K)
'.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BAN6AL.{3RE
DATED "was THE 18?" DAV OF DECEMBER';"2QC~§?__!:
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MEEJUSTICE MOHZAN :5H2;N'rAN'Ȥ'Ed'Lm':2.E_1'
wan PETITION NoL3E-3240/20LQ9(EbN%;E><E)E.
BETWEEN:
Mzmish A.Jai11 » _ -
S / 0.Ash0k KL11I1'c1I' R.Ja1i1'1
Aged 23 years .
R/atD&xI72/11gLahLhadfl ;=
3"! Cross. Ka1t.hrig§L1'})13e,
Viveka:1E1r1cia11;1'ga.f " "
Ba11gal()1*v3 »
{By M . I,E1\_xE-'A .,)_'
AND: U _ [_' "
I. Tfflc' I{(:g_Vgi«s;i"i*E1V1" . _
£;3;.m gz1101'Eé E; 11i\:A*ve1'si1:§;r
J 1j2111é1 B h 211"a"1,i1. i V 211111;) L1-S
"I:1E1n:g'aE()i'.1'C' U11ivr31'si1y
N G.11.esT, 1301.156
J E11'1ar.1i2.bE1 211'21f:hi
.. A 'T '1'-14:1 gz-1I1'c.'. LE111'\-'t?1"siE._\:'
I\§c>.w Cr'i1€',S{ E""I()L1S('
J mama .1-3ha1'at.hi
E321r1ga1<)1"<?~560 056
4. '§"1'1e §*'1'1'r1<*1'p2'1E
S.R.N.Ade.11'ssl"1 (,'.c)11ege
C1'1a1I1a1'e1j_pe1, __ " _ * V. L_ '
Bamga10re~ 1 8 . .RE3SI3QVNV{D'E%§N'TS
(By Sri M.K€shava Raddy. Adm, 1'(')F{37.
Sri V.B.R2i\'iSha11kE1I'_ Adv. for R4) A. '
This writ pemion is filed L1f1r_1e1'- ,A1'E'.iC1.€*S'226 éiind 227 of
the C0nst,iIu1.io1'1 of II?.C'£~} fc]., })1*a;y'i1'1g '!.O"q11z1sh "illeggai and
21rbi€:1'a1*_v. t.§"1€ €11d01'se1"--..1€{r"1{. dam:-d. f;=...1"1.2~0_O9 issued by R3,
vide An1'1exL1re--D._ etc. 'A 'L 3' '
."i:'11ié: W.1ii5€. )ei7f£€i0t1"h.éivin fbéen heard and 1'es(»:n/ed for
01'CiL'%1'$1_011--_13'?! 1T)c&L<:e1'T1:beg 2009-. and 01:1 this day the 181" day
0%' DCCC11.1be.1'._ 2009..'LI"1is§..CA(1I..u'--~€ pm1'1m.a11(":c{1 the f"()1l(mring_;:~
"% " @GRDER
Pé'i:itio3'1ei"--w , _1_'_1__;1:s sought: for que1s}'1i1'1g E1116
' {:'f}'{§.()1"53§Ti'i'}<EE}.'j1{f'Eli. AlI'1I'1(iXl.EI'C~D, (.iai:c(i 2.1 1.2009 iSS'LI(i'.d by
1"jhe"*Uniircéifjsgi1:37. by which Qe1'i:a_i1'1. pu_nish_mem': i.mp0s<:éd
'V on €.i:.1eu2._:grou11ci tj1'121i[ the p<3i.ii:.im'1e':' we;1s:s i;'1.c1:..11gi11g in
" IfI]vE1}i'}'JlTE1C3U.(T€ in ti]:-1*. L-':xarnir1ai.i.0r1s.
'Vt;
-x
,5,
2. Pet.i1:.io1'1e1' tine. si:uc.ie1'1E of the 4"} 1'esp(')1'1Ci€1'1'{,--
coilege and is pursuing MBA Course in the said college.
