IN THE 53%”? CGBRT SF KARNATAKA; §45.N§fis.LQRE
SATEB TFIIS “WEE 2973 QA? §F SEPTE%~%BER 2316
8sEFޤ..E
THE :-mama MR. JBSTZCE man: MAw«zg;j’r’H« _
EEEWEEK
1
(sv
A”%._VAf€§:3%»f.V
MKSHMARA, 46 YEIJ-.R$,.*
5/0 E;’HIKKATHI%?£MAIAfi %
AC~iR}CU£.TURIS”?, RIAT sfiixwe EGG%§s?-$fi:?€Afi{?;E’3Bi
WLLAGE, HAMLETQF Mfi;¥3;+’a£*§£Rfiz-»L__
msgsg HQBLI, RA_¥’*3iAfiI;&#.Rfi.?€§ ‘.{A.£..£J§€
BA%%GA§£RE (R) 513?. L ‘,
$EVARAJU_f _ % %
40′ YEARS’, $j,{£’_-3′ CHEK2~.é:*fi.”rHIM§?$AL&HV»”
AGRI€1_.i}’L”E’i.§REST2_'”, ‘agar ‘salvage; Egowmammom
VILLAGE, SAMLE? Qfiiffiaafififigm
9c&.SAgA*’%a93i§gVL.RAMgNAaaa£M TAM:
8fsWG&i;eR.E{{:}§1 $¥_ _ –
. . ,fisF’?ELL§?*§T5s
:32 RfAfiI§§?fia5;._$fiVQ{ZA?E)
V .*1CHVi7i<%§%:£:T%§i?%"iMA£A§é
X »._Sf0.-£_.A'¥fE%{§l'4KA'?1&GG§%fBfis
aim: new 52' ms
" Sm. BQRAMMA, 70 '{EfixR$
% kvL41:efe:';s:: s.m'E ca:K§cA?Hz9&:«:A2Aa
2AmMAaALu 'VILLAGE
BIQAQE H083
RAMA£*€fi£–'afi;RAM "E'A¥..i§§€
fifi:NG5£.GRE (R) 533$?
(hr) S19¥T.!**$.%§’sffis¥*1P¥A,, 42 YEARS,
Wffl E.fi=TE 5%Hwa;r4m.
mmxamu ‘%{§§.iAG-E
BEAM 3383
QA¥%’¥A¥Si@RAM TALE?!
BAN$43;.GRE (R) $13?
(:3 swim:-1AmMm
W/£3 ¥4:fii-iA9EVA}’A¥%
ms: 39 vaamg,
F..A¥(Kfis8N’§§RA, HAMLET G?
S¥.5%fimiA!-W.1.I s<AsABAV 3931.21
R..5.!'*¥A!'€@R5c?-if TALUK '
EARGALORE (a) 3:5':
(d}S£H$’¥’.iAKSHM§X§§A
SIS f§£A?i.3A??A ” ‘
AGE: ssvaaas, . «
mmammu x;z;.:.«ss.=L%k « % % A
BIfiAQI§§£3§$3;.i*_-.
ram:
mémmses §;a;%szs:% L %
{e} sszwkavgrmgazga
W29 Ge%saA§?$* % %
AGE: 59 Y£eRS',._j .
mmsrascmaimn ,;:::.Lm&
KQOTA*a~'&L i-iQB§..1- %
.% «i1EA§’iAH%A5’r?A§*¥ ‘ff-‘t§…{.§K
– .,. (§}'”fi$T
% f ]% kg:;s§é?;3.a¥’mMA wxa flA?~iJiJ¥€E3AP?.&
, = ,¢.ss: ‘#4 1213 mass
A x.e.1~a§§&;.;:& ama, ¥v£YS{3RE
(§} seegmawaamag
1 , we szaaam.
