Loading...

Kum Soumya H D/O Honnagangaiah vs Visveswaraiah Technological … on 19 March, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Kum Soumya H D/O Honnagangaiah vs Visveswaraiah Technological … on 19 March, 2008
Author: Ashok B.Hinchigeri
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, BAN§AI;dRfEt<%
DATED THIS THE 19*" DAY or MARCHQQOQQ A'  = 
BEFORE       t x  

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE A;sHc:1(B. 

Writ Paflflnn Nn_9'na;fi2_ nf ahnj 'rt§A:s,-i$&1'  

BETWEEN

Kurn. Soumya H, V V
DIG Hannagangaiam.   
Aged about 24 y_aas*§,'_v

Residifiq at ivio._1:;:,  , ., p 

6"' Cross. 4"' ii Mafianf    
Chandana Extension', ' 
Sunkadakatte,     
Banga|otfe--560AG£¥V1._é  -. 

 %  _ PETIHONER
*   tIBy'9rI"A}v--. ,§:;mgadharappa, Advocate]

_ AND__{' "

, 

_  viétfé;-sI4§ara!eh Technolwical J:~..-.'ers!t',',
" » Be:gaurfr:.--590 014,

* Kavrrataixad' State,

'' "*VRepres'e~ntéd by Its Registrar (Evaluation).

V --V 2. "4"'E)oiaV.B¢5:-itzo Institute of Technology,

  f5angaiore--560 074.

Kurfibaigodu,

 ~  Mysore Road,
 RESPONDENTS

[By Sr! Arvlnd Kulkarnl, Advocate for
Sr! Basava Prabhu S. Patll, Advocate for R1,
R2 sewed]

This writ petition is filed under Articles 226 and

for the
constitution of Indie preying to eeesh the !ette?”‘dt–t.1’3,i 1,-,2t1.,t.1?

vide Annexure-K and etc.

This petition coming on for v.hearl.ng t_hi’s.4.’d,ay,.,’

Court made the foilowinfi: A_ p A.
The petitioner’s gdevancel’l’is’,v:thet the ‘._re’spoun;dent’s order,
dated 19″‘ November, not keeping with

the order, dated ,1″ Octoher,–..2.dO1i?, this Court in writ

“.11-1-I-im-. Lin ‘l’:!”‘i.V,E’I”,”n.4-“”‘!l’Il”\E i A
|JI=u|.IuII IVLI-J.JI.’.JJ.:.*,’.Il ‘V.1.t.3lv’\J’J. :_ ‘_ ._

2., …. the…cese are that the respondent

found the ‘«petition’er:’g,ti”iiti[“~~of ‘certain examination malpractice

end pa-.sed the punitive erder, dated 23″‘ September, 2095
:n….- ..-a_ _..a. ._-..n.n-.. -1 n.L… …..z-_ n.. ._ _n_.___.:_.__|
U’-‘\i1fi&.’XUfI::”H} IHE YEFEVGHE POITIOH OI’ HIE OTCIET I5 Xllfa EEO

herel,hbelow~;,f~~. __

.__”‘V%”Deni’ai1V.oii benefit of performance of the fixaminations
“- conducted during June 2006.

_ Rejection of semester results, Readmisslon, change of

V ” «..ce!.ie.ge and change of seer;-e e.n.=.- not

Mnf nnrmifhnzi In falrn arlmiccinn In flu: hinhar gal-nae!-nr
I’VE FIVHIUIIIUIN-‘I-‘ U’, IFITIEI ‘IHIFFIUJ-JIIIII I? “I’m! l’I””‘%l’ 3\i””Ef;’¥”

till the redeeming of punishments imposed.”

