-D ;-J
IN THE HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
DATED THIS THE 12*" DAY OF AUGUST, 2009
PRESENT
THE HON'Bi.E MR.JUSTICE K.L.MAND.3:13N¢:t1fr%éDC'% *
AND.
THE HOIWBLE MR.3usTzkr§
WRIT APPEAL Nc:..553 €}F_f_;g;{"1(_)_§_3_L$_3;j'~_4;;E_S_)_. jg "
BETWEEN :
1.
am CHA¥¢DRAi{AU9§ _
D/O MDN1’Di\!?PA,””TVD.__ _
AGED ABDW—..2–5 ‘fE,A§'{S
‘RENii_KA VEENA “ru:.1LAYA’
. – –5<ARAHALL1Rofi;-D
BAi\iGARi3ET+:S63 114.
.V 3 N’ D.D*mLA
” 539% B FNARAYANAPPA
A” ” AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS
EHQTRENAHALLI VILLAGE
MALLUR POST
SISLAGHATTA.
% * -D3} M SURE$i-i KUMAR
§/O MUNISWAMY
AGEE3 ABQUT 32 YEARS
530.8, “YESU f\¥ILAYA”
KADHRIPURA VILLAGE
KOLAR~563 101.
. D M VENKATESHAPPA
S/O MUNIYAPPA
AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS
BODDA DASENAHALLI v1Lp;AGE’~
KADALAC-BURKE POST
SHIELAGHATTA TALUK
CHIKKABALLAPURA 9:s*:gIc’fp
. M P GANESH BABU
SIG M PXLLAPPAJ
AGED ABOUT zsmaarts ”
MARJENAHALLI VILLAGE”
KAMADe:~:;c.HALL.H=c>sT
KOLAP.§e3’s.~.x§’_’101§,_
. GEM’t}V( ZE§;ii*{VfI55;£!€:
AGEE3».AE<;i!JVT 35()"\s?:E:5:R$. '
vS'r'i"." we r: i<A1t*a:-;:3H'»=.;ARA NILAYA
:':CHA£*iAP'FA»..BUIL'mi'~iC5 %
CfriIKKABIDA;?A'KALLU..-
NA{;ASANV£3¥U'«h PQS T.
,;’ “M,suSHmA’
” ASEQ ABom*«25 YEARS
‘;:.’jrY§E;f 21?
T’ _ Egrv:s;m A::;AR CGLONY
%. 553 115.
§’i”§’iA§iiGALAM8A
»D;'{> K M MUNIYAPPA
ASED ABQUT 27 YEARS
AA JAGAJEEVANAPALYA
= SRINIVAS?URATALUK.
9. K VIJAYA KUMAR
S/O KRISHNAPPA
AGES ABOUT 30 YEARS
SHILLANGERE U & P
KOLAR TALUK
KOLAR-563 101.
10. RAMESH SIDRAMAWA Gfl;\.’A:§3:;”£_.
5/0 SIDRAMAPPA GAwaaI ‘
AGED ABOUT 37 YEA”r’iS”»
R/AT MOHAMADAPURA”¥~’AL%J_K
BIJAPUR DzsTa;cT..%A’ ‘
11. V RADHAKRISHNAN
S/G VENKATESH
AGE? AiB,€3UT;:3O gvmas-%’ u A
No4,.354,%2″,_%.k%1sT« gzaoss if; V
s=>;;Ls;:a;:»s om LA’2’f%;)L¥’T..
% %1§QL;§R»5;§3 :01 ~
12. PADMAvA1*fHArsmA’%”~’.%« ‘- ” ‘V
W0 8 NARAYANAPPAV
AGED ABOUT 26 YEARS .– ”
HOUSE NO.146,,”~ ”
35+-ma ;3H’A5HEER SHAMZL.
.. ….. .. ”
EAGEP.-.’~i_,LLT. ‘Tc; wN«.._
KQLAR5
V K DEVARAJU _’ . ‘
sic: xo’i3IRza;»m’
‘=__AGED Asot;T«;.29 YEARS
S.K..”‘r£AL{‘.§_« POST
cHmTAi~iA:~:1 TALUK
V” £,’H’1i<k:ABALLAPuiz ms"m<:'r.
14.
15.
15.
172%
M ” cHIT:u5’ouRGA-577 541.
{By’L:;ré aQwmAMDsv C ULLAL, ADVOCATE)
SHARANAPPA
s/0 BHAGANNA
QHANEGUNDI
maexax TALUK
GULBARGA–575 202.
S K BHAGYAMMA
w/0 KRISHNAPPA A
AGED ABOUT 13 YEARS
MARJENAHALLI v1L1A€;E%–%.
MADDERI POST
Roma-563 191.,
A PREMAVATHI % =
D/O S.HANJE?iA»YAwPPA« r
AGE:!D’;~?gBC)UT;_27§YEARS’ Vk ‘
C.B.”PUF;;A.RGAi)’:._ g
i§A’—,_
AGE33 figscséfl SGVYEARS
CF:~1TRAi”fiJRGA~TALUK
. . .APPEi.LANTS
GOWRNMENT 0:: KARNATAKA
” DEPARTMENT OF RURAL DEVELOPMENT AND
“MNCHAYATRAJ
M.S.BUILDIf\iG, DR. AMEEDKAR RGAD
BANCSALORE-560 O01.
REE BY XTS WQINCIPAL SECRETARY
…5…..
2. KO{_AR ZELLA PANCHAYATH
KOLAR REP. SY ITS CHIEF EXECUTIVE GFFICER,
3. DHARWAD ZILLA PANCHAYATH
DHARWAD,
REP. BY CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER.
4. RAICHUR ZIZLLA PANCHAYATH T
RAICHUR, REP. BY CHIEF EXECUTIVE omcggg, _
5. BHASKARAV
s/0 LATE VERAPPA
ZGGAVRU VILLAGE, CHAN’=A_APL-JRA; HOBi.,I=
ANEKALTALUK -. . ” ‘
SANGALORE RURAL EJIS__TRICT_ ‘
6. VENKATARAYAPPAP
s/ca PAPAN:~:A M.
AGED AEQUT 35 YEARS
‘S;=smvi$*iAKi(::g’LAre::;L.§.I TALUK
GCLLAH&L_LiiPOSTv…__ ~ ‘
“€HIN’§”AMA”NiV
KQLAR D§STRECT;., i …RESP()¥\iDEI\iTS
_;(‘By.sr: $4; :s;A§iAv;riNA REDDY, ADVOCATE
rrogsi Srnt.’ :w.v1JAvA, AGA FOR. R1 “re 4
5: sr;_t:;.ii«5ANc;I asoov, ADVGCATE FOR R6)
—-o-»e—o-
‘ *i’iiis Writ Appeai is filed u/s 4 of the Karnataka High
C~au’r;.t Act praying set aside the erder passed £21 the Writ:
X. Petition Ne.1e457;04 dated 13572305.
This appeal caming on for erders this day, Manjunath
3., Deiivered the foiiow%ng:~«
.. 5 _
LQQQLT
In this appeai, the appeiiant is chalienging the order
passed in Writ Petition 940.1045?/2004 which Petition was
fiied by one Venkatarayappa, chailienging the vieiielity and
the correctness of the Notification issued:.~«b§i of
Karnataka to rm up reguiar vacancies_irise..fajf:’as reietes
to Secretary Grade»! in var;ioi:is::”Gre’m the
State. The Notifications wereieriociuceé?’}§ini:e};iii–e§34Af B
8: C to the Writ Petitior§’;”i’e»Tifhe iearii.ed”A3iiidgje come to
the conclusion thetV.«the_«”Viiiiotlfieations wtivitcitvwere produced
aks A:1i2exii:es}i1;,ie»’BV.$i~~C,’ ii’: so far as it resatee to Grade! of
the “Secrete:’y.”to Grame Panchayat requires to be
,.EC’oueshed'”ae.V§;?ivaAi:ici. Being aggrievefi by the order another
it *ifx_{iAriA’i:% P£etivt_ion was filed by the appeiiants herein in writ
“-7.,«?ét1é’t:eo’nsi~§$aoi.19443/2007 on the ground that they were not
peijtiesii before the iearneci Judge in Writ Petition
~ 5255,1045?/2oo4 31 1174222005 and the order passed in
it “the aferesaid writ Petitions wouid affect their rights,
because the subject matter of the Writ Petitierxs was only
\’>/’
in regard to the iegaiity and the correctness of the
recruitments of Grade-I of Secretary to the Grama
Panchayat and that the appellants are aggrieved.i’n_regard
to the qtiashing of the entire Notification *uii*V:’.t.V:’¥’a«.nt3es
Grade-II. The iearned Ridge has oismisstati to:i£i’é$eti:’ti_oir:.o%
Ne.19648/2007 on 7″‘ March, 12668;«gr’ant;ie§:”i’ioeft3k’ to’:filé7_ it
a Writ Appeal. Therefore,_the apbp.’eai”i’s fileti’; ”
2. Having heard theiiibiesarnteti appearing for
the parties the oniy.._..i:,ioin’t to .vibe.._’co”ris_idered by us in this
app_eai__ . order passed in Writ Petition
No.1io4S?/2o’aéiito ttieerfect that the Notification issued by
tgrte GoveVrnmV_en’t,fo§’ recruitment to Grade-II secretaries to
«,:Vii:i*~:eE”‘i§Aazivt:’ia.eyats is issued by the respective Ziiia Panchayai:
~AV.9§.f’ter hearing the parties, we notice that the
“‘;3eti$_;iorte’i”s in Writ Petition Nes.10457[2004 and
t.Voa13.1742;2oo5 have chaiienged the iegaiity am the
it cerrectness of the Notifications issues: so far as it reiata to
Grade—I Secretary to the Grama Panchayat oniy.
(Q/.
is ailoweeda
Therefore, we are of the opinion that on account of
mistake in Cluashing the entire Notification vtVh’e”‘»learned
Judge by oversight has set aside the recro%troewo_§’;g”ofocess
of Gra{$e–II. In the circumstances these’ V
to be ailowed and the order1;:;;>;t::?:1’é
has to be modified _?:o_%din gé’~~A_:£hat
Annexures-A,B & c: and tiiefifeséer aforeseid
writ Petitions is re_Gra£§e–II .
Witfifohe eaogvel»obsebfietione;’Vibe order of the
learned Sfieqie 3Vu¢fic;V; e*’VAi$V.b£rso«o’i»fied. Accordingly this appeai
H’ …..
JUDGE
Sd/-
JUDGE