬁg: ﬁaing mg ‘ $%;{‘3:.’¢”Ll£E'”

_ V   . ﬁaéa "a;2§      -2

 awn aamréirg '§¥ﬁ ?§~§. éﬁ 

 

3.2

2%. Emmﬁ %§:£§§§ﬁ§ fear ﬁéfﬁﬁﬁaﬂi. féggi suégsgrigaiitmsé

ﬁie f

e:i$§ué;e§ d€}¢E.Eﬁﬁ§}’§§ E§:aaP«=3§ azzéi E3-%’?”

thia ﬁﬂﬁﬁ aﬁ 1:333 §§&in?;:2§ win hag’ %§§f{;i§f§ﬁ’–..:§i§.£’E

cia fﬁiiﬂf af $§ﬁ:::§§%c §§Ef§ E§¢ﬁ” Qf iéfzé ::5z’;g:*§;’:£;3$£;%.g ” ,

hm is ggww the mmiﬁezm ﬁf

the axfmmrxw 9? _i$~’_V:p;§:*¢§ai%_g _$i§”1$C£’ﬁ:{‘ﬁ an {Ex
swam $3 rmu:2?zHﬁ_;€$ ﬁea €33 ymm tim
agmmrzm Ema sxamﬁs” eﬁ

fmzr t’§:”:.g%,V:§”‘-.,g’-«y.*;’.ﬁ’?;e:m$ af %§”a-»§ tn %» am

r:amz?$i§ee:2*s:2?;*i=..Ta}$- ef 9%-«Z, ii. éﬁw mt

“T ﬂag: Eﬁere ia mi ﬁg3″ r1t

ﬁézifg -it? EEK in ﬁawm ﬁf ﬁm 1′: E3

%&§:1s;;€:ig.;;” irzﬁg yﬁfssaﬁaﬁ m :22; maam 3%’ WM mg?

‘ilﬁfl-*

32$ admits cm: Ely zmtém ﬂaw zamxags

ﬁf’ :§é*=:mr*@”* ﬁamﬁ

wfﬁah ﬁg thﬁ gavar $§ ﬁiiﬁfﬁﬁ}? ﬁxﬁﬁﬁiﬁéi 3%;

ﬁefmiéaaz 1%,: mid. Em zmﬁzzaf mzé {Em gaﬁ pewgr Q?

aitsﬁm; km 12%;: ﬁﬁiﬁﬁgﬁi :32′: £§§:’*§ §%5. Zrisaafwrg E23,?»

g:9x*”/”‘2’

ézm “EXﬂ?§ZL’§3£i”3’§ 3:

H H K §§§ ﬁham :35′ éka

313 a rﬁéfszésargzrsa maﬁa E33″ thg giaixuetztéﬁ as Est’; age afxﬁzﬁ

pewer @§’ awry” is éamﬁ 3§,§.2,§%-ﬁn: E ”a%:&

aiismwf wag ﬁg: eaxigtﬁmes is’: faamgr ﬁf 3&3
was ﬁaximeileﬁ m1§§* in $13 yam” .§5=§§_5;§ K x

mxﬂistiig 533$ Eiiﬂfﬁ paws: asf &§i§:m%:,%T ‘if:

mxaa. Ema &$$ -.

ﬁiﬁé iii’: Jimﬁ wgi 3313,’: $$w~”f:s$_:’~¥:%§-»L..t1¢fz:2:::%§:z%;:V:§aa.§ is

Em ﬁ§.1§; §$§ asf wwer sf
aﬁaﬁmg éiﬁii §:§15§§§’_- ‘V thega wag 21¢
nsmd. faaé? _&x§é;c2§t& $3153 yam gawey {sf

af£;mrms:¢2 ‘ .§;*:’ is {Eat 2%: maﬁa? £3? ﬁafgﬁﬁani

2%.}. akéé Ezmm ggmmmi sf sale in

ﬁaafﬂiﬁr, thc rmﬁzai ﬁg éafénﬁwi. f%’a.}1

kéataﬁ 1i§§ﬁ$§,§§*-1» mzﬁ aha Ema

is: fawxg asf

azé Z3; ﬁe raiied. an E:;tP-§§§ the 33%

T §3Z”f;2{i§}i€’£%§ by ﬁx gssiaﬁtiﬁ? ts: Shaw Eémt am mi:

