High Court Karnataka High Court

Mr Jerome D’Silva S/O Thomas … vs M/S Maruthi Traders Having Its … on 19 June, 2008

Karnataka High Court
Mr Jerome D’Silva S/O Thomas … vs M/S Maruthi Traders Having Its … on 19 June, 2008
Author: H N Das
OHM" 0? %%RN&TAi(fle. HEGH COUl%?fl'F;*_.;'(ARNA?AKA HIGH COURT 0F KARNATAKA I-HG!-I COBRT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COESRT OF KARNATAKA FRGH COURT

13:: mm RICH-I cam? cm rmmamm, 

nmrzn mm THE 1?" my G3' %me[ 

ms 1-1o:e:r'31.s rm. .:;3s'rI»i:3 

cmmm m*1~':&:c1¢ iqa..:2'az:',:2%3V=f.$ s%%' k

cnxmrxm  'rémfiiazé LT':z'«z'*:*:.'s..,'}"_.»::'_$ we as ea
cm_,P,no, % " ' 
MR    
3.63  wsznrgaza M 
mm:  a2%w:1*as'.%%' 

Rmmnarmm;   :¢m;aa4ra=;x:2.A.::e.s:&n.n
%  '     wrxwrgzmg

 &  ma mm mm mm;

 '*i'3.=mERs
1:m.v1£«.rG'o§£'IcE MI'

 gauxxmm can s':r9.Em:
 * 3.32 3': ms ymymzrsp.
--  arm. mwmm away 2

'Sim: B mmmma smmm

 Amy? 4:: ms

.. .. B.ESE"J,N3.'.Z€R'I'

(BE SE32; B.1'!."-'iii CGRB.BA§

C}'v\/V



yum ur KAXNAWMA Hifiifl CDURTAAQEFKARNATAKA HIGH cmm Q5 KARNAVAKA MG!-I COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COUR?

in?

C:'RL.E' 3:32.333 a',.»'§.4a2 c2.P.cV.. »§?£<.'_ rm
mvmam ma 'rm PETITIDHEB. PRE1.¥I1§&i4-,TH?;T"-.31-I19
If13r}I'BJZ;E cszrzmr Hm' BE Bnmszn Tat: ;s?__E:'r'
amsa n:t..11.'?.£1r§ mssm 33 mm  F391;.' --s;J*...,

1J.K., !®L'HG3lL€3RE, IE  SZ'§'£"g

AS1313 Tm: rznm 2:er.2::.5';¥io"4'%':=rs;s.s£1:: _m*_  .m1:~:.*;-

v caum, mrzaawns, :;.:g-.A~..--=1N,A:;'-:.:;:é§§;1_,'?As;:;;e»4"--~.5

ISSUING snmmz-rs TE} TIE1__F£'£'R..  :2U£§.S:fi 
Cowman: m c.:.r:ej;?«sVo;cs4-A. 9mgzm2_ar;*§.1z:'=.1; jz.:fe--m 2.11.;
as '1'I--£E mya-'5: arzrzmm  r':a,zs:. , I24 39
ran. as THE mm. :5 =:;,cr.2»::§'::::£c;1~m:s'.'  'e

¢RL.9.Hn.2a1x2s$§_' 

ssmzr:  

rm       
am    

 MAI" "'1%=.*~.~2';V% :;2&3_"a.§a1w.
ABUQHAEI '  AT cm:-12; 5335?
mum' 

  """ ~ " . . . pgwrrzerzaa

 53:5: "~.§_§R.z:.1:.3:.EIm ma mzrrema .5 mm;

153' 3 'I-mam: TFAJEEEES

' ~  :r:'::*s E.'aF}':"IIi'."E gar
 VE1~3I<ZsTFs.B33.K.5£¢.R wzmm; cm. swpma',
..

RE?’ BY ITS ?R0.?’RIE’.?fi

MR. EI€’?$TH 5’£iEI*¥’.1:’… =$*:».*’..,_ ma
mvmnrm mm mm ysrxrzazma £>1i!..E.?i’Lfi§;{§3f-$1-I§&’:T”~.’3’£~IIS
I-i1’Ja1’I*BLE: sway mi 35 zénmasrs 3’21’; 5:3?’

