IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAICA AT BANGALORE
1.3m'-£51)'1"1~1t$'rm2 team DAY OF f\1()\='I'£1\/II:3¥.£R.;'~iZC)«£}§i}.._
2 PRESENT I
THE HON'BLE MR. JUsT1cE4N.Kfii;qri*.:1.
AND
THE HON'BLI3 MR. JU&31}"rc_B;
M.F.A.NQ. 1 1 2005 (M'vg..A
£3E'I'WE3EN: ' ' ' H 2 ' .
M..J.S1.11'esh S/Q'Jzjgya:'1:eihEf2fii§ LI1_4i.}1.:V- V .
Aéloci 2'1b()u€ 37
R/ 0. 'I'y2'1;_{21_r?a_§'2I_;':eig;1*:If. '€Tf_jz;_]]a}<('::t* V .
C1"11'£1'2'1ciu1'gz-1I_}i§91,. ' "
V ____ '«1.;:____ ' ' ...A;.)pe11am1
(By Sndt. Sp(}r.;§'§1}_\_;T'§------IE §'01'_ Sri.I).R.E\Ia1ggz'11'e.1'§2'1. z'\d\»'{)(.'£;1Et')
AND: ' V '
1. IV!/s..s NL'K'i'~vE1i(ii.E'§V }j:\sS".:_11'Vzf1"f1V(?(* (.70. E,[d..
Iii»-' 'Vi E5 1'21 E i(?AE1_V Ma'-:1'1z.1,g{e1'.
--_'__%'(m{1.:1.. Co-op St)L':'it*'i'y building.
' Ncm" .T;!_E'1A'1'l«.<;: c.):'1'n.~c. xmz-wi Ci1"<*Ic.
M Sri. ¥".E'3.Raj1.1. Adv('a1
' C3111i"1'«17;1t1m';,{é.1';--
; K.M2;1nju§;:;.1;'i ha S/(1) K.'v".Li1'1g21;')pz':.
CE' 'e-.1 E3611 E 50 yea rs.
O\-V'11ۤ:f of E {em 1 iontf :1
.A _SPfL 'Hd(.)i' No.Kf\~ E6/E'{~875().
V V 'ix:/c). V21ltiaikim-1ga1'. Ch€lH£5lkL.'I'(" '%'<m-'r1.
' {Ssh it 1'z.1c11.z1"§.§a I')isL.
Re-rsp(.:1:c11'11.s
R2« §\I()Ei('£' EVIV AC1 ;1;g;"1i1"1}=s»1[ 1.111-*
jLk(;1g1':1c'1'11 zzmcl em-'a1"(1 (1£1I('("i 11.5.2()O£S 1.1);-1>ssc("i_ »i§'1~._?\.f{'v'C
No.58/O4 [564/2004) on the {filo 0E'1hC Clix-'i] tJt1c.[gggf('ES1'jI)'1:1.}¢g;
Ac§{'ll. 1'./1/\(.,"'I'. CI'1z1IE;1kc1*c. pz1:"1ly z-Lllc.J\\'i:'1g 111:' (>.!__2'1iriE'v.pc1_i1§im.'1
for ('()I]1[}CT:1SE'11i()l'1 z-md scoI<En;;' (':1l':e1mtc.*1T:1r::'1t U1."'(SD11:{)'€?.1l'S1-if.'i(.).f1 '
This MFA £?()U1El}_é_{ on i'()I' i1L'$fi.E;I':'}.s;;{'," l}I1iS}.:_.v(}1.}:;{3 VN.'K'.
PATIL, -1.. delivered the fo§I(.)wi1'1g:"'; ' I
J U .I').(_''} M 33;];
This appeal by 1' he c'121i"1'n};i'111 is ('i'i2fn_~.(§:1.js=3¥::E z:1 'g21i1'1s1 the
_judg.§,n1er1t anci axvarci-~.§1a11e§1~"'1 1 i_?f- 2'O"G'cL,~'; )21ss<_'(i in
M.\/. C. No. 58/2004 {.56 /-:2()Qéi§--}V.iv m7i- l§m}' E7"_1p of (.;'.m1 J n(ig__§c
{Sr.If)v11.} 2u'1'ri'" .__Ac1d'Ei'iVt.5:m:.Vi 'M»c'i)§(u*~ ;}'ic_tcici(*:1E Claims
'1'1'il):.1zV1':1'i';' . _C;-heft?1i§:}§r;'1'C-.,_ (1'<_}1*"""sI§():"1. "I'ribm1z11'). for
tr[1ha1it%g'1'i1c1*:1 .(:)f7.'t"mi1v})6;-1,:ézV.;.1ion on the ground the-1:, the
('0Inpc.*1'1sai'i.r)1'i <)§' §:'{sA."v1.'1"'3.150/~ z.:w2u'c1<.*(i in l"av()ur (.)I"1l'1c=:*
("E£::.iI'1:'12'i_£'2«.i' a_pp011ai'fI£'j"L15; 2-1;gai:"1.s'1' his ctl2"1in1 for 13.50
__ i";-d,{Iu'is; _ %i:v1.V£1':'i_é_qz1z11'0.
2,~~_ f'.}'lT1c' ap1)eIlam' (rlzlinls 10 be an E1c(ttrice11
('01111*zw,I.I":t)r. cr:;11"1'1i1'1g :1 sum of R.s.6.0()O/~ per m011Eh. Ho
" -,\1va:a.:sfa1g__geci about 37 yezirss, as on the date of a() A.§Vi, he \x-'as;
' \t!2'I':;'s$. n
p:'(..)"1i¢>"L.=11f' 111a:1:1c1' a11(.l (ia;1:~;!1m;i»--. é"::£z»i'%1'.}s!' 1l"£c§'=
motor cycle-4= oE'1'!'u:é :;1ppciI:;-1111. on'».g=:('co;.:.1591t k=>.1'w!:i'irt?i4:"!-1_c"*i:kj-1!
down and susta~n'nec1 grievoi_,1's:._ViI1j1_.:r'-fives 1,0 iii-S »!L=*v£7t._!pg_g .21n«3.
o1l':er injuries. In'm'1e('lia-}i_(%'i3f, 'xx-*21s;_ sfl*:i1'i(m:! 10
Government. Hqucmly
:'cé1'c=.1'1j'L'é"(:1" i ()1 !"1 E 1 pfi. J '{)_i':1g,_;j1:)si it V Cont re. I)z1\*z11:g'c':'e, wh c- re-r
he? t<")c')¥; 1'u-1*1.!1<:~1*'i=:fé:21i1'z.1t%'1»n He was il-1&1}-)E]{'i(/1'1'1 in SL'.\-'L".l'E11
H0._3pii':a1ls '\».'c:'*e'1.l'.(.>L"?c'ra;£sic'>11s. 1.012-a}l_v for a pcrioci 01' 32
V ' O1f1~.Vgaiar([:;1'ic\/ous injL.:ri<3s susiaineci
in"-«.__1l'1L: 'aL{L5~i(ie1'11_' the .';.Epp(.'1l:;-11'}? l'"ilmi the claim pcti1io1'1
" _b€:f()re=---i'11e '£'r1'bL1nal secki11g c()mp<-:1T1sati<)11 of 21 sum of
""_RS"'1'-3.50 lakhs 21g21ir1s1: the respondents. The said claim
–“pe1i1io1’1 hzici (‘D1110 up 1’01’ <'t on file zmd
2111.91′ e-1pp1″c(ti;11i011 of I’.1″1c oral aulci <.l’»’i._c1″e:1<i?c-'.
allowed the oiaim pc1it:i'”-a2.f;:e.1:.i:§’:§__of
l”{s.1,13.}5()/» \-\’iEl”1 i111o1’L%.=»*I all 6′?/E; per2-1.I.:.z.IV1_i”r:1 ‘ET1}'()§11 {“1910 ..
date of pe1it.ion {ill the (f21:E__(.’ :u._f
dis.<.s2:1t'isI'ie(.1 with the qL121r1tm'1_'_y of <§umpe11s:;ai"i0:»,w;1\~.rgi1'(.1(+(1VV'2
by the '1'ribunal. £110 a.1§)!.)C!l2.1fi'i. ire in ;~1;_;~p¢;11 E){?E'<..)1'c this
Court., seeking e;'1l1211'1-c_éiI1e1'.11 (2)?v(.?U!1'l})6i71.S&1ti0I1.
