High Court Karnataka High Court

Karnataka State Road Transport … vs Virupaxshappa Demappa Mindolli on 9 September, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Karnataka State Road Transport … vs Virupaxshappa Demappa Mindolli on 9 September, 2008
Author: Subhash B.Adi
  '  

...... W..." W Mmmmm mun t;x,.au;t'r or mmnmm HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT o:= KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or xAmAm<A mew c

IR was HIGH CfiURT BF xnxmamkxn AT aAxQALeRE ".

aawzn Tazs was 3th HAY as snrwmuann 2QQé : ff'v

EEFDRE

THE Hbfi'BLE MR. JUSTICE sufiaxaa 3..ah:T_: V=x

R.F.wa.25ex2o¢aV7-A
.222: 5′

w.p.§o.13e15fsi%a%xsRT¢i* i”‘
atwfinul: H ” ‘ K ”

1 Efifififfififi sways mean_T§amsPonrv:a3PoRxwxmw
3? I?$ Mamnaxws n2R£c?nR.fl- V._v
gawwnaa Q¥fISES,EH 353353 asap j
sanfiwzahfiaagfaamfifibeaz 2?}. V
REP BY ITS CEIEF tar DFFI¢ER=
xsxwc caxwagp 0nF1cE5,’aamgALsRz–27

2 wafi nAfi#$iwQ_fi1RE¢Taa, maxra WEST
xakflafiaxa Rc33_¥RA&s?Qa? c0aPoRATIax
aoKuL_aaan,,Hu3L;”,_=*

3 was azvisinmaa éanfénaank
xsawfi Bsasaafiwflxvxsxow

_£” THE_E$ViSi¢fiAL ccwwnmauza
.,”x$RTcjc3Igxnn1 DIVI$ION
‘ i:€}’¢’»§.IP§’ ~ EIS’!”P.1C’I’ . . . F-‘ETITIOISRE

tag 3}: vxsaaxawu Afl8QcI&ESE, anvacamaaj

Afiifl t”«

‘a_ L’1} ¥iR§9Ax3HAs?A BE§A??A.MIHBDLbI

7 ESE ?3 YEARS
RETE aa 28f@2f199fi A3 TC EAILHDRGAL
BEPQT Gfi BELGAEM
2;: H’fiG. sséxiia, 3333 sannam maxuxxss
EAELHHHGAE B13? BELEAUE

mu COURT OF KARNA’l’M£A H361-i OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA I-iiGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH C

E1 ‘J :3:-mmvnm

FUSE EBGUT 56 ‘t3’EF:R3

RETB. DN 31f3./93 AS ‘I’.€3.

SIRE LHQNEAL ESFGT, EELGEJ-\l’.3M I}I’U”I$ICJN
Rfffi H.E’3G.1932,. TA{:Pait’?cR3’3ALizI,
EJHLHOWQRL

BEST: BELEAW!

E 3 MEBAR

A53: “:2 YEARS

as-rs. ma 31i5;92 AS ‘3’

EM bananas BEST: BEz.s5.’=.Ur6=.. ‘

;:,.is :s.se’3u=:.n.3:1:;::.m;,:£,,. H.b3GA..1«7_$’1\_
Bmbaatesha, nI$’1’:__”1?+;_ELé2;=xL3:s:V ,

A 3 znyxvm – _ .

ASE: 52 was 1 .,
RETE. are :z:::2x¢5;;»*9ru5,=:_ Ag ..H.m*r .:1:z1;.{;:éizma
ie*’@RmH::3§.,’«..,B5f_{;G._3t..;*.!~s’« _ j. V

P%.,é”Q

3 2;~’:.:’m.:f::?e _

ASE: as ?aAR5*, ._ , ._
RETE.’DH’31f??2fi?9?%3_CGRDUCTflR
£a:xx3nz_H$2Q?[= “gO*’

RES ELK, caLaw¥,’c3:xxmn1

aims’: BEVLQADMVO’ ‘

– “A 1:: iflaffannan “”” ”

» “~Ai3E.:fi?$
V 3.s*::sOsg’.:»2.;m:; «._£3′:».:. sifiizizim AS T.C.