C31′-%I3ER D71′.-t2′.8.33 935533 3%’ mg 9.833′. ~3;J;..,

3.1-:.,, xmmaraiat-3, I1»: €3Z$?.ZA.»V.B.P’.I€:43′;§Z§}§Vt:§$’V.. .:g;a*9__
ASII3E mam ssym m*r..3:s,5′;::»;”‘:;;;s;..s3n _B;=:=:_’1;’§m .:rm=::5—
V i3€.’JUEJ£’,,~ ztsaz-zc3a*+.L::2RE; ‘D–?i£;~..«T’m.. -2:;-::.’;:~;f-.::’_.’?a_r:;:,4-‘s«:;’*~. ~

ISEIJEIEZ’-a summs tm ‘£’1-}fE’.__?;€ffI’fi.. mafia
cmrwmnn :34 c.c.,zq:::1J.*:r:,s;z’s,*’r:a»;V_ @m::;’}Ii’s%.;$2§ $1:-m ?,’I§7′,’*-;E
:35′ ‘mm J!-am?-*-I ::’:::3m’1=¢.*::2,» “–;msGMmP.§:,’_: 1:, 1c:”.’,. I14! 2:2:
ma. as mm mm. IS ¢;’}2~:::mj.1~zE13″;

THESE cmziiam ;é*:e:z*;.*fi*2_”é:;;${“5’_w_. Camus 3:: 5:33
ADHISSIf}}I.’. “s’~if3URT mm ‘I’ll-IE
2aLLaw:tw:..V’w1’– . ‘~ ‘

, _ Thé”afi$sp$nd&nt in thaae twm petitions

,4,]:f.iv;finfl :éaV’_};:«.’1:’:f:=.?a.te ::3saz@lain.t in. Pv::E..Ha.53-a;’2rau4
” fig§ifi%§€”£h& petiticners herein and eight
“mth§£ék far afifence jpgniahahla ‘unflex fiactian

AA . __;L3§’ u afi the lslzagotialaléa Inatmmnt Fact in

‘te$9ect af dishfinwx ai certain ahafiuea.

2. The petitianeza in these twv yetitiona
are acausad Has.4 anfi 9 hefiare the trial

C¢uxt. The trial fiourt had taken cagnizance

dry

ZOURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH €0UR»TA.!9I’f”_;KARNAT&KA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNA’TAKA HIGH COUR? OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT

of thn affianaa, raeerded swarm stafi&¢§§t cf

tha zeapandent anfi imaged _{§£¢¢§$§g _hy

registering the Q-e.5e_MHin .r::;;c.;j:;e;;~vf%8–r;;2br3;L—,

aggrieved by tag a:d£t @f;th£ tfi£é1 Ch§t$ th§ai

patiticnars are héfigra tHis £éfi$tM Sn %this

patitian undar Sectiéfiyéag CfiLP@§. §

3′.I–Ia£:.rd tvhe-v..g;xgumg;i£’s ‘::§,r;;” bath side and
peruagflat3§;s:imi5al,§§§ifiién papezfi.
_$. ?h¢ <¢nl§~_céntenxien. of thg leazned

Caufififil f&r°£h§F§§titianars is that there is

»_@§u3ya%i§£§ a§armgn: against these getitienszs
V *{fl&€i #§q§ired under Qactimn 141 sf tha
" §§§$fi@fi§E% Inatrument Eat and therefore, tbs
"9;fi¢a§hings in as fiax as thaae ystitianers are
fl*.. a§fi$erns6. arm liahla ta he quaahad. In

'Bupport sf his nantantian, relianca 1% ylayafi

an a Judgmant mi tbs lazger Banah mi the
Suprame Cauxt in the case af

S.H.S.PHfiRHRfi£EUTIC%L3 LTB., ?S.NEELA; EHELLA

'\._./

€94?"

agalnst fig§%§:

% judge:

The trial Caurt to pxaaaed
accused in accarfianca with law.

Ska

Esau 3%: §§.<z«.§ mo Esau :2… S_§<§§ no .§:ou _.§.._ S.<.Ezu§ mo …§ou 33.. §«»«zu§..Hwa.._§3cu 2%.. §§.§m§ me $20