A zsgiwéuia ggmyerﬁﬁ wem asaq223r3rad: by §€3*T$}’;;.r1a§p&:, ﬁw

tsemuﬁ wig ziaaﬁ. mﬁ.

fathﬁ «:::§’ iiﬁfﬁﬁﬁﬁﬂt ﬁag E maﬁa? a

firm. gaf ‘Em. 1″ V L»

V’ }<:..t:: t;Ezr33 égég s2§ ﬁt§

it is mi 713?; ééﬁpﬁiﬁ ﬁmt Em &2:¢§ 3Z§.i:&za§£ §mx=:5.tg j;§§g§::z:§

mid &af t £3.33

aueecmaisﬁgz aka, it ﬁﬁwhm am ééigg. .g%n,:§€E%:%§4'vV'4$§".';Vg'§,§§c:§%ég§1a::tA
33.3. azﬁ d&f § ﬁagis EHE: 2525:; Egg

13$ em": mzléﬁ gag: ham mg: mg? af ' '

wig arﬁ §m*m?es1:.%r1}3 ﬁmlm

ha: ﬁfaiigsa:-ii mg mg; $2' ﬁzifsndant

Iiasxi $11.5; 2 ﬁe

Raga: aaﬁ " fs&:*'._:'$§t:e mtarzt af gmra af

thaig eveﬁ ggmrﬁﬁzg m the

phﬁiiﬁ' E§:;u§. éimi abaszzt SE3

years is h.:f:<w%r km ?P ﬁmi as

% am}; cgmegr mta¥3§§,a§m am

§§;¢f§j::*::§é.m2 Eéal diéﬁ 3:1 Eﬁﬁiﬁgé is. aka? sﬁ:

'Vmnnfﬁgt is the agmmt ﬁm ; ease £5 t%m§:.5

3&1 mézi E233 fgfiﬁm

'g:§°'§& Emum af' F%?-%; 3 $£;*i%a, éftm tifsg ..

h V '4 wr"2i%:t$:';;§ hath ﬂag yiairﬁzéﬁ' arzé aiﬁfaziﬁmi. EEQ}; wazg. ta

ha éigafmm 9%' mxarg

” §£fﬁE§ €32: sﬁggfg ﬁg &g;i’ﬁi’ﬁ$§%’L agaz. jsfms

,5?»

pemz: was rwuiz-Q m $i§1 ﬁm :

am wiazamg gs WW2 is gm:mm§i«§g ‘. jg:

matfzgr wars prmemé 331$ 3 was

%: at $23 _ ﬁm
In&§$§’:,§:£:§:3;?jg mg agz E ;§%mag:%;g;g,W and 3%
53533 mg. in §::a;p%g{§g%%:§&a: :§i$r’VV§mmk;:fj%”V§:éjz*.’~.iV:a:§”‘{§Zief’$z’1§a,$:’§: 1%. 3 am

an ;§%§%aV m€vz§§.E:$ aaﬁier Er} iézﬁ

$1? 3%»? i3 aﬁ ; it
_ V _ ._ p ,

ﬁlaig matiiaf »s.:s»§” :i«¢%f5a§13;g;.?é§::§”‘§§9.1 Wag gmsmit 33$ mrégicézg

‘V V’ gubméﬁgé ﬁg: awn ﬁ€$ﬁ ta
firm: rim age 3%” éﬂésanziﬁt Eiﬁl was

aE:;:a.3;*–1:i Whﬁfﬁﬁﬁ Fﬁwi aiatsﬁ 53%: ha $3.2;

V §*8&m 35 agg. ﬁg giibmgzfétaﬁ tfmf,

V’ ” zgﬁﬁg-9′ Em sﬁiﬁsmmﬁa in :a$§§%£§::¥a§ ﬁiae: saga $1.1: ‘sham

3% yaam in deﬁcmiﬁizg

” agsa af ﬁafgziéaﬁi £212, E-£3 aim $u”§§m?:..t& ﬁat ?%–2

has gmm €23 ‘Elms mien: sf ataﬁstkg ﬁat aim maﬁa: ﬁg

ﬁg, Eﬁg zsimsrijg’ ahews

€3.$f€ﬁ§§1:%’§f§; E 3

,, .._::: mg argiyf ée§t’£%h3;:§.§z«”az”;’£. E*§l..f§:.- V

§m;;,_’g, ~ ., ” *

we
WET”

that PW-2 was not the witness to the

lcuowa about the agreaezzznent, his evidexwa _&

the record. PW-4, a scribe, in his
plaintiff, deferniaxn No.1 and de£e:Ldan:%%%%No.1J*s%
come to his house. When V’

PWI:-.–2 and 5 came and adnﬁg iduentify
the signature unlcaa it admita that,
he had He also
relied on ma witness and
aubnnwmai gnaw’ and defendant
No.1 wcr§V’A’a1f3’n§ house. of PW-4 and there

were at/her came after FW~S went to the

However’ “”” ” , PW»~1 states that PWE-2 and 5

Wéairg n::t[AW’hen the agrcemacnt was draftad. ‘I’he-3.?

