Andhra High Court High Court

K. Subba Rao vs Southern Petrochemicals … on 10 December, 2001

Andhra High Court
K. Subba Rao vs Southern Petrochemicals … on 10 December, 2001
Equivalent citations: 2002 (1) ALD 796, 2001 (6) ALT 784
Author: A Lakshmanan
Bench: A Lakshmanan, V Rao


JUDGMENT

Ar. Lakshmanan, C.J.

1. The matter was heard by this Bench in the forenoon. Again the case was taken up at 2-15 p.m. At that time, the learned Counsel for the appellant/petitioner states that this writ appeal may be posted before some other Bench since one of us. (Dr. AR. Lakshmaman, J., as he then was) has taken

the view that writ petition against Southern Petrochemicals Industries Corporation Limited was not maintainable in Writ Petition No. 15720 of 1995 dated 13-2-1996. High Court, Madras, wherein it was held that the first respondent herein is neither an instrumentality nor an authority of the State.

2. It is unfortunate that such a representation was made by the learned Counsel for the appellant/petitioner since one of us has taken the view while deciding an identical case against the very same Corporation as a Judge of Madras High Court. It is settled law that Counsel and parties cannot choose the Bench and Bench hunting is deprecated. We are very much disturbed in regard to the representation made. We, are therefore, not inclined to hear this matter.

3. Hence, the Registry is directed to place this matter before 2nd Bench. We also further direct the Registry not to list any of the cases filed by Sri T. V.L. Narasimha Rao before the Hon’ble the Chief Justice Dr. AR. Lakshmanan and also Justice V.V.S. Rao.