” V ‘1§:{§Ef 41 YE§R3,
¥3.§}§3Rfi:i$H§?’i}?a§ VIQAQE
¥*¥AD§UR ‘?:5si.U-K
?~?A£5§9?fia DIS”¥’RI{I’F
{£3} sm:;~:2E9am:v;aa
W18 Ymwfia
JBLGE: 38 YEfisRS,
Sfl§VANE%WBANfi«.flG[§BI
RAMLET SF MABAPURA
KASa5s5.% HQBLI
{i} S?4’¥’sVA%L&KSHMAb%£’~€A
AGES Amy? 32 ‘YEARS,
sHIvANEmwDA:4AmDBI
HAM£.ET OF MADAPURA
mgmg mm
§AMAt%AGARAM “€A£.Ui<
emaams-":5 at; RAL mm
vaumraswmv, Ase: §:s_"¥i eARs, V
311:3 L1-'#3'E CHIKKATHIMMAEAH % "
RIG SHIVANEG(§¥¥E3ANA.Qs;’}D§}I VI,Li.AGE
HAMLET 0F Hfiflfiflfififl, Kkfififi-‘.’i ‘*E-§0BL§
RAMANAGARAM ‘¥’A£.i.5_%m: gimme
§~%AML£”T <'.–'{F :?£A§HAPasR_A; HGBLE
RAMAޤޣ"a%R:ߣ?4_?"ALU_K, BAQGALGRE (R) DIST
Grézfméa, .Vgri;EV:jT33:M:v$Aas,
sic L;a';'E ;C%£'IK!(.§.T%-£;1.i4fi'L&§Ai-i,
52,26 8HE'Al'3EGOV#E3A!§ADO£3E}I VILLAGE
.».§fIAMLET ¥(ASABfi2 HGBLE
~ TALUK, BANGALGRE {R} DIST
% 3 ea: mg;3oPAm , me; 24 YEARS,
g sge v§s:i<:A'rAsm.~z¥
Rffif $L§f-§VA§5E%W€3§NA§3C}QQ§ VH.f.fiLGE
HGBE, RAM.5.£'§AGARAM TALUK
s;'azs1:;;.aLoRE(R) ms':
V. %}%%§a V h¥ATARAJfi. , AGE; 22 mags,
5,19 vex;-carsmwgmv
R,/AT SHI§lAfiéEGOW$é1W£%D$I \f£§.£.A£’.5’E
KASA% HGSLI, RA!%1ARAGAR.A§’r’£ TALLEK
Bfie3*éGfi§,0RE (R) 315?
£9′? 3.? SRIflI3iA$A MURTHE’
W
ass; 18 YEARS,
5/Q vemmrmwmv
REA’? .’Si~EIVA!stEGOW§ANA9%E3DE VILLAGE
wsm Hcau, RAMANAQARAM TA¥.UK
Basssmmazg (FE) 9:51′
RES?QrsiQ,St’4i¥;$;;’_~
{av 39:, $.h£.SU83A SHASTRY, Aw ma R.§v~%%r§; Ljj
sag smuesowm, Aw, FGR.-*fi;’1(A&£§_. – gasgssm
mm, and), we), aim, R1is),%ar=::h>}+ sE%Rv&fD;
am} -« N€}’E’§€E msmesga mm, %
sR:£.T.R.sHAN1<ARA RANtZ:AEPA, ' *
mvacnrs ma R—2 ~ A8s$E!'§;iT,.
Sf9§T.ANIT§-EA RAvINaARAN,F;aa*mcA:E t ‘T % ;
FOR R3 3: R4 ~ ABSENT) –
RFA mzakuzs 95%”o.s=%¢r§.r1:;*%Lr%::;:;:*;2n:;aE cons
Acmsss? THE;~’§£§_m:$MEEMT€ .-éN3 }’:$§§:;Rf._E:E err, 431.2693
masses IN ,*:’;3%%%.:§:t?:%.%1§§s,*:Ls§a 11Z’:fi’:’«’3_’§-£5»?-*§§_E as THE cm;
sums V§ia:R.«h§,j ;:.w£F:i:«;%% Réfiéarégmaagm, DISMESSENG
THE 39:: am VB”§i’.f:£5:?§.K'{I (.”;i’?«3,’ Pmrmmé Arm SEPARATE
9055553135: m{::.1=%::3é; :s£Es’rssE vmsrrs.
