Lakshminarayana vs State Of Karnataka on 22 July, 2009

1
{$3 “E’}£E EEG}-‘i €;§Q7UR*T SF E{AR?§fi;T’A§~’;f%. AT B§3s..E’é'{}AL{3§€E§;

DATES TEES ‘THE? 21236 .1}??? OF’ EEEELY 2889
BEFQRE

THE HONBLE MR. JUS’FI{j,’;E: ARALE ” %

CR:M1:w:A:L APPEAL 2:40.124%€:3,z;2′:;s{):$»A.T.fjj . ‘ A

EETWEEi?§*=I:

E.’ LaZK$hm§31ara§;ana.»’
S330′ Kandappa,
38 y€a1’s..

2:

S 1′ <2, Sfii:'1?.§1i'1§'.§§1ilZ1IiE3IiI1a§
years; ~ " –~

3.. _ Ré:E§n2.a%:_1fia,
‘ ‘ ~ 1%’ f a.1.;a.};si’:rn§:1ara.ya::a.§

V 2 Aggii abé3;;é:’QE> §;€3.E$$e

_ ~

‘ GT; Scxfizzihi ‘E°’hippm1a,
.~ ahaui 38 yaazg,

” fi§E am £’€$i§fifii”S :3?

Ja:?s:big€ma:*adaha§}.§,
{[§:::ii§;::a11d€ Taiuk,

§{<}}aI' §§S'£ri{:t_ ,;~'%P?ELL-fi&'<5'TS

{B32 Sm: N. ?adma¥a€hi, Adan;

(

in

State: af Eiaznafiakag
By Ciuflibande P€)fi{3C

{Rap 3:; ieameg SP?) R::”:S%%{::;%§4T:}£::~éT

(By Sri AVE Ranlakrishila, ‘

This Crixiniiza}; Appfiai :3 f’i1e»:*;.wVm;gi3.’?%{§’}’:’.{:?E§;’§?€;'”:.Vp:f3;§é;:’1§*’

to 55: asiéfi tbs: j’i.1{igE§;i€I}i ziafiati j18.’?.a”‘_i;72€3–0″E’3 ;t.§::§: PEI,

383833113 Judgé, Kcrzizgr, in Si’) ?éEg:g-¥_.{:a:::1vi”:::i;ii:g the’ ”

aypellantsfaccused far fl}.€ *=;’}§f€i’1{:€’S. 1:%f1:f$x3§=£3$«§:, i’304–§§”Z§?€3
arid :1/3.4 grid 6 9f the ~..Ac§: a31_dV$é:?;té:5};Ci:~2g’ %:h€:::; ta
Lzzgdazga SI fer a periztxé sf Ci1?1§i1 §zf€ar’mf1éi’5ts gay 3. fine zzef
?;3.:2g{}%{},s’~» for the aifences;p,!1,:;’;’$.1%§8é. .’§§’€_7§ azfzd S€i’i{.€E1CiI}g
than: {:0 :1z1<i€:'g£3 SI f3f:'._4_&'«.§3@:'.;i0d;. ;c§'f–«$_a:¥g*t::€} yearfi fag" {he Qffancas
p,f:.1j$,3€}4B EPC arid f:::f;:ér._é:@:1i.:1§.7g1;s ‘:%.a<;*?_; fQ1"*'é.h§V'@§f€:nC€$ §3j':,1;'s.4 amcé 6
0%' the ET},?, fi::f:.z§fia:?:_ ?:{3;_€::;;}13;fy'g2t« §§:'2é:*–;0i:' R:;.'2,{}{}€}j – §:2f–zi’ said fiflfi azs-zarésd ffii’
Eheaffazzaa §V>,:””a:s/’§;;%_§8A_V~-..__§§?€;§ -~’aa:; 3:} $.63; 35 5} izé’ $1.”??? §§s:*:%,,
a<:<:;;$cd §~E:::n_} 7f'§:;e;*;=} 3&3}; 'Tf1V;:{:fi*:5:* ::g:'1ii{:rgs Si fan? 3; pariascé 0%' six
:E:m:'£;§1$' :::"a<:§:;; f%i51::.3ac§z, :5'? §§;1€'vvQf{*€f1C€$, 9:23;}; {ha sabazaéiiivé
$CIEi$§;i§:;?€S §1"_:la?§.'§–v_a}§.c:i;,€ ':{:;§:._ ccyizcazmfimfiyfi

._ gaming 0:: far qiigttaiing juégtzgzaamsihia

{Egg figs. :::m~: éefivared firm fafiawizzg;

a§§;EE}GI%:§EZ’E§’§”E”‘

3 = ff.-“§’E1$ acmssaé Séfisi §Z%1§ % i::: Sessiagza {Tiagez §%z3’:}Jé%E§/ E§%§%

$3”: Eha fiie sf {ha Earned ?:’i::<:%g;:ai §f,SSi§§1S $:,:(.%g<4:, Eiaéazg

ihesrfiiizgiier :'€fe:"§*€e:E 33 as $13 "fifiiaj ééaiugfi" far §{'ii'}E°"%;';} haw:

€:§*_;a.E1€ngé:ci {ha cayragmesg 3%' {he ééiiigfiifiiiiz 3.51:1 £":E"fi€'i' {sf

6"–(\"'"""""'

3
cQ:”:vi(::i.:>f: and $:=:1’1£€:1:.::e dazeé 13.3.2993 paggeti ;§.}fi’.T€h€ gaifi

case {:*omz§{:t.i1″:g §.’%1sz;1 3}} §.::::* iiiaa :}f§’es”:c:«:s iEi”}fifi§?”§;:’i€§§;§i_§i’§3_ %<98£a,

:;%{}%§% 1336 am} $€c'£:i:1$ 5% $5 6 :}f Eéswrgf 33$

2. Staifzd in b:’i»::f the (sass éisf’tf§::”§”§::*QSa’?:§é111:.§€;::”€W%;:~:%_ 3E§€g${i ‘

1:} {tie mpia;}”:’i:, E}<I.P} V€ié;if::c§ §;'2._6;f%.,§'~}4 13:; "aha
mmpiainargé §i:Ei§}}€§§;" 1 %'«s::1}<a*§aI"a;:::.;4ma,:r:§:2a, "the
msiher sf 'she fieéeaméi'SrgztlE§ia.:§:§adé:¥iv"%.5 "sag 1EZ'§€§€f':

_ was givezi in zfiarzéagsr :0
E153" marfiage with him '@233
gsérféfjgziagi %:§;. V§§;<~:',i* §g:§§f<"::1'{.s an 2835, 3.992, 335% has: beam
'§',.'fl»-."i? m5:§:::::f; $3 Sim. Eéiathzzaznma has been the aidar
é'5i1:»féLi::~::§;* sf A52' f§';'i:1§9asizi;ha:nur%.E:§*. 5.} La%{$§m3.ina:'a};a:1a§
'VVE%§é:::E41f:§ "E§f%§:'* 'i;:.1_$ba11é 0? A3 ?"§&E'&§i8&}8fi1§I§8;, ES {ha Gihfii'
fl '-.Vréi1a1_::i§.§%€ ';%;%£; A2 §V§aY&S§§11Ii3&§fl°§iZ'Eh}', aha E1"::$%2a;§1d sf {ha

-~ {Ea-.{i§iav3é:<i.

.. V’ L. 3%’-‘ : sfiftar E363? ifiarriage with $2, ififi §e{::€a$ef:ai §i:a:’§&§

_A”.-Estagfing iii ha? xzaatriingmiaé hama aiamg with him: amfi his
333*; rz-*:§a€.i2r$$. ‘E’hq::2§g}1 £3 fiaragfarzanzmas {ha skier
sister ézéf 3:23 wa$ gfviarz E2: mlaziiagé ii; GEES

éa§§$%m:;§z:afaya:1a :31’ E-iasasheiiéfghafii ‘ifififigfiy she was

~.

.-~.r””~”~v=

§%a2::23.}:r§sE1:’:a, Eaarnazi ‘éiégh; Cfliifll {}<3v€2*z1:11{:I';§? ?1r3;9.{ie:r*f':"'I:;:=»3.f"'=*:§€::+:A4

Siam ami gezmzsatgi ma impugleti jtzdgnent and 3}sT–:f{"Lhe:'T "

mafizériai :§'<3::::'zd in ihfi arigixiai rzecord <:v:'i;:'Ea;3*;m;eci5_4§'2*:§:§:" 't§:é'TréaE'v..

_ Céziraré;

3%., ‘_§’h€ pmrztg ‘£313: Wauicii ‘”i’+::,:r :”r:3r-ri;eV€:::If:I;if;,aii’ér§ iii
this appeal are:

{i) ‘iFJ%1et%’1€r the ‘E’r§.a3 €Z<§z;:*: f£«'+?€;S E33 {:::':m:"i:;:§;§ng
tbs ac€:L1:s_r::'a:§._ N{3§;4;"i" ~:("; ~"–"I%.}§".r_:_s1' *;:h,§: <3ffc:1{::<: under

Sé€:%iie':1A. §E7'<_.,"';' »2,=§i'i:1'101'iiV"frafi:i:1g sspecéfis: charge
against: 3:h.€..;;:'3_» Af{.:::j "said aifsncss '9

{ii} Wh6E}:_€F _ '{'}E'€f §T§'§.a§:~ ('Z::mri ,\fu:'fh€.r jEg$%;§§"3§:"3 ii}
V<:gr:v1?c:i'i.;1_g €3.11 tifm accused; N03. 1 {Q 4 Sitar aha;
.._%.pi'f{~::"1ce i..:f1~::§er Ser:t§<m 5:98 A ;EP€ffi.'?
{§::j;«.. _ '%'§,If1:*:ii3§:£*~–. fghe Trig; £30133': ,\f1_:I'the:* gézzgiéfifié in
' " é::;:i:§ic:?i:%g:..aceusfid Fiaswi ta 4 501’ the Gfffifififi
‘-.’§iflV(i€}”.;’,§{*;€fZ;J’i§{}I1$ 4 and éx af §GWEf§? ?r0hib2Z”fs.i0n ;%{::.’?

–V “?, E2/§j;é3;::;;é§i:§g$ <33}. fizesss: Efiifiifi era as Eizifiaér:

AA ' in the "negative?

“iii; in the ‘wegatisre’
{iii} Ea {he “negative? as 3:; §G§1¥§Ci§{}£”1; fan’ the
Gfffiflfifi E.1j$§.é 332% in tfsaa ‘affirmative’ as {g
{:r.:m,vi{::’£§m1 fer {E25 §f’§’€§:é:6: ‘:3;’$,4- sf {E26 E}?

§§.c’i,.

3:2″ “$33.:-é sariezis {3{f=1’i$€(f§3J?jfiC€3: w%1§. ‘G#§:{i;_:3;§;:: A’

aariiézr She wa_$ $u”Q§E5te{§_ £0 ‘i%:a§’*§:$3:1:<é:¥::L.. "'§:{y °:%§?&r

h2_:.3ba1f3.<:i with tiamand fer ée':;2§?i";f, s::{{:i"::_ §"11;ES.§§é&1:'§jéVV§*§'{'V)E,T£§§
has gmfity sf' £116 eifemzegn §}1§.–£:§i1g:g:a.g& Q1" 'S5:::?£ic::.:31 304-B
{Pi} read with Sectiefi '1_1: 3_~B._é:)fj_5;}fié'*–}§3'i{i€3:'§C€ Act. But. if

ihfi murdsr sf his wife &§_:"g;3§._acii§1.§££13f'~at:fbii1:ii–it?.:€d fiithfir "by

a fiaagié. <::§"'Ei:§f;Ta a fé:§*Gré.si act tins: husbanéi
€213.11 'ieafi €:2?i::i'6::1§{:éj'ii{§ £113: £16 had no fiaiié in hag"
<:Ee=:at%f: at :33, %+Ef}i£~'; _:i§i,:;::<:€:;é§3;s Era. d§s<;:h.argi:1g {ha b?_z:*{i€:§"s, <1?

prises? 7f?:{3:_§$ not §é.'b }E ha {f{}F,§Vi€§.€(i {Hider S€Ci§€}I1 334-

-B, “if “figs: h:.i§b’35i1d ix chaxgad ezrzkjsz zmfiar SSCEEGEE

Z§§%32? gm ¥:>ur<;i€:: E0 grfififi that his Wiffi was

:13;-:1¥':*s*.:.%=%e§'v{E5:€:§ "E.i}{<::"Jthat". as E36 sax} have E133 tssaiiitiegai

iififéfifiév-,_' tha §§'{i%$€€Ef§.§{33;": hag faficd ts; girwa fiat:

*::?";a:r'gé .{:§?' :?:::i:*:i%€:* agaimsi. Eaém 321$ @3331: 3:2 Qféiifi" 0%

" _' é':L€3{§'%L§f€_§ffCé§j:v "

33. *'”}”‘?:e aésve iiiiisimticiz iii-‘G¥;fi§ 3ZI§§3§f}r’ 15.3332:

u g:*22Vi’€3; 9?’ {ha {3{)IZS€€}E}€i”iCii befafiifig an a{:C”i1$é3{§ if he

was Giiifif agkeii :23 ciafafici :9; Qfzarge zzrzzier $€€3{§€}f§. 3&2

…..,,_(“”—\—-W-v

§§~”£T.i 3g”::s:% wag aE*:.m”, a,z1f~,~’ E?.{}§.§{I€i’ €12′: ézim, ‘$€a’:2;:3;$;e;”‘§1;,;:’:’i$<i€g3fi¥*§i*§2§30:’tm3.§E§s’ is {§i8§§§”{3″w€€; “‘$§1: € «%;:i;:*{§§:«:: {:é1:%*§,’$151 %::”:i:1 ‘

3:}? Eazaf. ”

7:3 ?:?'<}§E{;§::€i.L: %~§:::n’b_E::
S:,::§}:re:1:a:: €.’E:_:.’:*%. E3: §’.’§:<»:~ &:zi:';:3;:':;:3»§S<i*f:_~_,V 233:: {,%mz1a3i: Ex: cézarggs wag §”;:;:z;€£§;

s;?;a3E2′[::»;’i:. é:.*§’::”; {E-){“i i”.§:2a€_; was fraznazi
§:g§aé§:a:§%:._ 4 A

A 7;;3;[” §%3§3§;.:2*:’§12g {:3 :;:§§:’:»:. £2}? {E26 :~§a%_{§ §::{§gg:”2:&:’;’£’,3 €313

“§%’ié;’§*:’3.€:.{% §C’5J{‘i§”‘B§E’.i€§§i§1 §3§s:a:i_:–::* {:s”:I:%ifi:’_;<§é:€§ §,E;";:..3i:T if éfsaég

. {§{:%,:§*%I"E":sE{§§;'*:;?.:§:%. $152. ajggggggiéfigmw {"i£§%§;§{§ f§'E{E§'. izag-'$3 2}:-252:: :;:%::é:é<:i§3::E

§Z§'"3.§_':f €3§€:2@{=: :n:z:::§sz::' ifii-:<:%E;§{§:2 ;§§}<'1'%% SEE??? fifiii §}i:a£§'§'.'5£.?:5'£' 75::/33 31$} 3:36:

-f.’.–?§%:%:a§:ééé=:i§ $6 3.236 “?§”%a3 {rE€~§f£;E-{YEA ‘§J§;§lE a, s:3;Mi:*€:{:§;M3E$zz’: 3%; §2}1’€§{:€:€€’§

” zéigfaéfigi %;E;;€~: a;”s§3€iE:;:§::.3 ~ a::{:é.:$s:e:§ §§*{3:.:3 {E15 giaga <2? 5 Eh?

E§’i?’§d€?§’:{fi€§ z§<:::.

£3, £1: ég :10? in {iis§;11té tE:7a:’E §f;;%€: J

Efazriasievi éiéii Wimjzl E’W{} t§,’§:é§I.,”«{fS 9f”-E3553 _§:L3r1″*:i:éig::. éésiih £22′
E–=”¢.3.r'{§1er, ‘the fact “aha: L21: psé:iEa:1f£,$ 5«_’:ic;c’:.:s$E1″§\Eég3= -§};;:sf1% hazyéé: baa} Qzzmzictezi far
SEEK? aifericar. *::%’:Q_ié..¥.?.. .’;§Séc.€:;r;§”:–~.._498$ :22″: the: geigné am $26
§?{}S€{‘;’iN1 ‘§,i(“}§7§’hE?cS ‘§’f§:”£fl_&§;3.E§fi””‘§C{§ pmve b€§;’Q:1é §’s«:a3§::a’Ei:§e éigzzbi
$3536 §3:9;{:im:’:1,__€}f_ §,§§§:’é;3fi{:’2::%i;:<2;t gi"s.r'€5'I;% 3:3; $16: &::c':,.a:§€,-':e:i {:3 $163

A £4; . E:f; ézxfcktr :5; see izshafiier ihi': zgéaitsrr zéeaszrvésg is be

;:*£T:§_3f::i%.:f;aiéi%§"~ _g;gffiiéa Tafiai £39131'? far gérocefidizzg wig': thé: €336

_§'r<}:;<:""*€,E;<*_:. siaigs af iiafezzce fiviéengt: :0 E98 éztdéiiifjfiiii 'Q35' fiiié

a§:<tL:%§;¢<§ erdér €152 ré:2:m%, $325 §}}f'€S{};I§}.}}'iI§§I1 mat. has :9 fie

against aha acczzgazi s;11d5:r $@{:t}§:3§:. M38 {inf {ha

~ V'_E§"§':{im"1ce Eaci, E E3393 :9 finci €312: '«.3'§.§'1€fi"1fiI' {E16 §}E'GS€Q'E11i§{}1'1 has

péazcéizi an §*es{2r'¢:% évidézziite Szjiiisiezié; {er} haid that the eiazréasfid

M

E4

mcerds éifidefifi that his eXa:";:iz1aE:i0m~i§1~chi€fj%;a;é;$5 ifz:C0raied

an 36.1.2082 aziaé his crass éxafliinatian wsajé (i:*;'f17:<Véz'€*éa:i;."_T<:I;:'vi*,a}/13":

éajs at. Eha §'€qEi€S"£ (3? {ha iearxififi»-.£:@::';1$ci§ ";£*épfé:S.€§1€i+3g'

accused and zhereafier, his prégeiicé' séi3£;§–.n§t" ?;s€:C1.:z'e:3

§m'ing {amber ma} <31" {}1eVc:€§SL?_%§vhié:E1 a£v:§:"i_: aTs}th %§1c»$§<;§i&$ Caififi to be
heard' 'E'h&:*efQm, 'i;§1e4"£§:%_§.a1–'iI?,<;§t;;rt ebserved at para

Fifi. £8 Qf iEs_.vjfe.–:;dgm€i,fi: 2 was not subjected to

amss'éxé:I:§:i.ati{i%%fi 0:1héhaif6?the accused, mg evidenae in
axa:11i:';ation«i115€:?;i%:§ 1103: ha aansidfirad. '$111.13, {hem

E'€E3{}:€~'s;_§3f1S §iiiy_V't1':§'.'$ari:;i€f'i§<:a sf §3Ws.§ and 3 is 5.

Smt. 'ifenézataranzanamma, the IE}£:¥£ii'1€i' af the

'.:ifé5&3.$fai3re:1ts anti they used is £34363: hm” bf; beaatiizg and bf?’

naarriage with a£3CU;S€fi    1"I3.3I*fi€{i
Eff: far few flags 3:143   fi1~§ma.i;i::;g
her by bea:;ii:r._g    ;'§3"%{€}isiii3i;:§g:V.fé her {ha i.%11"1::}§ feed