V g’:”V’ t was prepared. F’W–5 claixns that
A ‘ ;:ie’f;§ndant No.1 and his mother and aha admits
took place in 1173 praaence and except
_ V the document, he did not know anythirg beyond
same. R’eferriI;Ig m the evidence of Pm-.~2, 4 and 5, he

submitted that time: prwenoe of mega witnesaes at the time

of allcgad agresement is doubtful,

statemnt of all the witnesses in

contradicting to each other and

P’W–2 stated that t11e»z1;oth#$¥i§w:.:6’as

very difficult. to believe such {igfendant

Hows mother had

. The prcaenoc of Pwa-2 by

the plaintiﬂ’ hlms-8′ g 5 stating that
they were cannot 13¢

acczeptedgr

11-111 aL6″fe{1′ V:-123′ 53 oonccrnesd, he submitted’

denied the exectxtion of Ex.P–31

that there was no need for the

i deﬁ.-,ndantA V execute a power cf attarzney, paras’ ularly

‘ carlicr power of attorney as per E:-LP-32.

4I*Ir£A:’ Eubmitted that it ‘3 not in dispute that the phan1t_1ﬁ’ ‘

power sf attorney holder for lzﬁtmelfand his mother

he was lacking after the cases ani trust was repcused

V. on the phmﬁﬂarﬂ in this regard, Exam?-29 and .33 i.e. tin

sale deed as well as registered deed were handed
him. Taking advantage of these
has got out of Ex.P-3?’ for the purpose V’
against defendant No.1. He

evidence of PW-1 has statedkjtzﬁgci to

show that he had rzpriegg off’. December
1994. He has relied on”4i?e:3 that
though the ﬁeimuea, but has
given separafmw issue. hence the
ctubbmg any irxjuatice to the

for deﬁendaut No.2 also

of the Trial Court.

of the rival cmzztenxtiuns, the point

fer oomideratian in this appeal is:

V’ theplaintiﬁhan proved the agreement

of sale Ex.P-47′?’

/1″,

}% D 33’~§’a. §ie5f§§§ %

af wﬁckiz ¥.1;.,@§%§f- wag

£4». 2: ?$ 21$: if: éiisgmtﬁ am: am §%in:§’

tr: éeiénéaﬁt ﬁagﬁ; mxﬁ hia ﬂmﬁm -~ ﬁamxgaé K

Ekfs:1da§;i.§§$,}; baa amitzeg gm;

at’£ar:%* Emifﬁar mi téwéx 2% ﬁﬁgéimai

this is ﬁ”‘afi€3L$’&,”‘$d by Ex§’«=;32. “I=if§§§?§%§;” §§:§§;§7§*¥%3i1’;§.a£ﬁat%y&r

pawm af aiéﬁfxﬁ $ﬁ*m’2g};}*
mﬁmi rm E33; aha iiiﬁgzziaé bf
éafenﬁam §€ag§.a_, azzé aha ﬁx
aégaatum ‘A Whﬂ Ema mma
kfmsa $§3sE§§t”.§ §

mzwt §3sr:::s%95 ::_1?:§ agmamaamt, “E2? ggwrsw the

@$t&r1;;:ee” sf ﬁw p§.ai1’1ﬁ§ hag ymducaﬁ

:’V’V.E§§;P+%? mam: $§ wig stamé ta Emve Iaamn

ﬁiﬁiﬁéfﬁﬁii E;*%?”:3.ﬁf§§ 3 E; §z:€5er-ﬁlia a £113 £315 ¢f
J ._ ._ $3″ ..