_.;j*zé;i§ A?Pi&.a.§§.::3§éIr4§ are ma Hfififiifiifi TE-IE5 my,
. “1*§~:§”mL;r{2}’:’ §.*2~5;.Iv§R.Ea THE F'(}L£.0¥’1fING:-
Aggféevefi by the judgnm-‘st ané decree flateé
aaweé by the Ci??? fiudgeifirxfin} arm 3.l*=%.F.C,,
‘ ,.._” $§fnan§aram, in Q.S,fic.1-4511988 $§5£’fi§$$¥£’£§ the 52.1%: fer
. f’partEt§6r§, this §§fl§¥?t§gS ham fiiaé the grssant agpafii.
V4″
z/’
namafy, the firs: daafandant, exacutw a regisbered Wilt
éated 33.198? in favaur sf wfergéants S ta ? namai§g;___2he
chiidran éf the defendant n¢.2. By gdaezirzg raiéancé
said tr’€i¥§, the defendana cksim thefir share.
prapartiw being aprpartiened by §r–irtu–aaf’ j§§é’:¥ _thé- V’
ciaim mafia by the detanzsam of’the wiAia*k%g;§§§%1_
Ex.E1, the piaintiffs have f§ia§”~’.f,?t$ p”r9__sfinj::V»’-§u’i:§vV”‘$’eek§ng ” V
partition and pessessicm. (ff t¥1a’s.sV-s$ié.tf_:–;3:*’;«;~.a;;Ip§ert*;’,v'”b3:v–a£av§}r:ing ‘*8′
se:I*1eéss§a pmperty 6?’ ii: partitian and
segarate poss§;.~.’§;$i::_pfs afi the 52.2%:
“”” rsameiy, tha father
his wriistea statement that
the glsa sf £?iaa._:§:ia%£*stiffs Viés imtormszt and thus wit regzérss
:I:;3§ae:t§é, ” F”§’i’é?t7″v<:r: 3.5.19$?, he has execrsfiaé a
favsur of 2"' ée§er:daf:'zt'§ chiiérea ansé
¥'2sé£~aeg:§ thagf entitieé far the samaa, The sama bemg a
wéii, it simasfi fie aceefi awn. Even thaagh,
'%&g;ia§g§¢anz N<:n1~ Chikkathimrrzaiah is the ssgnawry ta the
' *…_ ?§%'scha=;afi1 ?arikath, Ex.FE, he denim the axecution of
» fits wme. Hewevat", fiw 2*" w§fe~ Scramma has stand in
the arass» examinatian regarding emcutiam sf E13: by her
224/
hushamé. The 1*' cfasfenciant — Chikkatfiimmaiah éieai an
1,9.3.9%3. A mama was flied by the defenéants 2 -ta 4
afiapting the written statermnt cf flue 15*
Defendants 3 tr: 5 submitted their
smtement that than; is rm yartitiganwné iifiafifi.'§1v;g:y £sé¥:;§., V'
the LES. of the 1" defendant was
his pmyerty. Howavsr, in tf§fi:"\%af§deA§icsa ¥:hV1é:3{ Ehat " V
Exfii has been exeaufigedz. Th;aV-~*F§;§ai¥. Cmzrt issues
and by the impugned j:¥d§g'ne;§2.tV§'%§;?:t{:'$§§.§§éfiismissed the
wit Heme, %
5. garage} appearing far
the 1-._i;:’%%i”sv:;’:p1:g:’:eé jazdgment and
éecrwe faquiras to be set xzsicfa. fie
conten:isLAth«§?t; ractsrded fig {ha ‘§’ria¥ Ceurt én
¥’i:i3at*..;t§:e have faiiafi to pmve that the
“”§c¥¥r;_£’Vfa:§§£–E§1( were fiivifiafi if’: arms sf Exfiz is
E$’£’E}.¥f£§’§$i£.F$~3_§”§3§’?I$’ V. is iiafife ta: he set asiée, fie santenés that
f*:a;_._é7~ fiaen executed by afi the members as we?! as
V i?§\3.»_’.§é;ther cf dafendant am: and hence; the finding
. _:fgé:e:fiaaé by Etna Trisaé Ccsart is: contrary, erronesam and
» iiahia is be interfered wédw. Ha subrtfits that awn though
the defendanfi pfiead imp§errmr;mtier: ef Emtiif since rm
3%,?
