High Court Karnataka High Court

Manjappa S/O Nagappa vs The Union Of India on 22 July, 2009

Karnataka High Court
Manjappa S/O Nagappa vs The Union Of India on 22 July, 2009
Author: B.S.Patil


m 5»
EN” T’E~’§§r.*§§ ‘E”§.i{‘3§”§: €Q.’,€fj§éE§’%’f’ i”fjiE*-‘ .§{jX§-3.:”§_?§Tf’fi§§;’E A”? §?,%;”§E’~§{};’5;Lf{I)_.§€iEf§

::};x:_2_’:%::;} ‘”‘E’E?-fiifi ‘”§E”?i§%Z 32% _:’f2;w {T}??? JEj§£’r” ;;e:%,:s:_;%§’ =u

§3EIZ;F€f}§€E§

*:m;,s: §~»:§;:::a5§s:;§s: §=51.’:~<f. J{?::§'§'E.§~2s..::}95:i:;2<;:€;': §:=;fé;z; . .
zgésiga 5 2{}:M";?, 25$} 21 'f';{3{,%"?' X
/N L). P. No. 15950/zoo-? .'

§§.%€Z'i'§§f§E%E§'*E

ET §a«'i;%E'x%¢..§£i'§-EEA ;E>;a_
A.{}E:>E} :”§§3{)’U’§’ «<35 YEZ:A.§_«%.§:"§. i
&i};%§{:a::,rTf:_;;'§2;s§'§' '

:%,saar@<s:§;<%;: 4 .

:§;:,{; ‘;$é.;”:%§:M.’:3j§;»§:;a3.:_§”;;i:sa

;aa::e;e%:>’–AE;<;i,§':'*

8,, L 2x;;a';:§ALg:»%%_g§';2.

. E,$£’§7§é1,§v:§i;Eéi}.§}E.% “x:’E?;§?ZE€;’%.§3§’?*«,

‘-i:;:_:,§-§>:§> ;3;EZ3{‘}’£§’§7..:f7:F..?7’:”EiZAE&$=

‘$4:

3′ ‘i
wfw’

” ~ :>::>§g§>§i>a S} {1} v§:;%:§e;2;3;};:
E§{2’$7:;’:i_§f}” :§§?%’a*;”}E§’§’ 4%; “‘f§3,.«%?E3§§&
. ‘ “V’j§2?3;.§§%&E}EZ’§§.z’3;§}i3.%§
:~:;f_ §i§%=§E:i%’2§:éA§3§’–2%
£fa{}§:”:’.:E) ;:§3{:2;? am ?§;;§§e$,

éigzmévégaéga

” 2 is: ; 2} ;.,§;’§éa:. Efiifiéi ;%.§}E3.5’a
«;%s:}}?::> mm}? 5:: %’§?:,%?€’;f%§.

E73′ §§AE§’%fi£E’§-E S2} {T} §j);%?~é’:%P§3’P:
§E{3EZ§f} &§f§r’C}’i.§’T’ 41% YEZ§§RS.

ct, SB Efiiégiiij ikiéifi
ii} §’}{}§’~§}iE3’PA_,
§£{§E_Ti§I} .c’iE§{}3L;§’?’ 36 YTEARS,

2% :s§:..>§_:_é;%?E% V
5:; ; 2.} i.}{f;_i._3 §.:>;w %TiE%:§%£A§¥’§>& _
z::i§§:§ z’%..E_§i;>2.,?’E” 36 ‘*f”£i1ARE§;–,

a, H’i§.§\€i.1§v’§A?\i’?%-§r’i§>P:%,””‘
$55} :vm%§a§}z:v,a::*:§?;;«– ‘_ _ u
aagti} AB€i}¥_§'”F 6: YE?;¥€%;

‘:3, E*i?;L:§§»§§s_!§;§ ” 1

22.5; 2:} m*:?:e:’,’§%§::.:PPA.§ N::A~ A .
‘3:.f¥’?*Y%?2;%.E3§;.

