High Court Karnataka High Court

Miss V Vagdevi vs M/S Santosh Builders And … on 16 July, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Miss V Vagdevi vs M/S Santosh Builders And … on 16 July, 2008
Author: Ajit J Gunjal


HGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH (.’_0U_RT OF KARNATAKA HEGH COURT OF KARNATAKA I-IGH COURT OF KAINMAKA HIGH COURT OF KAINATAKA HIGH C
_:;;_.;;; ‘4

xvi

AT Bfil%’G&I_§RE>

3% TETE7 §:§3UR’§” S?

mmfi mg 1% mm my OT JUL?

EEFSRE

‘mg HOWOLE an ;_§z_:s’:*z§§; &E?&»=£§§§§;§§.L~ _ T T T

.&.:*;%;TT as :mi1*w

Eamaapa”: %

kgm *s£.¥ag§E.v§,
fisgesfi a%:1.1’s~:E§§?¢ax’s:., ~

Efai Efigfififi Taak _

2% Swag; %Fu,:z§.g2–. ‘} _

Bamalszxrar-fiééii 036. TV ; ..;;.%’I’I’I’IQRERS

:3:-3: .¢a§?:9*i5’I§a;?’?1-«§¥%t§¢’§(i3»«as:::_3::’;:1.;:”§3__ ‘

-a OET3 axld Qevekwm
fix Em Ofimm
firs: §*€%:;;,.;2é:Zt4f;f 23%., ;£§.:z’;1¢r5}:a§*a Tampie Sizrwt,
_ E§aga%:.%»,*»§;g:al§’a, if.-‘gi ,\?.Ee:& Rlagari

» m ms.

– in Farm

.. S::%*;€;i%2E«4.T;B°E*1§:.g9’ara€$m.

th Rwfifi
F&;?;”‘Ii{3!3$*§§ %£E,¢’ 5§ h Eui§&z.=z/m
§%:é£._ Egmlgfim, Riat Rafi} 23%,
Tafik Street?

fzzmh

J * »1I’i§2§;a”*w£&m13″a:

* -*Cff’i§1%am3…?1 Piagaxg

Em%ai<3re:~=§fii31 ®§3.

Szfi thy

Panama

Fégfafimxtcssfi Buéldgfi and Dwaiepera

R5 at 2&3 .%1§$fia}*a Tempie $’&mt,

EM

(fa)
M

Z’i’aga2a:%¢§xt*&.’ *a, $yV. Eager
B§3z’%t§&if;:=:’fi-§@:3 Cfifi .MRE»SP3NE*EHT$

{Em “§.¥’i;§5~..§*a$he§:ar& § g$$ifliififi§ Padwy. 1:5:
E23; . ‘« n

‘{f;E9IP” is ffifii utfifif af
A3€*%im”a’&:m azfi ‘1’?;%fi;«, _ “ts 7
agwifit a auifiahk gzhihfimr :fnr–* 7p93fgfm;e’.~’A::;_af
ar§;§u§§.i:::$;’ii;%fi sf tfia fifapgsta hemwmfi titss ;.§ti:§2:nz2;f”~afi.*–i
fizz r§:.::2apf;::*::i»~.§§’§3 and rafaif ‘aha éisyum :i?;at~V.}’3.3s.§’¢
Efitwgfin 5% wtfiansar its: the saié
a§’?m<i%r'a&:;r €53: ad§ud§m%3::Bn$_§;§'%haV. _§11'x?&e1*a:s;%.vV::f_3::i1st?:c:e afi

=£f»§»iP mmzm is fitzn this fiayg the
iiiaurimmia i' ? V. 1 O

'E%r¢ sabwcshxte my af
tha " The §:x'amr't3.r 332 qzzmtinzi is
5:3' Liféé ?m$§$ at" a rgisharai gift dacd

'tn Efiave; Ewen mmufiw by mr

' gefitinner ia cf' 5: jf§Q1.li% saga azzfi. (iew :15:

Efifige 311$ aha $3 2193'.

