Lalan Pandey vs The Union Of India &Amp; Ors on 30 August, 2010

          IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA

              LETTERS PATENT APPEAL No.1621 of 2009
                        IN
                   CWJC 7364/2009

       ===========================================
        THE    STATE    OF     BIHAR   THROUGH     THE
       COMMISSIONER-CUM-SECRETARY          DEPARTMENT
       OF COOPERATIVE, GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR, PATNA
                          Versus
1.     PRAMOD BIHARI S/O SRI RAMASHISH SHARMA R/O
       VILL.- JHUNATHI, P.S.- ARWAL, DISTT.- ARWAL
2.    RAJENDRA PRASAD SINGH S/O LATE JWALA PRASAD
       SINGH R/O VILL.- ASANI, P.S.- UDWANTNAGAR,
       DISTT.- BHOJPUR
3.      SHYAM NARAYAN SINGH S/O LATE RAM NATH
       SINGH R/O VILL.- AARRAWATI, P.O.- SAKALDIHA,
       DISTT.- CHANDAULI, UTTAR PRADESH
4.     RAMJI CHOUDHARY S/O LATE TILAKDHARI
       CHOUDHARY R/O MOHALLA- SAHID BHAGAT
       SINGH COLONY, MUSTAFABAD, P.O.- GAYA, P.S.-
       RAMPUR, DISTT.- GAYA
5.    KAMAL KISHORE LALIT S/O LATE BRAJ KISHORE
       PRASAD R/O VILL.- BABANBIGHA, P.O. & P.S. -
       BARBIGHA, DISTT.- SHEIKHPURA
6.     BIHAR STATE COOPERATIVE LAND DEVELOPMENT
       BANK LTD. BUDHMARG, PATNA-1 THROUGH ITS
       MANAGING DIRECTOR
 7.   THE CHAIRMAN BIHAR STATE COOPERATIVE LAND
       DEVELOPMENT BANK, BUDHMARG, PATNA-1
8.    THAT MANAGING DIRECTOR             BIHAR STATE
       COOPERATIVE LAND DEVELOPMENT BANK LTD.,
       BUDHMARG, PATNA-1
9.    THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR (PERSONNEL) BIHAR STATE
       COOPERATIVE LAND DEVELOPMENT BANK LTD.,
       BUDHMARG, PATNA-1

       ===========================================
                        with

         CIVIL WRIT JURISDICTION CASE No.7056 of 2009

       ===========================================
                   VIJAY KUMAR SINGH - Petitioner
                        Versus
                 UNION OF INDIA & ORS- Respondents

       ===========================================
                         with
        CIVIL WRIT JURISDICTION CASE No.1730 of 2010
                    2




      ===========================================
      BIHAR RAJYA SAHKARI BHUMI VIKAS BANK
      SAMATI,    BIHAR     AND    JHARKHAND,BUDH
      MARG,PATNA-800001          THROUGH      LAW
      OFFICER,RAMASHANKAR SINGH,S/O LATE BAIDYA
      NATH          SINGH,         R/O        VILL
      &P.O.NARWARA,P.S.TARIYANI,DISTT-SHEOHAR
                       Versus
1.   THE STATE OF BIHAR
2.     THE CHIEF SECRETARY        GOVERNMENT OF
      BIHAR,OLD SECRETARIAT,PATNA
3.   THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,FINANCE DEPARTMENT
      GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR,OLD SECRETARIAT,
      PATNA
4.    THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,MINOR IRRIGATION
      DEPARTMENT       GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR,NEW
      SECRETARIAT,PATNA
5.   THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,DEPARTMENT OF
      COOPERATIVE      GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR,NEW
      SECRETARIAT,PATNA
6.   THE REGISTRAR, DEPARTMENT OF COOPERATIVE
      SOCIETIES       GOVERNMENT OF BIHAR,NEW
      SECRETARIAT,PATNA

      ===========================================
                       with

        CIVIL WRIT JURISDICTION CASE No.15541 of 2009

      ===========================================
1.    RADHA MOHAN SINGH S/O LATE AWADH BIHARI
      SINGH VILLAGE AND P.O.- HARADIAN, P.S.-
      JAGDISHPUR, DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARA
2.   LALLAN PANDEY S/O LATE AKALU PANDEY VILLAGE
      AND P.O.- HARADIAN, P.S.- JAGDISHPUR, DISTT.-
      BHOJPUR, ARA
3.     LAXMAN PANDEY S/O SRI BISWANATH PANDEY
      VILLAGE AND P.O.- HARADIAN, P.S.- JAGDISHPUR,
      DISTT.- BHOJPUR, ARA
4.    ASHWINI KUMAR SINGH S/O LATE RAM DHYAN
      SINGH VILL.- AMSARI, P.O.- AMSARI, P.S.- MURAR,
      DISTT.- BUXAR
                        Versus
1.    THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH THE SECRETARY
      GOVERNMENT       OF     BIHAR,   CO-OPERATIVE
      DEPARTMENT, BIHAR, PATNA
2.    THE REGISTRAR CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES, BIHAR,
      PATNA
                    3




3.    THE BIHAR RAJYA SAHAKARI BHUMI VIKAS BANK
       SIMIT     BUDH MARG, PATNA THROUGH ITS
       MANAGING DIRECTOR
4.    SRI P.K. SINHA, JOINT REGISTRAR (MARKETING) CO-
       OPERATIVE SOCIETIES, BIHAR, PATNA-CUM-
       MANAGING DIRECTOR             THE BIHAR RAJYA
       SAHAKARI BHUMI VIKAS BANK SIMIT, PATNA
5.    THE DIRECTOR PERSONNEL BIHAR STATE CO-
       OPERATIVE LAND DEPARTMENT BANK LTD.,
       BUDHA MARG, PATNA
6.     THE BRANCH MANAGER              BIHAR STATE CO-
       OPERATIVE LAND DEVELOPMENT BANK LTD.,
       BIHIYA, P.S.- BIHIYA, DISTT.- BHOJPUR
7.     THE BRANCH MANAGER null BIHAR STATE CO-
       OPERATIVE LAND DEVELOPMENT BANK LTD.,
       DUMRAON, P.S.- DUMRAON, DISTT.- BUXAR
8.     THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS OF THE BIHAR STATE
       CO-OPERATIVE LAND DEVELOPMENT BANK LTD.
       PATNA THROUGH ITS CHAIRMAN

      ===========================================
                       with

     MISCELLANEOUS JURISDICTION CASE No.2813 of 2010

      ===========================================
                  RADHA MOHAN SINGH - Petitioner
                       Versus
                STATE OF BIHAR & ORS.- Respondents

      ===========================================
                       with

         CIVIL WRIT JURISDICTION CASE No.9757 of 2010

      ===========================================
      LALAN PANDEY, S/O LATE AKLU PANDEY, R/O
      VILLAGE     AND      P.O.   HARDIYA,     P.S.
      JAGDISHPUR,DISTRICT- BHOJPUR AT ARA.
                       Versus
1.   THE UNION OF INDIA THROUGH THE MINISTRY OF
      AGRICULTURE, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
      AND CO-OPERATION,GOVT. OF INDIA,KRISHI
      BHAWAN,NEW DELHI.
2.   THE SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
      AND CO-OPERATION,GOVT. OF INDIA,KRISHI
      BHAWAN,NEW DELHI.
3.     THE JOINT SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF INDIA
      CUM CENTRAL REGISTRAR OF CO-OPERATIVE
      SOCIETIES, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE AND
                      4




       CO-OPERATION,GOVT.        OF      INDIA,KRISHI
       BHAWAN,NEW DELHI.
4.    THE STATE OF BIHAR THROUGH THE CHIEF
       SECRETARY,GOVT. OF BIHAR,PATNA
5.     THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,         CO-OPERATIVE
       DEPARTMENT,GOVT. OF BIHAR, PATNA.
6.         THE    REGISTRAR,     null   CO-OPERATIVE
       SOCIETIES,GOVT. OF BIHAR, PATNA.
7.   THE BIHAR RAJYA SAHKARI BHUMI VIKAS BANK
       SIMIT,BUDHA   MARG,PATNA       THROUGH    THE
       CHAIRMAN.
8.       THE CHAIRMAN, THE BIHAR RAJYA SAHKARI
       BHUMI VIKAS BANK SIMIT,BUDHA MARG,PATNA.
9.    THE MANAGING DIRECTOR, THE BIHAR RAJYA
       SAHKARI BHUMI VIKAS BANK SIMIT,BUDHA
       MARG,PATNA.

      ===========================================
      Appearance:
         In LPA No.1621 of 2009
        For the Appellant : Mr. P.K. Shahi (Advocate General)
        For the Respondent: Mr. MITHILESH KUMAR RAI
                             Mr. SHIV KUMAR (CGC)
                             Mr. ISHWARI SINGH
                             Mr. KISHOR KUMAR SINHA
                             Mr. VIRENDRA KUMAR RAI
                             Mr. BIPIN BIHARI SINGH
                             Mr. KAMLENDRA PRASAD SINGH
                             Mr. SHYAMA KANT SINGH
                             Mr. BINOD BIHARI SINHA
                             Mr. RAGHIB AHSAN(ASG)
       In CWJC No.7056 of 2009
            For the Petitioner: Mr. SRI KRISHNA RANJAN
                                 Mr. ANIL KUMAR SINHA
            For the Respondent: Mr. SARVA DEO SINGH(CGC)
       In CWJC No.1730 of 2010
              For the Petitioner: Mr. SHYAMA KANT SINGH
       In CWJC No.15541 of 2009
            For the Petitioner: Mr. KIRAN KUMARI
            For the Respondent: Mr. RAJESH PD.CHOUDHARY
                                  Mr. BIPIN BIHARI SINGH
                                  Mr. SRI KRISHNA RANJAN
       In MJC No.2813 of 2010
            For the Petitioner: None
            For the Respondent: None
       In CWJC No.9757 of 2010
             For the Petitioner: Mr. MANIMALA
           For the Respondent: Mr. RAGHIB AHSAN(ASST.SG)
                         Mr. RAJESH PRASAD CHOUDHARY

      ===========================================
                                           5




                          CORAM: HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
                                   and
                                  HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE JYOTI SARAN
                          ORAL ORDER

(Per: HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE)

12. 30.08.2010 At the request of learned Advocate General Mr.

P.K. Shahi, stand over to 6th September 2010.

(R.M. Doshit, CJ.)

(Jyoti Saran, J.)
S.Sb/-