High Court Karnataka High Court

K Shekar Shetty vs Mathew Rebello on 8 November, 2010

Karnataka High Court
K Shekar Shetty vs Mathew Rebello on 8 November, 2010
Author: Dr.K.Bhakthavatsala


RQTEE» fifififlfi

N3′ lfitefiafig flRQ§3N3′ FLC*€3K§
34% mm’ Rfl&§§ gm’? ETAQE,

WEET Q?” mmxm R.fl%,

Mfiflfi%.I€$§’§é V

flfi’sE’¥Q:%§mi3R;E-fifi.

% % :%r£ém:?e%*©r%;

{By M 1é:”, F’QF; gémfig %._

Rm mm z;m_M;§aaVV W; am,~AA:mmm* THE
.wm»mr€T &1*;I§I.T2 §;3Z€”_,;flE;_§EE”E)g~’3;’i”§”;,E§e’:’–.V§;”?;fi’;f}?’a”§16 Pasmtn M
mmm.a’:m{£WW?:*€ ;’£”m: §”u,Ef £:::;F* “Sis-1?: xxx; mm. mm
mm & ?.;El%fiEQ1%’.*”b’¥’..__ $a:2:ss:m_ mwgvmmm, {can 23;,
mammm zsgmr E?1’£3R;.?F{“‘3~fi$Efi$I€I}E*¥.

m*i>:s3$;,_ mm’ 133mm” Imam amm Km RLILE 3.
mm? wtwimm ‘E.5 ‘Q§_F7″—._fi%t’; pmvmc; Tm may ‘THE
®F’TEi¥fiss,’f’1fl*E~75i”*–«§3&§5* THE ‘-f3§£E’~E€ paawm EV mm ABEL. Cm
%31Vfi:;’¢3T§’flQEfi§f”a&N53fiLmRE ms; m.mm.3*:mi mofi aw”

V. m§;::a.m m ?mz3%1m:::;__§1?::;s%L §3E3¥fi$.&L my THE Aymm.

;:aw:§ewf%*§%:fi”gs%=».;ii;’kT~+,;mz>s’m Mm’: mm. mmm ms Fm
Amgzmaig 5% *:%:§m mm, THE Qmm EEL-IVVEREE “rag

QWUWW3 5′? ?fi;§WL’..IE

‘ H ‘§”§:x§$ fig {Em aezgmal mm by ciafamlmit §%’c:.E. umlar

wfiwtimm @fi mi” flfifi mhafimmgirag the judgment arid émxrm

miaatmcfi £.i?u$vQ'{:}:E»{§ mm mm 131% mi’ am. EIQW fidfiifiiamm fiity

fiivi} a§3}.}fig§«’~’ at Emxgaismra (City {Q;{Z’i§’i §’iw.i?;3′,1_.

L\

Rm:*=s§?_”a{2i’:3.::*éEx«l;f%I*3S’% V

3. Far {Sim yzmwae azxf mszzwmimm mtii

mfmmfi in $33,? mm

Elia. 11,. rim yiainfifi mad fiafexxflant

3 ,.

* brief §’ga’m fiésage fiw

fifiitig 0%” fihfialfi aapgmi a.§”§

Rmywxi1£%5e::§::*z;;;;. -. a fiuit £13
c:m%mm§%g gf Amatimaz City
Qivzéi 1 gzmzaemt apmflamt and him

E:24§%%”mu1*~24e%’;:%;§f:3-%&:1:r3;§:r:;$ fi$»p,.§”}};:I?§§;;Q”«ii’1 fax” Thtzxir ajmtmant frmn

thug mggii; plemfiiztzg fimi: ma fiéafmndanta

}ai;m3;:*1 fiééfgwgpfiflmm wf the m::E:: am%m1:.iat;=2 pmmiaea madam”

§_m.-<%«A;{z§E"$i mmfitkfiy mm: ai' f ?,0w'f – prm amsi.

_ immfiafi mfim ta quit mifii fifiiivar the vacant

;;§fmwsaV#,§:§%§§u'fi mi' firm &u;§§: mhedula pmmiamn in fipiw art'

rmtim; fim aiafemémmm haw mm; vawmmfi tbs suit

T fiahafimla §3%£'£%»¥3;"§§%t'f$..- Tha W defanciant emtamfi

mzfi ma wyitmm. m.m~mmm1t. admitfim the

m}a"t£m";a~;*§h.ip wf the: lam lfird mzfi m;m,a.s:1t ma mat rite;


L_

  flm appefiamt amé Kim   9 

 13$}    .'



mm 31,3 gmyabim mm. m” Wars 5% mi” mmry :§1c»’3x1t}1.Ha_i;1:¢;if”‘t5§’;;a ” ~ V.