§
Egmea wage fgfimaéf iéza §$§$§’%§§f”:§§ §%§”Eé*%%§; 5% §§§§§5é%~€§_ :§
wig fig? iiag gaéfi %?z§§§§ £5: gzggggazéé sf tfiaé? agmtagaaiémm
:22 gm at fiafiéa 33235:??? mg ésakzgggg :M;;%;;F;:;:e;
r
aggagyiag fir 2% §’§§§@?”%§§§””駧 $§%¢:¥;_%:’§%«.,
§%’%’2§é.§§§'”%@§ gagfigmagsé §§”:§ éeégfega:°z§’:%§:*:-§:’:§s ‘%%:§€§”%:%§é3*=%”§.%v’V’
as arm? zamméwfi 53;’ $32 Tr%a§’%’=i;%::;::*€ $r;§.§.3:§*’*;§.;§§§r;%§§%§ §%
am saééi is $3 §:$$§§a::s’§:~..&_§§§€.§%V”‘§$%$fl’14.3%’-._:;g§%:§:éV§§ §2ai am
findifig gaacarfigd §%g $23 :§%:§ftvAA.§§~§%_’_.§§%Satéfis haw
§§§§$fi ta’: §§m§§:3 ‘§§;§:,,§§i £5 3:2-.a$£$$’a§§a€§ T§§§i§z iavé argfi fa:
%:’%%%:”§&?;:’a¥:’2%§a—.§}s$j;Vagééaé ‘i::3=§f;- é:§§:2*s;§’§’%%§§g§ fie fiwmizg €313?
agggai 55:22: §%ss2:’*a§$§@§;.
E». °§§:-% %§%§?;&£§ $%.’::§§%’é%i§ §§§s&a§%§%§ fag” gfaia} 33% {E};
§::é’:’:=€§ avg V§?§’§:a§*’::, flea %”‘%?’%’§%§?§%:??§ §’§§§§§§”§§&%%{‘5 ya
L–§&f:i§*él:§ aééz-é 1::é*;’;:<*::a§:.-::°%§a:r%%%fik
%,v–..'%§é§%§ £§§§§'%:§€§§f§ 5:25? axaméfiaé fig ffiéfifiifi'
V 'A it §s Em giaa gf 3% giaéaiifig iifzait $23 §§:*t§%'%&s%
"_ i§5$i§3' 'éfiggtaé $2 2§,1$.§§$i agiéa 33?; "'?'%z% isfiiafiig $3?
'"Ei:i.§§ '%s%§f§é§§§ §§$§§'§'§' iéifiééfiifi fig? E§"3§%"$ 'ég a §§E"§§'EE£3?"§§ *~s§§:%§%:
wm §as;§§:§§§3s &§$€%§§ §?§§§§%§§€i éfimgeif arm? §;§§ gm»: §;'%
%"'fi§§:%€'§§ 4%?' aéé fig §%*§§§;*§§a$ §%%"§%§;§ fig ézémi '"??*sa 3?
V
Chiakkafifimmaiah is ales a s¥gr;a£cry f:$ Ex}-'*1.
