Karnataka Public Service … vs K.Sharada D/O Tukaram Raikar on 15 December, 2010

In W’rii Petition N0. _:3191.*c1′ 2.-0:59 {s»I:_<A%1'1"
BETWEEN: * " ' " " '

G Kugmar V ,
Aged aboui, 4'.~6'y¥é'é3_1'S V
Son 0f GGvi:1de:;pp2é,_?:V' x V
Assisiani' Er1gi11ée_1' '
P1'e.se_ni.ly w'0rj§{'i11.g.'–at

NCQ3. EXii~93g21<?.i'ify S:1.b–E)%Visi0I1

' _ B':arigz=s,1-Qr€:~–Deveiopfmézfi, Az:th0rit.y
. 'BEA Sfzgpgsiragz Compiex
_ *I"iTSR Lagrtvsévi. " .

” ._E3€z_:1g§:E1$?@_w5€§?0 E 02 …§3e:%.§t:§0z1er

{By Sri S V E:\E21;°21§3i:3’1h21:3, S% fag’
Sri E? €iE:a1::gga};*:’i’2é.jg21 Redxijjgg §%{§v:3<%22é:%}

AN D :

E3

Siaie <33" Kamataka

By its Principal Secretazcy
Pubiic Works Departmeni.

Kfikasa Soudha
Bangaiore A 560 001

}.*ia1’na{.ak8. Public: Sem*ibe.._.C0Inm§S§3i013 A

Udyoga Soudha
R€SiCi€§T:Cy Parka House L’
Ba.n.ga1o:”e W 560,—-O{)1 V L
Represe11ted by iié’ «Sec:–tet.;1r}j ~ ._ u ”

B N Keshava Pras_a_c i’ __ V’
Assistar; i3311gir1g3€:’, V2789 * -.

Nea_1’«’C’i’1.a’11-.d.zfi;:14 1;:1_§/Q Li L \?V:«.1§.é.r Ta 1.1}:
Ba1;ig;a11(j1*ew 560 *

K K .A¥x<%1§;%f1::V1fiVéihi«.. ' & %
7-Assista 13.1.' Efixlgifl 6&3, V"-ERD

Rf NO'.94:"3'—,. "–§,:~:"r:._:_§}"1':z'a"§ é\§i1aya"
Be1'x.«i.nd.'I'e1ephQ::ez_ };"Zxchar1ge

— .. B M Eiaaé – ‘-

PC FiyE{pE§iE1..&_

1.:s.a’§ys*o.;¢e {>131-f:¥é:i<;~,i.~ 5?: 19?

.. §:\j’sZ”‘§§r’§;’;4,fi’.«’j:?,”§,S

Q7: s’:.3%;’a:1.’é;~ E’;3g__.§é:’;e:3ra 1?’;-*”E'<iD

E"3i"§%'ff.€3EVi_:E§V:y' wéérking" 35$,
KNNL ME S%.:b~7E)i.V;ZSi{}:":

“E\1c{§{, E’i§§’@§<:s;1n1bi§ Savac%a':?;.i Tézhséeai

" . E§':31.5;§a3:L1;:i:1 §.f}:'.5::¥.,:*i{:i: W 5§1 E E8

E§::eh2%:a:*e1§};§a
.§'u~;s;'is€.2u11; E-7£}§f§I1~E?€F, W'}?%E§

, 4"15–.Mé1i'i'i, L'.-?'.I:§I.3.l.,'i:f

é,/

1.4

R/ at. Harthy, Magadi Taluk
]E3a11.gg"a1£:r£3 Rural Disstricti –~ 562 120

7:' G C Jagad£;*c*Sha

Assisiani Engéneex", WRD _ _– .

Office 91″ the 1-\ss:;st:ant Executive Phgincar — ‘
No.2, SubwDiVisi0n A. ‘
E\4a17keting Qexrelopmleni I3roje(,-E;

Baiavadi APMC ‘T ‘-

‘1’ umkur

8 H M” T Swamy _

S / 0 Ma1EikarjL1:1ei:Ia:h _

Asgistant E3n.g.i.r1eE3r»§’ WEI) g

R/at NO856, 3733 F-T.CE’OS”SV 5

201-” Ma’i1″1.,x4″‘*TVB’L;:.<:§~:" V
Jayazlazgzég 3 .

Ba;1gai.Qref» 560 “0 E11. j VV …Respor1dez1i.s
“”” Adxrocate {Gr RE;

_ S1’i_ Sa:_:je¢v.A11g2i*éi A_ssz:>cia’Les, Advocates for R2;
Ski PaIldifil_4AE?Sé'{?.ié{‘UiS,. Advocates for R3 and R5;
” u ” M ” W,f.Ré;”3.-3_;’:>”£3«:’1′”‘ci€nt:-;”3 serveci:
I3asa2.V21pré:£Q_hu S Patil, Se’r1i.0:;’ Cousasel for
‘VEvi;’s,VBaséavaurpabhu S. Patiig Associates;
Sri ‘A E€ira.;1jar1kL1mar, Aév<}cai.es fin' R6:

..S1’i Raixigagiaiha S. J 0139 Ad’«;o{t:5d;e fog” R17;
M R. Shailendrag Act§V:1 is. ffieci unséfir 27’m.1::::§<:=:::e 226 agléi 22'? G5

"EEECV«C€m:3%i'i1;'i§a3:1 of ir1c§%;;-"2;, §.}1"Ei,§i§"i§ 2:: qu22.s2: t}f:::< CO§?£"EE1"§{§'i"l {}'{'C§€F

£i'a§:..i{7;-itiozi N<}.3¥%5'"I?" Of 218885 and
C0::”_a’rs.&éC§,€E=d; at

V. ;’%;.:1§méxi::’€«A.

15

In Writ P€:LiLi.o:1 N0. 2-3682 012009 (SEAT)
BETVJEEN:

Venkaie Gowda

Aged about 46 years

Son of late ‘\s”€:1ka£.€ Gowda

Assistant Engineer « «_
Presentiy work.iI1g in the Officéz of t’~f*._1e .

Assistaiat Directoi”, ‘§’0wI’1 Plamtling ‘ __ V’ .V V
Bruhat Bangalore Mahanagz-r214–Pellike’-{‘W’e-Si) ” A ‘
Seshad.i.rp11ram . V
Bangalore W 560 020 _._,Pe’tii.ic§gner

(By Sri S VA__E\§2:11’a1s_iAI11h;1i’;;._:’§ci§’:iQ1′ Counsei)
AND: ‘ ‘ _’ ‘ ‘ ‘
1 Siaie 01’ Kaernat.aE<;a"» . V

fig ii,s.§5i"'i.f11r:jpa1
V ' VPL1bIi{: 5-;?\7or1§i:fs,VV 'Déj{;:3§i't{I1er_1i V
\/'ikasaVS.<;:3.dh'r1 _ 'A __
I3an.ga.Iore '–w "566 «O0 .14

2 E.{.aif;1af.c11£a State Pyiblic Service C{)I11'£1'}iSSi(}{E

– .. Udy0’g:1,S’m1’dha
R’.’€Si§€§E{‘iff P5a’rk;;1 H(}{§$€
3-LB:«1Ii’g.aI0§€ m ‘5″E«}(} 001
V . F{epr_€S:”%’_1_1te<§ by its Secreiazy
' f":§fS§E'£1'%:'Si E7':"as:»1a.:£’ ‘efé.-“‘2~2i;.:3,:’ ‘§”zm’;§’E3 — 568 $43

K K Raghupathi

Major

Assistant Engizaeer, WRD

R/at N.943. “Lakshmi Niiayex”

Behind Teiephone I33xchar1ge V
BM Road
E-“‘e:’iya1.3at.na ‘
Mysore District: W» 5’71 10’?

Gokuldas

Major .V
Assistant Er1g’i11€+3r, RVREI’ –. V
P1’esen1:1.y ‘vV0rki;3.g”‘é1t 1 V V’
No.0-3, KNNL MI’SL3bADi\gg13SiOE1″=_ ‘ ,
No.5, H:i3-ekumbi,Wfiétuadatti; ‘i’aEuk ..

Be1g;aum_’i)i$t.riC:i;A~ 595%. 1_ V
I3sh}v;a.r2}p§§.a_–.’. ‘
Px/IajL’u’ _j

\7VL V i1 -‘ ‘ ” V V
R/ at ha:;>:;§;y«é. Ma Taluk.

‘V-Bangaloréz .Rx,;:’aIv DiSé;”ri.c’i: – 562 120

G Jztgad-ee’Sha.–

Majér ” V

‘ ” f–‘\,ssis’ia:’1′:.L_Eizgifiaer, WRD
Eififiifigyez {sf ¥;’.hc~::v—As’:§i$tiar1.”1, Ex.%3c’utia-re Ezzgizzeéx’

T~§<) . 2 .f' «Sub -Divisicm

. _ " ?'y'f§£13?}€i€§I§§":g{ DeVe1<3§,3II":em;. Pmjmt
" :;'?§ja§_;1W.i1{ii-E" AE'1R/EC

T t:'.z::'§”,§ Sw21m}?

~. f%:E_z1§£>r
“E%,f{> ?v’§2;:§§:i§§a2:j§m’:z:i2%§”§ K

,s’%.:’§:~ais:a11€. Einggirzfieix EFJEZD
R;”aé E05856, 3?”! E’ Cm:s=;ss

E
Ԥ
§/

17

201″ Main, 4*” 71′ Biock
Jayariagazr ‘ K _ V
Baitzgaigre – 560 O}. 1 …R<:s}3on;j'er;is ~

(By Sznt. Sheela Krishn21Ij,..,Adx'Gc:_3{é'f0:'_R1':= ' V
{By Sri Na13jL1n.da ReddyghSe1zi0r._C*0u1'1s.e1" fr); ' '
Sri Reuben Jacob, Advoqziw-T'fof'»R2;} " V

Sri S G Angadi. Advccam for "

Resp0ndenis«4,<5,' and'-".(" am
Sr; P S Rajagopa'I';»L.LS'e;1ior C;@unse_1'_;1'0t'~:V
Sri P S Rzljaigopaj f'3$SOCiEi'i$S. '

Sr; M N PrasanI1z;:::;1d K&.P':'£it.<:fg9wd21, Advoesateés for R8)

This; Writ; I3€ti's,i0r1'isii1c.d 1:;~nd§:9'r.fxr*dci€s 226 and 22'? Of
the C0r1s1;i1;L1t,io:1. of 1ndia,. pray'i'ng it')"'qzV1'a1Sh*"i11e Common {yrder
dated 19«12#EO'O8 £31 App1:;;a'E',.iL3:_1 'Nu.\1V3'?'O of 2008 and
connected £Xp;JEji€:3ti0i–1 the am.at.ak21 Administraéive
Tribunal, _.Baf1g.§eiE0rfe."sQ,fa::_0;-ii pet4fl.ior1er is concerxled ai
Annexu'reLA\ : 2

In Writ P¢~;__1£§5:<;_NV¢3;.,2;a:5TS;3 95.2009 {S~«KA'I'}
Bafwfigzg; ' "

K B Nara’si.mhv21 M~L1Fih:§”«.._
Agtxfi “f-313011.? 5}3}’€farS ‘
S_;’£iyLa_t’£: K N B§i€§3fI}18.£&1}Z1

” &AS”:~3isf£i§1t. u£Z.:1gi§1e€1″, }?’\7\z’D
‘ ,P1’€:;5r:§1vi.Ij;izaeizking in the O’ffiC:e sf {he

E’3_3*<:6{€;§ii1?'€"{§§;gi§E'1€3§.” 3:33:33 {‘x?£:’ess*{.}

*iB:*s..:ha1f §3¥ar1g;:3.1©z’e M.a.h.amagara Paziike

3’~.I=.R S:g’:.2;;.f;§%.–

E3a::gg:a;”i{;r€ — 568 {E622 ,..Pez1’§tie:1<==;*

éiiiff;-" EEK? S §?~;E'2u"29;:=si§.:3":%:.:1:: Ssrzim' Cs:3:,m:'=s¢:%E}

/4

AND:

1.8

State of Karxlaitaka

By its Principal Secreizxry
Pubiic ‘Works Department.

Vikasa Soudha
Bangaiore ~« 560 001

K£1l’7f1£iL’;}.ka State P’L1bEi€’: SfiwiceAC0111::1i$$iéi§*;:<…

Udyoga Soudha.

Regidency Parka House

Bzmgaiore W 560rQQ1 A
Rep1’esem’.ed by i–1.s:rSe(t;”€i..;1;~y ” _

B N Keshava Prasrafi

Majog” _
Assisieint :f:Il’§§if1é.€f,€ W’RD” ”

R/ at Ni: ,1 E 4″? ..M;:i’in_, BCC ‘ 1(217gIL1t
‘Ne¢’.{if_VC1i1a’11d1’£i’ Igaxytiig-1 fink

VM,£3%a.n._g2:1gretz 560._()4_O ‘

1%; aj’;;gg_i;1:i 4 ‘ ‘”

‘§v§;13′{3r

As€si.s1″a:1t E11 t*1é:s:i{.;= WRD

— , R/at °’Laé{7Shzr1i §\Ei1a;;23f’

E’:/E~ Read
_ _E3v6ri§{a:’patz:a.

_L§?3si;£’i:::i’, — 5″TF’E E9?’

E3~:’~3Tm;:1d “‘;%.'<';*§.'ep%:0:.1e f':XChE'LZ"':f__{€

G:}.§V:{':,fiV{,}é€ifi«
Bégzféé A

' V;§ss§s%.a1'z:£ EngE:1{%6:r. WEI}

E?:'"€3é3:'1€:Ej; "v"J<}:"'2»<'=:r:g§ at

:€<;y<:w3. §i7?~é'§*~1'§, 31%?S'u.?:s»E§§%;'§s:;§.{;:r1
N235, §'Eir€:%kz§mbi. Sa*J21da§,£:£ 'Fa1u§r;

E3e1§§aL1:n ET}isst1″i{3I::w 591 EEG

ii/,…

19

6 I*3shwar21p:§321

Major

Assisiani Engineer, W123

R/at E-Earthy. Mezgadi Taiuk
Bangalore Rural Dis’£’.riC’t – 582 120

7 G C Jagadeesha

Major

Assistant Engineer, WRI) ‘ V ~ _ .

Office of {he Assistant’ Execui.i~.3e Eir1gi11eE:_1″_’ A ‘ ” ”

No.2, Sub--DiVisior1     W
Marketing Deve10pn1ent°Pr€)j€Ct.

Batawadi APMC  --

'"fL1mk'ur  ~

8 H M T Swarny _ V _ _

Major  A 

S/0 Ma11ika1ju.n.aiz:h  A _
Assistapj';Eragixiéger,.W"}?<D_  _ .

R/at F[_Ci"0s;~?§  " 

: 20""  453? T *
LIayVanaga1' '-~ %   * '

Ba:11§g;211ore.V_~V 565) O.1 _ §< …R<-:sp0ndems

{B}.-Y VSn1{;– Si';_€e'i'2i KI"iShI1é:1I)., Aéxméctaés .fGz" R1;
B}-*::3:fi N8.}'3j¥_iUdZ:1 Raddy", Seniar Cosmsczi fax"
81": 'Rtgzbézrg Jaeah, Acivgcaffi fer R23
Sfi S G Angadi, Advocate for R3;

Rwfi :3’ia.epS not éaI§«;e’:1;

. R5 8 anti “F are serveci:

<Sz"i. E? S Rz»:jag{:'pa§, Segzéez' Cazgrisei far
E;-;':;"2I"}7' S Rajagepai Ass0<tia1i'.§”: §i.}.<:d :.21':(i.€:' :%3.r°%;;%.<éEs:t$ 226 .2é.':1:i 22? {if

Aé;.hé::_ii<::1.ssE.ii.:.:.zé’n :*: m'<E{:=.:f
'a:§'_'§_§;=Ii§ 19«§2:-2:098 ii'; §:p'pEi<:ai.i<;:": §\§<::,§4»§'? ref 21398 ':33? iJ::h«€:

20

Karnata.ka z’XdI11EE’z§Si’.i’€1EiV(“3 TribL1na1, Bangeliore. S(;”=f£i1z11ing cm t”o1″”‘dVi1*§s:–.._

this day, N. KUMAR J., made the iiQ11VQ$=vi:2g_:’
0 R D :1?) R ‘ ‘

in all thesse wrif; g3€f;i?{y;’c3.n.ga. *:&}Vi<3.v."i3'rder
passéci by the Karnataka Adx3%iVi';i:§fiZ1'21§'iv*eV;§'rE£a};1'fia11 tthailenged.
Therefere, all these up V1;fi:*VAvVc:o:1siderati0n
i10,ge:i,her and disposed Qiigg-I;'V\{'.i€I~a

W.P.Nos. 6559 t}:C3’9: _ ”

2. _ . V’£”»h:;*..,_Ka.’rr::1iIaka. Pubiic S€§’V§{‘,€ CO§”I1ET1iSSi{)?3 {for
Shari ‘i1erv:%i1″:21f1;§3§”.i:0 as “[3333 ‘COm.missi.o11′), issued a
;20éifi::2itiG§.:: afiéatci-_ 3’§’._»%’~{E5″Z iziviiimg appiicéaémns fer E’f3{TY’LETi§J’f3€I1’i

:p0S’£:§” eff AASSE:-“§1′,211’1’E, Ex:*ké§ ‘f}¢M§,s;;:’i::”:t:::é:.{ The m.1r:1bs’:r 95 ;30s’:.:.~: n0’a:;’.§.ed was $2 in

‘Vi,§1é:€=:%:;§;id r:£§€,§f§{;.a3.i(>z1., ‘§.”v”h§=’3.:’1 Cc>[§1p:”i:<.;é:«:E 13:2 from awzongsi, Open

'{'G'I£"i}§}éi'f§§f§C§"§1.€§.£'£E1£§§{ii&?h?§E;?-E5 agrzaé ':§ f2*{'211': En~éaz:%:'°i;éz:<=: {%23.z1é%d22i.€s:a 'E"'h€

iziééi 'é:§2?£é,'€? £03" z"e€:€§'.§:2E sf 22§}§_駧{:2i3..§=:3:.":£; :?;§.€}5.2{3G?,
. :_ E

a/'

23.

SL1bs€.€;ue;1i;.]y. the CC)I}1YE’1iSSiG§’; issued another. “111.g§§fijit;?;}L*£{)1″:
dated O8~{)8~2()G7, by which t.1’1é”: 1’i11I}T1§(*3If.””;V4.’gf
eznhancted. The mzrxzbm’ of posts £T§Qi,if§§§d in”ifo’i;§£1_’_:x,x}é§ :éiat ”
of which, 84 posts were

canciidates and 20 fer inmser-;?ic1e:_c:emd1~<jIates. V _.