giiaixxtifi’ Ihaa wczaivaci advmmm amgmmt mf H

it iza film mmmmiexfl témt. M ‘ Emaa -ikiggffiflfiffiffiilfi

mm m.am33§, mm mm mf mtwggg 1* 5;a::zo};~*

mid: tma tmzmncy xncnrlth f$*<$:i':*:.x::{_
mmh gig: um ma; mf Q%2v%sA;m'e¢;gg2e:1gL ma
ffimmi. wait: ?i%;.& Emaégg 9? t}1g=;_ £3
mt 1'xm£x§t&i1jga:_§'z:s}§€:;'wL:V:. Egzia Ekmra W353 ma
WWW? éa aim: mantendad
that & Emmi in the: mama
aria? atgfifié §.fl?£':":z,'§§9 mid. may Emve

izxvemmei; _Ef1"2,1gi%;:'-. A' gram-Q33? in tha Efitel mm; 'therm Era rm:

é':itjfii*:3@~'%:'i?§w.= far ':3:-am purgwam af {:.:mt°x:"§g'i1::g the

'%::*2m:§;':m$ mm {mm at" azvitzrtiem ia paszaed tkiezy

L wmm 3:53 .;;m m Wm haxffltafimigm an-afi prayad fur

H H " ' = ._.'&§a:m3mm§. £3? 'aha: mxitm

in mm mf fim paaafim mm azvxzvmmi, thug

-»v€,2’£$§.}; flmm; fmxwwafi $3 mmxy W thrm imuaa. fin

E.i’.M3i3@@§ fifm txfial %?~r3’m*: fmmflfi; afifiditimml iaamfi @313 mg.

gziumim %”*”%”m¥;%mr ma wit Wm pmpmfiy whwvfi a3:*z~d

Smart {W 1% mid m? mt?

fl, £17; mmyywmz M” the aaae:”;:”;f

Fifi. Em rfimxtimlp 13 gm

timm alvm =5: _

am
gm maxim fim éfgm 7

fig ‘::Ej”§§”3.£::i_4_” Qb?i”é;:if’tf arguxmmta,
wmxaixgg dgmfifiammta pfiaam an Jzflrfi,

amwmfisiii Efifimfi ‘~iE?:;€’1d flfiiiififlfifli éaaxm in tha

il&;’;2%t;~mte»§j;A vammw mafi aziaiivmr vacant

§?®a;$¢$fi.:§{ér:::%. 3:13,: fifik-Elfiduifi pmgmfiy cm W bafam

Ea iznpugnsafi thin éxppaagai by the W

‘ ~ »- ‘ 4. _ ‘eiimfmzawéfiiiaarjgéi;

L@ § mammal fer’ tém appaiiamtf nfiafandwt

“M.§. mfmmim Mm: fim ‘aria: Elkmrt mad ix’: mast natitréng

that ‘Kim 1%” .z*w-pand=ema’1jy2m§n’1fifi’ kw ram: iwued grmlsar

nmtiam m:2__’- risif

{km tmmmy af ism

Lm

‘ mafimasd aa W31 ‘$::f§¢;£..V_gat V’1m,&rkéd’v_: ta ” V

apgsaekémat f dmfmfimi Nata. 1 am me anfiaraamgmij W V.

%y flaw ptmmfi amfimrifim eimm mt aiiamima mr1″é=§§:”§x£7z}:i;z§,vV H

2;; 3;

mm. mat Wm aammfi. it ia

rsmfixza Wssm imuiafi tm “rhea RW3 :’.’g«$m2;’xé:?.u5.-:!$3i terr3§1t;<iQ§t.mg

mnanmtggm it :13 vmhamfixfimfi» Q§0nté§fX§f?~'€i:.V':
Ewit rmpmndfimtf ad.@E;1;*é€EaV§VVV&r1d rm
mtésm Wag ammmfi} mi mm mi: amfi
tiwmfflm 'tfkm Witneaam
ware; dgmfmsfiants, rm
rfigmfi in aervim czzf

mmiztmzk $2.. L§:.&.m'1?t;:.'a::.i'?/;"@l:;§:«;:;4ké' Kim ciafenfiamta am tmtmmm

in fiif '1:,."":x;Vafmj"5ai'-1.2,§.tj.' azzzhefiufifi pmzmukm bfiarixzg Hum"

Maim Was: mf flhmfi. Rmadg E Emgag

Eaxfiaiarwflfig icmt the gslaimtifi 'Emma

V -V aéiuirma mi' the fi,fi%x°:&amE ma E§.fim.4–%–5 and

V' " ,t§t1a;:«.§2;'s.1z'?é matim Wm mi aerwd on the 72% ficfmfiaantw

— fifm ayapmlfimxt am an applicafimm mfnm ‘dim

” fimrm amdar flxfier 5 Rum 1’*’§-$2 aof’ mm {TEE on tiw

zmwmfiaxat Na.lip§mix”2:’t§fi’ m grim mrrmt adfinam. But,

the ‘zriafi Cimxrt mjémtm mm”: appiimtima and ma

LL

we}

mppwtumty Was: giarm m was QM fiafegmdant

pfiami mwfia bafum tba fréml Qatari.

fii. fifter afifirmsixfi msiéguxgiexiéfi

lmmafi mammai fm: the aggm-‘£1ga¢~:i3;:.;@1iE;&r1§i’t% ‘i§E’.’;§T:A’vé}:§I§h€3§?: = L’

apwliamt Ea mumfxg a Hfmtei, may
Em gmmaz:-mi vim vamfsfi _jm;1§£ jmfiazmiaas mm.