‘ ifha in Whifih Ehg

with

ia ma §i”‘G}}&I”§g? are in ha

simzi dmfi Sufiw i§ ii: gay fiat {:9

aka §§3:.é.§.%$z’:a~§§ film %?&ps;’&§}$$3:”3;€ in {kg meméz mi’ Smoker

‘liGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH OF KARNATAKA E-RGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF XARNATAKA IMGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HEGH 1

.§ urfiua eafiimntage 0? Ema” m afi;

afifia 232%” zizgabfiéézgr Ea zgnsziersmgxé 1&9} amtm macufififl

_{‘

aéizgiztfizgmentfi aéfgisafi a3 Jfikmt Bewlsgmnt

:13: gig wall was fim fiaanflal Fawer af

83%: $13 ii§{‘:”L1m€»§%% am
mma ta Iuxzzm’ a’®u§
wmfmazgzzz sgzmmn: and %
§§z’a,mm=:;’%§” %” tn Emile
iaga} :’:::::§a::ax::, 8. »%:%2:sp§: 53:’ 41;
mm ;::¢m2:m;’2 and mnamm
§££’:v*fi§Z$fi”;¥;£.Z1: agaemzyzx. was
firm £m.’%.:m§ _ if ‘ new? mmflfi
flea” 3:, was replied by that
ia preéuawd. at H&
B ” :1′:-%:’1’cx%:1′:$ fif ifm ifial mtém axfi

am: 1% mid jam ée:savs,e}u§xmex*11:

V fifififitfid Wifix Ear fufi kfl£’.’:4’§E?E%$ aw

— af tha mzfimix. Eke wtitimzmr &

Ema” ‘,:§§-“§§fii’§§’§ aiiagémf mam, 3 mg; cf Whkfih is pmdizmé

etiazafi Sizfiév»,-flfi’? 1:113 arbiflal

s;’_’5§afF.1§§T: 321$ aufifigfirg ‘him gamg af a scale §f§%itfa§flf :3

new COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH cougar or KARNATAKA HIGH coum’ or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA men c

aafiwiéa-ate Vibe d§s§uEsa beiwean {Em -‘ It is $3 be

rzmtimfi, it; :t 2113 rampsfimit ciiai mt mgfiy 3% the: safidfi

Z’

z*3;a::t3ic&=, Hflflflfi thim gxatifimi Eifidfif %$;ia§3 §.l{5} sf the
§§.§”%3:.”i1′.$§§§”.’§$E and €4;’:em§§ia’§nrz act? §;’?% {fir
£§.»i”§’-‘C§§., O O

Es Z%aI§:I§ia»§hu$u&hm Raaistz-., O
awfimim tfzai
agmmfiatg izmsmuaffa 3:3, hm lwarl
§7§%.aé:3:–2.:£ $33: afi
$3 %.3.”r§a’i:. $23.. impeciimant

in fiygafifiizmg ixgaamutzh aa, tk safi

Jfifilfiii ~* mgéaim an arbitral

afiauggg ” ‘

far the rmwzztient

V rgarfi Ea tha fag: tha very agreémmxt £3

V:%;._e§x2~:ia&§. wmzfi mmgm} v maan am. all {he

z:::z:23’§§$;fi;?:fi fiéamm am aim fififififi, 1:}:-:1: getitirmsr t

C ‘§:’.%E

IIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH I

sziauaea

% E Eaam gisvm my armmkua ziarmiéfiratiaan 1:3 the
gamma} far fiw fl
./

/’

