Loading...
Responsive image

Malatesh S/O Shambanna Araleswar vs The Managing Director The North … on 1 June, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Malatesh S/O Shambanna Araleswar vs The Managing Director The North … on 1 June, 2009
Author: K.Ramanna
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAXA

CIRCUIT BENCH AT DHARWAD

namp THIS THE 1-t mm' or JUNE,  5  ;_. A' 

BEFORE

THE nomsnm Mn_Jus'm;_:E r;;12are1x'31A--: "   '  J T

MISCELLANEOUS §«1I2s*If,n._§>'9EAL-- 1§ <;-.2212;.:*o£§S "  

BETWEEN:

MALATESH, S/' 0 saameafim AR;%xL§;s§i.r22._&»  "' ~ . _
AGE 3: YEARS     
occ; HOTEL BUSINESS,

R/Q KALBUR VILLAGE-., _   
:N;eANE13ENNU1«2~'r;aw;<   

m9:rR1C*f;. HAVE?-1vIV; » .» "
_  «. 1'    APPELLANT
(BY SR1. N4V."PtIANJUf*JA'i"1.~§,ASH)

 AND: ' 'V

  'fag: Aivizs N£'§}<}::~f<.34 _mRE:cToR
*:ma'4: MJRTH' WES'i'..KARNA'FA§{A

ma; ':'reA1<:s.Pr5.e;uL EEGAE},
HUBLI, ATEEUBLI 30

V . 2313'?» Efififiwffifi.

 .  '(.3u'r wR~QNa1,Y s1-£{>w1~: AS KSRTC, BEFORE: MAC?)

RESPONDENT

 V  _( r:.-3¥"s;:2':, V,S.PAi\¥CHAGAI\¥{, ADV FOR SR1 RAJENDRA c. DESAI,

THIS APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SEC'i'iON 1753(3) OF' MY ACT

 " ~' AGAINS'l" THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD 'DATED 5.13005 PASSED

m Mvc: NO,33/2002 ON 'THE F} E OF' THE CIVIL JUf){}E(SR,{)N}
 71;;/f'



Area 13521.. JMFC, RANEBENUR, PARTLY ALLOWENG A_£1§§;OW€.1$Ki}_j'F-E13 
CLAIM PETETION my compawszmow Amp . S.EfjK.I"NG 

ENHANCEMENT OF COMPENSATION.

THIS AP¥'EAL COMENG on FOR HEg}gk§--NG Tarts: 
mum' DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING;     ~ _ R  

Junémrfigagr
Easing not safisfiéd:_.'fwit1§1_   __coInpensatio11 of
Rs.15,000/-- awarded    Judge(Senior
Division), and   }'\Jf'$fC§"VI\Eo.33/2002 dated
5th Januggrv,  is before this Court

seeking ()f"C€}EI1p€hS€itj.OI1.

 _  .£}:¢eA'¢_3r%g,'fiIneI1ts of Mr. V.S.Pa12chaga11i,

 mumsel apjfirtéafing for the respon&ent--insuran<";e

i':§rnpa:33§f;"«  ~ 

Sp " _T'i'1"e counsel for the respoI1de:"1t~insuranc:e

"  :;pf.:13ant has under gone treatznent at

_  at Davangere. According to me

ap'pe.fia£ntv,A  Féséas carrying on hotel business ané was

 A4 '.g€ttiI§g ifiepme more: than Rs..§,f)()0/~ per month. In ordc-:1'

   Zgzfdvfe the mature of the injuries sufibred by him, he has

  _.._ ilvri§duced the wound certificate E)x.I~"'---4 and Ex.P-'7-

  'éfldischarge card. Ex.P-'7 issued by Bapuji Hospital,

Davangere discloses that the gppeflant was admitted on

/V"-"'

,,,//'

<','_'_#../2""



4
09/ I0 and was ciiseharged on 14/ 10. Thereafter, he was

shified to the Government Hospital Further, Ex.§'--5--C)PD

produced by the appeliant goes to Show the natu1jee'.:(:§fe.1;}1e

injufies sustained by the appellant due to #316'  H

and X~ray was adviseci. During the eourseef  't1f:;e* V. 

x:--ray was produced. It is to be hptieerl -'2V:is__ net

the Doctor who treated the  

suffered by the appellant on   a lapse

cf 5 years, the appeflarrtiiiae-_ La1:;);[_.2:fi551ev§.1;'ede» PW~2 to assess

the  " " PW-2 has Opififid that the

appellant §u_£ferSVVV'3_5'%§; " permanent physical disability.

.-veffhe  Tiihunal, censiciering the nature of the

"--,iI1jJ,iI'ies oral and documentary evidence placed on

reeofd;  Vf':V3V have quanfifieé the compensatien under

 '.§peeiéi1..e1V}1{1hV$geneIaI damages. Which has not been done

   global cempensation of Rs.15,0()0/- is awarded,

V'  ' w«'1'iiei1 cannot be sustained. ,.:

.

/
<."M'#___,__,_,..'…–r—*"""'

6
Coolie and was getting a sum of Rs.1()O/- per ciay. Having

regard to the fact that 3 to 4 weeks is required for

troatment and follow up tzteatxzlemz, of

Rs.3,00(}/- under the head of loss of eaz’n_f1fig-«’

during laid period would _. ~ 4. A ., »

and reasonable.

8. PW–2 is of t§1e.»’opiI1ioi*1.V_ that has;

sustained 35% of éisability Vljimb, the

contentjéof be oiiéfiecied, therefore 1/3″ of

the physical disability would

come. -3roi11″4§d 1%’. considering the age of the

V. “‘3.ppVk’:1.Za21fzftA by..’;1pp1j§éiifigAvthe proper multiplier ’16’ which is

facts and circumstances of the case, the

Aontitled to a sum of Rs.63,36{)/- { 1.6.,

30{j8o.x«12x16x1 1% Rewards loss of future earrxings and

— towards loss of amenities. Thus in all, the

V% .a.}:;pe1lam: is entitied to Compensation of Fis.90,86G/-

1/<3"

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

* Copy This Password *

* Type Or Paste Password Here *

Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies. More Information