3. The Gave:-nr11en’i;, ‘”-of K:11*22’af;:”§;§2 i”t3ga1’di1ig”‘%}’1’e resemE;Lt.io11

policy under A2-iinties the Canstiiution of

E-nciia. laying §i<3&§§*t1_1.he§:' ('.fC}f»I1':_}§.==."t1'1'€','I*?L§'.<'_;"i.?\_/'(3 tf:»<3.zi113y iayer policy. The

said An.:1€Xii15é:_~ 1_&1. tQ E-1fi1 é*3a.ic1 Governmem Order provides a list
of peféezass {x–*1'zQ"Ve%§_17é:_»T'vrsgfig.-..}5§é’»–.i'{:;*A’::s;:;;3r\;2″:’ii;%: zjazider ‘£37352 sgezié {7.2,1€:<3g;?<§r§r :1}? balskwzird

{:§_;3sses;,. " ' L

22

4. ‘i”1’1(: Karmliaka R<5se:"vaté01'1 of App{)iniT'1;§i'€%:1ts Of
Posis {in the Civil Servictes of 'the State] for E%L1;jjai– C'z=3é'di'c%.ates

AC1, 2000, for Short; ihe 'Act', wass bxfmxgllt iI}'£.€:"!i

F€bm.ary. 2001. Se<::i3i0'n 3 of the said Act. pr'uv*i..::fe::i"i~1ia§25_%" Qf

fhe vacancies ear' marked for direpi, re§:rL;ifi?:1€f1f. viii' –r.:::=a.§:'}V1 {Q{

ca*{€g01*ies of ge1'1e3*a1 :<31:=;rit, Scéhexdtalfii Ca1s'té:f to Secéion
3 9f the said Act pr0’v_ide_ci 11112;:vi.he ‘vr:;j1:pept of ctreamy iayer

madej &113]3’§_KAiACf%2fi)1(§ €13 -pvé1*.vth_e ‘order of the GOVE:1″‘1″1ment with
rega1″d’1′,:> f’E’.’-S~’E31″‘x,~”.§13′.V,i*:’,’v.E’1 §l§S.,§,{€’.d’.%iI.1d€1′ elezmse ~51» GE A.:'{.i£:1:-: 16 of the

C0’11:>fi£11té<iVr1..$§'1ai§"ap'p§§;*'rma£:a£:is mz4:::a;'2dz'.s '€23 éhe ease of 3 1*z,:r2:1

&C.:11fi dEd'12:'i;.e"' ..b€3i01:gi§'1§§;' "£10 C:€.:"1¢=:1"a1 E'v"i€*:'i"t 91" Ofi"§€*E' E3aCkwa:'€§

':18;S3}i}'"S–z_ {*'.';~'.:(E'?(–.?*.§}"_€:,..{?2fii{€g()»}.'}' E. élxercéssing p<*3w£-3:" zmdfir Secéitm § of

§,.?:'»7g€'f gairtf; 27-'«.;:ii; {.239 State: {'z§3*«.,»«'€:r:'1:z'1{::':%;: Elam iS':3?..1€?€.§; 2: G{}'»"¢31'E"HE"£€E}11.

Q§"€1€*Zf ééizsied E3.G2;G.£ whiith ::§a:°:%§'i::¢s:~; {",i'33E"i.E:§.iE'3 5159:-::<:i.s~:; 22%.}:

~,T:fé?§_%:;_':.%:'{§ is E°€f§}}§':1:’=;§de:n:s for ihe: au.i}:2{:ri1.§es.-1 xx-*§1e:> are cgzizgaitieziig is

%

23

iS$¥.1€ Lzertifictatezs fer the saidi purpose and presrn1s

tllereio. Clause I of {he said G0ve3i’r1m&*i1t {:3FCl:i17

the concept of creamy layer shall a_ppl\;_ to cziiitE§’;téé;’»bélongiiég_

to general <::af;.<–:go'ry and cz1l,€g0rie$A;4ll~;»X',T Gf

Backward Clauses.

5. The res;30rlden1,s ,%.:z3l_’ Ei{):f).liC§VV?l1_iliV.i:311 lllo. 1770 ,1′ 08,
1792/08, 1794/08, 3403/58. 4795/08.

479E:L/O8 anal 4797/Q8. in the Public

Works 1Dept:E_” the ‘_’VVai:ér—-Reso-urces Development

Dep§,..lv'{VJRD’D) A’:;s:;:~;t.ani,'”=§,–::{gi11eez’s. Tliey applied in
pursaiaiace 3.? il.a_,E:-..Said”n(ji:i.{i.c::s.1i0n. Thssy are all eligible to be
c::3nsider’§§”£:Z{§§’:*-.4@f:£,{€[€g<§:?i<£S, Cf€i"lIE3Jil'1 §::<}Sl'8 am §'€S€3I"~£€Ci :25; par the

"'§f€,'Ef:£E§°'é;"&1l;.l£.f)i'E'.l fisslégty al' €'.h<:=. G{}V§%I'E1}"§1€3f:l'.. 2

24

6. Responciatltis 1 £10 9 are aCi§I}.i.’LiE”i’d1yI :G1’fGUp~B

officers. “Except r:::~sspox:1c§ent:-3 2 and 4, i}1&::..__’4I’eVé’2,*uihe

respondems have produced cert4if§cat.es iss%.:ed.–§:5:y* t.h_é’E.”7 *;11$’;1*::3a.r

in Form–F which. is a czzste {:e:i:ii’ic:21t.eJ£S$’ué@:%» {*0 ‘perfsofis

belrzmging to Backward Ciassesfl <:e':i¢;é;§Qri4é3s"' A:jt.1'1ér..'~t_E1a.,r1Tffofw

ctategery 1. The said (;:er£ifi§*.at€ "p{:;fSGzzé'-3:1
whose favour it is isssueci ..130t. i',.1r'ie' (:rea1ii1f
layer as prescribed b}?V__G-overnméAmj_ oV£i_VKa'rf:ataV.}_<:a.VA_in respect of
respondents 2 anci 4.,' QO1€1C€§'I]€3{}..T?3j;iSib1dEiI"S her»-*6 refu$ed to

issue such a CTCFUfiQ.at€ in'T'E*?_Q:'§<i_1§F'b o:3..i4héI'V_'g;féu11d that they hoid

Grouip~Ei'» pds'i{.s_» am} c0nS"eqL1e11_i1y, come within 'she creamy iayer
as described .»'{30v£. Order. N*t.i<:'§11g '£:h€ said
an0ma1y a::.j1c;£-ce;"é;ifia:2ite3%.s'" issued by the "§'ahs3iidar and 'taking

111%; {E5nSid€F3"E~§,QH ef me Gm:<:~1"I1.121<::":%;. Orciez' am? {E26 §i::""i;.her

. A Q2:§':§–§fi.§.§3£f€!.': §;:;S§’.§i.8:é {he :”€$;>0:1=:§en§Z.s N8. E to 9 haéé C%:'{>L1pwB

*;};>’:~;?;$ =.,_i:51.. Gmfl§;., C{:smz11i$::;fZm”: ;Z:’3.§¥;}’;”§::.}+£:::E {E326 $ai€E

“E’=:~’:~%§§c:1r:§e§:;–:3A i=’;§%’:e1%; ‘%.h€i’r C3865 €Ei3Ti1.’2{§E. be itazzsgiiisired Llfifiéf Ehe,

{:;é;’£;e%§§§:::°éei=s “EE«:’%, E§»§%., §§§–g2 zmcé {E38 :32? Ezhéj E3:§,4:.*,§;;W£¥.’§’i”§ <:§21s:3S€s:.

/'

25

7. Aggrievezi by thte said a<:iior1 01' {he CGfi%fi1.i$SiGI},
I"€SpO1'1d€I3'£'.S 1 to 9 have i'r1dividL1a1}3,r filed 21'p§1Vi'§%f;ii{§it344€:*»'Vifieibre
the Trfiaunal. The respcmdenis N0. 2 and -<§ 1"':':1'
C2lS"€.€ certificates have not been_iss:,:ed_."by'
Tah.Si.1.d.arS soughl, a di.}:eCt.ion to
their Claim uxlcier H16 (to:1ce1iI1¢d {72i{.¢§or3r '{;'i£1%'$S€AS
anti consequently for a dirVec:i;Vi:'i':L'r; to 'CE-&.}__1 U–'1_ér't: viii???'VVI}Q~;:SOE1aii1i:i,?
test under the said category V_f'(3_12'V:'&'~,'f:1'L""vQv1,i()I{T1.'3l"ld E¥.Qi5{)i1'1'LI11<':3i'}'f, to
the post of The 01116;:

respondents, respondents Z, 1’1E1V€ sought for a

direciion i_(> ‘t1i_e Cé3Inzr1iSs;s~:i0r2_r1*ot. to igrwre the ifiaim of the said
r€sp0z15d=_§§’:};~;.,sai1:8 and 54:9 :

8′ ~ “E316 :”€3g3<::":d@:::¥;s; E Magi 2; £31 E:§}§}§i£':aE§{}.'{'£

_I'V€?;'§':«':~..},"§*"'°53;'{}E§ aziai 3.§»'%6;"'€39 are s§::1iie1§:§j; §:¥E2':<':,e{é as éizaé }E§I”‘€é§£'[i§3’i?–_ 0:1

the bas3i$ eff:-1136 casta ceri’.ifica$,es._ ..Cl,1ai1en’§i’fig*f%;e é’a.§ d. ae’:ti€51:u ”

of the Commission. Applicaiion ;’N0;[_”‘LiF’53}’O8 _:éi1ici O8 ”

were filed.

W.P.No.651O to 6513/2009 :

9. The in Jgpfiiiatatian Nos.

1756, 1757, 1758 aigglj fire all woriaing as

Assis1;.a’r1t hi. this “Ei’ae;i5a_r it:x1er1.t…4:ol” Public Works. They

app1ie«_iA”‘[L;.y;d’s3i” §§5:»r1’eraE””:::V;1{ég0ry in pLEII.’SU’c3.’I1C€ of the
n0t:ific:_ati0r1 .is s»ied” Commission for re<<-:<:i;:.1;i*{9':m:V' Eiig"§fiée1*s undey the 'in service' quota.

'?he_ -re3p0:'{de;:i's. 3135- cfézinaeci the berzefii. ef :r€serva'ILi..:.?e:: ‘V§’Z3éjI>’;’Z’)*'{4§”ij’1’v;’fV§i”§.. ::€:z’€.i§”é<:aEe::s in Fem; 2 21$5s'ue£§ by ihe <.:«:2:"2<:e3med

a.zi:h0:'§§j'éS_, "£71.16 ;'€sp{3m.Cieni.55 'W€E§'€i i$$2m£% ir1¥;,€3:r's«-"E699 ifiiésrs

r€:::'j;z:é:'iV:1g"{}:5::r;: is 2a;p§§<3az" far me pnaE.i§.jy” Exist by éhég-: KPSC9

..’E’?:€;*. S2′;-‘}.§€3 1*esp,

;/

General Merit. {rural} czltfigory as they were €l.igiblé’w’I,:fi2dEf the
Same. The responclents ware not eligible iiéfmlé-t*«”f{_)r

ini,e:’vie\v if their C£i’I’1CllClalE,EI’E3 ware to be c(3’v?:.s3i_{3’:~?1fvéc§.:”L:rider”

general (‘,Ei{€gOE”§-‘. The I’€SpOI1dfi’.I:TLSm2i1″3 “21’l:l;31§l§t§élCi3},-*
officers in the services of the St3.l.”c.V
corne Within the creamy 1ay{::1f_v’as§ préscfibed rd§:li~
C111. 30-3-O2. They were motll”i1fllc:}riev}écl! are not
considered under Ge11l:f”a1l ~–Q;1’teg0fj’ lflhaay were not
eligible to be §nie:’view*edl.AV_ zictiorz of the

Commission _3’3’1 1′}Qi. (§X§.en§f;é.r1g beiércfit of GE-ineral Merit

{Rural} cat{“ég{é’1%y._AVVi’Vl31¢ :~”:2t1:i§'{l.Vv;”esp_nndents filed a_pp§.1’cai.:ons before
the ‘{‘ril:)i3ri:a1. “c’;ii’ec:.ior1 to the KPSC to permit them

:0 ;)3.3’t.ici;32i1rz:_éz’§£16 peréonality lea. In the said appiicatiens,

Atliifié’ 5.&ElSO”..’SOLIg§}lil llll for 2: €lt3ClE}.I”E’E{i(}§} thafi; pm'”l’.i:r1 of the

daiecl 30»3wG2 §3§°i:”:g{ilf.e.g {E26 {}«’:3’l2.€I’3.l lkéleréé

{:’z__,;ral} V.c;i’iI@§:;:>ry z,.::;Cl{;%;” iéreaarzéfg l;2;”%.:€€3§S’ <?i: anti pregcrébmfg

§*'{>:”:1}. {:15 illegal 21:15? imfaaliéé.

E 3
%v// ,.z ‘

28

E0. The app1ic::;1nts~; in Ap;>1ic:ai.ion N’c§¥.’5Q13fQ7
cerrespanding 110 Vv’? N0.E$418/0?’ ~ R. Rayj§§t_i2;ih3:zja'”-and

Applicatiorl 510.5015/O7 correspo:1dir1g to W?:”NQ;é34i:”1′?j.(3–?

K. C. Sh§Va.ku’m.a1′. working in O1,h€’If”VCr{}V€I’?1ifi€f}J1″D{5§)El’i’U13fiIifS._

They 1’1ave not been interviewed }K4?Si:3_’0-:24″i.h6: g.m1Q1.11d.’~-_

that they are over aged. ‘Fif}.ey céemcfided t1i’1:EifL’_’i;{ L11€v6[‘3}fb] ~.Qf
the Gezaeml Rercruiimfzxzi RL1:}es a~pp1ie.:§ tr) T’.§’3.,§3: 4éLfi’C1’V:i}1<:y
Ezmitled for the beizefiyef age :'_e.1é§x:;i1an azs.'ct3:1vt_§1i1j;V<;}d §,}1ez'ein, in
which event, U16 C0:%1113;i1"'graV'e iliegality in not

sailing ihezm for iniervie\v.'7

1 1. " ' ~' péti'[.§,O'I.1Q::{;-(3. Kfifiletr is working as an Assistant
E)n.gi::{ee'r'; 4prcse11 t'i§.{ 'un 'd.cpa_,n;ati0n in Bangaiore i)eve10'pment'
Au*:h0ritf§.?;.__ " _ H:-3 V\7£'8UE;.'é.f)§}OiI1.i.€E§. as, an Assisiani Elngiizeer in

?L;1;)1.i'C; W"0'rks;'*§}_éV'pVé11'%.fi1t:%§2%i'. (izgiring E991. HES 'f6C1'{Ei'tf:'1€i":?; was in

'ié'E"'£'T:'.':&?»;5»- 7s";§ iihe Rfiiéé {:&¥.1§€"d £3725 §'Za:°;';21ia'E~:,;a_ §311."b§§c 'i3J§§~;S
‘ V.VE:Z1.§;{iI’E§€?§i§’§§;u_f}_€p21I’*{‘.1’IT:€”E1i. S£5:’vic6S {}”<Zr:£’,} Rzsieis. $88

” .x§3§;§<?%i";4;:z1:{::.;i;f:i:a ffifiifi from, E'}"'.8..:§E%§< R £5; §:~:é.21%:i-:53 éhzai, éffzss

§'\:E}E"I£'2.&Ei1'fi£&;i:'.,-§3"EE§")§3§C Vv'm"§:s; {§2"z'i§;;;"§'t4;1:;:»:: S€'£"'J§£3€S} {§%€CruE§me:':'i:'.}

E

29

Rifles. 3.988 also Came 10 be f;’am€d si.I11111ta§:e(>;.;S[§;§;”:_VThus

there: were S€i’pE”iI.’.’:1t€? and di.siim:t ren._’ E)e&’1)a:*’tr:t–€:I1f{‘ “21. ‘

not,ific:e;r.tio13. dated 22.52,.200′.?’ t.1’i’::

Eng.iI1ee1’ing De’par’E.me’r1t Sgwices 7[R€;-::.:L:’I””~..by (.j.GT§1})6?f§iVtIi’g’€§”‘=:EX€iIf;:i§’:aTVi{f)i”i)
Rulea 2007 p1’€SCI’ibifig the x:_1_¢i{}’1{;;j’ pf réériafigxaegfi, 1,0 thfi’, post
of the Assis’t.ar1t ‘”.[I_)ivi$io11.–1}, mode of

Conduciing conapetitive <:Xarr;i":1VéJfi0r-s,._vprfiépgfiatien of seled: list,

eta, aw/as; _iT;<§$5:;-.s=:c_iV. v.V"1"1'3§%"~«I?_L1b1ig* W0rk$ C0;Im1i.ss3'0:r1 Vide ihfiit"
E10§,ifiCEi{iQ'l'":"d2ii€d ii'i"¢'E'§'.€iC} 2,1pp1iCI;1'{.iOi}-S frorri rsligible
(',&11'1diC§21?:.€;§" f{j;',12';*.§fi§%;.'*;;vg "1;i.p 52 posts of Assisiané Executive

E1if§g;ir1b_<~:L::'r {DiVi$iO:'1"+"§§='Vzmi. G? which E6 p<33é;S 233%: €a§"mai::'k€d E01"

' V.V§.t';.::3e;-wicées'*._§'és;r1{iidates in KPWE}. E'et'éi'.'iG::€:§ ambméited his
. ez.T§;;.1Ei<7~:%.?it;:;:1 gi-:a;–v"a1g};g:i:2s%;' tbs saaid; :2ai'.ifi€:3..i:i<}::. Er: the farnzai 0f

*§;'::2§.-3 ap§;éi~;éL*_'.§§i§§1 221; SE. i'\E<3.'?Z ii is S§§€;'.{:§f§{?:/3.3}? staéfiii as 'n.1E'1€§{".§"' : M

w5…….,.',

1

30

“Do you ciaim in-service quaia? : Yes 0, No O
For PWD employees oniy. if 50. shade Vfine
apprapriate circle” H

12. On 8.8.200′? yet anoéher :1c>i.if’E{:2uj’i&;nv.{:;é:t1x§€3 be

issued enhancing the number ofvgzzefists ‘ 1’Q%;:.’VQ’t1’Vf’£3’f:’ a
which 84 posts were 6:’c1}.”1I}611’i:%2’§i%(T1::._’_ f’€’;’:V1′
candidates and 20 posts f<)i"V._iV:r"1~:..s§e3rx.r"iA(§'::…Pétit£e::%*r
wha belongs to category under 2A.

Responcients 3 to 8 hv23(“w; b.eé«r1: appointed in ‘Natal’

Resources Dep2u’1,1ner1£”ifisr:S1’iO:§f’»WE{i)] €i:Li1;:iz1g the yaar 2002M

2003.¥__ Thii’ ;5e’i:i€1*r;fie1f”e§§fit_e1’1ds that the two depar’::11en1:s are

separate”V.Le1’A:iitié:s “1′.1Aéw’iV1:.1″‘.g§ 4sepa1’ai.e rec1’:::i1.me-m. ruies, Gm

145).} 1 31,99 K1333/fV V{Vfri§{é:i,i;: Services} {E?;ec:m1i’:.rr:€:”;é. €}§ASSiS1E1fi’E

A «f£~?;f{§,g;i:3é:§:”:~=_ ‘;2;:;_2d &L1:r:§0r Engineers} Spextiai Ruies, EQQS was

.i*3§;z&é{%L:”‘~«P§L2E§’T?'{2}{_b} 9%’ the said Ruies s§;e£:%§i.ca.§§y przwédess {he

gztace §”iiéif}§S 0f 5% far 6229?: §:6:21i’ £3? S-3€}’°Vi{?{:’. szxbjeati {:2 rzlaxzlnnxnz

Ag}? 38%.-:i3Ir1a1E.E be aciéeii ii} {The §}€fC€’.§”§ia§§€ {:5 £493,211 iziazrkis gaiétzraéé

‘ 5:; c3emd%é_2:é.£§ £2: ézirfui. :;z,:&§3i§E;° :-‘:x3.’m§:”;aé.i:3:”:§ if :?~sI;4:<*:ir1 stazzdridzzéa
._ E

iv/I//4….

AA a2:§:.§::° ‘v§7.:3f{?€§§3*{, 6;? ap§31i:%21i;’iaz:;<; §"r<}::: G§i"i{?ia§:% ::2?€:=:*k§:§;§, in

" "Re_:=;C%;z.r{?es; D€§321:"I::11€:*:':%i §.§1.zé§z::iiztzg' :'€S;2(;:1:§e::%;§ 3

31

has served on c{>:3i,ra<:1: basis; as Assistant I+Zr1.gines:r_"cs3.jTJu.r1.i0r

ingisaeer as the erase rs121;,=-' be in the Ir*n'ge1%',i(mj'E3ep;¢:*£I:é¢_n[i. of

the State. A car1dida'§:e who is working 0_n._,<;d'nii'a§:'i .baSiis..

