Wp20410.0'?
12¢ THE HIGH COURT or KAR!iATA1'3_. ' *- '
cmctm assert AT nI»;.5RwAn-- ~ .. _ jjy..
DATEI) 'ti-I13 ms rrm nA¥';»'or:.n31;Y'; "
swans
THE HON'BL!S MRJUSTICE na'e1}§Au
wnrr P§'!'ITI¢3N.1_€o.204.' ""1c'2g_dg:;_{;A-figfiz
Between:
E.
_'-J
E1:
_A}~?A 45 Yf.f1ARS
KZRISHNAPPA v§:NKAPPA"RAG:§m "
AGE 43YEA.,=.~2:§';..__'« '_ ; '
GANGAWM. €i;,zc3v-L§;,xiaA}=PA"~RA:§Hi§._' '
A.;AsoYEgxR:3_ '
sAh§€§A%15PATA ;i£s.NA§8;fa'?-PA' RAGHA ' ' "
A,'A¥ 44 ';'EA.RS=" ..__ = = . .
mxmm 1e.aNGA1$PA§.'R§.V ' 4 ="
AKA 35 Y:«;_ARr~3 ' = "
Rggmwg pAr»:3:>A;f>I$A 12 .-mama
' = ..BH1m9r.aA'?aNDAPPA RAGHA
V _A;'AV'?8'Y'f*iAR_S"
" . :+:;ANA§.4s;¥%PA'[1§QxsAP?A JAKANUR
-5;/A 5e~2g3aRs
RA;fEf§'fE)RA.KUIs§AR SHANKARAPPA PATTAR
.. I Am 4-0 vgms
* .._xéi3;NKApPA LAX?-JEAN SHIRABUR
Agg 35 YEARS
TAMMANEAPPA SHBRAMMAPPA PUJARI
Ala 35 YEARS
SADAPPA SEDRAMAPPA PUJARI
A./A 30 YEARS
--V 24'
V 27.
Wp204}{).€'?
CHANDRASHEKAR SIDRANEAPPA 'PUJARI
MA 45 ms,
SADASHEVA SIDRAMAPPA PUJAR1
A/A 35 YEARS
SURESH MALLAPPA JAKANUR
A/A 40 YEAR'S
BHIMAPPA PARAPPA PUJARI
A/A 53 YEEARS
BEEYAMMA W/O RAJESAB MULLA * V
Am 60 YEARS p ; V
MALLAYYA SE-EIVAYYA. HERE} ._TI'£--i _ f'
A/A 5OYEARS '
YALL¢§.VVA_W;7fG 3i*;=i1saAzstAP§s; QAGA '
Ala 60 »
YANK._AA.E?A"::ajb im}.VMAr.£A'PE;&AV£G)};
A/ASOYEARS '~ *
RAz~.#i;a,?1%§ sprj Yéméwiafiegvvvacg
AGE: 49 YRS,' V ~
MALAPFAE»/0 YAV§.:A1¥mPPAV VAGA
»A;GE;3.s ms,'-» ., _
" "PRAEi§AP15A.«S;'O YAQAHAPPA VAGA
* «. gag; ea YRS,
_ "' ._L§LCEv€:ti;'4; F'P!Vi AEZIVEPFA ormaom
. "A/A 4mj'g_s:5Rs
"m.r.&--mA:~iéiAPPA M&LI..APPA SARASHE'i"I"{
A25 4:) YEARS
I :..t;m.NNA MALLAP'?A samsamw
V _,éx/A 37 mares
SMVAPPA SANGAFPA TAPAREDDY
AAA 50 YEARS
PANDAPPA KALIAFPA omzsczsz
A/A 65 YEARS
Wp2G45G.0?
23. SHRISHAIL msama PUJAR1
MA 38 YEARS
29. GOURAVVA AYYAFPA JAKANUR
Ala 55 YEARS
30. KALLAPPA HANAMAPPA KAI\EAKAI\XNAV;'}'.R ~
A[A 55 YEARS _
31. GOUDAPPA SHEKAPPA PATIL '
EVA 55 YEARS
ALL ARE AGRICULTURISTS
R/C) KOLUR VILLAGE _ ._ = _
TQ BILAGI DiS'I" BAGALKOT ' --. prnrxaxmns
[By sr1.: :z.n.nzsa.;, 4.sgm_r_.,)
AND
1" THE SPECiALf¥,;Ai§D ALéQ:JITs;:1'1§3£¢~-OFI«€1cER{,
UPmf«;I:z.K,RiS*H_NA '
B1I.£;GITAbUK,
BAGALKOT D1<:T..._ '
:2. THE GENERAL 1L.1VA'z~z-,t..\'e.:=»E1-:-,.A_
UPPER KRISTSNA 'p_Rc;.:§;cf1';_;
NAYANAGAR, ' _ ,
a,.é.G'A1.,;<;o'r um". mmvomamrrs
'{:3y'si¥i;*§}Ki*§1*m'1*:, Hc<;PV%«4tiR R1)
is filed under Articles 226 and 227' of the
Con:si:§tutio}:1"."L:9fA'T:= India praying to ciimct the resptmdants to
comgearsation in ::1 sum of Rs.2,23,30(}]- in respect of
' thc 1a11ds 0f the pctifioncrs, which Watt acquired undm' the
h 1:¥0_ti7f1cafi.<;2r.{vide ANNEXA and eta,
This petition coming on for prefiminaxy healixag in 'B'
_. "go%:1p, this day, the Court made the following:
wp2{}r1i{}.{}?
