High Court Karnataka High Court

Managing Director vs K K Sidappa S/O Kengallappa on 25 August, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Managing Director vs K K Sidappa S/O Kengallappa on 25 August, 2010
Author: N.K.Patil And S.N.Satyanarayana


6:

§?’z.’§2″§’t1s=::1 ?i’:h:% ,2~,1§3§3»:*:’E}2::’:t.s; hr:-?§”<;%.§:"3 wa.%r:7% {iir:=:i.v<§ {<3 settrgs 22;}

i;E:c pay 9? f€$p('}E'3{3e.€?1"i'§ 0;": par with pa-12:; ;;;–€

fv'Ez1z'1_;§:;§_:_1ai.h21n with :*:fi7:::m .’L’§”‘X E. 1.AEE?§i*:

<trr€sp:>:1€£ing_j§iy £:::”:fc3:.r {E162 Eix-,-*,=n€r£°’£.<;': mi" the :"eFe'~:?.§;i<3i:'f;;w.<5f' ;;sa;; '

fmm: t,i1"ne in time and a£5s<3 {ii:"c::g:1:€:é(i ii)' ;32'-my *:i:§'1_e*.__.?:§'zl£fEg::F<3'i:':(%Ei~

in E1II1{}uE1€, :3? E3213' ami <3TtEj1.er <;E<):T:':1;~£:1:;1.ze:1–%.i2:1' §}6:f:v:*:f"i%*i':sas"»

a<:(::':.1i:'1.g t._he:;:'<%i'r0r11 upm cieztff;

5. Bcsirag 0f the L-ee1r;’1ed
Single J 11dge=;. E1{;>.;’Jf3J1L3:£’3;:I’?”{Z,Vv’}”1′{%}§fi?fi£;i’_ ” fic2<:&3ssi1:21t,eCi to
fiie the

{,'E1I1V'cIE:5S€C1 by the
Eeelrilécl t ¥:1"e.–T§§p}jeil211:11.$, at the 0:,,1t:5:se't: is that,

it is t;I':e d_1,iIf.% {f2e2.st4'A<J:2¢ E13 res <:md§.”G:nc>t.ed*V i33.23511. 315: 112155 t.akc11 ::’1iy on {)’1,0Efi9E;%2. ‘.I”h<:%r€f()'re:'; he

::c)1,i"L_.'£ not ggest: $131.6 beémefliii an par wii:h N5 M2mj:,.me1'{'.h2-2.11

2§é,i1<:i if is mat; ;3e:%r.rr;i§s5s§bEc% :,m::s:

Eifid mfies ‘».Xs'”E’1€i£°%:?.’§.E’T§ he <:<}u§c;E ix: c;*:.xé,e§':ci:=:<§ gm: 321.31%?

7

§}E?E1€f§.{I$. “§.’E’::*.R%1″<3z"$:%, '£19 2′<:;i<?:' «:3? 11336:. E,e:*.e3;;'m:{:i Si:':;;§e:

Jucigge wili E12ws;': {:0 106 vi?.ia3?;.{':<:§a

2?". 21g§e1i:2:aE $233., {the c.:<.)121'::a~;d 'fin? ma-;–§).{;:1§ié§;f;*§,;.¢

i.I'1f;,€'1"ali::1., sa;11'bs3E:211'1i.iaE.ec1 the. 1in?1p2_..1gg1'1.e:::.%. §}..i{ig'§esj1*:e::t.

pai:;:+;e:d 135; the i,A::2u"1'1e<i Si.z'1.§-gje s_}__:,z{.igge éi?E'1é:.€;.' th'«i2 {L:«r5'<:§_§;3:'w.:,.iS

:'~5trim"}y in {.'(1¥I'I;f~30E'§£:}.I}.(':€;'f' i:.1.&:<;' .21:':;..i" 'V;1.'?V"1i_:§::if (1:19

C():';side:'e1i::i(}11 sf fE1.<;f ::?1;.11'<3:'14i;;;1VV _ :}f:i.ie, the
Le.e1rr1<-td Sirigie J1.1c1Vge.. :"n.a:§»-.L. a1pprL)p1'iai;<:

directiozl in th§;’~vgr1*ii: e:’1d01’sem<:=.11t
issued by. }¢ 1;:icV£f i'fif:e_r:fe're11ce by thig
court gromld is rnacie gut
by 'for i1_1te1'iE§:1'nc:e in the

weal} (:c)1’1.sid.§:3rcd <)1fd&:*.1"Kr.-f–.i_1"1e Lear1T1<=::<:I Single J1,1C1gEf.

_25§fft,e:r c:a1'rci€:° of the

Leéir:1e.[d’f:1:1′;ngg1e Jzracige thc’~r {)I11fy’ §)(}iE1i’. t.h.21{. E’:1i’iS€i5~§ E01″

c:{;:r1::;i:1€§re1§,2?s_>:’1 1S :

“\7xfE1e:’f;.h€::” the impuggzleti €)£”d{?I” ;)2′;::3:’sed by-* ‘£E’1<«3

¥_£z1.r11c1 Singjiac Juethsgct is; se12s§.2>ziz1aE)§@ u.2’1<ier

.-if
2 WWW"

:

E.,,g:i2f?