._ EC-‘§_;$=.§’3}{;’$”§fIk?1?’i3§;’I3fi0T, mm
‘E3; EELQILIJM

3 :11? MAT’?-Ob {J , 3&
:31 ~3’r::*;. BE Laxms

V ?”~«.£;aELHe*;=¢4}ct

‘-:=gf.;:E: 5.5 ‘mam

REM. r::::r«z sazlafaa As Hm? Cfiilvflirfiiki DEE)?
T 2231*: asnsam

Rffi »3″I§3E!=3BE?x !~1IV?:$,. BIG E
HEEBCQ E-‘.’.'(3£:G2€’:’

E331 IQEIEIBI 53$’?

BE Eééfixiifl

Mn ‘I-JUNK! w mmmmm mum u;ux’I or mmamm man com”: or MMMAKA men COURT or KARNATAKA may (mm or mmnmm HIGH ca

19

1E

11

“-%’BCKfl£KARfiI

$ $ 8 EIREHATH
ASE: £5 YERRS
EETB. Qfi 3$f4f§9, AS T C
ZHKKKSEI EEPQT,
R/Q Eflfilfififififififi, CHIKKDDI
313?: BSLGAEM

S M aawxn

A53: 10 ?EAS

315?: EELGAHM, CHIKKUBI n;#:sIos’, uA.
EEG EEAREHHRERR, H}N3.4869;,fiIflRSUSIaT’
mg sxfimxgawnk, n:$r; BEL$A&flE ‘ *

agva. an 3af9!§5 AS T.C(’33HKESH?ER.BEP§

X’ K 2%

AGE: M mamas — _ 5 ‘
RETE. am 4:12:99 A3=T;c; SIT? EE?QTVfiG.3
ggggggn ‘*x . 3 i V? %V 2 ”

:-am :v4:!rLr:;b«.§E2m.. “:3; i’3’£*¥I«Ki}¢:{3BI .,- ij
3231*: BEE£§,.%Lf1″3’5v ” “— 5 I

5-; 3 :*»::i.a.:’:’1’=::ta»’2=~..B’3::, V.

ASE: . _’

§e.E=m.. ms’ 31’ff§f§;a~._w.4a’*L3?,T’ _£.’;’E-‘1’IKK9DI 13:»:
EI§LGAf..T.B-S _

E56 H.me; sax, sA:nha£LLz

Efiffififlfll, §IST:”EELSRfiM

. $113-E: $1=.’:*2s.fi.m

“&_R£?E; awV3i{i;92 As T.C.

, 16

‘§<::¢;::EP<z" ~§_£Ié;::r~::'," §'£°:§.?'ERI,. HUBLI 3!?!
RF? HIR:IG£LLI
:«:.réa.1–.9;2.3V," cmxxonz, mam BELGALIM

'E ,1; mm
;=a:s2:«. «Ea mm

vgsvsg 9% 31/1×95 As assw. ACCT Ksawc
fifibakfix 3%., Baasaux

._W"_§fQ RJAMEERR, FLU? fifi. 11

3 $3333, BEEGRHN

3.3 fiflfiflfifil
E53: 5? YERRS
RETE. 3N 31f5fQ5 £5 T.C. EAILHDNGAL DE?T

1:5:-1 COEMT OF WKNAVRKA H§®H OF i(fiAR§iEATAKA H58?! COURT OF KARNATAKA mm-4 CODE? OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNAYAKA HIGH C1

15

15

1?

313?: Bfibfiflfifl
R33 IHCHEL, TQ: SSUQHRTTI
313?: EELEAUH

3 1 mmmmm
ms: £3 was
an-m. an 3¥3f§f2f§E:!1 AS *r.c.;’BA1L-2-19:;
flE?QT; BELGABM fiIVISIQN ‘ ‘1
wag maxwxmnnz
I-§.{=33.3#5fA, aA1r;.Hc:24an.L.-‘

313?: fiELQAflM

2 R xnanxnn ,
A35; 61 mm 5 ,
FETR. ms 2§fEf94,”‘AS-A}331_I”ifER ‘-
anzummaaan 3390? *V_ 7′: ;av*;;_»
Rm 3ua2=a::sI*ar:=’:.-a–s:=zs;.’2=a.::=:””G’a.–£aLI. 1:;-.._::r>.es.,§
§n1L§mwGAL;anxsw:_Eguanfim wj._W;

