High Court Karnataka High Court

K M Manjappa S/O M Mahadevappa vs State Of Karnataka By Holalkere Ps on 2 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
K M Manjappa S/O M Mahadevappa vs State Of Karnataka By Holalkere Ps on 2 July, 2009
Author: Jawad Rahim
I

tiwd

fé THE "Ei':3" Q3' 'if? G? _"53s.R".""§""""' E'-E? "°'AE'w3!?fi:LG§E

§E'?%';'E§E's£ :

 as :'*'iA:":i3A??fi. 35:3: Ev? ;v:;2fi,?a;s§%&:;;??:;   
Atsga AS€3EJ',¥' 34 --  1 A
AGR,Z£ijL'¥'UR_EST  % ._   
 R;;"§;':': §;as:;<;:??§ 251::   
§-€fi.Z,3LéL§<ZEREV"§'fii.i.i.¥§€... M 
c:%:?a.Ama§a §:f";3T: 

  A     % :2:«*?a;m:\f?
{E32 5?: 3: S._$%-§:€%.5"'?;:"{gfi:§gé'a'£*:,4 @m,,:;
;sm%;;[%%
f:'&"§""'?§3.:§;v;" ?<?:Rf",S'-:'?Ai*?-+.i
 « %:§5?<3:§§§:*T
{$5 55%;: mix; §i.§5Rfi.§'*4'iA%**i'¥'fix easy", :-%€:s;;?;
"--.;f"§_.L§A??§§aiW :5 ;~*z;§§ :;,s's33:m{2:; ::.:?<:5~.§= 3' ms
_ ~.§%i.;f§E.?§€ "$5 ?€L§§. T?-*.§;E .3%§3?EL3kL§'§T fixffifilfiifi'? THE f.§L§§§§-*§E§'*»§T
T%:*s"a:§2.2§:';5 aagga 3*: 'ma :%:.'T:*§Lg 3.3,; 5&3? ':"Rfiet§§
%~«::s::n:m*:*,, €§'§§"I"§fie,§1i§§;§fi;, 2;»: §,§,§4z:2.e?;a*:: -» Ci3?~§'i£EC":a§éQ

"»%+§--i,-"r §%??§Li$:?é'?}"§%CC%J§E§ ;?€}fi THE i3?FE§§{ZE ?fiifS,3€3§
5*' ??€Z7 Afiégifi S§;?\iTE?~§CI§'if.3 H355; TE} QMEEREEQ R}. FQR A

"?E?¥,Z{§i§ 2'33?' %="V'E ':'E,-{£35 Fsfiéfi ALSG "§"i'} ?"'F€':' zgifxifi £3?

§$,l§i'3§f- FQE é:§§'vi§*¥E$SE§?é fifl' Ti-éfi §??*'E?'«§€E L5i§3,3§Zi§
VF §?fZ.'Z 3.23., €22? R%Y?%€EE'§"§' Q? $3345 .&f:Ci.§$E§ S§~§fi:LE...
GEQSERGG Si, §'{}R %'~:i§§"§'3"i5E:§i ?E§'iE{§i:': G? '§'§"§3REE §'*v"i:fi?*é"'§"§"§Sg

aw



,4
I
4.:

?§"§E A?;?*'ELLé'3g?*€T;'fi¥::Ci.i§E® F?u3J¥'§ '2'?-£539?' TEE QEQVE
QREER ;?'~"§;5S'2" 3% $3'? .$.;$§§§,$

"""%:§$ ameai camifig 6:: far éiciiaéing izgégmerai this say, the

'!f!l"§!'*Al--§!
§§Egi52§«.§;§§T

Qizfiviiiiéé acargseé fig if: aptgzeai against t%:.fé"3'§€§g?*r§és:.t_"j "

2. I faave heard €.:.i1,r-1" .%.§ar:3e'é :";%:1:.;:":*§é;'$% 3*": iiié fififiéiiéfii
$55 ééarfiefi satiga Sré Raja 5:;E;rf:253':;'rr;an3i,;:§»..B5:ai
3, €;"<:§':t'ej;::i;;a,§ " ffifiivi'-..__§"'§é«"?':§§£?$"":§i"§§ fram :52 fétfiféé
reexse-a¥= " % ' ' " 

 "$23 fifipaiiafsvaiazgéeé 3:25 ?'¥:-":a*n&s%:war§p;a
{€1$z"§'%;§§3%§:§{:§:§ are §é§i§e':2:s 9% Qasékai e w§§a§e, "@§3E§"§i«'.1  §':?*'§3§'§&S§"§%§i§?'§§£3a§, @225 wife-

