High Court Karnataka High Court

Kothari Sugars And Chemicals … vs The Union Of India on 4 March, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Kothari Sugars And Chemicals … vs The Union Of India on 4 March, 2010
Author: Ajit J Gunjal
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
CIRCUIT BENCH AT GULBARGA

DATED THIS THE 4TH DAY OF' MARCH, 20 IO
BEFORE   C

THE HONBLE MR. JUSTICE AJIT J   -A '

WRIT PETITION NO.6050 2Oo6..«(G;II§Rg~$V)I

BETWEEN

KOTHARI SUGARS &
CHEMICALS LIMITED,

“KOTHAR1 BUILDINGS”, é
115, MAHATMA GANDHI SAIAI
NUNGAMBAKAM, ”

CHENNAI–~600_O34. _

REP. BY ITS:.CQ_1ViPAI$JY SECRETARY. …PETITIONER

[BY PRAII/CICOLIN KA.i:”H_A’fII, A:OV., (ABSENTD
AND 1′ I I
I. TfI~I’EA.U N10′?-I ‘EOE INDIA,

‘~ _ BY§1TS_

, MI,NIsI”R1éO–I5 CONSUMER
A.E_FAIRs i*+”‘O.QD.. AND PUBLIC
I DI’s’IR1E1mON,
D’IREc’rOR~ATE OF’ SUGAR,

– KRISHIEIIAVAN,
I NEW DEIIHI.

5 TI~IE CHIEF DIRECTOR

IQ

(SUGAR),

GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
MINISTRY OF CONSUMER
AFFAIRS, FOOD AND PUBLIC
DISTRIBUTION.

DIRECTORATE OF SUGAR
KRISHI BHAVAN,

NEW DELHI.

3. THE JOINT DIRECTOR (SUOA’R)ID~V–

GOVERNMENT OF INDIA, ~
MINISTRY OF CONSUMER

AFFAIRS, FOOD AND, II>U13I,IC7f

DISTRIBUTION, I I, ,
DIRECTORATE OF SUGAR.’

KRISHI BHAVAN,

4. THE DEPU’II¥’SDVIRf3C’IfOR

OovERN1\aII;I\;TOE_1NDIA;~. _ V I
MINISTRY AFFAIRS,
FOOD AND PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
DIRECTORATE’ I
KRISHIBHAVAN; N~EVv”..,___f)E’LHI.

(BY SRI C RSEIIAASIIRIKAINIII, CGSC]

$*$*$*$

(SIIc:{I;zIRf

. . .RESPO NDENTS

\Ifr’i.t-:”petItion is filed under Articles 226 and

SeC’t.ion.__” 3(3) and 3(E)

22’7’of the: ‘Constitution of India, praying to declare that
_ and 3(1) of the Essential
Commodities (Amendment) Act, 2008 and Clauses 4 and
the Sugar (Control) Order, 1966, as ultra vires and

._ LInC’onStitutionaI and hence unenforceable; therefore

_ “petitioner Consent and etC.,

This petition Corning on for preliminary hearing In
‘B’ group this day, the Court made the following:

None appears.

N o representation.

Dismissed. _

YKL/- A