High Court Karnataka High Court

Karnataka State Road Transport … vs P G Geetha on 30 March, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Karnataka State Road Transport … vs P G Geetha on 30 March, 2009
Author: H.Billappa


‘°%”%§%+a §%§;;”‘?£z %§ féégfi 2,;§$.’%”?3{E} 8? ?%s§:f Ra’: a§a§§§:§?;._:%”:a

gzzégmefii am §%;¥ara? saieei Efififiéiéfié §a$$ed4v§r:_:’-.:?~g§’L?_Q
§’s§$«23’2.§$§ 3:’: 3% féia S? 3% ”9: Aééé Ssméé €$a,33:&:t$_ §§:§{§§§ %

§:%fi$’?, Eamgaéargg {SSCH §%éa.2}§ awarfiérag §::€f%§:: &?3§$f*.3:%<.§':fs_T"A_

:2? R$,2,32,§%§§» wééh §%'fi%%'%%$ 3% '?%%.a gay

ffézés ?«§§§~%% $%§?"%§%°'E§ ?§§" 3&3?'-af:.§s3%§§§; d:ay5:_":§¢.&.,V§'éu§f€'.

éeiézserad; {fie §@%§m%;?:n§:-

3 Q §k%..;”;&_&%}§§ ?~é ‘§-” fi

“§’%*;§§ aggeaé ‘{§%:*%@f§?$é_”Aa%§.a%;é$:A 352$ géééfégivvsézeaé 3:26:

awgsfi éaéaé €f§}?;§»2Q§§é{; ;:s;&$ §$§e»§ ;?*g%3?aC”§”§ §§§éga.%::§*a

2:: x

“2:-_ ‘t;§*;% *§:?:’§ “i?é*::;2::§5’€%:;g–:*;:….§v:;%£§§:*§§n% 3&5; §’%§’§%’é, Efig
‘?z:§:;:.?;a:; %:r:a2::§%§ags::g:s%%a:g§;;§%::gaa§a:: gi §s2,325:::aa::» vg%%%’a

%;?”‘§i$?€$§ ?*”*?.:g ;r§:’ ;a§%::%.:s’%2”:; frgm 2% figée sf §%%;%%%§:*; %%3%§ fie

–::§?3§:a .3? ziagscgéég ….. .. v

5.J’VV’v:%;’§§§%§2s%é fig? iézé ag§§a%§§;2°:%«§§:§m*§é%§fi

“E233 fiééeé %-frzég gggeai

:% Es’: iyiéaf, fig §a:’::i$ 35$? iha %”§$;{3fi%”‘¥;§%?%§
gajigéaégzeéfi %:’:§a;:”§$$ ‘:2’: ‘:?§”2§ §$$%§e§’*:i: ‘%:’:’:;§§ §::2:a:§?§§ $2 *2§»~§~

‘%%§§ 3% amasi égiié, ?:%%%” Eéaéégaafiggééss gr: §$f$§%.,§?’%% 352%

V,

7.4-«.3

k

§’§$§”2 352$ ;*”%%§§%§$f%i §§”§’a:§::’:§ $3? $333 ::~:;:§; ? %a:i:’2§ ?2§s*:,;%{§«§§»~§–«

3

“s$2f3% in ¥g%:%g%: $3 Y€&pm_deo_«Eé:§§ éfaézeéééagk “?%”‘:§i.’¥¢é._g3b~rndentL#

sigameaf sfimgéggaiéafi sf ;%.~:7.é~;5.}{3§€éé’:*%f-,

aiaasazfieé $Q§’E’E§€§38§i%%§’§ af §$.2§3};2.i’%.{€3 §:!~ ”
gig’ /. . . V _ .

5′ ,5′-*’a§§:’%@%;a§ iiifié =3;;:f$a%V§>f;eé:%2§ii:-§§fé’§°§:;~é§’at%@§éV’V
@353 fééafi €?:%$ aggeai; ‘ ‘ A E

“§”%%s>; §§az*§’:£s§_ L'{:’$3a§’§”%§i.$§ ” €:%%$= a§§§§%§§’%%»~

;;@§§§:3*§%€;{§~v:s’:;§fg§%3:2§e_£ %:§:§”‘:?::;i?E.§F§5?%$&§%a?2 awaségé 33%;’

fig$75′:%§;;§%aT§’._%$;%s£.:§§.:é”:e§§:::a§ %x§§:’:3% §§ §”2%§%’:§%g %K$%%§§i:’*%
32$ %i§*:..§:*&%?$r%’-2;.. §é’~«.’::5§2’§:A§%”if& Sééaifiifififi 33%;. Eéia 3&3