ORDER
1. Pefitioncrs No.1 to 4 are the ‘w
measuring 3 acres 5 gnzltas situatcflat
Taluk. Petitioner 5 is the ow1)fiér<__.<)f
acres 38 glmtas situate at Taluk.
Petifioncr 6 is the acre 38 gtmtas situate at Kolur Petitioner 7 is the owner sf gtmtas situate at Kolur villagei. 8 is the owner of Sy.No.23]"P6 at Koiur village in Bilagi H is the owner of Sy.N.71/2
measuring 18, situate at Kolur village in Bilagi
‘3″3§)€TE§;:iAVfiO}’Tl€I’S” 11 are the awimzrs of Sy.No.78/ 1+2C.,
–.me2§§u.xi1;gV’1 $1 guntas situate at Kolur viiiage in Bilag’
‘§’a1uAi:<i;V 10, 12 and 13 am the: owners of
jSy.b¥o"."'I'S]'v3a measuring 32 guntas situate at Kolur village in
",.;3i:;agi1.._f1*ai£1;<. Peijfiozwr M is the owner of Sy.No,'?'9/28/ P,
2?' guntas situate at Kalur village in Biiagi Taluk.
T Petitiener 15 is the owner of Sy.1\¥o.3}./1A measuring 'E7 guntas
V siizuate at Kolur viiiage in Biiagi Taluk. Petitioner 16 is the
wp20~<1iG.07
5
owner of Sy.N0.87/1P measuzéng 1 EICIE 6 guntas situaie at
Koiur village in Bilagi Taluk. Petiiioncr 17 is the me:%% of
Sy.No.88/P measming 1 acre 2 guntas situate at
in Bilagi Taluk. Petitioners 13 to 22 are_..t11u¢f”VV.§$\}éf1crs Tar,
Sy.No.88jP1 measuring 2 acres 27!’
village in Biiagi Taiuk. P€ti$3′,(_>ncr is :o\%zrzé’;;
Sy.No.88/P2 measuring 4 §i:E7x.iatEv;’a{VV Kalur V
vmage in Bi1agiTa1uk. Petitigyneré€1″i=§:1§é:A%:;:az~ne;¥’¢1’sy.No.23/P
measuring :1 and Sy.No.’4VC:;/Ag” acre 9 guntas
situate Petitioner 25 is the
owner af Sy’*.Ne:i.24:/ 10 guntas situate at K0111:
village ‘I’€:’1uVkV-_. Pcfifififier 26 is the owner of Sy.No.55/ 2
‘r:3_.A&asi§.i’ingL 3.cre$V”i2¢%—g11n.tas situate at Kalnr village: in Bilagi
‘-‘i\’3}.1§.k.= is the ewner of Sy.No.6£ measming 1 acre:
’24 g1.1}1’:asV s§%:e;;;=~;:fa:s’at Kolur vfllagct in 8i1agi”I’aluI<;. Petitiaxmr 29
thz Sy.N0.'?9/ 3 measming 1 acre: 1% gamtas situata
".5? AK'<T3E:.;r fiiilage in Bilagi Taluk. Petitio:t1c:r .30 is '(ha owner" Qf
'measuring 2 acres 24 guntas situate at Kalur
" in Bilagi Taiuk. Petitioner 31 is the awn:-:r of Sy*.N~:::,4'7/5
L6;
wp2€)4lO.€t7′
measuring 1 acre 32 guntas and Sy.No.55/1 }3′:;eas1;1*ingV4..aa’czjes
39 guntas situate at Koiur village: in Biiagi *ra1uk. _ %j
2. The aforementioned lands wer{:H;1o'{ified” ‘tbr.:ac€§t1isi£ion ” ”
for the purpose of Upper KI’iShI}é..
notificafion dated 25.01.2005′ -.wh;ic’1’1.,_’was T.
Karnatalca Gazattc dated
netificafion is produced’ the wfit petition.
Thereafier, f.11a1 notj1icatio;;V_9fva.s a consent
award was pa$§siéL:?:;j[.L:v:.f0r irrigated lands.