<2' ____ £:&'%3.V:§':€}:.§§§§é_,_"V A

(2 gsé;§;E.';,?~<sLé;§~%i§':ag§g:?%.§A _
A<':::'E:-:i:»- §'~a,E%€Z}'é:E'fEf"-~ :»T.?::;T5§:<$, '

2.5%' %§s;:i';':%;%$é;é§"i~;~s Qt'; %é'f2{?g§X§-'E-"'E*:

_;%%'I3eE:§} .s"§'§.§{?if7§'v'*Z§é=-§"'F{E.?';%RS3'

v- '1 1_ , :A§a:%4&
2% 513;: :%:.§é§.:zm§>§>,és,

;2§”,§E§§} £868? 336 “§E§.e%§:?§§,

A §’£X5

fiiééffli} §%E%{_}i_?”§”‘ {:3 E. ‘2″”EZi%.§€E€&,

2:, éfififif 5,233 EVE fififix
E56′ 5 {E SE EL??? E,s§,E’?é §};’%E’3§3′,F§

_;3,V
A%;§%:;.§.Z’% ;%§’§§iL’i}Ei”‘§” ?€is ‘£5-Fl-f%,§E§:§K

‘:2 ‘ fr-i E ‘%f;%Y {.}€};’i 9 E31
E 8 SEE.)§..}§’a¥’%:Z§ii%?gE’i33Ps5
:’E.{3r¥.$E} §§E3{}Ti___§’i” 56: ‘*¢'”‘§.-‘Z;~°§i4ET§’§_,

{L SE? 3% §”§”RAE&2’§ ME

W 5 {‘3 §A’i’§:£k§?L H AN U .§¥’§i§§f”§’>§’E”E§§§§3P§;,
§%,{I%§?.1§} 33s8i”}i.VE’ Ii»? “a”‘E2§R$..

(E. E, “v’E.-Ei§§%AN.N&

if} E}-i §}§}fE%’E’.’,1EZE%fi§3E’5£§,

,:aL{3iE:E} £’§B€Z}U’§’ 46% “f1§g§’RE§T,

‘x§E1E§§%AE%”*£
:=;; §r’E%i:E%:E%AB§%A§T}§’~%AP?A
;’%GE.§ ABGEET’ 55, fvzsgzagzg

5: §3A$;sVA§~2;g_%A¥>p§;’% ‘

.. .

535:; 3:} ;r=;§»<::z;*;*-:.s*;. ; %'§.Ei»f§:2$. _

V 4:»; at; gs;;x§§vi_.;_§;;g§¥%'»:?§§sxWza
2; ; gm; .§&:.:3';'£_AiT2%i;+§;:::.,:T,%;; mg:

V mi-:§.«:.*:.;: é*'.E_§:j_sai§m :3; 1 *§::;;2&3.

<32 §§.:';';:%'§5;;%§iss3é§£;«§:%*x
' — 3; :5 -:;:a:: ma: }'§}E};%E}E'3A§E;£_E}E,E.iE 3:;

w-%-'
.!r"'*'

;%V{§?;-E} AE{}U'.{' iii}, YEARS,

" S"'*§'EZ:§} ;::~§A§»z:;a§ Ssaa
3; <2 :,g2'rza¢<;;,a§:3§~;a$m

_7?§g,;;

‘mm
1: «
‘s«:’w”

:%ii}§E§} §*s.B€’_”}i.§”§’ 33% ‘§f’§Zg%.RS.

§fi{§’EZl §~§§i§\§ i§§%”EE’§’%i'”%f§’x W; {C} £§}fi?~%§§;”%§-3%-2%
f§§?\§{_T’.E} §}”§§E%E}3 E€fE*Z§3§%E:E§§I?=§’E”E%?§3 ES? §,-iéifié

$.31}

‘Hi

V. E5;

2 _ §;E3{:}E,§’E”‘ 35’ E. 3’§::r’i§93;5§

E-%i”::§%§?%£:z%.?a?é§%: {}E%E;”‘1if£§”E {E E§}5§5f§é§i§3s§*§
§%{}E§§§ §%E:3€}{§”§’ {“33 “:”‘E§’§.’é€8

9% g%€}§'{£ E’% E} R33 E3 ¥’;”i 51% f {T} E§3’%§”~1?*é?s§3§’3z%
;*%{}§{?Z§.}’* §%.Ef§{§i§”‘§’ 36 ‘:’EZ;’§§?$E§

3-.~;( €_§§§?€€.§;%?s%.§J’:§ :2~ag{‘: H %;:g§a:’~:’;aP:>;a_H_ _”~..
s’§{..}E~’_§%’} :”:B{}Z_%’§’ ‘s:’EAE2S ._ *