Acccsrdingiy, pksint 'A' scheduk prcspertées wara allabbaé to
the pkéntiffs' mather' namaly, fiarakfa – the
piairst 'B' schefiuie prcparties aessem aiiatteé "
of the defsrzdants 2 ta 4
wife and Em 'C' schaaduia srupertia§$«V§v£$.§févra;is§fi6L§v
snaintenanace of hinweif and i:¥§"~~s¢:eA§id.__§v£Efsé'f~§s;fé%ar11ifia.
The Tria£ zicsurt same c:),2':–:.;:.$:§::':i'~-.t_§-safhz' E§t.?.}..%;e£r:g an
unregistered dacLsrrxe:*:{'fi.~_._;1r:'é::.i; intc far the
purgose af paritii?:f§fis&*e.._ It;:'$i§6 he iacxkefi
irate 3113:: fa; :1" '
reassning retarded by
the Tr§ai'£_:_e'urt.'?l5¢f.'Arri§ii:§%ia¥"on racers! wouié Show that
Exg?15;*3§s isi:iA?art§."by '§arth the patties. Evar since the
. V. "'ex;etu;fi£d–:'2'AoF' E;;(.P§.;5£5t«V?1 sf than: have bean gngeyéng thair
terms 9!' Exm. Nm.e£t§:st-anéée-;g the
Fa¢f'–..§§ha:.~Ei_§',:§¥§:' $5 an urtregistered éaczinmrst, the fact at'
""~.__ '§¢veraEz;ésf status, the pmws-ties being éfividezd and each
x :"§§na.éf aha parfim anjmfing fiieir reayactisee shares waialé
_§::_€i§eate ;3ar¥:it§on. Therefara, the mare nanwrsgéstratian
% waafid mt irwaiidate the garfiténn deaé smaiy on the
gr-suné that it wag wt 3 registemd écttaimargt Hence, the
9%
18
finéirzg 9? fine Triai Caurt an the said issue requires ta be
reverseé,
12, The Yriai Cauri: aka zartsiéawé EXJBI
the ‘#333 set up by fits éefendants. The
that C:§1ick5§&.L;:eci.,, V
am said Wiil an 3.5.1987 in faveu?-af*5f:f1:éV &:fe:¥=e:sd::g;:~.{}tsA%’L%%;-;.,§ae;~§_
7. fiawevar, éi: is to: txe seen 2;§&8;V_ no Aiwsze to ” L’
the vafidity Q? the WEB was fraVm駔vb?”«tbe .T*fé%a§.§:eVsA:;3rt. Yhe
semnd wifie ‘-Smt. Barautr°2.§T:a;’~ eviéance has
stawé that i’:e:f*_:’§’e;_1sfi»a:;r*:”§” wha was
aged at the_rei¢7{é:sf§§:~;.g3¢si§§?f_A_:csf. ‘tin1a1f”‘;%::as:’§*§$t érz 3 fit sate of
mind she does; mt supper:
the caseffif thé rss;;?fi.éiVi:§Ti:ig:tfa*§”enéa:§$ in swpart of Exfii.
Even_th0éug¥{“t§§a’Vé§:i§¥enVéé af D.Wg1 is against her mm
‘*§n£s’:*%t::,/,”L€:?m.A.5amé f:§é aw: wrarsgiy appreciatsé by the
I?ia_§_ = ‘f’ i-::e “:«.e5¢2-e, mnsidering hfie materiai 9:2 regard
asédi vieraa? éixa specific statement at’ B.*s€sf.1 – Bcramn-:3,
mntfiééz’ es’ tha defersdana with regard 1:9 the heaith of
“‘}:i?i_A§E:’_>_§1j’§i.;sbr+a:1é cm tbs éate cf e-xamtisn af Exam ciaarfy
% “~,.._ §§§:a§3§shas that Ex.D1 is wt rm fwm suspicicm. ma
» satire avidanca wiflx rwaré two E3331 has has’: mnsidaracé
fiy the Yréai Caurg, but rm issaze has keen frarzmé for
3/1/-
5′.
