I
1N'l"H.E I>:iI('.}.H COUR'i' or: KAR.NA'1'AKA AT I3A.N(.}A1,0RE*Z
DA'I'lEZI) '1';--us m£«: 24»-2% DAY OF H:Bm.:ARY. 2010
PRESENT V 4_
'1';-113: 1-1c>;\:'B1.,1«.: MR. JUS'I'ICE N KL;;\;1AIé.: "
AND
THE HONBLE3 MR. Jus"1"1};:1i: é T
c.c.c. No.-406/2009 C/vs C3.C.C':Nt3s.52.;{;f£.74«.&':'4;75.V ',
52:3 (3: 524, 676 & e3_'0..& 742/zvoQ9_{C..m1}v%
C.C.C. No.406/2009
BETVVEEN
1} K Mgmix'1-4;?;n.1'a;. ..,._ _
S/(')."K(§'i'1§§3:§1 P~r')_("Jj:;1Ai"i'. ~ V
Vi .V{:}.)( ) {.1131 'i?37''y;f2a1's. . V V
R/_a--.. £)o;.;»::'N<.=,~% 1 ":3..1._c:g, N0. 25.
V e 1V1.l<e11.e1;)p2:1' . B'L1.i_1'(ii1j1.g,
Iwlialc Bi 1'1Vi'::11 i'aAé1 £1 21 .
V. _ I1'1(iii*::11Vie:2.;.§;'¥i'a";-a
B:-111;_.__{a'l<)1f<f-T560 (JOIB8.
» 2.} _V . S1ii 'A.ifm__appe1,
Ii P I..c:c=.Eadh211" C0. Adv.)
* _ <3. 1\ria1f;:. a.1i1"1ge3 P00} ari.
Agm Vé,},b()t.11I 43 y€z11'S.
_E{~/ _eij.:(.} 1.1.11.2 p1'z=zse"1(:i (Tl01'1cii1'2'1e.ms.
.. "E:"e111ge11z;>1'<='-- 560 023. . . (.30mp1a1'n ants
K3,,/'
AND:
1, Sicfitiaizth. M2':g'()1' in ag_.;'c.
'i'h<: C()I1'1I'I'1i.S5§5i.()1"}.€§1".
Ba11ga.l(')1'c: [)evc1()}')me1"1I Aut.:l'ici' ' Vl.'!.l."1°d,€T1"~' 'E3ec.£1ioI1s 1.1. and 12 of
the C'(')§it.'£:u1tr};;5}3t A<:_ff"1971, praying to init;iat.e
(:()r1t1é__n1_pi:* proceedings commitmd by
a(:C1,::'-fictd /'€r0I'1t--e1'1"i1A:_1()_1*'i--J;1"Viwlat:iI1g and Show dis1"E-1313001 to
the (lire:-~:L;1i(t)1:1 Vi'.'5.'.-34LiL'.'LiV by this H0n'b1s3 (301111 011 dated
11.V1i2o<)a_+ gmvw.P;=No':'14651/2007 under Am-1_exure--A
e1:x:1¢j pLI:1'1ish'r:h(-2m in a(1c.()rcl211'1(:e with law and fu1*t11er
d';-mbf;-,"L'tile.1'esp0f"iCiéI1t.' 'to (éompiy the direcuon of this
» iH»(,)I1qblfj5.C«Qfi!'f. in the 21b()v&', writ pctit.i01'1.
" '. '§§'.(i§.,§:ZV2x./2O(}§):
Bé'f.\vtE--r; 1'1 3 4'
V, " E5::¥__1t..EViz;11'1.j:1la Joshi,
about 453 yeans.
" ZW/0. P1'ak21.sh .
7Re.ptd., by 1161]' (EPA Holder:
" Sri K N I\/E()I*.1aI1,
A;.g€Ei aluout 46 years.
S/().1a11'.e K S N ';\/iur1.1'1y.
N0. E01, (}a1'1ga Residenvy,
Pipelinzs Road, Behind
Dayemanda Sagan' College,
Kumaraswamy Layout,
BEi,I1f-.§a1()1'€*56O O58. .. Cc)1np1gv;%fi.éi'11t;A_' -5
(By Sri P V C1'1a:'1ci:'as1'1(:ka:', Adv.)
And:
Sri Siddaiah, 1AS.,
Commissioner.
Bangalore D€veiopm_¢':11't
Aut.h01'ity, Kumara P__aii=k
West EX1:n.. ' P_ .