PWD is not eligibie fez' such we§.§__1hi.agé«Qf35%'{.E)3* <3_ach'yeé{_:' of

service iike £1 C()I]U;'E1{'I €ngi1.1eer ii}. the AErrigé1¥_Vib'n_ De};fiéi1rtfi'1€I1t.
Thus, the ré2C1'L1§'tII1€I1't rL1I€S_ I.V~,-'{§*-d€3pVaI'{1;11€if;1';E3…{}f{}E31'EHf.€v§.i;1
seiparate fields and d€{.3artn36:1i:§_ 211$: separgité." Itgis csnly after
the publicaiion of n1av1'k:3_1;is'c'2:11d'e1§giE5'i1_it'y list i&*i't}: reference tie
register number thr: p€4i'iV1;i0%,';éér1'].é;~21i'1;i;~Vih.a1. iI1e1.i.g.ibIe WRD

Engineer ctan.c§i€ia_t.es fhave;bs:e32 '–r:Q:ris;E:i€i*ed under iryservice

post; "1'}1e_[15e1vi.%iiQt1t,r \s2j2i;t:._1_";0t: afzwan-3 of the said facé at the {ime
of parti::ip:.'1_tir1'g.V_infmvé'–.r§v':"ii't'er1 e:X21n1i113J;'iG11. ii; is only after

Com-.in.g to 41%:220wV<3'i" Séarne he has preferreci téxis Writ Petitien

A Ch«21§€»€*z'g§i1*1g§mafia' :§é§éc'u0n ameng Qthm' grotmés.

':23 .:E~'1fI;–=:": Pubiic Siirvice CGE."£1;E"§}§SS1:0Z"§ fig: 'aha zrepijs "befere
'iéwg '§'§*§b:;::21E 'i.r21a-*e'rs.%.:.1g {he aibresaifi £1§€§.?f_8J;.§{§§"iS s§€.z21.ed éha:

15sf21'§.€;%§."

1-“W

Q

/

/

8
E
$9? /

32

eI.arifieat.ion has been sought. {rem PWD in ézhis as

per Eetier daied 3}-ii.-2008 a §;het.eee’py ef whi(:h:–.

AI11″i€XU.E’€wRI has informed that theA»Vapp1ie:e1iie’11e{_”fe§*tVa1:dcrj by

the applicants through ‘?=’_’WI).

(C0r:1.municat.§0r1 8: Bllildiviljgfifil 03;’-VCiV}*’;%ef’
Resources Development <3-113;?' E;3e ireaied as
applications from Accordingly,
applications of respondents 3
"L0 8 Engineer, PW}?

(Cen}I11u11ir;at.i:eE_1 8%” »Bi1i}edi’ngs) Chief Engineer, Water

ReS0t._1rces_ ‘:;_m-r¢1b,pm;:ia~«+..__ Orgaliisatiosa 0111}; have been
ezlteriamed. ‘ii ;.s~s§a;~”m:. __fr1a1.;={hough FWD and Wat:er Resources
Deve10;>me.:_;t. ‘O’I’g3_HiL3£1L{iQ~’i{“l are bifurcated ihe separatien ef the

txxgqi :iepa1’t:r§’eeze is no: fL1§y eempiete a.11.<:E 'ijhai. eommen.

V'.se'f1ie;9i§;4jy1fg§,.§2§{ia€ion. éisi ef E§SSi8lZa1"i§ Eingiygeere ii-3 beimg

":g&_;}e:fejé;é;{iIe . §e~:j 'jihe puepese ea? ;3:"e:"ee*:.ie:*:. E1 is; in {hie

ei;*e:,z:;;1.s£.2';.%f;ee'., :"ee§3enéer:te 3 "E3 8 have been permiéied fie a.§3p'i.y

§ef'iEt1e?".pes§' ?;;'3};* we:,»: 22.5; far &::;'s:~s e<:m:e:'3§:*§af::2 <3? Eéze a§:=;:z¥;§a:2"::1*{.

E
%
=_,/

33

is conctermzd the sarne has; to be 1.ra1v&r&2ed by resp9f1d_éni:”No. 1-

State o£’E{amai21ka.

14. The State at para 6 0_f..i..h;:3§ sizi_i.éiiéVé£2f_’: .0f’0bj.ec:v£i0fm_ ”

have made I-.he:’ir position clear. T11-.e}r :§i1bfi1ified~i hatV; :iji’=:.¢§?1.hc ve ”

insirucied the KPSC not to.

Govemmeni as irysemfice [j ri3;3a1*’1.ment’. of
Public Wo1″ks and .fi:’fi5j'{f1;{:{,iOH C€1II1€ to be
issued by t4hisA._res;)Qn:i€:}1i.4V. )y1:”§”1:.€ faci; that Public

Works £)e§)2:i_rt.§I’§:~:’i1_1 h}.1s _ié§su§§riA._ VV{iC}1ii’1IZ1Of1 seniority list. 01″

AssisE,a;1″1i: “EVrs:ri§s Depart::mené’, and Ir’riga1′;i(>n
Depa?irz1s:1*1t ?,$§’F'()+~t:§T1I’i'<:.;11'ic}:'1 dazcrcl ZQWBWZZOOB. Verticai
bi1'L1:"Caii{)£*; of $Y\}\:'OfkS De'partmer1.t anti I1'3"igaii.01.1
Dep21rtme£i'é. h.'-£1011. takrsgrx piactix In ether Words, it is

Si.';I'E}:I1j'ij?;€d, ' ihai' '{;h.e«'pr{3Lt€ss of bifL1:°c2m%.011 of E.W'{': sen-was

» 1:'1–a::1<:iy;«.§*:;"Eés; '€i="':*%;s; I}ep:5:’fl;.:”:’1<:é11':'. £1i"§{§ Ez*:"ig21%'i::z:": E)23;:’é’m::%:”1ii. is

. ¢EG’v<:é%;i£3.:rC.a1.i;2gg {he §3u’0iic

3;*5;}2’i~;55=.~§;?<:L::f%;iA:*::: :«;»::z{i Er:*ig:3:1j{;':": §£é€?}""€i{.';€.' §$ heizz;-gg ¥;.E{§§ii*i'E up Er; 819:

pmCf&:?sé;; ii: is iimmii '%'.h2:'€'. r2':2m§; <3f§i{':<=.'i's wha f;',X€E"{?iE3€ E:h€ir :3§é.§<m

34

at: one poini of T.’i’I}1€ came ‘:10 be pi”Of§10′[.€d to the Vnéfigfhigher

e;:ac§1’e or r€i.ir(~:d fmm service and c0:1sequ€ni1}-*. Ijihfié’ 3;iié”;Qf5’t§on

exercised by them has become infr’uctu0u.s.”-._II’1 ivifzféi? ‘ C)f: [“h’i;’:”.’_

necassary steps are being taken u_p.i0_ir1x-‘i_te cfpf;i_C.n ‘f;$GfI’:;_ ‘

among the Gfficers in variaus, {fadI’€_iS. .E’a§_Jf3ak§I1g..ifi-to'”3_’€;:o’a:;::=§ of

this fact, arid corzsidering f;ac.i
appeinteé in Irrigati0’r1 é0t1sidered
for promotiorl along 5.>~’.fi:Vh E1r1gi11:?{C::~./:§””app0i’§é€’;ed the Pubiic
Works Depairtment, t.h € 4.éi.’§1 3;§’ir1-1fl§ci in the iI”rigatin
Department ar6a.e’111′.iti¢r§« :haVv—:=:_ “Benefit. in respect of

the ri;:c:rL1i1′.1i1’c’r_a1_._at:.{},ths:Vfags?Q5 Assistzzmi, EXe<::ut:iv€ Engineers
Divisiofi E11 pL1bfi;(.?"'sV'DI:kS' ':D€pE3.1'[§I1€3I17., Elfid a<:C01"di1'1g1_*y*. the

KPSC was i%';s€r11cvf.€<:§ to cczzsifier thff' Irrigeitisn personnei as 31.21-

– «sé’rvie:*.é” * *f?;8;1T1 &id8J;€S .W

‘ ” VV State has pzreilssrred 21 detaiieé «:::,:m.er ‘gefsre

€12.17: E{z1r;:a,f;j;;§{a Ad’r;1ini$E’:’2:§:’.iar€: Trébmzal iziaiéiing éfiheir S!;a.n.d V523;

:”:1.€:3.:’ $63 $111″ 2153 ‘éhe {f€}}”3€féE’§}T§ G? {::”z3;1:31§.,-” §:£–‘;jJ€§° azéci ‘ghfii Qe:3’%::.

‘Qr%:i’?.::’:r$ givézagg s:i”§’e<%£' £0 ihe: Said e::':"<":amf§; £235,782' peiicfjg. '§"i::€§:

C0nt.:::'nd 'ihéit a persson who falls w.it.hin thti C',1't'.E1I*.«3i:}_V§"-.§_.£ftj«:f'.t'i7V is 21

person reaching acivanced level or s;1a'Lus. A p.é_rS'c}2":V_'W't;0%~Vg.iVC<:s

not belong £0 either 'SC or ST or any of cl33s.:3::§"__

n0t,iI.ied by vir1.L1e of the pI'OViSi:G".{iS_§3Or1fléIj3'}'é{ir_Lii1§}f;j'1;'4§1"L':.C1€ .,

16(4) of the Constitué.i0n is Ve::1ee1;"11e “f€51’v~~rc~:§e:”vat§£;t1
as 3 rural Czmdidate. To dei’.é’:’_r;1i:1c whU;he3* aiperson who

“reached an E’iC1′.—‘”E1}’iC€’ A__S13.C:i211 A Iejvei -,_{;~:i :-:.*{:atL1s fails within the
creamy iayer, ec0nomic’:$ss’£:22.tu:§;~ ¢;1aIi1e1yVV1Z’he income limit and

properties held’either.’b’t5iefigi’11g_:Q §*7iV;_11¢ cV};9’hisa family is also to

be f,21?K€I1 iI1’1′.V’~r.V!’ ‘r_,}’.(_-3’€}()v”i.3.VI11.”.<'V§§LS.SLEC:§'}. considering this aspect and by
referrirzg icy t1?1€%:sé:'-. I:'::1<::1'.}:..__ £15161 aiso f;7s:11evC0{:rt Eeiating {:0 {he coilcepé, of {?E’€aII”£}’ Eayer.

«t:he«:’OrderAvHé{{ed 33.82209: {A;zn€Xur5~:’3} {tame {Q be

“%g.;3:;::3§V1′;»–.V_«§t :18. jzéssi. and proper :«:m{§ 31:1 a<m:i21:: w}’.”é.§:: the lam?

iaid :>m;” $1516 fS’Lzp:”€§:1::% C0u:’?;.,

” AA 1%: ” Fa. £3 i”u§*E.h€:’r s22%3rm7’%’:.E:é%:i magi. ii: is :1 $:1

‘ 8.% E*é1W ‘J 21′: {$.36 R-“€’E°§,.~’ Gbjféfié ;'{::31′”1.:?.€p%: 95 E’€;?3§’Ei”‘£E%¥:§G§”: is ‘:10 “re:–‘£86

38

the status of 8. group Of persons to reach the 1eveI”0f”-pezjsom;

who are at the higher level. ‘I”1’1:;:%; being the §)0$:é:t’§{t$ri>,vVV_’:{*g–.:§§siidbe

noted {hat admiéxediy, the persons xvh0…,§_fi5_eV1Q1*:gT’ ti) Zotheréfi

Backward Ciasses under Article the; C_n”fiaref. V

deemed to have 1″68.Ch€d advemce:t;¥¢
ihat of {he persons who Vé0 r1{>t”¥_)ve’1″:>r:g cegetegerieea
Spectified under Artide 16(4). {,heV311_§_p’ui§;neV€i;Cievernmeht
Order while .insisti.ng Co;j1{:e:’;).ff_:’r3f”Q;*ea.riij}”layee for persons
belonging to other Article 16(4) of ‘the

Constimtion prescribes; {he canchldaies

beloriging £0″ ggenei;a,1 1*:1e3~=it_. claim of the aitandidaies Ceuld
be eX1,e–nded preVx%ie3;’s0r1s §3e1.0;’1gi11g

tie ,E3ackxi?a::€;i-C1é13se5″ufider Article 16(4) of {he C0nsi;it;u1i0;1

a1j.;c_;_E. genera? h1e’r£i. car1d:;da?;.es are equaé in siaius. Such piea

‘V ‘ eeé:’i’}n<j'{"E%eVV'ezzieflazined for {he eitrngjle I'€EiSQI"1 ":";%:23:':'. made? Aréieke

' E e'i'<:.

\ ‘;gm?;»5pE§;r1Eié;”2z:’e iteé. e§’2″E!ii.§e§:E E8 the ?t3e§§.e,f§fi;. Sf ‘EE’2»e {%:}*¥e:”:1.:::e§1é.

” AA GTerde’r’::ficEe Am”1exure«~5. “file azbeve nar:”2:%,’.e€1 ézzeia pssitizm

3%

L//..

37

of law L1Z”i11}iS'{.£1k£ibI:,—‘ demo’11sir8J.e that {he app1ica§’_:’£3 not

made Gut any 02136 which V»-‘E1§’I’3.I1iS inf.e_¥’i”é§re:’f§g.€’j:«–..[th.e

irilpugneck order and 115-“nee. they 35:: _1.iE’ib1€f J[“(‘)v’1I}¥”.’.fV: £i£’$:1é£iAss<:d «€111 "

law.

17. The I’€SpO1EC1€}}’; _ 339.2, 4» ‘:3, fi-1.$<:1
separate objections. They co:}'{é£1VcE,–.Vby v.§rL«-:,.zc' of fiote 1 in the

Govt. arder, rule': not apply to direct

recruiiment of posts W11-irzh. insists' Esra :ag'p'i*es{:ribed period 0%'

service in a_V13Q\vef:"V'pV£:si "<)1'1€:};;§{3€If_iVE§'{1('3'€ Viiiki past 21 qualification
or eEig;i'¥:5'i1£é;_ ." – En" i;.1g;t;21n£;3'ursL1a:1£ hi} 1'10tifiCa'ti0n dt.'
}?«4«Q7 I and' '1'esp0'r1de'r11:s have applied for
appointmem'. Et,':"V'$'-iIf'.VE":tt1'\?-'i'£?_€' cemdidams, Le. by virwe of heaving

<:x;3$;–"ie1r1(:€:1;E*;£:v"ps:empt.e-d eateggrjg arid the Rule

V :«’:”0n’ij;a:’i:1ée:% Es” i:1z1p§3E§::21E}§€u S§;’.{?{}%_’§€’.fi}7, ii 2:233 iimiiandeii E316

‘–SI:%.te azatgéeptecé éhé-3: €}i’d€*E’ 0%’ {he Eiifl’ in ‘é.eZ’:E’1TE2’E.é of {he

AA E?’Jx?D.=… 19%??? hag fiiffiifiéfii E§E3SC ti: ézxipiaixzené. éha ggzziw {:5 {he

{§§i*€{3§.’3._{§§2*éi’§EEt,'{.€Ei G2w§3~»€3L’E iasued by “éhéi “E-?’:’;iH:::i;§aE §€Cf€?21’F},?,

E

38

E<ZA"1.' dated 19-12438. A copy cf the said <:1i1"eC.ti0n 1:3 produced
as Arzriexure 2. KPSC iS only 21 re<:ruiti11;__§ b0d:;rVT'._féé'}"§.ich is

1'eq_ui1*ed to make 1"eC.rL1i.t.ment. in acco'rdan<::e Kfi.–3"1'fi"l.. ?.M1:i'ié':f.f_ and

R€g111a1,i0:1$ laid down by $116 Lcigislation _ it }.'2"£C'~,§§I'S ~._

any locus whatsoever to maintain] the _§1bE}V';E_ \-';';'{'i"i.'-.336:-i,i1§0Vf1,V:A}'y'I1€1'Z'H.

the deCisi0'r1 of the KAT' 113$ beé-:1 a.c:cepi,é3d.Alb}? t1F;:,<3."'St.'a£e
Government. On ixhai, gmund V".–'.EiII1tV"I'}'.1'€3'VV'£i¢'51V":l'J{ iigtiiions 'to be
dismissed. Even in.é~h_e of Vfpetiiions the

respezzcfenis have filed C01-ixjtcif'i*2¥isE1:*:g"i}ieVgtry Same grotxxlds.

18. “”” . _ vhf’-h€ ‘{:3fiaI’1:-::1 to 8:303 pmvided thaii the <:0nc::3§t of

H{f'E'.{*32Vi'1'f1§i no: axggsiicrzabie '£10 G.i E’~£E£3§’£’i. 21:25? ifzzéegary E

‘<:f_'§3a:<:}<;*a2;*:2§:%§;§Abiasseg. They':-3.£f<:§'6., 1:19 Gem. Orziez" daieci §3–2–€)E

W£§%.3§{§" 23:31:: }T§.E3.'i?€'. ;}:z"e;i:ee::;°ib€t{i §'l??€1"§ <?z":%2:m},.-* $211:-'<:§" is; algmiiitzébété is

?

gab

319

Ge11e31*a1 Merii. and herme the Govt. order is ir1y§3:>_E£1€..§(>:1 of

Seciion 3 of the 5′-XCL

19. “By the impugned Urdar, the ‘£’ri§:1;1;;§_:éx§V disf)’G5,.e4d4″‘.._

of 40 appiicaiions including Ehe. €i.£?k§i>i3iC’i1_ti»iV>’n’5–._ séaid7.._

respondenis 1. to 4. The e1[3§);i£Tati’Q\~;3g:;§ /-are 2iV3.’3.’C>’§.’7.§3:ci
that the Govt. Order dated vv1ri”i»:* _Ei Genegal
Merit (Rurai) c21x1didz1fi;~s_ 1a5&r’eV:V’ 2ii;1vd gwescribes
Form } is in vioiation of; Act, The Tr’ibLmaI

also held fie R€scmi.1;men€; Rules

appiies §3C~27’I~I’iéSSibE€« There is no Compleie
biE’L1r%:tat;i0:’3 “Works E)ep21rt1nen?i, and Irz*igatio’I1
Departfxzgffl; aiafii pezrsons working in both the
GEe§a:ft:11e£45;%sV_é:1’f3,é1.igiv§:>I锑 ‘£0 apply for me posis in §)’L3:Z”S1.l’c1I”lC€’ Of

[E3<52:1Q§:ii"E{;fat:i0réV;" ;§'.\._§_§§f'1€V€§ by {he said c<m"1m<:r1 Order da¥;.:1::ni$s~:§’.{m has pr€i£?:”:fe::E §,%1§$ haze}: of

. \;2.fi*E’:j.1 ;:ss:%;’§’:viV:t{s=.–“‘ Gm: paégitéom pz’ei%:.rz”@:E E3},–* 1:216 f?:’1f’;}}§Qjg’€3€S GE”

iE3’»:_;§3EicVT’iE;2’a:£:”E:é2 E%1::g;iz3::%<:§"§n§.;; §}<:§3a2"§;':z":<:%:3é; _

20.

40

The p{}i”I1′(.S that &1E’iS€’. for c<ms§d<:=rz11.i<m .8; wréi

p<::*:tii.i<ms are as under:

(11

{2}

‘E-362, Eemzs cf me not§fi’cta:.ior2.