5
11
wrssideratison, which 52 a reisvemt faster in datgarrrtigzing the
5%; it
23. 1: is scam in am evkienca of 2% we
fiaat during the fife-time :3? her husband, 3 Pa
hefié in the viiiage and the efdseriy-Infiemhgifs
and athers were prasant daring t%§A£2V_F§§$§§:A&ha}?§§§1;~ %1e-m
Panchayatia was effecimd 133 Efi%».,§33§i§fE€.§§CIf§ fiff u§s.: ¥¥ Mir’: sjthe ‘V V
grassnce 0? harsaaif azgdfiar ‘;s§s*c#§e%f+-F4’E*a2»s§£<§<aA" 3"" zaéife. She
has further stated fimt ' 5fit7¢__'sa'fd exacuted 18
yam"; prior ta §he];'da_te e§f§&ué3';%:;:fs5V' far the fast 3.8
years er éifiéikiéthgmmaiah haé suffered
a paraigfffrfl' staying aicrmg with fiar
hashand? g.'V13fe::':e:!a__:r*;'§;A:.LjV':'*:i<:: _.'1.:_ §a'::fi was fucking after him. In
reganf. flié .y:é§:a§i.:t§érr2 i'r::u§ Ex.D§, the evidemta :2!" Smt.
""$¢ré§:§1'ma; fiame§3§AiF;"%F.1 vsroafid therefow ::£ea{Iy indicate
regarding the exacutsars 3%' Exfii,
t:e§9:i»:§:1: is her interest. She has herzefi aérnitted
"'-.-» §1at th'e___Ae§xacutia:2 at' am: is against her Eaterest. "fire
' T"':é_Aa§§,_'§{i?§denacaa requires is be accagated especiaiiy in xéevss <21'
' 556$ that she is tha wftnsss far this dzfienéants.
W
12
14. Tha avidence cf Smt~Boramma, win: was #333
secarné wife and mnther at’ the defersdanm 2 to 4 is :9 the
effect tfmt she denm the exeafitém of Exfll narne-j{!y.’V_f§:;2
witi in favwr cf defaandari-3 S m 2?. Hcwevegy
1:913: the Fanchayath Parikath vide_Ex,_P1 335$’ ‘ V
3%! the parfias ccrmerneé, Fzsrthefi $¥;’_er ~s§u;$;3:§:r£%’:!§’é:”L_c§§e.j
cf an-e piaintiffs with reg&rd _ta_ tkzuax’-e’:i<sr::_:t:'%;;:f':?i %%k.1;;§%kkgx%;91.
Hawever, the Triai cosuft ;§cce 'p€:;E§§.R§f.? am the
gmund tfzat it was n aA£«– §%;agiss}V;':f:a;2f;:aa;1H"a£;$; ::a:f:nei: be ¥:3ok;eé
inks even fer ;:¢¥fa£jerai:_pa::;p§:sev; "§{fa;'!§:£}.'::".f:"e':£*e§:1abnva, the
finding of tifns the executiorz of
Ex.?1 §s__§r%&:r§éa%i3§5 fitegaricai statsmarzt
snada B==3:'§Véf;$Vfr:§1:,: hersalf with regard tn: the
aémissimfz E.'=;.?'},, be heid that fix.?i has been
va§§§£§g' §pms.ra$. ~ _
~. 'éftréétenéad 5? ths daafarzdants that thus scrfihe
.V of E'S:';D2–. f§aLs bea:1 axamified afi BfiA?.4. 53! relying am his
,éVf*€5*$f2Cfi; hE sufiméts that £3,%%',4 was the stamg verifier
'a':x;§7"y¥és prasent when same was axeauwé ané ha was mat
VT asséare {sf ti-'ya fast fimt Chikkathimmaiai-s was a pa:*aiytE:;a£
V " gatieat arid he was nest in 3 pasitim mt meagre' Therefiare,
34"
3.3
ha caatméa %ha%: 323 aizaiamafi made $3; B.%%€.% V–:*;:;§s
aersfirarg m tfia ezsiéargca 3? §§’§.:§.’, wfia
C§’zEZéka§%simm&Eai*: ¥-mé ggifiareé garaéysig aw %a§a’gé§_?:i2r°s§:b§EV%” M
%”£”§$’%f£.