Bar1gaI(;)re--E5€5O O20. " f':i_'I<T=1,i-Sed
(By SH' Pra\%_E:£§f;jE<;.L1mé_1"
';._"1'h.i:-3 C{'CL;{f{'i:5°i~i}é'CI under Sectioltls 11. and 12 of
the CC':«I'1t.("n1p't_(13f..jC(')iit~1ff""Aaft, 1971 read with A1"t:i(:Ie 215
of C()l"1SVVE'.i1':1'I't,§()I'f' _()i"J.:':'ci¢i*¢};, pmyi'11g,{ 1.0 'mks S1l.fi.E1b}€ a.ct'.i()1":
a1gaix1s1: t'.Ir1't: ,_ac:(;:u-'sad by ir1iti21ti11g the c_:01'11':c:mp1", of court:
pr<f»g:eeAdi11gs f(3:iy_s;f_i_&1I.i"L,:i dis--obe,die1'1ce of the court order
A 'dE[§.€£§*K?»8";53.2009 passed in W.P.E'.\¥0.1377E.%/2009 (EDA)
,a';'1d p{1~1T1'iETah'__E:}1€? e1(1.c:1.1se(1 for ViO1£1U()i'I and Wii.lf1.11 dis-
e).bcjtii¢:?1fLgfé Q'i7VE.v}1t? (.)rdc1' }'):«;1ss;e{i by this H<'m'b1e C<..)u1't.
C*;44C.C1_;'?E.<§.is.A474 ot,1.i. 53 yearss. \
R/z:1.N0.3. 5"' ('3a'::5s..
Appeli.ahswe-1my I-2:1y1.11.
Ut E.e;11'al'121.1}i.
B21nggz1l(>1'c:~56O O61 .
2. Smt. Kam ala.
W/o.S1'i Krishlaai.-a1'1.
Aged aboui 49 yea1's.
R/a.No. 156. Kalagdna
Nilaya., 2"" St.a1geé.
Guamajy'£_hi1'1aga1'.
(hzlzzznabh:u'ai:.l'1i.. T V '
E3e11'1ga1(.)1'Cw56O O56. " _ TC1V1i1';3v1.a:jn1a11t.s--.J'
(By Sri K211Gem1,11le1s1'1e1J'ief1', '
And:
Sn' Siddaiah,_' . H - _
S / 0.1101'. k11(jW1:§;I:-G '.r1'1'-ea C.é')Ifi'iipl2Ii1}2II1't.S»~'
Majgf, C(SmjfiisS5f($i:r:t".» _
B211'1gal(':.1'(: E.)e'x.IcflQpg};€:':'}1."'A1L:1t_'i'1ority.
B'(1I}§__§'d'}()1'E?--56Q 001.. " .. Ae..r(::L_1s:;tc1
(By-Sr: K Kz*j .__I. of C.T<;n.m' A01. 1971. }3:'e1yi1"tg" to im'fiat':e:*
<.:'()11"t@,.If':pi. g'):fo~cc?c;tcli1:1gs e1g;21i1'1st: tide? 21<':(:uscc1 for wiiftlll
di'30b(?di5§:'1(}}c of the (ijre(:ti.()ns issm;-.d by this H0n'b1e
x with 'lam-*.
(fit-)_u1'T'V_*EIE VV.P.NC).11004/2008 and W.P.No.1}..OO5/2008
<:iated"A14.8.2()O8 and punish the a(:<:1.:s~sed in a(:co1"dance
la//T %
C.C.C. N()t5.523 éiz 524/20()9:
Be£.\vee11:
1.
C A Sridh2;11’a1.
Aged about 46 }–‘CE11’53.
8/ ().C S AI.’1é1II1′.}”1E.E.
Pac1n1a1’1abha Ram,
No.17. 5″‘ Cross,
J P Road, 1 Phase.
(3i1*i1’1ag.__{a1′.
Bar1ge1E0r«:-.–5b’O 085. V
2. P N Ravi.r1dra1’1at.h21. .
Aged aboul 48 yeaL1’s,
S/0.}? K Na1″d.yéi2′;…
No.1.33. 6″ (“31″(5:~.:2.*-3t, _ g
1 Main M S R Nagalj, ”
EVIat.3’1i.k;e1’t:, —
B211’1gai0i*§_g’56O=__OF34:7 .. Complainants
(By 53:1 V C.’§’if}I’T1’d]”2:iShE?Kai’,-‘Ad\’.}
Anti: L’ — .. V
Sri _Siddai’ah.:
C,r.)_§mmiSsic)1ie:’1<_.. A V
I;fiv;<z.i'i1g_g?e,i1(.)1~'tj Dex-»~' C 1V(.ip"1'n<:1'a1 AL.1E}"1()1'i1 y ,
» i'<ZL_:11a*.-._a1':.1A Pa'1*k_ \Ve$t §3xt:n.,
' E3.ar1gfi;-figyrcwfifii) O20. .. Accused.