3 B cHRxhBE,'”‘ »-,.

ASE: aa»xEa3_ _« *Ia_ ;

RET§;”c§f31f3£§6″AS-?.Q;~”
2A2LH3NaAngngPoT=_’a ‘
BI3?;’3E&GAfifi*,’;.’ _

axe xgyranaamrcannxsxnn magma

I cnagat aazuamsanpg 315?: asnann

aim xzT?3R”»

‘ ‘ … . . . . . .. ‘V
‘«&3?g; as 31;3;a1 As BRJVER

‘_gmfigaawrz,a3F0w, asasnnn ya

“xxx: “z~zfi;_=e.1§. ‘E-“‘.EL’3’ER E-ICIUSE

‘QgAzLE$m@aL , nzsr: EELGAUM

a _-‘£3

E S fi3REJKRR

n,fiEEf”§fl wanna

Earn. :35; 2s’e;*2.:’r::4 as ART mwrc

“fi3fififlRTTI DEPOT, Efibfififl fiIVI$I3N

K33 mmwasz BBESfl

253

T EECHRLF TQ: SBUBER?T3

EEST: EEEGRHH

3H? MEHAEEVI KHR1
fiffi QETE BHIHEEH Gfififihfifififl KHRI
ESE: £1 Ygfikfi, RETfl. fifi 31/fiffifi

sag ff V

un wuuunu um” mnmvmgmmn mun uqmm OF KARNATAKA H!GH COLERT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA H36?! COURT OF KARNAYAKR HIGH CI

21

24

as

‘3″.i3. SiI3EJI3§1)§’P’3’T. Z3EF$’1″,

§E€.s§}’£§3¥4 E, Rffi 3.31. PUJAR
I-$1.?-353.29, PQLIIZE QUAREFERS

E*?iE..F-fit. ?@;?§’?-KR RG33}, HUE};I-?9

£3 E PATIL AGE’; 52 YEIKRS

EE?§. aw zaxzxgg as ASST. ER? – A,
Ef:’¢ELG=.r’%f.’5M RURAL DEPCPT, EELGKQM
R39 &Ax31HAsAE, V canss 2992 1
Kax?1, Ta: 323?: agnsauax ‘

E3 3 §i3RTP«.3(KI
ESE; ’58 YERF5

REE. ma 3016!§5 §S=T.cL’5:nsa¢fi,nnRA¢”‘”

EEPST, 523.1, EE&Sm”M–. .

3.30 H.:»Io.244, UFPRRCRLL-I 1
Kfikfifififi, 5EE5AHx,””‘ ” “‘

% 9 X3fiARE3. ,1_:_ . ,u ‘M
agz; $1 ?EA33V”*.”w5,’»__ 3>v
F:.E’}*D. are Esififizcas As’-n;»>:Iv’sR
£s’§~n=.R.u?;v:;§”J’EI¢;$:-:7, ‘*§2::.1.B’L~: “nI*u’1?s7u:;b:
aft: §:3§«s;«.hrJ3.R?£%faj*I?.§aI;«.A.3.&-317:5; £31521
xzwwwa BIS?:_BE&ERfiH4_”_

zsm am5;_ m:<:;u==1=».n. E szmmnmn
P&E£:E;$' }" RETE3. "LC. BEIEHIM Eb}
:«:..~*»:::; asakmmvgm, Q rczmm

' '» EI3T:%§E%6fifl """ "

Uags; §1′?ERR3

F;.’5fE’B. e:>.r«:’V:i;::z}’x:,e’a3 as *r.:::. mum-m mm
as-z€;;,=.z;:r;’r::T;.v
FLJXZS im*~::§.s.’.?1é, tmmaasmax

‘ ..$:;3:m}.:;~ BEST: EELGAUH

:i3*» 3 Lw$*TAR

‘ass: 53 ?EAR$

V’ .._..§?’.E’3’E.. ma 31×3;’Q1 as J3.%’3′. *z=.1.