3% guzxias mﬁ

2 asrgg Q8 gzmim 35$, §’.1,;;2€},€3€ﬁ;-

£8: &§’ ¢ Th

T ” ‘iihﬁ aaiﬁ érscuwﬁi, Em Ezm méiaé an ﬁﬁﬁiémﬁﬁiafy”

éﬁédéﬁwﬁ Exﬁég. Em?-ﬁﬁ E 3; $315 émd E33; fawm Sf ﬁx

father af ﬁﬁffiiéﬁéi fig’:

ﬁmaasﬁ §<1:*%1*:m§§3a3

r%~:tL»

4 x

‘I113 fatllcr of defendant No.1 has

schedule properties under a sale K

the death of the mother of defmdahillﬂo;

being the only son and sole
become: the. absolute owner. the V

agreelnent is admitted ?.11~~Ex.P%’:§:1″V; aupprecx iate
11:13.?-47,13-31 and p.29,1111111,1- exammmw
by the plailxiiff and 5 are the

111 l 111′ the plaintiff mm’ 5311 in

his cvid¢:1?1c;f:,” is Q was an earlier power of

attnrzney’ ~jgiz111ly by defendant Haul and his

the said power of attorney was

dated 1-1.4.1995 (154.1995), which

the plainﬁff on 19.4.1995. Even beﬁore

A l of power of attorney, plaintiﬂ” claims that
No.1 executed another power of attorrxrz-:y as per
l:’1*~’:,j1«¢’;P-V31, which is: dated 12.1.1995. There is 110
in the evidence of the Plaintiff as to Whg.

separate power of attomey was executed, However, it ‘E

$91

/Z”:

contended that since defendant No.1 became

owner after the death of his mother, he

of attorney in favour of the

examination, p1a1’r1tiﬂ’ admits

place, except defendant his—etl1er ‘V

person were present
However, the be attested lay
witnesses, so 1 went near
‘secured PW-2 and
To JI:”iV~2 who according to the

and PW-5 were already present. He goes to the
of saying that except mother of defendant No.1,
.PtV~5 and one ﬁ’ie-nd of defendant No.1, no other person
3 was present. He also further alleges that rrwther of

defendant N23,} signed the a.grec.m-ant in

43 is produced by defexuiam No.1

certiﬁcate of deceased ‘:41: -:

Sarojamnzua died on 29.6.1994 at

mistake. PW-2, at various gﬁcﬁwr
of t No.1 put her
signature. If she is éﬁantm prior ta
the ﬂﬂrﬁﬁmellt, Vof agreement ‘n
impossiblc. is PW-5. In
the sgfma that when plainﬁif

and defend:-njxf Ncﬂl house of PW-4 – a s_acr1’bc,

vexcep’§ ;F”J’Je4, person was present, and ten

2. Though PW-5 clainzis that he is

Imnwmn ofdefendant No.1, but his evidence is

§ .. the evidence of defendant No. 1. Beyond
agreement, he pbada igrmrarnze in regard In
From the evidence: of PWs-1, 2 and 5, it
clear that there is no coirlzfntency. It is also clear am

thc presence of PW-2 is doubtful as he rafcrs to the

${$tx?;?;éﬁ 5j’:’is:%”waa ﬁazzmtﬁ, izﬁy ﬁat}: ﬂﬁifa .?

‘ §iX.?”3§>

ﬁfﬁﬁﬂéﬁ ﬁf émeaﬁﬁé msiiwf ai’ éafaziﬁami §§s:e&:K

PW-«S akg swim ﬂmt %§–2 WEE ma gamaﬁnt at t.%1$e_’

exzmaﬁazz :3f sggwmgﬁa Ema P?§=~1 égimm .
£ éefemiam 2%’ E aim’; Ezég ”

prawn: ﬁt 3&3 ‘éime Gf eézmégéiﬁzz &f;’;agr§;~&§:’:::a:*:f;

mzribe ‘$”§1″}.ﬁ mtg?

amrai ezfsasxszﬁ 51$ 5: §§itI’i€;$$: §’§ﬁ——–§Li?’§1ﬁIf aéimiifa {ﬁat ?mth
‘£113 witmmgm PW$~2 ‘._:’f£%:?£ Wham: ﬁw

agwmwszxzt Wm J ‘§’E;ia:_ §§j–.,g,}sa*~:.«:§éaas:”§.m’*s.§-§; $3 {Em

35; §I’};§»=i’é {Saar 5:_$. Ea§:;Z?4=3§, is mgzaﬁmaég it hag mme:

