High Court Karnataka High Court

K S Venkateshan S/O Lt K … vs N P Balaraju S/O H V Puttaswamy on 9 December, 2010

Karnataka High Court
K S Venkateshan S/O Lt K … vs N P Balaraju S/O H V Puttaswamy on 9 December, 2010
Author: B.S.Patil

‘~ A ‘ ;;’*3’=1§ :2 =§;’;:’é;t§§;aw&:z”:§,2

12:? §5’s\;:§:i’§.¢:§;§,{ am:

3%’ TE”??? EEEQEE éifiiifi’? S?

§§§§;%E<T&§ §$§z§§;a%§%§%

Qgfig mg fiféfi *:'*z?§ gm ms: Q? §§§:§::a§;a:*%;;::g?§j'§jg§:;§:%:?:?f*' '-

%§§§:*:* ?§%:m$:§ §§.3:?Vga§; '2:§a:«§{i<a::2«g:+é§§i%:;

Sfé Eifig 'gankatfiémmg ' V '
figeé aémut, ffi _ .

S; as Ema KM $§%$ §a§m
E§fz§§%’¥;” I’§§J2§3;§;’7″ , _ ”
3&3 §v§§.%I1fi’§®&i§g”‘1§?>._ _ V
§a,§ga;;’§§:¥:?e::f-‘i”*:%iéfx€§.’f§ €§1.”f’¥_;’ V

:35; ésgwaagfi far zség 3,
* .–

% gr; _i§.g§1é:§;a:§*§§”§.1%

” _ »-;22%;»:§’g:i €33 §!

Em}: ?% at 1%;

3%?» $*m$&§ 5&3; Eiimég
$5″; Eeégififgg fiafgmzagazg
Emggaéswwg $2 1

3» 32$. 3
figfii §:§3£§EE:i fig gaam
$55 33% 3%, 31% ” T”

fig 35

.». .,H.,»m.Mww.mx.axfi~:»xv~.ar¢z:w’pr»»g~w&932

§’:’§:%§:§* ‘§§@2″:§

E$.§:}ga}:;f$»§fi{E Q33. EE $?§f§§i;§§§V§§ffi’f7~f.”

ggfii 31% figfié

gar §–§ 8% – &

22%;:

fisngtimzfmn af ixfiiia ;3?a§*§z§”?:;§’::;uar-;%:” 91%;:-9:;-\

gamé éagég 25%;: am ma iiity
£31??? Qfizzcigm §\a’§&}’@ 53.3% §::§§;§ _;Ba_z2;§gi;2.2$:*a 8?
E€€s,}.fi&3§§%§ at fkwtiiiszz

mgmagmamtiy éiamiaa g&§§§.37:§;é§»i§{Ze:{“E».§§:’§;* §§§r”g2.”m:.;;.:°z1=:~§Z%e

§§fit-U
Esgmsizxg £22 §.a§;rgj_’~%§;;a Vjiiauri mafia iim
§%§%%*§r%: ‘– ~ ~ ‘«

‘V
§€:’€l§?i€}fi$§’ Egg {fifiéé in

§;§§m§t’%$1′:: 1§g’%;’i2S€§ gfiaaeafi E3: iém

.’ V. tfifi agnkgiéméfifirz §§@ zzrgdgy %;;;”‘%:*§a2*

2. $313 2&1? $1.?i$, a:§§€

?;%:$~..g§§§§§§§x:é~Ea§§@mé§fi§ Eéag. E m@ 2 Ezzaféézi :5 mmfi

;j;:V3,faé::r;%;9«§:3; 331% éasafiirzzza ziia gait $3 fizz}; Eéfiiéifig’ §§?$§§

A. Q ‘ ‘E'””” V.

‘V Qfiwmgfiiwfi fififaézfs azzé Eaéig §{§ fifiéfiafimzéjgmz: figfiiifii

§%’Ef§&Z’$§.”§§”§i”. ézigaazigfimzz

§§’*a%&Z3.’§ §§§Z3:?;§Q§”§fif
rfigmcéz if 33%: §s:E:%$%.:.§& §§f€’;%§@§}2 mg 5123?: %?&$

igggiiizzwé $3: 52i§§’«’- §5$’%:fi’%2′” 2%?” §m@§3.%&2′:§%§ iii fizaé :2

~–%”

. %’Efi§H’

h %§3:§§§?fi’:§:§i2: :32? éfzaa &§§.=::

§’1fi§’i’:i§’1 §}”:.§::c§m$.%{% aha amt sehaaizéig grfigflriy aE:::§gg_:

fithm Wfimm. mi gsgag 25% gm. Sm’; za, –

wie fieefi §%§i:31?1§&§§% 3

ramarée Sam; iéwgg’ flag’; ‘*~:%§}§Ei:2a_f::§:::;,§ éams ” ‘

fiém a§§§1:*m” V §Eg£sg§§.:;?;§§§£;:§-§ may

afifiavit ffififi

§’:2:é§m= €.§’§.§fi €335: iiiafijf

= ma gmtég-$3? ‘fiia fimé §§iifi§
gggég 3&5; %gg;§§;mfi mazaafi saagr m
them mrztfizséfi. fig? fim