S${3E£=1§S.’}”‘?I

gzzfiwz’, EELGAQM EIVISIOH

zzrxa sammsm :;:a.:..:.1, E-I.!~3£2i.212’2
51.33:} Exiffiifééfiab, B133′: BELSAEIM

EGH COURT OF l(ARN&”¥’m{A HIGH OF KARNATAKA REG?! CQURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATQKA HEGH COUR? OF KARNATAKA E-HG!-E C1

2′?

E8

29

30

H R Efifignhfl

ASE 51 $3333, RETB aw 29302304

as BR1VER.BRELHONQAL BEPQT,E3LQAUH

sin aAQwn§ canwan 1-:

H;§6.54§, BAlLHBfiGAL 215? Baasaux *.
B 3 aauuaxz 1″”

M33 69 mans
RETB an 31z@3:95 as T c nnrnacgean \W –

naraw ea ssnsamn RIG 5fiIK3fiAK_cHAwL;*f; ‘}’

2-3. am: . 5″I”2f’A, EA: LHSNGAL
BEST BELEABM ‘w

an? 317×333 H10 aE?E Fsmacaamgfia M sAfiART
Rfifi ea YERRS “”;.’ 3} ‘p”n’»

RE?E on 3Q!&§f92 – _ 5 2 .«_v.}_.

A3 A Macaxflza, aI?§afi: 3339? 1 a”

Bfibéflflfi REE 9:FEa:fig.Rnnn” f._ j
$E§RXEfi$GfiR5f–;~ % ; »’* “W

Efiafihflfi ” “”

@ A EETA$3RQHE?H”» =

REE £1 ¥EAns,*.%-,’a_ ‘;
RETBva§428302391=as=n@m¢mRBaJLHuxwL
BE 3*? EEL’£3.f.E’=Eu_R;’–S’-

Kunanxfsgz, xx??§§,,:asr EELGAU

$«§ fifi3fiHfifiI*.M _____ H
Ps§E 157 ‘f’3.zI’\RS

.A f;;<2:3;*r2:x__r;:.§s:–21s~;.sf:32;9e7 AS 'r c: GDKAK mm-Jr
*_";a2xgapx'e§;nIsT asaamun
~.E£$ ?REA§fi$?I, rm saumwnvz

'ngsw gangnsn

E?» 3'! *~

uass $5 vzaas

V RE"§?fi CEJ!*1fi£1C'}'f3R SELEREEM CIT? BEPGT Q}

szzgssaxzaez 1:;_.:'0 nmmmm, mg sawnmw

'g2:§? 3353503

A *3' iifizffifib, }§$E 32' YEARS

REE? fiti 31fQ1f%2 AS '1' E E33-'KE.1'a'C B390'?
f3§-§I1¢I)€32:BI HE-I, BELGPLEJM

Rf? TTI, TQ 3¢

315? Efihfikflfi

M. ………u \-Fl' nnnnwmwtnfl Blur! wmga Ur mxmmm Ham comm' or KARNATAKA HIGH counr or nm.mAmm HIGH count or mmnmxn mm: C

34

35

36

3?

B S GHflTQE

REE 5? YEHRS
RETE fifi 3GK04f§? AS CQNDUCTGR SIKSI

EEFQT E K Rf? LIKGEERLLI POST
BEhV%fiZ TB Efilbfiflfififib
BEST EELGAUM

a 3 FUJAE , _”_;

A53 52 YEARS ‘Q ‘g

wry 3:»: 31505591 As F3034-._KSRTfi.HUBLI

Rig 3 E I cmaamv, HR3TYU$3AYR Nxgnvg ;

mam? mm, mime, _

3 V HURALI _ 5

ms 51 ‘mm ‘ _ .

EE?3 ax 31:19:02 as GQ§EQCTGRwBAlLHfiNGAL
2:59:32′, Bsasames, R;{<"2"'"n'Q.i5SH'E?I'TY ::%mie".:.
swmwMmmxycm$m.mum@mmLf

5:3? 3ELzs_A':JM '
3 A snmungwrxxamw ~."'

M555 –.