4*" r<=:spo1'1c1entecoliczge e1E'I'1'l,iaE:ed 10 ffielliggzxloref
University. appearecl for 2"" scmc:s1.er (:?XEl1'i4]ifi€1'{i.Q'1'}..S
which c:0rnr1'1<-znccd from 8.6.2009. The é«2§é1r':1.iz1iiti%()h'$ '
were scheduled to end on 22.6.2'OO9;'« '_
3. While the petit1'o11er \i»'as1'~_ih 1:11"e., p1''WYQS i1'1(i1.1lg(:(1 in ('.1"oss--c0pyir1g.
'l'he_Vigi1aihcé3 VSqa.1é1.-r_i"ss"<3i7:ed the '<?tI1SV\/'01" paper of the
pe5t1i.'E.io:;'~ae1' ».a1'1d $t1.'111m011ed the pet.if,i()I1ei' 110 the mom of
iii_1e_3' 'I)i::'":{(éL:5i<,_()i'fzhc 4%" 1*esp()nc1e1:1twollege. A report was
1:£1'.1"1_e::.* which
pxfoéitxcterd at A1'n1exure--I*3 to the wrn petit.i011. The
('*7
pet,i1;i()1'1e1' has aE2Cin1i1:1.e(1 fhal; he was (_*.z11[1ghE. \-vhilcr
Copying. Ht} also signeci the reporé 1311-;*.p211*e.<j V..b"_g 'Ea.11cr
Squad membe1'S. 'I'}'1e1'c'=,2i:1fi1e1' 2-1 S1'}()V\-"(,'.21L.1SC':I'1(){'i[?'é:"' ~
issuad to {:h(--: pE}tiii'.i()1'1€I' as pep.A1';rT1e_X1.1fC«»{§, 133/ xf{;1'u;§ V
NIEi1pI'a(i:f.i(3e E11'1qui1'y Co1m"nit.1ee 231'} 3'.8';2009"Hi5tI'E;{'Z?1_.i;':i'g
the peti1'.io11(-tr to appe/¢11~' .1j!'g)1'c: U'}_C' _Co.I_11"n_ji'i'te:§ 011"
18.8.2009
for further ;_.enq_ui;f§,r——:s{1’1v£i £0LAha1\’I(é’ms in the
matter.
4. On the course of
enqL1iry, t:3.”1″tf””p€£f-§1’i;OIi€.1f –¢’1di1′;it,ted the <.:he1.1'ge% as is
Clear :'f1*<)1':n. Yi 1ET' «1T_&Y4C.?€i)1"('1S "21'1E-{H211alilled by the U1'1ive1*si':'.y.
B<:'.ib1'€ the Ma}._p1'a'(?r1fi<:e"=ET.111.qairy C<)n11nit1:ee the pit-221 of
t.}1c.pc§Vti{',i011r1<:d__§"éi's' ~ .'.V'_"'{._g-':_.¢is,:.._'l"g_
adlnit. the cha1_"ge"'. The peti'£:i(_mc1' has &:4ig§;1'"1'L*:d.:i.'E1:$'*ple;1.
5. From the above, it is (:1 <:.2._1.1;"1_h'c1t
has 'uh:_in1at:ely admitted thti"-a.q;'E";211*ge i:"E"1_’1:1g;”.E-.1 191; was in
two minds at an <;é21.1*Ti'c%1f pr)i_ni" Lime. Bziséd on t:he
admission of the petit10n_er',"'the_.~..1j11;i},t¢f.s.itTy Syndicate
11215 taken _i:'I'ijtA'?'[:v-§1e(:i:Si()z} '~ ':()'" ?IT'Ij)€i)S_{f.i p€21"1a.IE'y on the
])eE'iti(3–1'1e3r_ .(iéj1'}fi2:}_;;§athQ "b_en€fit. of pe3'f0rn1aJ'1o{«3 of ail
papers ('E*h€i*_;! .1313′? é:n’1be1′. 2009.
