High Court Karnataka High Court

Leelavathi vs B L Divakara on 27 October, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Leelavathi vs B L Divakara on 27 October, 2010
Author: K.L.Manjunath And B.Manohar
  gay   ggggg 

 

 §%§{§§:F.g%. $3: E-fi§€{§§E;%f:f§E%?;E:

 

fifi $§Z%§'§'

 

   

fig    1  ',
  §«§@:§*§:§:   

 

 

E

:$m§:«ia;.':%%;§     
Eégia  éiéwfi :&§§%§§§?é%% %%% % 
'?§ m§%$ .' %    
as a&;!§%i'§§§§§;§§§%%i§.f:§§§vE§§§£§:;3§ '§§§%;§ kma
E§a%§'§%é;%,;?;§;§é§.;§%,' $'§"§%'.:*:§'*§7' ~  

   , ~. 

 

Q 3 g%:*§§§.&§§;%A
gagg-gxgaztzx gag gs; L§%?<;§::%.%§
 53? gggasg E§§;},3§"§:Z} gmga

 

 

X 3.; :;§V§;j%:§g§;?§Tw}:§;.~§:%§§€
   
§§£:,§_;§5?§ BE. Egzifiafig.   3% mg
 ;%;g':§%:2§%:§§§ gfiéfgggg Léiéfi  ?§%.E;,.;'£;%
 n T §s'a?:'§§&§.§E§';

 

 

 

§?'%§ Eééii 3 €§"£§§§§  § 3

  

 

 

 2'??? my $2? <"}§'E*%§BE§;;'E€%'%§_:  L' 

 gggf ;%éi:'sfi;.E*%:a§§§§§§:f§§ 'V  1 T T



     fifié 

2

En";

  

*   

am; gag §.§§§£E§E % §s£:§;_g3?:%:;_: ‘$§_§iE§::§s%%Pj?fi_£§§$’$,
mg E3; ‘; ” ”

$§§5%iE§§E$§’§ §§–$t’??2?’; »§§’:§%i §?{;%§?i:j2§. ” %

mg §§g%:?::£E:::%’:3;%39§ 3%.; E4E§’7’€f} Efi,-Z E 3 {T}?

52% §§$.§E;E
§Ei§§.E2§i}3«§%%§§§§%§.E3i%2faE_A_:§.,%~E’¥a§,v:%.@’é§§’? §§§ fig Fag
$3? :’§%§’%;;’;{:§*§5EE’7;::» Jg§§g:z:§*; ggm agfga
§E+§a§§§.§%§ M :%::;§f:?::ii§i3.iE?E:s», *§f’§§.,¥L§;:.§§’§°T §’€;T}§
.

WW’

“E””%§<g%?%5é%{§;;' 53% §"'§§:'; maggg
m"§:Ak§£§fi§§§L;*:::'§%*a;a;'§§?%g,§;%§§::g%;§§§§ " %

i'…'§"§§§%

gmw gfiggegi 2% zirg §%*§§§.:23@§ mg: g:;;@g ggangw

; * §:g:§E::g£€§:s3 g: §::m§§.:§s§;:§§*;

in giggs-$3 by fiw §§\§§$i§%§?§f$;

%:’::a: wax?” ?:t:a¢:E$¥:a §&§§3§}§§$:::: am: ‘$33 pégfizifii

§%§$§”fi@z’2:: “E wag ii 3
6/’

3% 3% ffiiztg iwfiégg ‘fig fizziég mag are fifi .

‘flag giézizz $3?’ fifiiéfi §fi§§3fi.£&fi§S~§L mg 3; ‘:;:f: ‘% * ”

$5 gig Efiélég

gégizzé féfiifiéfg §§*:§§}&§”?£’a:?% 37.35% * §:*§§§r£§% aria

£2: Eiéfézfi fiawzfifig

is $%3.iZ2§,::=:ié:E&, §s§’.’~2:;»*é:**§£:’ 523:’: ‘ in ééia

fig” 3&3 :;as;%;;[g%k%;afi%g::;;@a:%a;§& was ésmi 3::
gm: as {Em ifiiézfiig kafim hag
3&3: Sf fifi Q35 éfiffia

fimiégggjg gfiggiagizgggggg gm azgzéégéafi 3 E33

:§%§:§is;’:%:–«£%&m飧* gffifigfifiimg 23%: fig {gage

212$ .