§:333i%§f§}}§}1§a s;;a’::> §v§:z§a;.:A§}§?;%
as ;1§§{:;z.s’§’ ~»é-is; *2’§:s:::23. ‘

;x.%;§;a_:r%;z§rA’:’2«§: Evifzféaiii§’~EPx’§’%i$’*§t§fi,} E’§Vzi.§:}}§A§21’_§3.*§% ‘

.:’a€;j’;E;:{} ;%§3€:>a3*? :3 2. ‘:_’%3iARE§

‘§’§§ : :2;~>::::~:;2é 2%.; ; §;§2;–vm.§’5> E35.
gag} 23:2 _,s’§i.§€«T~§V¥~J§f:’§”‘ “:33 *’rfjE*2″a;{%E”§ _-

2% is :3:g_:%é’:1éV;%;:;§é,’5′::;%:’;:s.;%;a;:.§r:’_ 2:*,:”z_ %’;;:_.:i§2s

$9;–§§;’;§–:«;;;_:§a;%;%ai ;~;;§’; :«:s§~§§v;a;7-%:4>A

~§sé’}%..%,.L;a§>§>;2 5%; £3 f?’§§E”3″i§A:%;%§«Et2%;?*s:E.?«;§3§4>g5».

~–.V;§a::i;%;: £1: …a.’§§»:;:e’a ,5′? 4%: ?%:a§9;S

“éé ii E-i’»%:~s:%_;§»m:iaé’J:’z:§4Ag;>:};s. f%*;f{jfs §%;?a?=:§fi§>§>3’i

Eéilifiifl} §3s,E~;§{_}?;.?”§* ‘£2 “€E*Zfi;RS

E’€s%{}§g§€z%§;%§3E3%% §;;:s §€§§§v§;%§3E*’?*=.

f§{§%.%i§f} £§B{[}§..§T’ 4%}

:32. 3% E §»§§£?%;%&s’%§>§3?a {E §§I;*i?a%E;’§§3§-15%
fi{§-EEK.) 5§,E7§€T’}E§”?’ 362 ‘%’°§fZ?%.§>?§’§

Z7

38

P1}

2%}

ii if E93.’ ._§A€};§§}}i§§:iE:§i~£ {T} E%é;M%§}E3’&
E-%{}E§E3 ;*’%.E%§{f}{.?T 312 YE:3z’%.F€S

3-{ANEE ::zmN’a’:~;;3:>P& s:»;;'<i3 §i3§i>A:£:§é:;:;AE>.§}A i’

;%{}E:iE} fiE:”§€.’} U’? 39 YEr”:E€S

E%5’i$?3§*’§’9’§§ 53:3} {.3 i*4;3’i§\E.§”%;%§}§*’!%
A€}.’§{3E} é3:§3{_§UT’ £35} YELEERS

H 1+; f-%§H?«.?4’%{z%E€§s§’P’A gs} §::§»mé::’.§4égéégigés-“;gaé’§>#
JKTSEEED ;a.§3z:::.s’:*’ 3:; Y§3AE%2S* =
f;fi§:§3’§E’*=%Z’\§;%E3I?3fi éggiis §é%*e%;%:s:§i;:’;::1s%:§%.;aé4>:?£’T
f’i€}§§E’% 5%B~*f}LE’§’ $0 ‘fz’Eiz%RE:§ ,…. _

2-}. E.~§,%:’~}:Aif’A Rzixffi ;’.€_’§’– ;;f:§;§;%§\: ii;-§%g§,§§#;:::za§’3§>gfig
ga::;:«::i; ;\,’:’~3{‘,’:m’- :55 “:'”E.;»”&E?,S j

**** .E–?f}§§i5€és.§§§1§:i:%E~§”u¥f;&%€;%’EF;i’v§VV§r§2C} §–i&;J;:§>P,:x
r”–g{§”€;§f}_ ;%.’:§>A

;isi*:;fz:;»§f; :a%3{:::%?’- yéiggg

; :9; sé§;’%.§.,:_é§;§g%.§;”:’;–§A:’3s-:25: 2-iggas :«-igzmiigia
._f _ ‘ .;:=;j::_;%:;;;:,%’ :2 ;%e;;»:’:: ._:2:.:; “£’§i%3».»%§”%EE%

§rfi?sE*’§~”;% {‘3 E-§§’£’~é’§§E”%:’E;%%€’§’Ei?a,P§3%%
§3{T§.§..§’§’ 333%??? ‘§E§1;E3ff**§