Wht3z:’her the Kamaz4aI<qm}';.zbiiC.'Sér":2i§¢€ C0r1'z.;nis3io:1

has locus siandi z.o[c!101iAi¢zA;g'C._ i:f1€'–._C4i3'£i£3I'VAQ[ jI:I'ae~.._

Kammaka Admi.r1is1'.r c:1_.i.L5(9_ Tri.lc}L.:»r1aI». =1Lé?:i%2';»"2, file
Govemmeni. has» (2.C'C€p{€(i."ih€ 3afd:kja¢ign1e;'iz. am} .5

seekirlg Io z'r71p{er71ef*z'E.:h:3Vsaz71té; ._ 'T '

Wherher it1.–.<2:CLpp3:i.ccs}_rzis" A:é'rz._£iiled to the b€I'l€f{."{, Qf
relaxaiforl ';}:f'§dér Rule 6{3b} of the

_G:;=n._er'aZ Riecruf i:i:11e:1.i:7Ri_.;wlefs. 'PV V

_{.'f"cc~:% C.rr3c;77i;; layer policy is appiicable to

' M iriserbice CC:-r.fz_i:i£CEttI"esf9

' Wizeii-';er."f:E1»é5.emp£oyees who are warkirzg in WRDO

aré"'eiz'.gib£e to appiy againsz. fwserazzce pOSii rzozgféeci

41

POINT NO. 1

LOCUS STANDI OF KPSC

Whether {he KPSC has locus-«:i:’lja:2di 113;) c}_1e1Hei;;ge vtfié E}’.fd€f:’

Qf the Kamaiaka Adminfsl.’rai:iL:e Ti:i.b11:-fiat! ‘Vwhc2;1″~1}_ie’ G{,§VL*er?£~.r?:eI2.i ”

has accepted its judgmenie arid ff’ i.t)_ ?§'”i”.pI€?7?C}’:§-I.’vV

21. Sri K, Subba CoL1nsei
contended that” the Kzirtleéitefiiem’V1§i.;:§§§§§v}E’;er2riceVVébfiexraission has
no locus si.and.i to against the order

passed by 1′,i*1e”‘a*:ci.17′:—uz1és._1 on ..t:f1e1″i1}S’ .:é;”s:..i_1_4__V;é:1r1:*:{>’i; be said to be an

agg1″i<%m–"e:d _1::$e:'séErS”€;.:”:_a.:1é, {hey are ezzéitieéci {:0 clméiegégge {he same

. :§3efe;6::« ‘§ehisA”€Q:zrt.. On {he questim: sf §r:’:4e:”§>rei.e;i:i0:} of a

~.;j’r0;?2>’i.séia3;5}f’_v» .{:£°*;1;:%m.?, car 2: {§é}1–~”€*.I’}”1E’§}§;3§’;?L, Qzdegx wE.3.e:: zthsz ‘Z’:ri’:3L:z:221E

§2e;;z3 E33; me KPSC zmd has

* 1%€:;_§e::”€,§=it§ {he sgaéd ‘i’i’;’i€E”§}:’é’.’?E%;§.§f}§”; :3? the ::L:E€:%>; zmié 13.95 am}

1:.E*;:-‘3%j:”afe’s_§i.i=~’:°§ {E19 €f§r*v’€:”I’1:i§’:e’::%;. did 313%. {*h2–‘&’§::%:”2ggéir {Ex-é S_§Ei§7;”;%’;”,’ aneci an

42

{he cont.ra:’y accttrptsd ihe ssemze, the KPSC has no.«’lz>c}’15 .3:’_Z’GJ1df

£10 cha11e’r1ge the order :3″ the Tribunal.

cont.: vCOL13″v”[.-” ” » 1

22. Per cont,ra., Srti N21z1j:;ndaAA[fiyaédyfi’1é:;ir:2e.;:§V«STe;é.ior7–.

Counsei etpgaearing for the c:é>’n1 €r1ded [Viki-;<;:'{ .:,V 11:<3': '§;«r§.13.*V§i':::*
KPSC has 21 right to <:haiieng'6§"1:.:IVfT1.Vé o;."der if arfiy
adverse remarks are also on
meritss, if the interpret.a£i®. pfé{c;§cii ,"tz_{_'1?.-?SC is not accepted

by the Tribuixual,' fiéz: {hat the KPSC is an

Authsawity" ;fé)'1";?$ijt_jaV£E:d =%.1fIde1' the Con.si.itz,2ti0n and it is expected
ta S(Z§"Li1;3'L'l1€}LlS1:f_fiJ1'If;}.'£i;;"fihgé" «S*cat.L1i.0ry miss 9p€raE.3':1g in 'ihe field
and if 111116: ..ir1vte::"p:'et£ati::~:iV plated by the Gaa-*er11rz1.e:1é or the

auihezritiézs <7{:rie*::"V:_f;_::;é¢f. is :i’1v’.ghi4 is m;<3mi:: ha-“r :”s’.-éiéea 0:”: she: L} LE<i;1:1.§I}1€t}:3E. 9:'

A;;Ve;:'LA5gj_o%;n~: in tbs. case 9:' mnfim PRADESR PLEBLEC
sggvfcg' aamgzssrerg ;%§ sgfimg

Effiffi fififi

V» ioimjmgs 552099; 1 sec (1;&S}999.

43

23. Chap1,e3’1~ ii of Parbxlv of the Const§_.:.’t:t§’@.r§’«deals

w1’I;.h the Public S€rvir::t? C{}II§§11iSE-‘>§{}I.1. A.rti£:§e 3_1–:”;3. (§1€fé1″I’5:’;_:”~%.7*..-“i”{;’}*1~ _%i1<1V€:

esta'oE§shmf_’v’i’«hE:»» ULf1i(}.{1″2’1S_

weél as the S1316 and Ariicle 320 ‘wiilh «’={:1r1_€:’A§”‘v.Vi?’r1’fi_5″oi_”the

Public S(fI’\~”iCff Co’rm’nissi0’r1

320. Functions of Public Service Carrifnisfiions

{I} II” sI*t’aVii{bé~.JI.I1i’:3V Ifihe Umrm and
the Stan; P11.bli.cAVV_Sér:;ic€§_V £:§’oz’2ii:{71’i;<§é%iV;:=r':i. {.0 cond.uMre2v .S£c::£é’..s;o*..i{> do; to assist. £.hos<-,= Stakes in

'V j';:r::r'?*:fr1§; 'a.rj€f a~p§3:*aziing :;che:"r2s3:; <zf':j0£.z2.f:' :¥3z:rz:i:.:m3r2.{.
"."an_;; s€rL;zEés fir)? whicffc. c'a.ndz'd.af.{2s possessing
V T. 'V3?§§e§?i.::2.{}:;;aai§[iic?€ {fa:3’zm.:Tss:'{srz.g as {$26 €955
* V mag; E36, s;’§2::z§.§ e:?cm.s:2zf:e€E

ix’

44

(a) on all matters relating {<3 melhocis of reCrz.:i4i:men_i:l~.V_

(".0 civil services andfor civil poszs; _
(1:3) on the principles {.0 be followed z':*.%._ l'rr?.::zl::iirl2_;;jl

appoint'ment's to civil seru_;ices__ar1d;j:5l§S'ts'.':an'ti £3:

malcirtg promolions arzcl l,ra,z1s__}'eri3 ."[foz.n"w.o~n_g f

service [.0 £UlOl.l1€I' and on file suiVi_;§:.l5ili1'y 'Qf'

ctamrlidaies for such__§ilppoi11lfnenl:s,V lg3;"e§3<:_}:c62';eic32"ié:
oriransjers; K 'H b

{C} on all disciplli*:a.ry .elj}'eel.i7Ig llperson
serving under l ..V__India er the
Goverfuvzerzi inlfi Veilvil capacity.

ir1el2l1,dll;§Q’ l;7lr:vr%mofi;1llé of relating lo such

r?”:.att:e;*s V. l ‘

:n”_}és;:}ecr; Qf a person who is
l ‘*servilig’l:§i;r4lha$”:3_elf’:%ed under the Govemmenl of
‘=.llzl7r;l.ia Or Q)” a St’at.e or under {he
Cu2′:{;rI,.lfiI’1′ Iylciiclzlor under’ me Gouemmen: Qf an
I:zdiarl”S’E’::::*e,’ in :1 civil capaciig, Ehaij any cssies

i:2Ci.2;”recZ. bl mnz in de ‘enclin le al meeed:’r’z s
V _ J K. 9 .9 E? Q

A ..§n:;.l1:’:’:.z’:ied ag<;a:'r2.s§: him. $31 ?'€Spe<e{::.:.§.f0r2. Qf E253
dI,£l'§,} Slzauld, be paid on: Q/" file Censalifiazeecl
Fzznsd ggjfizdial on Q5; Elie cage ?":'Z:f§__;; ee. 61.251" Elle

€a?%s:}§l{§m";e:§. F%i.m.€E, 33;' Else S::::z.§,e;

45

{e} on any claim for the award Qf a .per1sia11_e:”‘mJ’~~.
respect of ixy’urz’.es sustained by ca pergéri’
serving under the Govermneni. Qf rag’:-:4 aer=.z”V’f1eA T
Govemmenf, of :1 State or”u:2der ‘c:r;~;>w;~’: v:’,’_rf2_
India or under the Goz§z;a4rr1.::,{“ae.n::. («jj car”£”‘,Fri’clV::i:.’.}j1
Stai;e. in (2 Civil eap§;:c{.;y, arid. eazlgj qz,;<%§.z.ie%1 £25 'ifo.

{he amounz ofculy s21::;}i'*;m:ard,'.. V

and ii: sh.a,l.li;=.e_ ;au1};:i.c "Servi.ce
Comm.z'ssz'.0n :15 d§iL*I'ee_ ar:igV:_:v:wxcLL:':er se referred
in them arlel.-"en. igzrly v_ rriikiifier u,r-Inch the
the Governor,
<€jj»fVI.i'i,.é'a tvci-fiie m.-

ihai’ ‘i:§§_.e £’resVieEer1I as respects the all
‘India .,dIj%€i also as respects other
:~:eruiceS._cir:ii in corm.eci’:ion with the ogfjairs
of 2’fi'”i.E,:?V’ V{v,’1’I’1.i(i)vf”;. and the Gezverrzorg, as respeeis
{flier Se:-‘cases and poses in e:mnee£.ier2 with {he

Qf a S’I'{11’.’e3, rnziéy make reguiaéiens

‘V ‘ “_”_vs:;3ei5:§f’§;§r1g {he maaers in mhiefz ezfzher gerzerailga

‘ .ei>–f fr: azzgg ;2<2r{'icz/ziar eéass Qf ease er in, a,r2.g;
pezrzziezzéer s§;~f~::zrg;j%:r 5: §3:,§E2E.€:r ;’E§:;>r:.%i:?e (f0m:rm.:~;s:'<sr: :15} 3e

C::ez2§;z,£E£;ed

repealof vQi;fé'1€3I1dTTl€I1I'. as both Houses Qf'

46

{4} Nzmling in Clause { 3 } shall require ..~::e..E¥:1bli:C’.j’
Service Commission to be consulted T

the manner in which any p,rg>:;isior1’fejerf_e:iTia in

clause ( 4 ,2 of Article ITtQ_y’

respects the manner iz14′:_1_,:h:c}!”a ~mé~’1yi;>.e*~. ‘

given to the provisions”QfArl’ie’Ie 335 V

(5)

to clause { 3 by {he £?%g*2s£d{:’ni:’o.r the Governor

All regz.Llaii5}h;s*A.rftaciee. under’ 1,?’ gbrovfso

Q1′ (1 Vsrmxe smzz-.,be_ aaz.¢i”-j’o’r~V.’:_n_o’: less than
_[‘oL;.~;’ieeri’dag}*:s b_e_3′..b~’re”etief:-.FioL{Se Qf Parliament;
er ihe5§E.{(i–z1ée.:or;’e.ach Hozxse Q!’ the Legislmure

of {§”i~1c>1’V.;_\fS.!;aI.e_, may be. as soon as

§2f1eg.*are made, and shall be

S1£iq;’ec£”i'<3.Suchmecigficalfons. whether by ugay

Par§€.e§zhen£' for the Htause or hath I-muses Q)" the

"£,egisEe£fiiIi'eAQf" the f;5ifc:uf'e may make Ciurmg {he

Apex Cazmg. 131. the case {)5 Siam of £5.19. :23

[AIR 8'? Supp SCC 481}, Cieahilg w§'{.?: ihe

f¥;3§':{";E'§f;jE';ii2

"¥.§.Z1{';€§I-

3;; G? ‘ghe Pu.b}.:£<fi SEi"'if}:£f€ CG§'nm'£:<_=,.:–3:%..(}§'.a E1223 Ifileéii 22$

47

“.30. The Cornmission is an inciepemrienI.~~~eXper£;

body. 1:. has to aci; in an imtlependeni: r1:§:.cirirzer zne”A

making {he selection on the pre5cribeC{ “r’2’or–{r’fis.”‘= II.

may consult {he State Govemrniirétjj. etr:Ld::’.£?’t€3

Court in reseribin (‘he n0f’.I_rLS’. or ‘udqi?t5 *£he’
P Q . . J _.-A J

3ufI.abiIif:y of ear1d£{idi1:es no _ f1on%;§”””are

prescribed in. the Rules.»””.,O:e1–ee fhe «.Ccf:mnru’:ssion

deierrnines ihe ::_I”.t’L’9I’}’7’1S”VAVCl!v1a’.fA,i.””3%”(i(Tl,.Ei:3S selveeljfvorz. on
the conclusion Q)” exCin”_zi.r2.a£ior1 and
submiris _A£;s_i; QffiIi’e* to the
C§<)I;e_rfr§.:rw1e;g%fecEiff: nolif :;={*,§b"e+1*VV'f'f1e seieciion by

ioLuSérzr1§;"VdbLL:r1, {}?r1é– ..!'"} .C)ffTfI.':'p,'5' "ail =3–he mstance of {he

.»GOL1€7l'?UR€fi:E:;. }_",'-flme praeiiee: Q)" revising file result

jive é}{CiT§3i?'i'(L:iOfI by changing norms is

foilouged it:ii_f';';*e co21fusz',c)n and the peopie

_ 1.vili "E.os'e €_fcI;{IhA~.2_ir1"~~:'he i.z1si.i{'1..:tion Q1" Pubiie Service

Conlmisfi'-0:1" azzai {he a:;§.f1er2E:écif;g; of seiecégiori.

""§ee§,/'e_:::;:i_e.3 Qf the opinierz {Thar the Commissécm shozdd

V' = .s3i"an<i in éfzese maziers in ma§c€:'z§ :':'§"z.e

seEe;7?;::§:1 in oseeardamre wé£':?"2. z'.'§"2.e :':o;'ms fixed 59g;

"–Ea:§; 4' G?' _}'¥:<'ed by 5:, in a{?C0r(Eanee wz'€.§2 Eau:

".a.z%'2§§§4fE2.se:2::ec::3' 52;; {he 03€rec£.z'<}ns egg" she S€;a{,e

£32-€:sa:er;:me:":E' 2e:§::s=:.s;2;3{2:°:e:5 E3; msg? §%€:;.zEe5;"

«mm: WW"

\

48

Again the Apex Court. in the case of INDER
Vs STATE 05* J & K1200-41(6) scc ms; held 2_a_s5:-.t.z’I’3.ic:’i”l:;.z’f:’*——.l’ “‘

“The Public Service Corz1Iniss_ic12 his a ifbdg .

under the Cor1.sliI:1.Ltion. EQQZCTIiSl'(I.{é:;’~§’€§3;1SI€1l£’€eSJVl
its own Public Servicc Cor71§f:is$;fcr1 lo .’;_:_§.c”c»:
constiiiuilcnal req1:ire%}1cfiIi..V_ fc>rA.”{:l1__eV
clfscharging flis duties V U”L€.’C(l>l’l§liZ’Ll§[‘i()7L
Appoirltmcnt, la ill’: ._ n1ufi’l:’ in
consonance wifh ‘ihcco’nsl%f.};11l:cfic1lgfifczaisions and
in cory’cr*m-iljy u:ilf,fi”i.»h{é’& (T4;ll?Ld’_]”I’€(£CiOIIl Qf’
p,«cecLlz::_i;c ‘ ‘ ‘Qf..::f1c Conslftultion

in1;9?)se$””VVtlVii’l§:1, “–:pllou2 i’:’h.c siaitlaiorg

” gpgaraiirzg €31 §;?1e_ffcZa’.. 3′; may $6 {F191 fer
{‘E3rl§}f:;§z{‘ }3L£l”§}€}SE3S, j”<::r €XQ«?'}E;)Z€e fcr {the p{zi§:}3{}S€ 53;"
"'$l1.c2'"{:E£sz.iz'zgf :1" can lag; :i<)z.:;;":. 55:5: wn, procedure.
‘lzc {3cmm.§.s:5€cr2. lzzyasscccr, magi lag; d.{m2;is $2.55
prcc-édzlrc ;€:.?°:z::§;E§; in cr2cmca-? :,s:z’.€_l’:. 331.53

si4a£’,:.:£lor§; mics. Eff cam”z.:>z’: §”c:;.ics;> czzzy Q,€ffI§O??; zzsfzicfilz

5+
E.

3

49

per Sf-3 would be uz’0la{z’ve Qf the ;~:I:’a{:’u£:'<}ry rt.zIe;s'~.c_§"r°«._¢
makes the 3511-7153 fr1c){)era{:'iue for all im.er;'1'I""a;;tj;~c.i.__}
purport, [Juan far the ]')i,U'pOS(_;' Qf si7.c)rI.Eis'if_r2g; fI.53é

Commzssican c:anr1oI.flx any kmd Q1-'c~z.:?:¥cg[f}f'z.:L:rkS;'3

Agair: in the ("$2156 of STATE OF} vs "

MANJIT SINGH AND OTHER_S’*–.{2OOL?’ ._!1′ 1} 11.631

as Lmder: ~

“‘1 1. Tirze’~_Co_r31;7nisss’i;>fé”V- .d’E?bi:L?§’S its powers
under Ari”iCI.e £32091″ ElieCabst’i’fm.i:jVf1. well as its

linms i,0s”}.a }:1.de;:>er23d¢;r¢zI. -.gi1″:<'?ij«j}:£i:'=working Q1' ("he

{Eff»L§.'i.ITIOSHf§'i"¥;*C)!"Z"ClI1C€, It is also not
;u.nder any pressure Qf {he
G'C}1?fL"f"FlIT'E£;V"I'1.I_., ":S§£,i$TTlil.i'€d on biahczif' Qf {he

— .. app::fsi.0ns; Qf’ @516 {am and hzzzs also
.Vvi{}«.ja,£3zT1i*c% __b;; {he miss and r’9§;;.£iai:’i{2ns 0:2 z”‘f’2,e s:,zi3;’eCi

1 ” :'<§.T'V§'::'§%:e imic» ::scmz.m: {E15 g3<)Zi{?g_.; {£.e<?2"$z'0r1s :,:.,-M052.
{£5-'".£L': L':¥:_;2g'z1:'.,":.z'.z'z. 5.53%: €§(m'2(/air}. 53;" sf.?'2_e? 85633.8 {_}:23′; IE.
. V’:€f5;z’2§’:{>§, fmgmse 3’5. 5; (}E,{.?F? _§3{}Z§¢f,’§; ::?é3{,*€:;£z€-2z,:.:

50

Again. it is stated as under:

It is to be noted that, under clause.

Article 3120, the Union Public Service Corr1r2″t:éssi(:¥n».’fire

the State Public Service CoII*crnissi.o_.rz~;~~l::_aE. be

consulted by the G-ovem.n1en;t’ relating to rr2eI._l.10clSV Of ‘V

recruitment in civil serviees:’.Var’.dz_/’or ‘Ci;/u.l,VpQS:’:§§;~..

promotiozzs and i”rarL§je§s as. ‘lifffll
suitability ofcaII.didaieesv’Ve£.e–§; Tlte c:§:>r2.<_;_lill'w,t:f(:)V;§1. may
also be in regard ~t.:Q discfj5li'3:.aryj"r:lat't.eré a;{]'?éet.ing a
person serving ze:rit._Vl/V-' then find
that elausfe [41 part;ie1{E»arlg,z_pfcieieleélltiiat rzotrhmg tn
clausef 4l3%l~t:t:.'Sl1t;_ll iLr'el;Lz'i're:.V ':.b@r1s.2§tl:atior1 Q/' the
Corntt1l§¢_sta'rt tt'a_t:'l*ae marmer in ushich any
in 'K-Xrtjicle 16(4) may be made
er ther:1arnte'r_'li1Q.. _:iL–,:l1:i.¢.l1 the effect' mag; be given. {:0
the apfoigis qf' Aftiele 335.

‘V jimtele deals with reservaz”:’Gns and Article
‘~.gaert:’afa’$;H to eonstderatiatz Qf :*e$er:sat’:a:’2.

