High Court Karnataka High Court

Karigulappa vs Jaganath on 29 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Karigulappa vs Jaganath on 29 July, 2009
Author: V Jagannathan


S»: ‘?%”§i§ H§*’:}§’§ C7i{}URT’ {T}? §{2″§RNE’xTAKA

CEEIECEEE?’ E’sE§N{f§§, GULEEARGR

§3sm<::3 mas mg: 2&3?" ma? <:)_;m%g:,':' :–:éi:i9'*–:'_';V.

3 E; 13' G R E

*:';~4§§:. %~§{)Pé'E-ESE, §«:§m:;s3'r: ;é¢{{it:z. _
BSP£E§§: u

Karégzzéappa 3f£:«.ShivaE:11a1 _ ‘
Age : 31 yrs;. {.)e:>»:: : fv3.§z:;:a.ger:_’it1 . _
Eihadi ‘~3i’aj3.a ‘Ud:v’0′;_?§ 8»:v’j;;M:’3§: “\F€:1éi.ii:g ”
Efiusinfiss 3{o.I):uir:3§i’__(Tia3}r;_¥1′::§? V’ ‘ ‘
Cfiuihafiéza 1 ‘ ‘ ‘ V

‘ ‘ «–._.,,.V,\_..,~AF’f3ELLANT

{By 8riz£3ééfi?a1*:%Z»_ ;§1;a.1:e;:1§¢t;,z;’ M§.Art:21ana Murthjy” PK

§vi3.Sa1″it;E1aj,__ Srzi. §{.’i’3;£§§$§i;§:f€t3r%TV Smt, Umaéevi S: B. –Advs.}

AN};}:

1, ;.§faga:1j:g3ihL.3/ 0. G-izrgiiiaigh ‘
9 ‘~ figs :33 fgfrs. ,(§<?};o:’1y

{E’z;iba:’ga ‘ ‘M. .

EL’:

V T216 *£};_:’§£:;_:::a.2fl_ ui.f?:{;¥.TL%{3,

j ‘”?%;r{:aug§1 Viis Eivisioiiai Mariagei’

E3:’f(},.N9{},vS::<3f33}f)}€X, Z3' floor
' flikgipg –.§_\!§i:;.§ '~£'i&%?:.a::3; Seudha

. RES}7'*Zf}?'=EDE}§'JTS

S12m:£:Et1m B1 »-~ Adv, $33: R2}

1?;

EYES §*~/§Fi=’\ ES §7’fL§iE} i§§\§E}EiR SE»C7’§’§C*N 3.?3{TE) OF’
{WV A{.?’Y f&.{}&’iEN’S’T “i”‘H JE,3i,§)(_}EviEN’f’ ARE} AWARD .,

8. §)2.2{){}§ PASSSED EEE ?v§\%'{I §\§C).31€},’2C¥{}4 ON THE} ” :_.
“Ei z§i}f)L if-i’VEi, JEEEDCEE (SR1)N.) & ME?vIE3EZFi “MACS;

GU1_J3ARCi;%, PA§2TL’r” ;m,{>w§:x:G ‘1’%-EB crmzm ;>ET:3f:j:;~.s: “:?§f.:R

C{>MPE?r§S5’£T’E{}§\I av, SEEESKENG £3:x:Ai’;m\:<M:£-;:4;s;4E;'r«z*:*.,»' {pi=.'i'.V

{Ti} E3/i§'E§*€ 8513? O N.

‘§’EiES §§E?’P§};:’aL- <1i{)i'Vi§§'€G sa¥, *3′?-4§§_«: {:95 ii’? m«;2..:ws:§z§~:2> TEEE-“FQLE,{§”.&E’}N»{3V: ‘

J as’ 33 M E,$§:::1’%.