Ea; fir: the asfiae? izanfif $393 iézfisfééé; ::m>; :5f:_5 e¥~§¢:::*yV
§%a§:’s§é§’§s fig: piaaérag re§§§:2::.a asfs-¢}§?§$ *§§;;§%§a*9;;€’vv;¢:é£:té’§§j§Vé§it’V 3?’
gm éafaézdanéass mt2te:%§$~..;*.;%:at:V§éé%’%’::é.%’2j’ €§€ii$§§:3§aA§é§”‘?§$ .1 was
Siaiiiiég with bég Em w§fa’§:3§5:a?:zz;%:«aT§ _.§§’:.é%’;;.;§f”_§h:3 wing was
§$$§€5¥”§§ after §§§§:;4,’@§;’§é;.g§~; Em §ég§.2:’§ g.;_g’%§i;s;sa; d{“__g}j’p:ara§§it%: straéwzafi
Er: v%e%*sM§¥?2é* ‘§%;’%¥é aamaiy, éfiarakka, the
g-rs$ti’;e§* 5%’. S’:-駧§E%%%§§3%;V’–.i§”aé%e:5 the Z55 wig as §$;*3:’r2ma,
§$’§$t§’E€V§’f éf zééé g§e§gegs§al%:v;%e:’%%2 sg 5 2a:%’2a hag mm mar Em
“~:s§a%§ ?%§?i£e;g i§3ais’§%£r%tten fiifiifimfifii $1′ $29 2” vésiffi
9i§fa*rVa:’:?%:§§$s;,_:f¢é?1c:,_Vwag iéae gwarasgz §’é’§%§ iaakw aim: him
e*é§iwi£:§’ ‘%%1a$v_%3§£%?;.V_aéaiffieraé a §&§”‘§i?i§€ §:m%:§ §°’%§i.§§?$$ ta Ea
“;s__j:1::::a§2:e~A§;’;;’%i%*;;a fiza aégesza mg flame 2% 5535 aiceraéseg tfie
‘ éi§A§;éf§%f§~;-«ga :3? arm etéwfim with faéatim in §*sé§ éggaéth gr
..__””§t§”:%mése% magmas a gasarrgémy cansééaratéen. E-¥er:ce§ {ha
gav%anz§ gf Q,1?¥fi mafia: $3 a€§$§:§é,
$731 Fm’ the aferssazifi ?&3Efim$§ 3′ am e? :;
fiaififiéééffié Vééw 2%? 3% ‘§:*§a§ fiaéérk éws -T
14
array’ in misraadérzg the mataeréai svidafica an resoré in
i1a£d§r;g that Ex.?1 has net been pravefi fig: the pmazgrss.
The reaaanirzgs given fiy Ewe Trfai iiaurt are uz’:ssss_t:z:;é;:-:.a_;fs§_e.
The piaéntiffs have rightiy e.stah§ished the
&x.P1. Ever aims fins exxuizion 952:.P1,_.*t?*eva– §»’§fti£é$’*.ar”§” ” 2
enicying their respective sharei, i~iz;:’:n:?is,«5§ ‘a’锑r’:'”e+.,.~§A.~..[j%,..?:i”3s’».3_:A
cansidered View that 3ud§r¥:§¥2tuaf¥é-Eiés:ifi=’§fA..¢:i;”§3.§ rim
Caurt requires ta be sefi asidey
‘fha judgment
:3. Acwmingsy, aha’ gm: $
and dacrea by the Civil
Jud§e{Sr.3::x)’ Ramangaram, in
a.s.:am.24s_{19tfi”‘ m«.%%%gu;: af me
apgazsaracarpiaanaag Es’€s§f§1″$”ef 5):. $1.
1
sov-
IUDGE
=