§;:’?;::rg§*:%%:;§.V%§za;%:’ §’§”§§{Z2§”‘E§E§§”3§ figs ;”;%§’§;’:§§§$%§ maéésgi $323 %$

_ iii? fiféé §§”‘:§§%i§ Q? $353, $53 ?r%§a.:52§§

a $13??? a? §$:%,%$§§S;”~ §§%”£§§’fi$ széaéiagai

‘;:%X§%;._§*:f’a»iaé.zs:~; i?€§”%§$§’§ E3 %fii§§§*%;5 Efifififféfii 3?E€ &§’$$ $:;%%”:§%.°’§§§

.. ,i§%%a%%”‘$§§%%é§a2%: 33%’ éagég 2% “‘§s°§?::::.::’é§§ ééag. §%§*«§§?§$§ a gag??? 3?

V’ ‘-?;§,§§§%§§§;”-» %:*s2:<;§:§"§§ fé§$§§§§§§§}<*' gm? €;%22§a§§§'§; %% §"°%%§§§ its ge

mfifiéfégé.

L/

‘ET 533 a§a§s%$% Ehésg §’;§”é€ §§a:::g§ $§a:§:$e§ %§:_:° éw

:e:$§a§:§§:”:%. §:2§:”::§i’*:&§ $25: 232% ‘§§§b:s:*:g§ a$j”‘*’;*:;é’?;f:;:{;’>$:§’

$§%”%;§§§éf§’%§$§’§ @% ?§’%§ §”‘§’§§§§§’§&§ 3:”; gresegfi %§a$–«.4$§%kga€sI§§g€’

aszé zeagemabée aamgaagaééfigé i::–$;&?:§.g §”:f:e§_§:$é%’3v§e::s<§i§a§f%;$e?':a';

332$ fiéfizahéiéiy am :s§e:e§m§ £3 §ae;:;m:; :T:g§§ §s:%%z;%.e:*§e::§'zm«e*,k ,

%-Ea aéss szgésmgfzaé €543: t;?::%:::§§§.vLf::';*%;g :'§$§§s.:§%;ai§£:s§:j'%::é$ §%§§é;§e§ V

meéémé bééég is $313 €:,:*:;& Q? _§$(€§§V?V;{,*:f3§.5~ i'§°%§'73:fé§:,2§:§% figs

gafiggmaaé §§'%§"§f g sag?" '"§az:%s'a§'é$ ::%é§$g%

exgensag 353$ .§§%g§§%$i§$, :§%§;:3a-3[";'*':§:':,+§_;..;g;V§g¥§§ §j"{:%* égzéagfgraaae. E-is

§§$§ $éé§7.?%§%'3§fi£€;"§v.*?;§'%$§'i'%%$~.§'{é:§.§;T:°?%§$%"'%'§ has §é§fi%s""§§ ;§€§"'%'£%§"§@?§§§
aé%$a= %§§%gsL§*f%;fC¥§%é _§?'2:§ §:%2}éj;gf£a§"'& 2% "§":'§§ma§ mg a*¢;§?é§§? &

R$.§€%,'{,3§§;'~ ?§.:::%e;§§d$ fiéaaééfiigs am %:%§e:&;%:*§, éi figs

. 1 mi 353$;?::s§j§':2%§rf$§8;:5&:

S1. ‘% mafg $§?’%?i§§§§? aggzgéaiaesefi $373 §:s%§*§:%$$»§§§’:$

:*:”;§d5Ea~:.V;?:é*y* ‘iéég éggyzwé $§%.§%’%§$§ 2%? 2% ggfiéeg’

Q “?§é8 §:3§;:’*:£ éézgéi gzgag far my €3€§§”$$§§€f§€§§§”E ég

?%*:§é§3§:* fig £§%”?%§%§§S§%’§z3§”‘% §:»*a:’as’§e§ $3: §§”§$ Tiéfiagzéaé %ms=;§§’§$

§*§”:§§%<:§§ fifiégfififfifiéfi 23$ §§§§§§§§"§'§f safis §@s" §?'§§§§'§%§'"§%"%$%':'

'E3 ii §'E'§%°*£§§'%§ is 33%? 3% "%""?%§:;z':&% E233 §_'*z,%f§§'§§§

'- 7

E 33?: g? $3,': 4%; §€.§§,fw ?.;§¥'é&§'§$ mafiésai e"::f

53:53 33% ms §;*””S§L§$$§.§ :?:&a%§$»a.%..%§§§:§

§i$fa,£:?,$§s§§~: ‘§”%’2§ °’§§°§§:;:”2§% “a’::2;a§’:_€§:fi.