‘$33

:§§§£::1§$.§gf:i»§’$:i§.§§:%;;?. §f%.§f¥:§?f: Emé émgfi

-F: 2 in figfififigfiiy azggajg éimizs awry:

“£3 §m:%§&.,%

§f§@i*€§ ggzzi 235$}; $:§§f§:§§$3″ii3i®$

1:533; Qfiiifizzzza E3 §23§€:m:~’é:: ting yfigsfimimfz &2::a§L

§’%§’}§3.§€:fE§:$ 3; aim? 3 Emrgaiiz

5;: fix a;:*;:%&:2;% gmygrtgg

vii. at E3323 3 33%: £2″: fiififii’ is’;

aE§’%§%E”;: flfijigy iiw gszfifiuig §mfi2*%§ it was

fag 133% agfiéigrggzfig ta mtma am §%£}§’é is i’:=i’2′:§’E’%’Zsfi’;$’%”; ‘éfiéfi gait

it fig féiéifi azzfigaagfzzai gfimgéfiziafi, Téfiéfi

T {Em fizzfiamzfigg sf figs gzéiii .33: ?’i§;”}§ E3?” ‘

i2 éizfiafiéaai’ ‘ ” gxfi-i .

n..n~»>«n.fl»m£>%«’#@€fiV72(77))V/M99743?’

aggséimaiian 3&3 mmfiatatfi mi iffifi gmzzzzii;

$1 2; % wag mzé fig’: fig fisfilfi syaa

{fig §kfi2:;:£e:’::’;§? $5′ fix azgiifi

3% ‘E”h$ E35513} iimsrt $253, ;>:§r;33é1fi;@§z**a’:§§:f;,.si%i§7A’tE:7e

a53§§E::1&n§ has mg mg fig: gg :E2é~.u.éfié;%§4é;;;.:e@E fag:

tits: 52¢ agggiégamza ‘. aznfiigf

Effiéa figma a*g”;g}:§._3é;’§§f Q mafia? téw

géaizzzééfi’ lizagi i éfizw §i”2’§§$f§f{ ages

gas; T” T-

. agzfifiafi m mm 3::

ffiifififii §:§::r’=?:_*3$§»§.ir.u1g.’,*’a:§.V”‘it§*:g_;¢*7’ ” s§z.éii, ‘E%:§ Gaga? }:%3£§¥€” hag

:2? mg’;

§:zr:%”;&3′ iézfiap’ fig @3623 am

345.” sf fag: §E§»$. asf iiifi

aim: ag aimég Q3 £2 wag grésm fagig

iiiafi &§§3§i”:»§:§’§§§% E155: éfiriwé

m¢am;£r;@ %y 235% §%?m:§§ §m’£;§ 3;,

if 3; zirgra wag 21$

fizz” fig €:::s:§;: is

‘ firm aypiiganfi ta aamfi 53:’: §§ 2:: gmaamzia

Zhfi 333$

fa}: gfiéiifififififii’

wzzigraéxeé. gm: zém afiéfififififi “wag mafia

fly

afifimfisaiéaa 3:” ika &?:$§:;z,:;:$ gazififi £22 {$13 31.1%. ami $.52

praéimé. fix iiimzmé; aaf ‘iiém aggfiifiagfi ___ t?;m

a§§3§:i@&:’:E§§ swsgafiésaia wam azgfitiaé ‘Q2 {ragga mg’

agfitémé:

{Egg am : ‘

pwamgém sf 322.5%: §:*z3§:&:*f?;;g”‘” %ra– a, V

gaiwai §:°=m§i1ihi:%@§ is axatsgxtfi A’

gaiafmfifig is 3 32.33% fag’ %§::§;z::fi.i::§;

a. Eisfisiizg §;g:.a§§; :22: gm

amé,

havizg ”

{Em m:*;.€23e§§.%’.i::;w:§.§$” 3&3 33$: a.g:§E§éfi:’:*é:§ Tgfimm

%::,_i’;:7.:$’§€;};§§;123@ gwyrig 33% 3%; fiffifififi

v _§*:§:;*i:fi§*sgE 8? am 323%: fmm §§$£:.::::i§§

gala 3% mi maég égifiéazima fif gg

:«:ig7.n:%§§ag§: wizégirz wag

§:%:{:§§§2%§§::::}’j_§;:::$2$%& agaégfigi 32%: is: 222% mizzamififi, $2323:

gmfarg figég fiaufi: iii:

‘if

% %%§¢k%§g§é*§;%~§g.??g?g{;% wzmfifififi, with aééégsé, ‘f’fi§§ gem

mfiemé am Eémt épwai fiké

E35 ggfgaizziifi’ Eififfiéfi aizfi afifiiiéfii C$~&§3&ffif §m:f:€%

géfizta. 2% ma: wag Sf gm mg: mmgag

it’: fig 33.2% gait; 33$?