E-Eearti bzaih sigicg my;t4%:é}f;»:i};:’?; bfV:’jé!éf;€ apzpéai ;:.}referré:(i
$2}; tbs: %fi’£;”–i:1;:%;?0ia§éd, {he agpeai is
défipossai<,%ff"31"ié§E§§?,_., H ' %

2. E»:;é§;:’*:1€:{§._{:'{3i;:z1S:::f; ‘”f<3'i' the appefiant ssxbrrxits

Ehai, L213 _'Fri§:::}:'1::§" ::§*:';3€iA'–.§,:};~~i:si awardiyzg comperysaéiiorz

E'f}Wa1"{§_'§~3',;.'i{}j§S cf §'*{1"i*:;3:j{_:__::a1*I1§:1g capaciigs' and iswariis

'£{33$ ' 2i::f:{:.;1i%i.i%r:3 of iiééfi' 'ifzazzgli ihfi i1i€("§€:°3} avidémce

%:z§&§;–. §E,i'§ {£'<;éé"«».{§§s§i':)§}éi3»Y 23: 41% fG§.}€1)'z*€ifig {E16, fractures: of

V'».E._;’;{:«;:§ v.%.:;@?L’-;”:;.<:,~';V E3333} bans: éifiifi R335 af fang' teeth.

.'§;'i';v<:1'€:§'{;§'=::; V €%:'1%T.:ax':<:{*:r§1£:;'2§. is magi}? :m{i€:1'" Effie abavc

R
.:/'

'ml

3. £321″: 431:3 o’:.§’:£:;” ?i8}[i{“§, i<::3az;<:{.§. :::<:"aa":s€:I_§.'<_::'4:'. V

1:1:-;u;;'a:§<:e c0:'§'3;*;;;:é2:3§.~=' z-;2§g;'a':é:<;i ma? '§'.§1~;'3 fagifaifl' E:é;s._ r'if1t}}' T

a:2:':§;;*<is::§; fies: <:{3m;'3£:§::sati.<m taéiirig ;f:{3t.é' 'cf 'é;;11<2~:";'z,;2_¢t'–;£_?f;;é"ii"

{i:'%;§":if} a§":é=:z" aha a<:<:é::i§:1"1': '{Ei':e <:3ai:}1a3§:f:: was {iQ.i:;g" rim»;

vi:;"1<§ii':g E3'a;133',m:ss..

5% “§’:’:akirig note and the
m23§{::{‘ia.E piafiéii ‘_:iss:_§0r€:””‘ii1;i¥; per the
aiscussiori of -..”t;i§§j:’::” Presiding
Qffacaz’ {3f_.¥*._E’;e_ ithéz %i’37€w that thé
{iisa1′)i§§i}; “been taksn at 10% for

U16: Whoks *r;d<§_j3;" :.51:'i<fi_ ;§§';{;{:r;;:: 21%: Rs.3,(){)G/« per ilizarith

Tfxfem alEi,$:}u3'€:<:s fijétiifi_§{)§{}S{3(§'i}€f:E"Ifi}' ¥_i}"3.{§%EE' the haafi sf

V'E::%;~';'-:',V, £:f. i*:2.*{_;'::m".._:é}:1'Efr1%Az}§ c2z§:2aC§;{y' the apgxziiant W3} bfi

' V ¢:t§;ié*:i2'::€”§§,”» and ‘§Z{“}’i-“s-:3” “(is ‘£633 sf Stiiififlifififi af

Eff’, {:33 ziéézfizini {sf fess sf fear met}; anti fI*a::é:~:, m<–:€fi{':a1}. ::v§<'ie:';€:<:: izzdicaiizzg that the

__3;}p{%:fiaz"i?; gas gid{:%ii";:3§;$, hzf::’;3CI€3/~. “Ef.3i1.=fi_s§é._ii<§j;~ "

a:;z:<;«'a.1mA X25112}: C8.}'I'}' i:'§?<:1'itSt 3?; 6% p.21.

Tbs': awzsyd §§§£1I}.dS madifiézzi 1'_'7a1a:'i:0§*e°Zii":g§}_f; A' W

aflowiiig the app<':a_E .35": part.