4. We }’1.:.’1_\:e hvt,’-£:Ii”C§. fh;ai1*11′::_c1′ (“‘V”-_’)la1..ii;.§{.’1 for appeliant
211’1c.i 1tf211’1:i(%ci.. VL5:()111″11:’;~’sVVc5-*1 _E’b»:: i;1.s3z_.1 _1*éii’1;c:’+:; thzlt.
flap V(1CjffilF}’f’%I}_(VT(‘% of ac(ricic1’1t’ 21nd Ihe I’CSl..iH.2.1Il1 ir1_;’uric$
ssL1*:~s’_t21i1V_1c~ci_fly 21ppcElaI1t are not in (1i.<;put'.(*. A(.i11"1iIICdly.
the 21ppél1e111€. 112-13 sust.e1ir'1ecl grievous §l'1j1lI'i€S to his left.
and \.-x-1:15; i1'1–pe-11icnt' in sc\!cr:;1l H(.).<;1')it.2'»1l$ on s\=’c1’21.l
‘ * »v.c)<r(''e=1si(')11s for 1: 101.21! pCi(.)c'1 of 32 ($213-*8 e;1n<..1 he lms
;
1.11’1<.1cr:*5,{1’T1y 2’1p})C2-lrs to be on the mxver satin ._ .1″~..’i’1’~1,¢rr:i1_>;*L%: u
havingg regarci to the 1121t’t1re (‘)i.lf i1’2_jAu;~ficS=,_ ‘c:!1i’r:»11’i£§:’1_ ag:é.(!
1’1;-m11’e of 1′.1″ez111’11c:1I’. \\=~’c -‘{L”-;;’..l_’3’1 it ‘:’-it 1:) m-‘§’2’1″:A:g}’..:._1V 3-;L3m’1 (‘;.f
Rs.3O.OOOT/~ {ow2,11’ds ;)z1i:[:_’__§i’1:.(} –.sL:1’i”é.1*1:1cgs agai1’ast’
Rs.15.000/~.
ES. ‘1″hc ‘_}”1’iV}):.11m’I’ 91-;r_ér..} in’. ;s.§v»¢;i1′(:ii1ag2; 2:1 :11e2:1g{r<":
sum (')'F""R:es.. l /_."~.1h\xr;:1z"dS'V ('01'1vc*.ye1I1(::0. ntmrisliing
food emd '21t.{c?~1'}(:I2\A:_:"1E._ ('1)Véi:f§;@s. A(in1il.{.c(Hy. the E-1{)})C'HE'1!11.
\-va.s.i_11 p;1i.i.}s on !$(.’\-‘L*.!’dl n(‘.cz:s:;i<.31'1ss
&\»\~"hiéiif»-."mi':1}:ly (.'<)i'fiéS« to 32 day:-3 and 1'1;1.;01″tc
1 Vi11V_i-:’écW 0.;.)(‘.-:”V2’ii[1:.i(m5. ‘1’l1r 1’l1i. “l”ribm”121l lmss i’21ih'(‘} to award ally’ z1mo1n11′
-~710\v211’cis loss of ir1c0mT dilfillg {rc211.11’1cm period. ‘F1’1c
-‘4_’_’__»_,.,_…..-w
(3
-c’1}.)pcl!a1:’}1 11219. 12111011 t1*cz1In'”1c11l for 2k p01’i<)d of £32 ('Ian-*5 mi.
in pa"-11.ié*111' and s!'1(')uIc'E 1'12-1\='e Iak01": f()!l(.)w up I.1'(='e':1'1"z1t:11t
also. in-1\'i:"1g 1'c-*g,§e;11'c1 to H165' l1&1I1.1l'(1 of in_juricr.','()l’j!..’.’._:}I)y’ ‘-‘;1V:’!>iVVl”‘i1,..
“1”herei’ore. preSun'”1ing 111211. he has I’.2[1l<c1T1H__1V f'e;zt1Ij(:111 .:i1"1~d '
1'()!lu\.v up t:'02.1{.:'11c:1':t F01" a 1)(':' :'()(.l _A()f«–VlW()': m.(.)i"H }'T1V_s;Wz_.:j_11A:’1″1c at’Rs’;—4.()(){)}’~ . 150.1′ nj}sc)”:’1*.}’.1’=
as against Rs.6,000/– C1a1i11’1é’C1_b3,«’_ }1i:7’1;—\?y?A€%’i1\x-rézirri a :~’.L11’n
of Rs.8,000/- undel” ”
8. The ‘IHfil;)1:11;.1.1.hgirrs £§11.S() (?i”i'{‘(i”‘i.!f’:i” é1\«’v211*(1:’1’1;_g only 21
s1.11’h (‘)l'” ‘R3510.GOO/.4’»._:’Ti=11ia_r
limb ‘;1r1cl.V’3O% in respect of i”i’1c’:: whoie body. Hoxvmx-er,
” x309/u \~:2.ri’1()!e body <ii..=;21bi!i1y e1.cI0r appears
‘ ‘~ 1’o– be little c1xe1;gggc?r2’1t’:i01″: and t!’1e1*€rf()1’e:*. by d(:(:h..:(‘1i1’1;: the
~–50% riiseibility in respe’
01′ pa1*1i(%ular limb by 3, vvc
-4
éLSSL’.’SS the \.v1’1lc>. iaocly ciiisabiliiy an 17%. ‘I’1’zc.- 2’1}.)pc-‘I12-HIE
112:5 to pull on w1’t’}’1 lhis (iisabilily 11″]E'()L£g1’1()Ll.§’.’z1 .i’S ‘§.ifi?.