" siji .K%i§:~Eish1aa' Adv.)
. C.C.C. is flied under Se:ct,i()r1s3 H amcl 12 of
thezz 'C_<_jw1'1t.en1pi: of Couri, Acrt. 19371. read with A_1'ti(:ie 215
.. . AA OE._C(ms't.itut£()r1 of I1i1ciia. prayirag to 'cake SL1i1'.&1b1:’1E:empt’ of <_:oL1rt:
{L//..
(3.
prc)(.:ec?d.i.1’1g::~.3 for \>vi1ifL1t d,§S-()b€?di€2l”}C3C of the (‘ou2’1’ order
dated 20.3.2009 passczd in W.P.Nos.68i2 8; 6813/2009
{EDA} and pu1’1i:.-3h the av(tuse(:i for vi<)}ati0n and wiilful
c1isA(.)bc:dic1'1cc. of the c'):rd<'-:1' }3a.sss<:ci by this Ht_)n'b1e C0urt._
C.C.C. 'Nos.6'76 éiz 680/2009:
Betweellz
1. S11’1f:.P201vi101’11’a. S Ran,
Aged about 55 years, 1
W/0.Sri C L Shankar Rao.f~.__ _
No.8. :31″ West Main Road. V’ _
IT1 I,a_y0ut., Viv’eke11’1zm_C}–;-1 Nagan’. V
Be1nga10re–5E30 085. ”
2. Sm1:.K Kusuma’s.’~~._ ,
Aged about 70 ‘y’e~a1fs,7, ; .0
W/0.1at<~: Sundar R?},_() C L;., " V
N(,).172/3', ,Ar1a;i-gi'1ye1", " V' '
jV3"1" sax/1';«i§;i:; _ La1y<_)i.{1'.v.
2&3a.11ga1t);'.¢§=-.0560 ' ' .. Co:mpiain21.11I.s
{By Sri VF'V"CV1'1éi11dsf;1_sE1E§L1<z11', Adv.)
' ;S':'iVSidC1a%iz£iIiv,__1.A.S..
C()nmji*5S’13fi.:;j
* Bax’:gz1Iui’t:– I;’veveiop me 11 1; A’u1;hori.ty.
K:…_1_m2_1r¢*1 VV”esi:’ ELx1i1’1.._
Baz’;.ga1o1’e-560 020. .. Aa’c1.1s<–:d.
{VBy_Sri Bas21va1'aj V S21bE1l'8.('1. Adv.)
This C..C.C. filed undel' Se(7.E'.i(ms 11 and 12 of
~:t'.E'1e C()r'1.t,e1npi: of C()L1i'E A(':'L_. £971 read wi.i,h. A1"E',ic::}c 2i5
§q//
of C()1'1sIit L,11ior1 of mm. })1"z1yi1'1g to £a:1k<: suite1b}<:r 21(:E"i011
dg__3;ai1'1s1: {i'1L.' e.ut(:us(:d by i11it'ie11i11g 1h<_% (.r<T)t'1t€.'1'1'31.)1. of (.:ourt'
pr<.)(tc.(rdi1'1g__{s for wilH'1.11 (i'is~z_)'Dtf('iic1'::(f(é of t]'1c-* ('()1.z1".i""—:)1"c1c1"
da.I:.<:c1 12.6.2009 p21sssc<'i in W.P.Nus. 8:
15718/2009 (BEA) zmd punis§': {.119 accused j.'<.)1fv.i.di-:{1;£"i{3:1
and wi§}fu§ diSA(.)b€2di.(31)(..'{i'. of th_e 01*d.1* pe;s_3ised”
H011’b}e Ciourt. T’ ‘
C.C.C.N(.).74I»2/2009:
B€T.\\7€:’.(:?}’} :
Sn1{,.A111bika1 Je1gz1d.isl’1.
Agtatd about 39 yLra1″s,,
W/c.>_Sri ‘I’ R J:-1g:c1d1s’h_, ‘a
No.49?/57″}, 7’1″Ma1nf’ ” __
1 W1 Cross, Girinagar §_i_P}v1_z’1&sé:. L V _
Ba1T1gz1¥()1~e–5600.86. _ – Compéainant.
{By Sn’ P Adfi} ‘
A1’1d: _’
Sri Sir,i(‘i2:zia%’1, 4’
(T.oI1’1m.i:~;si<n1t;%If, " .
B 3 r’1g2;1.1)’eA E36U’~O2_Q, . . . Amused.
‘ sf; TL: $1′-a’=:s1″11’1e’~:. Adv.)