mm agpmilaxzfi, ism   ; " dammvaa
@ a'        
a %%%%    rm ma

W xwfiygdzgfifix-,1tig’ tlmm 213 mm merit in the

wm$’m1€.§m’35-§ ‘®n..m.s¢’} my am appflrflfiiii and

– am W um m am dafanfimnm hath mum

kLk%%%%am? .§§§f–;wmt mi Ragmmna past. I: is. mam

mu;’m1’f£§Mt’:¥:w&A unfimr tlw C€E”§Z3:fii:;fi.’¥:E Hf ymgfirlgp Elm

‘ ‘}1m,1aa¢’ zxéiémwr im mamtimsxmazi as: 455 mama mf M533 arnfl.
Ea ymxldirg 32:3. fiw fimt flaw? smf firm Haw}

amd fikm flefwmmzm am carzyixg an ‘aim fiatai

j v. ‘§.”3*m5$z?xmm in fim grw’m”1é flaw and five quit mmice gent by

U RWEED wags mrwd; an aim fififflfififiiififl as gar the

K

anfiamamnm giwm by 9% P93: €.’I3£fisC’fl~

amfimmmxmmm Emfi mifii Q fimwd; 2L”?;.%.;’?;fl{35;[ H

3-mm the rwimflzrafi “”‘1¥%?’i:?.s?~:;”£§A -3

Nam fiwaa fimfi awwr wam d;e1iwa1§:4é2:& €3::: 5k,*m§u}’:’.:«&.*» ::® ”

aim mmmndm timt aa pm

mm @535 g§~»r:ez*’:Vk§Mi..e:@’§}-:.p;;:sm£’;?:;;s M53 mjwmmmm

Am mwaamh mm wwyygg mm xm tam

‘tiw in ma far fifi
émmxm miirzméfié $”t.1″bmitt:&fi that ma
agapalmfitf éégimmtseafi an we admzacze

ammlmt $335 4’? aamairg incmrmmiexma ‘m

‘:i1a’i’%f’§;éV”ia.’Vs:t§3:ix:g in. firm fim: may wad 333$

in tha huiidixg anfl thaw trziai {Ewart has

%%’*;;§’sE%é:;ia’£1t: timm tier am apwssilazzt ta vamam the

. m.3;i5£”‘ami?:. «a;v;’iL9x§}m pmmimaa mm’; qumfimn M? granfixg 19.3139″

K Lfiaxsraf ix: am agzpakmzttm vamm flaws mi. ariaaa. it

–‘ mxbmitmd fimt fim dfifazfianm namakyy, $1215:

“agpaxsgant hm-$2: am am 2% rmpmwima km: am a we

in £}m$.§fi’a,$5E”‘}’f Q6: ma tfifm fih wf thaw XEAK addifinmi

fiiiity Qivfi fig Swaimm «image; at

_.,=, .

ECQH 44)

3%

pmwwié af law? Fmflmr, “aha antim acim%§1§:€2.__&z:2§i::;:’i,i:r3§i:

Ema fin mdjumfid mwmfia rant’ $I’zj1;$h«:

czrimumfitamnmfi fix: appaaimxxty §|:1§’e:ii'”»r::zi’1g§;s:.:tfzf£§_’:

Wm xmm ymm fimaa ‘Sm vamam-A a;.x£%,. A.

pmmism e;’..:&m1@% Em grammig “”£’Q§.*€f}*_m §:3%¢cu£’+?;;””§;€;v$vJm ig.3.zi meat
the enafia mf §1.a_$m?m Kim 32$ ta

mmw :;m& fimfiiwfx” Ema $g1;.;i.t Vs:¢¢hfmifazlé.%:’~§§i*e{:*g;i$.m.

E3 i-Ex:”‘$E1%.V. ‘9§p’g;§:a»a;-LE’ faiia and ma mum

is .m: mt§fgaV–fi:§” adnteiaaimx imelf.

M; ‘”§f}i:xfi gmmmd ‘Eizzm ‘ism quit aml

amggr ;zm%%Lwg:kkam&m§a¢§g premsm in fimvcsur cxf am

an mt’ ‘mf”m’=ws fifinfiwfifiil aubjmt m a.

I aypefiant ghafl my 9:” fiayczsait the

_ z};m§%mg€§.z2?;:guEmr17;r 53% Mind Whmzs, it fafia fine. In the

W ” ‘A .L ;w.».*c?::eff1i’€~ t3;f”§G:fl1£’X1I7fi’,i11§ may’ fiafault aim paymmxt ifif fiamagm,

xmgwndemtfyiamtifi im am; Ehayty tn mmute rim

~ awri ‘bafom expixgv mi ma ‘aéma. Nair» mama.

K

Em flaw mi’ fim ciiafiffiwaal wf ma apgueafi,

15s&?mac:,{3vL1′?%%$i§{§ far may flaw Hm. $mWi§k:%:’j<«..§';:sxf
mmifiaratimmk . " 4. ' .