V -V Q? E}! ififi

u .$§a§$§ gf {Em géigsz

§%§%$ 3&2}: ai’ §’%&§%$fiim§
agaggg g*é:a§%§§§& a ma: $a$§s;,¢§g%§; % 55:» fmmgs
géé §e§$ im§§

131% wmfiifizz gigigmgfii; T%%* figémzié: fim

£1

afizi “aha %’$§&§i{3:£’%$§’:*§§

£6

3?: “fiéfifii

%’és”}:?§°i 5 ‘§’§;$§ gag
(\,/

:3 fffafi §T

fiifi Egiriiééf’ $;§’:é:;’§ §§;$f$::=$§.3.§2’%;§2;»E”–$.§§:§é $”€:s;:§mi%2?;”:§.%§§~

3; jfiéfii §m:::;; gzffi; 33% A

‘. _ “E°:$z§§jjt §i’+;”%.ifia§’§§.

A V ‘ V _ _V ;’3:§3+$§€i”;:§ &« _
% A wig; fig: ;:{:§§f§

asaéagégfiég 2% m gzmm; iié ‘§§”i§ mg;
u u ‘ x

Eiigagzégéi aéiwg $3’: 23% % am fwtéégij.

am jg: gfifiggfigégzz fif fix _§f@iz’:*’§

ififi égafiz $35′

z”‘;%$%’£§fl§§fi 2% T”

fiw §§§&:*:§%;&2:€:$

§§$,;’f€mw§§%§§’7? mt: 133:5 fik

=: zéifi § §§§ ‘g3;§§:é%:2:2; gmé; féfii

2% éififififffiiffi w:§’:E§.i:E2$ ‘V azggaeg-;:

‘a’?;§fi$__ fig .


 

 6? suit fig?'

 

$5 fig 323$:  '
gtaifi     a E': E '(Em

§%$§”§’§:*£’.:i”._%f§,§.%é:’ §§&_–%fi;$é.”‘§::i§ *5{‘§’fi.'{ £23? . _ aim ééfa Efmfiz

%3;* 22m $3232: Sit}?

Q? §.r»%;:*;§§.§%§af%; g aa_§¥:é.

géié §§é§£wé&

— fiaai gm §§ 3:5 E? mgmzm

. gar: 352% ifi

fiat flag mié aéiéai £3

%
E’=}$;fi§§:§§ga§:§:_.:%g.A§’::’ ”
wgtegfl §é;f2;a?’ A’

* % 233$ §::éi£i__g§§§2;”:3g§§ :E3€:’ §::§§a.§§:}t13§3 it’:

»i§’3§§§§s:«:%:%;2%:* gségégzaifif 3% amifi
_

fish

% §%§f.*fi§§§§3§~Z§ §§9i:§ tézsé %§fZ’§:§i§.fii’§ fiigtfiiziffiéi

axapfirgigigrg gag fififiififiéfi zffwii %;f:’2g $1333: ~ 3

éfiifi 3§€§§§E’%. famgiigz §§3’§§§-€’:§’fis% $13.??? £3: 32% H _ ”

§m$:3:”§:_y Q? 21%? §:’&.%§:,§2*= E,

Eggésémgg gm amfiiéaé ‘Ea magi ?’°§i**.:.§;.%-‘:3*’*.4a§€¢%;–*§§ $22 aigém

§;§:’fE §;%:§:*»::: :33’: g:;%f%;”*~;f::*:;g:%@:%%;§;*” 332$ azigxfi 3

if: fix gmgréggj Efififiéfi 5:5 12%

§3%:?:§’i§§i \

2.32:3: fafigwiiig

§$m% ‘§m:% §:’§mz.””?°°a§a;§A,Lj’§?§§j°é%?a«;«:?;;;:v*:;;:=*1;*. ‘kifiafz

3:: ‘%§’§:?;§:iE’:$§ §§§g:izé%;-§§’& :’;f.§$§ 21:31: Ezmugiaé ihé fifiiéffi §$%.:::
§s:”$§E-:9*:ié~;::–~~é;:;:”§§3 Ezazgéa gwg?

£3? §§z’%Z*§.5.m:? E? 3%
fig fig wfiééfia 35:; Egéaéa gzgéi?

?~ $3 §:'”fi:€”.%”*?

§§’§fiE’ 3:5: ¥fi ?:,%$3§%°* $fi§E§2$fi§.?§.Q2″‘§§§

mi? fifi Ev Ea :*$§§.%§

“-fig’ ggz fiififlfiiéfifié :3

V. E}:g?E fig 13$. %§§:-§2::é&’*zt=-§ %'”§§ ag §”§§§*

$3 Efifgfififi £3 wag

‘ éagzéwg wag

sag s § 1: Egg éfifamégfiiwé wag §§§$

5°»

aféi 31% gsmg gggfi; g5§a%::g;i=§;:§§3 asmg éfigézifii E§:$

. _ fig %;%’;é%;: §T§&§

;;:§;::;;?*:;’» éfigzzaaagg aazééé $23 gag giaaé.

sag 3%? ‘§,’,§?;$:§ ffififii’-2% Egg §~§:f;¥§. az:§;_.__§§a

“fig iffifii fiaazfi fififié” mmgéfifirzizg {Egg >§’5§§§%;’é'”§s€3& Eaéiz

mg fgrfifisfig .Z%:§E;é éggzzé Eéfié. Eifigfififi argfi : ”

V$fE”g§:,.:%

{§§:§&3f:é§§°:%:%*’§ Es; % am afiiéiéaai 32$ ma? .

