High Court Karnataka High Court

Mr Lokesh S/O Somaiah vs Mr Ramesh S/O Dodda Thimmaiah on 14 December, 2010

Karnataka High Court
Mr Lokesh S/O Somaiah vs Mr Ramesh S/O Dodda Thimmaiah on 14 December, 2010
Author: B.Sreenivase Gowda

gr

B’? E Efififi $3353? §§”

fififififi Tfifi 3% ie4~’?T’5 3&3?’ Q? EECE; 2§1§

§E§’@R§3

‘rm I~§§§’ELE 1&m,§£¥S’f’£SE BgS§EE§§Vfi;%7§*~?§§;§¥§*1}g§;

M.F’:.&5 imwsgzéég {%§g3§:;%%L[j %

wnwmwn»u.unn:4nuunI-nu9hA~a–.A.

mmmsfi
$,4’Q$Q§£F:.%§f€
$§E§A.EQZf’§£?Y%R$; —

ErL£IRAP?Am 3EE:zH:§LI§.miIR;w*f@’§é;;L*%;%
§ZS’f’R1{‘_e_’i’ ‘ = ‘X ”

mam; K§§.%§AjR$f§§AE§f;; % %

5′ -$453 fififiififisg-.

M333 …..

ggfingagfyga §«§£§§Y
mg?

V’ . * €:§é§:§a;éAL§§ gmme?

*:’1%;:.Hg §~¥S£}E£.Ni:iE 3% z:§®$
.§§f&.HC§’I emézg
Ram,

3 KY3 EE$F§§§§E§?§*$

F33 % fififi Ki SE51′?-.:

$35; FEEB fiffi §’?f§§.} ‘Q? E? 2%??? ‘§’§E
J’£}5E§E5@E*3’? Aiffi AWREE Efiifffifi §.§g§9§§§}§§ P’§s$$E§ R¥
EEVQ 2’¥§§§5E,£’2%5 QR ‘E33 E33 G? §E§TE§$’§ Jfifififi &

8%”

mmmgmr Qyiéféfia mfifif ‘Emmi QQEERTHE & m;c*§«-§§
?§.RfiY AJ£;L§’%’E§ mg max PETETTGIE
mg C£}§3@EE”3A’I*§;’Q§%’ gm fiffifiifififi _:CEhfisZ:BI’Z’ mg
C%§§E§%’§’EQ£%’Z

T315 mm Cammm ms mg $R3E§§N€§§%:§’ j’§f§¥;
mg mug? DELEVERSB mg m§ém”a§:’mt»:.h _ ” ‘ ~ * — ” :.-

JE§GM£K$ W

fkzig agpeai 5% by $15 far,” L.

af mmmnsafisn awwfiaii ;:

2; Eawég mg is ma ma’ 2: mg
fififlfififit afziig far ihé
paxtigrs §§$§m55_i$

3.’ mnxzanignsafi the gafiiaa 31:6

t9 afi rafarraad; :6: in ‘ma {mm fiaafiiifizi

A ‘ ‘ V . »A ;b$f§ra _§;§«

‘ §7″;€;E1»:; mag fagfgg af the may

.. H 3’§,§§§§§5§ Whfifl the 5.: W%

‘””§€§.§:&~3.3~L»»3$&§ as a pfifian fififii’ may Vinayaka

& .

Kaggitai an Efi-iwfiflfi Eaaé ma :*i&§* af 31¢ sfifi

33?; 3.. raah fiifi fiegiiggni

mfiiamycfis Efififi tiw

f mi sausacé agcident, Em a :’*fi$&:g3§i;’»T.€E:a

auatainafi ifijilfifisg fiance, he (5;

peéiiiazi befmré §§A€’Z”,

Qfifipfifififiiififi $35′ Rs,1§,€§Q;{}§§;;$fiv ‘§’§z’.§

awardéfi him & aamyaisafign 9%».

intgreat 3: §% $3..