‘ i*z1_%3 mam amaréétxg is ﬁm

‘..4’f;:i=§§:§m* aaf atﬁﬁrgwy 3% gm’ Ex.?v-s32 was it:

féagl mﬁ

I: ﬁg gm: $x§:.’§§a_ir:ad aizﬁar £2′: ﬁg §1a§1ﬁt ﬁf in
kg’ tfkze giﬁémiiﬁ sag 33 why ?.E*::a aawmzﬁ wwrar as?

was axwuzﬁiﬁ axmgt rﬁéjgézg $2′: 221% meimi :35′

Egan ‘ta Exﬁwﬁié 233%: rgsmais. ﬁat tiw

mi ‘§:E;a§ 22:»: 1:;.a;é’ * L’

is £;§§a:§.d$.2′:t 3&3 aﬁii in ali fﬁﬁ Egé

%.m%,§:$g

mm ‘£9 gag agmmgm, “E”E’3i$

mithar m1%

.- ..,;: ‘fgz. thus &$ﬁ@%.””:«i?.Ti. E235?»-é~?” gay :2: is t}:§–~.§:%a$§i”

gimnag ﬁr g: :a arzgiaénﬁ $2 the §}$’§§.”§§§§.:E’§ ‘T

ta whaé. was tha mam: gaici ta .

Hail £3″: Eﬁyﬁt nf thaa V. ‘V

§j$£’.§1G$% ﬁat it was mi’ V

% gig; 1 f%:%%:*’%é=’}:i;$§i: %i%§:,2%ﬁﬁ;~ ma

%%;&$:: ﬁw ﬁme 9%’
mxmzitimiv V H $$ am: ihssm 31%
E33}? ~*m2E £x,P~–31 aaﬁﬁafimaily

mmzimss aﬁmzirzt mi” %f..3;,${:,Qi§§§- %y

5 :1.'”§7a’}’}__m1§&?;§§§3G%f~ fby £13 mﬁﬂiﬁi’ Qf ﬁefeméant

fa ta mtg Em: ‘six data sf pewgr :3?

Ray’: 3%:

attm§:”;::£jg Whmaaﬁ iﬁtw mgiéwr :31′ gﬁeiendmt

§§§.}§§%. E’: E3 z*’:z:£; ax§}.a§.::ﬁ as it: haw

9%’ §§§:s,§. @ﬁ an amamzzt ﬁum Elm

VT E§:~:,?-33 is ﬁﬁ sf mmiraﬁiéiiiai}; and smnfragr E3

% “Ex§»a~? ma 22¢ avzfﬁmzm sf $3»; §”m1m; Wham aim

éﬁﬁﬁé? it wag §:::° ﬁw gkizztéﬁ’ my

siﬁaimw 31% apmiz i

~V;_ars%§&§%é.§%~»$ –s;*;:?§5a;2§m”‘mﬁ 313$

&ﬁ%§”% $31 231% 35-=.;;:’

pram $3-sa §;E.?w3l E32:

$22 ﬁﬁi ﬁémﬁa §’§mm% ,’,”>t§*:@

mi: Ex?-3}; £5 :25: 5&3} €31″

prawriéssasﬁ s;;:§m.:_§&;: anﬁ §5ﬁ7ff;.–i ms mm ﬁg «

iiefaﬁéazsi {$6.}; mid ihiﬁ is

tbs awe 3? my :3? the §§ éﬁfsndwt
Haj. hazi 1%: my at hag mm
with gag grapersm’ smgg it :3 rm: in

cifﬁgufe: ﬁat 13$ dafgmant R331

arﬁ _ ﬂy gaiﬁ §f§ E ﬁt

£3$E2m$§:’~i:%mz %,§*3.§z%*»§j_j ~ : £311, but Em: Emzxizi mt

premng ﬁx 9;? ﬁiégﬁnﬁﬁt 1%.? ﬁﬁsm mtmutﬁg

” §ﬁ an far 33 ha gémra in ﬁw

£3 wiﬁaﬁmé Er: Emﬁkﬁg

ﬁ%:§’EﬁZ”;£& an i§,§.Z%~§3 mgmh grim’ r

ta thg agwmgzzi: Ea fawn? m:::§’ $3315 §31a§1:1’§:iﬁ’

an ‘EiiH_3f1~,1*%§,3 Efiw mﬁflwr mi’ ﬁaasfanﬁargz Eéagﬁi an
I and in aéaw sf’ tiga simth Sf éafgmimgfé §a:.};.’s

ita egéciz aré

émsumani 3′

Er; whﬁm ﬁg am

aﬁméiiaﬁkg were ‘£3;