X

A

% % %:m.$ gag: i£..3.?;§.E

?§€f&§£§§”$; iésfi

‘ ” é ” — ._ : ”*§,%:§§§§£:’1€§:§_.g’§

_ gffimnfssaézéfiizg

§3z’$$§€%%.i:.-is. ‘§h§ mfiifififigm Qf $15 gafmaizi ‘E531:
2&3: fim aaié mfiez” gasaaé; ‘iféifi figurt 31:1 ~
, fissiamé in as mush as 33% ggizizré:-2 }::;::,*~e:;:§.:~fi§:r-.§%i:;;&*”ia:.:% gfiigiifi’ ‘V

$23333′ 3&3} wag 3%

§$::?;§:’:%@:: ;:

‘$13: iimm am thrw
:2: $3; %€:;,?§5@;:::§ if; :”m§:;:es%#3’§§_””v’%?£’:zF;;:*$.$f”§lié*«»i*’iiiEtiéz§§¢ mzfi.

$ fi§fi wsaeaaiafl §mz.a:V: ‘maé–.§: E3; Eim Esfifig :§1.§;§
iimm: Ema

_i.§§§§,. v’ jffixg ;;:g§$;§%§’::i’:V~7 -gfiafigztifi’ Sm»:

$:m:»;:ka;fiV %%%% Ea’ §§§u§2¥§§@§~m- 3%. §}3é.€; 3% 39%

is: :::3:§.§ $37′ flag iifims

iifi fiifi fi??f§3:§5fi§3;E3§V “3?;’§fi§
311%: ifgfififi Vi’.%;e$& ‘§%:5z%§fi:%§ it za§*s:”:;:.%%: *m §§*§:fl&”

fig Véfiiaiézzfz af fiifi irgigrim §§”€§&E”

§La$fié: 7%?

V3?

£23 zwrg §§§ gag 5%

$33 fim

fif iifixé E”%’fi’&§’§% éféfifg ziéafi:

wag éa mg

2?’. E1: 3% far fifi firm éiéaags éffifiiéfiiififfi afimzgmfi

gigaifii ‘iéiai fiwrfi E53 i%:}”$$&: 21:: fiiéif

maflfiizimfi fifimzfg

V

% aamgigé fégzy aifizgggifi :%{*:a–;§9cs::”‘–

irz’-eiiiszguié k

fizhgi? f&%%’§?:E’ 333$ iézarafgrm Eigaay 3.2% ffiigiiéffié “:2? ymiact

ihfir yflasgmaififi;

$3 33% =: mange} far $333 m$@22fi$:’2ut _;éi3.§

mgrwsfié agyrahfizxsima ihaét if 2&3 M

:3: {mm mt: Emgé ta Efiffifififiiiie fi°_3s*:: ”

tiiarg 3% awgfg’ fiéifiiikméé ssef fix §}:%§§§a::€ .’

aggfiamfima
a§’*%f$$ émrw Egizzg §asa¢§g%3§g:: afifmz 11%
irzfitarwt sf tém gm 2%

“§% $’:§:sif§§§2v.$2i%§;9§;:’-».A%<%::é§'. émméfi axfiuamii far {Egg

aggfiémanmf' Léaaefim tzgigsxgé-§g2°gL%?;fi:3»3 'Egg mgfig

§*$pe;:1:i§$:§%a§ mii 23$ {he

E?' 23% {Z-gar: %§fi%%s* WEEEE

3§§;§ii::a:§f::§:%::L1'1_ €33 fig Eghi. 5;? 'tééefi éfifiififiiifififi fig

§§§ a%% E fimva gm Emaiiigiéfim ii; Emié

5.’ §.:f.§”E.3§”‘§, hfiisw fiié 22$: smmmii $22}? gr

fif’ jmyfiégfimm 33$: fiamirg file %m§z2§,::§§ fiffifilf,

E $2: 23%: firm? ax}? mm: ii: §$:§=§*: §:$%3;’§i:.:s§:E

Ea figs ‘$’§’3:’i gfsififin :5 3%

am

afwawfiiiagzs 32:5: iézéfi csfésg m E3: 521$ fiffifii’ pasafi

*3? iém Clgmfi: aw $32.13* fax’ 23% ywwaa Q? fiifwfiefiai $§

%”

mi§*§.::.§;3:g._Vwiz§%’5:’-,.;%és:..*E; ax:

fig :%§$%§:

£