5, A3 V $31333″

mmmms §s§*éC€—-~£3;::d iiaismizy $5 the
fixgxéfégr :21′ éaéhicieg fix: $212}? gczsisit 333$
arifiefi fa? éémfiicgnieraézimn in the aggaai £5:

递w}i*z&i?1€::s tbs aamyfiwaiiagz awardéé

.’§_’:”ibz2:2.&E is fag: and raagmzmiaie GI’

aeémem?”

A far

awmfi :3? mg “£’1?%2.:naZ§ E ax: fif {Em flaw thm am

casmparzaaiiazz :’:’ §:§ Elm Txéhunai :3 mt 3:X£$’£ and

=4»

mamziafiégfi it £3 $33 the Eéifiafir 3% 321% hang ii $3

ffiqiiiffifi ta be azzhmacdg

‘E’, fifhe ¢ kw mszaineé

an the mesa ma Emir; E93′: aaxa, 1a£&f&i;&§;_:fi’§§?fi;§5é_

the rigizt gidc af fsmhgad

brass; ané mntzzsimz G31′-%;:_h$ }i3e~:’;:;cli;f§i%a.:’i.”‘ ;%%:1

gaarzfiirig remrt ahsm «.u§f£§§1iv’fimu§§pic
mm mm; a~ae:u:gL.%%k1’ ‘a.’;f§.3;$§;m?1’ze§ by the
alaimafit are Ext?»
3, aartifiaata

$zg9§<€;-.} c§?zsa§'i?w:.3:3i:*,;%Vj&c,':=:t*:%.Lifij::;a.te' Ex,?-3?? X~ra.y$ Exs,P-135

1:9 13? a.V§n:i_V$'r._:§§.;'.;.5:§'Vz"€::§{+;';.E§?';3x»? am: magma as am 5

v "

:*é;f$;:s§::f:§%$’s§1§=:§::’ ~jF@-«Q; aha dmtasr af Shaicm Ea .+;-

the $ : $3 azzfikrim fifim fighi

eye zmfsgmzia mamfim 33:53: ?W-33, $2: Sfifiiafii $33:

staieé; sham: {Em mm bme framium wgci 22:3

__3§’is§@z: 3? iflfi right eye was émitasefi $291 hgamg” af

5%

iaft my aim ig

éfiabfiiiy as? 6:: ,&§%.;

8. Cansééarigzg the nature a? ~_’i;’£1;§5:1;;zzj§:?;s’.;%g:;.g

R§.,68,fi06{~ aaazerarfied by fiw Tribmiai

arm azzfigring’ 5.3 jigs’: arm §mp§Lz*”‘is;::.iz§ :E’;ez*;j§:” ‘:1§ ‘

for gnhanazsamrgz mafia: this

tmwmds ‘msaéical wrgrx the meéimi

hills §raducf=fs;(f'{ft;.*3;j ,%,§§§;~ and

i§1ere,’%:i5e¥[‘ mag: zhig §*:ga§§
§:3. ~ treaied $3 izzyaféiant far 3.

Qefirsd §f xaam ix: mmm Eisagcim C:§:’§.ai§§r1’1′:g

figfi’.C$§’1iife3;t%1t3;: gs’:remm:, m.m§0m1- &?e¥’$§ée§ by

A “- fiifi

‘incidemai

311$}: &§

mégwgjaéwg nmzmfimszzt arzfi aitméana chazgaass is

§#e:;:s;_’§ §f§§fif and §’.§’:€ii’& £3 :13 simpfi far

. °g:fi%:éxmemez:§ mazigr ‘%;’t’z’m mag

9%’

E E, “E235 aiaimmt E5: be

fiéwar dgcfigazar and . sa, gum af Rg,§§§€}G;« gar

manfiig fiat Em $am$ is $13? esmbiisheé $3; ggysmiéizafizg

any dacnmenta in the abwnisa afyrmrf fif

‘fribufzai 21% fghtiy agseasafi §f£~.