Ravrnvi ma c£;’:28.gf3’2% as “:::,s;>2rz3;=L_:r::-3’02
$Si3E3I3i.P:TT3 ‘n£:r~a’fr._ ‘_ ” _
gamaazzreg we :-ez,z_:r«.:;-ma ‘3:_g”43oumnmT1

B23? EELQBUH

i~5£1*s*1$1c1iI=: A
R$E.?3.YERR8

‘agTa_a§–3i;fi5X9i As nxxvsx
ave?

.RfQ«ER£flfiEfiIflGGhLLI

‘E3. tum . 59,.’ – iaagrz c;.n.z-zmnzmrsan
sfizaaziaizfi v

‘ .. :2 :2 Rmfimrux

;r=?,si§ 65 mm, BET}! an 31;’r3:3z9’:r as

;VEE3?EE.EEILHG§QAL BEPOT, flIST BELGAUE

§§Q KRHTKQREQI
fifilfigflfifififi E13? EELGAUH

K G HEEAR
REE 5% YEHRS
EET§ fifl 3QfQ§f§5 Afi fl££T EH WGRKSHD?

-um Laura 01* KARNATAKA HIGH OF MRNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAECA H3614 COURT 0? MRNAWKA WGH COURT OF KAMVHAKA HIGH C1

41

42

43

44

Sfiififififllg HIST BKLGEUH
Rig $HETTIGAEhI G5Uh’3 H3335
CBIKKBEI, HIST EELGAEM

3H? H 3 JREXEIRQER
ESE 64 YEERS

RETE an alxesiaa, AS Jn.AssTea£cT W ‘f ‘

€EC?I$K, fifi GFFICE EELQEQHI _ ‘fl’
Kim xxxwz ~. ITTW
73 mas? Bznennm r

fl x:nuLua »,~.’ » »_;

£83 fifi YEARS, RETB OH 31fQ8K3$AS”_ V
mazvaa, CfiIKK$BI:QEPGT;”31$T fiEusAnn~~V~
R53 XREAEUR ‘ “– 5 ,. 2;.’-

age cazxxmnz
3:3? szasxua

w M $mfiT3AmTGa_;~ 4_ _ g §. ,
REE $1 ?EAR3,”‘v$n”a§,3e1Q4x§2
R3 ? 2 cfizxxfigz D$PQT-” %
§:sT*BEn£3$x i’ <_"

xKa*nAMaAL”:$gomv*,’a_ .’
cHIxKn§I_’ ‘ ‘ *2 ‘.’

am? mafiisfixx kxalpkafi xxnssaugxz KnL3xAzz
£fiE’5§ YEERSg”RET§ UH 31f95f§3 A3
aa§vER;snnxEsH$a.nEPo7, an CHEKKDEI

‘ “-Asiswifiaumasx REG PARETGAELI

u”§3S?_$$L$AQ$g

“‘V-V45

‘m_é afifififisi

BQE 32 V3535
EE?fi ea 39ffi6i92

= “n#3 EVER? aausxun
~.”.fi§;5w$x3floP, Rio TEfi5IRKERISAhLI
=_§ am. 2?§?

_v b 4$_

ififibfihfifi

E R BUGLE. AGE ?1 YERR3

EETB DH 31f§§f§3 H8 T C Bfilfififlfififib
BEST EELGRUH RIG sazvnmnmn
Efififikflfikfihfi

H’fi§. 534f9, BEIfiHD&$AL HIST BELGAUM

:-w

an 5 av…” ‘hf! cmmmatwt-utflmm nmm !…Jfl,I§.»’l;_:£.E U!’ KAKNATAKA I-EIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HEGH COURT OF KARN.M’AKA HIGH COLRTOF’ KARNAWKA HIGH Ci

4? 3»? Ixayun via LATE samnyvn c MATHAEETI { H

48

49

50

$1

RQE 50 YERRS, RETB DRIVER
ERELHQEGAL EEPQT

BEEERUH, RKO HARUTIGRLLI
Efilbfifififikb DIST EELGHUH

M s mazxaa »~w–« , M
22 &§ vxxns, RETH an 31iaaf05_AS;’:’