9
Acc_é<m:':.i:&:s {7§ffizf.<?r. "?h.iss iE,s;:%§f" p;"<'}*».x*{2se:% %3eym£ :”é%z’1:~’az’1:1E3§:%

citmbi: Ehai: ‘ilE’1.&’.E.”€:3 ws:%’ru:% Eap.s+;c:és~::; {“241 iha: §:)2>::*1,. {sf ‘::E’2¢=;= S§l§}.,CI’i(,)’E”

{}ff”‘1c?;c;:r in m:3?;’, ‘1’&:ié::3xringj;’ i’}’1{:~ :fe:s;’3:’1&sé:1″é, quizikiy’, ‘€sé’§1e%<:r2 :fve<i an }.?§"'i._§,§.f;;8i.M mi V'

{be :i%.'::1II1(:'f (fizzy he Ims 2:sss:;1T1111e;1i {.H€§' <;:i"1.2a.:.";g_§e:: }j}i'g"}'1€:i%

officer an prc_:n1t£<}I'121.E pm? g?»1r_1 127.3-.1§1.98i,_}.E:; <3'ws1–.£.?3v;;a.?.'–..

%:h.’;’e we1’e 1aE’.<':1'1:’1§:f;g of the?
d<:part.me.11i: on the });:1fi1'~.{3f' U16?_IT€3t:3pO};id(§fI1T<, He 1.(iing_;’ i.ha,1:, I1a:i’i-gé’:3j’7§:.i.i:;i<a:ci for benefit.

aCCr11e<:i wit':E_i ~1'i_; Qf- .vi(\/f€1}§ 1f1.Ef'£?iV'§.i"}'€iiI1, 0:11 aezrcouxii. of
lapses cm 1;3;1é»..p'§;1.:"t. bf «t:1i'I’E11;,’iOI1. which

is :1 oij “L1 $1.1 i’iVa1′;–‘3..r§.;.V_ ” g

__’11. \7V33._’;-?I()A’-._11i::*i’; find a1’1yT sL1bsi:an’n. m2.1.C1’E’=:””‘%:$y tihe: C£)11I1Sf;’1 for ‘.1116 &’:pp€;”i1I&11’1′{‘..

it-=~9_ §},<3 not: find any g_;ood grr;3u:1ds tic.) interiérz-2

if: -i;j.}1<3 mé1_1'4j'1*<&%23.ss1:’1ez:i <'2_r'd<:'1' passssczézi ':33? i:]:'1<3 §;,If E}TI€,’. i”reg<:i1T1g.;j §'{?-'€1S(-.-}E':1S.'; as: e:;«;14aE;:=.(i 2:ib{)V€".', 'giize

°if§Fi§i ;1pp€:2'::E ;f'i1e«:£ 133; $331': 2:.p;3e;»r_§I2-m{.59:::z)rpor21'%:ir} izis

di:::ps::s€:d ef :°:::£~;e-:’%.;i:T2;;’ ifiycézréjy {<3 éhe 'c31§}§I}€f.'E1Z'1I{'1§.§"

a.:<:§:';5:°2.:.Ei:i{;:?: in ;:»E2-.-*;:::f:i>:”:=i% §.E’1€-? §.%2a.:'{i ‘:1;

Ii}

i_rn;i)Z>:;’:n”1€.1.1’i’ 111:2? :.’c::ié:1′ ;T:=;a£e’:-.»:..<_:-i:;<=:'§i E3},-' £E'1<3 L<':?ra.:.2'::<3<:"E §§:':'1g§e:':

J1,:«:ig<.% as :::x_pc%<i§ii2;:$E}? £1-S1; §)::}=E%;é5E?.’3}_i:-;? z»-si. éH’§§=” ;’;::’E”s-=; ax;;€;_E:ié;’1

washes; f:’«:)m ‘£12129 {.12-K9: <3? I"E?('.?€i§)'£. { 2.2. <"::==:r<tiiie<'E;"<::*c:}pjy._géf °§_E51.;1«s+:

rde-;**1:

CECE. .?\1′{l665 /2(}.§;€}:

153. In the §I”iS’E}£§i4i’1i. t: 1»jf>g7f”,E:i:ic):'”:;’; i’.i1é’.

<:0r12p1az'I1ami. prays; to 1'n:itLiLa.t'_:E=. .21}')}3£'(3}}.1;i§1"é1('; §(.'f{)fi'.1f€131p{i

proceeclinga 3.55.exlviszigczdfL1i1($c31_' i} 1;r3Aj*€:Iéva:'1t. pr<)visioI3$

of the Cf)I1'fL€fIWpAfb['(?f' *£fT"(3u.'1v'-*2' ACE. f§I1'\.r;i.éii-T' of ciisobeclien{:<:% G?

the ()l"d€1'~" "(i1:;3_t€(l _, passed in WP.