gammy- par mm; me

mat he must. haw bean ziizxtifir 34§¢5:’k’a:11;é;TV§}:4:é§:;:m§ar§;§; féséi *

a §¢r’im:i af 4 mggtrza snm fif

R:.12.mfi,!» is _ fif mcamg

éuring iaid u;}_:p§ria;§*§ L

aammiitcé ea arrm in

‘lags cf amaxzitiga’ and

wmpenfiatiazi taswwda ‘ieag sf

Cmzfiideriw ihfi diaabiiity statcé by

jr’%§;:§§§:*v& Eiffig it fig jag?

and an amimzxi af fimmmfart amé

3 the $ t hag 2:: Zifififirgfi in his

mafia? fig 3. sum zgf

‘i@% Q? Jamazzitiaa’ afid ii: is

awaréaaf $3 against gm E23: tfie

‘E’r§Cm.i::a§§

in; It has mma in tim avidexzm sf

that vigissn fif mg @111; egg &f1fi hgarifig. .V :

ia fi§€ and mare is

ma disamiity is the *s¥2’1@_3$ gm ki:se§ %

{§m;;%/4=§.5g41%}. czar: be

swié iimt than Wifi ‘§fi :i*:§;é£1cE;z?<;sr:"'*§Q1%1
and tfzerafsazfg it * 'far
mm§$:1$a;£isi§n__ *-$flfa3:{§.:re imfime'.

;'3iT'fEm fihmzt 24» years ai iiha iimc

sf 5§@idé:fi§':_V; appfiaabia is his aga

gfiifiyi A§*ii$….§2:.3¢cme is asmasafi ai

_'_'§i§12<:ti$::a§ azasamity is agseggga at 25%,

filéie 'Z333 3? future iiicama' wrks $13.: ta

{mm x mgma :2 :2 x :3; ma :2: £3

1%. flag} {ha aifimani ig fifiiififié fa? Eh:

— – sampe£zmfi&:::=-

2} Fair: arzé sufiarirm ~ ;_. A’ _

hr} Bfidécai axmnggs ~ fi$’.._§’,és5a;,;G1fi§;}=

3} Ezmidarztai exmmes ~_-Eifi-,..§,:§}§§3{}§–_

é§§,a»Lassaffsztzzxfia V -.«_§<<"§3V*%ei.':"_§§I.3;.<lT*': v '

mzéan .§§$,;_§3,ff?'§§;2GC?

3%. AccQIwding1: jr;A' in yarta

éh& "§'ribut1&1 is

The guémeggzimfi

Emrein abmm, ':'-ha
cam' a: 3:' a ma: Cfiififififlfiaiifiii :3?

Rm;3;i%§~f9,2§ fi{5j«' as fifiggfisgmiw awmga 5;:

V. – Wi;£'2?1""§fii;em$t at 6% pa, mi {Em ;:_;;:.:;;-::T

R&84,2Wfs~ fifiifi fix data af

§§'t;3Z<£i0:i fiaae Qf

m "E"h@ Erzsxgzraficg aampany fig mafia ta

. V. __§¢:§9ai'£ fizz ezzhwegé afimgmmafififi amasigizi iaagfithar

/

§E"i§1 ifiiazwi axiifiim ififi méffiihfi §%*§& iihfi $323 aef

rficaipt {Ef & gag}? sf tifis jgzdgmaxit.

3?: ma; as am anizmcad m§¢ngg;1g.;;$;amf

thé amamt malt}: gmgartianatgé m§1§ §éz§Ls:§ £53

be izzvéstgei 21.2'; fixad éemagiz: tifiiaézzzxna
any Raiianaiiaad Bmzkf ?;§¢;$tW¥Q¥§¢¢2
far 3. mrieé asf § ifi §cm'g mfi
with m: Cfitkéfi gcriaficaiiys
Rema1'n;'g'g_V intermt 12$

7!-£2 -:3";

a:*d§r§£§%.._;t¢’I’*,§¢’1:.; :32? ‘cm $1
;*mmé.:.is:a:a§y a1zjg;:%[:§§¢%g«§p»s;g::;

;’ _c}’Ifi¢:* ?:3.3vt0 seats,

Sd/~
IUDQE:

“mg

§:€’i3:: ‘,