$13 33% aififa ‘

mé <:§&$:*a:%:::,_ £3 §V:é:L._z§a2$€':?::::2'2* if:

8: af iéfifi ggmééagzég %$%:z*$ 23%

g 3&2′-émzg grzfir :21

‘ giaaéafi 5%?

%’§.§i’% §E£§:?;%§§Efi §§*a::2§:%:*’§§ wag téza gag;

3% Lam gag’ fifm A

-«J

:*..x:s§:%§é§§’§.:3 94$ 3; §e§i%::’: famégfi §;:§’¢§:%§*:;:g gs’? §.f:;;:§a§:§§%i§._”fi::§§
0/

gfirzar mwfirmmm $5? iize

23$}: _§:””z§:%:’_~ _

amfiafimafié. :3 ?;:§’%;% Eéigafigu Law; “§E’E$ a:§§§:£:§§:m:é§§ €::€i%§%¥:;$§:§f§%

‘aha: 33% s.§’%.,:£;

mzé fiimrme flag

Em Ez:;§§f?i,%::%g i%:§;éi: $2}; ‘$333 §f%§3;””§§i£”$ agfé’ fig v

flag?’ azézmra,

fir mafia? £55: 11% 1&2

§”%§%§’:%=§%:?§£ éémfi’: ‘%§%:::%..E;_.$.g~; Eitfiifi

kg! 23%

$=_a%£:i£% E33 éwffiiz aim
g” 53% E3

3%: §:§éi§:%§.§ _ §’ii’§i?*”s %%’m.§*»&. g%<?a%;~4.:}§=é2?:g :3

Emir, 2:3 $23 223$ mufi Egg

§_2§:3$§$&é&:% 955$ €§::i$"'-assfémsiaéaé §::*:3;:";$r§§% 335 gm §$?;§f2'§

V. $};::;s3 §%;z*:§¥:fi:* fimazmzfig 2323?. 32%

.%§;=:@:: Ea': £2': E123; $13; § fi§ is; gizfiw

" _ mg: $3' :§*§:%

"§;éf'§ifi jmizfta. mg iéfzgrsa wag 3:25 jaéizai

z 333%; @332». iéza §f€3§§"'?_;.§;§% '%§'a3*E'& asggzgfiffié Egg'

fzgmfiga fig sifiififiéi

= -~f$t%':§§* $:.3;%2';:i2£:$ '%iE'§§?; wégfifi 2&2: §;:*s:§§%:*fi§$ 3;:-fig 133$ gag}:

§z*a:§@::’**§Z% mgfiiafigg af §§:3§:%a§@ mag Eim awe

@323 $3 €.:%’3*§&’%E§”2§:”%, wéfié méaé fiazzghza-ya fsamzfii

tAx=7{‘ ‘”

mzimmii Eifiéi saga fiiifi

ts.

#9

KZQ

ffifm =%§*%’2§:::2 iéiag ?§$§§ ggszififik E3: %;§§§:

fix fgfiiéfiffi 231$ mgr: fig éifi 5 fig agsfié ‘ -V .’

3%.; §=§§”%§§§

fiw fifiiiififiafii fmg

gig ffilgfiféffii :23 ® zmégéfiazffiii; :;§é,_ .’

:2 §$a$* §§§§’§.1’f;$ ‘fig agfigiiiiiitaéig %i:§}.®¢ fi’§&?€%°_§§ £225:

. my ‘ggggfi mzfimf?

2% §§@$:E:§:* 55:22: ifiéfififiieiiiiéfigiiifivfii fig 35:13:

gmgm? % 5j¥ ~

3; méigmw $2″ éiéfi §*§;%g: mm

€33

%: wfi

:?§§z:m” ____ _§S§,:a&$ §a§:1%;% am E:i’§§;§§’~

aggzggg wig: $12 232.: gsfgzzg afigazma $33′ gm

1 ‘aka mzaafzsgg

, aé’ Etésse fiiaifiii

§s§&;’@=:z;3§

,..~ ifiifi gmyarfiag gm rm’: in

= -:§:%§s;§$-g “fig €i§fi§§£ fiifigiiifi fig §§§7;&%§*m§ flag $13: aaizmiizia

gram 3&3?» gig

Q a$§:§&fi§%§Z iégg

E’-izgggga ifififi Em gifiémt :_;Z=

;fi fim m.::*e’::.§;*%; ” ‘§§’%[E§T}.§§1 §fL$7§§3’°’