::.:ft}:1§

§n t $ by the

‘§’::% apyméata iha rivaé cantezmbng

£ g ii ia fimffifififi? is §%i: fats ézf

‘elm §:2*:’?: 333% Seating {E} srsf

%$§”m $3 ta: ‘Mia: fig :;z§3*::~§itf$:.®3:’§.”ssg};1 f’ t:::_,:a?,,

fix-Jfi –

?.:ha:’: ta S1$§ffl§ii {gr mrtain
§77m§*:.2::’.:m ix:-‘¥i°xic%z arm betwmn
#3? Whcthtzr’
maz§£m::’.:%::_§a”‘§ gr ‘? 9? tha
fiat §§?’£:%L?x§:’.’§ fiifiifi may R in
the ffimm §::§ §::%.:f:. a mxmaci er §g the
{:25 a S~uPb~$e::ct;’nfl. @ at’
H’ is. ” ‘cc: m

ana 8″z2b~Smt§$:*z gar; atatm that it

.. «

E3; the 5:22: “ewuitzi ragga ‘fig: %& @r§1Z3i§’§iI’£§.€:fi 0%’

Win’: 5.3 :*e};a1.sa::a§ Es wfiefimr fw {Em yuri

‘ am ifiifigffitfi “m£*«;§=m:2 thg mrtiw, thc

mm Emmim 2% as-bimfal aiazzm. fl 16(1)

» :35′ mg fiaifi wauid zmfi as undar: fl

IIGH COURT or KARNATAKA HiGl-I COU_RT or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT o:= KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH COURT or KARNATAKA HIGH c

J’

j

-IIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGI-j[»CO_:URT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNAFAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH I

“E Ewsafiwm a£aa’bi’&”a£ §’fi%ta rule out

gzzyéafiififisn immjng m
‘§§~”;i:§’E 3mg: %9 the «afzf
&%’§3i?I”a§fifi 2,}

IE:

:3; fig &rhi ciE§nf:;1t3_ga bf
fiscisflfixaai sfialé

i:1dap£3ndc1’h;;~§f fif xwmracrig

:22; 3. ¢é§w;i.ajr:l@n:”%* :iLaa;:}:ma;%:fibm; that rm
mt entail

gg §g”;éa.rb}Em,*.at:i;::n sigma.”

rélaszafii far film pus-wae sf

of 3&8 yrfivkians Weufi gizwrizy
‘O n:s:w~iti~mtand%m tha fact that the
X agfiwmt 3% gm at E: 2% fit; 5: mm as am, em
{flange mrmzfi anrvfiva, y fi 13 met in

dfigliifi £1135, ah: fisiat Daamimpmrmt —

afi ayffiitraé flmzse wifich ‘gmu§d rmd ax uzrzder:
1*: msmnm : Q

ISGH COURT OF KAHNEATAKA HIGH COEERT OF KARNAHKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HEGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH C

‘.’¥?’.l}: Ix: ‘tiw mam :7»ft%;t*:s 5313,: fiiapufla with
ragarda fig ziéfi nt 93.” ufiuatr $33

2:221″ %m&@e%a’£mn mi’ any 3% $3

9%’ ‘tJ:12:s aymmmt fix
rfzéffimrxai ta arhéarafian $£V’M§,§ $:3le.”a:s”&~it:$;i§r’–Ata .
a§:;:%:5mtm¥; $5; the yaafiéjés “a’§}.i’,§§;’–._i?;$?§E}5{§§f_:3′;3;’§?§£§iI1 O

mag 7% Em. E’;r1g1im%;_a;z1s:3. as s§5z¢}%%§mavas§§ins¢£
firisifraéifig anti gmgeégamn Jastg sea: 6%’
353.9% $1′ mach g;:’?§i&t*a§,i;m~iij’ a:}f:2;.~a.§ ‘:25. Ofiamgalrfim,”

as. well
3:5 %’ifl3}9}2IIZ!]fi;i’1t

the
‘ mfi miszaprmexfiafistm ‘film

zgszfibiaiéi vmxzid survive Ezavfim ward ta

3% {b} cf 11% fiat. Indead, if ariy

. r éi%3;;§a%§$ii*$ss’T;=::*§qi§ir@§ an ‘€§§.& qzgmfimig, am (an refer ta

fig; gag? wammmr am; xmw mm

:¢~*m. , V; ms, mm mm LT9″. Mm saws

zwgr-‘*’%.:£~v:.:§ {$59733 ,&)’.’E mm 415.

.24-