 ~».E,?.£{'. __'i'3"§& wag fiiféfiiéfi aizé "'5: {i€}¥"¥'§?E'E§'E§a§,» mg: ié 'tfigé

" §;::é§ iééé Eaégei :"~'a5i "%'r§§§<; :':GQ?i, fifiiifafifgrga,

is §'¥§'§§§?'% géféfiéiiéiiérfi axamémé 3% wiineggas

aw»

M
{:12
4121
{$52
{$5.
332:
mg
W
"'23
WW
sP"'?€"



*1.
J

IZEL

féffifféti "ié Céfiiféfiiéiiéfifi if: 332 Siaiéffléfiifi sf ;P'zs'*.;':_§__ in

 W

$E:¥32 am? rzéarkeé iizem &$ E3531 aim' ms CCfi§§'fijé§'5§?'§.§

the fa: fizai iéza Emu had Changeé fine szergiasa gévéfi *3;
i"§:f2'i arm fiéffifiiziéziaé 'gig éws": "'e§'é§'$§§I¥""s gaging: ihé asziused

.'E"§*2.:,§s, _;E.x;¥ .? :~, refiierta, ii??? the E3353 :3?" whézfi émrggazgazifisé

zrrsfiaciaai
  Réfergiizg iifi "$32 aasiéagzca $3 E"'é€fi¥'§, £22 asgezsié
3;2"m"" iéaai iéfifiié as? tfzé zasitséiasses fiaya afiegaé aaizgsaé



§%;.§§'s§S§":§T'§&'§'3E grescrifiad fer the Qffafififi usdag' Seciizfin 3%,

WW!

Ra is imgrégarzraent which may e:x:%eraé wig :';{'g'f~;_é§r$;

-

“s”?3E’§”‘é is as mE?zEmL:m aaréggi fyresfiréba

<:f0T'L2§"i may take ifie View that Eféé saris _.=:,-…,.§:i::jrf'§§–¥i€i§ff1'¥"é€

fiazérahaninya aha: Si§}§ipG"r;s3""i?§_€: u§'fT!3_§%;.§§%i&';:f.. jrgagn ant,

Qairaiirsg sag: that E: is §§::1E_[_ais' but aimé i 3-

'%:;:sves'*c,f%..:§<:e :a;*fi;;e*–~'i.%'f'ag& arm? ifiai they hay Zr":

3

JD.

a§’:r:’:e:=;i C£}¥&fE§ anéer Tfigéiififi 3&6, 1P,s..,= He iherefmre

have ‘§”§~&}€a¥”§’¥§f§€_§:fj ?,?”?§ evifiéfiéé an ?&’f’;’€:€3§”i7′,w ‘_

1 g .

am
K13
E9
‘*1
WE
it-ml
at
£21..

«’4
W:

””’T’
M?

IN!’

ivéafiésféwafaaga, iamgziairzant a”;’::f.f’f%:ef*~.§f”«t§:e “1%;i::%im,

wiifiefifigfi haxgé S;3i,,W{&f€ ‘§i:3 #33753-3, 5, § 352%? 12 are

‘-$1. V –

§;r’s§&§em:z’_a;+;i W» §F”¥E§.$;éj’S, }£i:é:;’;.is&a? $333 :23′: fiigmzieé i’:”2e’:.«’ are

{:1

‘:§:_i:?:Q§:Ei§V*a_§a:.ié*’s$ihim ta irzafasige Er; faiseéy’ 2:’.r”<:§§i§ati:r's§ ir:§:r::,

?§'%§§¥~$?:i'zia§§::§a§§a $233533 that £322 aéilfiifiéfi naé

L.

A é_’::§§*: 3:’: 3:55 Qwfi 3 wfiak §¥’§€1§’ is; the izéaiiééfii areé ivzafi

‘”-«–,:§ia?§§r:::ai§;:’ giaied itfréai; ‘y’§fra§§a§=r:r:*zar §”3§é gsszszaizzaaf

s

~ 4\.4;;§i%:@:;i; ;??”%&¥’Z¥’§a£’,:,}f§ i§”‘§f§%.;Z§§’I séiéaéi ééaiéraacy wgiéé his 33$,

akiw

G the eazsaarzca; ifargéefa-,2fv_%_i§’*~,fv ?’:s’»é;’;;~’~. ‘

Pwlaml
.»».

‘w.