6″;_L€”a1rr1e(i c()1.1nsel 21ppe:;11″i11g on behalf of the
pa-‘=.’1ii~t_:n1′(_)r1e:.’ sL.1b.n1iEis E’,1’12-rt the irI1pz.1gned €?I1d()I’SC1}’1C’.’1′}T is
P7
_ ,
issued without’ he211*i1’1g the pei.ii’.i()ne1′ and the sigI121u.a1’e
of 1119 p<-;i:iiiion01' is taken forcibly on ('he report. of Elie
squad menibeis on the date 01' ex:;1n1inai'i()1"1.
The said submissio1″i Caiiiioii i)_c-i_ é{(‘t.’:f:’jt’;%1:A)’t.”(i-:._rj’i.
inasmuch iihe petitionexr has .1101: _oniy_-‘aidrn-i.fi.(:-€1-btzforre
tile squacl that: in the €XE1£11i]1E1’E.i;C)1’1 ‘wa3;~;_Ca}.igiii;f”wfii£c
c:()1)yi1’1g, but has also a1(i;1_1″i-161.661 A1′”iif;3 \§:jI.,l2iH. “bV(-:fi)1’r:€ {the-‘
NIa1pI’aCf’.i(2(-3 EIr1q’ui1’y__ Con1ms’i:_i§,ee”‘–o11 1″8.–8,A2QO9. As
aforementioneci, tihé’ ‘M .eAxé..1_jnfi13.a1.iohn.V% “was held on
22.6.2009. i:.1_1c 21fi1’1′;ii.i,ec1 thali. he was
CaL1ght. w_hi1é’CQ§2Ying;.._i:5e.tbre[the squad rriembers. Elven
:;1’fi’.er the’-.ifeceip’i:– of” Si’1.()w:<ie11.1se m.)i.icc, the pei'.ii..ioner Iias
.21c§n:1it.f.ed thé: …§§i'1Va1'gé: bei"ore the. MaIpr21(éi:ice Enquiry
.2 C<)iiim:ii:Ai..cr3'A'on 18.8.2009. which cieariy goes to Sh()W
H {.1'i:1_1_« e§a.~:i':£~.1' &1b(.)'l.£f Ewo }'I1()1'}1.11$ 1"r()n:1 E1110 c:Iai:ti' of
e1(:'i:4i:e11"*–Air1(:'i(:i€n'£., the pet:ii:i011e1f as:imit;1.ed the (:h2:1rge.
2 "i'Eie_se f'a.(~.i;s wii] a1:)u.1"1c:1ant.1y ggzi to slmw i:.11e;1'é'. i:.i'1m*e is no
;'"g)i'(:c-3 or (':
, «g ,
8. It 1’eI€va1’1t: 1’0 note tllaii SEI{1.dE?.I’}’i’,S wlm were
also C2.iL1gh'{. on ‘L116 spot by 11110 s(‘{L1a(.1 committee were
<-:tx()11€.1'21.t:eci after Q-.11q1..1iry. T116'. 5153,1110 a1$() c.:Ie2i:T1j .".i".{'L')I11
the rec()rds 1'1':ai1'1t:.aineci by 111%: C{)1"1('.C.l'1"t€Ci1. VV:1'1'i'(:«E.1V'~:.1_1"e;.
that. the enquiry is c011ducted in a fair. ..
fact. 11<:gatives 1.110 c()11t.eI1ti0I'} (if1;}'1£:.Tp}3ti*t»iOr1ér 't,1?1'z¢.-11.
Ma1p1'actice E.1_1qL1iz"y Cc':m.-:3_.1it,t.e;1s 2’fiig;£:h.a1’1j§0.e11iy_ V>
conciuded the p1’0Ce(~:dings in iii’-1_C fI1E1′{‘i.€i’.«.._
‘E’11e..:’eff£;~ fif11_<:i any g:'oL:nd to
i1'11;erf<»:rrc with the im:piT1'gg11_f¢€1 "(_).1f'd:31'/'.:21jz&€I{51'semam. issued
by 1,h'»;.? IJ__:'T:i\*V6r1*.e;E«iy";VA 'i€[_é'1':(§ci–. fihe writ. peE",i1?i(T)n fails and
a(?Co1'c1ing}y ~s:«m"1–e 'i":_s ciiémissed.
I’ ‘A …..
3UDGE
“‘(‘§{‘}.’ —