N0.I§;34€3;’2OC*5’*-.;1g21i1′}ss{f”*–t’h6t’ 2-1C(:1:1se:rci, in t,h_<: i1'V1t.e1'€st Of

j1.:st,i(:e am "e<;11ii*:"y.2 2 "

“–‘&2V’:3 ir1_22¥f(-%”‘}1e2s,:’ci 1119 Eezamned atomjls-mi appearitlg

f’::;: ‘iiiifi:;;{<3::'i.p1gié11amt. and the Eea2:1':£:C.1 c':L,ms5;e§ a.ppe2.m5ng

fcyr-‘…__%§’1x;_2.~ :?u:§<?:~':§S<;:c£. The £<:2;1.:':1c-xi cm;’:$eI Shri, RS. I3a2e.t:.i1,

appcéz-11*i.:’:g :fr t:h<% 2;1{:<%:.:§;«s<:€i, asst. Exhe :1§’:s_n1it’:E:.<:éd E:}"1at':_.
'–..§}f'1:..~.=<;¥E\sv' 0%" i.h::*.- <i2?:-apmszii <3? i:E'2z=i mam': 9…–m. ap§3a~?z1§ Wi'zE'};

V …=;§.iz'<::<:*i.io:1 to me: E§<:322r<.%. E0 i'::,:_E:<.-?. s:ie::Essi.{:}z'1 fog' {:<)r:1;3h2::'2.Ce <1»?

E1319 ::'2:"{:E<'::° p£;2.sj;~:::~s£:?:<'i %3y' £é'1€% Le;:1*:':é3{§ Si:'1;§§&*. {.J1.,:{ig_§<: wi%,§1§r: :'5-six

'sa.-Ya:%€:.i.<:.s f§"€i}§?E E"h%;":' <E:;:t'.:s: <3? :'€.<_:r;3;§pE2: $5 the: e:"7<');}}«' of E"E':<-:3 gézfler

'1 E.

anti in ‘V§(‘t’*Jx=’ :3? %;E’::’: iiifiléi cxt,m’:<k»%:T.i ME :5-six w€eks–1–s., zm
cIit:e;=._mpi’ §”)€**i.ifi.§{}§.’I fileci by ‘é.E3e==, €’*{)I1’E}f}i2?£i?i£1I’3i,. 113a},-* éx”:
(ii:~;p.sae«:i of 21:55; it {Em-=::%; not. s.:;::r;.-*:iv<:*; {<3}: amt:&ss3;€ie':*z2§_.£<;;:1_ at

€:E1iss~; Si',£-1§_L§€?.

15. A55 él§E1i’I’1S§j. {hiss H19 E€:bé::.r;’1:;.}é:§8..1ji’f2§,»§

for the <:r11p§2’1i.n2:1nt £1’1’£:er:f;i§i;;L {‘T4fI}ITE__E”.Ef:’1§i€;%.:(“} ‘ f2;1§:”Ey”

ssubmified th:r,1t tI’:::f,—- ffi7EE}de’ ctmmsei
appearmg fez’ 21<:{:z1Sr»;dV';it;%§;~.3i"%i11Ei: be placaad on
record and xin21y be disposseci
of res(2'wia*ig to revive or fiie fa
i'::"'_'t'r'1"c%'V§<=:*ve:'at', {he 0z'd<"-:1" of U536
Id.ee1}."}:t; éi;.r71 beer: Cv:)mp1ied with by the
Board of; V_:resp'()fid»;3Vi"I{;<:0rp()r22,t.i011.

».’E’11€’ %3i:”r)’:’Iiissi01′: Hlade by this léifklffflfitd CO’LiI1S(‘3]

‘i7;>.z_:* % E5§:>€:.If1″_. U516 ;)ar*’tiies £5 piaméci em ‘re<:0rd, the

c:mi.e2mp€,L'j_–pe*{.it.i<m fiieci 1:3}? f..h.c=t 1’12g31ai.1″:a:1E. st.a111ds

{ir<}p§2é3__:ftE_, :"€':s{%.:"2/*§L:1;;; liberiy Eli} 3.1.6: €;.:<::mpiiaiI:1e1:'1i, to file

" £*:+s_-egg: a::<mi:e;':mpi: prL in ‘H16-r. csevcgégzig this §:>o2;1rd of the

_ ..i°:’1a:%e.I’1E”«1″2″s.’i:i::3:’1. <:i<:1€::s3 amt: <_".:»:m1.pi§,,-* with ms.-3 {:s1*e:i€2r:-Ea:

0? i,1'1€:2 L§;',£3;§"'I}{fi{§ Sifégkf zfmiggez wii'§:';%':'} ;='_sé,_x awaékss fE"'{.3E1Ti the

éizzite sf £'{"§€?%;:'.i§;}§l' £3? E}. ztfiiiépy {'7}? i':E':3?s'<: {j¥'€i.§?.EQ
5'