SE35 isifi frsém tézai Vifsfiéamifia was *§f&§§’33%3i; i§*2’r<":a":s–"é1.

gfiiéfié

We

3…; Emu-IV’

:33″, gm he

gm!
»
£3?’

vearabfrsaéé’
§¥;§C§”‘.£ srnaisszef agaifisi ifie gifi.

aé aé’*;’:$e him mi %§_.$.§:;*5::a7E-:LI”§T;r:

:2, ?’v’\£12-3ayamma, visa §;a4*r’e:::3§:::’;’~=::’*:*:’?T».s%’ :é’£?§'<a§gii&::;_A

T§"§f§£§'%§§*'a'I§, 3% weeks is "fa:-i Eiiai iha £:_s:£;V:;:a2é,:3;V éfgaii

fie? aflé ifiié iifii "

‘ 2;§§::;”z§arr%:§32fa;* _ irtsarfi “v_:§%:::?éixr&é *r;’:’:ir°m.:§’:’2
‘5ee;r§§;’s%:a§*ra__§3;3’a’ ~?’zjie_é_;3§.__.fi;=:::*a%§€§’; site Eiafi aim

‘§”%”:& §”%§§§&§’E{;& aé T”z%£3 {§¥”§i§”:E¥’ 3%’ iiéé victim} is $5:

{an

:2§:::3 fram ii’:

W
wt’
ma,
{£3
3
W:

M
Q
“*5
PEP

23…

{E3
uh
fa’
$7;

f”‘1|*
W
W
13??

E3}?

jlgfir
3;»
ma
€33′
W
my
‘C3
R
“Z3
~|l”*”‘€$”

$3;

5?

{(331
5.3″!”

CI’.

“”””».

‘{2};

{ml
ms

pug: -. ,

iirsai what wzfi s§eaE’~

i?%& Q??? aasftg wag ;£¥””2€§{;:uQ§éQi’y’ ‘;:§2§’:%.a:r?§&§%«,..v “wag. _’;§.:-;:’=:,ie is keg;

..V ‘.L.; 51! .,

ii’: ifgifié aézgfi ‘vi_E3:..2g§;vz.;a~.§_»,es >§if*s’-.Z_r”é.;Ei’?.§5’§~’T§’$&S ‘f*é§””:&?’E gazégia Siege :3:

siege §r£;:s:%z9:’s:?E’;i~%aa§- :’i;:A:’;”:.a}é;:~–rfVs:’Vs:2f this Rina Vaffegéf: them

z:;w$::f:” E-:3 -*$*i7:§¥a;

rum»;

‘J’:

wesiréffieé, fiié saégj S&fi§E§’1C:E may as fiififiéfifiéé witéz,

héiéifig tits peréée’ cf 3 rrzészths cefifinemani zgnéergefie by

ES “me iaaméii tnaé jassfifie, z:.§n$:a’e{irsg 3% 3′”iErs€$:’§'{z§
isriumfiiafifiafi hag ganiensed the aécaéed ‘:9 gznfiésgfi} R:

E7!’¥£:§§;”§é§ *3: fake a yer? §e§””:§¢=*r’s”i;.§e,é’é~$’sz’»* sin-firfsés. _:’&T§ara:;_’_’;*v–a.s ~w&

have gear’; thaf; frxisi wart azig §’3.?g.§§’vifé§.=fi;,¥§iéd §n..i_¢Ss’of fife.

s

§2*:*:§ri:-:s§ri;:”r’:&r:?:3 ” ;:I}a:7ifia§¥?;§”*’;f.__ rs:a_miat::::y.

hfea Ffifiiffiéhfi

;:§’:éer~tr”ia?§ V::§:2fE;2’ze2fr:e£:’: fie-:.-:”:__’v;’,r*”«:r”:”::i;i ‘Se safficiezgét.

final.

M13
fiw-‘hi

fie ;”.e§::§’i, ivéfié gerzienge :3? §ZI’fi’Q?§S§’§’!§”‘F’§§2″”:’E sf 2

};%é;:§§;%;%§rs..–§%a $2225 flftéaiffififié, as ‘germéggibie zgfifier fieétién

awe

$»2§;».:,?f’; ‘fééé méer iregaréing fine $3,. hswever,

,5:

‘ ‘=;FTE’.’s§f:§’§’1;E§i?£’:$§i ?§?§¥$ sfsaié be fixe észéy fiééfisfiiaiiflfi ié tire

03/

acctzgsa” siiaéi surfenéar ‘zfzaftare iiée ijrfigijj.£;::xg””iAA’ta::”»;::’1.s::é’rV§§’

izha Eefiiéfifié wéiiaér: fear wags?