_ __ . “”E’fi’i.,s_ C:;C’.(Z. is filed under Se<:i.i0ns 11" and 12 of
me' Ci0_1[;t€;m.~;51? of Cot,11't Act, 197.1. read with Article 215
0 °"~f3t):v'-1Vsti't,L":'(Lion of Endia. p1'ayi1'1g to t.a_k.e s1,titabIc': as:%t:i0n
ag3;aiI*:sf':.1.he. a(:c1.1s<:d by init;i2u':.ir'1g the c:011ternp'é' of court
";1TrQ<tr;?€itii11gs for wi}1f1.1l dis~o13edie1'z(;:e of the court: order
V€i_;_1t;§;tc£ 18.2.2008 passed in W.P.N0.i858/2008 (EDA)
V,
H
221m} pu1'1i$h {he ;;a.("('*use(:i 1'01" vTi0iz21ti01'1 and willful dis-
<')b00Ii(-:1"1(':c? of1.h(:? 01'(.iday,
KUMAR J pass:se.(i t;}’1e f(_)}_}<)w.i:'1g: T
(')RI")E'£{
"£'1'r1e (':c)11T1p1a.int. made in t.h:f.(.”,'()l~l]3′;)iV’c:1′.’l.}1-#t::~’SQVV
to one macie in CZCC Nmaosa/2:508 zgfmi
111e1t,1:ers, which were (iisp(jS*a:1 off by _ this’~. C”a:,u*t. on*
9.7.2009. ‘I’hc’~rrct'<)1'e 1111656? §iised
off in similar 1.c::rm$. W1? jp::1Sbf f'(;1: ic>w’ing order:
(1) The v..\c__;h2111w of all the
cc)r11pVi..a}in:;:’1’1!.SW”%3§§iku’E%~._j”this; C()Lu’t. if not airc-rady
rT:():1sidc:rE~:L311nc=i11t ofsi”t;s;&in’::3u1’s1.:a:1<.?(;2 of the cnfciers 3a.~ss:sc:c§ bv
_ . _ .. ….. ..1 –
.ih.is ‘£%’4(::’.£Vp,l’iflj”V””.’V aiiot. a site on the basis of se1’1.i<:)ri1__y
'cXpé:ci.i f:i_<;{1'$I§y'.
(2) E’E.’ ‘£’m_’ any re,aso.I:1, Iht-3 BDA feels that they are not:
AVé1ig.i’b1e, E’,1’1t’3I’1 they 1m,1st: c:Ic-éariy out in U16
–~e11d()z’s<?m.e.1'1t: 1'0 be iSSL1€.'.(i {"0 them, the reas()n why £'_E1ci'r
V"
9
case is not (‘(}1’1SidC}'{::'(“.1. It wili mlabicr t’.hi$ C0u1’t, in H16
event. (3? sucll a=-.1.1<:1(_.)rsse.111c11t b<3.ing._§ ch2111e1'1ge(i by the
agg1'ievcci persons. to imci out \vhc='E.}'1er I"}'1&?4…B'}[.")A,_ is
ju_si1'fit:d in their' ac1.io1'1 in c1enyi11g .21 site.
(3) If it. is f(..)1.111d H1211. wit'_lmj::;t:'"'aziyflthe;
BDA i'1as3 helci that. the a1.}3;)1i
aH01im<;*.nt. of the t6 "£11111 1ihé
exper1ciit_ U re i1'1(tu1're(:3':' b_\/fir s14,'1V(?}"1" 'iii 3 p"131'0aChin
this Courf and Q) ,Ag;:p pfx:p1’1ate d{‘}U()I1
against suoh=’ t’jE3i7i(?:i211s=._211”:c.§~iicr(imL?m.
{4} :{f)1’1’£tC »i.:s’5″~¢:;T%’1′–;’):i’1é:1.:s§.z(‘(1 that if E.i”1c: 21ppii(‘:£u’1t.s
who am? ‘S£’_T€f’r(iI1§’_{-‘&1Ai’§(.}’tfl1~ET}’1i’ of sites in purS;uar1(._*.c> of the
C7.?’JT7*~1″‘: ._O1’f,it:1’$ ‘é1′:’11vc’.i.__._(“Eo 1101 <_)wn a site in E_:.3;1:.1g211()1fe axid
V :'r1iey_ E'…I'(:E: §5*1~i§:§ib1<=:r E0 gget: 21 si1..c:._ if they are de1':ie(':i siw. on
éxny i1ir1i~3yLn1<i, smch n1atEe1's would be viewed
se1'i<)s,1siy by this C01.1rt".
Hex:-ve*ve%1″. the leemmd <tou1'1sei for the mpI21im1m.s
___Su’13n1i_i’s t:h.a1″ 1.1.I11€S.’~; the Eime {Farms is I’jxe3c.i in 1’trsa})e<.éE. of
3'/,