3. This order was challenged by the petitioner in writ

FiE’H.

petiti_on No.13’751 of 2006. This Court in the said writf”%:petitIon,

by its interim order, dated 29″‘ September, 200:6 the

. petitioner to prosecute her studies without

further interim order was granted’.V_o:n_ J

permitting the petitioner to appee’r._for a”ii.th’eory: e*.r:a’ni’inations’of

this Court in its gprii, 2667 ciarified
that there was p_roirib’itioh} to declare the
petitioner’s resi;_itsA~–:ef~_V_the_VSaiiI.._semesterrtherefore the petitioner
was permittedfto lbapijpeartfor semester examination and
such ortheee ieiseeiueieeiei the V11 semester, if any. This
C ‘”‘t ‘”‘A ‘inaii a it

R _
um L; uy |.e>,’|

.—_dispoeed__i”ofj the”‘w_ri_t.npetition hoiding that the punishment

imDosed.A__’haefl’tvo_ be read and understood as cancellation of

regu’ia’r vvexarnin:ation that she had taken in June, 2006 and not

ythe examienations taken by the petitioner for clearing the arrears

has suppiementary examination. It was held that her appearing

entitled in law to the same.

this Court, the respondent has Tsent.pttteyietter,”tiated,.A19””–.., 4}

November, 2007 calling upon her to__stsbmlt»”uh’er’_vexarn.I’nation
application form at the Coil’eoeu’Vtfo_rdthe subjects and to
take the admission tonthe ‘.Asem_ester after it acquiring the

eligibility. The petltionerfs-.griey§an–ce,.”i’e’:,’,tllat the respondent

in
II I III VII IIIE

st stake admission or readmission to t

=Srl.’iiflf;–.¢a.n’aa’d’ha’rappa, the learned counsel for the

ltioner mil,-um.-«e of the lnt_r!m or ere passed by

prosecutieti vii and VIII semester studies and also appeared

forthe sa:iVd’_v»,–sefonester.. examinations. It Is Srl Ganqadharappa’s

V «V emphatiéippsubrnlsslon that the punitive order is left undisturbed

this Court’s order, dated 1″ October, 2007 passed in writ

petition No.13751 of 2005 only in respect of the cancellation of

6. Sri Arvind, the learned counsel

respondent submits that the petitioner is not the

VII semester, unless she has tlfie””‘ei*igibiilitytit V-‘eiig’i’biiVIty”A’

prescribed is that the candidate 5

subje…s As the pe.itioner has invmore than four subjects,

ruies do not permit ‘ner~- .admissionVi_;’toV”‘the V’ii’semester without
clearing the requisite nurnberof in the previous

semester, namelytthe V, V’

NJ
U’:

‘*5
“£9-

I

5..

2|
CL
in
r’
*-i
E:

III
F
:’il’
fll
a-Ir _
«

2|’ ‘
ill a
mi
‘Cl
‘El
mi
2’.

E-

3!
mi
I:

ni
G!
EL
:i
Ian
91
Hr
:r’
mi

order mt1stac;ttei,iaw passed in writ petition No.13751
of 200$; ” Sri’ ,.,:Cieling:adh’a’rappa submits that there is no

impedimentilinidisphosin-gliof this petition, as the petitioner has

‘”faile”ti{toé.,’per’su,adeV tlieiliivislon Bench to grant any interim order

submits that the matter is of urgency, The

which site’ has appeared. if she has failed in any of the subjects,

. to submit the examination application form for the failed

‘ “-v.f:_subJects and the last date for doing the same is fast

» approaching.

HBH.

8. on careful consideration of the submiss_ion’s”rj’IaiadVe at

the bar, I find that the impugned order, datedA«’:_fi9.”‘_’VATfloirerfibect,

2007 (Annexure-K) is not in conforniitvwith oifletr’,

is entitieci to aii the vbenefitsi””exc;ept-»s.the ‘oe”nefits of the ‘VT

semester examination, steei”tooi_<::i'nf3u'he, 2006.

semester" _ iiieediess to observe that if the
petitioner ha'sp%fa'iied"ef"the subjects of the VIII semester

examination; 'can aiwai/s appear for the same by submitting

1-'f'i"'the Vétaitiinatiton apflplication form and remitting the necessary

' exe.min:.atien" fee;

petition is allowed. No order as to costs.

5?

😐
U}
Q;

~—.

I –

dated 1″ October, zoo? passed gr ti

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *

Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies. More Information