;%:§;§§:${§§§’«» §§%”€%§’§$ :*s*é%*§§’g.g;% eE”;.:%1_2’*2:*.;r2%$.v-._ §’éa:*§:&%:’E~’

$§i§E””%$€§ fig: §1§”%%:’% §§%;%;;£2:§%§€§€V.V:?;::,%.::§§:$a$ vséséafi is éaiaiéig

§s”::%;%§§§e£%:f T”?;:§2;::$§§ 3%? §’%§§S$§”%i§$?3?; ggégfiééiéaé

ff-£233: .€:;§% zé:;$§.;%:::s’:%;é§:*:i Egg ;;§a§:,;§§<.§ maééaai Esééég its

3% €525 "§:%;'3a§§%§% hag $%*£%?§§§ 33%? 3

..%:';;':§%§§§§§»a ifivgagég ':"%'§§§§$§§ %X§§§"E$%'*i$ §§"'§§

' é%:g§.a§:é':9§;; ii; figag mi 33%? éef %§"2%%§";'%:'%§2m_ §'s£&?'1 §$$%.,%§"§'E§?%§

%?'~;::%;§_ :%*:§ §"%$§§§"%§§§"§§., ézag :§§*$§zs::;%§ meéésgi éiiéa 2% 2&5 ?;'a.§§";%

32%? 33% _2§,E§»§:'« $3 afiisieafigfi: fig 3% §§a:r§:§«§ izaamggé

%§' $23 ggggééaaég iééafi 32%, éééas a$:"§2§§::$§%%::::2 gé

§1'%$f§é§s§§§5~ §%?£§?§§§§ fig fig "§":°%§a;:2a§ :§z:§a:"a*§$ mgdésaé

V

axgfizzaég is ééigi arsfi gga-$53 §?§'*£%f'3§ zegfizé :3

iggaémgné éaézefi $3; %§*:%s :°e§§$§'*:§§§':%, fififi :féé'e}§

53%? 33%! $3? §::§§rfa;r%§z$§_

E? ""§"'%*;% T%"§§}é..é§"%§§ §§}?:$ a*»;;a5{§é':?%; a SE32f'§';3§t§%S§=§{?4,§§5§§%=

iawarég d§$§§§§§§'§;i "€39 ;{§:'2§%<:s§ %2a§..:%:a;*z%::gef:134 fig? ?§'%§

:%$§@§';§e:":?: $38 gag???'-"é£%;§ §%«$?§%§'§%%§,:}f :%§"E:%f§ ,2§% " '?'%':$ "§§%§3:,:§:§§
$233 £223: aaeegtgé éhés, $3 €§é?*§'V:*§§:–g«:3é'é;–:[_%:§f§i§ ég 57$ sags fag"

{fig E$$%§';$5"'§"§$?§§ §§?€§{ §<:~'5a:§« é§%%'.f;%f€§$§ §;§%'?'%;§%?':S§€E§G?% 3%

%3..§s;"fs;é'%%ii,';%§.:T-s. ' %:§*:2:f:§;° The ?§$§§?E§%§”%;’§,’ 5&3
$i§§§’§$?%i3?’§”§%¥§§?;,}5’w 3§v:”:ffii'”‘?::a%g’i%%::I%;*;§ §”%§;3:’$ éa *:;?*:% :3

WWW

‘V %§*:§?:2%%;._V$;*%é.,_§%::§§%%%%§ §:.§f%§;’§::fi, ér: 5:23; Qggrza—%§a:§:*°§§ :.s%$%’:z: Eéég

§fié?§??§=$§%*i§;’%§53$§§ §;2*;§§’§$é $35 ‘§§'””%§ ‘§”z%§:;:§§% ?’:§’%飧%’§$ ééggfiééy $3

aw»

giegfigé’ 3:32;; %?2e;§f$,§’%, 5 §:::% mg: agé fa!

.. _§fi%a§’?e§§§§§§4

“%”%2a:g is :33 zrzegéé Es”: 353:3 aggegé 332$ ézgggssa ii is §§§%§§

L’/..

is M f;”§§§??E§.$$§§.

fig s§–é$$@§%?”€§§’§, ii §%§:z”:%§§§§§

TEE gm :.::§§§@$%% $%z<¢:%% m ifanggzééééefi as

"'%"§*%b:.:§. Efar ééamgsgménig Qfifigg éa fiéyeaiafi se§é_;1:§1i-';:;a:*:§~::.' L.

%'€§é';3E°§Sg

$33.