‘£1’

:g;2:*%§2;f*§:;%%$i, ‘E'”}2$r&§$:*&§ E: %;g a::~§:§::£§3i’?:§::§ ‘£5; aha &§3§;%;jEE$:.::§é$

5

$333: $33 33%: gmwfigém as %}m agééigaqzzézéfifi

232$ L?§’%$;§::§:s$. &E”%§ §.§fg;:%:f:>i”: Egg §$$.:ZE& $32,? 32% Egg; ;:%:~§ ”

fimiifigé :3

§§%w’a Em’: :§:§1:§§::%z:§&i’:%r’1

:%§::.§ m§g5i§”z-g :.3;§§é:%§”§ éizg &§.fi:;£§§§€;2.°§’~–;:g:;}a:§i& §’i€§§$i’%,

$m m: fig aafiéisfiffiii _ ‘::hz%%~. fizag 22$

zzafifigifigg fa’ éiifi fiéé fizigifizgm :3?
gfiimé; § Egmmgéiéaag mafia by

‘ghg éafazfiafiia é’§?3′;ié§§i$i’::*;*:7§eEEf:E, SE23 §;§:§’:a:*
mm 4 £3 332% éazsghtfim

E?§fi:”§ zém gsrigzggé $%.*g&..:r*g§ 512.: 532$’; gkgfzigai

§§ $33 w:i%;i;§:: g%:§?§¢:5;::::s::§i’_.§§ 232% éafaxzigzzig £2 £3 fiéaar

2% fig §.f.§§é:%.€ gcazéfi gmgagfiim mam

‘$§5:§*§¥V3;,$€§_%E:;i:*::aj;§;u”‘§:%:%z;;%:*:.i%;:a $5 Eéiwggzgsggg agzaii gizfi 53 gfzzéti

Eézifgfi §§”§”‘?§§7§$:’E fiifiifimfiifi, fE€§ “E%? Eézfi 3% a:§%:*’%:°:;:§a:*:i.$ if 53:

éfiffiiiéfi Ewsé Ema fya Eiifigfi $3; 133% gififiéifgg 3%” 23% 393

fififfifiéfifiig éfi wag E3? ‘E333 Ea: £3: Eéffigffif amifimm

‘i'”§§gre§§m§ §§’§ Q? iférm ggéfigrz

RV

“§§;$§$ Egggézggii $33: 232$ §§.§$§
A 3? 5% Emw $3”:

E3}? gsrmrzféégag §’%%§E§&:§6§% :-

3%

téwi ihfi “§’:*:?a§ fiazsfi. has 2:” “iigaé £3 fifififiiafi war if:

ma §§§’§?fi §& gggig Esageé :33′: ?.:%&$:

éé €325. iififéfi

afiie am gfimm $3? gait

gféggarygy €12?’ L. __ gggg

:: Eff §§$ 3% c§§§§§”g.;%a%§z%I,;’
r 33% ._ b

‘ %”$’% flag: asazgésérfifi <¥3i $*:*- gag?

fiie Eazifii famié * Eiéifiifiiifi $s§iL,»_3§.; Q; ‘ A E32′ §m~’V-gamma’? ékéf
J 3 V 4_ _ V V ,v 1 _ ,

gigs”: fi§§fi $5 33% gm: $3233, a§:§§§;:§2 3%
‘flag §$§§~’E’§§&2’Z§% aw fig: 3152 fax’
fifi ‘§’§°?£§ $%’a3;:§_ ii: @325: % am

afifiéiaég ES £§§2a§fi;i:~$%3a;§§’:e J 3:3?’ fig

fiégéfiig V§;§;%:.z~ ;

, –E.%%, i;.’%:§%$&°-i=§:é§ agmsig gf iififfi mm: a:’& Z”3£§”€.

fiézzgfi: fig

§7€:’s§§%:,;

ii ‘

E53 23*; {Eases :*§§::E%.§ aka %.§ is 3

:3g$¢§a3§:%:;:%? £22 §.§j.§§iT:%”:t3

— mafia? ::.

m=%:§§§§m*$.?.§§:”;;_. :32: iiéfi Eégfii éf ::_’?%$§%:#~ta,:§a:=’;::$ éigaiifi

23% ii} §;%

? azfi émrw a§ iém zzfiafé _ V’

é 3:332 “ff?%.*§a§ fi=a’.%T%:4-‘ég. fay §’f®$%:T