‘§*§é;.:; ;%;%§E&:;;..g=§£:.;§e§ ?”é§&ss{.;’:’é§,§'”}§”Ef§a
;2€:;:’:::: fi’£:%if}E3″£”‘ 2?: ¥§}::zaEé:s§

ii; :4 :2§g:s3;xaI§i§2.;a_§’;a§>§>§a

ag z: 2;As:;A;3§>;2

;a .r’§E§€T}EJ”E’ 5 3 ‘;”§iy%E%f:*§

3% 5»; v§JA’Ym;a:MA§%
:s;;a,.

;’i_{1:E%:§T:% .&§::§€}iJ’§’ :3 ‘2. :f§:;sg2:s;

H 3? ;*:a.N2,;:~v§A*ré%’ma2>P;x’
3:; <1"; M;x1,L:s:$§»~m§I3 3-if-a
A::;»§3_:',§'; fi;E3€73'i,i§'§' 3:3 %£;E3;a_§<es;_.—-..

:%::€::;A:é',;:s;:; Z§§3{j_E§§’§Tj_ 4 “ET 3:’§};}’§’Ei5ti}

v;::a%.&4%=;”‘%:%;§§:§::?:~;: ~ __ ‘

g 2:: :«;;;r%;:+:’;.§;§sa::A;§;J*¥2é; .
mi: ii} ;3::}:;:%:t *~;”§1i::g§’§::§ ‘

;-isx:r\;”:Tn2.:a§;*2$3′::;%;’::s§=>;ix.’ “”.’%w 4

_ 5′ {1} gas 222% gésaé-.>.§:–;a. :%;::.4>’:::.%:,.§1>s;{;;;=,3~: rxgagvsgw, s
, 5’§{§’§?i§§ a§::~::.;i§* ,*5s2:a_§as§§

:<.::_ %;.€,}'§"."§3%i;E§'3P§1
_ R; %

g i'g§'%' §§?3§%z%.§1'§*.é.

;:’§;§fs%:T}’:* ?: ‘fE7;§%..§€%§

:._

. . uE§?s%§§§{%:’;%?€g’§{§{f§’i,E.§;};5s.

” :%;{,’:: :;;¥a:vm§9§3A

fxifiéii} ;%E3{}EE’§’ fizfié ‘{E:£§E1E;’:§

V % ” v 2&3 ix: 3; %:;§g&4′:f_§«éé;§>:I>;%

1=’§;;§}§%

§€§%’.~§§.ii} #§i§:§{/.}§_,§?§.$ E ‘K?
€’,§2″§§*3 E-3Z§§§—EEK???-3%.

‘W

E’ .-:.E.

ii?»

::;;;:,..: E;%;%E<§;E§3§~?;%
.2x ;’a§:js{‘>a:’E’ 28 “*z’§2.?a§’€S3

2:. ‘ii E-T’§3a§’é{.§i%’§f’3§{$’§%’£é’§’§’3fxP§3’§§
5%»; {T} §.i:’%E%§;’?’*;E3§€»’%
5’i€.}E%%2§.} £*¥£§€Z}’§\,.f’E’ ‘§§fZ§’:R!?3

E3; E5; K §’éA§€§’:§_§ ..

{E §’§5E§éEi§f§§$r§§~.§%E5s’3\.§€F§§1’E%’i.
E”§€’}§7iEi} §’1..%3{;§E.§’f’ “SE Y§€i5″i§€5*§

‘:«;:::?::g:.:§Tg§ra:4’*£=:a E¥a§;;a:?%*A

f-%::”:;s: :..:s:::;a:f; $53?’ as 2: w:;’§:=r:,§§’:%:%«s9;:’§»z’

f if} §gE§”§”i%Z %{§?Z§”€€I..?§*§§’:§3§3£
5-%{§§*lE}} 3’§E’%{} U’? 126:. §’E%f’aE%3§:1″

:;§A:%;;w;>a :

:::;:;:*~s ::;:§%: §f:§53R.§i.’: £3? E_,i'<<:"Ev§;i;§?»i§§'?a!§g'§§'=€"§"§§_s":E?*§1?}% E
_
£'a%'i.§E€:{} §g§:~:VVV_2%A::;;*a$22333}—.. v “-.
?*e’§§m§{.’§'<–§3 ' "