T. ‘e§§tzé:4€;;.{:e%;£: 2;vz’:.l*2, the ma.t:zt:en.a.rtee Qj’ €:ff’}’€.c::ier2.ey qf
t:?:eV’a§.1;’§’%i.3’2£s£’raE.§or:.. As indieatecl, earlier; clause
.–,§4} ‘~ “slat” Atfiele 32$ {?§€’,C:if§:L,” gjma/’tales; that,

. »;::’t::%’z§z,:§t,e::t,€c}n :55′ the {fs:emr’3:’z’$§§:'{;;’e: w:.z.E{/f 320:’ $8

necessary in the maaerss ?°{?§eC£,E”i?TtQ :10 Ar?1ie§e>.:€ E 5%)
é

a,

and 335. ‘.I’herej]bre, it. u,-Quid be a. mcI,?i'{.£3r of
to be decided by the State CrOL’€3?’T1ITl8?”£f. as__:;ti”tv!ia–.i.: ;. ‘
measures, if rwcessary, may hem M
regarding resema1.ion.s z)fs~Ct~13I”s—- Inat-:r:1£’e:$7.L:z”1: a? “q;f_;_
ejffz’c:t’enCy in services. v’Wi1ej’r€..:’
qualification or az1g T’p_rescfi.f3¢ cfE- st:aTmtiard 2 qfi
€.j[f£.ciency over and ab0i;eri}1.;3
provided by the Rules =Sia{:e, it ‘u3e:>:..:£_;fi (1535 be

for me Comfrz{$’§–forz~’_ f,'{}~ z.?J_’1_p.(§s’e_ any extra
qual§ft’cat:ion./St;and.ar§{ for
rnain£a::1i}ig.. V” azgfficll, it thinks.

may NQV ¢3fzs;uL@I’i:éitfon with the
Cori:z;71is;: $tg3f1, “rm’1tI.V:,>§r.§, is envisaged in

z}iéé,::– ;;1rI.1′<:Ie 326? Q[' the
'V-Consz:v:z.£::fif'c…f"' .' '
25; ' ' "fT'E1tV"T('{f'.f{'?'1"VA"€:,..%h'§"}$'L'£b}iC Se-mice Ccmlnaisséan is 2;. bedjg

Cregied. 11n€§€;'. C¥:;1r2sE,§i.'uE',ioI1. Each State c.0nsd;itu%;e5 its

A «Q*5§§'r? F'§§:biE{:._.Sem.riC€ COII'§§"}:}iSSiO}'1 $2.0 meet 826 {?€)ITS§.i§UE§OTEaE

. }L"~€§f§?:iii£'f33f§".§{':"ii,T§T{3=i' iiile pasrpaaet {if £§.iSr:5§§;i.1:.:%I,3?.€2§:s. 222:: wfirii 213 E23; §?;m:§é.i&; fi,:;>{1 ‘E’§*:<-3

éziizm. The C{:'§:*;mis5S-£011 {§€§'§'L-"€':;'§ its; p{3"%)§:'i'§"f:1, :,md€:'§' ;-"i.ri;i{:'E<%

s

3%

52

C011’1Inissi0r1 is an izzdeperzdeni. €:Xp€’E”{. body. It h21sT,_{C act in

an independent manner in rmxkirzg the se1§3{:’;:io;i”L-{;~11VV”‘the

prescribed norms. Ir1Ciep€r1der11i and fair –s;\_?é>r}:;-i.3f;v.g-“bf *th’e_

CO1I1I1’1iSSiOE1 is 0f utmost i1I1pQ:’!:._anc(:_. It _”i.:Vs”‘r’1”::3T%;’:.9ti’p§)0S£;-d .’

fL1I1C¥’iO§}. under any pressure of t.1=s,_c C?.-0vxé1r:i1¢.«1.éx1t.V§’-Apjjmnvtiéfrsent

to Si-:’I’ViC(‘3 in a S¥.a1.€:: n1u.;:2_L be: ‘in CC}1’iS,f3’i’vi’-tlfivfiffi. vifith fix;
(:0nstii.u!T:i0r1a1 pmvisions and -iii”*~C:OI1Ik3i’m..i.ty– with “i,hVé “a L1t0r10rny

and freedem of e.x:eC;,11_iVe a_c7.Li{j:3_._ ‘While geving _E}11*oLagh the

selection process the vCQiTi1″I1i’SSi{3’E1. lzrjwéwjr, must. scrupulously

follow the stamtory yixlcs ._i9;; ihe field. The

Con11:1’1issi0ii.fhowévexz.émust lay down the pmceciure strictly in
C0I1S{)I1£’.}’1{‘i>E:W’iEh €1ht:* §9 ‘{—=3Jii;2i’t§I”y mJ.eS. The C0mmisSi{::n should

t’.ak_6– f’Em1 si:.;::j1d’in’ :11.é:kif1g the seiectiezz in a(:C.0rda:’:<:e with the

::'c.:f12§ .T.,g1xe.;:§ by §Véii~'{-' 01' fixed by it in &1CfCOE'dEifl£T€ with fan;

:V"'§'='t–1."§:ViV§';.'fl:1'V;:%","E'"£'{?v€'V3C§_ the €'Ii:'m_r,= sf {he -Séaie Gm-‘€1″:zz11em and

?¢.;_:’§=»:,2p;’:{:>’:”*£,’:’Qs;iTV’by Ehe Rules’

A26. ” The: K21z’°z”:a:.21E~§a Siam: Legi$§ai.m’€: izas $::€:;{:”:.e{§ 213$

“E§_a ::::–nataka Pubiic Service Cemmissiarz Efienfiueé af Business

g

53

and Additional Functions) Act, 1959 for the peribi-ffixzxggce GE’
its funC1;§<):1s and is prcvide fax' the €X€§*c§§e'- {'3-i"– :::.:é':rt;2z.i'r1

additiionafi I'L:'r1ci.i0r:s by the Commis-ss'i0n. Thf§ 1:-':E3.idA V€ria~.:'§'I2'2TeI1,t

was passed for $1336 perfarrzlazacq of t'§c:.<2""i'ui:ii;:tif}v:1s'goi thfé

C0m1niSSi0r1 under the C011s{.i1uz.;ior1 OI't;:1i'::1e§° z11<:_§%'–EavQVf{}1fjthea.

time being in force. Chapierlli deaés 'w_i.t.h e1d§iv§iio':1e21 ii«1f2~::VtiC–I?:s
of the Ccmmission. One s'L1r:h_ é;d_di1.i0zé.:;1} 1"u.rVV1c:t'1','i(3}Vi:.aé.'s"ct§5n£;21i:i<3d
in Se<:tti0'r1 E6 is the condtzci: bfservice"€X';iniir1a'§.i0ns, Such
examinations; which Vp:§rsons"Sefii;3g<.in cc:}ni"1:c':e:;"L'§{2n with the

affairs of the State arefeqztir-?,_d§';–£C 'p'é{:a§§4;~u;ir';r;1er 'die Conditions of

recru_ii'.me:1i"Ci?-»s(;1*§:<iCe:–.;u*eVa1p_p1iCab1e to ihem and which znay be
I10tifié€i by Cf<€}'\f(.i'}'5.:';1~.'{Ii§'j;*.TL_?.Z""E,§13'd€§' thia S€i'C'{'iO§":, and such other
exarnit1at:{ms"as §-11333 Ea' uetified by Gm-'e:'11:r:e:1t. from iirna to

i,i_:;i:£: sham, w:£.t"E1:'e{_1_é_ em;§{:?;§::éVf€c§ 11:*:€§£:*§’ Se£’i.i:3. E2? ‘é}”i{‘ 2u:*:,E}<;:'iLy €?:€=I§1}_TZ=€f;§E'.1"1§.

is <::asm'§_us::: §E§{Efi'§'":'§;f"§é?Lf.§{}E'1S fer" &?L'g}§}{}§Z"}§'I'E"E"§é;"f§'"§§.:%§ is fi'1<: §;£%r"22':{:<:%.§; ::;§

" Ejurjaé ziéfiheriiiess and ii: sizaéé be £E'1et Cézxy 5;? 2,51% C£3§:<m:§;Ss$i:3}:1 "s,

Vfirf:-~w

Condmxi $uc:h e};arni:{‘;at:i0I1s. Sectiom 1.8 of Act

empowem the G0verr1m<~:r1t ':0 maké Ruies for ..I.:l'1€

pU.I'p{)S€S of the Act in Consultation with

:1oiifica1}i1’1. in the efficiai gazette. .e”;cc.a1fdin’g1y,V GVG”.rérnt:;eritL.

in exercise of the powers conferred }:;y»S?3’eC’ti{3r1s”’15” of ”

thzz Act after consultation wi*;”;h the” .F(é{rr1ata1{£i’ Pizbficj’; §3érvi{,=5:
Commsisssion has Inade the RuE.;:é’*Vc:e1Iied *The_K_ari:afaka Pubiic
Service Commission (xunctioziza R1_11es,.1973′. Rule 3 of the
said Rufes provides thai.;”\.§r11’s:n;§he:”C_Gnir:njssic»n is Consulmd in

mgard to the making gi_”‘:’u}cv$ (ff ‘1f’é3cz9ui::I13–é11t’, relating to any

servime {hexCE;_m_n”i§ssiorivshall ~r.1dvice on 31% matters relating to
;*e<:rL:it:I1@§1't m.cI£:Eica§.:e11$

;°£<£:<?§'2z€:::§ Ema? ad .:.i$.&–;i:: s::§:::”z.:’iE{:a’%;:.'”«;* 3:} s32,.:{:E”: {E5 E’.§}{>E~3{?

” AA agépiégtaiiéayls are in oxide; am? wira fuifiki %h.€ 1°€:*q:::£:*e€i

%5/// ..

COI’1diiiti)I1S. in case of direct. rectruitmem by se1€3.ct_.ti’0:i’;«.’_i1:V.vshaéé

s<:3:utir1i:2..e the appiicatiens rec:c:ivr::d a11c§ ma.}<_.::""s~éiVt::ti.ié{1s"«in

accordance with the Karnataka S€'21'{6: Civi1"3¢nii_€ré=$ {}:)'iJ;é§C4['~.,'

rec:'1:1itmer1£: by Se1e<:tion) Rules, ]-9'7'3–.–. &'\«VEf1e:1, 41.19113 Cc$m.1fi<1is§s~i0hj

is Consulted in r'eg.§a'r<:§ to the SL1:i'I.£lb:3;1'i'i}'v 0f».a:1y"c2i'r1:éiidE1ii§é or "

Canéidates for p1*<3m0E.i0n, R'L:.1§3 6 €V§"§W_}iE3'i3kX-'€IT§§'"{h.€, COIfl;H1.iSSi§f1
for "recruitnlerzi by pITO.TI}0[iOfiL""'-.iI:;}'i{i 3a1id";jrdifi 9ti(5;j; be
selection G3' on the baaég OI'$611ig_fi1'§;C'}:iI1'ivfIiéi'i"t."S T1"1L1S, a free
hand is given to the _ the GOV€1'1'1I'£1€'Zf11'.

which has to c:0r1su1t Lvh’eV«f:..3_c::111:’1-1i_.<s»sL§ic;§'.tAi'.afi'€£_ nbt. the vice verssa.

27. I ‘ Fforifi -~ {T19 aaffdifesaid staéutary provisions and the
iaw iaid Ei3}.>if17,Vb;\} 1.he.Ap§§:; Court it is clear that’, when once the

assséggtaiice G§ 1.f§3€v CQr:11n§ssia:>r1 is smxghi far in ‘aha mafier 0:”

. ‘f*€”CfE.Ei’LIIl€’f1VT.'”‘-fiiihfif by éirecii :”e<:mi1;rz1E31.1*L by exaxzrzizzatéan <3?

.~.(§E:fir;:€*£'.V ;:*é§:»5:f;_§i~§fiie11t. by Sfiieiééioil G? :'c<:r:_:it.m:":t:1'¥:: 'i3f§; §3fG§11G§i{)E}§

itiéé aL:f.h<'3;"§i},? has 'is §:1{§@;3e:}.e:i&;3.£§§; act in ac<:G2*da'r1<:€ 'wi'£'.§1 'aha

~E:?;:.,_;}€§»;i !z:r:<{§ :*s22=§a{% fine: S€1'3C§,.§€§I1b E; is '§"i{)'L abéégeci ':9 am, 232% per

Efiégz" dia?:%;;.22,§£=. sf {hes-: @X€;’ity like the COI}1IE1iSSiO}’1 was
previded Ufldfli’ the i11di.a’I1 C{3nst.itL1″§.i()r1. Stalte L/eggii-Elzléeures

have passed e1.1aef;Ine11t’s giving effeci: to

corlstitutional previsions. It is the GOV€FI1IH€f}d[, xx-%§1′;%r_:}1 1*ias_{(‘)”-._

e01:1su.§i the Commiseion. CG’r’n:.11.i.’:3S1’é::11.. ;iI’1de;’V”.I1.C-4.

stalflutory 0§3.Eigat%0r1 to C(}IZSL1§i: ‘~_’t.:}:i€if .
:*eerui11mer1t’ to be made fly’ C-OéI1’fI1:iV’S’E5E’V€§V;’1 be i:1
COI}.S0.'{1€t;¥1C€ with the=”c:§>I1si.jv{t;éi.i.ef”i§2iu p_1j0xr*is;fc5:§:s the Acis
and Rules goVe’rn’ir1g 31 categ01*’ic21l.Ey

states appoi:1tfi1en1:s, §’1.)s:’Qrii'(,rt.;’Q13A’:-3;’a.;;d’ £fm’ns£e:’s, made by any

AppOi_11i’,i11g1;P§i.’;;1:h’Q;{*i§.y -I£i”~«:j0I1_t:mVention cf the relevant ruies of

I’E:Cru.i’£r2’1ue1’1L 1.;}’;£i”‘I5§;i:”:1éi$a§ia Public Serwice C0mz’1.1i:3$31011

(CQ;ns-Lziiaiicrg) 1.958 shall be reported t9 the

G:;»t}ez€I1:z1ee–:TU;’ by ’ems! Cenmxisgian. TI:1e G{)’$–‘€§”I1I1″1€i”.:E,. shall

‘V’,€fu.:E*i:§s§’:._«V M {he Cemnligsion 21:13.; i:1;€’e:’t::1ati’n K-Xihiith éhe

C’:j§}§’£’}}7§’1’1h_-‘§.i”§.’i{“,’~:1,'”;;’ eé:m$E{ie:’s; it §}€C’:€S;’5El§”§,:-‘ fer e::<):"s,s£:ieraté{m G? 2:23};

maE:~erA;*eier:*ed £9 :31 fag' <::”: unless:-.2« it: €€;’i”{i§i€:(§ by the

_C”z1′,§e.§ $e::::’e§,az’}-‘ is £§::3v:;%:”:”:§mém €.’;*z;”:é. s§:;m’:e :?;1:”::zzm’. Ese §’L,1:’;”:§s§ns”;*,{i

5′?

Without undue labour or shzmlci be withhetld iI71:””L.KI:.1:L’?’K.f’}§,i1£)1iC

ir1i;e:reSt_

28. It. is in the backgr0u’r_:_1d..Q[ thé

and the Rules, the iocus stand: 01″ “the;’Ce:hi1ni§ss:iQf1 ft) :t’:hé11.-zjage

the orders passed by the jL1t§§'{5i-?§..1 21:V{ti1<§V:1*i1'i¢s' '{:'h§\€1.'ir1g§,VVf9;11l'Lvv;i£?'1
the seiiections made by it. is VV

29. The –_C_as<: of A.P.PUBLIC
SERVICE con;M;ss:oNv:..¢; MOULEESWARE
REDDY dealing xvith 2: case:

Senrice Commission which
had Qf the Divisien Banch 0? {he High

C<:s=.A.1:'%.; sf Jiid.i:é2z§;.'Li're hi' Qgzzdhral Pradesh which had Lzpheld ihe

&0:vhdé'r3.–."'§«as*:sed b§;""fh«e Andhra Prackzsh S'€E1"{,€f ;":d:hi;';is,t:'21E.iv<3

:'i"bu:_§e.§ 1"1éi::i_ iii; :_.mder :~

'f'fZG:." '–§Q'::£e 5 Qf §.§'2,€ Pubizc Serviaie C0mmz'§;s§r2_ Mr, Pmbhaicar péaafzazé reE:'{zzz :5 H05″ :5?”
%:”::.:{:§?; s;£_::;n§§’§.{rm2.cé: E3′: <;§<3 r'a::€:<-3 2?: :2. c"§gi,{%*s3rz:3:":z':;"i.E4″E.a 5:’:

wiii Ezazze :10 appiicfiiarz in. {1 sage 53,?’ {his z*a<:az',ur'a

The law canncsz. be permmled :10 act: ur1_fE1f:_'Z'y, .:'<Izf "–
cannoli be arbitrary. The coumrg is gouerjjed' –bf;;.
rule 433]' jaw and net by men. Thus."__aZz.1;0L{g'h T'
mistake had. been cc)IIIn1iifeC€' 93%;;

same carmoi be directed be”per;§e;faied
because the CoImniss{a:1._’u::lZ }5;a.ve–!0 a.tad–e:7i;ake
selection process aga.i:1’afi.céa pariicarriarly,:’v_ir{1fiei);: figf’
t:i1e_facz’:’ I’:ha’t’ t:’h.e_ Stale Q,1TVV§F&11d.’:’1(a Pfadsasfz. not

question the O?’¢L;Z«E3?”.;i§”{3IA’~}E’?_(3(f¢’§~3′):L_;I ‘r;?.1eV,+”1″‘r.ibur1aI

30. Relying O2″l””iJ§’11??:3 ‘ jLic1gg;1.1e:af_ cantended first-fy
that, the 13′;;’Ib_1ic;%Se_:1vic’c C..f’)’%”1″iII’1iiVS§};’*:iV(51}u Tiéid no right to Chalienge
the order §3.’;1§.sef{j as well as, the High Court.
Secoigcily if.Véézrs..__eoz1te:§tie§§ .t’ha1:’, when the State Geverzluleni
has attcep-1′;ed “{‘r.ibu11a§ as weli as the High.
Court, %;hLe~,C0mn’;_isAs§e»’f;..–‘has :20 éovszgze $t:ar1c§§ E0 ehaiienge the

saziijie 7be£’0re”‘i.”:’:–e«,Ape.x Court. “E’hoz.2gh tine quesé;’:io:1 cf éocus

A «s{.:m.di °s;§¢’;r:s”«::;<}'{. decided expresslfgr $1: the zaferesaxid jaadgrzzezfi, in

Em-3 '§E1}:*:*Ei$ " Q§'~.?,'§r~1eii ;3212'é,17e2.:1:»1:° itasae, {he A§§e.x Ciztzm'. heié Ehe

_;;;f"£e't/';"a;r1;e;e"'§r_:§' "me. C0mmi§eS§on E§':a'£. it £23.:-3: {ta uzziiefiaaake tifirz

Sela/::E.§'{§:1 §22"2:3<:eé=§-£5-5 a;_§21,i.:f: if ihfi :3:°de:' pazészégegé by %,h=. E'§§;_§;1_ €0u_:z"§,
_ ~~ %

59

as well as the Tribunal stands was :19′: a good réezzsen for
inbarferirlg w1’t.h the Said Order. In that C:r:1ieX’t ii, .3;hat

the p€rs;<311 who COII11'I}§U€d the I1:}isLak;e was_i1}é1e {'3x't3$;f'€rrii'flé1a:

and the CrOV-"€£'3'1.3.'IE€E1t'. has accepted the:

preferred by thfi Com1<r1issi0'r1 to 1'L1'1(34'§vL1"§.'_)1'f;:"TfE'i€:_:

1'neri1;. '1'he'refore_. by no s't1'etVch 01';hir;;é;g§ha11:'§<jrv;-._hii' C0<L11nd:'.b.-:ed'$3id
that the said judgment lays» thé ;;r0;;dsjtibir1""Gf 'iaw theiiz
the Commission has no locu§"'=s:{a:2§fi té+ch:2§.11efi%ge an order
passed by a judicial '1;1fi'i3.t_zn2.d. " leadrhdéd Judge whe

passed the said judgment fig"; had an occasion

to CC3'13Sid¢'K1A'AV '3.'11ea V:A921ici.4Vq=uVeS.t§Q't1 specifically in a subsequezné,
judg1I1er;t 4*-.vhe1*é:_ thtz. $42':-§._d"'p":§riior1 of the i3"<1I'§§€§' judgment was

br0_:–:gh1'. 1.0"h:s'n{3tiC€, Afém" rleiicmg the same, the Eearmzéd

, J?a2dg€§–."§<:;1Ss .$§3€{1itE{§3;H§? c1a1'ifie<:i the }£:gaE pasiiirsgg in the C2156 of

~ 4VPR}%i.DESH PUBLIC SERVICE CfiMMISSIGN Vs

'gyms ' 'sgaiéfiavarfi ms OTHERS {(2069} E 36:: gmas;

99$; _I}?'ca}.mg wi€;}1 me quéjsiioh of {mus s2':<a.m:§z' af '€.§2€ §3'u"::»Ei::

,S<:*é""§««*§{i%:;3 Cf}§'1'EE"E'§§SES§{}H éifi {':E§aE.i::%§1§.,§§é ':.E":€ {'_§Ia"i§€§"f% ESL 'ii-$3.8 hs:-Ed 21$

V';::':2de;<' : ~ %/

"46. Sofar as {he question. Qf Zocus s{:ar2§;i:"{3jTV_':j}1.<;" :_.

appellaxlr: to file this special Zea1;eV__';_§eI'i.i:ie_% i' 4isT

concerned, we are Q)" the tjpifzitjn. U'.-at _.1Tf… h:1_.~: the

locus srandi. The High Ccaurzf"'::'tofife2'ii§; fieseent, asweie A

GOMS dated 31–_2_2__zs:3e7___m: ':i':..;m-s a1;;o"%A:;¢::'_g?;;:;§;e "

No{.§ffCaI.ior1 darted 27»12':«.2§i;e7. {J-"zhg_'1~1§g:-zt:oz,i%r's

judgrnenr: i5 {'0 be iII1pAieefi'1eraI.eVti-.eA .b’e_Azmdefzfiozkefie the appeliani.
FurI1hermo”re, in :’:e_r§r’ns 1 Ruzg 4 of [he
Code Qf«C_1’v’i{ 1r)f;D€’€{.il,,£:??E3§=U;{(3 §Z{[}p(31§’Z1I’8 eou.ri:’. in the

event. finc5′;g_9,5_ineri_i ._if’L…{f1e._”appeaZ a!” the instance qf

one Qj”5z’f1e reS;poz’ide:z.!:.§§V”may aside the entree

a__j1.tdgifie.§_ui_aciZt’I1e–z.4g?:_canofher respondent; had not

zappeafed *.€hz2feaQa:.r1;:;r’, The Commissiorz had

L:4rifti£3r%’mekei’:. :he..:..:a.€I< of holding preiiminary

e:<70m1i:ia.€j_fEl0z,:>ed the preceofure {aid

i.,£;EAs>z.:’>:3.& in {ism%iOi§ficai’i0r’2 z’:~:s;1.:;.e€E in Ems befmif’ and

‘_5.;”§:VO 5’v:’.:s’ isszzed by the SZ.a£’.e, H, Iherefbre, »::{)u5d

‘:eI’:.é_€?iE§;:;:f:?: ea zgirif g;e:.i:.£en.”.

C5}
L—-4

31. While: rei'<3:'ri:1g Le the a1'0:*esaid }r;:.d§I':.:é:<1_i in

P CHANDRA MOULEESWARE REDI)Y's case?_–'1;ha

held as u.r1{ier:-

“48. In Chandra zwozzleaaaarai-éead.;} ‘«

Staie had. accepled the jz_.tdgrr1é~n rfaf theI¢I–£g?t CCz1fjZ. ‘
A mistake on the pa.r{~v..Q:fV.a:;f1e Wffie
impugned direciiori zL:a,3_.ia:’c,tL:es§ior1 .i:Iierejr17_ was
in maxi context. c:-_5:fbrje:79ie’r;;’::?azi;2a observaiions
had been made. to befiiied
up LL>f1{2rs3a»;:.___a infill up only
ten po§:_I’:s. ;a”I.’f_”;e.iI’rib}1aal Siaie tofill up
all Q;”A’;;d’?1ra Pradesh did. not
Qj; i?1é Trib1,m,al. Even the
7¢¢,A¢’0r’*r1’r711’s$ii’;§:i’~ was Vi’aQ:t”r’r;t1air”ed. to carry out anyfresh
e«xaér’cz’se ‘Io Jwiz’;7’z the direction, Qf” the
Trilaaztal. £ h.e arder of Ilhsa Tribunai was moi.

Ef.d by fhe ‘i”:”i’i3Lx§’;£iE._ éhés {Z{>m’;nissé0n was-3 :”:.{>§ :”e<;':.23i2f'€z:§ {.0

§

aw

Carry out 2111:; fresh ézxercise to C()II}p1},-' with the direQ{li:)_f1~.Q.f {he

T1':ib1,mai_ I"*1w<3ve:', in BALOJI BADI£AVATH'$— {he

order of the I–Iigh Court is to be in1p}er;1.eI;ied,"'4?.,f1e.CQii1%i1is:giof;.._

had 'E0 undefigake the task 91*' pre:}.irz:»inary' €}<;£fi'fi}'}i.E';?1fiG1fi'.W;}1iCh~

had been 56?: asicie by the High C§)LlE'?{','." :;<,._m. ii "

was hekd 'that. if the :"e;a<;3*r1t;.ggrrjcess c{3'r1'uc3;;_cte<:i'; the
Commission, if it is found 1'a€a11'"v.rii,h 23.f1ci_ 'sci:-1a$é.;d€ the same:

and if the Cammissiou. beCa;.;:3*c.. 'E.ha'£, 0rdex"–..is.~E:Qmpe11ed to
redo the wh.o1e thiz1g_. –€'.hs::3 }Cfi';i1Vi:.1.i:S:~3i_or1 is an aggrieved
person. : . V

33. The .V:’C01:1VIi1i[séin_11′ is a consiituiienai authority

created z};34d€:r. the C~’}’1i:ai’_.i.iL:{i0r1. It has to function in terms of

ihé,co§’;5:'{itutié1?:2L3.,_Qlfuxsisiozas giving €ff€fiC”E, $0 the objeci; with

» iw-h_Vich E15,.’§S 3if€§:f1SJ{ii4[iZ1;€C1 unéer the C0::Sm,Lzé,.::};2 anti ‘éhfi Siata

‘-£…’*€2_’.£.L:}:’S§€’§.1é:”C,:]’::?9′ ‘:§éfi.m=:S its f::nc%:.i{>r1s–3. pi-18868 fa ‘ism-* and $§3E”:{iif§.{‘,

fL:if§<:%,i:§:2s§'2é:'e eassigzzsé {.0 ii" [.'§.EEC§f:'§° {E156 S1.e1i.'ut€. tbs C(}:'£1FfliSSiGi"i

"ff".?.;'=§,S: ééié wgrk ss?;.:°f§=L':£E§,.=' in zzcitisriiazxtéé wiiéz Ehgs: ss£.;2.i:.2%.s:":;

§:%i"<ji:'i.s§0:2s, Wheégg im E216 <:m:=-:-2&3: of “ésiéhargging iii? Ea:.w:1c::’.é::>r1:~3

AW

63

is of {he opinion that these aC:i,i.011s are in accardzxnce-.__with ihe

StatL1t.01″:,-” provisions Elfid if ii, {@615 the ‘re(:rL1i%.I:§~£i%1i.fldizc by

them is 111’1I1€C®SSEiZ’i1y Found fauit. wiih bgf.-fr §11_r:uiiC’iaE ‘§;T0t1y

whose decisioza is Contrary to the ,riE;.{;:c’:rtIa.i.nV1y.

they have 3, Iighi, £0 challengfi ‘die ofcief’ _}j2:$ée+’CE~..Ei§%.:the

judiciai amhority. The I’C’>£*;_,”§.¢£”;~3.f:.V fO”I’ ”
I'{“1’CI’L1i”£1’I1€i3’i’ §T)1″OC€’.SS :i.sV__n0t. the___g?:tVifA;’:V:<3_:*i;1»_7 It is'* Lgfinlaie result.
if any aciion of the faL1§¥; with and the
Cemmission ha.-sv to :1'°'t':5;%3 again and if the
.e;Léii_;$n a.c<:ordax1c:e Wfih law,
ithfiy jtldgmexlt Of a judicial body

which7ha:"»; f(3'L1VI1.C§:_"'fabLIIi_'K "€';Ti1;ih 1;hei:r' adieu. It is immateriai

\VI'1€31§'i€E' aCi;iQr17f_).f' me Cm1";miss;1o11 is fbund fauh; wiih by
n1af£<ii1gf. any %:E1.€;gai.i0;':5 agzmlsi '£.h.e C0:n.m..£ssi{;'n 0:' au.:*§E3L1ting

A«{:1V:i§z1'"fi{§€:§._<)::' purel.f;' 01': proceduraé i1"I'egz:.1a1'i*;.3* or beifigg

V{§§Z}§3§l"E3j..:}'."}{ £5} <?0:1::::: §h2»1:;. ¥;;.h.<:t C€;zn:"r1:i:<3si<}:": hag

'1"t;{)€}'2E'§E.£E_§, "E5 79:39 1%,-'iih {he app<}3;mr:1e.z:%;. in azrzy §3£1§'z".'ic;;L21:*

£i{%§::§'rii2::::%:§%. ;1f'E.:%§' ihé? :<3%3E<:<:%.'§:";:1 ;3:2:3<:€_é:e:'~,; <}v€~t:" zzrii if {Egg

" $c:%.§@C:,iié;: is 529% asicie, they e::am::1<}é:, be Ergeid is be e1g§g;:*§s:*xr€=:§

84

gyersons, car1r1c}4: be accr3p”Iied. ‘E’Ii1eL1gh the C0n11z1is$§{>i’;:–.»has no

persenai interest in any cf these 1′:’;’C’,’f’L1Zi.’:1. I}:1€:i’§’L”,.:’7.E13 21

c0nstii’L1E:ic)n21I aL1i’.horiiy when it. has condL’1ctec§._fh-ns e,I1d_.if sv: :_Ch ‘S§f’1€£3′?{§G1;1:’

is found fault. W-‘1’1i.C11 as i:11prope}’.;§r:i j1I<}g2£i','*
being an ixflependezli aL1t§'1<3:1»'i«t;':;,:?'§'V~.i,1'" it {i»*3a1i.s £53: 'EJLS: ac:ii.d1'1Lé.
and Show that their a(:.1iQ:1s gig?-e–VV<V§ii'fl:f-i'(:i11},{'in .é€','(.TOiTf51E1vE:§1{'.€ with iaw,
that can be done only 'order in the superior
C0'ur1:. erdea" f3'.nd.i.11g fauii

with the se1vséc§iG§j__ pr0c::$s1' «gar?-gmi be iaken away, in that 'iJi€V'.»'

of ihi': :11afiI'c:é*V,_«. '_s§ré}.Vi1<3.1Vfii"~«.1v,_1"12;1_–the Comm:issi0r1 has the locus
Siandiio'a:_haiEef1g§'e~ of 3. j;?.}diL';i£{1 aL:{ho1"'i1y, <31" a quasi

judicial éia_t'§;oVré¥;3s-'.ifA{'.h'"eVi.f..'L'se1e<:t§0115 am set at rlaughi. by t1'.1.e§11

r1Qi'_§:0f1£§,? an %;f1e..gz°0L1::§Ti sf mafia fidézs but even baing C0ni:;'az*g :10

V ' «éaqéyieg '"'£t:fl5:. ‘g:;5_€:n. is ihesm to Show it; the Sup€£”§O3.” C<::s:.,:.z°é;:a ihaé {he

I "r;:.af:;;;%V::§m_;e:';t. 3r3§<:~.<::€.i:}z; p:*0::s3ses3 which. éézegajg haws dams? is;

s;%,:i:é%.1§i_ i.i'i"1""a'2"%,C'?{';{}3;'Ci2iH£E€3r with law and it E1213 b€€E1 uzzzzésécasszeriija

i.:";*:..%,-:%';i.§'e*§":§{§ '$33; a j:.z€§t;<7§ai :31' {§,'éE%.'E:':'§

……..n

':.::=:ii:?.2T2*:§ ;«'m::§';::§r§é.§;,

POINT NO.2

AGE RELAXATION

whezher Ruie 6{3)(b) Qf the C}_eI.1e_r_al R{3é§iiff:?i_1:c'riI'vRulesliczg

got: oz,'-<–2r–riding ejffect over Rule Q]7_ 't,?:J.s;' G£'.{'£(E'~?"(il fV€€R:-r;ii§r_ner1t "

Rules and 2007 Rules?'

34. The learned Co=.:11Sé£. fc:r_ t.he.’i'{P_SC Siri Nanjunda
Ready, sv.§3m:iLs t1’1a’Lre;g:1?L1%’:::nr:fi*ts; are done “under a
special law, namely. the«.K2:r1ia$.a,ka T7’L1’b3i»L:”W01″ks Engineering
Departmem. ‘(R1-‘,v_3€IVI’L1.i’L;FI1(3’I’i’. Assistant Engineers.
DiV’iSi(}”i1{“–I,by:.C(§ii.}§3f3′(,€T{}f–_}§:Xé1.1’Eli.3Zéi;é,iOI1) Ruies, 2007. R1136 5 of
the Said ._Ru1Vé’s .prV<§Vide&; f"0r 'age Elfld acaciemig: quaiificatien of
the (1aI'.id:§(Zi'a't€f$.=,H."é1'}E§Q'.}QI46'éiCi€S that': Th€)I"€ is no maximum age.
limit; far (1',£§;"i":fl i:Ci.:v"-*.1j.(.E-f:§ cfaxiifieterit: LI§':d€*.Z' §Z';~S€i'i–'"iC€? q'u.i:&, which in

ii’.S€§.§’ 3:3′;’r:§a:><z1€i'o:1…_in«age» TI1E3I'€'§O§"E"'.n "£1116: provisiozls of Ge;1€~ra§

. 'R.§3{T1¥'!_;§.'§?{'§{f.'§"§j'~ R'Ll.1€:',S _;3:"0v§€§i:1g Eb?" :7:.ia,x2.u;.:E<m <2? agé: is 225%,

%%g;:g%;;:;{:;a;':e§%. %, 1111

66

323. The Karnataka PL1bii{: Works ..’E:{§g§fie_eri-mg

Ifieparimeni Sewi.£:€ {Re<:3:L1it.mem, of A£BSi'Ejs"f2iI"1T;"

Engineers, D1'visi<m~1 by Conlpetitivg: »£§XaI11i'i"i:-1"£;izj';3) 'fluiss Q'0"[::i':?'

cfe=a,l.s with Z'€CI'%.iiU11Ei1'i¥. to the pas?-gyf Assisyg 1?ixecuéiV€ E3-ng§i1fr;ee1*. "

Rule: 5 deals with agaix actadcmic é1e§_EtVi';:f'icaiT;'it3f:.V«:0f_Hca_:1d§da.*;?éés
which reads as under:

‘”5. Age V a§.;:ag1.eéira.i¢»firaxalification of
candidates:- Euery:psé’rs5:?i Lafio. {f;fiS_’_.a(:I;ain€d. the
age <)~f'.v2.1::'g;.<_ear:f: ?9V'L:i1i years in the
{he Scheduled
C515{gs,f_S;t:_fiefiiL:ie;§i*?fifrffie:~;V/Cc;:¥'1; 38 years in Case

1 ' '.téV'bEz(,egor"y 2A ,3 28/ 3A! 3B:

Eirty Ofiher candid,af;e:s as on the
idsi”daIe’j’iX'<'3§Z Qj'appIicaz'1'ons shaii be

— .. eligifiicfo’ fir}? recméirneni Lmder {hese rules.

. E-?ré*r;*:’*’-.e~:;’.«'{.}2.c1t’ ifizere is no m:::;<'£;rm:.m age iimiir
' fQ_r candid.afes c{3znpe£Ting :.:.n::ier in service

. ég:.4;{):;a.,

. Carzdidaies must be §"z0§:*: §;z’a;z.§’:s:»:§. 59;; 5: i§:2.i.:>er5;§§’§; §:’abEis§:£%rZ by

:’,am in Irzdfcz a::d.j’mr7’2 an §ns§f§:z.§{:e a:pp:'<::veo£ by the

g/,.

AICTE, or a f)ipZr;;>ma Ceri1f:caz.efmn1 i:I.z. .:1TI?$ii–IiI£€iO?’L

cgf Engineers (India) that he ha:-; pasgéi:i<Puar.:::s:.+fl. 6}. B

Qf the Associate Membersmp E,scc1m:nrqti'io}1 c;;af'.fth'e–..

Ins£'i.iiu.£"f0rz QfEr1gine<2rs=:: {India}.

35. Rule 13 deals wi1.h £;’i4§T3{‘3fIf=iVEA1..’i.i()E}> Qf ‘a.;3g)Ii.c::é{“é,–3f(ij1*1._VQ§’
Ge’r1ea”a.i Recruiigmeni. Rules a1fx€f§:’i’iw.’;’€£1dV.S ”

” 13. Applicgtion”bf*f34criér;1l Rééruiifttent
Ruler» E’:)((,’£”IZ1i””QF”!17~.’.”(;”L’~.’-_§:L’)(i’;4.”_V'{b. (‘3f’V.:?;:?1(i:ffi1’£?f’S for which
provision is nf1a.,d é_ in Ijflfise i;t?”2″e prou1’sions
Qf the’ ‘ ;{{§r,n1cf§jaica SI;a1;é _._SjérLvices {General

£Zé<,'fc1_ii%?.1ei~_} R_t:.fiéS5 i"9'/'«"V/_ ffor" the lime being in

s'?;§dil_"b¢" a;2p li.:i:ibZe for purposes Q1"

“r€c:*z,:£iriie.:jiI: uv2idTe%*’*i’}’1.ese rules.

875 _ .. R1112 with 21p§31i.Cat31Qr1 sf Other P311163 which
r%79§é*i9:_E1;S :.1_nds:§*f” ———- ~ *

Application of other rulesn T F16
‘_”_£{aj:’f§”:駣a.E>ca Cfvii S{:’¥”viCéfz(3?” miesflgr {he {fine baéng z’z%:_4f}::m::{3 regu.Eai:’::’.ng

{fee m:”zd}i§’:’a:”:s; 53;’ :%sré5:”:>z'{:e 53;’ {:~:° Size §}I'”{}E?§S{} La jirzicie 33$}

%/’/

68
Qf the Cor1s(.i.Zu.t’i0n of India, in sofa?” as such.
rules are not coI1sz’si’:em’. u;i:’h the pr(;:.%isions;{7_f
those rules. shail be applicable to

appointed under {hese rules. ”

38. In supp01’i. of his Con_I,m jL1dgmentss ‘of t;i’1′<;-. Apérx (3:it;'rf is '

rep€)rted in AIR 1961 SC
SPINNING AND WEAWNG .90.,' Vs; STATE 0?

UTTAR PRADESH in pzxragmgyh 9 and
10 ii has been hcfid as L1.F1.fZ§€§7: «b h’ ‘V

_ v’ti73*:.e:*<3r"ygill _' be Complete h.armoz'zy
}'z;9u§.s3vér–§f"'§V:§e._?i0I§"~§.zfas{:eac?Z, zI':a£"' Ciffifa} wiii appiy
in .oii te_r of proposed dismissal or

'"disCf1arQe__ éxc£a;§:. wfzere an z'r2qm'rj;; is; pending
}:iif:'it':':}: the %§i é'ti2'2iz:g Qf {3Z,.23,'We:3 reach $31.9 same

_ l§)\g*,'. appigizig a.nof:?ter zwsli fC?E€){.é.?3'?£ miss' Qf
Vv<fo}3:';;«?jrziz§?VE,§{)rz mat: gesrzerzczé prv€s:’:’3:2.3 ggieéd. 5’6 specfai
g:_:?s*é;z%:1;§f{}:23k Tfze Ze5:;m{-351 AE:;0m€§;–€§{:I2ez’s:zE seemed

” Vzj;§’i- szgggeszi ifzazl a.;:F”::’££;> zihis rz,:E£:’ Q2″ £:0z2.s;Z,z’z.:€z1i;;=Ez’::i{z;b§ee :0 rz£s;e:2§z,2e> §j§”i§’f =:.’.E”§§?i{fE. ?;:3:i:.:2ee.:’z 3’38
5_;,zen.s3:”{:E §:3?”{}{}iSii’}f’? in ::;:r<ae 35:5': and {$2.8 5;;2c§::s§

2

%/

69

provision in another Acl, the rule ccmnoli ap}r:l_l;l’-.i’a~.l_

resolving a C()1″§fliCI be1:ween general ancl.~«~s.;j_e.cialV.j’ , A’

provisians in the same legislative insz4mz:”;erI£’,’vilffiisl

SlI,Q’Q€3SliOI1 does nof:’fi.nd Sll}f,_{I’3.0I’l in. eiiilievf’ ;:iifineipl_eV

or aulzhorfly. The rule llhljlli aené:ra«l_ ‘pf0«vfSiar1s

k’)

should yield to specjfilc prk:::vz’szior1s shall’ an”

arbitrary principle mal.l1e.f saonly some of

them g%:s–l’::¢;-::;~a;;»n.1;j.«;” l;l1ai:A..i.hese””la£ler dfreclions

slioflld _§}’I’e1}ail—- these while as regards

ifesl, eazilfer clifééelziarz should have e}fec1,.

“gin Pfelilflll:”»S{)lll;l;’–V,A{fl’8.f3Q–53 23:12 1032) quoted in

Cfaiesl £)f’t’– S§.ai.a..l(§e–~sleaze at; p.206. 6″‘? Edition}

— ,Ror71i’lll;s:\rI.lI2′; n/1em’;i’oned. Elle rule 2§l2.us:– “The rule is

§f_1:az’.__wlzerie’z:e–:<«lhere is a parfzieular enaelmem', anal

_agge*::er.a§l enaclm.en.::' in {he same si:'al"uE.e and she

1"§€?éfl'§:vF'..T{5T§§9€e'3'l in its masi: eaz*:2_;'3«:'e?2ensfve sense;

l.l,_'*'}E,lZ§ evemlle £.h.ej'?:2rm.e:', {he pa:*:z'::?:.2.la2" €F'lQC§,3'":"'i{;'?'1I.'

.. :%::zs:' be aperaliee. anal the ggerzeral er:.sa:7§.me?iz2': rmzsz

Ejle z.e.£€e_2*": is afiecéi. (mfg; {he sz'.§":.er gaaris agf ilze s§:'{z::.;.§e

la i駧?.§{.'§'l ii mag; prgéggerlgg ::z;}g3l_:;"'

gr. .

The rule has been applied. as
dgflerenlr pr”OI)i.5i.Or13 Qf ihe same slaifile ‘
numerous cases some Q1″ wlzicll 25¢ T
menticmed; De ‘Wimon 1:. C$”€3(1S€3,~.[I’8.28}5EBli’lQ
United Slsaires 9. Chase, siege);-A1..:3§5 -.2′:2,5 la}ff’;er__1I&
Carroll 1). Greenwich Ins,_Co.. .1 ll

10. Applying i’l1i§”r1ll.e.Vqf’ eai’1sl?fllr:I.l0Vii i.!1(1l
in. cases Q)” conjlcl:i.~~lgelweeaal :,S.1’3VV{:”C?I:/{‘€C pz”c:»l?isil§:2 and
a general proL:i.siérl1_.:.i1e prevails
over then. geneyfaiv .g:§’:’oi)'{.s:;:;_rzl lhe general
pfOI}lSisjfl’fi.l:?:;.€5l§e§-_fmlgjltlio.§1,lef1:x’C’Ci§:eS wl1z’.ch are not
we musl hold that:

VCl.(.5{Cl} .,1>:as;,_n.o .,gpp’l1c’a{–if)r;_ A5′: a case where the

pee-fallpf.{ml$§£0ris.Qf7Cl.*23 are applicable.

39. ;/-Xg21li”:1_ Cmxrt. in the cage of STATE OF

RA,;§As:r*r£AN”‘Vs.:lGo1%I KISILAN SEN repz’i:e{§. in. AIR 1 992 so

‘1.795-4_’§1l¢.pa%¢h 5 has held as u:1′:’ff
untrained ieacflers as an exeepr4ie11;«–.Vifu:aVV V
cannot be given effect. (0. T rm; In.+3r:’f;’:

argumenr either. The r;°LL€e
c0nsi’mCi’i.on Q)” appafe2′?.I:lg; eo:1flz’.ei.’ir1g’v “${.at:y;:’erfQ
provisions is weil estaI§Vii.’~;?u;>d _jbrV’ ~;zeze}IeVZd.ir;ig and
giving effect’: to (2131 we pro’Lii3=;e:1e.é9″i3;§:_ft1r es”iI. rfiay be
possible, and _fc3f’af}ei<:i'if1gf.file.'"i}i:1::efp*rei'a€:ion which
may render any btiose. In {he
presenf; Reieg dee{i'§ii'{gV_.__;eifft payment, of

inc;rerne:«?_._t –é;}j_ gertsefaf I'e%r7'*a$ .=_u?1ile the Schedule in

:'"i.}i.'e 969*' :na';§és" a: special provision
Vivgoverrzirigeflieeé »ez.;4ii~é:j:«:iii–:1ed I.ea<:h.ers, attracting the
Ifiezsdrrw "gere1erdZi.I§i2;s'?'Speeialia d.erogam',". :'.e., if a

— , speei’a?V_;j:3re2;?:s€e:1 exade on :1 certain, suigjeez”, that
Es:z:.uE3z;ec%i:’ ieV”e;<c?.:.4decf.fl-om ihe generai _;0rem'si<m. '£'%1e
_ {Sehevei:4le in the E969 Rules, Eherejbre, nae:-33: be

– -p.%*ez:afE ever’ we genemi prezzisymxs 0f 2 §f;3§

Rz:i’Eeé3_,

?§’€},. Fmzz: éthe :;%f{3:’e£~::a:L<§ _§1,:{§g;e;:"1::%':':f.'.s;,_ ii. s::*Ee2':§ éézaé;

gefiemi gwevieiezze SE1z:$* E2; 1’10:

9/

. . p’1*:3*%.?§S–E’eI1 A.

72

an a;:bi’£,1.’ary pI’iI”1Cip1€: made by lawyers and §’l1dQ:€$.’:b”i1_t Spills
fmnl the COTI.T1fIE{)’I1 u’r1de’rs’t.2mding of 113621 and woméri.” Rule

is that, when.é:ver there is a parti{:L1§ar erkzictriiefii 8,I1¢if -ii ‘gérgeral

enactment: in the same saatute a11dM *ghe 1att:@r”tTaEieri”in’~iLs more
conaprehensive sanse would «ix-*e1*91’:,11_<3 'the f3rm43'1i

pa'r'£iCula'r enactmezai. must be :{3})é;rg1'iEve3 'c'-Lfid . 'Lhé.:_"'g¢V:1<3;'ai
eraaciiment. must be taken i1*11'.Q"'2aft"ec1 "only 'toVt.hé:G"£her*':paa*Ls'Qf
the si;atm:e to which it may prOj';€:r13i apm _111 case of<:o:o.i1ict
between spectifie pr<n?i–S_if,':;1 a:_I1d;_gei1e'1"21I'proviszion, the Sp€CifiC

provision prevafis over t4§'*;e_ géhe5:*a1.–=.pi*o§fi9_itm and the general

p1'0viISi0n VG.;11'_\,–*" '£:(')«_Vss'L1E_:I*1' cases which are 1'1Gi covered by
the Spe§:.i.fi<: p1¢.<;»\fiSiz”V24.”—.__E’i”‘«:1. Sp€{T’.i.’:”i1 prc::}V’isi0:§ :35; made on a

cterizzfizi sub§§_:Ct;U?Lha’1 slzbjeet is exc1u:: E ‘S5,:

V-Lv,;:£…~

{3}

73

Conlpetlitive I£xan1.iI1a{iGn$ Rules, 2007′ Th6 RL1.§€:$i’C}1′ 1977
previde for age limit for e3.p’p{>i’n’t’.m€n¥’… It is cG:3′{ain<":–s.l 8.

Similarly, Rule 5 of the R.LIl€S, 2007 §)r0x*i(}*é,?s

academic qL1a£ific:at:io'n of czxndidaies. '1"_'h1:~1"~3.f§;:fé3;'=.3.v«1;@n__€133

special rules specifictaliy pmvicle {Gr age-1' 9_1_V1L~'..V_,;i{§é;;:1e':r11__i_c,*.__

qu3.1i'fica'{.i013 Of Candidates, it 0\Ie1A;"1jié€:l§.lRullév_-!B;{'l)
with. the Same a.SpeCt. Rule _v<'$f-{lie riilgs of f2.{£}O"}5_;'CEee:l;i;"€s tliali
the Said Rule 5 has no appIiCatlllG«£1:ltGvVtl1e qiiota 1.6:. in so
far izrsewiita Candifiaztes poslé éarmarkecl for

S€I'ViC€ quota. ln respect": "Oil:'l{l'l€:fl'i~,i.'v~1f}lE3"'_1'118XlI'i'1L11'1'1 age: is

presc;'i§3ecE_.1"7.'1ffh_<;'réfo1'<23'ii; is not 21 case cf re§a,xa%.;io:1 of age
p:"es<:ri§:)er;E. in–Rtxlé,_5"..§2j'17..g;:»erso11s othef than the i::~ssez'vi<:€:
ce::r1dida.}:é$.4_V The said 2053? Rules tie 3&1, prcwide fcfzr reiaxatirm

0§,.e_,é.g€ Emit ;3ri<'3.3§::;'ibe;§ in rule 3 l~i9wm:'cr§ Rule l3 malies it

V ' »::léEa1* €:*:sq_ce;31;, 313*: respe:<:¥;. 0:' maiierss €03' whiezh gsmvisriens are

Vé;:.£1{'i[€_§'1:._?;fE';;és;$ EQIIEEESS 'Cl"zf:T p:"2::**v"i5_;§<ms»:§ <3?" 'i'.l'li° §r<:az°:':21'z.aZ§2:z S?;..a¥;.@ civil

-r

:2-‘s€i”=é:ic€:S {{$_£%tEe:”al R€{:m.ii.m::m.§ Ruiesl E9’??l E62″ £1326 {time biting

§11;.l§ll’§<723;':";2l:;=: 5:13" §3E3,§'§}€}-.':§{'. <2? :'e<?r::i£.::';e;2§"1*;4

i.'..Eff§Cl€1;"'l1l'1€S-Bi? Razlea Rtiléf E4 2*s£S{} az:1":§3l.i.fEes:; ': 32:; 2?.Sp€{_'.§=

l

Therefcrre, when the Rules of 2-007 do not prm-"ids :f:¢«lgi'};;1ti0r1

of age as contained in s=.:b~Ru1€:(3) 0? Rule 6,

(3) has to be read into the Rules (£2007, st$"i11é§t: Véige .];:'i1'itu

prescribed in the said Rule 5 3t2m:cis3:1'I'<:1r:;.}<:eR:1_ if i{he 'cbnd1iI1%i0ns "

prescribed in sub-Rule (3) of :R".;1\1€3 'aV¥.'i*:;fac;4f'.f,%'c*i}; VS}.'§}VC)t';RLi'1C
of Rule 6 reads as under:

“{3} I\’otLt:.1.§i:;§’:.3za}_’td:§;”;g}. affidtéhirig C=0nI’:ain,(-3d. in
sub–rule (1) the n1axi:rf1:Lfiih§fe _–E:’.g:9;v*a’ifj_'”<3b;4jappoinfmen:
shall ef1h: t:z:1¢e?:1 the _,*"oi1<)wz'r1g
cases. is _ r}z<;r1I:i§3: :{5jd"rfi1 z'i1ély;~
""" Q "f:j;j;*'~.' ca.§;;»""'};j' a candzidatie for

V' '~f.?:Lj3j:,»(v4)4V1"1'2_l_:rV%:<2_i"tI,' to a Ciass IV posl on the
ésigablishmeni. cf a Minister,

Qf Siate or Depziigg Mi?'1.§S{i€T,

'vvb;,:;j'¥ve years, if 3216}: appeirzirnsrzig is

only for the duraijiorz Qf {he term. Qf
Qjfficce sf such 2':/;'im'sz1er, 3%/I'ir:i;<sE"€r Q)?"

Smifes ar 53952553; §'JI£'¥":§.SIé'?'f

{E9} in :';E2.s5 sage Q?" :3; <?and£.{ia:'.'s3 :,.:;E2o '£3 az'
wag §'%{}§C§i?E§,I :3 g}{}SEJ zz:2.a'£e;" zifze

G{}U€I"3'"£m€3'":E 6}?' Ci Eacai a:.z.§,%2z}r££;g; 0:" {£1

E//….

375

Corporation esizabiished by a S{a.1′._e*
or a Ceni’ra.Z AC1″ GI’ esE:a,bli.she:’i”‘bgj..’j:–?if{: ;_.
Gouerrmlenl unclear :.;1’ ‘
the Govt, by $519 :_”I’1T:.zr 72}’:§é:z:j»
during wV1?:’i/J2 .r’_s 0r [1.,§CI£T’ ”

such _pc:~sI. ‘VII;-an ggéarsj ‘:.L:?é_:icfi<é:z}é%* is

5633;"

42. So if 21 £:2if1_cEidai.(~>7 };vh{§LT’~.t1;:)[5’iies for re(:ru;itrne11t
under the RLE1:3 ‘7.O07fi’fhd{1g1’1.1″1AE2. ‘C{§3f3S :1{Jt passess the age as
required z_:.r’1c{C.r_ i?,:.,:1-8 5-:éLt§$i’i.es»requi1’e’ment of clause (b)
of Ruk: “[*8}_§)I’j.RL{1£é::58. 0E7_R’u1e::,’ “1977, he would be eniflled to age
11-)1aX3_._t;i01’1’a$V 6:61′;-t2ii:1_€'(i~__i«i”:*– .1116′ saié proviso. Mierely because in
Rule 5″€:£_'{‘. ‘the. iTy,1g”«-ski “fnaxi11’au’1n age limit {Or candidates

com_;:_svei.iI1g”G:ide:17′.’–i23¥s€2:’%Eice queia is 1E1€Z’i'{.’iGZ2€&, {hat is 1:10: 2:

cgiée Qfage. §e3a§x:a.€”.i.0.n £0 G”thEt:*$ and that does 110% some in the

» fwrzgy Q{£v’::;3.§:}§§{éajat%{§:1. of Ruiifi 6{3}€b:E and ii, wimici :’:{:’£, hawe ihfi

. £:;§’f&¢r-csf-«:;§x<::f%~:¢:§i:1gg {he mid §}:'Gi£'i::31§{:=n,

E
E
3%.

76

43. In fact, the Tfibtliiéll on an eaflier 0c{:a’::~.i<3m a1SG
{oak a similar mew, w}1ich View has been affir'a1ad..'n37.;i f3{'§'§:'Vi'.':T-;.i'01'1
Bench of this Court in the \7\I.P'N0.2e'3O21~3E/9?', whgxuzé it

held, the 'Kaur11.a1',21ka civil Services: (_C3.r.€::_1era1_-'Ré'C;:i’f}(§idE1″£:.E§;%Vj_I71§5v¥;. afn <i"v'prdper azad
needs £10 interference. 'f'Ems.___ '2'1-fisingilal' Ca:"§iér1t§b1'1 raised by
KPSC was I1egativeé In View of ihe

rnaiier. the Tribxmal wag-3 i1__1._h~c§i;:1ibi1g that the aforesaid

two a._pp1ic_2ifi{Sv a'Vr£ e'I'1i.iVt'I€_ d $0 age }'€1£LXE1{.iOI"1 and $116 KPSC W-'{:1S
nei jLi'S.tifi€C1V in 'Iitj'L V.–them fer i;1ie;"vi€:*cv on 'iixe greund
that th.€f,?<–..g:'1"e age §:)é§I"r;<%1é. it is not 311?: dispute mat. if {Che

rgk§:1xé3.iLi.1A1 is Véxiezaded $0 these: ifxxza a.pp§§{ta’:1E:s. than they w<m§.<:i

V' .Séi'§.i.S§°'. '{.hé'~;'€qL1E}°€2}1E?1'}%. of gigs 213$ i.h.u.5.s eiigibiét mat {Kai}; {G

ij§«":_;:f9 «::%§{;3:::é';§:21€..§<:::1§ but 2333,20 ti': "£38 <::83§€t<% fcx' in£1.ewi.:3w. En

'–{.I?:::a§', 2'i€§€§%"L'$§" §:.h'€ :11£:'§:&5.e1: aw herzzbja Reid '$19.2'. Rifle fiiifiéébi {}§ ihe

' ~ s§i;3§:dé;' :'€.§2,%,§<.€:d ':0 %;'§:a'£ s:Xt:€m.,

E€;{;.k%:f~;<.€;§"v.?§'?'? 2:1E}§Ci§i€3$ 321:2 am. 2?:,§}?;§s §é:°<;ws2::;*i.§'3€:<?: :,::1.e:k~:.r Eiuisr 5

3

77

POINT N0: 3

CREAMY LAYER POLICY

Whemer 3’\feu= Comprehensivejfireamy”I;.ay:ér.Policy <:£ ai"éd

30"" March 2002 is appiicable to irt':ser;Jic(3' canc:'idt§"Li'e'S :i;3.I1i}:1V?_a'a.v(3 "

appliedjbr direcr recru:'Z:meni::wider 5%V_cE1€Tr2go.<fy'?A.V¢:

44. Sri. Nanjunda R§:_ddy,r._}€ar:<1'ed__Sen:ir Counsel
contended that in so’: £21: as {_:Tx<=:(i'z"v=Li3v*~;N:f'1'1':;*1f11V of 5% in–servi.ce
candidate is CUE?C(f1"'I"1®(ZL"-":10.pf3I*i£3Ct':_Of'.§€3};'\?}'{§'€'f.£1 the Eower post. or
experience su§:th_. post is Vpres?':1fibeé'.'""Eve:ry parse}: who has
atta1ir::_ed 1,11éA'2Lgs<~t _Qf"5:Z1 ~y§ap_s, _who has not zitiainsd the age 0138
'€3£l1'S, eiigfibée 't<i ' ~21 "3.E,\:';'»».4E;u£ in so far as iI1~S't3§"'v'§{I€ uota is

– _ . 1
eor1c€:rne’c’%;.._V;w 1::12:r,:>s:iA.1::,1’izr::i;~’L’ age Iimii. is p2:e$<*;rs'.bed. E-XI} thaif: he

I'1;3:§;_§§,O satésij,-I {he e:iv.<:a14ien21E q§,:a1;T§i<:21:.ioz: Llfiflfi? the R3168.

' f'F§"§:eref%:'f::._'xixE}€n 21 p;'esC,rib€é;% p{*;E'3{{}€§§ sf 5a:,»-’32” post’.

‘ “:3; é:2:p§:;:ji€;::{:.€V £2″; a pe:~;%;., E5 é;”;?. a c{:1’1;%”: §}E”{‘:{?€idffti’:'{‘. fax’

a3;;}pEy§;;g; jmg C@:”:1§re1’u:=:§3,esive C2’€21;1’1:; E,-2-3.53:? sf 2802 fig

::;3gé§:::j;>:;:e”§§ an ihzii Szzéfi E35333.

78

45. Thts ‘E’ribu.:”:a1 has: Cate§g0;”i(:a11y 1″ec:<)1'd.tid. é;-._finding

to ihe efiéci t}1at no S§)€:'fCifiC permd of ;',5&'.I""»–='i(Efl'_."§:;'S n{:*cé{'ed

prescribed in order to become: e1igjb]e__t9 21pfjIj,.? 3191* ivI4§#S(:-3f';"'};C€'_'

Candidaie. The cand.i.da'L<: must h;21Ve;'pu.i iIi».$Cm;it: S§Cfa5§(V"}§.'_EiI§d '

he should corltirmrs to be i:1'Vfs'c*sj;§(?eV"i0 "§1§:'.:)})}fv3'/ fiiid
that is s3L1I'fici<-:r11 to g1.tmct fijsaéicyi. T1143
learned Ccnmsel \.r1'_§:\2\z of the Tr'ibu:1a1 is
contrary to i'.he,_0bjec1 1I:"i'1;hfxv'i:figig' '(i:(:)'V'i""I'}:'§.)I'€}'lE3I'lSi'iz"(i' Creamy

Layer Policy 3T.x7»"c-':E;"c;i11f].:'.'!.)1'<;3"EfC'i Yh§f:'.G{)§§€£"1'i'II1€f1{.

46. “”” ..§f:fo1}j7f;’f19_”ifaéiizs se.i: d::t aibzwe it is Clear that KPSC
i5sL:eé;1 twe. z9:0Tt:i-i’i,Ac€21Lbi<§~11;:é"" ~.fCa1"' r¢ecruiE,meI1t of 104 Assistant
E:1gine<3:fs"{IL)i';»'i§ié;z§;~».1.}§L'*.,___0u€ of the 104 posts 10 be filled up,
?5% is €:2%[:"§11a.;"'§.rGm::;»’i.i0}:2. in

{h{§’,’i”€’Ifi8§ZE§I1§§h2Er§§}_, 2.0% 11% :0 ‘£36 fified up by €ii1″€c:i: ‘recruit::r1€zz§

“”*.?€}E§(‘I.'”1’ is @3532: E0 evergfezze ir1c§z:zs::E3;::g_; ‘aha: §3e’r3<::":5 'R-'SE16 am in.

A :3s_es:'"%s'i:3:§;'~3£§';€:§'r'€:2é;~s iézér I'€3I"}7:£1E§":iE1§.§ 5% 9f p:_1§},;-* §:i:}:z:” :.§}é:’Si:::;’:$ whi} aim? §H§r3i*§”§=’§{,’fé*. ii; ES in i§”:Ei’§l {f{}§1’E’.i?X’E $23

aha naeaaé far i:r1s:3:r’x.-ice eta1′:’1cEi€E21§,&s ezgaéxi %,E*1G.:Ia«e gmsis Ezmve

<"""""""""

./’

79

to be filled up accorcling 1.0 the Z’f3.S(;’I”v’E1[.iO’I1 p01ic:§; T:}I.’ the

G0v<–31*;2men*;. in which ev€nt pe1"s~;(ms3 wha fall 1,1§Ed€§1f"Q_$"{'i,éT§§§§i?'i€iS

ILA. 118, 111A amd BIB are erititied to 1*ese%:va1i.i'§};:z. [I11

C1'isp'L1t£: that. the appiicams who c:};1.§m_ 'I'€?ES€'I»;,'.\V;-'"é.'i";i'(),1§'1 .a'1"1V b'6}0'1="SVg"f:O_'

ba<:k'warc§ <:0mn'1um't.y and thzlt' i}}1ey.._;;zEve '€}z'0.i.tp "B"-.%JA_0f§'§.mi:'r$.'

The que§5i'.icm is 'xuecézmsei t.h<:j<; are Gr{)i1p 'B' <).1'"{'i£ié'rJ:é dt*4a'€i;"ir1g';fV. .21
pay Scale of Rs.6,00{)/– to R5,»; I.",..200/- do *;.h.éy fa11'VVtif:10§€1' §\§éw
Comprehensive C'rea.my 1.a1ye;'…Pol.i_c:y.."and iI'1'11.1§ e;2~fC1L1c§ec§ from
appiying for p<}si.s 1'1}f;;E;E"l"'l.~,'fC')'3'5 .{:21r1diz:1aies and Ciaim

1'ese'1'va.1ion atnong {hem _

47. ” ‘ is afisc 11’Oi i11 ciispfite i.h-aa. ali thase persons filfid
app}icf’a’tiC11s; €’:h?c’f,r”x;>c3’1»’6:* Cajiéd fog’ the writien eXan1ina§.ion, 211} of
€h.em héia-icéé 1.)aSs_e{iz 2″}: w’rii.’£:e:/2 ex2m’:§§:;1§,i(;:1, ‘£:h:;:r<:<a.i3';ez*

%nt§;m'211;i®ns wife' $562111" {:0 t.i§e}:1'1 '10 aé',i€:I1.d fihe i}1i€I"'»'iE*.'W basaved on
§,§v.'%§3'~:"r§:?:§°i:',.__ "§'§zi:ejL,§*'a%§–.£§« 'aiifwzzd {E7163 i.:1.:.e:°v"§.c%w, E31124 i.E":%:%§_: wfle 329%.

_éfi?_e:}x3.:é:<i"3,<}<__insi::i€: ihf: izfiesrview Ezziii 9:1 i.?3€, g,I'<}%.md ?;.f:".a2::'z. §..'i<3.I:}-*

" ._;':':"f{;3« ii-;":«¥; _€E§§;E'E'; §€: a?::':{§ 'i.E1€§;' 2:31? €:X{'é:.s{§eGi 'é}e:;?z:1.:s§;€: 5;'? €;?'%5:"

€;'__:{:'”s;3j_r::i””s§%::$:£*:£% C:*<:am::g 12.13,-*<:r ?i§::7j;,»: it is; in “§’§”i!:3..’€, {“?{“2¥”:'{.€f?’2€;%’_. E_.im?§:

80

appreached the “§’§ibL£I:’a1. The :’eas£>1″1.s assigned b§;..'{.i’1r§iiPSC as

is Clear {mm t.h<: statement of sbjecéions is, Nme 1'"i.£§:ih.é"—ESE'e–'3v

Comprehcansive Creamy Z..aye;' Po1i.cy bexc1L3.dVés""1;h't:s3é=G'mup

officers belonging ta the backxxraijd €_§€}}11'IE1.L1»F.1ii:}?. 1i'::V"L<;3&1"€?i%:_1* {,0 "

appreciate that comention to .2~1.._H1oc-3}§ air, the

said policy contairzed in A11nEaxL'm=:~11;VV

"ANNHxURE-1i«–t&"G.o. pg SW15' 2225 BCA 2000

dated ;30f'=-.1$7IcirchT'-..'2'_O(;_i_°.;.j.

NEW.COMPRJEHENSWE cP.E2;1mE' LAYER

H .z3}–:3ci¢"" iéééz 18(4) of the

C0fis§;i1:i.fifi}'Qn bf th e fégllbwing pe1'sns shall
,1’1m: _b£:, e1i’g;ék:1e”–f§3;*._ reS€:rs:z21tio1.1 of seats cf p5ts

categorised

V

‘N A’

4;::1d<:r"'1_1gx,_£1B, 111;», and ma.

T13’is”-»1fLiEé will not apply to abject

._1T€::1*i1i.};i’11en1s; is pogts which insist on
p§”es€’ribe€§ period of Servicsé in a
=___i_Q_W€:1′ pasi. or e:xpe’1″ienc:e in 21 §)0:-31:,

pmfeassian GI’ DC{ii3.p9J[.i{)§1 21
qu2zi§§’i{:21*{1’on <31" ehgibfiiiy.

‘}{‘}:1:i:-3 :°u.1é3. apgaéifig ‘:0 E§{}§}{S§ SE?”

é2mgi’§.£,e§”{s} sf {h.r:=s persmng gpeiéifieiszi
E3§:.E{m.;:

E3:s”$s§i<§€:':?;. <7}? I:':{2i§:1
E-".i.::€ P3'é3$i<:§=:3%:";%;. «:3? ézsiaiizia

{a

E
{b}

{C} Aéi i'L1:1C:.i.€::{:a;"i€$ haidin 5 Cabinet. zank

83

saié Order are 1:10? eligibie for rese1’va14;ion of seai.3 ‘ai””‘–po$ts

Categerized ¥.iI1d€’I’ HA, E18, EIIA and H18. in Qifiefi

persons m€’I1t.i0Ia{:t V€’zVdt.i:i’€%d to ”

reserv-*aEi0r1 though they be:h;{:fLg..

The _p€I’S-01′} to whom that 13{>1ic.:_vf_,L?:’VV’*c?=_1::§;;i.i§.:ss ‘:s~’;V’:4L::f.’.:f}E.E1LE1§Z’} clauses 1,
2, 3 and 4 under E which falis for
interpretation irfxthis

“L ‘fIi:’s fills wifl riot. apgylyv to Véffiect recruitment:

to pasts; “wI1ié’:’z’ {:i$;.i’si t).r17a ‘pféscri.bed period of

s€3z’v_iTC”c?fLn_aa?.{0Lz:§3f~«_p()s£ or €Xp€I°i€?1C€ in a posz,
“}:>r{§fs2sS£o:1’«.€:rV :<';c;:i1:pa,i;ior1 as a qzzalgffcatioréz or
eligi-?:43iAl1'i.;_,v."' . "

4»§..j; ‘V 55; c.afe£:’a,;§&Vre21d:ng of E:h:r;::’p}:e1’1e1:.::§xre C’1feamj; L.:1}r€s§° P<:§cj~; ii"? 'EW{} atiéass-:~$e5~s sf

p{é:";–'s<3:v"–1's$ {E5} :23 €§imc%i. §"EE{§§'1.E.ié.ZE1€E":{. and £19 §}€,":;'~3'§.§:"~. azshiaéh irgsiséi. an

V A.3:-_p:'i-:é§::?:"%%:sec§. §é:':§i0€§, :3? 9–5<%z"2,:*§<:e: in 21 Em. §3<:e§».vé;. :3}: {2} is £§§1'."tZ'.'(.','{",

. , as-3-. L§.11.:i;e1.";: A.

84

recfllitlnerlé anti to posis ‘~.-x.-‘hi1’C;1″.i .,.€t?§5 a

qzzaiification or eligibiliiy. Themfore, the i111.é:I._1I.i0I1″iés~it§i€a1′–;_ 1r1

the Case of direct recnxitmeni and {O p{3_’7.-3’€’:’)»..’;T3.€3I’i€)f’f1″0bf

S@.1″x-‘ic:c~: in a lower past. is 21 qua1iI’i(jation’o;” e:_>31 is a C1L1a1IiE”i_£:2i!._i0:r1. than”theygi:i<.oi1't_0{'
the New Com 1'€her1s1'v€: Créa1.t1i'3{ La ?€'r' Policv' .A1ineX'u:'s¥

11. If those two conditions ism: HE}-9:, p:iesc1’ib’t:C1_f0:* eé1i1gibi1i.1y than
the candidates who i’a_I.I”w:,3nc1.Ve1′ _G-:”eLr3 in the service of the

Govemmezzé; or holds an Public Secter fall

withizfn thc “CC_-1’eaii1y–.L§£13?er_P$3i.iLty anci am not eiltfiled [0
res€:1v9;i:iuoi1.A

50,- , Efiittzrgfirefi-§zg.’ 1.%:is pmvisiosa, the Tribmlai has heéd

. _ Gatzergmzezzi Grder giaisszi. 3€}.3.2QQ.,;’2 in
{1} has {fiearigg :°z.af<3oZ am: {he appi€cff.§; <33"
irearzzy La;/.;r pr2yz,sa%r€§c2i.:’zg {E28 .: <2?" é?}f§}Qf§€f§'E{T8 as; :2

£g:.:caE{,§%{:a§.ia}:'z <g_,f'eZ§g§b:'§i:§;, 'E"!"1;<3u§;?": 3'25) :~:§}ec;;'fz'<;*. periaéi

5*

85

Qf service is prescribed, in order to become
{“0 apply as can irvserzaice caizdidatge the Czfi?.;i’Ci€«>f.i_t§Lf£t’f’:. ~ ‘
must” have put in some service anal” Picfl s?j;:o.::L’lc1A T
Continue to be in service to }:,«e”‘e£ig’ibZéf’§ £II?1V(‘3″‘:”éidfifi ‘
{:0 be an in-service ca{7,;:1_{date; ‘ Me:>reiy 1bs§:35.1Vi’Ls&€2 rig.”
deffinitze period Q!” servic&:..L {.ii’V.cxpéf£erj_C::3_ V bu},
it’: does not: n_rzea.r1 ~__I’h~;{ pér£~:0n_ ;;§ii’hoLL£’
experience or tiuilli b%3CQ:7.1é”.<32igible. In {he
circ:umstance3, 2'2: is that aniy a.

person wfze_ is V’ sefijice and who
con{::int;:es _i.}2 2 S€i._I*i,’i;CtL’ will become
€iigibxleff:.’._V:»V’ ._ ,_ _ . ..

$1. “”” of the ‘F1’ibur2a1 it was
COI1iZ€:I””id.f;’ld” i,hatV,V in question is Soieiy for the in-
serfice {€a:;§i.r:1aVi.Ve§s.”i:i. qu;é;%.e3§:i.0n. The’ref0r::~:. {E23 first cendiiieza :0

be gfiecified is §’i€ I’11L1″:’:a1i1 $6 in service an {:16 Ciafg he makes an

A22g;:§}V§i{€.éi:§afE.,A ‘E’§’i€:§””*;?€231. ‘£7516 22.§3p§§.s::2-‘zéiiarfa {2£ ‘E\E::}£.€

V .={}T;”Viz:-.gé;:<:§':Vapersoié. Ruie E ;’i<:a§E}; gmiezs it wiii not

'*a;§3pij; £{;7.£.ir€i%::7:. :"::':7'r:.:i¥;.':":2::%:':%;' am? 31:; ;§}<}s;és~; Whia':h §§'2§«;%;;<~:§"2'. GET} '3} 2:

§}:*E::S<_tz:.i.'@eté""pa-riad sf s<'3:'*».ri<:t": in 2;. ism-'{;=:z' pas? £33' (2% :":~x'§3e':"iem::@ in

g

86

a post, p;’0feSSic)n or occupatimi as 21 qL121i’if’iCai.i0n (>i’e1igibiEii3f.
Mezfciiy ‘zaectamse 21 pei’S<m is in S€I"ViC€ he is 110i'. e1ig_ibi_§=3~..§.0–._appIy
to the notified post. He nmst be in service,

{he 1'equ'i.s1'.*L€ quaiification prescribed L1nder~t"::<c

52. Rule 5 of the Karnatefiia I;’é;i%3’1ic ‘wor1_{s :«i1§’;;:;1%:1e;~::;g ”

Depa’rt,ment, Services
Engineers Division} igy Rules, 200′?

p}:’€S3CI’ib€S the fc)1i<3x*L*iV1'1"g–_€..V::i;1._1afific;V;§tV{d§1_'L§:}{E3'; ::i:1.i.gibie £0 appiy for
the pasi. af Assistarai lDi:.vis.ion~ 1 :«~

V ' academic qualification of
VV gc1i'¢ciiVcit1_ViV;_c;z_,§{_;. E«I;fEr;::'person 2,912.0 has armined the
2I ;.ge%a;~s not ai;i§ir2.ed 40 years in the

' " t'3£IS€:" of. ;._:faVf1dicETaI.es belonging :0 the Scheduiezi
E"{:QSV'i'f;'fS,1!SC?;ié5iLZE3d 'fr:'besfCa£~E; 38 years; in Case

_ :'§::;N§.ida{'es beimlging to cafegery 213 ,5 28/ 3A ,/ BB;

V in case 9;)" am; <:2§.§:er <:ana'.€::£az'e.;<3 as; an {fies
..__Ec2L:~.:-i «€IE.<:z£e fi:<r reaeipi <3' app§.iCaE'z'z’:1E.e::€ zhaii §.??_{3§’€ 1’5; rm m{7::a::’m:.::21 §:’m:’z’.

for cc:r2€E.ida.§.s35; C{>::zp€§,i:25;; amgfm in ssszvigre agzmia.

87

Candidates Inns: be h.0id.er’ Qf a I3egr(3a2;

Civil Engirleering or Consm.zcz:’ion Tc3crI1.nj(§1c)g,*iV.,i_*-. ‘
Man.agemer1t grarlred by (1 Lfrliversiiy T
by Law in India cmd f”‘om an I1″:.:;!:1fi’z1i’€;’ a;3V;f}f:é::.:’cViV lay}.
the AICTE, or a Diploz’na -._Ce1I’I§f?Cdt;¢a j;f€j’:fd {h§
Ins£’1’mi:’ion. 0f Erzgirleerg {1rIdia)’– he
Parts A 8:, B Qf fhczi ‘”‘Assoé1’.a.t¢ ‘v.;’\xI{er}V§i;é?}?s”}1i;p

Exami.na2f.i.on. Qf the Ir1si’iI’jz.z.i{0:2 _Qf’i,E§ngi.r1e¢>r:_; {Initiia}.

53. No doubt £’;h’€:_T ‘1’ett:r;%i’1t5;3’1e;}i is ‘a,d.i1fect I”€C1″1Eii1I1€Ei’ii..
Any p€E’S{31’1 u{E}.V€)v__is é1i’t}z”ésa.ici q’L’1a1ific21’Lion is
eligible i.o:.3;:p1_y’i o.’i11é gziid-V.pc>:.~itT.f;1\s is ciear fmm the albresaid
}}’I’bTu’VV’€,X’p.31″i€I”1C€ in a goat/p1-efession er

0ccL1pe1tioL:*;:..is”pre9_R¥’ri’beC§~-‘as q:,1aIifia::a1.i{>n 0;’ eligibility criteria.

‘ . E3’4;._ 2 in o:*CIe’f°{.dé1§}p}*€:’esai{§ GS’£»’f:’I’f’1IE1{3E1§. ariietr

‘eg.,r}ié:TiV “h¢;:s “iv53_ _b€ 366:1 £226 provisi:”:.e: s:?{>m;a,i:”:e& in {he

E:;1E”r:21i.;}kg’:—-_. “Public ‘%?\Frk5s §:ir1g§i:1@sé:’i12g; Uf:’§,}£1§”‘EIE”i€§E§ 8é:*rviz’;. Q’-:=’i£:.

{§{{%{:£°:;i€1;:12<3:1%.} Ruécssg, EQSS. R;u§:": 2 pm%:'§c§€és§ "%'.%::% %:':'a§::'EI'w{§ 0?

81

NO.

XX

5

Category
Of post

XX

Assistant
Exectu ‘Live
Engineer

Divisioni

88

Method of r€C1″u1’Lmer1t

Xx

Severn five er Ccifit bis « &_
Y P V 5/
pr<3mot'i{sI1 from 11:15: <:2?;.'dr.€.T'

of A333 stani; E:3gine'c{rs;* . _
and "I'WentyVper. cent i-)3;

direct I’€C?1’L1i[.§”I~1’§3.:I”i~T, in
accordance with: the. u
Karma mka }Pu”{)’1j.C _\?V0i*1§_S
Elngineeiéng -‘_De;;.a rtmeVI1″t. %

Service ‘ (VR€C’f’EE1iiVi’}T3;EI1T.’ 01′ » V’
VAss1s1aVnVL EX€Cj.1tEV’€’ “~ ‘
f Engmems; ‘E:}i\z’.ISiQ’1-‘1’-E ‘
‘ in pé3.i.it;i=ivc “iEIxé1r;1Vi:I;1;:’ti 0.11)

.’ ‘R._.u;!es,._1$:3’TI3;

Ffiivf: p._<§1'<.:é'11i by direct

rE*7cfu'i1§iI1. é13tfrorfii ameng

V , ;3¢:~s;gnsT{1Vn sezvice}

' ,bVc-1f0:1'i;:3' Karr1at.aka

PL1b1ji_<i x;x;.o;~:ێ
for dirétcril rt;=:::1″L1:Ei’me:1t’ in

In fact afier the    "1'ribu;:1a1, th€
G0ve;m_n'1ent     They are not

Complete. It is not in  A'   
senioriiy/gradation list of'     b€it1g