$GfiEfiCTGR saax 3399?, CHIHKD3I°DN M

Esaaaun BIS? RIO HARATHA GA&hI=
agax wannnnvva ?EMrLE’_’g “V
§.wm.2z55, GGKAK DIST BEQGAUH

v’3 KHBKRRHI ,1. 5 _v*, ,”
ASE Ed YERRE, RETB GE 31f1£f98;R3 _
caanucwsg, aaznwmusau Data? *« ~
sfiaasmw BM, R16 KIEER.BEHI§§ _
aAmArm$1 TEBE§E, GGmRK’EIST=EELQfiUM

R 3 aAL3vIg=V” . .;,’._, 2A~
33$ 31 V3335; xmrg ow 3;fQ?£93 As
w I fiESfiAflfi na;”Rfu can 333,
R?fiQE¥fiME5fiR~EGST”$EI¥E31NAGAR
§EAR§xngH&PnK{ca$3s*, ,

3355353 _ – “W’_ g ‘

3z?~3SH§$¥5″w?6 LA§E C B AMAvALMAni
aagygaas RETfl.Q$_31f7f32,flIP£AEI nape?
Egg 533% E33 ETBHE, CHIKRBDI

» ssua35M»_*

5é7.

54

$ ? EREBQE REED 61 YEARS

Rfiwn fix i£12f4 as CGREUCTDR caixxxnz T
EEhSR§H;”RfONASALAPUR RAIEAS

asasamm

_g R.KHMAT

$3 YEARS, RETE on ifiiaxa AS was nxflma

Vgfixpaw, cwzxxnsz, 3233353
.T§:,é”Ci m§’E’ENSI£Iif*3 RRER, EQEAR. I3UR,C-EA TMPLE

GGK&K, BELGAHM

F H flYRKR&MARREI
$3 ?ERRS, RETD fifi»36féf§2 33 T C BAELHGL
3Ere?, BELGAUM

19

£42552? EKBLI , SOURQRTTI
BE :’.s33P<.E.EH

55 33 JEVURKAR
6? YEARS, RETB an 3:35:98 As TC _V _-
QELGAQE $ITY 3330?? Rio vE2gA£HAnRAN1vfis'*
II QR533, YQEIKBL EXTEHSIGE " ' ~. V
I;C'13m1£ SSIBQT, HELGAUH

56 T K B ASRR 61 YEAR3 s z_ ', 2 g;.m ;
RETQ am Sifiié As DRIVER; EABAMI PEPE?' ""
BR£A&KDT RIG CHAhUK¥A MHEAR. " ' 1
1: camss, BAnAM1,gnQALx$?f~.'

51 3 c.xnLL:sunA "J-';_E} '.g_ x
53 $3335, RETD an 2332;? fis=*.V»;_~
§Qfi§QETGR, fia3AH2"DEPQ?,kEAehaxQT
axe 2A3m3a£a,}asH:w5»Po$T'cF§:¢E
$&fiAHE,.B$$E§£§T» _;;. "2

53 K R JAsn38R&_ H&V\'fi'" ;
5% ?E3R5g;RETE"5Rv3fi£€f§$"£5 ?c
aannn: nB§a?a"fiaaaugmT,j2x0 KALKERI POST
aaakgfian; 6h£R$*B:s$ 2ELsAnM

59 2 9 Hmwaaux .v*,<

6§*YEARS,aRETB am 3125/96 AS HRJVER

agganz BEPQ?.fi3$flLKBT nxvzsxan
1A"fi£a%a§Am3mAsaR, III aassa
» j~3agan: ,fzagaaxaw

颻'£;s"H§REE%?é
'$3 ?EARS,"RE?n ea 3o;5I9a A3 we
§aRg§w3"nE9aT Hfifibl mm are KDLIGERI
amifs; mama}, amanmr amvaunnma

} ?hi3 Review Petitian is filefi Uffi 47 Rule 1

:ef flat, praying far review cf the ordar dated 1?-
., "§i~2§§8 @$$3£d WP 13515/2607 on the file 9! the
"*B$n'bl& High Csurt Qf Karnataka, Bangalore.

run mauxl U?' KA§i§NA"%"AKA H361-I OF KARNIWAKA HEGH COURT OF KARNATAKA Hffifi COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT 0!' XARNKTAKA MGM Ci

?his review getitian cemibg an for erders
this flay, the Eamrt §a3sa§ tha fallawing:~