Of (.'()1.:z’.=s0. t’hi.=; c.1ise’1h:l1ty, En s0z’11(-‘ (“x1m11’._.<'&~»1T11§?s§.i'11 jE7i——1fi.-
xvay of 11116.' :;1p;.)c!!am.'s day i(') (izj1y~z.:.r._',Ei\?i.{ies$." b"Ci:'_1Vg_g £.:_V1"1u
e2Eec:i:1*ict21I c:011t'ra(:t'.01*. 'l'}1c?1'€?f()1'E?, I=:._3v:i1"1g"–r¢4g;.:;-11:1 "?J:(')«._.'£"i1.e
:1n}'12=:}.)pi:1L-:85 2-ind (ii:+('()miE)_;L9i";~._\\\-'l"1ii'1:1_ inf "3}1u:'1–y"'"i'Iaiv(' E0"
sL1t'E'c1' in 1'1.1'tL.n"e. \w=2' C1€@fI.1'""'i1-.'V__'f7iE "'?() e:1\.Ve'1'rd «:91 sum of
Rs.40.000/ V t:0ward..<; 'lvc3_$'s <?-f' ;:.1111__éI1if't.i;§'s-. on :;.1('('.'()u1'1t' of
(lisability.
9. i5.,344″SV1:”‘¢-i.I:€’..d’ ‘t’.’1«1’fé=1fI’*?iii%3 ‘a_pp(%l1arT1t. has 1.0 L1nde1’g()
“\.
one 1;ii():'[C”cA).;}i*1’2;1I’f:’§jVé’: f(;»s.T ‘i’r:11″1()V?Ll of iE11p1e11’11’&5. ’11’1orcf():’L’.
1’1e.1\.*i1’1g§.1′(:g,{2:1i’d 1.0′ A:_:”:1_c§(i–i__(iA:”:»!. £~xp(:1’1sC5s and other i11(.’.E(ie1’1i’ct1
(‘1’E£1V§.fCS i1’ii»’rj)_1viz:1g s’t_..1c.Ii 0pcraI’i(‘)r’1. xvc am-“(‘::1′(“1 3 .sum of
– «RS. (X000,/5 i'(.)\\-‘zVV1″:7({i”é3 i’u’1’urc:’ nlc.-di(“2:’1.1 c=’x;.)c’*1″1sc-*5.
‘ ” I5i~<)wc\re1'. a sum of Rs.76.150/ ~ awarded by
Ti""17._1'")L1EVjEE1'1. :'~i(.)\V€1FdF§ 1m-:c1icz'1} ('X})("'l'1S('S just amd
° .r(j:$e1s(__)1"i-3.11311? and does not call fox' i11Ec==rr'fc=1'cr1(.*c=;' by this
_C'C}".J:}'t.
T110 Ins1u’z11’1(‘c C0n’1p2;u1y (1i1’£.'(T1E'(1 to (i(*1)()fsi1 ‘:1T1(>
c:1I1a111cT~e(.i Lt<)1'11po:1sa==1tion oi' Rs.'?1.()0()/– \-\"iE1'):".i'Vl:.H:§:"r'.§':S1
1hcrc:11}jav1’}y, 1
shall be 1’€Ic21s€(i 2’11 –.f.’_;f\”~’~.rV)111″ V” of ‘ .14I’T1′.*;=j u”~,é’ippé’1E2111′:f’
immcxjliz-1E.(>1y.
Office 1′ 0 eiimw z.1wL.1’1’c1QL-z1{“c”(.)1*_gii’i.1§;j.Iy’.–.