“§3’sZ.?f”:§'{3; $2 is ma: %

«%~&–

_’ 31$

lzwqueatiagé 222:: Eéw Egﬁl. Thaw £3 rm zﬁaiaﬁaé ﬁg

saiﬁ M53?” If mg gmggy wag mt awzia. 2 ”
défﬁﬁﬁaﬁi 33.: Ea 5%}: it ég £i1’$E::*’z:”.;,:E:E; it;
defﬁrldam gm: muiﬁ iéave ._

wiizémsgi §;i2§£&%:$?§g 331$ .{§:3§:%;_§:%’:z%:;:’€.”‘ ‘V

wiﬁmut £iara%a§% ky

defarzﬁazgi §m¥ mfmgagt s::;m ‘.§:s&*:§2%i’ic3%:=.:1*’§

uzﬁﬁr E.x.§~3. if féze :3 ﬁégpgitesﬁg <.-ha

Qatar: $%w'?azli§ 1:35:13 $ ﬂ1f& amﬁ.

gm its maﬁa? gﬁmuid $3.33
‘awn raééigfesﬁ. %?;.€: s3§=:$rfs.:, Eiswmrm”, ma

‘éfieya iﬁ ymw §@ aamjae Fmm

” A

‘seam aﬁézzwé 23:5 §1ai::1i’::§ﬁ: it

§’1§,’T%§§%§.§’E§i$§ inf 35$ agrwmassgé $3 dﬁfﬁﬁﬁﬁﬁt

‘ Kai; ‘Em ‘aim Imam? fa: rafarrig ﬁm Egg?’-

§ E am sf’ tha <3§§§$n Em':

ﬁmaagmnt fa? §$7.m}.%i&

‘ Whﬁﬁ iﬁlhﬁf wédanm Ema by $35 ;f:a1a§x%§§,iﬁ’ E3

tm é2$§m’% ﬁnk saga!

‘ . ‘higﬁﬁ évﬁﬁrme

% 3.7z§§ ‘giwﬁ

2′?’

mt gm {gm aaﬁaﬁama sf gafmaaaxzg; ji%§$;:;1

dmziy mta&l:§§m ﬁmi 6&3 gragrefﬁm Wara

pig {sf fagsgia

him 31% imdiayuiaély hia ‘vﬁetvgiﬁﬂﬁ «.

beqﬁgatizixzg Em? ghwa ﬁf ‘kragﬁfﬁgins af

defandazzi Egagi aﬁég 2, mt
ham ‘mm zﬁmxuizaé °§sy” ‘ix’: fﬁsgwmzi 9?

3?’, 553;’ ¥;:5§’2fﬁ:f!,Bi§§ é§§”‘ éiéﬁiiﬁﬁ 323% Sﬁﬁﬁﬁﬁiﬁdg
ﬁg’ .,$}e;*..§%m%§.3 ‘w ﬁm iriﬁepﬁnéiexitly

dwét. wiﬁa séazb 33¢ éﬁguﬁ, 81.2%: if ‘aim

ﬂsmrt mizﬁ aim”; tha éamzﬁ mg giw

L E in ﬁm ‘gm; %C’iz:mx*’E: am azuésma aim

‘mi; #31:. has aaafmiﬁrg-:2;°m eﬁémcﬁ

Emauﬁg mﬁ tha ﬁﬁﬁhkﬁm 31% 2%: pregmééﬁ the
“j €35 gag piaizfséjiﬁ’. 2: gm ﬁg’ zéaa aémw fmaizm,
£5 ma mrii: $31 t%x§$ -Ea Swim} E am asf ‘aim

3: §m§g&gm ;«;<$4mg;r:m:

A-‘I’

ﬁg

3pim”§f: ﬁﬁt fiat: juﬁgxmﬁt ﬁé’ ﬁg Eﬁiaé Cﬁéifi éiﬁﬁ

far iz1’t.m:’§€3*@:me;

£m~@§&§ng§}g aggml

ﬁa aréag as $3 the saga.

?gy”%g)Tudqe

Like this:

Related

Leave a Comment Cancel

K M Byrappa vs Venkateshwara Prasad on 9 November, 2010

Share this:

Like this:

Related

Leave a Comment Cancel