Accommg t0, ‘the’ said. amount of Rs.1,48,2€)()/-
was initial «pa4}’;Iment– {he respondent-authoiities hat!
vass11r;::;i”‘2:I1e L§>étififiéi’::.er$’ that they would be gzaid total
Rs.1,05,3Q(}/– for dry lands, Rs.1,75,5(}O/-
single crop and Rs.2,.,23,2&£}/– far
2 hfigfitsd twa craps. The petitioners claim that all
” <__i:l'1::sc:f are irrigated lands. The C-spy of the awani is
A at Anriexumwg to the: writ pefition. The {and ownsrs
Eands which were acquired tmdsr tim very
notificafion dated 25.012005 (pubiished in thti
Official Gazette on 01.02.2005) are awaxfied compensation of
M
wpzoaxaet!
'?
Rs.,?,23,30€)/~ in respect of the irrigated lands “7hCI’€fi1 two
crops were being grown. The said award was passe;4cl.VV§in»fi11g
Febmaxy 2007. Ccpy of the same is pracluced at. .
to the writ pefitign. O11 ceming to know about”fi;é:anv5ma1y ” =
payment of compensation, the petit:ie(;-£1613 Seem.’
mpmsentations to the msponde3its__reqiiesting _}:’ig}:1t ;
the anomaly situation and to mscfivaébthg t1i:% ati11g ihe
petitioners’ case on par’ £.iF1eV.<§f«.perso:A1AsVAwho were
granted co::a.pcnsa1:iQ:1 in a_s}v1 m_of' Tfll this day,
tha Comfiiifiisatiéén is 110%: granted to the:
pefitionfirfi "H€ti1L"::EtV, pgztifion is filed {graying for such
compensatiaxr , *
are stateé to be irrigated leads. Q1}
1:Ai:f':1"3.Vv'&'«sf':'IjVg?"7A béisis, Vt:I"1§ 'petitioI1ers Who 3113 the owners (If 133:: lands
ii} qg15'stiQi1' granteé compefisation of Rs.i,48§20G[–~ by
o;.'tv.V_¥::ahe csnsent award dated 06.042096. Hawcver,
V' the Iané owners whose lamis Wage the subjrstct mattsr
pmliminaxjy nvtificatian are granteci cempensation of
_ fR$.2,23,3{){)/– by virtue of the award passaci substzquaenfly
ciurizlg tha month Qf Febmaxy 200'? Vidfi AI:nexu.re–Cl to the
F}/WE
§
Wp2€)41(}.{)'?
writ petifien. It is sxsttlesd law that when a hand if; ”
under the provisimrs of the Land Acquisaiticrn Ac’:-:¥
value: of the land so acquirtd shall §”i&ii?&’*?O E-_”e oh; u
the basis of tha date of Notifica{ic;1’i’.Vu};.§’?§r (:3 _ €)E
Acquisition Act and net on the V13::.1$i”ssV_M0f .(3’0m*.?£:é:;*31;z1’§t.1§*t atlzat is underiying 11/S 28-15; of the Land
Aciguisifigii View (inf the same, the State Gov:-:rn1.nen.t wiil
‘haste ;:c..1V5ay.V1;11¢: same: comgensatzion ef Rs.2,23,3@3/- to film
x V’ gwfifieneré; if their lands were yielding twat Crops 3139 as has
~ ésvmdeé to thoss iand ownem WhOS€ lancis ware acqui:rez;¥
” iiiider the: same notification.
V’
Wp20410.0?
4. Under similar cirtzzmzstaxxces, this Ciarurf. £11 -:f)f_
SHIVALINGAPPA T. GAMGER vs. GENERAL MAN1gQ:i«:fi
UKP, NAVANAGAR, BAGALKOT >”Eggfi?’K’NQ;r¥é$3’§9:[V2£§0g’V’
disposed of on 12.07.20(}’? has orci€3.réd_V_n$0 “the: V’
comgaensatien to 3}} the land owizéfabwhcg haw-:_ ‘V
xméer the very acquisition .;1ot:Lfi.caii63;1*. u’1’_he pfinciplej invoivcd
in the said mafisr is exacu3;«’%t;;s ‘s.i1i*£i}ar:’3[$v’iw;iVo}ved in this Wxit
pctifion. Accoz*d§r:zgg1&yL;..0?t1§:r is~:f:Lad¢: /_
The :t$p9n{it:nt.s'”a1t: c§%;;*e§:’ted éxwatd compenaation to
the petitionejiféfs-1a11(AiVVV<:fi§i?1;s:1i}s __rat£: of Rs.1,05,3(}O/ – for dry
lands, Rs. 1,7§;$0§)f «V growing single crop and
R$:.2,23,2C{O fog" land growing two Crops.
fire Withijz four months from the date
of
5'. The'jw1°§iL ._p;:4fifioa is disposed of amerdingiy.
Sé/~*
EUDGE
' Jm/«