. ¢”:€i;§Z”{2 ;:::::a:; :4 ¥§:A_§%é§

i = “‘$E:;’%£’;%§’€§%§*§E,§::§;};%§>E3i?a
~ __ r s % ii§:faf*§;%_§*Eifis
Ti ” %:i;>§€:=. ‘

” ._;::;§’:;’::,,.?§* «$113 §’§:;;a§2S ‘

§’°Ez§?x’%’&%’§5>fi

;<:;;§;1; ?€s'%€I};§§5'§-3;'-"s
22%; {:3 Ea:

z%:;:.:«m.> ;as:::T;:,s’:’ {T:}_::%E2E~§

‘xi E $5 éif 5% E3 ¥-25’:

ii} %»§z’%§’T§;”‘i§3’§»’?%

2%”: ;”fl§z.§ {E E4?

§%£,,%§f.Cl§} §%§:§€l}E4§’E7 “E ‘§’§}=§1.»”»’2E”–3f4$

‘E {E-

ET .

“E5.-‘ 3 ‘.

{§z%§,§ Eiééifivfi §i«’§:’§

$5 {.7} §?5§’§’EiE; N § ?%§{3?:§3′.’:%%
?az§!§s.§*f…}§%§

iii?’ ‘-£13″; 2′-“2§€3’§{L} UT’ {éfé ‘}f’§El§’§.§93E§l

“$2. {3Eé’£i?é’ ?%;§§:§;E§%;§E>§5′;%

3:3; {.2 §«;{_}5;”§~:;w%-iii ~
,E’£é%-.§€i’§§-%E 1
.ra{;’:~_:-ii; g?.;’E;<t:; 42:3; '€'¥f<1f§E%S§

3*; {"f:§*§s§§<a'E}§%f§'%$§§~-E§f;E«4;£i.%{§§13:§%;%
s;;e:':: ::;;a:s;fig:?;3;1 .. *
:s.:gsm~:::§e
3-fi,<;';~r§:'::u:: a%;3;{;;:"_;";' 54 %;?;£:;%3"esefa"
>§3*;a, §s;;:::%: s;;;:§’§’;:§>§:a
%g%_m.;§;§2
;2~§;%; .
:v*;é_..2m’:f}’§~3’%v ” A =

V :i,_{1:§:7;E:2 ‘;¢:§i::?:.;:=2Mzi*;3~– :5; m*’::§’;:§2:e;

5 .’::; V. ‘§~;;§:::*=; é->52

i:;-:1; {1} :a,a:§§.is§’j:;a;f>;>g%

” rm ¥:,:<:z "

M

.__..%;.§é§’:;:::’é,\:*§ -1?: yggwg

1- ‘€” ‘:«s;?:”:’:a2;::<;§a;m–s

$5' §r§?i§%§z'%, Fifi
§g%:f:;,2:';R

v"~_.;5's£.}:E:Z"§i} 5§§:%iZ}%§"§' :;s;:'; *;';%:;z:;%s;;

3.’ 3%; {E E&§E§E§§%i?fx§€z%«…§_fi».§1’§i”3§

5 {I3 §’§?%£’»E E} ..?a:’E;%?%§’§”§-§’i%§9§”i%
5%.? 5.} $3
E §5Z§.,} §\.§};%é’,}§§,§’§” 53 “E %”;%§§§§5:5§

~ 25,} —

§§e:”:€_f’:§;%i.}E: $.32 <::s§' £;"?,,E'i<jfi £%.§'i.?i aim zawii. a$:~_;.i: s?a:”i}i%;’:>,§i:.}3.’_ ‘:5

zzénéxi:-T=::.:%:,:’:<;,*: 3:3 §'§?.{f{'3§I£E§§€§{""i§' éézg': §':'§.::2i%,.:-;*:§" ':¥3%,.E:§.:"; 3 ;;<':r§u§%

ézmzfiizsg .i:"'§'s:;m ::,§:::% s.:'§::;;%:-V: <.;'§' E"§'f{3{:':§§.}'i, <3'? 22 a:a':sp}; sis? %%"';%..=;'

;w="'+g:::£"::3;:"v:.i'::"':.g:§_§.§=g §.§"';:::s§é;: 32:11: Eiiéézmsaa 2%:-§A»:3:.%£<2*§e:_;{::§.

..

£.I§.’2fE’: